Base analogs in study of restriction enzyme-DNA interactions

Type II restriction endonucleases--a historical perspective and more

This article continues the series of Surveys and Summaries on restriction endonucleases (REases) begun this year in Nucleic Acids Research. Here we discuss 'Type II' REases, the kind used for DNA analysis and cloning. We focus on their biochemistry: what they are, what they do, and how they do it. Type II REases are produced by prokaryotes to combat bacteriophages. With extreme accuracy, each recognizes a particular sequence in double-stranded DNA and cleaves at a fixed position within or nearby. The discoveries of these enzymes in the 1970s, and of the uses to which they could be put, have since impacted every corner of the life sciences. They became the enabling tools of molecular biology, genetics and biotechnology, and made analysis at the most fundamental levels routine. Hundreds of different REases have been discovered and are available commercially. Their genes have been cloned, sequenced and overexpressed. Most have been characterized to some extent, but few have been studied in depth. Here, we describe the original discoveries in this field, and the properties of the first Type II REases investigated. We discuss the mechanisms of sequence recognition and catalysis, and the varied oligomeric modes in which Type II REases act. We describe the surprising heterogeneity revealed by comparisons of their sequences and structures.

Mechanism of CpG DNA methyltransferases M.SssI and Dnmt3a studied by DNA containing 2-aminopurine

Murine DNA methyltransferases Dnmt3a-CD and M.SssI from Spiroplasma methylate cytosines at CpG sites. The role of 6-oxo groups of guanines in DNA methylation by these enzymes has been studied using DNA substrates, which contained 2-aminopurine at different positions. Removal of the 6-oxo group of the guanine located adjacent to the target cytosine in the CpG site dramatically reduces the stability of the methyltransferase-DNA complexes and leads to a significant decrease in the methylation. Apparently, O6 of this guanine is involved in the recognition of CpG sites by the enzymes. Cooperative binding of Dnmt3a-CD to 2-aminopurine-containing DNA and the formation of nonproductive enzyme-substrate complexes were observed.

Oxidative DNA Strand Scission Induced by a Trinuclear Copper(II) Complex

A novel trinuclear copper(II) complex, Cu3-L (L = N,N,N',N',N' ',N' '-hexakis(2-pyridyl)-1,3,5-tris(aminomethyl)benzene), exhibited efficient oxidative strand scission of plasmid DNA. The solution behavior of the complex has been studied by potentiometric titration, UV spectroscopy, and cyclic voltammetry. The data showed that there are three redox-active copper ions in the complex with three types of bound water. The complex demonstrated a moderate binding ability for DNA. Cu3-L readily cleaves plasmid DNA in the presence of ascorbate to give nicked (form II) and then linear (form III) products, while the cleavage efficiency using H2O2 is less than by ascorbate, suggesting that the cleavage mode of the trinuclear complex is somewhat different from the traditional Fenton-like catalysis. Meanwhile, Cu3-L is far more efficient than its mononuclear analogue Cu-DPA (DPA = 2,2'-dipyridylamine) at the same [Cu2+] concentration, which suggests a possible synergy between the three or at least two Cu(II) centers in Cu3-L that contributes to its relatively high nucleolytic efficiency. Furthermore, the presence of standard radical scavengers does not have clear effect on the cleavage efficiency, suggesting the reactive intermediates leading to DNA cleavage are not freely diffusible radicals.

