Independent evolution of porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus 2 with genetic heterogeneity in antigenic regions of structural proteins in Korea

Characterization of Glycoprotein 5-Specific Response in Pigs Vaccinated with Modified Live Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome Virus Vaccine Derived from Two Different Lineages

BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES

Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) is classified into various lineages based on the phylogenetic variation of orf5, which encodes a major surface glycoprotein GP5 containing both neutralizing and non-neutralizing linear epitopes. Several positively selected sites have been identified on the GP5 ectodomain, indicating host immune pressure on these sites. This present study aimed to investigate the kinetics of antibody responses to GP5 and to map the epitope-specific response to the GP5 ectodomain from different PRRSV lineages after vaccination with commercially available modified live virus (MLV) vaccines.

METHODS

Post-weaning pigs were vaccinated with MLV vaccines derived from either lineage 1D (Prevacent PRRS®) or lineage 5 (Ingelvac PRRS®). Animals were challenged with a heterologous (lineage 1A) strain at 64 days post-vaccination (dpv). Blood samples were collected at various times post-vaccination and challenge. Kinetics of antibody response to different PRRSV antigens were monitored and virus neutralization against archetypal and contemporary strains belonging to lineage 5 and 1A were evaluated. In addition, antibody responses to peptides derived from the GP5 ectodomain of different viral lineages were assessed.

RESULTS

Our results showed that the GP5-specific antibody response observed between 18 and 35 dpv was delayed compared to responses to the viral nucleocapsid protein. The polyclonal antibody response in both vaccinated groups showed similar levels of binding to variant GP5 peptides from different sub-lineages. Notably, in both vaccinated groups, the antibody directed to a peptide representing the GP5 ectodomain of a lineage 1C strain (variant 1C.5) displayed a rise in titer at 64 dpv, which was further increased by the challenge with the lineage 1A strain. Less than 50% of animals developed heterologous neutralizing antibodies post-vaccination with both MLV vaccines. However, higher neutralization titers were observed in all vaccinated animal post-challenge.

CONCLUSIONS

Together, these data provide insights into the antibody responses to the GP5 ectodomain in MLV-vaccinated swine herds.

Comparative Genomic and Biological Investigation of NADC30- and NADC34-Like PRRSV Strains Isolated in South Korea

Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) is a globally endemic, costly swine arterivirus with wide genetic and antigenic variations, leading to the frequent appearance of novel virulent strains that hampers PRRSV control. Recently, NADC30-like (lineage 1C, L1C) and NADC34-like (lineage 1A, L1A) PRRSV strains were reported to be prevalent in mainland South Korea and became the main epidemic strains persistently attributed to PRRSV outbreaks nationwide, raising great concern in the domestic pork industry. Although the genotypic and pathotypic variability of NADC30- and NADC34-like viruses has been explored in the United States and China, their genomic and biological characteristics have been scarcely studied in South Korea. Here, NADC34-like GNU-2353 and NADC30-like GNU-2377 strains were independently identified from vaccinated swine herds experiencing high piglet mortality. Whole-genome sequencing and phylogenetic analysis revealed that GNU-2353 and GNU-2377 clustered into sublineages L1A (NADC34-like) and L1C (NADC30-like), respectively, sharing high genomic homology with their corresponding lineage-representative strains and harboring the same molecular signatures of continuous 100 and discontinuous 131 amino acid deletions in the nsp2-coding region, respectively. Recombination detection indicated that GNU-2353 and GNU-2377 were recombinants and evolved through natural interlineage recombination between NADC34-like (L1A, major parent) or NADC30-like (L1C, major parent) and RespPRRS modified live virus (MLV)-like (lineage 5, minor parent) strains, respectively. Both viruses displayed homogenous growth kinetics but replicated faster than the prototype VR-2332 in a porcine alveolar macrophage cell line (PAM-KNU). The transcriptional profiles of immune response genes in infected PAM-KNU cells varied between the isolates and VR-2332; particularly, interleukin-10 expression was dramatically upregulated in cells infected with GNU-2353 and GNU-2377. Piglets with GNU-2353 and GNU-2377 infection had high fever; weight loss; increased viremia and nasal shedding; viral distribution in various tissues; thymic atrophy; and apparent macroscopic and microscopic lung lesions, including interstitial pneumonia and viral colonization, compared with control piglets, suggesting that both isolates were virulent to pigs. Remarkably, GNU-2353 caused higher fever, mortality rate (40%) with cyanosis, viremia, and viral shedding within 2 weeks and significantly higher viral loads in several organs than GNU-2377 infection. Thus, NADC34-like GNU-2353 was more pathogenic than NADC30-like GNU-2377. Our findings provide insights into the current epizootic circumstance of NADC30- and NADC34-like PRRSV in South Korea and can aid in tailoring improved control strategies.

