A Comparison of Deep Learning Techniques for Arterial Blood Pressure Prediction

Photoplethysmography-based cuffless blood pressure estimation: an image encoding and fusion approach

Objective.Photoplethysmography (PPG) is a promising wearable technology that detects volumetric changes in microcirculation using a light source and a sensor on the skin's surface. PPG has been shown to be useful for non-invasive blood pressure (BP) measurement. Deep learning-based BP measurements are now gaining popularity. However, almost all methods focus on 1D PPG. We aimed to design an end-to-end approach for estimating BP using image encodings from a 2D perspective.Approach.In this paper, we present a BP estimation approach based on an image encoding and fusion (BP-IEF) technique. We convert the PPG into five image encodings and use them as input. The proposed BP-IEF consists of two parts: an encoder and a decoder. In addition, three kinds of well-known neural networks are taken as the fundamental architecture of the encoder. The decoder is a hybrid architecture that consists of convolutional and fully connected layers, which are used to fuse features from the encoder.Main results.The performance of the proposed BP-IEF is evaluated on the UCI database in both non-mixed and mixed manners. On the non-mixed dataset, the root mean square error and mean absolute error for systolic BP (SBP) are 13.031 mmHg and 9.187 mmHg respectively, while for diastolic BP (DBP) they are 5.049 mmHg and 3.810 mmHg. On the mixed dataset, the corresponding values for SBP are 4.623 mmHg and 3.058 mmHg, while for DBP the values are 2.350 mmHg and 1.608 mmHg. In addition, both SBP and DBP estimation on the mixed dataset achieved grade A compared to the British Hypertension Society standard. The DBP estimation on the non-mixed dataset also achieved grade A.Significance.The results indicate that the proposed approach has the potential to improve on the current mobile healthcare for cuffless BP measurement.

Capturing the pulse: a state-of-the-art review on camera-based jugular vein assessment

Heart failure is associated with a rehospitalisation rate of up to 50% within six months. Elevated central venous pressure may serve as an early warning sign. While invasive procedures are used to measure central venous pressure for guiding treatment in hospital, this becomes impractical upon discharge. A non-invasive estimation technique exists, where the clinician visually inspects the pulsation of the jugular veins in the neck, but it is less reliable due to human limitations. Video and signal processing technologies may offer a high-fidelity alternative. This state-of-the-art review analyses existing literature on camera-based methods for jugular vein assessment. We summarize key design considerations and suggest avenues for future research. Our review highlights the neck as a rich imaging target beyond the jugular veins, capturing comprehensive cardiac signals, and outlines factors affecting signal quality and measurement accuracy. Addressing an often quoted limitation in the field, we also propose minimum reporting standards for future studies.

A Systematic Approach Focused on Machine Learning Models for Exploring the Landscape of Physiological Measurement and Estimation Using Photoplethysmography (PPG)

A non-invasive optical technique known as photoplethysmography (PPG) can be used to provide various physiological measurements and estimations. PPG can be used to assess cardiovascular disease (CVD). Hypertension is a primary risk factor for CVD and a major health problem worldwide. PPG is popular because of its important applications in the evaluation of cardiac activity, variations in venous blood volume, blood oxygen saturation, blood pressure and heart rate variability, etc. In this study, we provide a comprehensive analysis of the extraction of various physiological parameters using PPG waveforms. In addition, we focused on the role of machine learning (ML) models used for the estimation of blood pressure and hypertension classification based on PPG waveforms to make future research and innovation recommendations. This study will be helpful for researchers, scientists, and medical practitioners working on PPG waveforms for monitoring, screening, and diagnosis, as a comparative study or reference.

