Connection, a microcomputer program for storing and analyzing structural properties of neural circuits

Combining structural connectivity and response latencies to model the structure of the visual system

Several approaches exist to ascertain the connectivity of the brain, and these approaches lead to markedly different topologies, often incompatible with each other. Specifically, recent single-cell recording results seem incompatible with current structural connectivity models. We present a novel method that combines anatomical and temporal constraints to generate biologically plausible connectivity patterns of the visual system of the macaque monkey. Our method takes structural connectivity data from the CoCoMac database and recent single-cell recording data as input and employs an optimization technique to arrive at a new connectivity pattern of the visual system that is in agreement with both types of experimental data. The new connectivity pattern yields a revised model that has fewer levels than current models. In addition, it introduces subcortical–cortical connections. We show that these connections are essential for explaining latency data, are consistent with our current knowledge of the structural connectivity of the visual system, and might explain recent functional imaging results in humans. Furthermore we show that the revised model is not underconstrained like previous models and can be extended to include newer data and other kinds of data. We conclude that the revised model of the connectivity of the visual system reflects current knowledge on the structure and function of the visual system and addresses some of the limitations of previous models.

Visual perception is very important to us, something we can easily come to realize if we imagine ourselves blind. The visual system consists of numerous interconnected brain areas. If we are to understand the functioning of the visual system, then we will need to understand the connectivity between these areas. Current models of the visual system have a number of limitations. One of these is that the time it takes for the neural signal to reach a certain area often seems inconsistent with the place of that area in the overall structure of the system; e.g., the signal might arrive relatively quickly at an area generally located “higher” in the visual system and slowly at an area located in the “lower” part. We combine data about the known connectivity in the monkey brain with timing data to find a network structure that is consistent with both kinds of data. The results show that the timing data can be explained when the network contains direct routes from subcortical areas to “higher” cortical areas. We show that our model has fewer limitations than previous models and might explain unresolved issues in the study of connectivity in the human brain.

The NeuARt II system: a viewing tool for neuroanatomical data based on published neuroanatomical atlases

Background

Anatomical studies of neural circuitry describing the basic wiring diagram of the brain produce intrinsically spatial, highly complex data of great value to the neuroscience community. Published neuroanatomical atlases provide a spatial framework for these studies. We have built an informatics framework based on these atlases for the representation of neuroanatomical knowledge. This framework not only captures current methods of anatomical data acquisition and analysis, it allows these studies to be collated, compared and synthesized within a single system.

Results

We have developed an atlas-viewing application ('NeuARt II') in the Java language with unique functional properties. These include the ability to use copyrighted atlases as templates within which users may view, save and retrieve data-maps and annotate them with volumetric delineations. NeuARt II also permits users to view multiple levels on multiple atlases at once. Each data-map in this system is simply a stack of vector images with one image per atlas level, so any set of accurate drawings made onto a supported atlas (in vector graphics format) could be uploaded into NeuARt II. Presently the database is populated with a corpus of high-quality neuroanatomical data from the laboratory of Dr Larry Swanson (consisting 64 highly-detailed maps of PHAL tract-tracing experiments, made up of 1039 separate drawings that were published in 27 primary research publications over 17 years). Herein we take selective examples from these data to demonstrate the features of NeuArt II. Our informatics tool permits users to browse, query and compare these maps. The NeuARt II tool operates within a bioinformatics knowledge management platform (called 'NeuroScholar') either as a standalone or a plug-in application.

Conclusion

Anatomical localization is fundamental to neuroscientific work and atlases provide an easily-understood framework that is widely used by neuroanatomists and non-neuroanatomists alike. NeuARt II, the neuroinformatics tool presented here, provides an accurate and powerful way of representing neuroanatomical data in the context of commonly-used brain atlases for visualization, comparison and analysis. Furthermore, it provides a framework that supports the delivery and manipulation of mapped data either as a standalone system or as a component in a larger knowledge management system.