Naringenin Improves Innate Immune Suppression after PRRSV Infection by Reactivating the RIG-I-MAVS Signaling Pathway, Promoting the Production of IFN-I

Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome (PRRS) has been prevalent for nearly forty years since it was first reported. It has been one of the major diseases jeopardizing the healthy development of the world swine industry, as well as causing great economic losses to the industry's economic development. Furthermore, no way has been found to combat the disease due to the immunosuppressive properties of its pathogen porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) infection. We previously examined the mRNA expression of IFN-I in PRRSV-infected Marc-145 cells at different time periods using qRT-PCR, and found that the mRNA expression of IFN-I in the late stage of PRRSV infection showed suppression. Naringenin is a flavonoid found in citrus fruits and has a very wide range of pharmacological activities. Therefore, the aim of the present study was to investigate the modulatory effect of naringenin on the suppressed innate immune response after PRRSV infection. The expression of IFN-I, IL-10, and ISGs in the late stage of PRRSV infection was examined using qRT-PCR, and the results showed that naringenin improved the expression of antiviral cytokines suppressed by PRRSV infection. Further results showed that naringenin treatment significantly up-regulated the expression of proteins related to the RIG-I-MAV immune signaling pathway, and that naringenin could not significantly activate the RIG-I-MAVS signaling pathway after the addition of the RIG-I inhibitor Cyclo. Overall, these data demonstrated that naringenin could improve the innate immune response suppressed by PRRSV infection by modulating the RIG-I-MAVS signaling pathway. Therefore, our study will provide a theoretical basis for the development of naringenin as a drug against immunosuppressive viral infectious disease infections.

Genetic Characteristics of Three Single-Farm-Isolated Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome Viruses with Novel Recombination among NADC30-Like, JXA1-Like, and QYYZ-Like Strains

Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) is an economically devastating pathogenic microorganism that greatly affects the pork industry in the world. The genetic variation and frequent emergence of novel strains greatly hinder the control efforts of PRRSV. Therefore, monitoring the evolutionary dynamics is long and rewarding work for PRRSV researchers and practitioners to make the control strategy. Here, three novel PRRSV strains named CHbj2101, CHbj2102, and CHbj2103 were isolated from different nursery barns with various mortality rates from 6% to 17%, belonging to the same farm, but at different periods of the outbreak. The genomic sequencing and phylogenetic analyses indicated that these three isolates were all clustered with NADC30-like virus CHsx1401, sharing higher genomic similarity from 87.3% to 89.8%, and having the same molecular marker of 131 amino acid residues deletion at their nsp2 coding region, but varied mutagenesis among the antigenic sites in the region of GP2 to GP5. Among the available PRRSV sequences in the GenBank, the isolates CHbj2101 and CHbj2102 display the highest genomic identity (90.1% and 89.8%) with NADC30-like recombinant strain 15LN3, and the rest CHbj2103 shows the highest genomic identity (90.8%) with NADC30-like virus strain 15SC3. The recombination analysis indicated that all three isolates are generated by multiple recombination events among the NADC30-like virus (major parent, Lineage 1), HP-PRRSV vaccine-like virus (minor parent, Lineage 8), and QYYZ-like virus (minor parent, Lineage 3). The isolates CHbj2101 and CHbj2102 shared a similar recombination pattern, but CHbj2103 has a different pattern in nonstructural protein coding regions. To further investigate the recombination characteristics of QYYZ-like strains, we analyzed all available whole genomic sequences of QYYZ-like PRRSV, submitted during the year 1991 and 2021 (n = 83) in China. The result shows that almost all QYYZ-like strains were products of recombination and their immunogenicity or protective protein fragments (nsp2-nsp7 and GP2-GP4) were mainly from QYYZ. These results provide us with some better insight into the evolution process of PRRSV strains in the field and warn us to pay more attention to monitoring and reducing the PRRSV variant on farms to reduce the risk of novel emergence and outbreak.

