Chiari malformation type 1-related headache: the importance of a multidisciplinary study

Combined Cerebrospinal Fluid Hydrodynamics and Fourth Ventricle Outlet Morphology to Improve Predictive Efficiency of Prognosis for Chiari Malformation Type I Decompression

OBJECTIVE

To identify the morphological characteristics together with cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) hydrodynamics on preoperative magnetic resonance imaging that improve the prediction of foramen magnum decompression (FMD) treatment outcome for Chiari malformations type I (CM-I) patients compared with the CSF hydrodynamics-based model.

METHODS

This retrospective study included CM-I patients who underwent FMD, phase-contrast cine magnetic resonance, and static MR between January 2018 and March 2022. The relationships of the preoperative CSF hydrodynamic quantifications derived from phase-contrast cine magnetic resonance and morphological measurements from static magnetic resonance imaging, clinical indicators with different outcomes, were analyzed with logistic regression analysis. The outcomes were determined using the Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale. The predictive performance was evaluated with receiver operating characteristic, calibration, decision curves and area under the receiver operating characteristic curve, net reclassification index, and integrated discrimination improvement and was compared with CSF hydrodynamics-based model.

RESULTS

A total of 27 patients were included. 17 (63%) had improved outcomes and 10 (37%) had poor outcomes. The peak diastolic velocity of the aqueduct midportion (odd ratio, 5.17; 95% confidence interval: 1.08, 24.70; P = 0.039) and the fourth ventricle outlet diameter (odd ratio, 7.17; 95% confidence interval: 1.07, 48.16; P = 0.043) were predictors of different prognoses. The predictive performance improved significantly than the CSF hydrodynamics-based model.

CONCLUSIONS

Combined CSF hydrodynamic and static morphologic MR measurements can better predict the response to FMD. A higher peak diastolic velocity of the aqueduct midportion and broader fourth ventricle outlet were associated with satisfying outcomes after decompression in CM-I patients.

Effect of modified clivoaxial angle on surgical decision making and treatment outcomes in patients with Chiari malformation type 1

Introduction

Chiari malformation type 1 (CM1), a complex pathological developmental disorder of the craniovertebral junction, is typically characterized by herniation of the cerebellar tonsils from the foramen magnum. Treatment using posterior fossa decompression alone without taking the ventral cervico-medullary compression into consideration may lead to unsatisfactory treatment outcomes. The current study evaluated the utility of the modified clivoaxial angle (MCAA) in assessing ventral compression and also examined its effect on treatment outcomes.

Method

This retrospective study included 215 adult patients who underwent surgical treatment for CM1 at one medical center over a 10-year period. The following surgical techniques were used to decompress the posterior fossa: (a) PFD: bone removal only; (b) PFDwD: bone removal with duraplasty; and (c) CTR: cerebellar tonsil resection. The morphometric measurements of the craniovertebral junction (including MCAA) were recorded using preoperative images, and the postoperative clinical status was evaluated using the Chicago Chiari outcome scale (CCOS).

Results

MCAA was positively correlated with the CCOS score and also independently predicted treatment outcome. To enable Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis of CCOS scores, the patients were divided into three groups based on the MCAA cut-off values, as follows: (a) severe (n = 43): MCAA ≤ 126; (b) moderate (n = 86): 126 < MCAA ≤ 138; and (c) mild (n = 86): MCAA > 138. Group a exhibited severe ventral cervico-medullary compression (VCMC), and their CCOS scores for the PFD, PFDwD, and CTR groups were 11.01 ± 1.2, 11.24 ± 1.3, and 13.01 ± 1.2, respectively (p < 0.05). The CCOS scores increased with widening of the MCAA angle in all surgical groups (p < 0.05). Furthermore, patients with mild MCAA (>138°) exhibited 78% regression of syringomyelia, and this was significantly greater than that observed in the other groups.

Discussion

MCAA can be used in the selection of appropriate surgical techniques and prediction of treatment outcomes, highlighting the importance of preoperative evaluation of ventral clivoaxial compression in patients with CM1.

Prevalence and treatment of typical and atypical headaches in patients with Chiari I malformation: A meta-analysis and literature review

OBJECTIVE

A meta-analysis was conducted to analyze the incidence of typical and atypical headaches and outcomes following various treatments in patients with Chiari I malformation.

BACKGROUND

Headache is the most common symptom of Chiari malformation, which can be divided into typical and atypical subgroups to facilitate management. Much controversy surrounds the etiology, prevalence and optimal therapeutic approach for both types of headaches.

