Animal Models and Alternatives in Vaginal Research: a Comparative Review

The Effect of Menopause on Vaginal Tissue Mechanics: A Brief Review

Often called "the change of life," menopause affects every part of a woman's body. As the sex hormones decrease, the reproductive organs experience the most remarkable changes, with the vagina becoming thinner, drier, and less elastic. Despite the important implications of these changes in genitourinary conditions, there are only a few experimental studies that focus on quantifying the effect of menopause on the mechanical properties of the vagina. These studies are mostly conducted using uniaxial tests on strips of vaginal tissues isolated from rats, rabbits, and sheep and, in only a few cases, from humans. The purpose of this article is to present a systematic review of experimental protocols, methods, and results that are currently published on how menopause alters the mechanical behavior of the vagina. This review will enable new investigators in the biomechanics field to identify important gaps and frame research questions that inform the design of new treatment options for menopausal symptoms.

Evaluation of Bi-layer Silk Fibroin Grafts for Inlay Vaginoplasty in a Rat Model

BACKGROUND

Autologous tissues derived from bowel, buccal mucosa and skin are primarily used to repair or replace diseased vaginal segments as well as create neovaginas for male-to-female transgenders. These grafts are often limited by scarce tissue supply, donor site morbidity and post-operative complications. Bi-layer silk fibroin (BLSF) biomaterials represent potential alternatives for vaginoplasty given their structural strength and elasticity, low immunogenicity, and processing flexibility. The goals of the current study were to assess the potential of acellular BLSF scaffolds for vaginal tissue regeneration in respect to conventional small intestinal submucosal (SIS) matrices in a rat model of vaginoplasty.

METHODS

Inlay vaginoplasty was performed with BLSF and SIS scaffolds (N = 21 per graft) in adult female rats for up to 2 months of implantation. Nonsurgical controls (N = 4) were investigated in parallel. Outcome analyses included histologic, immunohistochemical and histomorphometric evaluations of wound healing patterns; µ-computed tomography (CT) of vaginal continuity; and breeding assessments.

RESULTS

Animals in both scaffold cohorts exhibited 100% survival rates with no severe post-operative complications. At 2 months post-op, µ-CT analysis revealed normal vaginal anatomy and continuity in both graft groups similar to controls. In parallel, BLSF and SIS grafts also induced comparable constructive remodeling patterns and were histologically equivalent in their ability to support formation of vascularized vaginal neotissues with native tissue architecture, however with significantly less smooth muscle content. Vaginal tissues reconstructed with both implants were capable of supporting copulation, pregnancy and similar amounts of live births.

CONCLUSIONS

BLSF biomaterials represent potential "off-the-shelf" candidates for vaginoplasty.

A nine-month repeat-dose intravaginal ring (Ovaprene) irritation study in sheep

OBJECTIVES

Ovaprene is a novel, investigational, intravaginal hormone-free monthly ring contraceptive designed for use in women of reproductive age to be worn over multiple weeks (one menstrual cycle). The objective of this work was to evaluate the safety of Ovaprene during a nine-month repeat-dose sheep study.

STUDY DESIGN

In addition to traditional safety endpoints such as histopathological evaluation of the sheep female reproductive tract, vaginal fluids were collected and tested for released iron over time. Also, the amount of iron in the rings was assessed following removal, and serum iron levels were measured. There were four sheep in each group (Ovaprene group and sham group).

RESULTS

There were no macroscopic clinical findings. There was minimal to mild, mixed or mononuclear cell infiltration present in all levels of vagina (cranial, mid, and caudal) from all animals including sham controls based on post-study necropsy. The female reproductive tract from animals treated with the Ovaprene ring was comparable to the sham controls. The concentrations of serum iron in sheep treated with Ovaprene ring were similar compared to a sham treated animal. The average amount of ferrous gluconate released from Ovaprene over the 29-day period of use was 175 mg of the approximately 512 mg nominally loaded into the rings.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, the Ovaprene devices were well-tolerated in female sheep.

IMPLICATIONS

This study should support a chronic (e.g., one year) contraceptive efficacy study in women.

A missed opportunity: A scoping review of the effect of sex and age on osteoarthritis using large animal models

OBJECTIVE

The objective was to critically analyze the published literature accounting for sex differences and skeletal age (open vs. closed physis) in preclinical animal models of OA, including the disaggregation of data by sex and skeletal maturity when data is generated from combined sex and/or multi-aged cohorts without proper confounding.

METHOD

A scoping literature review of PubMed, Web of Science, EMBASE, and SCOPUS was performed for studies evaluating the effect of sex and age in experimental studies and clinical trials utilizing preclinical large animal models of OA.

