A tale of two rivers: implications of water management practices for mussel biodiversity outcomes during droughts

The positive impact of conservation action

Governments recently adopted new global targets to halt and reverse the loss of biodiversity. It is therefore crucial to understand the outcomes of conservation actions. We conducted a global meta-analysis of 186 studies (including 665 trials) that measured biodiversity over time and compared outcomes under conservation action with a suitable counterfactual of no action. We find that in two-thirds of cases, conservation either improved the state of biodiversity or at least slowed declines. Specifically, we find that interventions targeted at species and ecosystems, such as invasive species control, habitat loss reduction and restoration, protected areas, and sustainable management, are highly effective and have large effect sizes. This provides the strongest evidence to date that conservation actions are successful but require transformational scaling up to meet global targets.

Ecosystem bioelement variability is associated with freshwater animal aggregations at the aquatic-terrestrial interface

The impacts of animals on the biogeochemical cycles of major bioelements like C, N, and P are well-studied across ecosystem types. However, more than 20 elements are necessary for life. The feedbacks between animals and the biogeochemical cycles of the other bioelements are an emerging research priority. We explored how much freshwater mussels (Bivalvia: Unionoida) were related to variability in ecosystem pools of 10 bioelements (Ca, Cu, Fe, K, Mn, Na, Mg, P, S and Zn) in streams containing a natural mussel density gradient in the US Interior Highlands. We studied the concentrations of these bioelements across the aquatic-terrestrial interface-in the porewater of riverine gravel bars, and the emergent macrophyte Justicia americana. Higher mussel density was associated with increased calcium in gravel bars and macrophytes. Mussel density also correlated with variability in iron and other redox-sensitive trace elements in gravel bars and macrophytes, although this relationship was mediated by sediment grain size. We found that two explanations for the patterns we observed are worthy of further research: (1) increased calcium availability in gravel bars near denser mussel aggregations may be a product of the buildup and dissolution of shells in the gravel bar, and (2) mussels may alter redox conditions, and thus elemental availability in gravel bars with fine sediments, either behaviorally or through physical structure provided by shell material. A better understanding of the physical and biogeochemical impacts of animals on a wide range of elemental cycles is thus necessary to conserve the societal value of freshwater ecosystems.

Causes, Responses, and Implications of Anthropogenic versus Natural Flow Intermittence in River Networks

Rivers that do not flow year-round are the predominant type of running waters on Earth. Despite a burgeoning literature on natural flow intermittence (NFI), knowledge about the hydrological causes and ecological effects of human-induced, anthropogenic flow intermittence (AFI) remains limited. NFI and AFI could generate contrasting hydrological and biological responses in rivers because of distinct underlying causes of drying and evolutionary adaptations of their biota. We first review the causes of AFI and show how different anthropogenic drivers alter the timing, frequency and duration of drying, compared with NFI. Second, we evaluate the possible differences in biodiversity responses, ecological functions, and ecosystem services between NFI and AFI. Last, we outline knowledge gaps and management needs related to AFI. Because of the distinct hydrologic characteristics and ecological impacts of AFI, ignoring the distinction between NFI and AFI could undermine management of intermittent rivers and ephemeral streams and exacerbate risks to the ecosystems and societies downstream.

NiSO4 spill inflicts varying mortality between four freshwater mussel species (including protected Unio crassus Philipsson, 1788) in a western Finnish river

