The effect of long-term caloric restriction on function of T-cell subsets in old mice

Amino acid starvation enhances vaccine efficacy by augmenting neutralizing antibody production

Specific reduction in the intake of proteins or amino acids (AAs) offers enormous health benefits, including increased life span, protection against age-associated disorders, and improved metabolic fitness and immunity. Cells respond to conditions of AA starvation by activating the amino acid starvation response (AAR). Here, we showed that mimicking AAR with halofuginone (HF) enhanced the magnitude and affinity of neutralizing, antigen-specific antibody responses in mice immunized with dengue virus envelope domain III protein (DENVrEDIII), a potent vaccine candidate against DENV. HF enhanced the formation of germinal centers (GCs) and increased the production of the cytokine IL-10 in the secondary lymphoid organs of vaccinated mice. Furthermore, HF promoted the transcription of genes associated with memory B cell formation and maintenance and maturation of GCs in the draining lymph nodes of vaccinated mice. The increased abundance of IL-10 in HF-preconditioned mice correlated with enhanced GC responses and may promote the establishment of long-lived plasma cells that secrete antigen-specific, high-affinity antibodies. Thus, these data suggest that mimetics of AA starvation could provide an alternative strategy to augment the efficacy of vaccines against dengue and other infectious diseases.

Impact of Age, Caloric Restriction, and Influenza Infection on Mouse Gut Microbiome: An Exploratory Study of the Role of Age-Related Microbiome Changes on Influenza Responses

Immunosenescence refers to age-related declines in the capacity to respond to infections such as influenza (flu). Caloric restriction represents a known strategy to slow many aging processes, including those involving the immune system. More recently, some changes in the microbiome have been described with aging, while the gut microbiome appears to influence responses to flu vaccination and infection. With these considerations in mind, we used a well-established mouse model of flu infection to explore the impact of flu infection, aging, and caloric restriction on the gut microbiome. Young, middle-aged, and aged caloric restricted (CR) and ad lib fed (AL) mice were examined after a sublethal flu infection. All mice lost 10–20% body weight and, as expected for these early time points, losses were similar at different ages and between diet groups. Cytokine and chemokine levels were also similar with the notable exception of IL-1α, which rose more than fivefold in aged AL mouse serum, while it remained unchanged in aged CR serum. Fecal microbiome phyla abundance profiles were similar in young, middle-aged, and aged AL mice at baseline and at 4 days post flu infection, while increases in Proteobacteria were evident at 7 days post flu infection in all three age groups. CR mice, compared to AL mice in each age group, had increased abundance of Proteobacteria and Verrucomicrobia at all time points. Interestingly, principal coordinate analysis determined that diet exerts a greater effect on the microbiome than age or flu infection. Percentage body weight loss correlated with the relative abundance of Proteobacteria regardless of age, suggesting flu pathogenicity is related to Proteobacteria abundance. Further, several microbial Operational Taxonomic Units from the Bacteroidetes phyla correlated with serum chemokine/cytokines regardless of both diet and age suggesting an interplay between flu-induced systemic inflammation and gut microbiota. These exploratory studies highlight the impact of caloric restriction on fecal microbiome in both young and aged animals, as well as the many complex relationships between flu responses and gut microbiota. Thus, these preliminary studies provide the necessary groundwork to examine how gut microbiota alterations may be leveraged to influence declining immune responses with aging.

Exercise Training and Immunosenescence

During the aging process, a decrease in the ability of the immune system to control infection, known as immunosenescence, takes place. Paradoxically, aging also results in chronic low-level inflammation and exaggerated inflammatory responses. A number of studies have investigated the effects of a variety of exercise training interventions on the immune system both in humans and using animal models of aging. Cross-sectional studies that compared masters athletes to untrained, age-matched controls found that the athletes had significantly better immune function, but these studies suffered because of the difficulty in generalizing results from highly trained athletes to a general population of physically active older adults. Prospective studies in humans have attempted to address this, but these studies have resulted in sometimes equivocal findings, possibly as a result of the differences in exercise training programs used. Finally, animal studies, both observational and mechanistic, have almost universally supported the exercise effect on enhancing immune status in the aged. More research is needed to determine the mechanism by which exercise influences immunity in the aged and to identify exercise training programs for use in this population. It is clear, however, that exercise is likely to be effective at boosting immunity in the older people when undertaken regularly.

Nonhuman primate models of human immunology

Nonhuman primates have been used for biomedical research for several decades. The high level of genetic homology to humans coupled with their outbred nature has made nonhuman primates invaluable preclinical models. In this review, we summarize recent advances in our understanding of the nonhuman primate immune system, with special emphasis on studies carried out in rhesus macaque (Macaca mulatta). We highlight the utility of nonhuman primates in the characterization of immune senescence and the evaluation of new interventions to slow down the aging of the immune system.

