Dynamic Properties of Human Tympanic Membrane After Exposure to Blast Waves

Quantifying Real-Time Dynamic Responses and Damage Mechanics of Human Tympanic Membranes Exposed to Blast Waves

Understanding the tympanic membrane's (TM, or eardrum) response to high-intensity acoustical events, such as blasts, is crucial for preventing and treating blast-induced auditory injuries. Despite its importance, there remains a gap in methodologies and measurements of the TMs rapid dynamic responses to these events. This study investigates the behavior of human TMs exposed to blasts using a novel system that integrates high-speed quantitative imaging techniques with a custom shock tube (ST). High-speed three-dimensional-digital image correlation (DIC) and high-speed Schlieren imaging techniques are applied in synchronization with high-frequency pressure sensors to quantify generation and propagation of shock wave (SW) and its interaction with the TM during the tests. Additionally, digital microscopy and optical coherence tomography (OCT) are utilized to characterize the TM's morphology pre- and postblast exposure. The full-field high-speed dynamic responses of cadaveric human TMs and their fluid-solid interactions with different levels of blast overpressures are presented, and the rupture of the TMs is described in real-time. These measurements are employed to assess whether the TM behaves as a thin shell under exposure to high acoustical events. The findings from these studies enhance the comprehension of the TMs biomechanics and damage mechanics under harsh conditions, thereby advancing prevention and treatment strategies for blast-induced auditory damage.

Real-time measurement of stapes motion and intracochlear pressure during blast exposure

Blast-induced auditory injury is primarily caused by exposure to an overwhelming amount of energy transmitted into the external auditory canal, the middle ear, and then the cochlea. Quantification of this energy requires real-time measurement of stapes footplate (SFP) motion and intracochlear pressure in the scala vestibuli (Psv). To date, SFP and Psv have not been measured simultaneously during blast exposure, but a dual-laser experimental approach for detecting the movement of the SFP was reported by Jiang et al. (2021). In this study, we have incorporated the measurement of Psv with SFP motion and developed a novel approach to quantitatively measure the energy flux entering the cochlea during blast exposure. Five fresh human cadaveric temporal bones (TBs) were used in this study. A mastoidectomy and facial recess approach were performed to identify the SFP, followed by a cochleostomy into the scala vestibuli (SV). The TB was mounted to the "head block", a fixture to simulate a real human skull, with two pressure sensors - one inserted into the SV (Psv) and another in the ear canal near the tympanic membrane (P1). The TB was exposed to the blast overpressure (P0) around 4 psi or 28 kPa. Two laser Doppler vibrometers (LDVs) were used to measure the movements of the SFP and TB (as a reference). The LDVs, P1, and Psv signals were triggered by P0 and recorded simultaneously. The results include peak values for Psv of 100.8 ± 51.6 kPa (mean ± SD) and for SFP displacement of 72.6 ± 56.4 μm, which are consistent with published experimental results and finite element modeling data. Most of the P0 input energy flux into the cochlea occurred within 2 ms and resulted in 10-70 μJ total energy entering the cochlea. Although the middle ear pressure gain was close to that measured under acoustic stimulus conditions, the nonlinear behavior of the middle ear was observed from the elevated cochlear input impedance. For the first time, SFP movement and intracochlear pressure Psv have been successfully measured simultaneously during blast exposure. This study provides a new methodology and experimental data for determining the energy flux entering the cochlea during a blast, which serves as an injury index for quantifying blast-induced auditory damage.

