Detection of single base substitutions in influenza virus RNA molecules by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis of RNA-RNA or DNA-RNA heteroduplexes

Geographical clusters of dengue virus type 2 isolates based on analysis of infected cell RNA by the chemical cleavage at mismatch method

Genetic variation in 12 strains of dengue virus type 2, isolated from several epidemic areas in different years, was studied by chemical cleavage at mismatched cytosine in DNA:RNA heteroduplexes. End-labelled cDNA probes derived from the E and NS2A genes of the New Guinea C strain were hybridized to total RNA extracted from cells infected by individual isolates. Following modification of mismatched cytosine by hydroxylamine and nucleic acid strand cleavage by piperidine, the resulting fragments of radiolabelled probe were analysed by electrophoresis and autoradiography. The patterns of bands generated corresponded to the geographical groupings of the isolates. Thus this method is suitable in epidemiological studies for rapidly surveying a large number of isolates for genetic variation in a particular gene of interest.

Genome scanning by two-dimensional DNA typing: the use of repetitive DNA sequences for rapid mapping of genetic traits

The existence of repetitive DNA sequences offers the possibility to assess the mammalian genome for individual variation in its entirety rather than at one or only a few sites. In order to fully explore the various sets of mammalian repeat sequences for this purpose, analytical tools are required which allow many if not all individual members of sets of repetitive elements to be resolved and identified in terms of location and allelic variation. We have applied and further developed an electrophoretic system, two-dimensional DNA typing, which may fulfill these requirements. The two-dimensional system combines separation of DNA fragments by size in a neutral gel, with separation by sequence composition in a denaturing gradient gel. By hybridization with minisatellite- and simple-sequence core probes and by inter-repeat polymerase chain reaction techniques, it is possible to obtain individual--and even chromosome-specific separation patterns that consist of hundreds of spots. Computerized image analysis and matching of such spot patterns allows the rapid assessment of multiple polymorphisms, spread over the genome, to monitor genetic variability in populations. When coupled to databases of polymorphic DNA markers with a known genomic location, two-dimensional DNA typing can greatly accelerate the mapping of genetic traits in humans, animals, and plants.

An improved method for the detection of genetic variations in DNA with denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis

We have examined the feasibility of denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) of RNA:DNA duplexes to detect variations in genomic and cloned DNAs. The result has demonstrated that employment of RNA:DNA duplexes makes DGGE much more practical for screening a large number of samples than that of DNA:DNA heteroduplexes originally developed by Lerman et al. (1986), because preparation of RNA probes is easier than that of DNA probes. Three different 32P-labeled RNA probes were produced. Genomic or cloned DNAs were digested with restriction enzymes and hybridized to labeled RNA probes, and resulting RNA:DNA duplexes were examined by DGGE. The presence of mismatch(es) was detected as a difference in mobility of bands on the gel. The experimental conditions were determined using DNA segments from cloned normal and 3 thalassemic human beta-globin genes. The results of the experiments on the cloned DNAs suggest that DGGE of RNA:DNA duplexes will detect nucleotide substitutions and deletions in DNA. In the course of these studies, a polymorphism due to a single-base substitution at position 666 of IVS2 (IVS2-666) of the human beta-globin gene was directly identified using genomic DNA samples. A study of 59 unrelated Japanese from Hiroshima was made in which the frequency of the allele with C at IVS2-666 was 0.48 and that of the allele with T was 0.52. This approach was found to be very effective for the detection of heritable variation and should be a powerful tool for the detection of fresh mutations in DNA, which occur outside the known restriction sites.

Comparison of RNase A, a chemical cleavage and GC-clamped denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis for the detection of mutations in exon 9 of the human acid beta-glucosidase gene

Gaucher disease (GD), which results from mutations in the human acid beta-glucosidase (beta-Glc) gene, was used as a model system to compare the utility of three methods capable of detecting single base substitutions. PCR-amplified beta-Glc exon 9 sequences of GD patients were screened for single base mutations by GC-clamped denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) and RNase A cleavage of RNA-DNA heteroduplexes, and by chemical (hydroxylamine/osmium tetroxide) cleavage of dsDNA heteroduplexes. PCR products showing abnormal behaviour were cloned and sequenced. Three new point mutations were detected by this strategy. A G to C (Asp409 to His409) substitution was present in two Type 1 and one Type 3 GD patients; an A to T transversion (Asp409 to Val409) was detected in only a single Type 3 individual, and a G to T mutation (Val394 to Leu394) was present in one Type 1 and one Type 3 patient. GD thus exhibits extensive molecular heterogeneity, with at least five single base mutations in beta-Glc exon 9. In every case verified by ASO hybridization, DGGE had correctly identified the presence of the three new mutations, as well as the two previously described exon 9 mutations. In comparison, although RNase A and the chemical method were both able to detect some of these mutations, neither method reproducibly detected all of them. Additionally, DGGE was the only method that was able to reliably determine whether a given mutation was present homozygously or heterozygously. These results suggest that GC-clamped DGGE may be a more reliable and informative screening method for point mutation detection.