Tools for knowledge acquisition within the NeuroScholar system and their application to anatomical tract-tracing data

Background

Knowledge bases that summarize the published literature provide useful online references for specific areas of systems-level biology that are not otherwise supported by large-scale databases. In the field of neuroanatomy, groups of small focused teams have constructed medium size knowledge bases to summarize the literature describing tract-tracing experiments in several species. Despite years of collation and curation, these databases only provide partial coverage of the available published literature. Given that the scientists reading these papers must all generate the interpretations that would normally be entered into such a system, we attempt here to provide general-purpose annotation tools to make it easy for members of the community to contribute to the task of data collation.

Results

In this paper, we describe an open-source, freely available knowledge management system called 'NeuroScholar' that allows straightforward structured markup of the PDF files according to a well-designed schema to capture the essential details of this class of experiment. Although, the example worked through in this paper is quite specific to neuroanatomical connectivity, the design is freely extensible and could conceivably be used to construct local knowledge bases for other experiment types. Knowledge representations of the experiment are also directly linked to the contributing textual fragments from the original research article. Through the use of this system, not only could members of the community contribute to the collation task, but input data can be gathered for automated approaches to permit knowledge acquisition through the use of Natural Language Processing (NLP).

Conclusion

We present a functional, working tool to permit users to populate knowledge bases for neuroanatomical connectivity data from the literature through the use of structured questionnaires. This system is open-source, fully functional and available for download from [1].

The informatics of a C57BL/6J mouse brain atlas

The Mouse Atlas Project (MAP) aims to produce a framework for organizing and analyzing the large volumes of neuroscientific data produced by the proliferation of genetically modified animals. Atlases provide an invaluable aid in understanding the impact of genetic manipulations by providing a standard for comparison. We use a digital atlas as the hub of an informatics network, correlating imaging data, such as structural imaging and histology, with text-based data, such as nomenclature, connections, and references. We generated brain volumes using magnetic resonance microscopy (MRM), classical histology, and immunohistochemistry, and registered them into a common and defined coordinate system. Specially designed viewers were developed in order to visualize multiple datasets simultaneously and to coordinate between textual and image data. Researchers can navigate through the brain interchangeably, in either a text-based or image-based representation that automatically updates information as they move. The atlas also allows the independent entry of other types of data, the facile retrieval of information, and the straight-forward display of images. In conjunction with centralized servers, image and text data can be kept current and can decrease the burden on individual researchers' computers. A comprehensive framework that encompasses many forms of information in the context of anatomic imaging holds tremendous promise for producing new insights. The atlas and associated tools can be found at http://www.loni.ucla.edu/MAP.

Tools and approaches for the construction of knowledge models from the neuroscientific literature

Within this paper, we describe a neuroinformatics project (called "NeuroScholar," http://www.neuroscholar.org/) that enables researchers to examine, manage, manipulate, and use the information contained within the published neuroscientific literature. The project is built within a multi-level, multi-component framework constructed with the use of software engineering methods that themselves provide code-building functionality for neuroinformaticians. We describe the different software layers of the system. First, we present a hypothetical usage scenario illustrating how NeuroScholar permits users to address large-scale questions in a way that would otherwise be impossible. We do this by applying NeuroScholar to a "real-world" neuroscience question: How is stress-related information processed in the brain? We then explain how the overall design of NeuroScholar enables the system to work and illustrate different components of the user interface. We then describe the knowledge management strategy we use to store interpretations. Finally, we describe the software engineering framework we have devised (called the "View-Primitive-Data Model framework," [VPDMf]) to provide an open-source, accelerated software development environment for the project. We believe that NeuroScholar will be useful to experimental neuroscientists by helping them interact with the primary neuroscientific literature in a meaningful way, and to neuroinformaticians by providing them with useful, affordable software engineering tools.

Knowledge management of the neuroscientific literature: the data model and underlying strategy of the NeuroScholar system

This paper describes the underlying strategy and system's design of a knowledge management system for the neuroscientific literature called 'NeuroScholar'. The problem that the system is designed to address is to delineate fully the neural circuitry involved in a specific behaviour. The use of this system provides experimental neuroscientists with a new method of building computational models ('knowledge models') of the contents of the published literature. These models may provide input for analysis (conceptual or computational), or be used as constraint sets for conventional neural modelling work. The underlying problems inherent in this approach, the general framework for the proposed solution, the practical issues concerning usage of the system and a detailed, technical account of the system are described. The author uses a widely used software specification language (the Universal Modelling Language) to describe the design of the system and present examples from published work concerned with classical eyeblink conditioning in the rabbit.

