Catalysis of plastocyanin electron self-exchange by redox-inert multivalent cations

Manipulating electron transfer – the influence of substituents on novel copper guanidine quinolinyl complexes

Copper guanidine quinolinyl complexes act as good entatic state models due to their distorted structures leading to a high similarity between Cu(i) and Cu(ii) complexes. For a better understanding of the entatic state principle regarding electron transfer a series of guanidine quinolinyl ligands with different substituents in the 2- and 4-position were synthesized to examine the influence on the electron transfer properties of the corresponding copper complexes. Substituents with different steric or electronic influences were chosen. The effects on the properties of the copper complexes were studied applying different experimental and theoretical methods. The molecular structures of the bis(chelate) copper complexes were examined in the solid state by single-crystal X-ray diffraction and in solution by X-ray absorption spectroscopy and density functional theory (DFT) calculations revealing a significant impact of the substituents on the complex structures. For a better insight natural bond orbital (NBO) calculations of the ligands and copper complexes were performed. The electron transfer was analysed by the determination of the electron self-exchange rates following Marcus theory. The obtained results were correlated with the results of the structural analysis of the complexes and of the NBO calculations. Nelsen's four-point method calculations give a deeper understanding of the thermodynamic properties of the electron transfer. These studies reveal a significant impact of the substituents on the properties of the copper complexes.

Copper guanidine quinolinyl complexes act as good entatic state models for the electron transfer due to a high similarity between the corresponding Cu(i) and Cu(ii) complexes. The introduction of substituents leads to a further enhancement.

Transient homodimer interactions studied using the electron self-exchange reaction

Transient homodimer protein interactions have been investigated by analyzing the influence of ionic strength (NaCl) on the electron self-exchange (the bimolecular reaction whereby the two oxidation states of a redox protein interconvert) rate constant (k(ese)) of four plastocyanins. The k(ese) values for the plastocyanins from spinach, Dryopteris crassirhizoma (a fern), and the green alga Ulva pertusa, which possess acidic patches of varying size and locations, increase 190-, 29-, and 21-fold, respectively, at elevated ionic strength (I = 2.03 M). In contrast, the k(ese) for the almost neutral cyanobacterial plastocyanin from Anabaena variabilis exhibits very little dependence on ionic strength. The temperature dependence of the k(ese) for spinach plastocyanin (I = 0.28 M) provides evidence for poor packing at the homodimer interface. Representative structures of the transient homodimers involved in electron self-exchange, which are consistent with fits of the ionic strength dependence of k(ese) to van Leeuwen theory, have been obtained from protein modeling and docking simulations. The Coulombic energy of the docked homodimers follows the order spinach > D. crassirhizoma > U. pertusa > A. variabilis, which matches that of the overall influence of ionic strength on k(ese). Analysis of the homodimer structures indicates that poor packing and high planarity are features of the interface that favor transient interactions. The physiologically relevant Mg2+ ion has a much more pronounced influence on the k(ese) of spinach plastocyanin, which along with the known properties of the thylakoid lumen suggests a biological role for electron self-exchange.

Active-site structure and electron-transfer reactivity of plastocyanins

The active-site structures of Cu(II) plastocyanins (PCu's) from a higher plant (parsley), a seedless vascular plant (fern, Dryopteris crassirhizoma), a green alga (Ulva pertusa), and cyanobacteria (Anabaena variabilis and Synechococcus) have been investigated by paramagnetic (1)H NMR spectroscopy. In all cases the spectra are similar, indicating that the structures of the cupric sites, and the spin density distributions onto the ligands, do not differ greatly between the proteins. The active-site structure of PCu has remained unaltered during the evolutionary process. The electron transfer (et) reactivity of these PCu's is compared utilizing the electron self-exchange (ESE) reaction. At moderate ionic strength (0.10 M) the ESE rate constant is dictated by the distribution of charged amino acid residues on the surface of the PCu's. Most higher plant and the seedless vascular plant PCu's, which have a large number of acidic residues close to the hydrophobic patch surrounding the exposed His87 ligand (the proposed recognition patch for the self-exchange process), have ESE rate constants of approximately 10(3) M(-)(1) s(-)(1). Removal of some of these acidic residues, as in the parsley and green algal PCu's, results in more favorable protein-protein association and an ESE rate constant of approximately 10(4) M(-)(1) s(-)(1). Complete removal of the acidic patch, as in the cyanobacterial PCu's, leads to ESE rate constants of approximately 10(5)-10(6) M(-)(1) s(-)(1). The ESE rate constants of the PCu's with an acidic patch also tend toward approximately 10(5)-10(6) M(-)(1) s(-)(1) at higher ionic strength, thus indicating that once the influence of charged residues has been minimized the et capabilities of the PCu's are comparable. The cytochromes and Fe-S proteins, two other classes of redox metalloproteins, also possess ESE rate constants of approximately 10(5)-10(6) M(-)(1) s(-)(1) at high ionic strength. The effect of the protonation of the His87 ligand in PCu(I) on the ESE reactivity has been investigated. When the influence of the acidic patch is minimized, the ESE rate constant decreases at high [H(+)].

