Immune disorders caused by defects in the caspase cascade

Autoimmune lymphoproliferative immunodeficiencies (ALPID) in childhood: breakdown of immune homeostasis and immune dysregulation

Many inborn errors of immunity (IEI) manifest with hallmarks of both immunodeficiency and immune dysregulation due to uncontrolled immune responses and impaired immune homeostasis. A subgroup of these disorders frequently presents with autoimmunity and lymphoproliferation (ALPID phenotype). After the initial description of the genetic basis of autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome (ALPS) more than 20 years ago, progress in genetics has helped to identify many more genetic conditions underlying this ALPID phenotype. Among these, the majority is caused by a group of autosomal-dominant conditions including CTLA-4 haploinsufficiency, STAT3 gain-of-function disease, activated PI3 kinase syndrome, and NF-κB1 haploinsufficiency. Even within a defined genetic condition, ALPID patients may present with staggering clinical heterogeneity, which makes diagnosis and management a challenge. In this review, we discuss the pathophysiology, clinical presentation, approaches to diagnosis, and conventional as well as targeted therapy of the most common ALPID conditions.

A rare immunological disease, caspase 8 deficiency: case report and literature review

BACKGROUND

Caspase-8 is a molecule in the FAS pathway that initiates apoptosis. One of the rarest autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndromes is caspase-8 deficiency. Immunodeficiency, splenomegaly, and lymphadenopathy are the common symptoms of this condition.

CASE PRESENTATION

A two-year-old boy entered this study with a fever of unknown origin (FUO) and dysentery. Moreover, he suffered from failure to thrive and was allergic to the cow's milk protein. His fever and dysentery did not respond to antibiotic therapy. The colonoscopy revealed diffuse ulcerations regions in the sigmoid along with skipped areas, mimicking Crohn's disease aphthous lesions. He represented very early-onset inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) and was diagnosed with the caspase-8 deficiency.

CONCLUSION

There can be diarrhea or dysentery as the first or main symptoms of inborn errors of immunity (IEIs). The cause of diarrhea and dysentery in this case was early-onset IBD. One of the symptoms of IEIs such as caspase-8 deficiency is early-onset of IBD. Patients with early-onset had normal T cell count and low or normal immunoglobulin levels with insufficient immune response.

Caspase-9 Activation of Procaspase-3 but Not Procaspase-6 Is Based on the Local Context of Cleavage Site Motifs and on Sequence

Studying the interactions between a protease and its protein substrates at a molecular level is crucial for identifying the factors facilitating selection of particular proteolytic substrates and not others. These selection criteria include both the sequence and the local context of the substrate cleavage site where the active site of the protease initially binds and then performs proteolytic cleavage. Caspase-9, an initiator of the intrinsic apoptotic pathway, mediates activation of executioner procaspase-3 by cleavage of the intersubunit linker (ISL) at site ¹⁷²IETD↓S. Although procaspase-6, another executioner, possesses two ISL cleavage sites (site 1, ¹⁷⁶DVVD↓N; site 2, ¹⁹⁰TEVD↓A), neither is directly cut by caspase-9. Thus, caspase-9 directly activates procaspase-3 but not procaspase-6. To elucidate this selectivity of caspase-9, we engineered constructs of procaspase-3 (e.g., swapping the ISL site, ¹⁷²IETD↓S, with DVVDN and TEVDA) and procaspase-6 (e.g., swapping site 1, ¹⁷⁶DVVD↓N, and site 2, ¹⁹⁰TEVD↓A, with IETDS). Using the substrate digestion data of these constructs, we show here that the P4-P1' sequence of procaspase-6 ISL site 1 (DVVDN) can be accessed but not cleaved by caspase-9. We also found that caspase-9 can recognize the P4-P1' sequence of procaspase-6 ISL site 2 (TEVDA); however, the local context of this cleavage site is the critical factor that prevents proteolytic cleavage. Overall, our data have demonstrated that both the sequence and the local context of the ISL cleavage sites play a vital role in preventing the activation of procaspase-6 directly by caspase-9.

The genetic landscape of the FAS pathway deficiencies

Dysfunction of the FAS-FASLG pathway causes a lymphoproliferative disorder with autoimmunity called Autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome (ALPS) mainly caused by FAS mutations. The goal of this review is to describe the genetic bases of the autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome and to underline their genetic complexity with the contribution of both germline and somatic events accounting for the variable clinical penetrance of the FAS mutations. Starting from the cohort of patients studied in the French cohort (>165 cases), we also reviewed the literature cases in order to depict a full description of the mutations affecting the FAS-FASLG pathway involved in the outcome of this rare non-malignant and non-infectious pediatric lymphoproliferative disease. We also discussed the variable clinical penetrance associated with mutations affecting the extracellular domain of the protein. Such non-penetrant germline mutations are frequently associated with an additional somatic event impacting the second allele of FAS. Moreover, the uncomplete clinical penetrance associated with mutations affecting the intracellular domain of FAS, in patient lacking additional FAS somatic event, suggested a potential digenic inheritance with a FAS mutation accompanied by a genetic modifier possibly impacting another player of the lymphocytes homeostasis (affecting the survival, activation or apoptosis of the peripheral leukocytes).

