Endovascular Baroreflex Amplification for Resistant Hypertension

Research status and frontiers of renal denervation for hypertension: a bibliometric analysis from 2004 to 2023

BACKGROUND

Renal Denervation (RDN) is a novel non-pharmacological technique to treat hypertension. This technique lowers blood pressure by blocking the sympathetic nerve fibers around the renal artery, then causing a decrease in system sympathetic nerve excitability. This study aimed to visualize and analyze research hotspots and development trends in the field of RDN for hypertension through bibliometric analysis.

METHODS

In total, 1479 studies were retrieved on the Web of Science Core Collection (WoSCC) database from 2004 to 2023. Using CiteSpace (6.2.R4) and VOSviewer (1.6.18), visualization maps were generated by relevant literature in the field of RDN for hypertension to demonstrate the research status and frontiers.

RESULTS

The number of publications was found to be generally increasing. Europe and the United States were the first countries to carry out research on different techniques and related RDN clinical trials. The efficacy and safety of RDN have been repeatedly verified and gained increasing attention. The study involves multiple disciplines, including the cardiovascular system, peripheral vascular disease, and physiological pathology, among others. Research hotspots focus on elucidating the mechanism of RDN in the treatment of hypertension and the advantages of RDN in appliance therapy. Additionally, the research frontiers include improvement of RDN instruments and techniques, as well as exploration of the therapeutic effects of RDN in diseases with increased sympathetic nerve activity.

CONCLUSION

The research hotspots and frontiers reflect the status and development trend of RDN in hypertension. In the future, it is necessary to strengthen international collaboration and cooperation, conduct long-term clinical studies with a large sample size, and continuously improve RDN technology and devices. These measures will provide new options for more patients with hypertension, thereby improving their quality of life.

Device's design and clinical perspectives for resistant hypertension therapy

Introduction

Hypertension is the leading cause of death in the cardiovascular system. Indeed, untreated hypertension can affect one's general health, but medicine can help hypertensive people reduce their chance of developing high blood pressure. However, secondary hypertension remains an unresolved illness.

Areas covered

This review will go through the typical and unusual device-based therapies for resistant hypertension that have arisen in recent years. Further to that, the innovations developed in device-based RH treatment will be covered, as well as the research and studies assessing these novel technologies.

Expert opinion

The innovative device-based techniques that target resistant hypertension provide a potential therapy that has been backed by a number of studies and clinical trials, whereas pharmacological non-adherence and increased sympathetic activity are recognized to be the primary causes of resistant hypertension. Nevertheless, some limitations will be critical for the future of these RH systems, with the device's design and larger RCTs playing a significant role in determining whether a position in routine treatment could be warranted.

Neuromodulation Therapies in Heart Failure: A State-of-the-Art Review

Heart failure (HF) continues to impact the population globally with increasing prevalence. While the pathophysiology of HF is quite complex, the dysregulation of the autonomic nervous system, as evident in heightened sympathetic activity, serves as an attractive pathophysiological target for newer therapies and HF. The degree of neurohormonal activation has been found to correlate to the severity of symptoms, decline in functional capacity, and mortality. Neuromodulation of the autonomic nervous system aims to restore the balance between sympathetic nervous system and the parasympathetic nervous system. Given that autonomic dysregulation plays a major role in the development and progression of HF, restoring this balance may potentially have an impact on the core pathophysiological mechanisms and various HF syndromes. Autonomic modulation has been proposed as a potential therapeutic strategy aimed at reduction of systemic inflammation. Such therapies, complementary to drug and device-based therapies may lead to improved patient outcomes and reduce disease burden. Most professional societies currently do not provide a clear recommendation on the use of neuromodulation techniques in HF. These include direct and indirect vagal nerve stimulation, spinal cord stimulation, baroreflex activation therapy, carotid sinus stimulation, aortic arch stimulation, splanchnic nerve modulation, cardiopulmonary nerve stimulation, and renal sympathetic nerve denervation. In this review, we provide a comprehensive overview of neuromodulation in HF.