Effect of pH on the self-exchange reactivity of the plant plastocyanin from parsley

The self-exchange rate constant (25 degrees C) for parsley plastocyanin is 5.0 x 10(4) M-1 s-1 at pH* 7.5 (I = 0.10 M). This value is quite large for a higher plant plastocyanin and can be attributed to a diminished upper acidic patch in this protein. The self-exchange rate constant is almost independent of pH* in the range 7.5-5.6, with a value (25 degrees C) of 5.6 x 10(4) M-1 s-1 at pH* 5.6 (I = 0.10 M). At this pH*, the ligand His87 is protonated in approximately 50% of the reduced protein molecules (pKa* 5.6), and this would be expected to hinder electron transfer between the two oxidation states. However, this effect is counterbalanced by the enhanced association of two parsley plastocyanins at lower pH* due to the partial protonation of the acidic patch.

Voltammetry of Plastocyanin at a Graphite Electrode: Effects of Structure, Charge, and Electrolyte

Comparative voltammetric studies on Anabaena variabilis plastocyanin (positively charged at neutral pH) and spinach and poplar plastocyanins (negatively charged at neutral pH) have been undertaken at an edge-plane graphite electrode as a function of ionic strength, pH, and Mg(2+) concentration at 3 degrees C. The aim was to provide a more detailed understanding of the influence of the electrode-protein (solution) interfacial characteristics, as well as the variation of the formal potential with both the nature of the plastocyanin species and the pH. As might be expected, some of the interfacial properties associated with the positive charge on A. variabilis plastocyanin are the opposite of those observed with the negatively charged plastocyanins. For example, the linear diffusion component of the mass transport process for A. variabilis plastocyanin under the conditions of cyclic voltammetry is decreased and the radial diffusion component is increased by the addition of Mg(2+), whereas the reverse occurs with poplar and spinach plastocyanins. The voltammetrically determined reversible potentials for A. variabilis plastocyanin are considerably less positive than those for spinach and poplar plastocyanins, in agreement with values calculated from chemically based redox studies. Ionic strength effects, as determined by addition of NaClO(4) over the concentration range 0.005-0.20 M, are negligible for all three proteins. The addition of Mg(2+) causes a significant shift in the reversible potential toward more positive values for spinach and poplar plastocyanin but only a small positive shift for A. variabilis plastocyanin. The difference is attributed to a specific binding effect. The addition of Mg(2+) also dramatically alters the pH dependence of the reversible potential, indicating that the equilibrium between the protonated and unprotonated forms of reduced plastocyanin is modified by binding of Mg(2+) to the protein. It is concluded that the effects of biologically relevant redox-inactive cations such as Mg(2+) or Ca(2+) have to be considered carefully in studies of the redox chemistry of metalloproteins.

