Effects of bicarbonate depletion on secondary acceptors of Photosystem II

Efficiency of photosynthetic water oxidation at ambient and depleted levels of inorganic carbon

Over 40 years ago, Joliot et al. (Photochem Photobiol 10:309-329, 1969) designed and employed an elegant and highly sensitive electrochemical technique capable of measuring O2 evolved by photosystem II (PSII) in response to trains of single turn-over light flashes. The measurement and analysis of flash-induced oxygen evolution patterns (FIOPs) has since proven to be a powerful method for probing the turnover efficiency of PSII. Stemler et al. (Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 71(12):4679-4683, 1974), in Govindjee's lab, were the first to study the effect of "bicarbonate" on FIOPs by adding the competitive inhibitor acetate. Here, we extend this earlier work by performing FIOPs experiments at various, strictly controlled inorganic carbon (Ci) levels without addition of any inhibitors. For this, we placed a Joliot-type bare platinum electrode inside a N2-filled glove-box (containing 10-20 ppm CO2) and reduced the Ci concentration simply by washing the samples in Ci-depleted media. FIOPs of spinach thylakoids were recorded either at 20-times reduced levels of Ci or at ambient Ci conditions (390 ppm CO2). Numerical analysis of the FIOPs within an extended Kok model reveals that under Ci-depleted conditions the miss probability is discernibly larger (by 2-3 %) than at ambient conditions, and that the addition of 5 mM HCO3 (-) to the Ci-depleted thylakoids largely restores the original miss parameter. Since a "mild" Ci-depletion procedure was employed, we discuss our data with respect to a possible function of free or weakly bound HCO3 (-) at the water-splitting side of PSII.

Interactions of photosystem II with bicarbonate, formate and acetate

In this study, we probe the effects of bicarbonate (hydrogencarbonate), BC, removal from photosystem II in spinach thylakoids by measuring flash-induced oxygen evolution patterns (FIOPs) with a Joliot-type electrode. For this we compared three commonly employed methods: (1) washing in BC-free medium, (2) formate addition, and (3) acetate addition. Washing of the samples with buffers depleted of BC and CO2 by bubbling with argon (Method 1) under our conditions leads to an increase in the double hit parameter of the first flash (beta 1), while the miss parameter and the overall activity remain unchanged. In contrast, addition of 40-50 mM formate or acetate results in a significant increase in the miss parameter and to an approximately 50% (formate) and approximately 10% (acetate) inhibition of the overall oxygen evolution activity, but not to an increased beta 1 parameter. All described effects could be reversed by washing with formate/acetate free buffer and/or addition of 2-10 mM bicarbonate. The redox potential of the water-oxidizing complex (WOC) in samples treated by Method 1 is compared to samples containing 2 mM bicarbonate in two ways: (1) The lifetimes of the S0, S2, and S3 states were measured, and no differences were found between the two sample types. (2) The S1, S0, S(-1), and S(-2) states were probed by incubation with small concentrations of NH2OH. These experiments displayed a subtle, yet highly reproducible difference in the apparent Si/S(-i) state distribution which is shown to arise from the interaction of BC with PSII in the already reduced states of the WOC. These data are discussed in detail by also taking into account the CO2 concentrations present in the buffers after argon bubbling and during the measurements. These values were measured by membrane-inlet mass spectrometry (MIMS).

The relationship between the capacity to evolve oxygen and the variable fluorescence of chlorophyll after microsecond illumination in Chlorella, pea leaves and pea thylakoids

The relationship between the capacity to evolve oxygen following a flash of a few microseconds duration and the variable fluorescence of chlorophyll was determined in Chlorella, leaf disks of peas, and thylakoids of pea leaves. It was found that this relationship is linear in intact plant material, while it is nonlinear in thylakoids. However, in thylakoids, the recovery of the capacity to evolve oxygen does not track the decay of the variable yield of Chl a fluorescence. This nonlinear relationship in thylakoids results from a reduced rate in the oxygen evolution reaction with no change in the decay of the variable yield of Chl a fluorescence. From a new application of the matrix analysis method to oxygen flash yields, the S1'-->S2, S2'-->S3 and S3'-->S4-->S0 transitions are found to be slowed or delayed in pea thylakoids and this underlies the slower rate of the recovery of the capacity to evolve oxygen in thylakoids. It is concluded that in intact cells the QA-QB(-)-->QA QB- reaction was rate-limiting for the recovery of the capacity to evolve oxygen, the equal energy-transfer hypothesis and the sequential double-hit model are valid in pea leaves and that the apparent invalidity in thylakoids is actually due to slowing of reaction steps in the oxygen evolution mechanism.

