Identification of three different anti-4S RNA sera associated with autoimmune disease

Synthetic antibodies for accelerated RNA crystallography

RNA structure is crucial to a wide range of cellular processes. The intimate relationship between macromolecular structure and function necessitates the determination of high-resolution structures of functional RNA molecules. X-ray crystallography is the predominant technique used for macromolecular structure determination; however, solving RNA structures has been more challenging than their protein counterparts, as reflected in their poor representation in the Protein Data Bank (<1%). Antibody-assisted RNA crystallography is a relatively new technique that promises to accelerate RNA structure determination by employing synthetic antibodies (Fabs) as crystallization chaperones that are specifically raised against target RNAs. Antibody chaperones facilitate the formation of ordered crystal lattices by minimizing RNA flexibility and replacing unfavorable RNA-RNA contacts with contacts between chaperone molecules. Atomic coordinates of these antibody fragments can also be used as search models to obtain phase information during structure determination. Antibody-assisted RNA crystallography has enabled the structure determination of 15 unique RNA targets, including 11 in the last 6 years. In this review, I cover the historical development of antibody fragments as crystallization chaperones and their application to diverse RNA targets. I discuss how the first structures of antibody-RNA complexes informed the design of second-generation antibodies and led to the development of portable crystallization modules that have greatly reduced the uncertainties associated with RNA crystallography. Finally, I outline unexplored avenues that can increase the impact of this technology in structural biology research and discuss potential applications of antibodies as affinity reagents for interrogating RNA biology outside of their use in crystallography. This article is categorized under: RNA Structure and Dynamics > RNA Structure, Dynamics and Chemistry RNA Interactions with Proteins and Other Molecules > Protein-RNA Recognition RNA Interactions with Proteins and Other Molecules > RNA-Protein Complexes.

Specific Recognition of a Single-Stranded RNA Sequence by a Synthetic Antibody Fragment

Antibodies that bind RNA represent an unrealized source of reagents for synthetic biology and for characterizing cellular transcriptomes. However, facile access to RNA-binding antibodies requires the engineering of effective Fab libraries guided by the knowledge of the principles that govern RNA recognition. Here, we describe a Fab identified from a minimalist synthetic library during phage display against a branched RNA target. The Fab (BRG) binds with 20nM dissociation constant to a single-stranded RNA (ssRNA) sequence adjacent to the branch site and can block the action of debranchase enzyme. We report the crystal structure in complex with RNA target at 2.38Å. The Fab traps the RNA in a hairpin conformation that contains a 2-bp duplex capped by a tetraloop. The paratope surface consists of residues located in four complementarity-determining regions including a major contribution from H3, which adopts a helical structure that projects into a deep, wide groove formed by the RNA. The amino acid composition of the paratope reflects the library diversity, consisting mostly of tyrosine and serine residues and a small but significant contribution from a single arginine residue. This structure, involving the recognition of ssRNA via a stem-loop conformation, together with our two previous structures involving the recognition of an RNA hairpin loop and an RNA tertiary structure, reveals the capacity of minimalist libraries biased with tyrosine, serine, glycine, and arginine to form binding surfaces for specific RNA conformations and distinct levels of RNA structural hierarchy.

RNA surfaces as functional mimetics of proteins

Accumulating evidence suggests that RNA molecules can form surfaces that mimic those of proteins. Reactivity of autoantibodies with RNA surfaces may be due to cross-reactivity between a protein epitope and the RNA. The structural mimicry detected by an autoantibody may reflect functional mimicry.

RNA recognition by autoantigens and autoantibodies

The La, Ro, Sm and RNP autoantigens have been intensely studied over the past decade since cDNAs encoding autoantigens have been available. Most of these autoantigens are closely associated with RNA in RNP particles and molecular studies have provided insights into their modes of recognition and binding to RNA. For example, a common RNA Recognition Motif (RRM) was found to be a critical component of the RNA-binding domain of these autoantigens and the three dimensional structure of the RRM has been solved. As described in other articles in this series, the presence of La, Ro, Sm and RNP autoantibodies correlates with disease subsets, such as Sjogren's syndrome, systemic lupus erythematous and other connective tissue diseases. Immunological analysis of sera from autoimmune patients using recombinant autoantigens has revealed that multiple epitopes reside along the proteins and these represent both continuous and discontinuous (conformational) autotopes. Findings to date support a model of autoantibody induction which involves the direct presentation of proteinaceous autoantigens to the immune system. Circumstantial evidence has suggested that immunological crossreactivity between systemic autoantigens and structural components of infectious agents may play an initial role in the autoimmune response to certain antigens. However, the etiology of autoimmune diseases is probably multifactoral with genetic and other immune features acting on the organismal level. In addition, RNA molecules themselves can be autoantigens with higher order structural conformations which are recognized by RNP-type autoantibodies. Immune crossreactivity and/or direct presentation may generate autoantibodies reactive with conformational RNA epitopes. If crossreactivity with components of cellular or infectious agents give rise to RNA epitopes, they may represent structural or functional mimetics of the primary epitopes that actually drive the response. These ideas are discussed with respect to the role of mimetic processes in molecular recognition during autoimmunity.

