Using early life stages of marine animals to screen the toxicity of priority hazardous and noxious substances

A decade of toxicity research on sea urchins: A review

Sea urchins have been used extensively in toxicity studies worldwide. In this review, toxicity studies that used sea urchins as the organism of choice during the last decade (from 2014 to 2023) were assessed. The selected articles were analysed for the following main points: (i) the world regions where sea urchins are predominantly utilized in toxicological studies, (ii) the sea urchin species most frequently employed, (iii) the most frequently used toxicological assays, and (iv) the chemical under examination. The results indicate that the scientists in Europe most often decide to work with this organism. Specifically, sea urchins were sampled from the Tyrrhenian Sea and the Atlantic coast of Spain and Portugal for the toxicity studies. The most frequently selected species of sea urchin is Paracentrotus lividus, followed by Arbacia lixula and Strongylocentrotus purpuratus. Furthermore, the toxicity experimental method that is most often applied is the embryotoxicity that includes a version of the sea urchin embryo-larval development test endpoints. Currently metals are the most frequently researched pollutant of this species as target organism, followed by environmental samples (e.g. sediment or wastewaters), plastics and nanoparticles (metal and metal oxide nanoparticles, silicate nanoparticles, polystyrene nanoparticles and carbon nanotubes). At the end, the obtained results were discussed and recommendations for further work with sea urchins in toxicological studies were proposed.

Development of a Lymnaea stagnalis embryo bioassay for chemicals hazard assessment

The validation of high-throughput toxicity tests with invertebrate species is a key priority to improve hazard assessment of new chemicals and increase the available test guidelines with organisms from a representative set of taxa. This work aimed to contribute to the validation of an embryo test with the freshwater gastropod Lymnaea stagnalis, which has been identified by Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) as a potential invertebrate test model, and provide the basis for such an endeavor. Recently, a L. stagnalis reproductive test was standardized by the OECD. However, to encompass the entire life cycle, it is crucial to addresses embryogenic development - a phase highly susceptible to various anthropogenic chemicals, which is covered in the proposed methodology. The approach used in the present study is in line with the OECD guidelines and other published studies, namely the Detailed Review Paper (DRP) on Mollusks life-cycle toxicity testing. Here, the assay quality criteria such as basal mortality and abnormality rates, development, growth and hatching rates, the appropriated testing media, and the optimal assay duration were investigated. Cadmium was chosen as the positive test substance, due to the available data and the verified model sensitivity to this compound, namely in the OECD reproductive test validation process. The obtained data demonstrate that L. stagnalis embryogenesis using the developed methodology is highly sensitive to cadmium. High concentration-response correlation was observed using this reference compound, the EC10 and EC50 for growth are 13.57 and 21.84 μg/L, respectively, after 168 h of exposure. The development EC's 10 and 50 were 15.75 and 38.66 μg/L, respectively, after 240 h. This demonstrates the model sensitivity to this compound when compared with other embryo test models, as well as the model sensitivity during the embryogenesis, if compared with the adult stage. Further, given the determined sensitivity parameters, and incubation times, the test can be performed at 240 h as over 95 % of the control embryos were hatched and no further significant changes in the exposure groups were determined. Overall, the findings of the present study demonstrate that the embryo test with L. stagnalis has potential to high-throughput testing and the model has a high sensitivity to cadmium during this life cycle period. The background data provide by this study will be essential to foster the future standardization of this assay.

Field-portable seawater toxicity monitoring platform using lens-free shadow imaging technology

