Repair of a Proximal Hamstring Rupture in a 14-Year-Old Patient: A Case Report

Management trends and practices in ischial tuberosity avulsion fractures: a cross-sectional study among hip surgeons in the UK, surgical technique and literature review

BACKGROUND

Ischial tuberosity avulsion fracture (ITAF) is a rare injury affecting predominantly adolescent athletes yet lacks standardised management protocols. This study aims to investigate the diverse management preferences among hip surgeons regarding ITAF and share our preferred surgical technique and management.

METHODS

In a cross-sectional study, 237 British Hip Society members were surveyed regarding various aspects of ITAF management, including preferences for operative versus non-operative approaches, surgical techniques and postoperative rehabilitation regimens. Sixty-two surgeons responded, yielding a 26% response rate.

RESULTS

Thirty-six surgeons (58.1%) favoured conservative treatment, while 26 (41.9%) preferred surgery based on the degree of displacement. Among those advocating for surgery, 16 (61.5%) deemed displacement ≥20mm as significant, with 5 (19.2%) considering ≥15mm significant and another 19.2% regarding any displacement as significant. Prone theatre positioning was overwhelmingly preferred by 96.2%, with a majority (65.4%) favouring the transverse gluteal crease approach. Postoperatively, 11.5% preferred immediate full weight bearing, while 88.5% opted for six weeks of non-weight-bearing following surgery. Among conservative management advocates, 29% allowed unrestricted weight-bearing post-injury, 11.3% preferred weight-bearing until further review and 59.7% opted for partial weight-bearing for at least six weeks.

CONCLUSIONS

This study highlights the absence of a consensus on ITAF management. We present our preferred approach through a case analysis involving an ITAF patient treated at our department to enhance understanding of this rare injury and potentially improve management strategies.

Outcomes following adolescent athlete proximal hamstring apophyseal avulsion bone fragment excision and direct tendon-ischial tuberosity reattachment

Apophyseal proximal hamstring bone avulsion is uncommon, occurring in adolescents following sudden forceful contraction of the musculotendinous unit. It can be severely disabling, preventing return to sport. This study assessed outcome following avulsed bone excision and direct hamstring tendon-ischial tuberosity reattachment using bone anchors. Validated hamstring-specific Sydney hamstring orthopaedic research evaluation PROMs were prospectively collected from consecutively treated athletes (7 elite and 11 recreational) by a single surgeon over 13 years. Outcomes at 1-year and final follow-up for primary acute surgery at less than 3 months after injury (group 1), primary chronic surgery at more than 3 months after established nonunion (group 2) and revision following failed screw fixation (group 3) were analyzed with sport participation and level at 1 year. Sixteen primary and two revision procedures were analyzed. Mean injury age was 14.6 years (SD, 1.8). Combined primary mean injury scores improved from 11.89 (SD, 7.32) to 33.31 (SD, 2.30) and showed mean 1 year and final follow-up scores within 0.3-6.1% of preinjury values. Pronounced improvement occurred from injured scores for groups 1 versus 2, respectively at 1 year by 247.7% versus 59.0% and at final follow-up by 251.0% versus 64.1%, for groups 1 versus 2, respectively. Final outcome scores of group 3 were high. All cases returned to preinjury sport level by 1 year and indicated satisfaction to repeat treatment. No significant complications occurred. As the largest series to assess outcomes following this surgical technique, success is highlighted by high score improvements close to preinjury values and return to preinjury sport level.

Surgical repair techniques, functional outcome, and return to sports after apophyseal avulsion fractures of the ischial tuberosity in adolescents

Purpose

Among juvenile apophyseal avulsion injuries of the pelvis in adolescents, fractures of the ischial tuberosity are rare but sustainably debilitating. Also because informations on surgical repair options are very sparse and so far limited to general reviews, reports of individual cases or heterogeous small case series, practitioners, patients and their parental environment still feel a comprehensible hesitation regarding operative treatment. Therefore we intended to investigate patient related outcome measurements and return to sports rates after different types of surgical intervention in an own case series, so far unprecendented in its size.

Methods

Patient data of adolescents that underwent surgical intervention for a displaced apophyseal avulsion fracture of the ischial tuberosity between 01/2015 and 12/2019 in our institution were gathered. Patients were then evaluated using the hamstring injury specific Perth Hamstring Assessment Tool (PHAT). Furthermore the return to sports level in comparison to the particular pre-injury level was rated.

Results

Eleven adolescents with an acute or chronic mean fragment dislocation of 3.3 cm (SD ± 1.7) underwent surgical intervention in the assigned period. The mean post-operative PHAT score was 86.9 (0–100, SD ± 11.9) and thus good to excellent. The majority of adolescents (10/11) was able to return to their pre-injury sports, whereas 63.6% achieved full or nearly full level.

Conclusions

Surgical refixation or restoration of aphoyseal avulsion fractures of the ischial tuberosity result in good to excellent outcomes and return to sport rates, irrespective of the type of intervention. Here prompt diagnosis with a timely intervention seems more promising than delayed interventions in chronic cases. Beyond 1.5 cm of fragment displacement affected patients should be counselled for surgical intervention.

Chemoprotection with botulinum toxin following proximal hamstring-Ischial tuberosity avulsion fracture repair: Running title: Chemoprotection for hamstring avulsion fractures

INTRODUCTION

Surgical treatment for avulsion injuries of the proximal hamstrings has gained increasing popularity over the past decade. Despite good outcomes, early failures have been noted and have been attributed to slipping and falling, postoperative muscle spasm, or early mobilization. In a recent review of hamstring repair rehabilitation protocols, it was shown that there is marked variability in post-operative management. Post-operative bracing with limiting knee extension and hip flexion is the standard of care in most early rehabilitation protocols. Braces with limitation of hip flexion and knee locked in 90⁰ flexion can be awkward, cumbersome and create fall risk.Chemoprotection has more recently been proposed to be an alternative approach to prevent tendon repair failure and controlled mobilization which has been shown to be superior to complete immobilization. We present the first case series of the use of botulinum toxin for chemo-protection of the proximal hamstring ischial avulsion repair, demonstrating its safety and efficacy.

METHODS

Retrospective case series at a tertiary children's hospital which included patients <18 years of age who underwent interventional treatment for proximal hamstring avulsion injuries of the ischium utilizing botulinum toxin as a chemoprotective agent. Data collected included demographic data, injury and treatment details, imaging, post-operative rehabilitation and return to activity. Descriptive statistical analysis was conducted.

RESULTS

Five male patients with mean age 14 years (12-17) were included in the study. All were sports related non-contact injuries. Radiographs showed displaced avulsion fractures in all 5 patients. All patients had failed conservative management initially; mean time to surgery from initial injury was 34.4 weeks. 4 patients underwent open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF), 1 patient with less displacement had bone marrow aspirate (BMA) injection; all had chemoprotection using botulinum toxin injected in the hamstrings. No patient required hip immobilization or knee immobilization locked to 90°. We elected to use a brace locked at 20° knee flexion in 2/5 patients. All patients underwent supervised physical therapy and achieved symmetric knee range of motion (ROM). Post-operative radiographs confirmed healing of the avulsion fracture in all 5 patients and they all returned to previous level of activity at mean 32 weeks (21-43) from surgery. None of the patients had a hamstring re-injury at mean follow up of 27 months (11-42).

CONCLUSION

Our case series is the first in literature that shows the safety and efficacy of chemoprotection with botulinum toxin for the post-operative management of avulsion injuries of proximal hamstrings, by minimizing the need for cumbersome bracing and allowing controlled motion during physical therapy.