Autoantibodies against a serine tRNA-protein complex implicated in cotranslational selenocysteine insertion

We describe an autoantibody specificity present in a subgroup of patients with a severe form of autoimmune chronic active hepatitis. These antibodies precipitate a 90-nucleotide RNA from human whole cell extracts and recognize a 48-kDa polypeptide in immunoblotting assays. The RNA is a UGA suppressor serine tRNA that carries selenocysteine (tRNA[Ser]Sec)), as shown by sequence analysis. The protein does not appear to be seryl-tRNA synthetase; rather, it is an excellent candidate for a factor involved in cotranslational selenocysteine incorporation in human cells.

Autoreactive epitope defined as the anticodon region of alanine transfer RNA

Autoantibodies to aminoacyl-transfer RNA (tRNA) synthetases are common in the human autoimmune diseases polymyositis and dermatomyositis. Sera of the PL-12 specificity contain separate antibodies reacting with alanyl-tRNA synthetase and alanine tRNA (tRNAAla). The antibodies to tRNA recognize at least six distinguishable human tRNAAla species grouped into two sequence families. The antibody-reactive determinants on the tRNA were identified through ribonuclease protection and oligonucleotide binding experiments. The antibody binding site is a seven- to nine-nucleotide sequence containing the anticodon loop and requires an intact anticodon. No requirement for anticodon stem structure or sequence is observed, although the 5' portion of the stem is protected from nuclease attack. Antibodies from several patients appear to share the same specificitym, indicating that the antibodies are induced by a unique sequence feature in the immunogen.

A human auto-immune antibody specifically recognizing initiator methionine tRNA from yeast and higher eucaryotes

Analysis of sera from 168 patients with autoimmune disorders revealed that one patient with Sjôgren's syndrome produced antibodies against deproteinized initiator methionine tRNA in addition to those against La protein. This anti-tRNAimet recognizes also tRNAimet from yeast but not from Phaseolus vulgaris chloroplasts (bean) or E. coli. It appears therefore that the epitope could be located in the TF loop in which an A residue in position 60 and the AUCG sequence are the only common features in yeast and human tRNAimet.

Autoantibodies against alanyl-tRNA synthetase and tRNAAla coexist and are associated with myositis

The sera of six patients with autoimmune disease, predominantly myositis with pulmonary fibrosis, contain antibodies of the PL-12 specificity. These autoantibodies react with both protein and RNA components of human cells. The protein has a subunit molecular mass of 110 kD, and the RNA comprises a group of bands in the tRNA size class. Aminoacylation experiments identify the antigens as alanyl-tRNA synthetase and its corresponding tRNAs, tRNAAla. Anti-tRNA antibody can be absorbed out without depleting antisynthetase activity, showing that the antigens are recognized independently by separable antibodies that coexist in these sera. The concurrence of separate antibodies to the two components suggests that the autoimmune response may be mounted against the charging enzyme-tRNA complex. However, the antisynthetase antibody fails to coprecipitate tRNA with the enzyme, suggesting that the antibody reacts with its target only when it is not complexed with tRNA.

Anti-threonyl-tRNA synthetase, a second myositis-related autoantibody

An autoantibody known as PL-7 was found in the serum of four patients with myositis and one with a systemic lupus erythematosus-like syndrome. The PL-7 antigen is an 80,000 dalton polypeptide that coprecipitates with transfer RNA. In aminoacylation reactions, PL-7 IgG inhibited the charging of tRNA with threonine but had little or no effect on charging with other amino acids. Experimental antibodies raised against purified threonyl-tRNA synthetase recognized the same 80,000 dalton polypeptide, but tRNA was not coprecipitated. We conclude that PL-7 antibody is directed at threonyl-tRNA synthetase, and that different antigenic sites are recognized by the human and experimental autoantibodies. Our findings emphasize the link between myositis and autoimmunity to tRNA-related structures.

Detection of anti-RNA antibodies in systemic lupus erythematosus by ELISA using nylon as solid support

A highly sensitive and reproducible enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for the detection of anti-RNA antibodies is described. The assay procedure involves adsorption of total cellular RNA on nylon beads which could be conveniently stored for a considerable period of time without loss in antigenicity. Sixty-four percent of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) sera were positive for anti-RNA antibodies with fluorogenic substrate against 48% with colorigenic substrate.