Device-Based Therapy for Resistant Hypertension: An Up-to-Date Review

Hypertension is the major risk factor for cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. Matter of fact, untreated hypertension can worsen the overall health, whereas pharmacotherapy can play an important role in lowering the risk of high blood pressure in hypertensive patients. However, persistent uncontrolled hypertension remains an unsolved condition characterized by non-adherence to medication and increased sympathetic activity. This paper will review the non-pharmacological treatments for resistant hypertension (RH) that have emerged in recent years. In addition, the technologies developed in device-based RH therapy, as well as the clinical trials that support their use, will be discussed. Indeed, the novel device-based approaches that target RH present a promising therapy which has been supported by several studies and clinical trials, whereas drug non-adherence and high sympathetic activity are known to be the main causes of RH. Nevertheless, some additional aspects of these RH systems need to be tested in the near future, with a particular focus on the device's design and availability of randomized controlled trials.

The effect of endovascular baroreflex amplification on central sympathetic nerve circuits and cerebral blood flow in patients with resistant hypertension: A functional MRI study

BACKGROUND

Endovascular baroreflex amplification (EVBA) by implantation of the MobiusHD is hypothesized to lower blood pressure by decreasing sympathetic activity through the mechanism of the baroreflex. In the present exploratory study we investigated the impact of MobiusHD implantation on central sympathetic nerve circuits and cerebral blood flow (CBF) in patients with resistant hypertension.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In thirteen patients, we performed blood oxygenation level-dependent functional magnetic resonance imaging (BOLD fMRI) at rest and during Valsalva maneuvers, before and 3 months after EVBA. Data were analyzed using a whole-brain approach and a brainstem-specific analysis. CBF was assessed using arterial spin labeling MRI.

RESULTS

Resting-state fMRI analysis did not reveal significant differences in functional connectivity at 3 months after EVBA. For the Valsalva maneuver data, the whole-brain fMRI analysis revealed significantly increased activation in the posterior and anterior cingulate, the insular cortex, the precuneus, the left thalamus and the anterior cerebellum. The brainstem-specific fMRI analysis showed a significant increase in BOLD activity in the right midbrain 3 months after EVBA. Mean gray matter CBF (partial volume corrected) decreased significantly from 48.9 (9.9) ml/100 gr/min at baseline to 43.4 (13.0) ml/100 gr/min (p = 0.02) at 3 months.

CONCLUSIONS

This first fMRI pilot study in patients with resistant hypertension treated with EVBA showed a significant increase in BOLD activity during the Valsalva maneuver in brain regions related to sympathetic activity. No notable signal intensity changes were observed in brain areas involved in the baroreflex circuit. Future randomized controlled studies are needed to investigate whether the observed changes are directly caused by EVBA.

CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION

www.clinicaltrials.gov, identifier: NCT02827032.

Treatment of Resistant Hypertension With Endovascular Baroreflex Amplification: 3-Year Results From the CALM-FIM Study

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to evaluate the long-term (3-year) safety and effectiveness of endovascular baroreflex amplification (EVBA) from both the European and American CALM-FIM cohorts.

BACKGROUND

The CALM-FIM study demonstrated that EVBA in patients with resistant hypertension significantly lowered blood pressure (BP) with an acceptable safety profile during 6-month follow-up.

METHODS

The CALM-FIM studies were prospective, nonrandomized, first-in-human studies that enrolled patients with resistant hypertension (office systolic BP ≥160 mm Hg and mean 24-hour ambulatory BP ≥130/80 mm Hg despite a stable regimen of ≥3 antihypertensive medications, including a diuretic agent). The incidence of (serious) adverse events and changes in BP, heart rate, and prescribed antihypertensive medication up to 3 years after implantation were determined.

