Reducing Blood Culture Contamination Rates: Experiences of Four Hospital Systems

Reducing Blood Culture Contamination Rates: Introduction of a Combined Education and Skin Antisepsis Intervention

Background. Blood culture contamination (BCC) is an important quality concern in clinical microbiology as it can lead to unnecessary antimicrobial therapy in patients and increased workload for laboratory scientists. The Clinical Laboratory and Standards Institute recommend BCC rates to be <3 % and recently updated guidelines have set a new goal of 1 %. The aim of this project was to design and implement interventions to reduce BCC rates at our institution. Methods. We introduced a combined education and skin antisepsis intervention in a large Model 4 academic teaching hospital in the South of Ireland. BD ChloraPrep skin antisepsis applicators (2 % chlorhexidine gluconate/70 % isopropyl alcohol), licensed for use for blood culture specimen collection, were introduced, replacing Clinell (2 % chlorhexidine gluconate/70 % isopropyl alcohol) wipes. In addition, a multimodal education programme was designed and delivered. This consisted of a video demonstrating the recommended blood culture specimen collection technique using the new applicators as well as simulation training for all interns. The video was uploaded to the intranet as an educational resource available to all staff. Results. The interventions were implemented in July 2022 and BCC rates pre- and post-intervention were calculated. The average BCC rate for the 12 months preceding the intervention (July 2021 to July 2022) was 2.56 % with highest rates in the Emergency Department. This compared to an average rate of 2.2 % in the 12 months post-intervention (July 2022 to July 2023). In comparing the two rates the reduction in BCC rates between the two periods was not statistically significant (P=0.30). Conclusion. Overall BCC rates reduced but the difference between the two periods did not reach statistical significance. The resource-intensive nature of providing regular and timely feedback of contamination rates and the larger impact of in-person education and training over virtual modalities may explain the modest reduction. Further investments in these areas, particularly in the Emergency Department, will be necessary to further reduce rates in line with new recommendations.

Benchmarking blood culture quality in the emergency department: Contamination, single sets and positivity

OBJECTIVE

To benchmark blood culture (BC) quality in an Australian ED, explore groups at risk of suboptimal BC collection, and identify potential areas for improvement.

METHODS

This retrospective observational study was undertaken to benchmark quality of BCs in a tertiary adult ED in terms of number of BC sets per patient and proportion of patients with false positive (contaminated) BC results.

RESULTS

A single BC set was taken for 55% of patients, with lower acuity patients being more likely to have a single BC set taken. BC false positives occurred in 3.4% of presentations, with higher frequency in some critically unwell patient groups. The true positive BC rate was 10.9%, with pathogens most frequently isolated in older patients, those with a haematological condition or genitourinary source, and those admitted to inpatient wards. Hospital length of stay did not differ between patients with negative and patients with false positive BCs.

CONCLUSIONS

BC quality standards in the ED such as false positive rate <3% and single culture rate <20% are required to facilitate benchmarking and prospective quality improvement. The sensitivity and specificity of this common and critical test can be improved. Patient subgroups associated with poor-quality BC collection can be identified and should be a focus of future work.

Rising Drug Resistance Among Gram-Negative Pathogens in Bloodstream Infections: A Multicenter Study in Ulanhot, Inner Mongolia (2017-2021)

BACKGROUND Bloodstream infections, which arise when pathogenic microorganisms infiltrate the bloodstream, present a grave health risk. Their potentially lethal nature combined with the ability to severely impair physiological functions underscore the importance of understanding and mitigating such infections. This study aimed to elucidate drug sensitivity profiles and distribution of these pathogens in hospitals in Ulanhot, Inner Mongolia. MATERIAL AND METHODS From 2017 to 2021, we gathered blood culture-positive samples from several hospitals across Ulanhot. Using combined diagnostic techniques, including the instrument method, paper diffusion, and Epsilometer test (E-test), we determined the identity of pathogens and assessed their drug sensitivity. Subsequent data processing with WHONET 5.6 software provided insights into the patterns of microbial distribution and extent of drug resistance. RESULTS Of 2498 pathogenic strains identified, 35.83% were gram-positive, 62.45% were gram-negative, and a smaller fraction of 1.72% were fungi. Escherichia coli and Klebsiella pneumoniae were the primary bacteria, contributing to 35.15% and 15.73% of infections, respectively. Alarmingly, methicillin-resistant strains exhibited pronounced resistance to drugs, notably penicillin G (resistance rates of 80.87% to 100.00%) and erythromycin (resistance rates of 91.16% to 97.28%). Acinetobacter baumannii had a particularly high resistance profile, surpassing Pseudomonas aeruginosa, which exhibited a resistance rate below 30.00%. CONCLUSIONS Ulanhot's primary bloodstream infection agents were gram-negative bacteria, specifically E. coli and K. pneumoniae. The growing drug resistance observed, particularly among strains like A. baumannii, highlights the pressing need for rigorous drug resistance surveillance and the strategic use of antibiotics, ensuring their efficacy is preserved for future medical needs.