Non-metric multidimensional scaling in the analysis of neuroanatomical connection data and the organization of the primate cortical visual system

Neuroanatomists have established that the various gross structures of the brain are divided into a large number of different processing regions and have catalogued a large number of connections between these regions. The connectional data derived from neuroanatomical studies are complex, and reliable conclusions about the organization of brain systems cannot be drawn from considering them without some supporting analysis. Recognition of this problem has recently led to the application of a variety of techniques to the analysis of connection data. One of the techniques that we previously employed, non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS), appears to have revealed important aspects of the organization of the central nervous system, such as the gross organization of the whole cortical network in two species. We present here a detailed treatment of methodological aspects of the application of NMDS to connection data. We first examine in detail the particular properties of neuroanatomical connection data. Second, we consider the details of NMDS and discuss the propriety of different possible NMDS approaches. Third, we present results of the analyses of connection data from the primate visual system, and discuss their interpretation. Fourth, we study independent analyses of the organization of the visual system, and examine the relation between the results of these analyses and those from NMDS. Fifth, we investigate quantitatively the performance of a number of data transformation and conditioning procedures, as well as tied and untied NMDS analysis of untransformed low-level data, to determine how well NMDS can recover known metric parameters from artificial data. We then re-analyse real connectivity data with the most successful methods at removing the effects of sparsity, to ensure that this aspect of data structure does not obscure others. Finally, we summarize the evidence on the connectional organization of the primate visual system, and discuss the reliability of NMDS analyses of neuroanatomical connection data.

Structural analysis of neural circuits using the theory of directed graphs

A new approach to analysis of structural properties of biological neural circuits is proposed based on their representation in the form of abstract structures called directed graphs. To exemplify this methodology, structural properties of a biological neural network and randomly wired circuits (RC) were compared. The analyzed biological circuit (BC) represented a sample of 39 neural nuclei which are responsible for the control of the cardiovascular function in higher vertebrates. Initially, direct connections of both circuits were stored in a square matrix format. Then, standard algorithms derived from the theory of directed graphs were applied to analyze the pathways of the circuits according to their length (in number of synapses), degree of connectedness, and structural strength. Thus, the BC was characterized by the presence of short, reciprocal, and unidirectional pathways which presented a high degree of heterogeneity in their strengths. This heterogeneity was mainly due to the existence of a small cluster of reciprocally connected neural nuclei in the circuit that have access, through short pathways, to most of the network. On the other hand, RCs were characterized by the presence of long and mainly reciprocal pathways which showed lower and absolute homogeneous strengths. Through this study the proposed methodology was demonstrated to be a simple and efficient way to store, analyze, and compare basic neuroanatomical information.

Structural characterization of the neural circuit responsible for control of cardiovascular functions in higher vertebrates

A comparison of structural properties of a biological neural system responsible for cardiovascular function control in higher vertebrates with randomly connected networks was pursued using matrix representations of those circuits. The biological circuit was characterized by the presence of some heavily connected nuclei in contrast to the random networks that had equally distributed connections between their elements. This property of the analysed biological circuit was shown to account for a high logarithmic correlation found between two indexes defined to represent pointwise features of the nuclei and their global contribution to the whole network. The first index is obtained by the product of the number of inputs and of outputs of a nucleus and was called power index (PI). The second one, called occurrence index (OI), defines how many times a specific nucleus is crossed when all possible pathways joining two nuclei of the circuit are obtained. This PI-OI correlation was clearly dependent on the pathway length distribution (expressed in number of synapses), and was maximal considering pathways with a low number of synapses. When randomly connected circuits were analysed lower correlation was found between the same two indexes and only for much longer pathways. Therefore, it is proposed that the analysis of the PI-OI correlation can be useful to quantify structural differences between biological neural circuits as distinguished from randomly connected networks and also between neural systems at different levels of phylogenetic and ontogenetic development.