Characterization of DNA methylation in the rat

Cross-tissue patterns of DNA hypomethylation reveal genetically distinct histories of cell development

BACKGROUND

Establishment of DNA methylation (DNAme) patterns is essential for balanced multi-lineage cellular differentiation, but exactly how these patterns drive cellular phenotypes is unclear. While > 80% of CpG sites are stably methylated, tens of thousands of discrete CpG loci form hypomethylated regions (HMRs). Because they lack DNAme, HMRs are considered transcriptionally permissive, but not all HMRs actively regulate genes. Unlike promoter HMRs, a subset of non-coding HMRs is cell type-specific and enriched for tissue-specific gene regulatory functions. Our data further argues not only that HMR establishment is an important step in enforcing cell identity, but also that cross-cell type and spatial HMR patterns are functionally informative of gene regulation.

RESULTS

To understand the significance of non-coding HMRs, we systematically dissected HMR patterns across diverse human cell types and developmental timepoints, including embryonic, fetal, and adult tissues. Unsupervised clustering of 126,104 distinct HMRs revealed that levels of HMR specificity reflects a developmental hierarchy supported by enrichment of stage-specific transcription factors and gene ontologies. Using a pseudo-time course of development from embryonic stem cells to adult stem and mature hematopoietic cells, we find that most HMRs observed in differentiated cells (~ 60%) are established at early developmental stages and accumulate as development progresses. HMRs that arise during differentiation frequently (~ 35%) establish near existing HMRs (≤ 6 kb away), leading to the formation of HMR clusters associated with stronger enhancer activity. Using SNP-based partitioned heritability from GWAS summary statistics across diverse traits and clinical lab values, we discovered that genetic contribution to trait heritability is enriched within HMRs. Moreover, the contribution of heritability to cell-relevant traits increases with both increasing HMR specificity and HMR clustering, supporting the role of distinct HMR subsets in regulating normal cell function.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results demonstrate that the entire HMR repertoire within a cell-type, rather than just the cell type-specific HMRs, stores information that is key to understanding and predicting cellular phenotypes. Ultimately, these data provide novel insights into how DNA hypo-methylation provides genetically distinct historical records of a cell's journey through development, highlighting HMRs as functionally distinct from other epigenomic annotations.

The methylome and cell-free DNA: current applications in medicine and pediatric disease

DNA methylation is an epigenetic mechanism that contributes to cell regulation and development, and different methylation patterns allow for the identification of cell and tissue type. Cell-free DNA (cfDNA) is composed of small circulating fragments of DNA found in plasma and urine. Total cfDNA levels correlate with the presence of inflammation and tissue injury in a variety of disease states. Unfortunately, the utility of cfDNA is limited by its lack of tissue or cell-type specificity. However, methylome analysis of cfDNA allows the identification of the tissue or cell type from which cfDNA originated. Thus, methylation patterns in cfDNA from tissues isolated from direct study may provide windows into health and disease states, thereby serving as a "liquid biopsy". This review will discuss methylation and its role in establishing cellular identity, cfDNA as a biomarker and its pathophysiologic role in the inflammatory process, and the ways cfDNA and methylomics can be jointly applied in medicine. IMPACT: Cell-free DNA (cfDNA) is increasingly being used as a noninvasive diagnostic and disease-monitoring tool in pediatric medicine. However, the lack of specificity of cfDNA limits its utility. Identification of cell type-specific methylation signatures can help overcome the limited specificity of cfDNA. As knowledge of the cfDNA methylome improves, cfDNA will be more broadly applied in medicine, such that clinicians will need to understand the methods and applications of its use.

High-resolution genome-wide cytosine methylation profiling with simultaneous copy number analysis and optimization for limited cell numbers

Many genome-wide assays involve the generation of a subset (or representation) of the genome following restriction enzyme digestion. The use of enzymes sensitive to cytosine methylation allows high-throughput analysis of this epigenetic regulatory process. We show that the use of a dual-adapter approach allows us to generate genomic representations that includes fragments of <200 bp in size, previously not possible when using the standard approach of using a single adapter. By expanding the representation to smaller fragments using HpaII or MspI, we increase the representation by these isoschizomers to more than 1.32 million loci in the human genome, representing 98.5% of CpG islands and 91.1% of refSeq promoters. This advance allows the development of a new, high-resolution version of our HpaII-tiny fragment Enrichment by Ligation-mediated PCR (HELP) assay to study cytosine methylation. We also show that the MspI representation generates information about copy-number variation, that the assay can be used on as little as 10 ng of DNA and that massively parallel sequencing can be used as an alternative to microarrays to read the output of the assay, making this a powerful discovery platform for studies of genomic and epigenomic abnormalities.