RESULTS

A total of 9727 papers were identified in large animal (dog, pig, sheep, goat, horse) models for preclinical OA research, of which 238 ex vivo and/or in vivo studies disclosed model type, animal species, sex, and skeletal age sufficient to analyze their effect on outcomes. Dogs, followed by pigs, sheep, and horses, were the most commonly used models. A paucity of preclinical studies evaluated the effect of sex and age in large animal models of naturally occurring or experimentally induced OA: 26 total studies reported some kind of analysis of the effects of sex or age, with 4 studies discussing the effects of sex only, 11 studies discussing the effects of age only, and 11 studies analyzing both the effects of age and sex.

CONCLUSION

Fundamental to translational research, OARSI is uniquely positioned to develop recommendations for conducting preclinical studies using large animal models of OA that consider biological mechanisms linked to sex chromosomes, skeletal age, castration, and gonadal hormones affecting OA pathophysiology and treatment response.

The importance of animal specificity in animal experimentation, part I: Anatomy in relation to pediatric urology

Why and when is animal experimentation relevant? The answer to this question depends on the research question. In this short educational article we aim to raise awareness of the importance of formulating a very specific research question before choosing an animal species. An awareness of anatomical and physiological differences vis-a-vis similarities between species, will increase the potential for obtaining data that is relevant for translation to human conditions.

Biomedical, socio-behavioral, and implementation science gaps in multipurpose prevention technology research

There is strong global need for the development of Multipurpose Prevention Technologies (MPTs) that prevent HIV, pregnancy, and/or other sexually transmitted infections (STIs). However, despite decades of research focused on the development of MPTs, numerous research gaps remain, contributing to reproductive health disparities. This commentary will highlight biomedical, socio-behavioral, and implementation science gaps in MPT research. Biomedical gaps and barriers include limited dosage forms, challenges around drug selection and stable coformulation of multiple drugs, and an unclear regulatory pathway. Behavioral, social, and structural gaps include lack of research around MPT preferences for some subgroups of potential end users, lack of knowledge around whether MPTs improve uptake, adherence, and persistence vs. separate products, and a need to further understand how social and cultural factors might impact MPT interest and use. Gaps in implementation science research will need to be addressed to better understand how to implement MPTs to maximize effectiveness and benefit. This commentary will also identify opportunities for integrating biomedical and behavioral science around MPTs.

‘Distraction Vaginogenesis’: Preliminary Results Using a Novel Method for Vaginal Canal Expansion in Rats

Vaginal atresia is seen in genetic disorders such as Mayer–Rokitansky–Küster–Hauser (MRKH) syndrome, which can cause significant sexual dysfunction. Current treatments include surgical reconstruction or mechanical dilation of the vaginal canal. Mechanical dilation requires patients to be highly motivated and compliant while surgical reconstruction has high rates of complications. This study evaluated a novel vaginal expansion sleeve (VES) method as an alternative treatment for vaginal atresia. The proprietary cylindrical VES is a spring-like device consisting of polyethylene terephthalate helicoid trusses capped at each end with a fixed diameter resin cap for fixation within tissues. Following the development of the VES and mechanical characterization of the force–length relationships within the device, we deployed the VES in Sprague Dawley rat vaginas anchored with nonabsorbable sutures. We measured the VES length–tension relationships and post-implant vaginal canal expansion ex vivo. Vaginal histology was examined before and after implantation of the VES devices. Testing of 30 mm sleeves without caps resulted in an expansion force of 11.7 ± 3.4 N and 2.0 ± 0.1 N at 50% and 40%, respectively. The implanted 20 mm VES resulted in 5.36 mm ± 1.18 expansion of the vaginal canal, a 32.5 ± 23.6% increase (p = 0.004, Student t test). Histological evaluation of the VES implanted tissue showed a significant thinning of the vaginal wall when the VES was implanted. The novel VES device resulted in a significant expansion of the vaginal canal ex vivo. The VES device represents a unique alternative to traditional mechanical dilation therapy in the treatment of vaginal atresia and represents a useful platform for the mechanical distension of hollow compartments, which avoids reconstructive surgeries and progressive dilator approaches.