Freshwater mussels are one of the most threatened taxonomic groups in the world, and many species are on the brink of local or global extinction. Human activities have altered mussel living conditions in a plethora of ways. One of the most destructive human-induced impacts on running waters is the catastrophic spill of harmful substances, which results in massive die-offs. Even though Finland is regarded as the world's top country in terms of environmental regulation quality, riverine systems are not safe. In 2014, River Kokemäenjoki in western Finland experienced the worst NiSO₄ spill in the country's history, visibly affecting the mussel community - including protected Unio crassus - along the river. Because freshwater mussel toxicology is grossly understudied (particularly in Europe), any pollution -linked die-offs offer valuable opportunities to study the issue in natural environment. Here, we report the mussel investigations from 2014 and a follow-up study conducted in 2017 in order to assess the variation in species sensitivity on nickel pollution. In total, 104 sites were sampled, and over 20 000 mussels were identified and counted. Our results indicate that the most impacted species (i.e. that which experienced the highest spill-induced mortality) was Anodonta anatina (62%), followed by Unio pictorum (32%), U. crassus (24%) and Unio tumidus (9%). The underlying reason for the sensitivity of A. anatina is not resolved, hence more research is urgently needed. The low mortality among most of the species in 2017 highlights the temporal nature of the pollution impact and the recovery potential of the mussel community. However, the case is more complex with U. crassus population, which may be experiencing delayed impacts of the spill. Because nickel is one of the most commonly produced industrial metals in the world (hence the pollution incident risk is high) and River Kokemäenjoki hosts mussel community typical for European rivers, our results may benefit many researchers and stakeholders dealing with riverine environments.

A semi-arid river in distress: Contributing factors and recovery solutions for three imperiled freshwater mussels (Family Unionidae) endemic to the Rio Grande basin in North America

Freshwater resources in arid and semi-arid regions are in extreme demand, which creates conflicts between needs of humans and aquatic ecosystems. The Rio Grande basin in the southwestern United States and northern Mexico exemplifies this issue, as much of its aquatic biodiversity is in peril as a result of human activities. Unionid mussels have been disproportionately impacted, though the specific factors responsible for their decline remain largely unknown. This is problematic because the Rio Grande basin harbors one federally endangered unionid mussel (Popenaias popeii, Texas Hornshell) plus two other mussel species (Potamilus metnecktayi, Salina Mucket; and Truncilla cognata, Mexican Fawnsfoot), which are also being considered for listing under the U.S. Endangered Species Act. To date, surveys for these species have not corrected for variability in detection so current range estimates may be inaccurate. Using single occupancy-modeling to estimate detection and occupancy at 115 sites along ~800 river kilometers of the Rio Grande in Texas, we found that detection probabilities were relatively high, indicating that our survey design was efficient. In contrast, the estimated occupancy was low, indicating that our focal species were likely rare within the Rio Grande drainage. In general, the predicted occupancy of our focal species was low throughout their respective ranges, indicating possible range declines. A comparison of currently occupied ranges to presumptive ranges underscores this point. The best-approximating models indicated that occupancy was influenced by habitat, water quantity and quality, and proximity to large-scale human activities, such as dams and major urban centers. We also discuss a series of conservation options that may not only improve the long-term prognosis of our focal species but also other aquatic taxa.

Drought-induced changes in flow regimes lead to long-term losses in mussel-provided ecosystem services

Extreme hydro-meteorological events such as droughts are becoming more frequent, intense, and persistent. This is particularly true in the south central USA, where rapidly growing urban areas are running out of water and human-engineered water storage and management are leading to broad-scale changes in flow regimes. The Kiamichi River in southeastern Oklahoma, USA, has high fish and freshwater mussel biodiversity. However, water from this rural river is desired by multiple urban areas and other entities. Freshwater mussels are large, long-lived filter feeders that provide important ecosystem services. We ask how observed changes in mussel biomass and community composition resulting from drought-induced changes in flow regimes might lead to changes in river ecosystem services. We sampled mussel communities in this river over a 20-year period that included two severe droughts. We then used laboratory-derived physiological rates and river-wide estimates of species-specific mussel biomass to estimate three aggregate ecosystem services provided by mussels over this time period: biofiltration, nutrient recycling (nitrogen and phosphorus), and nutrient storage (nitrogen, phosphorus, and carbon). Mussel populations declined over 60%, and declines were directly linked to drought-induced changes in flow regimes. All ecosystem services declined over time and mirrored biomass losses. Mussel declines were exacerbated by human water management, which has increased the magnitude and frequency of hydrologic drought in downstream reaches of the river. Freshwater mussels are globally imperiled and declining around the world. Summed across multiple streams and rivers, mussel losses similar to those we document here could have considerable consequences for downstream water quality although lost biofiltration and nutrient retention. While we cannot control the frequency and severity of climatological droughts, water releases from reservoirs could be used to augment stream flows and prevent compounded anthropogenic stressors.