Immune senescence in aged nonhuman primates

Aging is accompanied by a general dysregulation in immune system function, commonly referred to as 'immune senescence'. This progressive deterioration affects both innate and adaptive immunity, although accumulating evidence indicates that the adaptive arm of the immune system may exhibit more profound changes. Most of our current understanding of immune senescence stems from clinical and rodent studies. More recently, the use of nonhuman primates (NHPs) to investigate immune senescence and test interventions aimed at delaying/reversing age-related changes in immune function has dramatically increased. These studies have been greatly facilitated by several key advances in our understanding of the immune system of old world monkeys, specifically the rhesus macaques. In this review we describe the hallmarks of immune senescence in this species and compare them to those described in humans. We also discuss the impact of immune senescence on the response to vaccination and the efficacy of immuno-restorative interventions investigated in this model system.

Comparative analysis of microarray data identifies common responses to caloric restriction among mouse tissues

Caloric restriction has been extensively investigated as an intervention that both extends lifespan and delays age-related disease in mammals. In mice, much interest has centered on evaluating gene expression changes induced by caloric restriction (CR) in particular tissue types, but the overall systemic effect of CR among multiple tissues has been examined less extensively. This study presents a comparative analysis of microarray datasets that have collectively examined the effects of CR in 10 different tissue types (liver, heart, muscle, hypothalamus, hippocampus, white adipose tissue, colon, kidney, lung and cochlea). Using novel methods for comparative analysis of microarray data, detailed comparisons of the effects of CR among tissues are provided, and 28 genes for which expression response to CR is most shared among tissues are identified. These genes characterize common responses to CR, which consist of both activation and inhibition of stress-response pathways. With respect to liver tissue, transcriptional effects of CR exhibited surprisingly little overlap with those of aging, and a variable degree of overlap with the potential CR-mimetic drug resveratrol. These analyses shed light on the systemic transcriptional activity associated with CR diets, and also illustrate new approaches for comparative analysis of microarray datasets in the context of aging biology.

High Growth Rate Fails to Enhance Adaptive Immune Responses of Neonatal Calves and Is Associated with Reduced Lymphocyte Viability

The objective of the study was to evaluate the effects of 3 targeted growth rates on adaptive (i.e., antigen-specific) immune responses of preruminant, milk replacer-fed calves. Calves (9.1 +/- 2.4 d of age) were assigned randomly to one of 3 dietary treatments to achieve 3 targeted daily rates of gain [no growth (maintenance) = 0.0 kg/d, low growth = 0.55 kg/d, or high growth = 1.2 kg/d] over an 8-wk period. The NRC Nutrient Requirements of Dairy Cattle calf model computer program was used to estimate the milk replacer intakes needed to achieve target growth rates. All calves were fed a 30% crude protein, 20% fat, all-milk protein milk replacer reconstituted to 14% dry matter. Diets were formulated to ensure that protein would not be limiting. All calves were vaccinated 3 wk after initiation of dietary treatments with Mycobacterium bovis, strain bacillus Calmette-Guerin and ovalbumin. Growth rates for no-growth (0.11 kg/d), low-growth (0.58 kg/d), and high-growth (1.16 kg/d) calves differed throughout the experimental period. Blood glucose concentrations in high-growth calves increased with time and were higher than in low- and no-growth calves. Mononuclear and polymorphonuclear leukocyte percentages in peripheral blood were unaffected by growth rate but did change with advancing age. Percentages of CD4(+) T cells increased with age in no-growth and low-growth calves, a characteristic of maturation, but failed to increase in high-growth calves. Growth rate did not affect the percentages of CD45RO(+) (memory) CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells, antigen (i.e., ovalbumin)-specific serum IgG concentrations, or antigen (i.e., purified protein derivative)-induced IFN-gamma and nitric oxide secretion by mononuclear cell cultures. Antigen-elicited cutaneous delayed-type hypersensitivity responses of no-growth calves exceeded responses of low-growth, but not high-growth, calves. In resting- and antigen-stimulated cell cultures, viabilities of CD4(+), CD8(+), and gammadeltaTCR(+) T cells from high-growth calves were lower than those of the same T cell subsets from no-growth and low-growth calves. Alternatively, resting cultures of mononuclear leukocytes from high-growth calves produced more nitric oxide than those from no-growth and low-growth calves. In conclusion, adaptive immune responses were affected minimally by growth rate. The results suggest that protein-energy malnutrition in the absence of weight loss is not detrimental to antigen-specific responses of neonatal vaccinated calves and that a high growth rate does not enhance these responses. The negative effect of a high growth rate on the viability of circulating T cell populations may influence infectious disease resistance of the calf.