2-Pyrimidinone as a probe for studying the EcoRII DNA methyltransferase-substrate interaction

EcoRII DNA methyltransferase (M.EcoRII) recognizes the 5' em leader CC*T/AGG em leader 3' DNA sequence and catalyzes the transfer of the methyl group from S-adenosyl-l-methionine to the C5 position of the inner cytosine residue (C*). Here, we study the mechanism of inhibition of M.EcoRII by DNA containing 2-pyrimidinone, a cytosine analogue lacking an NH(2) group at the C4 position of the pyrimidine ring. Also, DNA containing 2-pyrimidinone was used for probing contacts of M.EcoRII with functional groups of pyrimidine bases of the recognition sequence. 2-Pyrimidinone was incorporated into the 5' em leader CCT/AGG em leader 3' sequence replacing the target and nontarget cytosine and central thymine residues. Study of the DNA stability using thermal denaturation of 2-pyrimidinone containing duplexes pointed to the influence of the bases adjacent to 2-pyrimidinone and to a greater destabilizing influence of 2-pyrimidinone substitution for thymine than that for cytosine. Binding of M.EcoRII to 2-pyrimidinone containing DNA and methylation of these DNA demonstrate that the amino group of the outer cytosine in the EcoRII recognition sequence is not involved in the DNA-M.EcoRII interaction. It is probable that there are contacts between the functional groups of the central thymine exposed in the major groove and M.EcoRII. 2-Pyrimidinone replacing the target cytosine in the EcoRII recognition sequence forms covalent adducts with M.EcoRII. In the absence of the cofactor S-adenosyl-l-methionine, proton transfer to the C5 position of 2-pyrimidinone occurs and in the presence of S-adenosyl-l-methionine, methyl transfer to the C5 position of 2-pyrimidinone occurs.

Role of DNA minor groove interactions in substrate recognition by the M.SinI and M.EcoRII DNA (cytosine-5) methyltransferases

The SinI and EcoRII DNA methyltransferases recognize sequences (GG(A)/(T)CC and CC(A)/(T)GG, respectively), which are characterized by an (A)/(T) ambiguity. Recognition of the A.T and T.A base pair was studied by in vitro methyltransferase assays using oligonucleotide substrates containing a hypoxanthine.C base pair in the central position of the recognition sequence. Both enzymes methylated the substituted oligonucleotide with an efficiency that was comparable to methylation of the canonical substrate. These observations indicate that M.SinI and M.EcoRII discriminate between their canonical recognition site and the site containing a G.C or a C.G base pair in the center of the recognition sequence (GG(G)/(C)CC and CC(G)/(C)GG, respectively) by interaction(s) in the DNA minor groove. M.SinI mutants displaying a decreased capacity to discriminate between the GG(A)/(T)CC and GG(G)/(C)CC sequences were isolated by random mutagenesis and selection for the relaxed specificity phenotype. These mutations led to amino acid substitutions outside the variable region, previously thought to be the sole determinant of sequence specificity. These observations indicate that (A)/(T) versus (G)/(C) discrimination is mediated by interactions between the large domain of the methyltransferase and the minor groove surface of the DNA.

Substrate binding in vitro and kinetics of RsrI [N6-adenine] DNA methyltransferase

RSR:I [N:6-adenine] DNA methyltransferase (M.RSR:I), which recognizes GAATTC and is a member of a restriction-modification system in Rhodobacter sphaeroides, was purified to >95% homogeneity using a simplified procedure involving two ion exchange chromatographic steps. Electrophoretic gel retardation assays with purified M.RSR:I were performed on unmethylated, hemimethylated, dimethylated or non-specific target DNA duplexes (25 bp) in the presence of sinefungin, a potent inhibitory analog of AdoMet. M. RSR:I binding was affected by the methylation status of the DNA substrate and was enhanced by the presence of the cofactor analog. M. RSR:I bound DNA substrates in the presence of sinefungin with decreasing affinities: hemimethylated > unmethylated > dimethylated >> non-specific DNA. Gel retardation studies with DNA substrates containing an abasic site substituted for the target adenine DNA provided evidence consistent with M.RSR:I extruding the target base from the duplex. Consistent with such base flipping, an approximately 1.7-fold fluorescence intensity increase was observed upon stoichiometric addition of M.RSR:I to hemimethylated DNA containing the fluorescent analog 2-aminopurine in place of the target adenine. Pre-steady-state kinetic and isotope- partitioning experiments revealed that the enzyme displays burst kinetics, confirmed the catalytic competence of the M.RSR:I-AdoMet complex and eliminated the possibility of an ordered mechanism where DNA is required to bind first. The equilibrium dissociation constants for AdoMet, AdoHcy and sinefungin were determined using an intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence-quenching assay.