METHOD

We identified relevant studies published before 30 July 2022, with an electronic search of numerous literature databases. The results of this study were reported according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses statement.

RESULT

A total of 1913 Chiari malformation type I CIM patients were identified, 78% of whom presented with headache, within this group cephalgia was typical in 48% and atypical in 29% of patients, and migraine was the most common type of atypical headache. The ratio of typical/atypical headaches with international classification of headache disorders diagnosis was 1.53, and without international classification of headache disorders diagnosis was 1.56, respectively. The pooled improvement rates of typical headaches following conservative treatment, extradural decompression and intradural decompression were 69%, 88%, and 92%, respectively. The corresponding improvement rates for atypical headaches were 70%, 57.47%, and 69%, respectively. The complication rate in extradural decompression group was significantly lower than in intradural decompression group (RR, 0.31; 95% CI: 0.06-1.59, I² = 50%, P = 0.14). Low reoperation rates were observed for refractory headaches in extradural decompression and intradural decompression groups (1%).

CONCLUSION

The International Classification of Headache Disorders can assist in screening atypical headaches. extradural decompression is preferred for typical headaches, while conservative therapy is optimal for atypical headaches. A definite correlation exists between atypical headaches and Chiari Malformation Type I patients with higher prevalence than in the general population. Importantly, decompression is effective in relieving headaches in this particular patient population.

Headache characteristics and postoperative course in Chiari I malformation

Background

Chiari I malformation typically presents with cough headache. However, migraine-like or tension-type-like headaches may also occur. There are limited publications on Chiari I malformation-associated headache semiologies and the effect of foramen magnum decompression on different headache types.

Methods

A retrospective analysis complemented by structured phone interviews was performed on 65 patients with Chiari I malformation, treated at our hospital between 2010 and 2021. Headache semiology (according to ICHD-3), frequency, intensity, and radiological characteristics were evaluated pre- and postoperatively.

Results

We included 65 patients. 38 patients were female and 27 male. Mean age was 43.9 ± 15.7 years. Headache was predominant in 41 patients (63.0%). Twenty-one patients had cough headache and 20 had atypical headache (12 migrainous, eight tension-type headache-like). Thirty-five patients with headache underwent surgery. Frequency, intensity, and analgesic use was significantly reduced in cough headache (p < 0.001). Atypical headaches improved less (p = 0.004 to 0.176). Exploratory analysis suggested that larger preoperative tonsillar descent correlated with larger postoperative headache intensity relief (p = 0.025).

Conclusion

Decompression was effective in Chiari I malformation-related cough headache. Atypical headache responded less well, and the causal relation with Chiari I malformation remains uncertain. For atypical headache, decompression should only be considered after failed appropriate preventive therapy and within an interdisciplinary approach involving a neurologist.

"Motion-specific Headache": A Predictor for Diagnosis and Favorable Prognosis after Surgery in Young Patients with Chiari Malformation Type 1

As headache is known as one of the most common symptoms in the patients with Chiari malformation type 1 (CM1), it is difficult to find out CM1-related headache among the symptoms because headache itself is commonly seen. Herein, we retrospectively review the cases of six CM1 patients complaining only of headache by which they complained of deterioration in daily life activities. The symptom of headache worsened during anteflexion (n = 2; 33%), retroflexion (n = 1; 17%), jumping (n = 3; 50%), going up the stairs (n = 1; 17%), and running (n = 1; 17%). Mean age at the onset was 15.7 years old (ranging 11–18) and four out of six were female. These inductive factors were clearly different from “Valsalva-like maneuvers,” although the mechanism might originate from dynamic tonsil changes. We named these headaches as “motion-specific.” These headaches radiated to the posterior side. MRI revealed that the extent of tonsillar ectopia was 11.3 mm, while syringomyelia was observed in three out of six patients (50%). All patients underwent surgical treatment, with the “motion-specific headache” completely disappearing 12.5 days thereafter. Although headaches are common, “motion-specific headache” may be a good candidate symptom to distinguish CM1 patients, especially among teenagers with headaches, and a good predictor for favorable outcomes after surgical treatment.