Modeling Injury Risk From Multiple-Impulse, Area-Distributed Flash-bangs Using an Uncertainty Bounding Approach to Dose Accumulation

INTRODUCTION

Modeling of injury risk from nonlethal weapons including flash-bangs is a critical step in the design, acquisition, and application of such devices for military purposes. One flash-bang design concept currently being developed involves multiple, area-distributed flash-bangs. It is particularly difficult to model the variation inherent in operational settings employing such devices due to the randomness of flash-bang detonation positioning relative to targets. The problem is exacerbated by uncertainty related to changes in the mechanical properties of auditory system tissues and contraction of muscles in the middle ear (the acoustic reflex), which can both immediately follow impulse-noise exposure. In this article, we demonstrate a methodology to quantify uncertainty in injury risk estimation related to exposure to multiple area-distributed flash-bang impulses in short periods of time and analyze the effects of factors such as the number of impulses, their spatial distribution, and the uncertainties in their parameters on estimated injury risk.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We conducted Monte Carlo simulations of dispersion and timing of a mortar-and-submunition flash-bang device that distributes submunitions over an area, using the Auditory 4.5 model developed by L3 Applied Technologies to estimate the risk of hearing loss (permanent threshold shift) in an exposure area. We bound injury risk estimates by applying limiting assumptions for dose accumulation rules applied to short inter-pulse intervals and varied impulse-noise-intensity exposure characteristic of multi-impulse flash-bangs. The upper bound of risk assumes no trading of risk between the number of impulses and intensity of individual impulses, while the lower bound assumes a perfectly protective acoustic reflex.

RESULTS

In general, the risk to individuals standing in the most hazardous zone of the simulation is quite sensitive to the pattern of submunitions, relative to the sensitivity for those standing farther from that zone. Larger mortar burst radii (distributing submunitions over a wider area) reduce expected peak risk, while increasing the number of submunitions, the intensity of individual impulses, or the uncertainty in impulse intensity increases expected risk. We find that injury risk calculations must factor in device output variation because the injury risk curve in the flash-bang dose regime is asymmetric. We also find that increased numbers of submunitions increase the peak risk in an area more rapidly than scene-averaged risk and that the uncertainty related to dose accumulation in the acoustic reflex regime can be substantial for large numbers of submunitions and should not be ignored.

CONCLUSIONS

This work provides a methodology for exploring both the role of device parameters and the choice of dose accumulation rule in estimating the risk of significant injury and associated uncertainty for multi-impulse, area-distributed flash-bang exposures. This analysis can inform decisions about the design of flash-bangs and training for their operational usage. The methodology can be extended to other device designs or deployment concepts to generate risk maps and injury risk uncertainty ranges. This work does not account for additional injury types beyond permanent threshold shift that may occur as a result of flash-bang exposure. A useful extension of this work would be similar work connecting design and operational parameters to human effectiveness.

Dual-laser measurement of human stapes footplate motion under blast exposure

Hearing damage is one of the most frequently observed injuries in Service members and Veterans even though hearing protection devices (HPDs, e.g. earplugs) have been implemented to prevent blast-induced hearing loss. However, the formation and prevention mechanism of the blast-induced hearing damage remains unclear due to the difficulty for conducting biomechanical measurements in ears during blast exposure. Recently, an approach reported by Jiang et al. (2019) used two laser Doppler vibrometers (LDVs) to measure the motion of the tympanic membrane (TM) in human temporal bones during blast exposure. Using the dual laser setup, we further developed the technology to detect the movement of the stapes footplate (SFP) in ears with and without HPDs while under blast exposure. Eight fresh human cadaveric temporal bones (TBs) were involved in this study. The TB was mounted in a "head block" after performing a facial recess surgery to access the SFP, and a pressure sensor was inserted near the TM in the ear canal to measure the pressure reaching the TM (P1). The TB was exposed to a blast overpressure measuring around 7 psi or 48 kPa at the entrance of the ear canal (P0). Two LDVs were used to measure the vibrations of the SFP and TB (as a reference). The exact motion of the SFP was determined by subtracting the TB motion from the SFP data. Results included a measured peak-to-peak SFP displacement of 68.7 ± 31.6 μm (mean ± SD) from all eight TBs without HPDs. In five of the TBs, the insertion of a foam earplug reduced the SFP displacement from 48.3 ± 6.3 μm to 21.8 ± 10.4 μm. The time-frequency analysis of the SFP velocity signals indicated that most of the energy spectrum was concentrated at frequencies below 4 kHz within the first 2 ms after blast and the energy was reduced after the insertion of HPDs. This study describes a new methodology to quantitatively characterize the response of the middle ear and the energy entering the cochlea during blast exposure. The experimental data are critical for determining the injury of the peripheral auditory system and elucidating the damage formation and prevention mechanism in an ear exposed to blast.

