Methyl methanesulphonate (MMS) is clearly mutagenic in S. typhimurium strain TA1535; a comparison with strain TA100

In vitro induction of micronuclei by monofunctional methanesulphonic acid esters

Six monofunctional alkylating methanesulphonates of widely varying structures were investigated in the in vitro micronucleus assay with Syrian hamster embryo fibroblast cells. The results were compared with the alkylating activities measured in the 4-(nitrobenzyl)pyridine test (NBP-test) and the N-methyl mercaptoimidazole (MMI-test) as measures for S(N)2 reactivity as well as in the triflouoroacetic acid (TFA) solvolysis and the hydrolysis reaction as measures for S(N)1 reactivity in order to provide insights into the role of alkylation mechanisms on induction of micronuclei. Moreover we compared the results of micronucleus assay with those of the Ames tests in strain TA 100 and TA1535 and with those of the SOS chromotest with the strains PQ37, PQ243, PM21 and GC 4798. The potency of methanesulphonates to induce micronuclei depended only to a certain degree, on the total alkylating activity (S(N)1 and S(N)2 reactivity). An inverse, significant correlation between the Ames test and the micronucleus assay was observed and an inverse correlation between the micronucleus assay and the SOS chromotest with the different strains. The results indicate that the primary mechanism leading to induction of micronuclei is not O-alkylation in DNA as it is the case in the Ames test with the hisG46 strains TA1535 and TA100 and not N-alkylation as with the SOS chromotest. There is evidence that protein alkylation, e.g. in the spindle apparatus in mitosis is decisive for induction of micronuclei by alkylating compounds. The structurally voluminous methanesulphonates 2-phenyl ethyl methanesulphonate and 1-phenyl-2-propyl methanesulphonate show a clear higher micronuclei inducing potency than the other tested though the bulky methanesulphonates possess a lower total alkylating activity than the others. This effect can be explained by a higher disturbance during mitosis after alkylation of the spindle apparatus with the structurally more bulky methanesulphonates.

Residues of genotoxic alkyl mesylates in mesylate salt drug substances: Real or imaginary problems?

Mesylate esters of short-chain (n = 1-3) alcohols are reactive, direct-acting, genotoxic and possibly carcinogenic alkylating agents. Their chemical and biological properties appear to correlate well with Swain-Scott s constants; for example, high S(N)1 character (low s value) is associated with enhanced carcinogenic potential, but also a rapid hydrolysis rate. Concerns over the possible formation of such esters during the preparation of mesylate salt drug substances, by addition of methane sulfonic acid (MSA) to the free base dissolved in an alcoholic solvent, have led regulatory agencies to require applicants to demonstrate that the synthetic method employed does not lead to the presence of detectable levels of alkyl mesylates. Mechanistic considerations, relating mainly to the extremely low nucleophilicity of the mesylate anion, and experimental data, both indicate that alkyl mesylates should not be formed (except from MSA impurities) during mesylate salt synthesis. Mechanistic arguments also predict that residues of alkyl halides (possibly formed in the preparation of amine hydrochlorides or hydrobromides) could represent a similar or greater potential hazard than alkyl mesylates. The perceived risk of alkyl mesylate formation seems to rely on mistaken assumptions and so the concerns appear unjustified. Further reassurance could be achieved however by applying a variety of strategies during synthesis, including pH control, and use of high-purity MSA or of a non-hydroxylic reaction solvent.

Mutagenic and carcinogenic risk of oxygen containing chlorinated C-3 hydrocarbons: putative secondary products of C-3 chlorohydrocarbons and chlorination of water

Oxygen containing C-3 chlorohydrocarbons are secondary products of C-3 chlorohydrocarbons formed during oxidation at air, in the metabolism of pesticides and by chlorination of drinking water. These compounds are mutagenic, genotoxic and carcinogenic. 2-Chloroacroleins are extremely strong mutagens and genotoxins and form 1,N2-cyclic deoxyguanosine adducts. The role of such adducts in mutagenicity and carcinogenicity is discussed.

Absence of mutagenic action of 5 beta-cholan-24-oic acid derivatives in the bacterial fluctuation and standard Ames tests

Published data on the mutagenicity of 3 bile acids in the bacterial fluctuation test are conflicting. Eleven 5 beta-cholanoic acids including 2 of the bile acids were assayed for mutagenicity in Salmonella typhimurium TA98 and TA100 in the fluctuation tests. In any of these bile acids at the doses tested, there were no dose-related statistically significant increases in mutagenicity compared with appropriate controls. Similarly, none of these compounds showed positive mutagenicity in both strains in the standard Ames test either with or without hepatic metabolic activation. Our results support the claim that 3 bile acids are not mutagenic, and indicate that the initiation activity of 5 beta-cholanoic acids is not demonstrable with a short-term assay using Salmonella strains.

Induction of sfiA SOS function by peroxides using three different E. coli strains

Five peroxides and two related compounds were tested for genotoxicity by the SOS Chromotest using 3 different E. coli strains (PQ37, PM21, GC4798). All tested hydroperoxides (hydrogen peroxide, tert-butylhydroperoxide, cumene hydroperoxide) were clearly positive in all strains. From a comparison of results obtained from the different strains it can be concluded that neither DNA lesions leading to the induction of excision repair nor covalent binding of radicals to DNA is responsible for the induction of sfiA-SOS function by hydroperoxides. Among the remaining compounds tested, only dibenzoylperoxide gave a clearly positive result in strain PQ37 whereas di-tert-butylperoxide and azobisisobutyronitrile showed only borderline activity. When using strains PM21 and GC4798, none of the latter compounds was positive. Paraquat was inactive in all strains.