Artificial Intelligence ECG Analysis in Patients with Short QT Syndrome to Predict Life-Threatening Arrhythmic Events

Short QT syndrome (SQTS) is an inherited cardiac ion-channel disease related to an increased risk of sudden cardiac death (SCD) in young and otherwise healthy individuals. SCD is often the first clinical presentation in patients with SQTS. However, arrhythmia risk stratification is presently unsatisfactory in asymptomatic patients. In this context, artificial intelligence-based electrocardiogram (ECG) analysis has never been applied to refine risk stratification in patients with SQTS. The purpose of this study was to analyze ECGs from SQTS patients with the aid of different AI algorithms to evaluate their ability to discriminate between subjects with and without documented life-threatening arrhythmic events. The study group included 104 SQTS patients, 37 of whom had a documented major arrhythmic event at presentation and/or during follow-up. Thirteen ECG features were measured independently by three expert cardiologists; then, the dataset was randomly divided into three subsets (training, validation, and testing). Five shallow neural networks were trained, validated, and tested to predict subject-specific class (non-event/event) using different subsets of ECG features. Additionally, several deep learning and machine learning algorithms, such as Vision Transformer, Swin Transformer, MobileNetV3, EfficientNetV2, ConvNextTiny, Capsule Networks, and logistic regression were trained, validated, and tested directly on the scanned ECG images, without any manual feature extraction. Furthermore, a shallow neural network, a 1-D transformer classifier, and a 1-D CNN were trained, validated, and tested on ECG signals extracted from the aforementioned scanned images. Classification metrics were evaluated by means of sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values, accuracy, and area under the curve. Results prove that artificial intelligence can help clinicians in better stratifying risk of arrhythmia in patients with SQTS. In particular, shallow neural networks' processing features showed the best performance in identifying patients that will not suffer from a potentially lethal event. This could pave the way for refined ECG-based risk stratification in this group of patients, potentially helping in saving the lives of young and otherwise healthy individuals.

Continual Learning for Cuffless Blood Pressure Measurement using PPG and ECG Signals

Although numerous studies have been conducted on cuffless blood pressure (BP) estimation using machine learning methods, most of the data-driven models are static, with model parameters fixed after training is complete. However, BP is dynamic and the performance would degrade for a static model when the to-be predicted BP distribution deviates from the training BP distribution. In this paper, we propose a continual learning (CL) framework in which deep learning models are developed to learn dynamically and continuously for arterial BP (ABP) estimation with photoplethysmography (PPG) and electrocardiogram (ECG) waveforms. The effectiveness of the CL model is validated on UCI Repository and MIMIC-III database with a total of 132 individual samples, and compared with conventional training method. It was found that the CL model improved the ABP estimation accuracy in terms of mean absolute error (MAE) by 17.47% on average compared with conventional training model. Furthermore, the improvement increased with the variability of ABP. These results demonstrate that CL model has potential to estimate dynamic ABP, which has been challenging with conventional training.

Emerging sensing and modeling technologies for wearable and cuffless blood pressure monitoring

Cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) are a leading cause of death worldwide. For early diagnosis, intervention and management of CVDs, it is highly desirable to frequently monitor blood pressure (BP), a vital sign closely related to CVDs, during people's daily life, including sleep time. Towards this end, wearable and cuffless BP extraction methods have been extensively researched in recent years as part of the mobile healthcare initiative. This review focuses on the enabling technologies for wearable and cuffless BP monitoring platforms, covering both the emerging flexible sensor designs and BP extraction algorithms. Based on the signal type, the sensing devices are classified into electrical, optical, and mechanical sensors, and the state-of-the-art material choices, fabrication methods, and performances of each type of sensor are briefly reviewed. In the model part of the review, contemporary algorithmic BP estimation methods for beat-to-beat BP measurements and continuous BP waveform extraction are introduced. Mainstream approaches, such as pulse transit time-based analytical models and machine learning methods, are compared in terms of their input modalities, features, implementation algorithms, and performances. The review sheds light on the interdisciplinary research opportunities to combine the latest innovations in the sensor and signal processing research fields to achieve a new generation of cuffless BP measurement devices with improved wearability, reliability, and accuracy.