RESULTS

The Mobius device was implanted in 47 patients (30 in Europe, 17 in the United States; mean age 54 years, 23 women). Five serious adverse events (hypotension, n = 2; hypertension, n = 1; vascular access complications, n = 2) and 2 transient ischemic attacks occurred within 30 days postprocedure. Two strokes and 1 transient ischemic attack occurred more than 2 years postimplantation. Mean office BP at baseline was 181 ± 17/107 ± 16 mm Hg and decreased by 25/12 mm Hg (95% CI: 17-33/8-17 mm Hg) at 6 months and 30/12 mm Hg (95% CI: 21-38/8-17 mm Hg) at 3 years. Mean 24-hour ambulatory BP at baseline was 166 ± 16/98 ± 15 mm Hg and decreased by 20/11 mm Hg (95% CI: 14-25/8-15 mm Hg) at 6 months.

CONCLUSIONS

EVBA with the MobiusHD was effective in reducing BP at 3-year follow-up and appears to have an acceptable safety profile in patients with uncomplicated implantation, although data from randomized sham-controlled trials are needed to further evaluate the risk-benefit profile. (Controlling and Lowering Blood Pressure With the MobiusHD™ [CALM-FIM_EUR], NCT01911897; Controlling and Lowering Blood Pressure With the MobiusHD™ [CALM-FIM_US], NCT01831895).

Device-Based Sympathetic Nerve Regulation for Cardiovascular Diseases

Sympathetic overactivation plays an important role in promoting a variety of pathophysiological processes in cardiovascular diseases (CVDs), including ventricular remodeling, vascular endothelial injury and atherosclerotic plaque progression. Device-based sympathetic nerve (SN) regulation offers a new therapeutic option for some CVDs. Renal denervation (RDN) is the most well-documented method of device-based SN regulation in clinical studies, and several large-scale randomized controlled trials have confirmed its value in patients with resistant hypertension, and some studies have also found RDN to be effective in the control of heart failure and arrhythmias. Pulmonary artery denervation (PADN) has been clinically shown to be effective in controlling pulmonary hypertension. Hepatic artery denervation (HADN) and splenic artery denervation (SADN) are relatively novel approaches that hold promise for a role in cardiovascular metabolic and inflammatory-immune related diseases, and their first-in-man studies are ongoing. In addition, baroreflex activation, spinal cord stimulation and other device-based therapies also show favorable outcomes. This review summarizes the pathophysiological rationale and the latest clinical evidence for device-based therapies for some CVDs.

Endovascular baroreflex amplification and the effect on sympathetic nerve activity in patients with resistant hypertension: A proof-of-principle study

BACKGROUND

First in human studies suggest that endovascular baroreflex amplification (EVBA) lowers blood pressure (BP). To explore potential mechanisms for BP reduction, this study examines the effects of EVBA on muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA) and baroreceptor sensitivity (BRS).

METHODS

In a single-center sub-study of the CALM-DIEM study (Controlling And Lowering blood pressure with the MobiusHD-Defining Efficacy Markers), 14 patients with resistant hypertension were treated with EVBA. Microneurography and non-invasive continuous BP measurements were performed at baseline and three months after MobiusHD implantation. The primary outcome was change in MSNA. Secondary outcomes were change in baroreflex sensitivity (BRS), cardiovascular responses to a sympathetic stimulus, BP, heart rate (HR) and heart rate variability (HRV).

RESULTS

The primary endpoint was obtained in 10 of 14 patients enrolled in the sub-study. MSNA burst frequency and burst incidence decreased in 6 of 10 patients: mean change -4.1 bursts/min (95% confidence interval -12.2 to 4.0) and -3.8 bursts/100 heartbeats (-15.2 to 7.7). MSNA spike frequency and spike count decreased in 8 of 10 patients: mean change -2.8 spikes/sec (-7.3 to 1.8) and -3.0 spikes/heartbeat (-6.1 to 0.1). Change in MSNA and BP were not correlated. Office BP decreased by -14/-6 mmHg (-27 to -2/-15 to 3). We observed a trend towards decreased HR (-5 bpm, -10 to 1) and increased total power HRV (623 msec2, 78 to 1168). In contrast, BRS and cardiovascular responses remained unchanged after EVBA.

