Is pulsed Doppler velocimetry useful in the management of multiple-gestation pregnancies?

Do Doppler studies enhance surveillance of uncomplicated monochorionic diamniotic twins?

OBJECTIVES

To determine whether isolated abnormal Doppler indices before 28 weeks predict adverse pregnancy outcomes in uncomplicated monochorionic diamniotic (MCDA) twins.

METHODS

A retrospective cohort study of MCDA twin pregnancies receiving antenatal testing at a single center between 2007 and 2013 was conducted. Sonographic surveillance, including Doppler velocimetric studies of the umbilical artery, ductus venosus, and middle cerebral artery of each twin, was initiated by 28 weeks and repeated at least every 2 weeks. All pregnancies were deemed "uncomplicated" at initial sonography, without evidence of polyhydramnios, oligohydramnios, intrauterine growth restriction, twin growth discordance of at least 20%, structural or chromosomal anomalies, or unclear chorionicity. Pregnancies were divided into 2 groups: those with isolated Doppler abnormalities before 28 weeks and those with normal Doppler indices. The primary outcome was a composite including twin-twin transfusion syndrome, intrauterine growth restriction of more than 1 twin, growth discordance of at least 20%, preterm delivery before 34 weeks for fetal indications, or demise of more than 1 fetus.

RESULTS

Ninety-six patients were included, with 22 (22.9%) having isolated Doppler abnormalities before 28 weeks. The incidence of the primary outcome did not differ between groups (36.4% versus 28.4%; P = .47). The abnormal Doppler group underwent a greater number of sonographic examinations (15 versus 10; P= .001) and more antenatal admissions for fetal concerns (50.0% versus 12.2%; P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

Isolated Doppler abnormalities are commonly encountered in uncomplicated MCDA pregnancies before 28 weeks yet are not clearly predictive of twin-specific complications. Doppler abnormalities were associated with increased sonographic surveillance and antenatal hospitalizations, suggesting an influence on physician practice patterns. Data may not support Doppler studies before 28 weeks for routine MCDA twin monitoring.

Umbilical artery doppler sonography in Saanen goat fetuses during singleton and multiple pregnancies

The objective of this study was to evaluate the blood flow from the umbilical artery (UA) in healthy pregnant goats. Doppler sonography examinations were performed every two weeks in Saanen goats with a singleton (n = 5) or multiple (n = 4) pregnancy from 40 to 145 days of gestation. Fetal heart rates (FHR), pulsatility index (PI), and resistance index (RI) were recorded from the mid-cord site of the free-floating umbilical cord. FHR decreased gradually as the pregnancy progressed and significantly decreased during the last two examinations of all fetuses (P < 0.05). The mean PI level was dramatically different (P < 0.05) until 85 days of gestation, after which it reached a plateau level until parturition. Similar to PI, RI decreased by 85 days of gestation (P < 0.05), and decreased again by 130s gestation. No reverse or absent end-diastolic flow were observed in fetuses during any examinations. When comparing singleton and multiple pregnancies, there were no significant differences in UA pulsatility or resistance in fetuses seen. The middle of the second trimester was observed to be a threshold stage for indices in the pattern of caprine pregnancy. In conclusion, this work provides additional values that might be useful when evaluating singleton and multiple pregnancies, and may be evaluated in further studies regarding fetal monitoring.

Antenatal fetal assessment: multifetal gestation--an overview

As prevalence of multifetal gestation has increased in the United States, antenatal surveillance of these pregnancies has gained importance. This article focuses on the assessment of twin pregnancy, since critical data are lacking for the surveillance of higher order multiple gestations. Twin pregnancies encounter risks that differ in nature, frequency, and intensity from those seen in singleton pregnancies. Most of these risks stem from subnormal or discordant fetal growth or abnormalities of placentation. Sonographic modalities play key roles in antepartum surveillance. These include fetal biometry, serial growth studies, amniotic fluid volume assessment, Doppler velocimetry of fetal-placental circulation, and biophysical profile testing. Fetal heart rate testing, specifically nonstress testing, has also been used extensively in twin surveillance. This article examines the specific application of these modalities to twin gestation and reviews the best evidence available for their support. Assessment of unique risk conditions of twin-twin transfusion, monoamniotic twinning, and intrauterine death of one twin is addressed. Based on current data, a strategic outline for assessment of twin pregnancy is presented.