Mouse vaginal development with lateral enlargement at late embryonic stages and caudal elongation after birth

Müllerian ducts give rise to the oviducts, uterus, cervix, and vagina. During female reproductive tract development in mice, the bilateral Müllerian duct epithelium grows caudally until reaching the urogenital sinus epithelium. This is followed by further caudal growth with the reduction of the urogenital sinus epithelium. Finally, the vaginal epithelium of adult mice is entirely derived from the Müllerian duct epithelium. Here, we explored the mechanisms underlying mouse vaginal development via cell proliferation, apoptosis, and lineage analyses. We found that at the late embryonic stages, apoptosis occurred at the attachment site of bilateral Müllerian duct epithelia below the cervix, resulting in bilateral lumen traffic. The Müllerian duct epithelium was enclosed by the urogenital sinus epithelium at their boundary region on embryonic day (E) 16.5, whereas the Müllerian duct epithelium encased the urogenital sinus epithelium at postnatal day (P) 0 through lateral enlargement. Lateral Müllerian duct enlargement was accompanied by focal ERK activation within the curved epithelial tips and the specific localization of mitotic nuclei on the luminal side of the Müllerian duct epithelial layer at E17.5. Descent of the Müllerian duct epithelium and shortening of the urogenital sinus epithelium occurred rapidly after birth, accompanied by cell proliferation in the Müllerian duct epithelium and its peripheral mesenchymal tissues as well as intense apoptosis in the urogenital sinus epithelium around their boundary region. Urogenital sinus epithelium was localized at the base of the vagina at P7. In conclusion, the mouse vagina develops laterally at the late embryonic stages and caudally after birth.

In Silico Guided Nanoformulation Strategy for Circumvention of Candida albicans Biofilm for Effective Therapy of Candidal Vulvovaginitis

Candidal vulvovaginitis involving multispecies of Candida and epithelium-bound biofilm poses a drug-resistant pharmacotherapeutic challenge. The present study aims for a disease-specific predominant causative organism resolution for the development of a tailored vaginal drug delivery system. The proposed work fabricates a luliconazole-loaded nanostructured lipid carrier-based transvaginal gel for combating Candida albicans biofilm and disease amelioration. The interaction and binding affinity of luliconazole against the proteins of C. albicans and biofilm were assessed using in silico tools. A systematic QbD analysis was followed to prepare the proposed nanogel using a modified melt emulsification-ultrasonication-gelling method. The DoE optimization was logically implemented to ascertain the effect of independent process variables (excipients concentration; sonication time) on dependent formulation responses (particle size; polydispersity index; entrapment efficiency). The optimized formulation was characterized for final product suitability. The surface morphology and dimensions were spherical and ≤300 nm, respectively. The flow behavior of an optimized nanogel (semisolid) was non-Newtonian similar to marketed preparation. The texture pattern of a nanogel was firm, consistent, and cohesive. The release kinetic model followed was Higuchi (nanogel) with a % cumulative drug release of 83.97 ± 0.69% in 48 h. The % cumulative drug permeated across a goat vaginal membrane was found to be 53.148 ± 0.62% in 8 h. The skin-safety profile was examined using a vaginal irritation model (in vivo) and histological assessments. The drug and proposed formulation(s) were checked against the pathogenic strains of C. albicans (vaginal clinical isolates) and in vitro established biofilms. The visualization of biofilms was done under a fluorescence microscope revealing mature, inhibited, and eradicated biofilm structures.

Low intensity ultrasound-mediated drug-loaded nanoparticles intravaginal drug delivery: an effective synergistic therapy scheme for treatment of vulvovaginal candidiasis

PURPOSE

Vulvovaginal candidiasis (VVC) is a mucosal infection of the female lower genital tract for which treatment using conventional antifungal drugs shows limited effectiveness. Herein, amphotericin B-loaded poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid)-polyethylene glycol (PLGA-PEG) nanoparticles (AmB-NPs) were fabricated and combined with low intensity ultrasound (US) to mediate AmB-NPs intravaginal drug delivery to achieve productive synergistic antifungal activity in a rabbit model of VVC.

METHODS

Polymeric AmB-NPs were fabricated by a double emulsion method and the physical characteristics and biosafety of nanoparticles were analyzed. The distribution and tissue permeability of nanoparticles after intravaginal ultrasound irradiation (1.0 MHz, 1.0 W/cm², 5 min, 50% duty ratio) were observed in the vagina. The synergistic therapeutic activity of US-mediated AmB-NPs treatment was evaluated using an experimental rabbit model of VVC. Vaginal C. albicans colony counts, the pathological structure of the vagina epithelium, and Th1/Th2/Th17-type cytokine and oxidative stress levels were analyzed to investigate the therapeutic effect in vivo.

