Relative refractory state for late cutaneous allergic responses

Patterns of inflammatory responses following rechallenge of skin late-phase allergic reaction sites

BACKGROUND

Previous studies have suggested altered responses to repeat skin tests in the sites of IgE-mediated late-phase reactions (LPRs) induced within the previous 48 hours. To explore the possible modulation of LPRs in such rechallenge sites, we compared inflammatory responses in skin chambers induced over previous LPR and control sites.

METHODS

Skin blisters were induced and unroofed in 12 human subjects over two sites of previous LPRs induced by intradermal injection of pollen antigens 24 hours or 48 hours earlier and two sites previously injected with buffer diluent (B). Skin chambers containing the same antigens were appended to one intradermal antigen site (called Ag/Ag) and one intradermal B site (B/Ag), and B-containing chambers were placed over antigen (Ag/B) and B (B/B) intradermal sites. Fluids were collected after the first and the second through fifth hours of challenge.

RESULTS

In skin chamber challenges 24 hours after the intradermal injection, there was no significant difference after the first hours between the Ag/Ag or B/Ag sites in either histamine or tryptase levels; both were significantly higher than at Ag/B or B/B sites (p < 0.01). The same pattern of events was seen in fluids obtained from the second through fifth hours. The same pattern of findings was seen in examination of levels of the total leukocyte accumulation, total eosinophil accumulation, and frequency of activated (EG2+) eosinophils. Levels of lactoferrin, released from activated neutrophils, and eosinophil cationic protein, released from activated eosinophils, were also similar at Ag/Ag and B/Ag sites; both were significantly higher than at B/B sites, whereas levels at Ag/B sites were intermediate between those found at B/Ag and B/B sites. The pattern of events in skin chamber challenges 48 hours after intradermal injection was similar to that seen at 24 hours, except that levels of inflammatory mediators/cells in Ag/B sites were more intermediate between the B/Ag and B/B sites.

CONCLUSION

There is no significant alteration of mediator or inflammatory cell responses after antigen rechallenge of previous LPR sites when compared with those found in antigen challenge of non-LPR sites.

Effect of local allergen priming on early, late, delayed-phase, and epicutaneous skin reactions

Allergic disease is reflected in a chronic inflammatory response to an allergen. It is thought that local allergen priming underlies this chronicity. To assess the effect of allergen priming on the amplitude and histologic effect of the allergic reaction, four sequential, intracutaneous skin tests were done with 48-h intervals in 13 patients allergic to the house-dust mite Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus (Dpt). Reactions were measured at 15 min, and at 6, 24, and 48 h. Subsequently, epicutaneous tests were done on Dpt-primed spots (n = 5). At 6, 24, and 48 h, reactions increased after priming (P < 0.006), with unaltered early reactions. Epicutaneous reactions to Dpt on primed spots were larger than in epicutaneous controls on similarly primed skin. Local intradermal priming results in greater inflammatory responses at both intra- and epicutaneous challenge. This mechanism may explain the chronicity of allergic reactions at epithelial surfaces.

Inhibition of anti-IgE induced skin response in normals by formoterol, a new beta 2-adrenoceptor agonist, and terbutaline. 2. Effect on the late phase reaction

Formoterol, a new beta 2-selective long-acting bronchodilator, was compared with terbutaline in terms of ability to inhibit dual phase skin reactions to anti-human IgE in volunteers. Anti-IgE induced an early wheal and flare reaction (WFR) followed by a progressively increasing induration, the late phase reaction (LCR), lasting greater than or equal to 24 h. Intradermal injection of formoterol 20 ng or terbutaline 500 ng 5 min before challenge gave equal inhibition of the WFR. The subsequent LCR was suppressed by formoterol (30%) for the whole 24 h period, while terbutaline only attenuated the first 4 h period. Increasing the dose range of both drugs 25-fold, caused a further analogous reduction of the WFR to anti-IgE. In this higher dose range formoterol (0.5 micrograms) antagonized the following 1-24 h LCR by 50%, while terbutaline (25 micrograms) only attenuated the LCR by an average of 20%, with higher effect in the first 6 h period. The anti-LCR capacity of formoterol was highly superior to that of terbutaline (P less than 0.001). The histamine-elicited wheal response was attenuated by both drugs, but they had no effect on the flare response, favouring an anti-permeability action of both compounds. The data support the concept that terbutaline, given locally in a single dose shortly before challenge, inhibits the mast cell mediator release reaction with limited consequences for the following LCR. In contrast to terbutaline, formoterol exerted a substantial anti-LCR action, probably by interfering with inflammatory mechanisms after the initial mast cell mediator release.