Rapid chemical mapping of dengue virus variability using RNA isolated directly from cells

Osmium tetroxide and hydroxylamine (in combination with piperidine) have previously been shown to cleave mismatched T and C bases, respectively, in DNA.DNA heteroduplexes. In this work we report that mismatched T and C bases were similarly cleaved in DNA.RNA heteroduplexes of nucleic acids derived from different strains of dengue virus type 2. Further, some matched T or C bases one or two bases from mismatches were also chemically reactive and thus cleavable as detected by minor bands. Cleavages both at and near mismatches combined to generate a simply obtained pattern of difference between virus strains that could be used as a fingerprint of a given virus relative to another. The patterns obtained using viral RNA of one strain hybridized with the cDNA of another were similar for RNA prepared from purified virions and for total RNA extracted from infected cells. Use of probes of both senses should detect all differences. Two sequenced (NGC and PUO-218) and one unsequenced (D80-100) strains of virus were compared in these studies. The analyses allowed proof reading of the differences between NGC and PUO-218, ascertained from nucleotide sequencing, and demonstrated that D80-100 is more similar to PUO-218 than to NGC.

Temperature-gradient gel electrophoresis of nucleic acids: analysis of conformational transitions, sequence variations, and protein-nucleic acid interactions

Temperature-gradient gel electrophoresis (TGGE) is applied to analyze conformational transitions and sequence variations of nucleic acids and protein-nucleic acid interactions. A linear and highly reproducible temperature-gradient is established perpendicular or parallel to the direction of the electrophoresis. The instrument consists of an electrically insulated metal plate, which is heated at one edge and cooled at the other edge by two thermostating baths and is used as an ancillary device for commercial horizontal gel electrophoresis instruments. Biopolymers are separated in TGGE according to size, shape and thermal stability of their conformational transitions. If the temperature-gradient is established perpendicular to the electrophoresis, monomolecular conformational transitions of nucleic acids show up as continuous transition curves; strand-separation leads to discontinuous transitions. In the studies on viroid RNA it was shown that natural circular viroid RNA undergoes one highly cooperative transition detected by TGGE as a drastic retardation in mobility. Oligomeric replication intermediates of viroids exhibit coexisting structures which could not be detected by any other technique. Double-stranded satellite RNA from cucumber mosaic virus is a mixture of sequence variants, all of which have the identical length of 335 nucleotides. In TGGE six different strains were resolved. Sequence variants of viroids were analyzed by hybridizing viroid RNA to (-)strand viroid RNA transcripts from viroid cDNA clones. Sequence variations lead to mismatches in the double strands and thereby to a shift of the transition curve to lower temperature. Mutations in plasmids, particularly in cloned inserts, were detected by mixing plasmids of two different clones, linearizing, denaturing, renaturing, and searching for shifts in the transition curves, which are generated by mismatch-formation during the renaturation of (+)- and (-)strands from different clones. Examples are given for different viroid clones and HIV-clones from one and the same patient. In another example, clones with point mutations from site-directed mutagenesis are analyzed and selected by TGGE. TGGE is also applied to study the effect of amino acid exchanges in the Tet repressor from E. coli on the thermal stability of the repressor and on the mode of binding of the repressor to the operator DNA. The results are discussed under the aspect that TGGE may be applied as routine analytical laboratory procedure.

Detection of single-base mutations in DNA molecules using the solution melting method

RNA molecules that differ by a single base pair in their highest melting domain can be separated by the solution melting method (Smith et al., 1988) due to sequence-specific melting properties of double-stranded (ds) RNA heteroduplexes. We now show that this method can be used to reliably detect single base pair differences in DNA molecules, and we define the upper limit of the high melting domain length that can be analyzed by this method for dsRNA and RNA-DNA molecules as about 250 bp and 130 bp, respectively. The usefulness of this method to detect point mutations in human genomic DNA is evaluated. X-linked genes are most amenable to study, because results are most easily interpretable when only a single allele is present. Using the human factor VIII gene as an example, we show this method is capable of detecting polymorphisms present in genomic DNA after amplification by the polymerase chain reaction. This technique should prove useful in the simultaneous rapid screening of multiple exons of X-linked genes for single-base mutations.

Novel method of detecting single base substitutions in RNA molecules by differential melting behavior in solution

We have developed a quick and reliable way of detecting point mutations in RNA molecules. This method involves melting RNA-RNA heteroduplexes of varying lengths in a series of tubes containing a stepwise salt or formamide gradient, followed by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis to distinguish between single- and double-stranded RNA molecules. The manipulations required are technically simple, and the method is sensitive enough to detect destabilization of the highest melting domain of a dsRNA duplex by a single base mismatch. When this method is used in parallel with denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis, which detects point mutations in low-melting domains of duplexes, it should now be possible to rapidly screen for mutations located throughout the length of any RNA molecule whose wild-type sequence is known.