The value of umbilical artery Doppler velocimetry in the antenatal surveillance of uncomplicated monochorionic twin pregnancies

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the predictive value of abnormal umbilical artery Doppler findings on outcome in uncomplicated monochorionic (MC) twin pregnancies.

METHODS

Sixty-seven MC twin pregnancies, with antenatal care and delivery at the University Medical Center, Utrecht, The Netherlands, between 1999 and 2004, were studied. Pregnancies with antenatal signs of twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome were excluded. We analyzed the data according to both the last Doppler measurement of the umbilical artery before delivery and the presence of any abnormal Doppler measurement during the course of pregnancy. Risks of mortality and total neonatal morbidity were stratified according to the Doppler findings in one or both fetuses at the time of each standard ultrasound assessment in order to estimate the risk associated with an abnormal Doppler finding at or before that specific gestational age.

RESULTS

Mortality rates were similar in the normal and abnormal Doppler groups. Using both group definitions, total neonatal morbidity was higher in the abnormal Doppler group; this was significant at > 32 weeks' gestation, and was due to lower birth weight and earlier gestational age at delivery. There was no mortality at > or = 36 weeks in the abnormal Doppler group, but there were four perinatal deaths in the normal Doppler group. Gestational age at delivery was significantly lower when one or more abnormal Doppler findings had been present (median, 34 + 1 weeks vs. 36 + 3 weeks) and infants with abnormal Doppler findings weighed on average 261 g (95% CI, 21-502 g) less than those with normal findings.

CONCLUSIONS

In MC twins, abnormal Doppler flow of the umbilical artery identifies a subgroup at risk for preterm delivery, low birth weight and neonatal morbidity, but with a similar mortality risk to those with normal Doppler flow. At term, mortality occurred only in the group with normal Doppler findings, suggesting that fetal surveillance is insufficient in uncomplicated term MC twin pregnancies.

Early Intertwin Differences in Myocardial Performance During the Twin-to-Twin Transfusion Syndrome

Background— In the twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS), pressure rather than volume overload is increasingly considered as a key factor in the pathogenesis of the cardiomyopathy of the recipient twin. If this is the case, cardiac dysfunction should be among the first signs observed with TTTS. The objective of this study was to determine whether intertwin differences in myocardial function are modified early in the course of TTTS and whether they can help to differentiate this condition from intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR).

Methods and Results— Eight variables were analyzed on the first fetal echocardiography on 21 pairs of twins with TTTS and 11 with IUGR. No difference was found between the 2 groups for the cardiothoracic ratio, pulsatility indices in the umbilical and middle cerebral arteries, and peak velocity of the middle cerebral artery. Significant difference was found for ventricular septal thickness, but with no association with the conditions under study. With TTTS, left ventricular shortening fraction was consistently greater in the donor twins, and myocardial performance indices (MPIs) were elevated in the recipient twins. This increase in MPI was caused by a lengthening of the isovolumic periods compared with those of the donor twin: left ventricular and right ventricular isovolumic periods 0.105±0.047 and 0.097±0.026 seconds, respectively, for the recipient twins versus 0.0561±0.46 and 0.065±0.03 seconds, respectively, for the donor twins ( P <0.001). These changes in the isovolumic periods were mainly due to significant prolongation of isovolumic relaxation times. A change in left ventricular MPI ≥0.09 combined with a change in right ventricular MPI ≥0.05 would identify a TTTS with a sensitivity of 75% and a false-positive rate of 9%.

Conclusions— The observed diastolic function impairment goes along with the pressure-overload pathogenic concept proposed in TTTS. Assessment of intertwin difference in MPI is a valuable tool for early differential diagnosis between TTTS and isolated IUGR.

The creation of twin centile curves for size

OBJECTIVE

To create twin centile charts for size.

DESIGN

Retrospective study.

SETTING

Aberdeen Maternity Hospital.