Interactions between histamine and prostanoids in IgE-dependent, late cutaneous reactions in man

The contribution of histamine and cyclooxygenase metabolites of arachidonic acid to the wheal-and-flare reaction (WFR) (0 to 30 minutes) and the late cutaneous reaction (LCR) (1 to 24 hours) evoked by intradermal injection of antihuman IgE was appreciated in a comprehensive study of human volunteers treated with H1 and H2 antihistamines, cyclooxygenase inhibitors, as well as the combination of both types of drugs. The findings reinforce the concept that histamine is the major, but not exclusive, mediator of the WFR. In contrast, histamine accounted for but a limited portion of the LCR, but 48 hours of pretreatment with three different cyclooxygenase inhibitors, acetylsalicylic acid, indomethacin, or diclofenac sodium, had but a minor influence on the WFR, whereas all drugs produced a distinct overall inhibition of the LCR. However, for indomethacin, the inhibition was preceded by a potentiation (at 1 to 2 hours), which was abolished by antihistamines, suggesting increased histamine release from skin mast cells after cyclooxygenase inhibition. Furthermore, there was synergism between indomethacin and antihistamines during the LCR, and the combination of diclofenac sodium with antihistamines produced additive inhibition. It is proposed that cyclooxygenase products, such as prostaglandins and thromboxanes, contribute to IgE-dependent skin reactions, both as modulators of mediator release and as vasoactive mediators.

Increased bronchial reactivity and potentiated skin responses in hypertensive subjects suffering from coughs during ACE-inhibitor therapy

The aim of this study was to investigate whether ACE-inhibitors could influence bronchial reactivity and interfere with inflammatory skin responses. Ten hypertensive subjects, who had reacted with coughs during ACE-inhibitor therapy, were treated in a double-blind crossover fashion for two weeks with enalapril and with placebo. Enalapril reduced the PC20 value for histamine and augmented the dermal response. Circulating eosinophilic leukocyte level in venous blood dropped markedly after the histamine bronchoprovocation performed during enalapril treatment. Plasma substance P was reduced after histamine provocation performed during placebo treatment, whereas this reduction was abolished by enalapril. In this study, we have demonstrated ACE-inhibitor-induction of moderately increased bronchial reactivity in subjects with suspected ACE-inhibitor-elicited coughs. It is suggested that coughing during ACE-inhibitor therapy is due to an increased inflammatory state in the airways.

Immediate and late phase allergic cutaneous reactions are not inducers of unspecific or specific local hyperreactivity

The present study evaluates the possibility of allergen-induced unspecific and specific dermal hyperreactivity with special reference to the presence of late cutaneous reactions and allergen-induced nasal hyperreactivity. Twenty-six patients with strictly seasonal allergic rhinitis participated. All had a positive skin prick test for birch (Betula verrucosa) and/or timothy (Phleum pratense). Ten patients had previously displayed an allergen-induced nasal hyperreactivity and six patients a late cutaneous reaction. An initial skin prick test with a relevant pollen allergen was done in triplicate. The immediate skin reactions were recorded after 15 min and any late-phase reaction after 6 h. Twenty-four hours later the patients were retested. The same pollen allergen was sited in the first flare reaction from the previous day. A histamine prick test was sited in the weal as well as in the third reaction from day 1. A histamine control was also performed in a previously unaffected area. The allergen-induced weal reactions decreased significantly at rechallenge compared with the results from the previous day (P less than 0.05). The histamine tests resulted in similar skin reactions regardless of whether or not they were done on a previous allergen test site. This was true for both specific and unspecific reactions when the subgroups of patients with previously demonstrated allergen-induced nasal hyperreactivity or late-phase skin reactions were evaluated separately. These results indicate that allergen-induced hyperreactivity is not a general feature of allergic inflammation but is a phenomenon restricted to specific sites, such as the airway mucosa.

Early/late response model: implications for control of asthma and chronic cough in children

The observed airways inflammation in asthma and chronic cough supports the conclusions of clinical trials, namely, that our treatment regimens should emphasize inhaled cromolyn. The need for bronchodilators as backup therapy is real but represents testimony to the fact that in some cases it has not been possible to entirely eliminate the inflammation and the consequent airways hyperresponsiveness.

Allergen-induced hyperreactivity is not a feature of dermal immediate allergic reactions--in contrast to reactions of airways mucosa