RESULTS

The prepared AmB-NPs showed an obvious shell and core structure with uniform size and good dispersion and displayed high biosafety and US-sensitive slow drug release. Ultrasound significantly enhanced nanoparticle transport through the mucus and promoted permeability in the vaginal tissue. US-mediated AmB-NPs treatment effectively increased drug sensitivity, even in the presence of the vaginal mucus barrier in vitro. On the seventh day after treatment in vivo, the combination treatment of AmB-NPs and US significantly reduced the fungal load in the vagina, achieving over 95% clearance rates, and also improved the pathological epithelium structural damage and glycogen secretion function. The expression of Th1 (IFN-γ, IL-2) and Th17 (IL-17) cytokines were significantly increased and Th2 (IL-6, IL-10) cytokines significantly decreased in the US + AmB-NP group. Furthermore, US-mediated AmB-NPs treatment effectively increased C. albicans intracellular reactive oxygen species (ROS) levels and promoted vaginal oxidation and antioxidants to normal levels.

CONCLUSION

US-mediated drug-loaded nanoparticles with intravaginal drug delivery exhibited a productive synergistic antifungal effect, which may provide a new non-invasive, safe, and effective therapy for acute or recurrent fungal vaginitis.

Neuronal control of the vagina in vertebrates: A review

BACKGROUND

At present, there is an increased interest in the vaginal microbiome. It is believed that microbes play equally important roles in the vagina, including the modulation of neuronal pathways, as in the gut. However, in man as well as in animals, the vagina is the least well-studied part of the female reproductive system. The vagina, a fibromuscular tract, having two main functions, i.e., childbirth and sexual intercourse, is mainly innervated by the pudendal nerve and the pelvic splanchnic nerves (the uterovaginal nerve plexus) containing sympathetic, parasympathetic and nociceptive nerve fibers. Innervation density in the vaginal wall undergoes significant remodeling due to hormonally mediated physiological activity. Knowledge about expression and function of neuropeptides and neurotransmitters in the vaginal fibers is incomplete or not established. Most research concerning the neuroregulation of the vagina and the function and expression of neuropeptides and neurotransmitters, is performed in several vertebrate species, including large farm animals, rodents, domestic fowl and lizards.

METHODS

This review summarizes, on a bibliographic basis, the current knowledge on vaginal innervation and function of neuropeptides and neurotransmitters expressed in vaginal nerve fibers in several vertebrate species, including humans. The presence and role played by the local microbioma is also explored.

CONCLUSION

A thorough knowledge of the vaginal innervation is necessary to unravel the putative communication of the vaginal microbiome and vaginal nerve fibers, but also to understand the effects of vaginal pathologies and of administered drugs on the neuroregulation of the vagina.

Validation of an ovine vesicovaginal fistula model

INTRODUCTION AND HYPOTHESIS

A representative, large animal model of vesicovaginal fistulas is needed for the training of surgeons and for the development of new surgical techniques and materials for obstetric fistula repair.

METHODS

The safety, feasibility, and reproducibility of vesicovaginal fistula creation were studied in 4 adult female sheep. A 1-cm fistula was created between the vagina and the bladder through a transvaginal approach. The defect was allowed to heal for 8 weeks and the animals were then euthanized. The primary outcome was the fistula patency. Secondary outcomes were fistula size, urogenital dimensions, urodynamic evaluation, histology (inflammation, vascularization, collagen deposition) and biomechanical characteristics of the fistula edge (stress at break, maximum elongation, and stiffness).

RESULTS

The transvaginal creation of a vesicovaginal fistula was safe. All animals survived the surgical procedure and follow-up period, without complications. Three of the four animals demonstrated a patent vesicovaginal fistula after 8 weeks. Baseline data are provided of the urogenital dimensions and the urodynamic, histological, and biomechanical characteristics of the model.

CONCLUSIONS

The ewe is a safe, feasible, and reproducible model for vesicovaginal fistulas. The model can help to study new techniques and materials to boost surgical innovation for vesicovaginal fistula repair.

History-Dependent Deformations of Rat Vaginas under Inflation

The vagina is a highly inhomogeneous, anisotropic, and viscoelastic organ that undergoes significant deformations in vivo. The mechanical attributes of this organ facilitate important physiological functions during menstruation, intercourse, and birthing. Despite the crucial mechanical role that the vagina plays within the female reproductive system, the deformations that the organ can sustain over time under constant pressure, in both the longitudinal direction (LD) and circumferential direction (CD), have not been fully characterized. This experimental study focuses on quantifying the creep properties of the vagina via ex vivo inflation testing using the rat as animal model. Toward this end, rat vaginas were subjected to three consecutively increasing constant luminal pressures (28 kPa, 55 kPa, and 83 kPa) using a custom-built experimental setup and the resulting inhomogeneous deformations were measured using the digital image correlation (DIC) method. The vagina was found to deform significantly more in the CD than the LD at any constant pressure, suggesting that the organ primarily adapts to constant pressures by significantly changing the diameter rather that the length. The change in deformation over time (i.e., creep) was significantly higher during the 1st inflation test at a constant pressure of 28 kPa than over the 2nd and 3rd inflation tests at constant pressures of 55 kPa and 83 kPa, respectively. The findings of this study on the mechanical behavior of the vagina could serve to advance our limited knowledge about the physiology and pathophysiology of this important reproductive organ.