DNA duplexes containing altered sugar residues as probes of EcoRII and MvaI endonuclease interactions with sugar-phosphate backbone

Oligonucleotides containing 1-(beta-D-2'-deoxy-threo-pentofuranosyl)cytosine (dCx) and/or 1-(beta-D-2'-deoxy-threo-pentofuranosyl)thymine (dTx) in place of dC and dT residues in the EcoRII and MvaI recognition site CC(A/T)GG were synthesized in order to investigate specific recognition of the DNA sugar-phosphate backbone by EcoRII and MvaI restriction endonucleases. In 2'-deoxyxylosyl moieties of dCx and dTx, 3'-hydroxyl groups were inverted, which perturbs the related individual phosphates. Introduction of a single 2'-deoxyxylosyl moiety into a dC x dG pair resulted in a minor destabilization of double-stranded DNA structure. In the case of a dA x dT pair the effect of a 2'-deoxyxylose incorporation was much more pronounced. Multiple dCx modifications and their combination with dTx did not enhance the destabilization effect. Hydrolysis of dCx-containing DNA duplexes by EcoRII endonuclease was blocked and binding affinity was strongly depended on the location of an altered sugar. A DNA duplex containing a dTx residue was cleaved by the enzyme, but kcat/K(M) was slightly reduced. In contrast, MvaI endonuclease efficiently cleaved both types of sugar-altered substrate analogs. However it did not cleave conformationally perturbed scissile bonds, when the corresponding unmodified bonds were perfectly hydrolyzed in the same DNA duplexes. Based on these data the possible contributions of individual phosphates in the recognition site to substrate recognition and catalysis by EcoRII were proposed. We observed strikingly non-equivalent inputs for different phosphates with respect to their effect on EcoRII-DNA complex formation.

BanI restriction endonuclease binds in the major groove of DNA: an inhibition kinetic study using substrates with mismatch basepairs

Structural information on BanI-DNA interaction was obtained from simple inhibition kinetic assays using altered substrates. Self-complementary 13-mer oligodeoxynucleotides with or without mismatch basepairs in the BanI recognition sequence (GGPyPuCC) were synthesized. UV melting curves and CD spectra indicated double-stranded B-DNA structure for all the oligomers. Among the seven oligomers with recognition sequences, GGTACC, GGTGCC, GGTATC, GGCACC, GGAGCC, GGTAAC, and GGATCC, only the first two were cleaved with BanI. Kinetics of BanI cleavage of the native substrate was inhibited competitively by all of the other oligomers except the one with sequence GGCACC. From inhibition kinetic analysis in presence of a fixed concentration of the inhibitor, apparent K(m) and K(I) were determined. The data were analyzed in the context of alterations made in the hydrogen bonding potential in the major and minor groove of DNA within the recognition sequence due to basepair mismatches. Such analyses led to the conclusion that BanI, like BamHI, binds in the major groove and the central thymines make important contact with the protein.

Solution structure of a DNA duplex containing a replicable difluorotoluene-adenine pair

A nonpolar aromatic nucleoside derivative based on 2,4-difluorotoluene (F), a non-hydrogen bonding shape analog of thymidine, was recently shown to be replicated against adenine with high efficiency and fidelity. This led to the suggestion that geometric matching, potentially even in the absence of hydrogen bonding between bases in a pair, may be sufficient to direct nucleotide selection during replication. We have examined the solution structure of the F-A pair in the context of a 12 base pair DNA duplex. We find that, despite the destabilization caused by this analog, the F-A pair very closely resembles that of a T x A pair in the same context. This lends support to the importance of shape matching in replication.