METHODS

Ultrasound measurements of abdominal circumference (AC), biparietal diameter (BPD) and femur length (FL) for 1,011 twin pregnancies were extracted from a databank. The methodology is based on that described by Altman and Chitty [Br. J. Obstet. Gynaecol. 101 (1994) 29.]; only one measurement from each twin was used, polynomial regression models were fitted separately to the mean and standard deviation (SD) of the ultrasound parameter as functions of gestational age. The centiles were obtained assuming that at each gestation, the measurements had a normal distribution.

RESULTS

The growth pattern of AC for twins appear to follow closely that of singletons until 32 weeks. Thereafter, there is a gradual but definite fall off in growth away from singleton standards. The pattern of growth of FL is largely similar to that of singletons. From mid to early third trimester, the BPD of twin babies was larger than that of singletons.

Diamnionic monochorionic twin gestations: an overview

Monochorionic (MC) twins account for about 20-30% of all twins, but contribute disproportionately to mortality, intrauterine growth restriction, and preterm delivery compared with dichorionic (DC) twins. This higher mortality in MC twins is likely due to the effects of placental morphologic characteristics, which include complex vascular communications between the twins associated with twin-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS), and the tendency for the common placenta to be shared either symmetrically or asymmetrically. In assessment of clinical outcomes for TTTS, artery to vein anastomoses in the absence of artery to artery or vein to vein, especially if present with placental asymmetry, carry the worse prognosis. Chorion status in twins forms the basis for clinical risk assessment and can be determined by 7 menstrual weeks using transvaginal sonography. The variable results reported in the literature for intertwin umbilical artery Doppler findings in MC twins may be explained by differences between sonographic and clinical criteria (including differential hemoglobin concentrations) reported by various investigators. Antenatal fetal Doppler assessment of the umbilical artery and cerebral arteries can help distinguish between TTTS and placental insufficiency in MC twins. Significant restriction of fetal growth occurs in about 25% of multiple gestations, accounting for about 17% of all growth-retarded infants. Redistribution of fetal blood (brain-sparing effect), as determined by Doppler interrogation of fetal cerebral and umbilical arteries, occurs more commonly in MC twins compared to DC twins and in growth-restricted MC twins compared to nongrowth-restricted MC twins. Overall, the prognosis is poorer for the donor twins in TTTS and there is a greater prenatal death rate for the donor (18-35%), and a higher overall survival rate for recipients following fetoscopic laser treatment. Finally, the clinical and sonographic findings suggest that the polyhydramnios/oligohydramnios sequence seen in MC twins likely represents a spectrum strongly linked to placental variables.

Prediction of discordant twins by real-time ultrasonography combined with umbilical artery velocimetry

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the role of umbilical Doppler velocimetry combined with ultrasonographic intertwin differences derived from estimated fetal weight, biparietal diameter, abdominal circumference and femur length as a comprehensive test for the prediction of discordancy.

METHODS

The sets of twins were studied with real-time ultrasonography for morphometric measurements and with duplex Doppler velocimetry for the S/D ratio of the umbilical artery in third trimester. The following cutoff values were used to indicate abnormal test results: delta biparietal diameter > 6 mm, delta abdominal circumference > 20 mm, delta femur length > 5 mm, delta estimated fetal weight > 15% and delta systolic/diastolic ratio > 15%. Discordancy was identified when the birth weight difference exceeded 15%.

RESULTS

Among the 52 sets of twin pregnancies studied, 40 sets of twins fulfilled the study criteria. Thirteen sets of twins were discordant (32.5%) The mean gestational age at delivery was 37.15 +/- 2.24 weeks (range 28-41 weeks). The diagnostic accuracy provided by ultrasonographic morphometries was not significantly different from that provided by umbilical Doppler velocimetry. Overall the best predictors appeared to be the presence of either delta systolic/diastolic ratio > 15% or delta estimated fetal weights > 15% with sensitivity and specificity values of 92% and 70%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Real-time ultrasonography combined with umbilical artery velocimetry is useful in predicting discordant twins.