Insight into the Economic Effects of a Severe Korean PRRSV1 Outbreak in a Farrow-to-Nursery Farm

Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome (PRRS) is a disease that has inflicted economic losses in the swine industry. The causative agent, porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV), is known to have a high genetic diversity which leads to heterogeneous pathogenicity. To date, the impact of PRRS outbreaks on swine production and the economy of the swine industry in South Korea has been rarely reported. In this study, we compare the reproductive performance in the breeding-farrowing phase and growth performance in the nursery phase, in two 27-week periods, one before and one after a PRRSV1 outbreak on a 650-sow farrow-to-nursery farm caused by a Korean PRRSV1 isolate which was genetically distinct from vaccine strains or other global strains. The reproductive performance of sows and the growth performance of nursery pigs were compared using row data consisting of 1907 mating records, 1648 farrowing records, and 17,129 weaning records from 32 breeding batches. The following variables were significantly different between the pre-PRRS outbreak period and the post-PRRS outbreak period: the farrowing rate (−7.1%, p < 0.0001), the abortion rate (+3.9%, p < 0.0001), the return rate (+2.9%, p = 0.0250), weaning to estrus interval days (+1.9 days, p < 0.0001), total piglets born (−1.2 pigs/litter, p < 0.0001), piglets born alive (−2.2 pigs/litter, p < 0.0001), weaned piglets (−2.7 pigs/litter, p < 0.0001), pre-weaning mortality (+7.4%, p < 0.0001), weaning weight (−0.9 kg/pig, p = 0.0015), the mortality rate (+2.8%, p < 0.0001), average daily gain (−69.8 g/d, p < 0.0001), and the feed conversion ratio (+0.26, p = 0.0036). Economic losses for a period of 27 weeks after a PRRS outbreak were calculated at KRW 99,378 (USD 82.8) per mated female for the breeding-farrowing phase, KRW 8,968 (USD 7.5) per pig for the nursery growth phase, and KRW 245,174 (USD 204.3) per sow in the post-outbreak period. In conclusion, the farrow-to-nursery farm in our study suffered extensive production and economic losses as a result of a PRRSV1 outbreak.

Genetic diversity of imported PRRSV-2 strains, 2005-2020, Hungary

Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus 2 (PRRSV-2) remains sporadic in Europe. In this study, we investigated the molecular epidemiology of PRRSV-2 infections encompassing 15 years in Hungary. Partial (423 bp long) ORF5 sequences (n = 44) from 20 Hungarian pig herds were analyzed. The study strains fell into two genetic lineages, L1 and L5, being L5 strains more prevalent (88.6 vs. 11.4%). Pairwise sequence identities within Hungarian representative PRRSV-2 strains ranged between 84.7 to 100% (nucleotide, nt) and 85 to 100% (amino acid, aa). When compared with reference strains, identity values fell between 87 and 100% (L1, nt 87–91%, aa 87–93%, reference strain IAF-exp91; L5, nt 87–100%, aa 88–100%, reference strain Ingelvac MLV). Epidemiologic examination implied that the majority of L5 strains were imported repeatedly from other European countries where Ingelvac MLV was approved for routine use. The emergence of L1 strains was thought to be associated with a single introduction and subsequent dissemination between pig farms of a large integrator. Results presented here contribute to a better understanding of the epizootiology of PRRSV-2 infections and shed light on the genetic diversity of viral strains in non-endemic countries.

Novel lineage 1 recombinants of porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus isolated from vaccinated herds: genome sequences and cytokine production profiles

Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) is a widely disseminated, macrophage-tropic arterivirus that exhibits profound genetic and pathogenic heterogeneity. The present study was conducted to determine the complete genome sequences of two novel Korean lineage 1 PRRSV-2 strains, KNU-1901 and KNU-1902, which were isolated from vaccinated pig farms experiencing unusually high morbidity and mortality. Both isolates contained notable discontinuous 423-nucleotide deletions (DELs) within the genes encoding nonstructural protein 2 (nsp2) and GP3 when compared with the prototype strain VR-2332. In particular, the nsp2 DEL viruses had unique quadripartite discontinuous DEL signatures (111-1-19-9) in nsp2; this is an expanded version of the tripartite 111-1-19 DEL previously identified in virulent lineage 1 PRRSV-2 strains. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that both novel nsp2 DEL viruses belong to the Korean clade (KOR C) of lineage 1 isolates based on ORF5 but cluster with lineage KOR A strains based on the nsp2 or complete genome sequence. Recombination detection analysis suggested that both novel isolates are recombinants and may have evolved via natural inter-lineage recombination between circulating KOR A and KOR C strains. Interestingly, compared with the prototype VR-2332 virus, the novel nsp2 DEL variants were less efficient at promoting the expression of immune response genes in porcine alveolar macrophage culture. Taken together, we conclude that KNU-1901 and KNU-1902 are recently evolved recombinant variants of the virulent lineage 1 family that caused the regional severe PRRS outbreaks.