Modified oligonucleotides: synthesis and strategy for users

Synthetic oligonucleotide analogs have greatly aided our understanding of several biochemical processes. Efficient solid-phase and enzyme-assisted synthetic methods and the availability of modified base analogs have added to the utility of such oligonucleotides. In this review, we discuss the applications of synthetic oligonucleotides that contain backbone, base, and sugar modifications to investigate the mechanism and stereochemical aspects of biochemical reactions. We also discuss interference mapping of nucleic acid-protein interactions; spectroscopic analysis of biochemical reactions and nucleic acid structures; and nucleic acid cross-linking studies. The automation of oligonucleotide synthesis, the development of versatile phosphoramidite reagents, and efficient scale-up have expanded the application of modified oligonucleotides to diverse areas of fundamental and applied biological research. Numerous reports have covered oligonucleotides for which modifications have been made of the phosphodiester backbone, of the purine and pyrimidine heterocyclic bases, and of the sugar moiety; these modifications serve as structural and mechanistic probes. In this chapter, we review the range, scope, and practical utility of such chemically modified oligonucleotides. Because of space limitations, we discuss only those oligonucleotides that contain phosphate and phosphate analogs as internucleotidic linkages.

Binding of daunomycin to diaminopurine- and/or inosine-substituted DNA

The binding of the anticancer drug daunomycin to double-helical DNA has been investigated by DNase I footprinting and fluorescence titration, using a series of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) synthesized DNA fragments that contained systematic base substitutions to alter the disposition of functional groups within the minor groove. The 160 bp tyrT DNA fragment constituted the starting material. Fragments in which (i) inosine was substituted for guanosine, (ii) diaminopurine was substituted for adenine, and (iii) both inosine and diaminopurine were substituted for guanosine and adenine, respectively, were studied. These fragments permit the role of the 2-amino group in the minor groove to be systematically explored. The results of DNase I footprinting experiments confirmed that daunomycin binds preferentially to 5'(A/T)GC and 5'(A/T)CG triplets in the normal fragment. Substitution of inosine for guanosine, with the concomitant loss of the N-2 in the minor groove, weakened binding affinity but did not dramatically alter the sequence preference associated with daunomycin binding. Complete reversal of the location of the N-2 group by the double substitution, however, completely altered the sequence preference of daunomycin and shifted its binding from the canonical triplets to ones with a 5'IDD motif. These results have critically tested and confirmed the proposed key roles of the daunosamine moiety and the 9-OH group of daunomycin in dictating binding to preferred sites. In a parallel study, both macroscopic and microscopic binding to the normal tyrT fragment were investigated, experiments made possible by using PCR to prepare large quantities of the long, defined DNA sequence. The results of these experiments underscored the complexity of the interaction of the drug with the DNA lattice and revealed unequivocal heterogeneity in its affinity for different binding sites. A class of high-affinity sites, most probably corresponding to the 5'(A/T)GC and 5'(A/T)CG triplets, was identified and characterized in macroscopic binding isotherms.

Influence of the phosphate backbone on the recognition and hydrolysis of DNA by the EcoRV restriction endonuclease. A study using oligodeoxynucleotide phosphorothioates

A set of phosphorothioate-containing oligonucleotides based on pGACGATATCGTC, a self-complementary dodecamer that contains the EcoRV recognition sequence (GATATC), has been prepared. The phosphorothioate group has been individually introduced at the central nine phosphate positions and the two diastereomers produced at each site separated and purified. The Km and Vmax values found for each of these modified DNA molecules with the EcoRV restriction endonuclease have been determined and compared with those seen for the unmodified all-phosphate-containing dodecamer. This has enabled an evaluation of the roles that both of the non-esterified oxygen atoms in the individual phosphates play in DNA binding and hydrolysis by the endonuclease. The results have also been compared with crystal structures of the EcoRV endonuclease, complexed with an oligodeoxynucleotide, to allow further definition of phosphate group function during substrate binding and turnover. For further study, see the related article "Probing the Indirect Readout of the Restriction Enzyme EcoRV: Mutational Analysis of Contacts to the DNA Backbone" (Wenz, A., Jeltsch, A., and Pingoud, A. (1996) J. Biol. Chem. 271, 5565-5573).