The accidental spill of hazardous and noxious substances (HNSs) in the ocean has serious environmental and human health consequences. Assessing the ecotoxicity of seawater exposed to various HNS is challenging due to the constant development of new HNS or mixtures, and assessment methods are also limited. Microalgae viability tests are often used among the various biological indicators for ecotoxicity testing, as they are the primary producers in aquatic ecosystems. However, since the conventional cell growth rate test measures cell viability over three to four days using manual inspection under a conventional optical microscope, it is labor- and time-intensive and prone to subjective errors. In this study, we propose a rapid and automated method to evaluate seawater ecotoxicity by quantification of the morphological changes of microalgae exposed to more than 30 HNSs. This method was further validated using conventional growth rate test results. Dunaliella tertiolecta, a microalgae species without rigid cell walls, was selected as the test organism. Its morphological changes in response to HNS exposure were measured at the single cell level using a custom-developed device that uses lens-free shadow imaging technology. The ecotoxicity evaluation induced by the morphological change could be available in as little as 5 min using the proposed method and device, and it could be effective for 20 HNSs out of 30 HNSs tested. Moreover, the test results of six selected HNSs with high marine transport volume and toxicity revealed that the sensitivity of the proposed method extends to half the maximum effective concentration (EC50) and even to the lowest observed effective concentration (LOEC). Furthermore, the average correlation index between the growth inhibition test (three to four days) and the proposed morphology changes test (5 min) for the six selected HNSs was 0.84, indicating great promise in the field of various point-of-care water quality monitoring. Thus, the proposed equipment and technology may provide a viable alternative to traditional on-site toxicity testing, and the potential of rapid morphological analysis may replace traditional growth inhibition testing.

Study on Risk Assessment Methods and Zoning of Hazardous Chemicals Leaking into Seas

In China, studies on the regional risk assessment of hazardous chemicals have been carried out for only a few years, and there are few studies on hazardous chemicals leaking into seas. Previous regional-risk-assessment methods considered a single risk factor for most assessment targets, and comprehensive considerations of risk sources and sensitive resources for a study area are not sufficiently included. Based on previous work, this study established a regional-risk-assessment method for hazardous chemicals leaking into seas. This method considered the hazards of hazardous chemicals and the tolerance of the regional environment by means of a case study in Tianjin. The results showed that the risk level of the enterprise was Grade I, classified as a high-risk source of hazardous chemicals; the main reasons were the strong toxicity and large quantity of hazardous chemicals. This method provides technical support for scientifically assessing marine-environmental-risk levels for hazardous-chemical-leakage areas and for carrying out risk-prevention and restoration assessments of hazardous chemicals leaking into seas.

Impact of P-Chloroaniline on Oxidative Stress and Biomacromolecules Damage in the Clam Ruditapes philippinarums: A Simulate Toxicity Test of Spill Incident

As a hazardous chemical, p-chloroaniline (PCA) shows intensive adsorption and accumulation after entering the aquatic ecosystem, which can be enriched in organisms and cause damage. With the objective of achieving an integrated and mechanistic view of the toxic effects of PCA in the marine sentinel organism Ruditapes philippinarum, Manila clams were exposed to different concentration of PCA (0.5, 2 and 5 mg/L) for 15 days. Focusing on the gills, first targeting the toxic and digestive gland, the metabolic detoxification organ, we detected dose- and time-related changes inantioxidase activities and biomacromolecular damages in treated clams. Glutathione S-transferase (GST) activity and glutathione (GSH) contents were significantly induced, and superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity increased at the beginning of exposure and then decreased. The malondialdehyde (MDA) and protein methylation (PC) contents which represent lipid peroxidation and carbonylation of proteins, increased first with exposure time and then decreased in the digestive gland. DNA strand break levels were consistently higher than those in the control group. The digestive gland showed more sensitivity to the stress of PCA than the gills. GST and MDA in the gill and GST, GSH, SOD, DNA strand break level in the digestive gland showed significant correlation with PCA exposure, which indicated that these parameters can be used as sensitive biomarkers to indicate toxic effects from chloraniline leakage.