A comparative laser-flash absorption spectroscopy study of Anabaena PCC 7119 plastocyanin and cytochrome c6 photooxidation by photosystem I particles

Laser-flash absorption spectroscopy has been used to investigate the kinetics of electron transfer from reduced cytochrome c6 and plastocyanin, isolated from Anabaena PCC 7119, to oxidized P700 in photosystem-I particles isolated from the same cyanobacterium and from spinach. For all metalloproteins and photosystems, the observed rate constant has a non-linear protein-concentration dependence, thus suggesting complex formation preceding electron transfer. Plastocyanin and cytochrome c6 have similar association constants for complex formation with spinach photosystem I, but the copper protein exhibits a higher intracomplex-electron-transfer rate constant (twofold). With Anabaena photosystem I, the two redox proteins are more effective with respect to both complex formation (5-10-fold) and electron transfer (1.5-4-fold) than with the spinach photosystem. In all cases, the observed rate constants for electron-transfer monotonically decrease with increasing NaCl or MgCl2 concentration. This is interpreted in terms of the involvement of attractive electrostatic interactions, which result in the initial collision complex having the most productive orientation for the electron transfer process, without a requirement for further reorientation. The magnitude of the response to MgCl2 suggests the occurrence of specific ion effects as well. In the absence of added salts, the reduction rate of oxidized P700 increases with pH from approximately 6 to 8, but decreases slightly at pH 8.5.

Characterisation of the electron self-exchange rates in hexametaphosphate-cytochrome-c aggregates measured using high-resolution 1H-NMR spectroscopy

1H-NMR spectroscopy has been used to measure the rate of unimolecular electron exchange between cytochrome c molecules in protein aggregates stabilised by the addition of sodium hexametaphosphate. The average intracomplex electron exchange rate is measured from line broadening of hyperfine-shifted resonances of ferricytochrome c in an equimolar mixture of reduced and oxidised protein. The line-broadening due to electron exchange is significantly greater than that due to protein aggregation and reaches a maximum value between 1-2 mol hexametaphosphate/mol protein. Significantly the exchange-induced broadening is a first-order process and is directly proportional to the size of the cytochrome c oligomer. From the temperature dependence of exchange broadening the activation enthalpy was estimated to be 75.8 kJ mol-1 whereas the activation entropy was 295 J mol-1 K-1 for a dimer of cytochrome c at a hexametaphosphate/protein molar ratio of 1. Both activation parameters decrease in magnitude as the order of the cytochrome c oligomer increases. The rates of intracomplex electron exchange in Saccharomyces cerevisiae iso-2 and Candida krusei cytochromes c are lower than that of the horse protein, implying that primary sequence plays a fundamental part in determining the rate of exchange. The relevance of these observations is discussed in terms of the function of cytochrome c.

The complex formed between plastocyanin and cytochrome c. Investigation by NMR spectroscopy

Spinach plastocyanin and horse heart cytochrome c have been shown, by monitoring the behaviour of the hyperfine-shifted heme resonances of Fe(III) cytochrome c on titration with Cu(II) plastocyanin, to form a 1:1 complex with a dissociation constant of 67 mM (D2O, pH* 7.0, 300 K). The interaction sites on the plastocyanin surface have been investigated in one- and two-dimensional NMR experiments involving competition for plastocyanin between cytochrome c and the paramagnetic cation Cr(NH3)(3+)6. The plastocyanin resonances which are paramagnetically broadened in the spectrum of plastocyanin alone are also broadened in the spectrum of the mixture of the two proteins. This shows that, on the NMR time scale, no plastocyanin residues are hidden from Cr(NH3)(3+)6 by complexation with cytochrome c. [It has been shown that Cr(NH3)(3+)6 does not disrupt formation of the complex between the two proteins.] It appears that initial complexation of cytochrome c takes place at the acidic east site of plastocyanin, and that the extensive negative electrostatic surface of plastocyanin accommodates the paramagnetic probe and cytochrome c simultaneously in a dynamic ternary complex. The location of the electron transfer site on plastocyanin is discussed.

A 1H-NMR study on the blue copper protein amicyanin from Thiobacillus versutus. Resonance identifications, structural rearrangements and determination of the electron self-exchange rate constant

A number of resonances in the 1H-NMR spectra of reduced and oxidised amicyanin from Thiobacillus versutus have been identified by one- and two-dimensional NMR techniques. The second-order electron self-exchange rate constant (8.5 x 10(4) M-1.s-1; pH = 7.4; T = 308.5 K) was determined by measuring the line broadening of six singlets in slightly oxidised solutions of the protein. A large increase in electron exchange rate is observed in the presence of ferrocyanide. The copper atom in the reactive centre of the protein appears to be coordinated by nitrogens from two histidines and sulfurs from a methionine and a cysteine. One of the ligand histidines becomes protonated at low pH [pK*a = 6.74 (+/- 0.02)], the asterisk indicating value uncorrected for the deuterium isotope effect] in reduced amicyanin. This is the first example of a non-photosynthetic blue copper protein in which a ligand histidine becomes protonated at low pH. A small pH-independent conformational rearrangement occurs upon oxidation.