Migraine in Chiari 1 Malformation: a cross-sectional, single centre study

In Chiari 1 Malformation (CM1) the most frequent symptom is exertional headache, but other headache types have been reported, such as migraine. This cross-sectional study is aimed to examine the prevalence of migraine in a group of CM1 headache patients and to compare clinical-demographic characteristics between migraine and non-migraine patients. 427 adults were enrolled at the multidisciplinary Chiari Center in Torino. 230 headache patients were classified, based on radiological criteria. Frequencies (absolute/percentage values) were calculated in the whole sample for: migraine presence (with and without aura), gender, age, radiologic phenotypes and headache clinical characteristics. The association between CM1 diagnosis and headache characteristics (independent variables) and migraine diagnosis (dependent variable) was estimated by logistic regression models. Seventy-eight patients (67 females) out of 230 presenting headache had a migraine (34%), 44/78 (56%) with aura; in 58/78 (74%) migraine was comorbid with secondary headache attributable to CM1. Migraine prevalence in patients with isolated CM1 (52/120, 43.3%) was higher (p = 0.0016) than in all the other patients (26/110, 23.6%). Although migraine was prevalent in females (86%; 6:1 female:male ratio), age classes and gender were not risk factors for migraine at multivariate analysis, while migraine was associated with isolated CM1 phenotype (OR = 2.6). This study shows a high prevalence of migraine in CM1 patients and a significant association between migraine and isolated CM1. In patients with radiological evidence of CM1, particularly in the absence of neurological signs, a careful headache clinical characterization, according to the International Headache Society criteria, may be advised.

Association Between Resistance to Cerebrospinal Fluid Flow Near the Foramen Magnum and Cough-Associated Headache in Adult Chiari Malformation Type I

Cough-associated headaches (CAHs) are thought to be distinctive for Chiari malformation type I (CMI) patients and have been shown to be related to the motion of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) near the foramen magnum (FM). We used computational fluid dynamics (CFD) to compute patient-specific resistance to CSF motion in the spinal canal for CMI patients to determine its accuracy in predicting CAH. Fifty-one symptomatic CMI patients with cerebellar tonsillar position (CTP) ≥ 5 mm were included in this study. The patients were divided into two groups based on their symptoms (CAH and non-CAH) by review of the neurosurgical records. CFD was utilized to simulate CSF motion, and the integrated longitudinal impedance (ILI) was calculated for all patients. A receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve was evaluated for its accuracy in predicting CAH. The ILI for CMI patients with CAH (776 dyn/cm5, 288-1444 dyn/cm5; median, interquartile range) was significantly larger compared to non-CAH (285 dyn/cm5, 187-450 dyn/cm5; p = 0.001). The ILI was more accurate in predicting CAH in CMI patients than the CTP when the comparison was made using the area under the ROC curve (AUC) (0.77 and 0.70, for ILI and CTP, respectively). ILI ≥ 750 dyn/cm5 had a sensitivity of 50% and a specificity of 95% in predicting CAH. ILI is a parameter that is used to assess CSF blockage in the spinal canal and can predict patients with and without CAH with greater accuracy than CTP.

Ventrolateral Tonsillar Position Defines Novel Chiari 0.5 Classification

BACKGROUND

Cervicomedullary compression in young children has been described in the context of Chiari type 1 malformation, with symptoms associated with the extent of tonsillar herniation below McRae line. Historically, Chiari type 1 malformation has been defined by tonsillar herniation of at least 5 mm. However, in certain populations, including very young children, Chiari symptoms may be present without this finding. A new Chiari classification is thus necessary.

METHODS

Cases involving patients up to 5 years of age evaluated for possible posterior fossa decompression were retrospectively reviewed. Preoperative symptoms, magnetic resonance imaging findings, surgical management, and short- and long-term outcome and follow-up were recorded. Tonsillar descent and presence of ventral herniation (VH) were recorded. We define VH as the tonsils crossing a line that bisects the caudal medulla at the level of the foramen magnum, thus creating a novel entity, Chiari type 0.5 malformation. Patients with ventrally herniated tonsils were compared with patients exhibiting more typical Chiari morphology.

RESULTS

Of 41 cases retrospectively reviewed, 20 met criteria for VH. These differed from cases without VH because of the predominance of medullary symptoms. In the VH cohort, 11 patients underwent surgical decompression with symptom resolution; 9 were initially managed conservatively, but 3 subsequently required surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

We define a novel Chiari entity, Chiari type 0.5 malformation, characterized by ventral tonsillar wrapping around the medulla in young children in the absence of classic Chiari type 1 malformation imaging findings. These patients are more likely to present with medullary symptoms than patients without VH. They are also more likely to require surgical decompression and respond favorably to intervention.