Mechanical Properties of Baboon Tympanic Membrane from Young to Adult

Mechanical properties of the tympanic membrane (TM) play an important role in sound transmission through the middle ear. While numerous studies have investigated the mechanical properties of the adult human TM, the effects of age on the TM's properties remain unclear because of the limited published data on the TM of young children. To address this deprivation, we used baboons in this study as an animal model for investigating the effect of age on the mechanical properties of the TM. Temporal bones were harvested from baboons (Papio anubis) of four different age groups: less than 1 year, 1-3 years, 3-5 years, and older than 5 years of age or adult. The TM specimens were harvested from baboon temporal bones and cut into rectangle strips along the inferior-superior direction, mainly capturing the influence of the circumferential direction fibers on the TM's mechanical properties. The elasticity, ultimate tensile strength, and relaxation behavior of the baboon TM were measured in each of the four age groups with a mechanical analyzer. The average effective Young's modulus of adult baboon TM was approximately 3.1 MPa, about two times higher than that of a human TM. The Young's moduli of the TM samples demonstrated a 26 % decrease from newborn to adult (from 4.2 to 3.1 MPa). The average ultimate tensile strength of the TMs for all the age groups was ~ 2.5 MPa. There was no significant change in the ultimate tensile strength and relaxation behavior among age groups. The preliminary results reported in this study provide a first step towards understanding the effect of age on the TM mechanical properties from young to adult.

Hearing Damage Induced by Blast Overpressure at Mild TBI Level in a Chinchilla Model

Introduction

The peripheral auditory system and various structures within the central auditory system are vulnerable to blast injuries, and even blast overpressure is at relatively mild traumatic brain injury (TBI) level. However, the extent of hearing loss in relation to blast number and time course of post-blast is not well understood. This study reports the progressive hearing damage measured in chinchillas after multiple blast exposures at mild TBI levels (103–138 kPa or 15–20 psi).

Materials and Methods

Sixteen animals (two controls) were exposed to two blasts and three blasts, respectively, in two groups with both ears plugged with foam earplugs to prevent the eardrum from rupturing. Auditory brainstem response (ABR) and distortion product otoacoustic emission (DPOAE) were measured in pre- and post-blasts. Immunohistochemical study of chinchilla brains were performed at the end of experiment.

Results

Results show that the ABR threshold and DPOAE level shifts in 2-blast animals were recovered after 7 days. In 3-blast animals, the ABR and DPOAE shifts remained at 26 and 23 dB, respectively after 14 days. Variation of auditory cortex damage between 2-blast and 3-blast was also observed in immunofluorescence images.

Conclusions

This study demonstrates that the number of blasts causing mild TBI critically affects hearing damage.

The Development of a Tympanic Membrane Model and Probabilistic Dose-Response Risk Assessment of Rupture Because of Blast

INTRODUCTION

There is no dose-response model available for the assessment of the risk of tympanic membrane rupture (TMR), commonly known as eardrum rupture, from exposures to blast from nonlethal flashbangs, which can occur concurrently with temporary threshold shift. Therefore, the objective of this work was to develop a fast-running, lumped parameter model of the tympanic membrane (TM) with probabilistic dose-dependent prediction of injury risk.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The lumped parameter model was first benchmarked with a finite element model of the middle ear. To develop the dose-response curves, TMR data from a historic cadaver study were utilized. From these data, the binary probability response was constructed and logistic regression was applied to generate the respective dose-response curves at moderate and severe eardrum rupture severity.