Comparison of alterations in fetal regional arterial vascular resistance in appropriate-for-gestational-age singleton, twin and triplet pregnancies

The objective of this longitudinal study was to evaluate alterations in fetal vascular resistance of fetal peripheral arteries with advancing gestation in singleton appropriate-for-gestational-age (S-AGA), twin appropriate-for-gestational-age (Tw-AGA) and triplet appropriate-for-gestational-age (Tri-AGA) infants. Colour Doppler flow imaging and pulsed Doppler ultrasonographic examinations were performed on 35 S-AGA, 52 Tw-AGA and 12 Tri-AGA fetuses. The pulsatility index for middle cerebral artery (MCAPI), umbilical artery (UAPI), descending aorta (DAPI), splenic artery (SAPI), renal artery (RAPI) and femoral artery (FAPI) was measured as vascular resistance every 2 weeks after 15 weeks of menstrual age until delivery. Optimal models and normal ranges for pulsatility index for each artery in each group were generated. The alterations in various fetal regional arterial pulsatility indices with advancing gestational age showed no significant differences in S-AGA, Tw-AGA and Tri-AGA infants, respectively. These results suggest that there is no significant difference for regional arterial vascular resistance in AGA fetuses among singleton, twin, and triplet pregnancies, whereas there was a slight difference in fetal growth pattern among singleton, twin, and triplet pregnancies described in our previous investigation.

Umbilical Doppler velocimetry prediction of discordant twins

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the role of umbilical Doppler velocimetry as a comprehensive test for the prediction of discordant twins.

METHODS

The sets of twins were studied with duplex Doppler velocimetry for umbilical artery in third trimester. A systolic/diastolic ratio was measured for each twin. The average difference in the ratios between each twin > or = 0.4 was used to indicate abnormal test. Discordancy was identified when the birth weight difference of > 25%.

RESULTS

Among the 52 sets of twin pregnancies studied, 40 sets of twins fulfilled the study criteria. Eight sets of twins were discordant (20%). The mean gestational age at delivery was 37.15 +/- 2.24 weeks (range 28 to 41 weeks). The test correctly identified 6 of the 8 growth discordant twins which had a sensitivity of 75%, specificity of 68.75%, and accuracy of 70%.

CONCLUSION

Umbilical Doppler velocimetry is useful in prediction of discordant twins.

Doppler ultrasound in multiple pregnancies

This chapter aims to provide a current review of the use of Doppler ultrasound in the management of multiple pregnancies. OVID and Medline searches were undertaken. Randomized controlled trials, where available, were assessed by the Cochrane Review Manager (RevMan-version 3.0). The specific multiple pregnancy problems of fetal growth restriction (FGR), twin reversed arterial perfusion sequence and twin-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) were also reviewed. Historically, controlled and randomized controlled trials show a promising reduction in perinatal mortality in twin pregnancies where Doppler ultrasound is used. However, the numbers are small and further trials are recommended. In those twin pregnancies in which there is FGR as a result of placental dysfunction, Doppler ultrasonography will show intertwin discordancy. In those twin pairs where development is complicated by TTTS, there is often discordant fetal size, with concordant fetal Doppler results. Thus Doppler ultrasound appears to be useful in the management of twin pregnancies and in delineating those complicated by FGR and TTTS.

Potential value of fetal echocardiography in the differential diagnosis of twin pregnancy with presence of polyhydramnios-oligohydramnios syndrome

OBJECTIVE

Our purpose was to establish whether index values of cardiac performance could discriminate between the twin-twin transfusion syndrome and placental insufficiency as the etiology of the polyhydramnios-oligohydramnios sequence in monochorionic diamniotic twins.

STUDY DESIGN

Thirteen monochorionic diamniotic twin pregnancies with ultrasonographic evidence of polyhydramnios-oligohydramnios sequence had a complete echocardiography. The etiology was confirmed postnatally: placental insufficiency in eight pairs and the twin-twin transfusion syndrome in five. Intertwin comparisons were made for the following cardiac parameters: cardiothoracic index, end-diastolic thickness of the ventricular walls and septum, aortic and pulmonary artery Doppler peak velocities, ejection and acceleration times, left ventricular shortening fraction, and combined cardiac output and output indexed to fetal weight.