FAS and RAS related Apoptosis defects: From autoimmunity to leukemia

The human adaptive immune system recognizes almost all the pathogens that we encounter and all the tumor antigens that may arise during our lifetime. Primary immunodeficiencies affecting lymphocyte development or function therefore lead to severe infections and tumor susceptibility. Furthermore, the fact that autoimmunity is a frequent feature of primary immunodeficiencies reveals a third function of the adaptive immune system: its self-regulation. Indeed, the generation of a broad repertoire of antigen receptors (via a unique strategy of random somatic rearrangements of gene segments in T cell and B cell receptor loci) inevitably creates receptors with specificity for self-antigens and thus leads to the presence of autoreactive lymphocytes. There are many different mechanisms for controlling the emergence or action of autoreactive lymphocytes, including clonal deletion in the primary lymphoid organs, receptor editing, anergy, suppression of effector lymphocytes by regulatory lymphocytes, and programmed cell death. Here, we review the genetic defects affecting lymphocyte apoptosis and that are associated with lymphoproliferation and autoimmunity, together with the role of somatic mutations and their potential involvement in more common autoimmune diseases.

The Autoimmune Lymphoproliferative Syndrome with Defective FAS or FAS-Ligand Functions

The autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome (ALPS) is a non-malignant and non-infectious uncontrolled proliferation of lymphocytes accompanied by autoimmune cytopenia. The genetic etiology of the ALPS was described in 1995 by the discovery of the FAS gene mutations. The related apoptosis defect accounts for the accumulation of autoreactive lymphocytes as well as for specific clinical and biological features that distinguish the ALPS-FAS from other monogenic defects of this apoptosis pathway, such as FADD and CASPASE 8 deficiencies. The ALPS-FAS was the first description of a monogenic cause of autoimmunity, but its non-Mendelian expression remained elusive until the description of somatic and germline mutations in ALPS patients. The recognition of these genetic diseases brought new information on the role of this apoptotic pathway in controlling the adaptive immune response in humans.

Underexpression and overexpression of Fas and Fas ligand: a double-edged sword

OBJECTIVE

To compare autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome (ALPS) and Stevens-Johnson syndrome (SJS) with respect to the defects in Fas- and Fas ligand (FasL)-mediated apoptosis.

DATA SOURCES

Selected reviews, case reports, and original studies were searched in PubMed and MEDLINE for the keywords ALPS, SJS, Fas, FasL, and apoptosis.

STUDY SELECTION

Case reports of ALPS and SJS were selected as examples of Fas- and FasL-mediated diseases. In addition, we selected articles that examined the pathophysiology of apoptosis in the context of Fas-FasL interaction.

RESULTS

Failure to initiate apoptosis of abnormal T lymphocytes occurs in such diseases as ALPS, leading to the accumulation of double negative T cells with an increase in autoimmunity. In contrast to apoptotic failure, SJS is associated with a pathological increase in programmed keratinocyte cell death.

CONCLUSION

The consequences of dysregulated Fas- and FasL-mediated apoptosis leads to self-reactivity, malignant transformation, and immune dysfunction. An understanding of underlying mechanisms and qualitative assessment of Fas and FasL may have clinical benefits when control of these homeostatic mechanisms is in question.

Genetic alterations in caspase-10 may be causative or protective in autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome

Autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome (ALPS) is characterized by lymphadenopathy, elevated numbers of T cells with alphabeta-T cell receptors but neither CD4 nor CD8 co-receptors, and impaired lymphocyte apoptosis in vitro. Defects in the Fas receptor are the most common cause of ALPS (ALPS Ia), but in rare cases other apoptosis proteins have been implicated, including caspase-10 (ALPS II). We investigated the role of variants of caspase-10 in ALPS. Of 32 unrelated probands with ALPS who did not have Fas defects, two were heterozygous for the caspase-10 missense mutation I406L. Like the previously reported ALPS II-associated mutation L285F, I406L impaired apoptosis when transfected alone and dominantly inhibited apoptosis mediated by wild type caspase-10 in a co-transfection assay. Other variants in caspase-10, V410I and Y446C, were found in 3.4 and 1.6% of chromosomes in Caucasians, and in 0.5 and <0.5% of African Americans, respectively. In contrast to L285F and I406L, these variants had no dominant negative effect in co-transfection assays into the H9 lymphocytic cell line. We found healthy individuals homozygous for V410I, challenging the earlier suggestion that homozygosity for V410I alone causes ALPS. Moreover, an association analysis suggested protection from severe disease by caspase-10 V410I in 63 families with ALPS Ia due to dominant Fas mutations (P<0.05). Thus, different genetic variations in caspase-10 can produce contrasting phenotypic effects.