Caloric restriction prevents radiation-induced myeloid leukemia in C3H/HeMs mice and inversely increases incidence of tumor-free death: implications in changes in number of hemopoietic progenitor cells

OBJECTIVES

Previously, we found a clear decrease in the incidence of radiation-induced myeloid leukemia in C3H/HeMs mouse caused by caloric restriction (CalR). In this report, CalR before and after irradiation was examined to determine whether they exert different effects on the prevention of radiation-induced myeloid leukemogenesis and the consequent extension of life span by CalR.

METHODS

The C3H/HeMS strain, which is prone to radiation-induced myeloid leukemia, was used. Groups subjected to different CalR timings, pre- and postirradiation, were compared with groups not subjected to CalR during their lifetime for the incidences of neoplasms, specifically that of myeloid leukemia, and the incidence of tumor-free death. A single dose of 3Gy X-ray was administered to mice at 10 weeks old. Results of colonization assay before and after CalR were compared with the incidence of leukemogenesis among the groups.

RESULTS

Irrespective of the CalR timing in terms of irradiation, there was a significant difference in the prevention of myeloid leukemogenesis, and a consequent difference in longevity (731 approximately 805 days for CalR groups vs. 697 days for the group without CalR; Log rank, P<0.03). During CalR, the number of hemopoietic progenitor cells (HPCs), potential leukemogenic targets, significantly decreased (0.4 x 10(4) vs. 4.2 x 10(4) of granulomacrophage colony forming units per spleen; 1.3 x 10(4) vs. 7.6 x 10(4) of the splenic colony forming units per spleen), but this decreased number of HPCs returned to that of the non-CalR control group, when the CalR group was returned to nonrestricted diet (returned to 1.5 x 10(4) granulomacrophage colony-forming units per spleen; returned to 2.8 x 10(4) splenic colony-forming units per spleen). Although preirradiation CalR followed by a conventional non-CalR diet negates the potential preventive effect, prevention conferred by pre-and postirradiation CalR suggests different underlying mechanisms; preirradiation CalR prevents the initiation of direct genotoxic leukemogenesis, while postirradiation CalR the indirect, epigenetic, leukemogenesis.

CONCLUSION

The incidences of tumor-free death significantly increased in all the groups undergoing CalR except for the group subjected to preirradiation CalR, which contributed to the longevity of the groups undergoing CalR.

Mice and flies and monkeys too: caloric restriction rejuvenates the aging immune system of non-human primates

Humanity has been obsessed with extending life span and reversing the aging process throughout recorded history and this quest most likely preceded the invention of the written word. The search for eternal youth has spurred holy wars and precipitated the discovery of the new world (the 'Fountain of youth'). It therefore comes as no surprise that an increasingly greater amount of research effort is dedicated to improve our understanding of the aging process and finding interventions to moderate its impact on health. Caloric restriction (CR) is the only intervention in biology that consistently extends maximal and median life span in a variety of short-lived species. Several theories to explain the mechanisms of action of CR have been put forth, including the possibility that CR acts by retarding immune senescence. The question remains, however, whether CR will have the same beneficial impact on human aging, and, if so, how long does CR need to last to produce beneficial effects. To address this question, several groups initiated long-term studies in Rhesus macaques (RM) in the 1980s. Here, we review published data describing the impact of CR on the aging immune system of mice and primates, and discuss our unpublished data that delineate similarities and differences in the effects of CR upon T cell aging and homeostasis between these two models.

Can exercise training improve immune function in the aged?

Many strategies have been used to improve immune function in the aged. Unfortunately, many of these interventions have been disappointing, impractical, costly to develop and administer, or accompanied by adverse side effects. Aside from dietary manipulation (caloric restriction without malnutrition or antioxidant supplementation), research involving behavioral preventative or restorative therapies has been lacking. Moderate exercise training has been shown to elicit beneficial outcomes in both the prevention and rehabilitation of many diseases of the elderly. It has been hypothesized that moderate levels of exercise improves, whereas strenuous exercise or overtraining suppresses, various immune function measures. Three general approaches have been implemented to study the impact of exercise on immune functioning in the elderly: (1) cross-sectional studies, (2) longitudinal studies, and (3) animal studies. In general, cross-sectional studies examining highly active elderly have demonstrated improved in vitro T cell responses to polyclonal stimulation when compared to sedentary elderly. This is corroborated by several animal studies that have shown improved splenic T cell responses in vitro. Unfortunately, human prospective studies have failed to demonstrate consistent improvements in various measures of immune function in older adults. However, it should be cautioned that these studies have included small samples followed over a short duration, measuring a limited number of in vitro immune parameters, with some failing to account for potential confounding influences. Although such findings have the potential to be of substantial public health importance, very few systematic studies have been conducted.