RESULTS

All five recipient twins had thickened ventricular walls. The left ventricular shortening fractions and outputs were significantly increased in the donor twin with twin-twin transfusion syndrome and normal in placental insufficiency.

CONCLUSION

In twin-twin transfusion syndrome the donor twin shows evidence of a hyperdynamic cardiac state. Intertwin comparison of cardiac parameters, especially the left ventricular shortening fraction, can be considered a useful tool in diagnosing the different etiologies of the polyhydramnios-oligohydraminos sequence.

Antenatal assessment of twin gestation

We have identified that twin gestation presents considerable risks to the well-being of both infants that can be traced to either related maternal or intrinsic fetoplacental factors. A protocol for the assessment of twin gestation is established, beginning with a basis in ultrasound identification of twinning and correct gestational dating. Because most hazards for twins are related to abnormal growth, discrepant growth between twins, and abnormalities of placentation, the approach to assessing well-being requires good serial biometry of twins. This critical review addresses the individual and combined application of standard tests used for evaluation of intrauterine health in single pregnancies: (1) ultrasound fetal growth curves; (2) Doppler velocimetry of the umbilical artery; (3) nonstress tests; (4) amniotic fluid assessment and (5) biophysical profile testing. The best current evidence suggests that there are clear deficiencies in the basis for growth nomograms for twin gestations, and with the exception of femur length, most individual anatomic measurements start to deviate from singleton standards between 21 and 30 weeks' gestation. Regardless of formulae used, estimated fetal weight provides the best discriminator for discordant growth. Dynamic assessment of fetal well-being is best provided by a combination of Doppler velocimetry and nonstress testing. Semiquantitative amniotic fluid assessment, other than establishing pathological conditions (eg, twin transfusion syndrome), is problematic and difficult to reproduce. Inadequate data exist to establish the value of the biophysical profile in twins. Given the limitations of present knowledge, serial assessment of twins beginning in the midtrimester with ultrasound observation, and adding combinations of Doppler velocimetry and nonstress testing in the third trimester, seems to represent the most reasonable current clinical approach to twin well-being.

Monofetal death in multiple pregnancies: risks for the co-twin, risk factors and obstetrical management

The intrauterine death of one fetus in the case of multiple pregnancies can have an impact on the development of the surviving twin. Based on a single-centre retrospective personal study of 248 multiple pregnancies, 10 of which presented a monofetal intrauterine death, the authors observed the type of placentation, the age and cause of the death, the way in which pregnancy continued and the outcome of the surviving twin. This investigation also includes a review of published documents. Monochorial pregnancies were more frequently encountered in the case of monofetal death in utero. The etiology of the death was not always found and one surviving twin presented lesions as microcephaly convulsions and was retarded on a psychomotor level. In this series these complications did not exist when the pregnancy was bichorial. The authors conclude by demonstrating the major risk of fetal contamination for a live twin coexisting with a dead twin in the case on monochorial pregnancy. Other parameters (cause of death, gestational age at death, delay and duration of cohabitation), do not seem to be significant. It would appear to be of fundamental importance to establish an accurate diagnosis of placentation and to implement specific surveillance of monochorial pregnancies. A decision tree is suggested for use in the case of monofetal death.

Is it time to reassess the risk for the growth-retarded fetus with normal Doppler velocimetry of the umbilical artery?

OBJECTIVE

Previous studies demonstrate an association between abnormal umbilical artery Doppler velocimetry and the birth of a small-for-gestational-age infant and between abnormal result and adverse neonatal outcome. The hypothesis is that preterm growth-retarded infants with normal antenatal velocimetry have outcomes similar to other preterm infants, whereas preterm small-for-gestational-age infants with abnormal Doppler results define a subgroup with increased morbidity.

STUDY DESIGN

For 100 live-born infants, at risk for fetal growth retardation and undergoing antenatal Doppler and targeted ultrasonographic examinations, we assessed a number of complete neonatal outcome parameters.