Toxicity evaluation of butyl acrylate on the photosynthetic pigments, chlorophyll fluorescence parameters, and oxygen evolution activity of Phaeodactylum tricornutum and Platymonas subcordiformis

Butyl acrylate is a hazardous and noxious substance (HNS) listed in the top 50 chemicals that is most likely to be involved in HNS spilling incident. At present, information about toxicity effect of butyl acrylate on marine organisms was insufficient, especially on marine microalgae. Phaeodactylum tricornutum (P. tricornutum) and Platymonas subcordiformis (P. subcordiformis) were used as test organism to evaluate the toxic effect of butyl acrylate on their photosynthetic system. Results showed that chlorophyll a (Chl-a) content, the net photosynthetic oxygen evolution rate (NOR), and chlorophyll fluorescence parameters including maximal photochemical efficiency (Fv/Fm), electron transfer rate (ETR), photochemical quenching (qP), and non-photochemical quenching (NPQ) were all stimulated in the toxic dose of 5,10, and 25 mg/L while those were significantly inhibited in the highest concentration of 25 mg/L groups after 96 h. Meanwhile, it was also found that Fv/Fm would be a suitable indicator for evaluating the toxicity of butyl acrylate on the photosynthetic system of two marine microalgae according to the analysis of Pearson correlation coefficient and integrated biomarker response (IBR). Once butyl acrylate enters the marine ecosystem, the toxicity data obtained in this study could be used as a reference for evaluating the effect of butyl acrylate on the photosynthetic capacity of marine microalgae.

Acute toxic effect of typical chemicals and ecological risk assessment based on two marine microalgae, Phaeodactylum tricornutum and Platymonas subcordiformis

With the increasing demand for typical hazardous and noxious substances (HNS) in chemical industry, there is an increased leakage risk of these HNS during transportation by vessel and storage nearby seashore. In this study, the acute toxicity of nonylphenol, butyl acrylate and 1, 2-dichloroethane to Phaeodactylum tricornutum (P. tricornutum) and Platymonas subcordiformis (P. subcordiformis), was investigated to assess their ecological risk. The results showed that the three kinds of HNS showed significant time- and dose-dependent patterns on the growth inhibition of two marine microalgae. The 96 h-EC₅₀ of nonylphenol, butyl acrylate and 1, 2-dichloroethane on P. tricornutum was 1.088, 45.908 and 396 mg L^-1, respectively, and the 96 h-EC₅₀ of that on P. subcordiformis was 0.851, 52.621 and 389 mg L^-1, respectively. It was a common method to evaluate the harm of pollutants to organisms by calculating HC₅ value (the minimum pollutant concentration value harmful to 95 % of the studied species, which was no-effect concentration) with Species Sensitivity Distribution (SSD). On the basis of EC₅₀, the ecological risk assessment was further carried out, and HC₅ value of nonylphenol and 1, 2-dichloroethane to aquatic organism was 0.079 and 44 mg L^-1, respectively.

Toxic effect of p-chloroaniline and butyl acrylateon Nannochloropsis oculata based on water samples from two sea areas

To compare the influence of water samples collected from various areas on toxic effect of HNS, we examined the toxic effect of two commonly found HNS: p-chloroaniline and butyl acrylate, on Nannochloropsis oculata cultured in seawater collected from Laizhou bay and Jiaozhou bay (China). The results showed that both p-chloroaniline and butyl acrylate had significant toxic effect on N. oculata cultured in both water samples. P-chloroaniline inhibited its net oxygenation rate and oxygen consumption rate. Butyl acrylate inhibited the net oxygenation rate whereas significantly stimulated oxygen consumption rate. Performance of N. oculata changed between two water samples under same level of p-chloroaniline and butyl acrylate. The net oxygenation rate of N. oculata cultured in the seawater from the Jiaozhou bay increased by 11.60 %, the oxygen consumption rate increased by 26.91 %, algae cell growth decreased by 16.83 %, compared to those from Laizhou bay. The Fv/Fm of N. oculata cultured in Jiaozhou bay was more significantly inhibited at 0.5 and 2.0 mg L^-1 p-chloroaniline, while it was significantly inhibited at 5. 0 mg L^-1 of butyl acrylate, compared to those from Laizhou bay. Moreover, the toxic effect of both HNS on net oxygenation rate and oxygen consumption rate were significantly attenuated as the concentration increased. The growth inhibition of microalgae cultured in two seawater samples was more evident at 0.5 and 5.0 mg L^-1 p-chloroaniline than at 2.0 mg L^-1 p-chloroaniline,and the growth inhibition of microalgae cultured in two seawater samples was more evident at 2.0 and 5.0 mg L^-1 butyl acrylate than at 0.5 mg L^-1 butyl acrylate. These results indicated that toxic effect of p-chloroaniline and butyl acrylate on the growth of N. oculata was influenced by the pollutants in the two water samples. Consequently, a corresponding research on water sample is required in advance to increase accuracy of future ecological risk assessment of HNS.