Aging results in hypermethylation of ribosomal DNA in sperm and liver of male rats

There is a concern that increased paternal age may be associated with altered fertility and an increased incidence of birth defects in man. In previous studies of aged male rats, we have found abnormalities in the fertility and in the embryos sired by older males. Aging in mammals is associated with alterations in the content and patterns of DNA methylation in somatic cells; however, little is known in regard to germ cells. A systematic search for global and gene-specific alterations of DNA methylation in germ cells and liver of male rats was done. Restriction landmark genomic scanning, a method used to determine specific methylation patterns of CpG island sequences, has revealed a region of the ribosomal DNA locus that is preferentially hypermethylated with age in both spermatozoa and liver. In contrast, all single copy CpG island sequences in spermatozoa and in liver remain unaltered with age. We further demonstrate that a large proportion of rat ribosomal DNA is normally methylated and that regional and site-specific differences exist in the patterns of methylation between spermatozoa and liver. We conclude that patterns of ribosomal DNA methylation in spermatozoa are vulnerable to the same age-dependent alterations that we observe in normal aging liver. Failure to maintain normal DNA methylation patterns in male germ cells could be one of the mechanisms underlying age-related abnormalities in fertility and progeny outcome.

Evolutionary changes in CpG and methylation levels in the genome of vertebrates

We have analysed the levels of 5-methylcytosine (5mC) in DNAs from 42 vertebrates, and compiled, including data from literature, a table of genomic 5mC and GC levels (as well as the available c-values, i.e., the haploid genome sizes) of 87 species from all vertebrate classes. An analysis of the data indicates that (i) two positive correlations hold between the 5mC and GC levels of the genomes of fishes/amphibians and mammals/birds, respectively; (ii) the genomes of fishes and amphibians are, on average, about twice as methylated as those of mammals, birds and reptiles, this difference being unrelated to the amounts of repetitive DNA sequences; (iii) the 5mC and CpG observed/expected values show no overlap between the two groups of vertebrates and suggest the existence of two equilibria. The transition separating the two equilibria appears to have taken place at the time of appearance of reptiles. Its possible cause(s) and its implications are discussed.

DNA methylation patterns in human tissues of uniparental origin using a zinc-finger gene (ZNF127) from the Angelman/Prader-Willi region

In order to further our understanding of the epigenetic modifications of DNA and its role in imprinting, we examined DNA methylation patterns of human tissues of uniparental origin. We used complete hydatidiform moles (CHM), which are totally androgenetic conceptions, to examine the paternal methylation pattern in the absence of a maternal contribution and we used ovarian teratomas to represent the maternal counterpart. We carried out an analysis of DNA methylation of a gene which has been shown to contain sites which are differentially methylated in a parent-specific fashion. The gene, ZNF127, is located on chromosome 15q11-q13 in the region associated with Prader-Willi and Angelman syndromes. The parent-of-origin DNA methylation has been postulated to reflect the presence of an imprint and recent studies have confirmed that ZNF127 is differentially expressed only from the paternal chromosome. We identified a unique pattern of hyper- and hypomethylated sites in androgenetic conceptions which was nearly identical to the paternal pattern found in sperm. This may represent the paternal germ-line methylation imprint. We also studied partial hydatidiform moles, non-molar triploid conceptions, normal chorionic villi, and somatic tissue. These all demonstrated a modified DNA methylation pattern characteristic of normal chorionic villi with only limited findings of the imprint. Our results suggest that human androgenetic conceptions may provide an excellent model to analyze epigenetic DNA modifications, such as methylation, in imprinted genes. The paternal allele-specific methylation imprint will also be useful clinically to confirm the androgenetic nature of suspected molar conceptions in which parental blood samples may not be available.

Regulation of sex hormone-binding globulin production by isoflavonoids and patterns of isoflavonoid conjugation in HepG2 cell cultures

The effect of the isoflavonoid phytoestrogens daidzein, equol, and genistein on sex hormone-binding globulin (SHBG) levels, SHBG mRNA transcript levels, and SHBG gene methylation was studied in HepG2 cell cultures by fluoroimmunometric SHBG assay and Northern and Southern hybridizations, respectively. The effect of 17 beta-estradiol on these parameters was studied as a control. The metabolism of isoflavonoids in HepG2 cells was determined by isotope dilution gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, after ion-exchange chromatography. Daidzein and equol increased SHBG levels in parallel intracellularly and extracellularly, whereas genistein increased SHBG levels only within the cells, resembling thus the effect of 17 beta-estradiol. The difference may originate from the fact that genistein has more hydroxyl groups than daidzein and equol. The regulation of SHBG production by phytoestrogens appears to occur at the post-transcriptional level. Firstly, daidzein, equol, or genistein did not have a clear effect on the steady-state SHBG mRNA levels. Secondly, no effect on SHBG gene methylation was observed by genistein. The findings applied also to 17 beta-estradiol. However, as the SHBG gene was more methylated in SHBG-negative MCF-7 cells than in SHBG-positive HepG2 cells, DNA methylation may play a role in the tissue-specific activation of this gene. The metabolism of isoflavonoids in HepG2 cells yielded mainly unconjugated and sulfated compounds. Similar metabolism in hepatocytes in vivo might retain their biological activity in tissues responsive to estrogens.