RESULTS

Ten neonatal deaths occurred in the study population, seven with abnormal Doppler results and three with normal Doppler results. Of the 90 surviving infants, gestational age at delivery was not different between the Doppler normal and abnormal neonates, whereas birth weight (1714 gm vs 1379 gm) was higher in the Doppler normal group (p = 0.006). The presence of intraventricular hemorrhage (20% vs 6%) was higher in the abnormal group (p = 0.05). Abnormal Doppler results defined an infant group destined for prolonged hospitalization, mean intensive care days (21 vs 9), and special care nursery days (25 vs 9). Thirty-eight percent of small-for-gestational-age babies had a normal Doppler result. Analysis of variance indicated small-for-gestational-age infants with abnormal Doppler results (n = 20) had a mean intensive care unit stay of 31 days, significantly different (p = 0.005) from small-for-gestational-age infants with normal Doppler results (n = 14), non-small-for-gestational-age infants with abnormal results (n = 21), and non-small-for-gestational-age infants with normal results (n = 35) whose mean intensive care unit stays were 14, 12, and 7 days, respectively. Gestational age at delivery (33.0 weeks) was not different among these groupings, not accounting for the observed differences.

CONCLUSION

Normal antenatal velocimetry defines a distinct subgroup of preterm small-for-gestational-age infants at less risk for prolonged hospitalization compared with those with abnormal velocimetry.

Doppler velocimetry in pregnancy

Since the late 1970s, Doppler velocimetry has been investigated extensively for use in obstetrics. Initially, this technique showed promise for the management of certain complications of pregnancy; this promise has yet to be fulfilled. Doppler velocimetry of either the uterine or umbilical vessels, which showed some merit in selecting growth-retarded fetuses at particular risk, has neither become a screening tool for intrauterine growth retardation nor proven clinically successful in improving fetal outcome. Likewise, its use for other complications of pregnancy (eg, postdate pregnancy, twin pregnancy, and diabetes) has not led to improved pregnancy outcome. More recently this technique has been used to study other vascular beds. Changes in the Doppler characteristics of these vascular beds may demonstrate the fetal response to its environment. These investigations provide the potential for a better understanding of fetal physiology; however, it has yet to be shown by prospective evaluation that their application results in improved pregnancy outcome. This review defines the uses and limitations of Doppler ultrasound in current obstetric practice.

Comparison of dynamic image and pulsed Doppler ultrasonography for the diagnosis of the small-for-gestational-age fetus

OBJECTIVE

Because poor fetal growth is a significant cause of perinatal morbidity and mortality, a prospective study was undertaken to evaluate the ability of real-time ultrasonography and Doppler velocimetry to detect the small-for-gestational-age fetus.

STUDY DESIGN

A prospective study of 136 women at risk for fetal growth abnormalities was conducted. Patients were delivered within 3 weeks and had live-born, nonanomalous, singleton infants. The relative estimated fetal weight (estimated fetal weight divided by the median birth weight for gestational age) and the systolic/diastolic ratio were measured and compared with receiver-operator characteristic curves. In this method the area under the curve is the index of performance.

RESULTS

Forty-six infants were small for gestational age. Although both relative estimated fetal weight (area under the curve = 0.923) and systolic/diastolic ratio (area under the curve = 0.837) were significantly associated with the small for gestational age fetus, the former was more strongly correlated, p = 0.021.

CONCLUSION

Relative estimated weight is more sensitive and specific and should be the preferred parameter when gestational age is known.

Umbilical artery blood flow velocity waveforms in twin pregnancies

To detect discordant fetal growth in twin pregnancies and assess a possible role for Doppler ultrasound measurements of blood flow velocity waveforms in umbilical arteries in such cases, 32 twin pregnancies were examined on 125 occasions. The last examination was within 14 days of delivery. There was postpartum death of one pair of twins with the twin transfusion syndrome. Birthweight was appropriate for gestational age in 15 twin pairs, both infants were small for gestational age (SGA) in 5, and one of the infants was SGA in 12 twin pairs. The correlation coefficient of RI difference at the last examination and percentage birth weight difference in twin pairs was 0.68. Cutoff points for the delta RI and weight difference were established. The sensitivity of delta RI (0.1) was 77.8%; specificity, 95.8%; positive predictive value, 87.5%; and negative predictive value, 92.0%.