RESULTS

Hosmer-Lemeshow statistical and receiver operation characteristic analyses showed that maximum stored TM energy was the overall best dose metric or injury correlate when compared with total work and peak TM pressure.

CONCLUSIONS

Dose-response curves are needed for probabilistic risk assessments of unintended effects like TMR. For increased functionality, the lumped parameter model was packaged as a software library that predicts eardrum rupture for a given blast loading condition.

The effect of blast overpressure on the mechanical properties of the human tympanic membrane

The rupture of the tympanic membrane (TM) is one of the major indicators for blast injuries due to the vulnerability of TM under exposure to blast overpressure. The mechanical properties of the human TM exhibit a significant change after it is exposed to such a high intensity blast. To date, the published data were obtained from measurement on TM strips cut from a TM following an exposure to blast overpressure. The dissection of a TM for preparation of strip samples can induce secondary damage to the TM and thus potentially lead to data not representative of the blast damage. In this paper, we conduct mechanical testing on the full TM in a human temporal bone. A bulging experiment on the entire TM is carried out on each sample prepared from a temporal bone following the exposure to blast three times at a pressure level slightly below the TM rupture threshold. Using a micro-fringe projection method, the volume displacement is obtained as a function of pressure, and their relationship is modeled in the finite element analysis to determine the mechanical properties of the post-blast human TMs, the results of which are compared with the control TMs without an exposure to the blast. It is found that Young's modulus of human TM decreases by approximately 20% after exposure to multiple blast waves. The results can be used in the human ear simulation models to assist the understanding of the effect of blast overpressure on hearing loss.

Surface Motion Changes of Tympanic Membrane Damaged by Blast Waves

Eardrum or tympanic membrane (TM) is a multilayer soft tissue membrane located at the end of the ear canal to receive sound pressure and transport the sound into the middle ear and cochlea. Recent studies reported that the TM microstructure and mechanical properties varied after the ear was exposed to blast overpressure. However, the impact of such biomechanical changes of the TM on its movement for sound transmission has not been investigated. This paper reports the full-field surface motion of the human TM using the scanning laser Doppler vibrometry in human temporal bones under normal and postblast conditions. An increase of the TM displacement after blast exposure was observed in the posterior region of the TM in four temporal bone samples at the frequencies between 3 and 4 kHz. A finite element model of human TM with multilayer microstructure and orthogonal fiber network was created to simulate the TM damaged by blast waves. The consistency between the experimental data and the model-derived TM surface motion suggests that the tissue injuries were resulted from a combination of mechanical property change and regional discontinuity of collagen fibers. This study provides the evidences of surface motion changes of the TM damaged by blast waves and possible fiber damage locations.

Characterization of Protection Mechanisms to Blast Overpressure for Personal Hearing Protection Devices – Biomechanical Measurement and Computational Modeling

Hearing damage induced by blast exposure is a common injury in military personnel involved in most operation activities. Personal hearing protection devices such as earplugs come as a standard issue for Service members; however, it is not clear how to accurately evaluate the protection mechanisms of different hearing protection devices for blast overpressures (BOP). This paper reports a recent study on characterization of earplugs’ protective function to BOP using human cadaver ears and 3D finite element (FE) model of the human ear. The cadaver ear mounted with pressure sensors near the eardrum (P1) and inside the middle ear (P2) and with an earplug inserted was exposed to BOP in the blast test chamber. P1, P2, and BOP at the ear canal entrance (P0) were simultaneously recorded. The measured P0 waveform was then applied at the ear canal entrance in the FE model and the P1 and P2 pressures were derived from the model. Both experiments and FE modeling resulted in the P1 reduction which represents the effective protection function of the earplug. Different earplugs showed variations in pressure waveforms transmitted to the eardrum, which determine the protection level of earplugs.