Development and validation of a standardized blood culture contamination definition and metric dashboard for a large health care system

OBJECTIVES

Blood culture contamination is a major problem in health care, with significant impacts on both patient safety and cost. Initiatives to reduce blood culture contamination require a reliable, consistent metric to track the success of interventions. The objective of our project was to establish a standardized definition of blood culture contamination suitable for use in a Veterans Health Administration (VHA) national data query, then to validate this definition and query. A secondary objective was to construct a national VHA data dashboard to display the data from this query that could be used in VHA quality improvement projects aimed at reducing blood culture contamination.

METHODS

A VHA microbiology expert work group was formed to generate a standardized definition and oversee the validation studies. The standardized definition was used to generate data for calendar year 2021 using a Structured Query Language data query. Twelve VHA hospital microbiology laboratories compared the data from the query against their own locally derived contamination data and recorded those data in a data collection worksheet that all sites used. Data were collated and presented to the work group.

RESULTS

More than 50,000 blood culture accessions were in the validation data set, with more than 1,200 contamination events. The overall blood culture contamination rate for the 12 facilities participating was 2.56% with local definitions and data and 2.43% with the standardized definitions and data query. The main differences noted between the 2 data sets were deemed to be issues in local definitions. The query and definition were then converted into a national data dashboard that all VHA facilities can now access.

CONCLUSIONS

A standardized definition for blood culture contamination and a national data query were validated for enterprise-wide VHA use. To our knowledge, this represents the first reported standardized, validated, and automated approach for calculating and tracking blood culture contamination. This tool will be key in quality initiatives aimed at reducing contamination events in VHA.

Factors impacting the pre-analytical quality of blood cultures-Analysis at a tertiary medical center

BACKGROUND

Blood cultures (BC) are critical for the diagnosis of bloodstream infections, pathogen identification, and resistance testing. Guidelines recommend a blood volume of 8-10 mL per bottle as lower volumes result in decreased sensitivity. We aimed to evaluate factors for non-adherence to recommended volumes and assess the effects on diagnostic performance.

METHODS

From February to April 2020, we measured collected blood volumes by weighing all BC containers from inpatient samples at the University Hospital Basel. Information on BC volumes was merged with clinical and microbiological data, as well as nursing staff schedules. We analyzed factors associated with (i) BC sampling volume, (ii) reaching recommended volumes (≥8 mL), (iii) BC positivity, and (iv) time to positivity using linear and generalized linear mixed effect models.

RESULTS

We evaluated a total of 4'118 BC bottles collected from 686 patients. A total of 1'495 (36.3%) of all bottles contained the recommended filling volume of ≥8 mL. Using a central venous and arterial catheter for drawing blood resulted in an increase of filling volume by 0.26 mL (95% CI 0.10, 0.41) and 0.50 mL (95% CI 0.31, 0.69) compared to peripheral venipuncture, respectively. Each additional nursing staff working at the time of blood drawing was associated with 6% higher odds of achieving the recommended filling volume. We found no significant correlation between the filling volume and the positivity rate.

CONCLUSION

Our results indicate critical pre-analytical quality markers linked to BC collection procedures to reach recommended collection volumes. No significant impact on the positivity rate was found.

Changes in Use of Blood Cultures in a COVID-19-Dedicated Tertiary Hospital

Blood cultures should be collected within an hour in the setting of sepsis/septic shock. The contamination rate should be below 3%. Worldwide reports have described an increase in blood contamination rates during the COVID-19 pandemic. We performed a retrospective analysis of the blood cultures collected during a 10-month period (March−December 2020) at NIID “Prof. Dr. Matei Balș”. The results were compared with data from the pre-pandemic period (March−December 2016) and with the existing data in the literature. During the pandemic, there was a significant decrease in the number of blood cultures collected (1274 blood cultures in 2020 vs. 5399 in 2016). The contamination rate was higher in 2020 (11.7%) compared to 2016 (8.2%), p < 0.001. The rate of infectious episodes in which the etiological agent was identified was constant: 11% in 2020 versus 11.9% in 2016, p = 0.479, but there were fewer invasive bacterial/fungal infections: 0.95/1000 patient days in 2020 vs. 2.39/1000 patient days in 2016, p < 0.001. We observed a change in the species distribution. The Gram-negative isolate’s proportion increased from 50.6% to 63.1% and the gram-positive isolate’s proportion decreased from 31.8% to 19%. Collection of a low number of blood cultures and a high contamination rate was identified in our clinic. In order to improve the usefulness of blood cultures as a diagnostic method, at least two sets should be collected in aseptic conditions.