A PPG-Based Calibration-Free Cuffless Blood Pressure Estimation Method Using Cardiovascular Dynamics

Traditional cuff-based sphygmomanometers for measuring blood pressure can be uncomfortable and particularly unsuitable to use during sleep. A proposed alternative method uses dynamic changes in the pulse waveform over short intervals and replaces calibration with information from photoplethysmogram (PPG) morphology to provide a calibration-free approach using a single sensor. Results from 30 patients show a high correlation of 73.64% for systolic blood pressure (SBP) and 77.72% for diastolic blood pressure (DBP) between blood pressure estimated with the PPG morphology features and the calibration method. This suggests that the PPG morphology features could replace the calibration stage for a calibration-free method with similar accuracy. Applying the proposed methodology on 200 patients and testing on 25 new patients resulted in a mean error (ME) of -0.31 mmHg, a standard deviation of error (SDE) of 4.89 mmHg, a mean absolute error (MAE) of 3.32 mmHg for DBP and an ME of -4.02 mmHg, an SDE of 10.40 mmHg, and an MAE of 7.41 mmHg for SBP. These results support the potential for using a PPG signal for calibration-free cuffless blood pressure estimation and improving accuracy by adding information from cardiovascular dynamics to different methods in the cuffless blood pressure monitoring field.

Cuff-Less Blood Pressure Prediction Based on Photoplethysmography and Modified ResNet

Cardiovascular disease (CVD) has become a common health problem of mankind, and the prevalence and mortality of CVD are rising on a year-to-year basis. Blood pressure (BP) is an important physiological parameter of the human body and also an important physiological indicator for the prevention and treatment of CVD. Existing intermittent measurement methods do not fully indicate the real BP status of the human body and cannot get rid of the restraining feeling of a cuff. Accordingly, this study proposed a deep learning network based on the ResNet34 framework for continuous prediction of BP using only the promising PPG signal. The high-quality PPG signals were first passed through a multi-scale feature extraction module after a series of pre-processing to expand the perceptive field and enhance the perception ability on features. Subsequently, useful feature information was then extracted by stacking multiple residual modules with channel attention to increase the accuracy of the model. Lastly, in the training stage, the Huber loss function was adopted to stabilize the iterative process and obtain the optimal solution of the model. On a subset of the MIMIC dataset, the errors of both SBP and DBP predicted by the model met the AAMI standards, while the accuracy of DBP reached Grade A of the BHS standard, and the accuracy of SBP almost reached Grade A of the BHS standard. The proposed method verifies the potential and feasibility of PPG signals combined with deep neural networks in the field of continuous BP monitoring. Furthermore, the method is easy to deploy in portable devices, and it is more consistent with the future trend of wearable blood-pressure-monitoring devices (e.g., smartphones and smartwatches).

A benchmark for machine-learning based non-invasive blood pressure estimation using photoplethysmogram

Blood Pressure (BP) is an important cardiovascular health indicator. BP is usually monitored non-invasively with a cuff-based device, which can be bulky and inconvenient. Thus, continuous and portable BP monitoring devices, such as those based on a photoplethysmography (PPG) waveform, are desirable. In particular, Machine Learning (ML) based BP estimation approaches have gained considerable attention as they have the potential to estimate intermittent or continuous BP with only a single PPG measurement. Over the last few years, many ML-based BP estimation approaches have been proposed with no agreement on their modeling methodology. To ease the model comparison, we designed a benchmark with four open datasets with shared preprocessing, the right validation strategy avoiding information shift and leak, and standard evaluation metrics. We also adapted Mean Absolute Scaled Error (MASE) to improve the interpretability of model evaluation, especially across different BP datasets. The proposed benchmark comes with open datasets and codes. We showcase its effectiveness by comparing 11 ML-based approaches of three different categories.

Wearable Continuous Blood Pressure Monitoring Devices Based on Pulse Wave Transit Time and Pulse Arrival Time: A Review

Continuous blood pressure (BP) monitoring is of great significance for the real-time monitoring and early prevention of cardiovascular diseases. Recently, wearable BP monitoring devices have made great progress in the development of daily BP monitoring because they adapt to long-term and high-comfort wear requirements. However, the research and development of wearable continuous BP monitoring devices still face great challenges such as obvious motion noise and slow dynamic response speeds. The pulse wave transit time method which is combined with photoplethysmography (PPG) waves and electrocardiogram (ECG) waves for continuous BP monitoring has received wide attention due to its advantages in terms of excellent dynamic response characteristics and high accuracy. Here, we review the recent state-of-art wearable continuous BP monitoring devices and related technology based on the pulse wave transit time; their measuring principles, design methods, preparation processes, and properties are analyzed in detail. In addition, the potential development directions and challenges of wearable continuous BP monitoring devices based on the pulse wave transit time method are discussed.