A physiologically relevant, estradiol‐17β [E2]‐responsive in vitro tissue‐engineered model of the vaginal epithelium for vaginal tissue research

Aims

There are many situations where preclinical models of the human vagina would be valuable for in vitro studies into the pathophysiology of vaginally transmitted diseases, microbicide efficacy, irritability testing, and particularly, for assessing materials to be inserted in the vagina for support of the pelvic floor. The aim of this study is to develop a physiologically relevant, low cost, and ethically suitable model of the vagina using sheep vaginal tissue (SVT) to reduce the need for animal testing in gynecological research.

Methods

Tissue‐engineered (TE) vaginal models were developed by culturing primary vaginal epithelial cells and vaginal fibroblasts, isolated from the native SVTs on decellularized sheep vaginal matrices at an air–liquid interface. Morphological analyses of the models were conducted by performing hematoxylin and eosin staining and further characterization was done by immunohistofluorescence (IHF) of structural proteins and cytokeratins.

Results

Histological analysis of the models revealed a gradual formation of a stratified epithelium on our decellularized matrices and cell metabolic activity remained high for 21 days as measured by the resazurin assay. Our models showed a dose‐dependent response to estradiol‐17β [E₂] with an increase in the vaginal epithelium thickness and cellular proliferation under higher E₂ concentrations (100–400 pg/ml). The physiological relevance of these results was confirmed by the IHF analysis of Ki67, and cytokeratins 10 and 19 expression.

Conclusion

In this study, we have developed an estradiol‐responsive TE vaginal model that closely mimics the structural and physiological properties of the native SVT.

Histological changes of cervical tumours following Zanthoxylum acanthopodium DC treatment, and its impact on cytokine expression

•

ZAM administration had no effect on the bodyweight of cervical cancer rats.

•

Antioxidants found in andaliman can lower levels of MDA and serum NGAL, thereby increasing SOD activity.

•

ZAM treatment can suppress the production of IL1β and TGFβ1 which promotes cancer cell growth in rats.

•

ZAM administration can increase IL-10 expression in cervical cancer rats, thereby suppressing the growth of cervical cancer.

•

ZAM decrease VEGFR1 serum expression and improve histology in cervical cancer rats.

Cervical cancer is the second most lethal cancer in Indonesia, behind breast cancer. One of the reasons cancer cells are difficult to treat is that the immune system is sometimes unable to recognise them as foreign. Cytokinin therapy is carried out so that the immune system can strengthen its response to cancer cells, with the aim of slowing or stopping the development of malignant cells. Zanthoxylum acanthopodium DC, also known as andaliman, is an Indonesian herb and a member of the Rutaceae family. It is rich in antioxidants and has anti-inflammatory and anti-cancer properties. The current study aimed to investigate the histological changes and changes in the expression of cytokines, such as IL-10, IL1β, VEGFR1, and TGFβ1, associated with andaliman treatment. Sample tissues and serums extracted from cervical cancer rat models were used. Rats were divided into five groups: a control group (C−), cancer model group (C+), cancer with a dose of Z. acanthopodium methanolic extract (ZAM) 100 mg/body weight (BW) ZAM (ZAM100), cancer with a dose of ZAM 200 mg/BW ZAM (ZAM200), and cancer with a dose of ZAM 400 mg/BW ZAM (ZAM400). Treatment lasted for 1 month. Blood samples were prepared for ELISA analysis, and cervical tissue was stained for immunohistochemistry using antibodies against IL-10, IL-1β, VEGFR1, and TGFβ1. Administration of ZAM had no significant effect on rat body weight and cervical organs (p > 0.05). However, it impacted haematological parameters in rats with cervical cancer (p < 0.05). Elevated malondialdehyde levels may be linked to superoxide dismutase deficiency in tumour tissue. ZAM significantly decreased the expression of IL1β, TGFβ1, and VEGFR1 (p < 0.01), while it increased the expression of IL-10. Therefore, ZAM may be a potential target for molecular cytokine therapy for cervical cancer.