Allergen challenges of airway mucosa are commonly followed by an increased sensitivity to rechallenge with allergen. In the lower airways this phenomenon has been associated with the late phase of allergic airway reactions, which in turn has been suggested as a link between anaphylaxis and continuous allergic airway disease. The aim of the present investigation was to explore further the phenomenon of allergen-induced hyperreactivity and to see whether it was possible to induce such a reaction in the skin. Twenty-six patients with seasonal allergic rhinitis due to birch and/or grass pollens were studied in the pollen-free winter months. Nine of these patients had previously demonstrated an increased reactivity following allergen challenge in the nose, and nine of the patients had cutaneous allergen-induced late-phase reactions to the allergen tested. Skin-prick tests were performed with pollen allergen, histamine, and a negative control. The areas of the weal-and-flare reactions were measured 15 min after the tests were set. Any late-phase reactions were recorded 6 hr after the skin challenge. The subjects were re-tested with allergen and histamine 24 hr after the initial prick test within the area of the corresponding weal from the previous day. In contrast to previous challenges of human airway mucosa, where the same time interval was used, we found no increased responsiveness to rechallenge as compared with the initial allergen challenge. This was true, even if only the subgroups with previously demonstrated nasal allergen-induced hyperreactivity, or cutaneous late-phase reaction were evaluated.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Prediction of late asthmatic responses to inhaled allergen

Relationships between cutaneous and bronchial responses to allergen were examined in nineteen atopic asthmatics. Allergen inhalation tests elicited an isolated early asthmatic response (EAR) in ten subjects and a dual asthmatic response (DAR) in nine subjects. Ragweed IgE RAST, performed with the sera of those patients tested with ragweed antigen, yielded higher values in all but one patient who experienced DAR than any of the patients with EAR. In one patient with annual symptoms in the ragweed season, positive skin tests with ragweed antigen and DAR to inhaled ragweed extracts, the IgE RAST was entirely negative and the serum IgE concentration was low. Dilutions of the allergen used in each individual for inhalation were also used in skin-prick tests. Early cutaneous allergic response (ECAR) mean wheal diameters were obtained at 10 min and late cutaneous allergic response (LCAR) mean diameters at 6-8 hr. Early asthmatic response (EAR) subjects differed modestly from DAR subjects in the relationships between ECAR and LCAR; in the EAR group, a significantly larger wheal diameter (P less than 0.01) was required before an LCAR ensued, however there was some overlap. Once LCAR developed, there was no difference between EAR and DAR groups in the magnitude of the LCAR. There was a trend (not significant) towards a requirement for a higher antigen concentration in the EAR group to elicit an LCAR.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Inhibition of the late phase reaction to anti-IgE by previous mast cell activation with compound 48/80

The concept of an obligate association between mast cell activation and development of a late phase reaction (LPR) to various agents in human skin was further elucidated. Skin sites were treated four times at 24 h intervals with non-LPR-inducing doses of the histamine liberator compound 48/80 in 10 volunteers. The previously compound 48/80-challenged sites responded with an approximately 40% attenuated early response (P less than 0.01) and a 70% reduction of the LPR (P less than 0.001) to subsequently injected anti-IgE as compared with simultaneous reactions at control sites. The data suggest that mediators from the cutaneous mast cells are necessary for the final expression of an LPR.

Suppression of immediate and late anti-IgE-induced skin reactions by topically applied alcohol/onion extract

In a double blind study, alcohol/onion extract (5% ethanol) was injected simultaneously with 20 IU and 200 IU rabbit anti-human-IgE intradermally in 12 adult volunteers (6 atopics, 6 non-atopics). Diameters of wheals and flares were measured 10 min after and compared with control sites challenged with 20 IU and 200 IU anti-IgE in a 5% ethanol solution. The skin sites were then treated epidermally with 45% alcohol/onion extract and 45% ethanol under occlusion. Diameters of late cutaneous reactions were measured hourly. Oedema formation was clinically estimated according to an arbitrary scale and skin thickness measured with a calliper. In the onion-treated skin sites the wheal areas were significantly reduced (20 IU: control: 108 +/- 53 mm2; onion 69 +/- 42 mm2, P less than 0.05; 200 IU anti-IgE: control: 152 +/- 25 mm2, onion: 138 +/- 26 mm2, P less than 0.02). The oedema formation during the late phase skin reaction was markedly depressed (P less than 0.005 at 2 h, P less than 0.01 at 4 and 6 h, P less than 0.02 at 8 h). The extent of late skin reactions was slightly, but not significantly reduced. Obviously, onions contain pharmacologically active substances with anti-inflammatory and/or allergic properties.

Effect of topical indomethacin on allergen-induced dual skin reactions

Twelve asthmatics with dual bronchial and skin reactions after allergen challenge received topical treatment with a 5%-indomethacin cream half an hour before and up to 7 h after intradermal allergen and histamine injections. The erythema during the first 20 min of the wheal and flare reaction (WFR) was not affected, neither were the diameters of wheals and flares. 40 to 60 min after injection we observed a marked reduction of the erythema in histamine- and allergen-tested skin areas of 10 patients. This effect lasted up to the 5th h after injection of high allergen doses. During the fully developed late cutaneous reactions (LCR) no effect of indomethacin on the erythema was observed, the edema of LCR was only insignificantly reduced. These results suggest that the erythema in LCR between the 1st and 4th h is caused, at least in part, by local formation of prostaglandins.