Specific purine N7-nitrogens are critical for high affinity binding by the trp repressor

We have analysed the interaction of the trp repressor with the trpEDCBA operator using a series of modified trp operator sequences incorporating two isosteric purine analogues that lack N7-nitrogens. Our results suggest that as well as the direct contact between Arg69 and G-9, three additional purine N7-nitrogens, implicated in specific, water-mediated contacts to the repressor, are critical for formation of the high-affinity repressor-operator complex. We conclude that the crystal structure obtained by Otwinowski et al. reflects high-affinity sequence-specific binding of the trp repressor to the trp operator, and that in some cases proteins can use water molecules to extend amino acid side chains in order to derive favorable binding energy in complex formation.

Substrate-assisted catalysis in the cleavage of DNA by the EcoRI and EcoRV restriction enzymes

The crystal structure analyses of the EcoRI-DNA and EcoRV-DNA complexes do not provide clear suggestions as to which amino acid residues are responsible for the activation of water to carry out the DNA cleavage. Based on molecular modeling, we have proposed recently that the attacking water molecule is activated by the negatively charged pro-Rp phosphoryl oxygen of the phosphate group 3' to the scissile phosphodiester bond. We now present experimental evidence to support this proposal. (i) Oligodeoxynucleotide substrates lacking this phosphate group in one strand are cleaved only in the other strand. (ii) Oligodeoxynucleotide substrates carrying an H-phosphonate substitution at this position in both strands and, therefore, lacking a negatively charged oxygen at this position are cleaved at least four orders of magnitude more slowly than the unmodified substrate. These results are supported by other modification studies: oligodeoxynucleotide substrates with a phosphorothioate substitution at this position in both strands are cleaved only if the negatively charged sulfur is in the RP configuration as shown for EcoRI [Koziolkiewicz, M. & Stec, W.J. (1992) Biochemistry 31, 9460-9466] and EcoRV (B. A. Connolly, personal communication). As the phosphate residue 3' to the scissile phosphodiester bond is not needed for strong DNA binding by both enzymes, these findings strongly suggest that this phosphate group plays an active role during catalysis. This proposal, furthermore, gives a straightforward explanation of why in the EcoRI-DNA and EcoRV-DNA complexes the DNA is distorted differently, but in each case the 3' phosphate group closely approaches the phosphate group that is attacked. Finally, an alternative mechanism for DNA cleavage involving two metal ions is unlikely in the light of our finding that both EcoRI and EcoRV need only one Mg2+ per active site for cleavage.

Influence of enzyme-substrate contacts located outside the EcoRI recognition site on cleavage of duplex oligodeoxyribonucleotide substrates by EcoRI endonuclease

A complete understanding of the sequence-specific interaction between the EcoRI restriction endonuclease and its DNA substrate requires identification of all contacts between the enzyme and substrate, and evaluation of their significance. We have searched for possible contacts adjacent to the recognition site, GAATTC, by using a series of substrates with differing lengths of flanking sequence. Each substrate is a duplex of non-self-complementary oligodeoxyribonucleotides in which the recognition site is flanked by six base pairs on one side and from zero to three base pairs on the other. Steady-state kinetic values were determined for the cleavage of each strand of these duplexes. A series of substrates in which the length of flanking sequence was varied on both sides of the hexamer was also examined. The enzyme cleaved both strands of each of the substrates. Decreasing the flanking sequence to fewer than three base pairs on one side of the recognition site induced an asymmetry in the rates of cleavage of the two strands. The scissile bond nearest the shortening sequence was hydrolyzed with increasing rapidity as base pairs were successively removed. Taken together, the KM and kcat values obtained may be interpreted to indicate the relative importance of several likely enzyme-substrate contacts located outside the canonical hexameric recognition site.