Environmental risk assessment of accidental marine spills: A new approach combining an online dynamic Hazardous and Noxious substances database with numerical dispersion, risk and population modelling

The foreseen rise on maritime transportation of Hazardous and Noxious Substances (HNS) increases the likelihood of accidents, leading to a higher risk of chemical spillage that can have severe ecological impacts. Considering the lack of information on HNS spills, the response to these events is less well established than those involving oil. Moreover, a paramount knowledge of the physicochemical and ecotoxicological properties of the substance involved is required for an effective environmental risk assessment and response to an HNS spill. In the present work, a new online interface, in which a dynamic HNS database feeds a chemical numerical dispersion model, was developed with the aim to improve predictions regarding the behaviour and environmental risk of HNS spills on marine ecosystems. Potential impacts to pelagic organisms were characterized by coupling model outputs with toxicity risk ratios. Furthermore, a simple population model was developed, foreseeing impacts at the ecological level. The integration of the developed tools establishes an innovative framework, which aims to improve predictions related to HNS plumes' behaviour and potential hazards to the marine environment and associated ecosystem services. Further, this new approach fosters an improved preparedness and response to coastal pollution incidents, enhancing effective decision making and management by competent authorities.

Current issues confounding the rapid toxicological assessment of oil spills

Oil spills of varying magnitude occur every year, each presenting a unique challenge to the local ecosystem. The complex, changeable nature of oil makes standardised risk assessment difficult. Our review of the state of science regarding oil's unique complexity; biological impact of oil spills and use of rapid assessment tools, including commercial toxicity kits and bioassays, allows us to explore the current issues preventing effective, rapid risk assessment of oils. We found that despite the advantages to monitoring programmes of using well validated standardised tests, which investigate impacts across trophic levels at environmentally relevant concentrations, only a small percentage of the available tests are specialised for use within the marine environment, or validated for the assessment of crude oil toxicity. We discuss the use of rapid tests at low trophic levels in addition to relevant sublethal toxicity assays to allow the characterisation of oil, dispersant and oil and dispersant mixture toxicity. We identify novel, passive dosing techniques as a practical and reproducible means of improving the accuracy and maintenance of nominal concentrations. Future work should explore the possibility of linking this tiered testing system with ecosystem models to allow the prediction and risk assessment of the entire ecosystem.

Toxicity effects of p-choroaniline on the growth, photosynthesis, respiration capacity and antioxidant enzyme activities of a diatom, Phaeodactylum tricornutu

The environmental risk issues of p-choroaniline have been concerned by the widespread application and transportation of this important chemical intermediate. The information about the toxicity of p-chloroaniline was mainly concentrated on freshwater organisms while the current knowledge on marine organisms was scarce yet. In this study, acute toxicity and toxic physiology characteristic of p-chloroaniline to Phaeodactylum tricornutum (P. tricornutum) were first determined. In the acute experiments, the effect of the p-choroaniline to P. tricornutum showed time- and dose-dependent response, which the half maximum effective concentration (EC₅₀) at 24 h, 48 h and 96 h was 35.35, 20.10 and 10.00 mgL^-1, respectively. Toxic physiology assays in P. tricornutum indicated that the p-choroaniline induced significant changes of photosynthetic pigments (Chl-a, Chl-b, Caro, Chl-a/b and Chl-(a+b)/Caro), Chlorophyll fluorescence parameters (Fv/Fm, ETR, qP and NPQ), rates of photosynthetic O₂ release and respiration O₂ consumption, and antioxidant enzyme activities (SOD, CAT). The obvious decrease of Fv/Fm, ETR and chl-a in low p-choroaniline treatments (≤ 5.00 mgL^-1) compared with the control could be observed, which implied that these parameters could be taken as sensitive indicators for the environmental assessment. Meanwhile, the activities of SOD and CAT significant increase in p-choroaniline stress after 24 h and the extent of the increase has fallen after 96 h. These toxicity data obtained here might provide available basic data for the ecological risk assessment of p-choroaniline pollution.