Effectiveness of multimodal intervention to improve blood culture collection in the emergency department

Introduction:

The blood culture (BC) contamination was a significant problem in our hospital, especially in the emergency department (ED). The study, therefore, was undertaken to improve the BC collection in the ED.

Methods:

The study was conducted for 1 year divided into two phases of 6 months each: Preintervention phase and intervention phase (regular and phlebotomist groups). The interventions comprised implementing standard protocol for BC collection and conducting educational sessions. In preintervention and regular groups, the BCs were collected by interns and technicians, while dedicated phlebotomist did so in the phlebotomist group. Data were analyzed and interpreted for the contamination rate as well as compliance in adequate filling of the requisition form. Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) version 22. A value of P < 0.005 was considered statistically significant, and P < 0.01 was considered statistically significant.

Results:

In the preintervention group, 13.7% of specimens were reported as contaminated which was reduced to 4.2% and 3.2% in the regular and phlebotomist group, respectively, after intervention. Compliance of health-care workers to various elements of BC collection protocol was also found to be significantly improved in the intervention phase compared to the preintervention phase (P < 0.001).

Conclusions:

Implementation of this multimodal intervention resulted in a drastic reduction in BC contamination and improvement in compliance to BC collection protocol and filling of various parameters in the BC requisition form, thus improving the overall effectiveness of BC testing. It was also noted that the contamination rate was further reduced by implementing dedicated phlebotomist.

Prevalence and Predictors of Bacterial Contamination in Excisional Lymph Node Biopsies: Implications for Diagnosis and Management

Routine tissue handling exposes lymph node specimens to microbial contamination that can confound microbiological culture results and interfere with diagnosis. The scope and impact of this problem remain poorly understood. We combined over 13 years of lymph node pathology, culture data, and patient records to define the prevalence, predisposing factors, microbiology, and clinical management of false-positive lymph node cultures at a large academic medical center. Nearly one third (31.9%) of 216 cultured lymph nodes yielded bacterial growth. Approximately 90% of positive bacterial cultures grew 1 of 2 common skin-resident taxa-coagulase-negative Staphylococcus and Cutibacterium acnes-with well-documented predispositions for contamination in other clinical settings. Lymph nodes excised from axillary, cervical, and inguinal regions yielded higher positive culture rates than nodes excised from the mediastinum, suggesting proximity to the skin surface may increase contamination risk. Accordingly, cultures from thoracoscopic pulmonary resections displayed contamination rates over 5-fold lower than those from percutaneously accessed lymph nodes. Lymph nodal tissue allocated for culture in the operating room yielded unexpectedly high contamination rates, significantly higher than cultures sent from the frozen section processing area. A significant minority of contamination events were noted in the clinical record and prompted antibiotic therapy on multiple occasions. Collectively, our results illuminate the risk factors contributing to bacterial contamination and argue that routine lymph node bacterial cultures provide minimal clinical benefit for adult patients. This widespread bacterial contamination also warrants cautious implementation of increasingly sensitive molecular microbiology tools for excised tissues.

Asynchronous Testing of 2 Specimen-Diversion Devices to Reduce Blood Culture Contamination: A Single-Site Product Supply Quality Improvement Project

OBJECTIVE

Blood culture contamination above the national threshold has been a consistent clinical issue in the ED setting. Two commercially available devices were examined that divert an initial small volume of the specimen before the collection of blood culture to reduce skin contamination.

METHODS

Prospectively, 2 different blood culture-diversion devices were made available in the unit supplies to ED clinicians at a single site during 2 different periods of time as a follow-up strategy to an ongoing quality improvement project. Blood samples were collected in the emergency department over a period of 16 months. A retrospective record review study was conducted comparing the use of the 2 specimen-diversion devices with no device (control group) for blood culture contamination rates. The main outcome of monthly blood culture contamination per device was tested using a Bayesian Poisson multilevel regression model.

RESULTS

A total of 4030 blood samples were collected and analyzed from November 2017 to February 2019. The model estimated that the mean incidence of contaminated blood draws in the device A group was 0.29 (0.14-0.55) times the incidence of contaminated draws in the control group. The mean incidence of contaminated blood draws in the device B group was 0.23 (0.13-0.37) times the incidence of contaminated draws in the control group, suggesting that initial-diversion methods reduced blood culture contamination.

CONCLUSION

Initial specimen-diversion devices supplement present standard phlebotomy protocols to bring down the blood culture contamination rate.