COVID-19 Detection Using Photoplethysmography and Neural Networks

The early identification of microvascular changes in patients with Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) may offer an important clinical opportunity. This study aimed to define a method, based on deep learning approaches, for the identification of COVID-19 patients from the analysis of the raw PPG signal, acquired with a pulse oximeter. To develop the method, we acquired the PPG signal of 93 COVID-19 patients and 90 healthy control subjects using a finger pulse oximeter. To select the good quality portions of the signal, we developed a template-matching method that excludes samples corrupted by noise or motion artefacts. These samples were subsequently used to develop a custom convolutional neural network model. The model accepts PPG signal segments as input and performs a binary classification between COVID-19 and control samples. The proposed model showed good performance in identifying COVID-19 patients, achieving 83.86% accuracy and 84.30% sensitivity (hold-out validation) on test data. The obtained results indicate that photoplethysmography may be a useful tool for microcirculation assessment and early recognition of SARS-CoV-2-induced microvascular changes. In addition, such a noninvasive and low-cost method is well suited for the development of a user-friendly system, potentially applicable even in resource-limited healthcare settings.

Applied machine learning for blood pressure estimation using a small, real-world electrocardiogram and photoplethysmogram dataset

Applying machine learning techniques to electrocardiography and photoplethysmography signals and their multivariate-derived waveforms is an ongoing effort to estimate non-occlusive blood pressure. Unfortunately, real ambulatory electrocardiography and photoplethysmography waveforms are inevitably affected by motion and noise artifacts, so established machine learning architectures perform poorly when trained on data of the Multiparameter Intelligent Monitoring in Intensive Care II type, a publicly available ICU database. Our study addresses this problem by applying four well-established machine learning methods, i.e., random forest regression, support vector regression, Adaboost regression and artificial neural networks, to a small, self-sampled electrocardiography-photoplethysmography dataset (n = 54) to improve the robustness of machine learning to real-world BP estimates. We evaluated the performance using a selection of optimal feature morphologies of waveforms by using pulse arrival time, morphological and frequency photoplethysmography parameters and heart rate variability as characterization data. On the basis of the root mean square error and mean absolute error, our study showed that support vector regression gave the best performance for blood pressure estimation from noisy data, achieving an mean absolute error of 6.97 mmHg, which meets the level C criteria set by the British Hypertension Society. We demonstrate that ambulatory electrocardiography- photoplethysmography signals acquired by mobile discrete devices can be used to estimate blood pressure.

Non-invasive blood pressure estimation combining deep neural networks with pre-training and partial fine-tuning

Objective. Daily blood pressure (BP) monitoring is essential since BP levels can reflect the functions of heart pumping and vasoconstriction. Although various neural network-based BP estimate approaches have been proposed, they have certain practical shortcomings, such as low estimation accuracy and poor model generalization. Based on the strategy of pre-training and partial fine-tuning, this work proposes a non-invasive method for BP estimation using the photoplethysmography (PPG) signal.Approach. To learn the PPG-BP relationship, the deep convolutional bidirectional recurrent neural network (DC-Bi-RNN) was pre-trained with data from the public medical information mark for intensive care (MIMIC III) database. A tiny quantity of data from the target subject was used to fine-tune the specific layers of the pre-trained model to learn more individual-specific information to achieve highly accurate BP estimation.Main results.The mean absolute error and the Pearson correlation coefficient (r) of the proposed algorithm are 3.21 mmHg and 0.919 for systolic BP, and 1.80 mmHg and 0.898 for diastolic BP (DBP). The experimental results show that our method outperforms other methods and meets the requirements of the Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation standard, and received an A grade according to the British Hypertension Society standard.Significance.The proposed method applies the strategy of pre-training and partial fine-tuning to BP estimation and verifies its effectiveness in improving the accuracy of non-invasive BP estimation.