The impact of propranolol, 17α-ethinylestradiol, and gemfibrozil on early life stages of marine organisms: effects and risk assessment

Pharmaceuticals are ubiquitously detected in the marine environment at the ng-μg/L range. Given their biological activity, these compounds are known to induce detrimental effects on biota at relatively low exposure levels; however, whether they affect early life stages of marine species is still unclear. In this study, a set of bioassays was performed to assess the effects of propranolol (PROP), 17-α ethinylestradiol (EE2), and gemfibrozil (GEM) on gamete fertilization and embryonic development of mussels (Mytilus galloprovincialis) and sea urchins (Paracentrotus lividus), and on the survival of seabream (Sparus aurata) larvae. Treatments of PROP (500, 5000, 50,000 ng/L), EE2 (5, 50, 500 ng/L), and GEM (50, 500, 5000 ng/L) were selected to encompass levels comparable or superior to environmental concentrations. Obtained data were tested for dose-response curve fitting and the lowest EC₁₀/LC₁₀ used to calculate risk quotients (RQs) based on the MEC/PNEC. No alteration was induced by PROP on the mussel gamete fertilization, while inhibitory effects were observed at environmental levels of EE2 (500 ng/L) and GEM (5000 ng/L). Fertilization was significantly reduced in sea urchin at all PROP and EE2 dosages. The 48-h exposure to all pharmaceuticals induced the onset of morphological abnormalities in either mussel or sea urchin embryos. Alterations were generally observed at environmentally relevant dosages, except for PROP in mussels, in which alterations occurred only at 50,000 ng/L. A decreased survival of seabream larvae was recorded after 96-h exposure to PROP (all treatments), EE2 (50-500 ng/L), and GEM (500 ng/L). A median RQ > 1 was obtained for all pharmaceuticals, assigning a high risk to their occurrence in marine environments. Overall, results showed that current levels of contamination by pharmaceuticals can impact early stages of marine species, which represent critical junctures in the resilience of coastal ecosystems.

Evaluating the toxic effects of three priority hazardous and noxious substances (HNS) to rotifer Brachionus plicatilis

Hazardous and noxious substances (HNS) spill in the marine environment is an issue of growing concern, and it will mostly continue to do so in the future owing to the increase of high chemical traffic. Nevertheless, the effects of HNS spill on marine environment, especially on aquatic organisms are unclear. Consequently, it is emergent to provide valuable information for the toxicities to marine biota caused by HNS spill. Accordingly, the acute toxicity of three preferential HNS and sub-lethal effects of acrylonitrile on Brachionus plicatilis were evaluated. The median lethal concentration (LC₅₀) at 24 h were 47.2 mg acrylonitrile L^-1, 276.9 mg styrene L^-1, and 488.3 mg p-xylene L^-1, respectively. Sub-lethal toxicity effects of acrylonitrile on feeding behavior, development, and reproduction parameters of B. plicatilis were also evaluated. Results demonstrated that rates of filtration and ingestion were significantly reduced at 2.0, 4.0, and 8.0 mg L^-1 of acrylonitrile. Additionally, reproductive period, fecundity, and life span were significantly decreased at high acrylonitrile concentrations. Conversely, juvenile period was significantly increased at the highest two doses and no effects were observed on embryonic development and post-reproductive period. Meanwhile, we found that ingestion rate decline could be a good predictor of reproduction toxicity in B. plicatilis and ecologically relevant endpoint for toxicity assessment. These data will be useful to assess and deal with marine HNS spillages.