Major swine viral diseases: an Asian perspective after the African swine fever introduction

Asia is a major pig producer of the world, and at present, African swine fever virus (ASFV) continues to significantly impact the Asian pig industry. Since more than 50% of the world’s pig population is in Asia, ASFV outbreaks in Asia will affect the global pig industry. Prior to the introduction of ASF, several outbreaks of major swine viruses occurred in Asia over the last two decades, including porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV), porcine epidemic diarrhea virus (PEDV) and foot and mouth disease virus (FMDV). The rapid spreading of those viruses throughout Asia involve many factors such as the various pig production systems and supply chains ranging from back-yard to intensive industrial farms, animal movement and animal product trading within and among countries, and consumer behaviors. ASF has notoriously been known as a human-driven disease. Travelers and international trading are the major ASFV-carriers for the transboundary transmission and introduction to naïve countries. Globalization puts the entire pig industry at risk for ASF and other infectious diseases arising from Asian countries. Disease control strategies for the various pig production systems in Asia are challenging. In order to ensure future food security in the region and to prevent the deleterious consequences of ASF and other major viral disease outbreaks, disease control strategies and production systems must be improved and modernized.

Evaluation of a type 2 modified live porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome vaccine against heterologous challenge of a lineage 3 highly virulent isolate in pigs

Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome (PRRS) is one of the most common diseases in the global swine industry. PRRSV is characterized by rapid mutation rates and extensive genetic divergences. It is divided into two genotypes, which are composed of several distinct sub-lineages. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the cross-protective efficacy of Fostera PRRS MLV, an attenuated lineage 8 strain, against the heterologous challenge of a lineage 3 isolate. Eighteen pigs were randomly divided into mock, MLV and unvaccinated (UnV) groups. The pigs in the MLV group were administered Fostera PRRS vaccine at 3 weeks of age and both the MLV and UnV groups were inoculated with a virulent PRRSV isolate at 7 weeks. Clinically, the MLV group showed a shorter duration and a lower magnitude of respiratory distress than the UnV group. The average days of fever in the MLV group was 3.0 ± 0.5, which was significantly lower than the 6.2 ± 0.5 days of the UnV group (P < 0.001). The average daily weight gains of the mock, MLV and UnV groups were 781 ± 31, 550 ± 44 and 405 ± 26 g/day, respectively, during the post-challenge phase. The pathological examinations revealed that the severity of interstitial pneumonia in the MLV group was milder compared to the UnV group. Furthermore, PRRSV viremia titers in the MLV pigs were consistently lower (10¹−10^1.5 genomic copies) than those of the UnV pigs from 4 to 14 DPC. In conclusion, vaccination with Fostera PRRS MLV confers partial cross-protection against heterologous challenge of a virulent lineage 3 PRRSV isolate.

Genomic characteristics and pathogenicity of natural recombinant porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus 2 harboring genes of a Korean field strain and VR-2332-like strain

Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome (PRRS), an economically-important disease caused by PRRS virus (PRRSV), has become endemic to most pig-producing countries. Point mutation and recombination are responsible for genetic heterogeneity, resulting in circulation of genetically-diverse strains. However, no natural recombinant PRRSV has yet been identified in Korea. Here, we successfully isolated natural recombinant PRRSV-2 (KU-N1202) using cell culture, investigated its genomic characteristics, and further evaluated its pathogenicity. KU-N1202 is a recombinant strain between Korean MN184-like and VR-2332-like strains. Specifically, ORF5 to partial ORF7 of the VR-2332-like strain was inserted into the backbone of a CP07-626-2-like strain. KU-N1202 induced mild-to-moderate clinical signs and mild histopathological changes with low viral loads in challenged pigs. Contact pigs showed minimal clinical signs and lower viral loads than those in the challenge group. This study demonstrates the genomic characteristics and pathogenicity of natural recombinant PRRSV-2, illustrating the potential importance of recombination in the field.

•

A natural recombinant PRRSV-2 virus (KU-N1202) was isolated using cell culture.

•

The virus harbored the genes from field strain and VR-2332-like strain.

•

KU-N1202 induced mild-to-moderate clinical signs with low viral loads in challenged pig.

•

Contact pigs showed minimal clinical signs with relatively low viral loads.