Determination of the mutation rate of a retrovirus

The mutation rate of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) was measured. Progeny descended from a single virion were collected after one replication cycle, and seven regions of the genome were analyzed for mutations by denaturing-gradient gel electrophoresis. In all, 65,250 nucleotides were screened, yielding nine mutations, and the RSV mutation rate was calculated as 1.4 x 10(-4) mutations per nucleotide per replication cycle. These results indicate that RSV is an extremely mutable virus. We speculate that the mutation rate of a virus may correlate inversely with the effectiveness of vaccination against a given virus and suggest that prevention of retrovirus-mediated disease via vaccination may prove difficult.

Analysis of genetic variability and mapping of point mutations in influenza virus by the RNase A mismatch cleavage method

We have applied the RNase A mismatch cleavage method to analyze genetic variability in RNA viruses by using influenza virus as a model system. Uniformly labeled RNA probes synthesized from a cloned hemagglutinin gene of a given viral strain were hybridized to RNA isolated from other strains of characterized or uncharacterized genetic composition. The RNA.RNA heteroduplexes containing a variable number of base mismatches were digested with RNase A, and the resistant products were analyzed by denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. We show that many of these single base mismatches are cleaved by RNase A, generating unique and characteristic patterns of resistant RNA fragments specific for each of the different viral strains. Comparative analysis of the cleavage patterns allows a qualitative estimation of the genetic relatedness and evolution of field strains. We also show that cleavage by RNase A at single base mismatches can readily detect and localize point mutations present in monoclonal antibody-resistant variants. This method should have wide applications in the study of RNA viruses, not only for epidemiological analysis but also in some diagnostic problems, such as characterization of phenotypic mutants.

Alterations in DNA helix stability due to base modifications can be evaluated using denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis

DNA molecules that differ by a single base-pair can be separated by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis due to the sequence-specific melting properties of DNA. Base modifications such as methylation are also known to affect the melting temperature of DNA. We examined the final position of DNA fragments containing either 5-methyl-cytosine or 6-methyl-adenine in denaturing gradient gels. The presence of a single methylated base within an early melting domain resulted in a well-resolved shift in fragment position relative to the unmethylated sequence. In addition, fragments containing hemimethylated and fully methylated sites could be distinguished, and a proportionally larger shift was observed with an increasing number of methylated bases. Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis thus provides a sensitive method for analyzing the methylation state of DNA, which is not dependent on the presence of restriction enzyme cleavage sites. We also demonstrate that denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis can be used to obtain a quantitative estimate of the change in helix stability caused by modification of one or two bases in a complex DNA sequence. Such estimates should allow more accurate modeling of melting of natural DNA sequences.

Genomic RNAs of influenza viruses are held in a circular conformation in virions and in infected cells by a terminal panhandle

The viral RNA segments in influenza virions were shown to be circular in conformation by using psoralen crosslinking methods. Electron microscopy of purified RNA following treatment of virus with the psoralen reagent 4'-aminomethyltrioxsalen (AMT) revealed circles with lengths corresponding to the individual segments. RNA blot analysis using polyacrylamide gels demonstrated that RNA from AMT-treated virus had a slowed migration, consistent with it being a single-stranded circle. Furthermore, nuclease S1 protection assays indicated that the termini of the RNA segments form an approximately 15-base-pair-long panhandle. This structure is consistent with the partial sequence complementarity that has been observed for the termini of all influenza virus RNAs. By RNA blot analysis, circular structures of viral sense RNA were also found in influenza virus-infected cells at early and late time points. The circular RNA was the predominant species at the time when the major transcription product is message RNA. This finding and the observation that the termination signal for mRNA synthesis directly abuts the panhandle suggest that a panhandle in the template viral RNA is a cis regulatory signal promoting the synthesis of mRNA instead of plus-sense template. Also, since the panhandle is present in high concentration in virions, we suggest that it is required for packaging and that the input RNA after infection is in the proper conformation for synthesis of primary transcripts.

Temperature-gradient gel electrophoresis. Thermodynamic analysis of nucleic acids and proteins in purified form and in cellular extracts

A temperature-gradient gel electrophoresis technique and its application to the study of structural transitions of nucleic acids and protein-nucleic acid complexes are described. The temperature gradient is established in a slab gel by means of a simple ancillary device for a commercial horizontal gel apparatus. The gradient may be freely selected between 10 and 80 degrees C, and is highly reproducible and linear. In a normal application the biopolymers migrate perpendicular to the temperature gradient so that every individual molecule is at constant temperature throughout electrophoresis. The structural transition of a biopolymer is seen as a continuous band which is retarded or speeded up in the temperature range of the transition. Dissociation processes are mostly irreversible under the conditions of electrophoresis and, therefore, show up as discontinuous transitions from a slow-moving to fast-moving band. As examples the conformational transitions of viroids, double-stranded RNA from reovirus, double-stranded satellite RNA from cucumber mosaic virus and repressor-operator complexes have been studied. It could be shown that by this method dsRNA molecules may be differentiated which differ only in one base-pair, or proteins differing in one amino acid only. As a particular advantage, temperature-gradient gel electrophoresis allows the study of conformational transitions of biopolymers which have not been purified. The biopolymer may either be identified by silver staining as a specific band among many others or, if the study is carried out on nucleic acids, these may be recorded by hybridization with a radioactive probe.