Distribution of the chlorophyll spectral forms in the chlorophyll-protein complexes of photosystem II antenna

The chlorophyll-protein complexes that form the antenna system of photosystem II have been purified and analyzed in terms of the commonly observed chlorophyll spectral forms. With the exception of chlorophyll b, which is known to be associated with the complexes comprising the outer antenna (LHCII, CP24, CP26, CP29), the spectral forms occur with similar absorption maxima and are present in rather similar amounts in each of the antenna complexes. On the basis of the published chlorophyll stoichiometries for the complexes in photosystem II antenna, the distribution of the spectral forms in a "reconstituted" antenna has been determined. These data were used to calculate the equilibrium population of excited states within the various chlorophyll-protein complexes within photosystem II. This was compared with the light absorption capacity of each of the complexes in the "reconstituted" antenna. The ratio of these two parameters (excited-state equilibrium distribution/absorption capacity) was determined to be 1.21 for the inner (core) antenna and 0.88 for LHCII. The standard free energy change for exciton transfer from the outer to the inner antenna was calculated to be -0.17 kcal mol-1. It is concluded that the photosystem II antenna is arranged as a very shallow funnel.

Arginine residues in the D2 polypeptide may stabilize bicarbonate binding in photosystem II of Synechocystis sp. PCC

Bicarbonate (HCO3-) causes a significant and reversible stimulation of anion-inhibited electron flow in photosystem II of higher plants and cyanobacteria. To test if selected arginine (Arg) residues are involved in the binding of HCO3-, we utilized oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis to construct Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 mutants carrying mutations in Arg residues in the D2 protein. Measurements of oxygen evolution showed that the D2 mutants R233Q (arginine-233----glutamine) and R251S (arginine-251----serine) were 10-fold more sensitive to formate than the wild type. The formate concentration giving half-maximal inhibition of the steady-state oxygen evolution rate was 48 mM, 4.5 mM and 4 mM for the wild type, R233Q and R251S, respectively. Measurements of oxygen evolution in single-turnover flashes confirm that the mutants are more sensitive to formate than the wild type. Measurements of chlorophyll a fluorescence decay kinetics after the second saturating actinic flash indicated that, after formate treatment, the halftime of QA- oxidation was decreased by approximately a factor of 2, 4 and 6 in the wild type, R251S and R233Q, respectively. The recombination rate between QA- and S2 was approx. 2-fold slower in R251S and R233Q than in the wild type. In the presence of 100 mM sodium formate, reactivation of the Hill reaction by bicarbonate showed that the wild type had an apparent Km for bicarbonate of 0.5 mM, while the Km values for R233Q and R251S were 1.4 and 1.5 mM, respectively. We suggest that Arg-233 and Arg-251 in the D2 polypeptide contribute to stabilization of HCO3- binding in Photosystem II.

Multiple anion effects on photosystem II in chloroplast membranes

We investigated the activity of several anions at various sites on photosystem II, in particular those associated with the Cl(-) effect (anion binding-site I) and the HCO3 (-) effect (anion binding-site II). Chlorophyll a fluorescence changes were used to monitor partial photosystem II reactions either in the oxygen-evolving mechanism or involving endogenous quinone electron acceptors. We find that anions such as NO3 (-), HCO3 (-), HCO2 (-), F(-), NO2 (-), and acetate can, depending on conditions, bind to either anion binding-site I, anion binding-site II, or both sites simultaneously. The anions N3 (-) and Au(CN)2 (-) are exceptions. In their presence, oxygen-consumption reactions are enhanced. The results demonstrate that an exclusive site or mode of action of an anion on photosystem II cannot be determined by measuring the Hill reaction alone. Anion interactions with photosystem II are shown to be very complex and, therefore, caution is advisable in interpreting related experiments. Carbonic anhydrase associated with photosystem II was also investigated as a possible target for some anion effects. In Cl(-)-depleted thylakoids, NO3 (-), stimulated both electron transport and carbonic anhydrase activity at low concentrations, while higher concentrations inhibited both. However, carbonic anhydrase was more sensitive to inhibition by NO3 (-) than was electron flow. Possible interpretations are discussed; the electron transport and carbonic anhydrase activity appear not to be functionally linked.

Reconciliation of the absorption change at 325 nm and other flash-yield determinations of concentrations of active photosystem II centers

The concentration of photosystem II was determined in thylakoids of dwarf peas by the use of the following methods: absorption change at 325 nm; atrazine binding; and flash yields of oxygen evolution (Emerson-Arnold method), of protons from oxidation of water, and of reduction of DCIP. For the first time all of the flash-yield measurements have been done on the same sample and give equivalent values for the concentration of photosystem II. Agreement of the absorption change measurement at 325 nm with the other measurements was accomplished by the introduction of important improvements to the methods of Melis and co-workers [Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA (1980) 77, 4712-4716]. The atrazine-binding method gave photosystem II values that were twice as large as any of the other photosystem II measurements. Possible reasons are discussed for this discrepancy in terms of the secondary acceptor (Q400) of Ikegami and Katoh [Plant Cell Physiol. (1973) 14, 829-836]. The concentration of photosystem I was measured by absorption change at 705 nm. From the concentration values of photosystem II and I the system II/I stoichiometry was calculated.