CONCLUSIONS

In this proof-of-principle study, EVBA did not significantly decrease MSNA in patients with resistant hypertension. EVBA did not impair baroreflex function.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

Clinical trial registration at NCT02827032.

[Interventional treatment of high blood pressure-Current state]

Arterial hypertension is a real global burden with a very high prevalence. In the last decades, many pharmaceutical approaches have been successfully developed for treating hypertension. Currently, novel medications for influencing blood pressure are not in sight. In recent years alternatives, such as interventional procedures for reducing blood pressure, have been developed and tested. Ablation of the renal sympathetic nerves (renal denervation, RDN), which are wrapped around the renal arteries in particular, has been intensively investigated as a procedure. After the first RDN studies a clear influence on the blood pressure could be shown; however, in the first sham-controlled studies the reduction in blood pressure by RDN could no longer consistently be shown. In very systematic sham-controlled, blinded studies in patients with hypertension but without medication a robust blood pressure reducing effect of RDN could be shown, which corresponded to the effect of a blood pressure-reducing drug. It is obvious that larger studies and also long-term studies have to sustainably confirm this effect. In recent years, active and passive stimulation of the baroreceptors could also be established as a blood pressure reducing principle, at least in studies but the evidence is still very low.

Increased lipopolysaccharide-induced hypothermia in neurogenic hypertension is caused by reduced hypothalamic PGE2 production and increased heat loss

KEY POINTS

The mechanisms involved in hypothermia and fever during systemic inflammation (SI) remain largely unknown. Our data support the contention that brain-mediated mechanisms are different in hypertension during SI. Considering that, clinically, it is not easy to assess all mechanisms involved in cardiovascular and thermoregulatory control during SI, the present study sheds light on these integrated mechanisms that may be triggered simultaneously in septic hypertensive patients. The result obtained demonstrate that, in lipopolysaccharide-induced SI, an increased hypothermia is observed in neurogenic hypertension, which is caused by reduced hypothalamic prostaglandin E₂ production and increased heat loss in conscious rats. Therefore, the results of the present study provide useful insight for clinical trials evaluating the thermoregulatory outcomes of septic patients with hypertension.

ABSTRACT

Hypertension is a prevalent disease characterized by autonomic-induced elevated and sustained blood pressure levels and abnormal body core temperature (Tb) regulation. The present study aimed to determine the brain-mediated mechanisms involved in the thermoregulatory changes observed during lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-induced systemic inflammation (SI; at a septic-like model) in spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR). We combined Tb and skin temperature (Tsk) analysis, assessment of prostaglandin (PG) E₂ levels (the proximal mediator of fever) in the anteroventral region of the hypothalamus (AVPO; an important site for Tb control), oxygen consumption analysis, cardiovascular recordings, assays of inflammatory markers, and evaluation of oxidative stress in the plasma and brain of male Wistar rats and SHR that had received LPS (1.5 mg kg^-1 ) or saline. LPS induced hypothermia followed by fever in Wistar rats, whereas, in SHR, a maintained hypothermia without fever were observed. These thermoregulatory responses were associated with an increased heat loss in SHR compared to Wistar rats. We measured LPS-induced increased PGE₂ levels in the AVPO in Wistar rats, but not in SHR. The LPS-induced drop in blood pressure was higher in SHR than in Wistar rats. Furthermore, LPS-induced plasma and brain [regions involved in autonomic control: nucleus tractus solitarius (NTS) and rostral ventrolateral medulla (RVLM)] cytokine surges were blunted, whereas oxidative stress was higher in SHR. LPS-induced SI leads to blunted cytokine surges both systemically (plasma) and centrally (NTS and RVLM) and reduced hypothalamic PGE₂ production, which are all associated with increased hypothermia mediated by increased heat loss, but not by heat production, in SHR.