Direct and indirect electron transfer between electrodes and redox proteins

The direct electrochemistry of redox proteins has been achieved at a variety of electrodes, including modified gold, pyrolytic graphite and metal oxides. Careful design of electrode surfaces and electrolyte conditions are required for the attainment of rapid and reversible protein-electrode interaction. The electron transfer reactions of more complex systems, such as redox enzymes, are now being examined. The 'well-behaved' electrochemistry of redox proteins can be usefully exploited by coupling the electrode reaction to enzymes for which the redox proteins act as cofactors. In systems where direct electron transfer is very slow, small electron carriers, or mediators, may be employed to enhance the rate of electron exchange with the electrode. The organometallic compound ferrocene and its derivatives have proved particularly effective in this role. A new generation of electrochemical biosensors employs ferrocene derivatives as mediators.

1H-NMR sequential assignments and cation-binding studies of spinach plastocyanin

The essentially complete assignment of the 1H-NMR spectrum of the Cu(i) form of spinach plastocyanin has been achieved using two-dimensional NMR techniques and sequence-specific resonance assignment procedures. A variety of pH and temperature conditions was utilised to overcome the problems of resonance overlap in the spectrum, degeneracy of C alpha H and solvent H2O chemical shifts, and cross-saturation of labile NH resonances. A qualitative analysis of the long-range nuclear Overhauser effects observed indicates that the backbone fold of spinach plastocyanin is very similar to that of poplar plastocyanin, whose structure has been solved by X-ray crystallography and differs in 22 of its 99 amino acid residues. The assignments provide a basis for further investigations into the structural and ion- and protein-binding properties of plastocyanin in solution.

The modulation of cytochrome c electron self-exchange by site-specific chemical modification and anion binding

The site-specific chemical modification of horse heart cytochrome c at Lys-13 and -72 using 4-chloro-3,5-dinitrobenzoic acid (CDNB) increases the electron self-exchange rate of the protein. In the presence of 0.24 M cacodylate (pH* 7.0) the electron self-exchange rate constants, kex, measured by a 1H NMR saturation transfer method at 300 K, are 600, 6 X 10(3) and 6 X 10(4) M-1 X s-1 for native, CDNP-K13 and CDNP-K72 cytochromes c respectively. Repulsive electrostatic interactions, which inhibit cytochrome c electron self-exchange, are differentially affected by modification. Measurements of 1H NMR line broadening observed with partially oxidised samples of native cytochrome c show that ATP and the redox inert multivalent anion Co(CN)3-6 catalyse electron self-exchange. At saturation a limiting value of approximately 1.4 X 10(5) M-1 X s-1 is observed for both anions.

Reactions of electron-transfer proteins at electrodes

Studies of electron-transfer reactions of redox proteins have, in recent years, attracted widespread interest and attention. Progress has been evident from both physical and biological standpoints, with the increasing availability of three-dimensional structural data for many small electron-transfer proteins prompting a variety of systematic investigations (Isied, 1985). Most recently, attention has been directed towards questions concerning the elementary transfer of electrons between spatially remote redox sites, and the nature of protein–protein interactions which, for intermolecular processes, stabilize specific precursor complexes which may be optimally juxtaposed for electron-transfer. These and other issues, including the necessary reversibility of protein interfacial interactions and the dynamic properties of proteins as carriers of electrons in biological electron-transport systems, are now being addressed in the rapidly emerging field of direct (unmediated) protein electrochemistry. It is our intention in this article to discuss developments made in this area and highlight points which we believe to have the most bearing on our current understanding of diffusion-dominated, protein-mediated electron transport at electrode surfaces. First we shall outline some basic considerations which are best considered with reference to homogeneous systems.