Clinical utility of 2-D anatomic measurements in predicting cough-associated headache in Chiari I malformation

PURPOSE

Cough-associated headache (CAH) is the most distinctive symptom of patients with Chiari I malformation (CMI) and indicates clinically significant disease. We determined the clinical utility of simple 2D anatomic measurements performed on a PACS workstation by assessing their diagnostic accuracy in predicting CAH in CMI patients.

METHODS

Seventy-two consecutive CMI patients (cerebellar tonsillar herniation > 5 mm) with headache seen by neurosurgeons over 6 years were included. Sagittal T1 images were used by two readers to measure: extent of tonsillar herniation, lengths of the clivus and supra-occiput, McRae and pB-C2 lines, as well as clivus-canal, odontoid retroversion, and skull base angles. Neurosurgery notes were reviewed to determine presence of CAH. Mann-Whitney test was used to compare measurements between patients with and without CAH. Predictive accuracy was assessed by receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve.

RESULTS

47/72 (65.3%) CMI patients reported CAH. Tonsillar herniation with CAH (10.2 mm, 7-14 mm; median, interquartile range) was significantly greater than those without CAH (7.9 mm, 6.3-10.9 mm; p = 0.02). Tonsillar herniation ≥ 10 mm showed sensitivity and specificity of 51% and 68%, and tonsillar herniation > 14 mm showed sensitivity and specificity of 30% and 100%, respectively, for predicting CAH. Other 2D measurements showed no statistically significant differences.

CONCLUSIONS

Among the 2D measurements used, only the extent of tonsillar herniation is different between CMI patients with and without CAH. Although CMI is diagnosed with tonsillar herniation of only 5 mm, we found that a much higher extent of herniation is needed to be predictive of CAH.

Management: opinions from different centers-the Istituto Giannina Gaslini experience

PURPOSE

Describe presentation and management of Chiari type 1 malformation. We report our surgical case series proposing a decision making scheme for helping surgeons decide which surgical procedure to perform and when.

METHODS

We retrospectively examined a series of surgically treated patients with Chiari type 1 malformation. Treatment of associated anomalies, surgical complications, and need for reintervention for insufficient decompression at first surgery are discussed.

RESULTS

A total of 172 patients have been surgically treated for Chiari type 1 malformation at the Neurosurgery Unit of IRCCS Giannina Gaslini Children Hospital of Genoa, Italy, in a period between 2006 and 2017. The first treatment addressing Chiari type 1 malformation was bone and ligamentous decompression alone in 104 patients (65%), associated with dural delamination in 3 patients (1.9%) and associated with duraplasty with autologous graft in 53 patients (33.1%). Postoperative complications occurred in 5 patients (2.9%). Reintervention for insufficient decompression at follow-up was needed in 6 patients (3.5%).

CONCLUSIONS

Surgical decompression of the posterior cranial fossa (PCF) is indicated in symptomatic patients while asymptomatic patients must be followed in a wait and see fashion. Different types of surgical decompression of different invasiveness have been proposed from only bone and ligamentous decompression to coagulation of cerebellar tonsils. Intraoperative ultrasonography is a useful tool to define when a decompression is sufficient. We did not find correlation between the need for reintervention for insufficient decompression and different invasiveness of the techniques. We believe that this finding suggests that our proposed scheme leads to the best tailored treatment for the single patient.

Headache, Chiari I malformation and foramen magnum decompression

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

With increasing use of MRI, more patients are being diagnosed with Chiari I malformation (CM1), many of whom are asymptomatic. When symptoms are present, headache is the most frequent presenting feature, although symptoms can be variable. The purpose of this review is to help primary care clinicians better understand the relationship between an individual's presenting symptoms and the presence of radiographic CM1, and to describe the expected outcomes for patients who undergo decompression surgery.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recent literature has shown that asymptomatic patients with CM1 tend to have a benign natural history. For symptomatic Chiari malformation, headache is the most common presenting symptom and the majority of patients that present with headache will have symptom improvement after foramen magnum decompression. This improvement is most reliable for patients with classic Chiari-type headache, which are described as occipital or cervical and tussive in nature, but has also been shown in patients with atypical headaches who have undergone surgery.

SUMMARY

CM1 is a common radiographic finding and associated symptoms can be variable. The relevance of this finding to a particular patient and need for intervention must be made on an individual basis.