Device profile of the MobiusHD EVBA system for the treatment of resistant hypertension: overview of its mechanism of action, safety and efficacy

INTRODUCTION

Early promising results of renal nerve denervation awakened interest in developing medical device alternatives for patients with resistant hypertension. The subsequent sham-controlled renal nerve denervation randomized trials were disappointing leading researchers and innovators to explore alternative device and trial designs to address this significant unmet need. We describe the innovation process leading to the first endovascular carotid baroreflex amplification device currently undergoing clinical trials in the United States and Europe.

AREAS COVERED

We provide a brief overview of carotid baroreceptor physiology and then couple this knowledge with the fundamental principles of strain pattern changes that led to the proposed innovation. The mechanism of blood pressure reduction via enhancing innate physiologic carotid sinus baroreceptor signaling through changes in pulsatile focal carotid bulb strain is described alongside preclinical testing and early clinical results.

EXPERT OPINION

The collective data to date suggest endovascular carotid baroreflex amplification may be an innovative alternative for resistant hypertension patients. However, well-controlled studies will be needed to assess efficacy, safety, durability, and risk: benefit of this permanent intravascular carotid implant.

SUBJECT CODES

high blood pressure, hypertension, treatment, physiology.

Baroreflex Amplification and Carotid Body Modulation for the Treatment of Resistant Hypertension

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Patients with true resistant hypertension (RH) are characterized by having high sympathetic activity and therefore potentially benefit from treatments such as baroreflex amplification (baroreflex activation therapy (BAT) or endovascular baroreflex amplification therapy (EVBA)) or carotid body (CB) modulation. This review aims at providing an up-to-date overview of the available evidence regarding these two therapies.

RECENT FINDINGS

In recent years, increasing evidence has confirmed the potential of baroreflex amplification, either electrically (Barostim neo) or mechanically (MobiusHD), to improve blood pressure control on short- and long-term with only few side effects, in patients with RH. Two studies regarding unilateral CB resection did not show a significant change in blood pressure. Only limited studies regarding CB modulation showed promising results for transvenous CB ablation, but not for unilateral CB resection. Despite promising results from mostly uncontrolled studies, more evidence regarding the safety and efficacy from ongoing large randomized sham-controlled trials is needed before baroreflex amplification and CB modulation can be implemented in routine clinical practice.

Recent advances in understanding and managing resistant/refractory hypertension

The management of resistant hypertension presents several challenges in everyday clinical practice. During the past few years, several studies have been performed to identify efficient and safe pharmacological and non-pharmacological options for the management of such patients. The Spironolactone versus placebo, bisoprolol, and doxazosin to determine the optimal treatment for drug-resistant hypertension (PATHWAY-2) trial demonstrated significant benefits with the use of spinorolactone as a fourth-line drug for the treatment of resistant hypertension over doxazosin and bisoprolol. In addition, recent data support that spironolactone may demonstrate superiority over central acting drugs in such patients, as well. Based on the European guidelines, spironolactone is recommended as the fourth-line drug option, followed by amiloride, other diuretics, doxazosin, bisoprolol or clonidine.  Among several device-based approaches, renal sympathetic denervation had fallen into hibernation after the disappointing results of the Renal Denervation in Patients With Uncontrolled Hypertension (SYMPLICITY HTN) 3 trial. However, the technique re-emerged at the epicenter of the clinical and research interest after the favorable results of three sham-controlled studies, which facilitated novel catheters and techniques to perform the denervation. Significant results of iliac anastomosis on blood pressure levels have also been demonstrated. Nevertheless, the technique-related adverse events resulted in withdrawal of this interventional approach. Last, the sympatholytic properties of the carotid baroreceptor activation therapy were associated with significant blood pressure reductions in patients with resistant hypertension, which need to be verified in larger controlled trials. Currently device-based approaches are recommended only in the setting of clinical trials until more safety and efficacy data become available.