Continuous Blood Pressure Estimation Based on Multi-Scale Feature Extraction by the Neural Network With Multi-Task Learning

In this article, a novel method for continuous blood pressure (BP) estimation based on multi-scale feature extraction by the neural network with multi-task learning (MST-net) has been proposed and evaluated. First, we preprocess the target (Electrocardiograph; Photoplethysmography) and label signals (arterial blood pressure), especially using peak-to-peak time limits of signals to eliminate the interference of the false peak. Then, we design a MST-net to extract multi-scale features related to BP, fully excavate and learn the relationship between multi-scale features and BP, and then estimate three BP values simultaneously. Finally, the performance of the developed neural network is verified by using a public multi-parameter intelligent monitoring waveform database. The results show that the mean absolute error ± standard deviation for systolic blood pressure (SBP), diastolic blood pressure (DBP), and mean arterial pressure (MAP) with the proposed method against reference are 4.04 ± 5.81, 2.29 ± 3.55, and 2.46 ± 3.58 mmHg, respectively; the correlation coefficients of SBP, DBP, and MAP are 0.96, 0.92, and 0.94, respectively, which meet the Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation standard and reach A level of the British Hypertension Society standard. This study provides insights into the improvement of accuracy and efficiency of a continuous BP estimation method with a simple structure and without calibration. The proposed algorithm for BP estimation could potentially enable continuous BP monitoring by mobile health devices.

Methods for Continuous Blood Pressure Estimation Using Temporal Convolutional Neural Networks and Ensemble Empirical Mode Decomposition

Arterial blood pressure is not only an important index that must be measured in routine physical examination but also a key monitoring parameter of the cardiovascular system in cardiac surgery, drug testing, and intensive care. To improve the measurement accuracy of continuous blood pressure, this paper uses photoplethysmography (PPG) signals to estimate diastolic blood pressure and systolic blood pressure based on ensemble empirical mode decomposition (EEMD) and temporal convolutional network (TCN). In this method, the clean PPG signal is decomposed by EEMD to obtain n-order intrinsic mode functions (IMF), and then the IMF and the original PPG are input into the constructed TCN neural network model, and the results are output. The results show that TCN has better performance than CNN, CNN-LSTM, and CNN-GRU. Using the data added with IMF, the results of the above neural network model are better than those of the model with only PPG as input, in which the systolic blood pressure (SBP) and diastolic blood pressure (DBP) results of EEMD-TCN are −1.55 ± 9.92 mmHg and 0.41 ± 4.86 mmHg. According to the estimation results, DBP meets the requirements of the AAMI standard, BHS evaluates it as Grade A, SD of SBP is close to the standard AAMI, and BHS evaluates it as Grade B.

State-of-the-art Deep Learning Methods on Electrocardiogram Data: A Systematic Review (Preprint)

Background

Electrocardiogram (ECG) is one of the most common noninvasive diagnostic tools that can provide useful information regarding a patient’s health status. Deep learning (DL) is an area of intense exploration that leads the way in most attempts to create powerful diagnostic models based on physiological signals.

Objective

This study aimed to provide a systematic review of DL methods applied to ECG data for various clinical applications.

Methods

The PubMed search engine was systematically searched by combining “deep learning” and keywords such as “ecg,” “ekg,” “electrocardiogram,” “electrocardiography,” and “electrocardiology.” Irrelevant articles were excluded from the study after screening titles and abstracts, and the remaining articles were further reviewed. The reasons for article exclusion were manuscripts written in any language other than English, absence of ECG data or DL methods involved in the study, and absence of a quantitative evaluation of the proposed approaches.

Results

We identified 230 relevant articles published between January 2020 and December 2021 and grouped them into 6 distinct medical applications, namely, blood pressure estimation, cardiovascular disease diagnosis, ECG analysis, biometric recognition, sleep analysis, and other clinical analyses. We provide a complete account of the state-of-the-art DL strategies per the field of application, as well as major ECG data sources. We also present open research problems, such as the lack of attempts to address the issue of blood pressure variability in training data sets, and point out potential gaps in the design and implementation of DL models.

Conclusions

We expect that this review will provide insights into state-of-the-art DL methods applied to ECG data and point to future directions for research on DL to create robust models that can assist medical experts in clinical decision-making.