Aging and T-cell-mediated immunity

Changes in the T-lymphocyte compartment represent the most critical component of immunological aging. Recent studies have demonstrated that the age-related decline in T-cell-mediated immunity is a multifactorial phenomenon affecting T-cell subset composition as well as several proximal events such as protein tyrosine phosphorylation, generation of second messengers, calcium mobilization and translocation of protein kinase C, and distal events such as lymphocyte proliferation and cytokine production of the T-cell activation pathway. Age-related T-cell immune deficiency is preceded by thymic involution and is influenced by several intrinsic as well as extrinsic factors. Further, the role of monocytes and macrophages in T-cell activation changes with advancing age. This brief review will summarize the current knowledge of the cellular as well as molecular aspects of immunodeficiency of T cells due to aging, some of the paradoxes of aging as related to T-cell-mediated immunity, and possible factors which contribute to this paradox. Finally, experimental approaches will be suggested that might resolve these controversies and that might provide insights into the diverse and complex mechanisms that contribute to immunodeficiency of T cells. Ultimately these studies may suggest possible therapeutic interventions to enhance immune function in the elderly.

Intervention in the aging immune system: Influence of dietary restriction, dehydroepiandrosterone, melatonin, and exercise

The decline in immunologic function with age is associated with an increase in susceptibility to infections and the occurrence of autoimmune diseases and cancers. Hence, the restoration of immunologic function is expected to have a beneficial effect in reducing pathology and maintaining a healthy condition in advanced age. A number of therapeutic strategies have been employed to intervene in the aging immune system. This article reviews the effect of dietary restriction (DR), dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) treatment, melatonin (MLT) therapy, and exercise on modulating the immune responses and retarding/reducing immunosenescence. DR has been subject to intensive research and is known to be the most efficacious means of increasing longevity, reducing pathology and enhancing immune function. The circulatory levels of the androgenic hormone DHEA and the pineal hormone MLT decrease with increasing age, and this decrease has been correlated with the age-related decline in the immune system. Therefore, the observation that immunosenescence is associated with low levels of DHEA and MLT has provided a rationale for therapeutic intervention. DHEA treatment and MLT therapy both exhibit immunostimulatory actions and preliminary reports indicate that hormonal (DHEA or MLT) substitution therapy reverses immunosenescence in mice. Similarly, exercise in some studies has been shown to enhance the immune response. However, these findings have not been confirmed by other laboratories. Thus, at the present time, it is difficult to draw any definitive conclusions on the efficacy of DHEA, MLT, and exercise on reversing or restoring the aging immune system.

Influence of age, sex, and dietary restriction on intracellular free calcium responses of CD4+ lymphocytes in rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta)

The influence of aging and dietary restriction on increase in intracellular free calcium ([Ca2+]i) of CD4+ lymphocytes from Macaca mulatta was examined after stimulation with anti-CD3 mAb. We used a flow cytometric assay with the dye indo-1 and either direct or reciprocal immunofluorescent staining to identify CD4+ cells. After stimulation with anti-CD3 mAb, intracellular free calcium responses were reduced in CD4+ lymphocytes from old male and female ad libitum fed monkeys compared to young and adult male or female monkeys. Old female monkeys had significantly lower [Ca2+]i than did old male monkeys. The reduced responses were in part related to a decreased percentage of responding cells. Dietary restriction of males over a four-year period did not alter [Ca2+]i response compared to ad libitum fed male monkeys. Female monkeys of all ages (which were restricted only for four months) also had similar [Ca2+]i responses to ad libitum fed controls. Our data suggest that age-related changes in [Ca2+]i responses are similar between humans and M. mulatta, and that over these intervals, no effects of caloric restrictions can be detected.

Age associated changes in mitogen induced proliferation and cytokine production by lymphocytes of the long-lived brown Norway rat

The long-lived, inbred Brown Norway (BN) rat demonstrates an age associated decrease in lymphoproliferation in response to ConA; however, these declines only become apparent after the age of median survival, 31 months. Significant declines in IL-2 production after ConA stimulation also occur after median survival. In contrast, production of IFN after ConA stimulation increases with age in BN rats. This increase in IFN production begins about 12 months of age and plateaus at about median lifespan. The imbalance in IL-2 and IFN production may reflect a dysregulation that results in a decreased proliferative response of lymphocytes with increasing age.