Endovascular baroreflex amplification for resistant hypertension: what you need to know

Endovascular baroreflex amplification is an alternative treatment strategy for patients with resistant hypertension. In endovascular baroreflex, the carotid baroreflex is activated by a MobiusHD^® device (MD) which has been implanted in the internal carotid artery. This review will discuss the MD technology and mechanism of action and promising results in the first-in-human prospective study involving the use of the MD in patients with resistant hypertension.

Baroreflex Activation Therapy for Resistant Hypertension and Heart Failure

Hypertension and heart failure are important contributors to global morbidity and mortality. Despite therapeutic lifestyle and pharmacological measures, a significant proportion of people with hypertension do not reach treatment targets. Patients with resistant or poorly controlled hypertension are at significantly increased risk of cardiovascular events, including heart failure. Since dysfunction of the sympathetic nervous system appears to play a key role in the development and progression of both hypertension and heart failure, these patients may benefit from treatment modalities aimed at reducing sympathetic function. The purpose of this paper is to provide an overview of baroreflex activation therapy as a potential treatment strategy in patients with resistant hypertension or heart failure.

The Current Status of Devices for the Treatment of Resistant Hypertension

Arterial hypertension is associated with increased cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. Although blood pressure-lowering therapies significantly reduce the risk of major cardiovascular events, blood pressure control remains unsatisfactorily low. Several device-based antihypertensive therapies have been investigated in patients with treatment-resistant hypertension and in patients unable or unwilling to adhere to antihypertensive medication. As the field of device-based therapies is subject to constant change, this review aims at providing an up-to-date overview of different device-based approaches for the treatment of hypertension. These approaches target the sympathetic nervous system (renal denervation, baroreflex amplification therapy, baroreflex activation therapy, and carotid body ablation) or alter mechanical arterial properties by creating an iliac arteriovenous fistula. Notably, the use of all of these treatment options is not recommended for the routine treatment of hypertension by current guidelines but should be investigated in the context of controlled clinical studies.

[Baroreflex activation therapy: One more step in the treatment of resistant arterial hypertension and chronic heart failure]

The number of patients who suffer refractory arterial hypertension and chronic heart failure in advanced stages is currently increasing. The case is presented of a patient with an implantable cardioverter defibrillator, and with the dual indication of chronic heart failure and refractory arterial hypertension, who required the implanting of a baroreceptors activation therapy device of the carotid sinus. As far as it is known, it is the first case reported in Spain?

Pre-emptive medicine for hypertension and its prospects

Pre-emptive medicine is a novel medical concept proposed in Japan that aims to precisely predict the onset and progression of diseases and to provide therapeutic interventions during early stages, before symptoms appear. The concept of pre-emptive medicine considers the time-course of a disease in each individual and seeks medical interventions to prevent disease progression. Suitable and promising targets for pre-emptive medicine are non-communicable diseases, including hypertension. Recent advances in genomic analysis, information technology, and artificial intelligence should make this medical concept feasible in the near future. In this review, we focused on pre-emptive medicine for hypertension, referring to concrete plans for the future direction of this research. The ultimate goal of pre-emptive medicine is to completely prevent the onset and progression of hypertension by precisely predicting the elevation of blood pressure and performing interventions to avoid it. The diagnostic processes of hypertension, from the standpoint of pre-emptive medicine, should include the detection of abnormal blood pressure regulation as the earliest manifestation of the disease, the depiction of the present status of hypertension in an individual ("nowcasting"), and a prediction of the future trajectory of the disease ("forecasting"). Novel therapeutic strategies for hypertension, from the standpoint of pre-emptive medicine, should aim for the regression of hypertension through early treatments and the remission of hypertension through intermittent intensive therapies. An efficient modification of lifestyle and therapies, according to the progression of hypertension, should be required. If pre-emptive medicine for hypertension becomes established, it would greatly contribute to the extension of a healthy lifespan, which cannot yet be satisfactorily achieved.