Effects of 5-azacytidine and methyl-group deficiency on NAD(P)H: quinone oxidoreductase and glutathione S-transferase in liver

Treatment with 5-azacytidine or dietary methyl-group deficiency effected DNA hypomethylation in mouse liver. With these treatments, NAD(P)H: quinone oxidoreductase (EC 1.6.99.2) and some glutathione S-transferase (EC 2.5.1.18) activities were over-expressed, lactate dehydrogenase (EC 1.1.1.27) activity was unaffected and the level of cytochrome P-450 was decreased. The 5-azacytidine induction of NAD(P)H: quinone oxidoreductase was significantly suppressed by puromycin, suggesting that increased enzyme activity results from an elevated level of enzyme-protein synthesis. Regulation at the transcriptional level was revealed by a substantial increase in mRNA of NAD(P)H: quinone oxidoreductase, as shown by Northern-blot analysis. The enzyme pattern observed with 5-azacytidine and with the (carcinogenic) dietary methyl-group deficiency resembles that found in hepatic nodules.

Albumin and alpha-fetoprotein gene expression and DNA methylation in rat hepatoma cell lines

To define systems for the study of gene control and differentiation in vitro, we analyzed albumin and alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) gene expression and gene methylation in a series of rat hepatoma-derived cell lines and controls. These cell lines had several specific phenotypes: adult (high albumin and low AFP mRNA), fetal (high albumin, high AFP), embryonic (low albumin, high AFP), or undifferentiated (no albumin or AFP). The adult hepatocyte phenotype is marked by a novel 2.2-kb AFP gene transcript and high DNA methylation. In general, tumor cell lines had higher albumin and AFP gene methylation than hepatocytes in vivo. Levels of total DNA methylation did not determine the methylation patterns of specific genes, except for one cell line with hypermethylated and one with hypomethylated DNA. 5'-Hypomethylation of the AFP gene correlated with gene activity in all cases; the albumin gene showed a similar relationship, but with some exceptions. Only adult hepatocytes, not cell lines, have a unique 3'-region of AFP gene demethylation.

Overabundance of rare-cutting restriction endonuclease sites in the human genome

A human chromosome 3-specific cosmid library was constructed from a somatic cell hybrid containing human chromosome 3 as its only human component. This library was screened to identify 230 human recombinants which contained an average insert size of 37 kilobases. DNA prepared from 54 of these cosmids, representing 2000 kilobases of human DNA, was then tested for restriction endonuclease sites for EcoRI, HindIII, KpnI, XhoI, and DraI, as well as those of the rare-cutting restriction endonucleases NotI, SfiI, NruI, MluI, SacII, and BssHII. Sites for the latter enzymes were much more abundant than would be expected from theoretical calculations, reflecting non-random clustering of these sites. This has important implications for the use of these enzymes in the construction of physical maps of chromosomes. Some individual cosmids contained large numbers of rare sites, offering an alternative means of physically mapping chromosomes based upon identifying clusters of rare restriction sites. These clusters appear to be spaced an average of 1000 kb apart.

Delayed methylation and the matrix bound DNA methylase

It is shown that the methylation of DNA that occurs in isolated nuclei is "delayed methylation". This methylation is not reduced in nuclei which have been pretreated with 0.2M NaCl to extract the soluble methylase suggesting that this methylation is the product of a firmly bound matrix associated DNA methylase. Evidence is provided that, like the methylase, the DNA substrate is associated with the nuclear matrix.

DNaseI sensitivity of the rat albumin and alpha-fetoprotein genes

We have analyzed the DNaseI sensitivity of chromatin from the rat albumin and alpha-fetoprotein genes in the fetal liver (which synthesizes albumin and alpha-fetoprotein), adult liver (which synthesizes albumin), fetal yolk sac (which synthesizes alpha-fetoprotein), and adult kidney (which synthesizes neither). Active genes were much more sensitive than their kidney counterparts, and the adult liver alpha-fetoprotein and fetal yolk sac albumin genes showed intermediate levels of sensitivity. Sensitivity was analyzed as a function of the extent of DNaseI digestion. Rate constants were calculated for the degradation of individual DNA hybridization bands and normalized to the intrinsic rate constants of the same bands degraded in purified DNA. This enabled us to eliminate the inconsistencies that otherwise result from comparing chromatin sensitivity of different DNA sequences, or chromatin sensitivity in different nuclear environments.

Developmental regulation of albumin and alpha-fetoprotein gene expression in the rat

Albumin and AFP comprise a developmentally regulated gene family expressed predominantly in liver and yolk sac. In this study, we have analyzed the developmental changes in the levels of transcripts in liver and yolk sac, and the methylation of the genes in yolk sac. We have previously analyzed the gene methylation in developing liver and non-expressing tissues (Kunnath and Locker, 1983, EMBO J., 2, 317-324). From these analyses we can distinguish 3 active modes of coordinated expression. The adult liver synthesizes albumin, the yolk sac synthesizes AFP, and the fetal liver synthesizes both. In the yolk sac, the relatively inactive albumin gene is hypermethylated, while the active AFP gene is undermethylated. Our data suggest that the genes are activated simultaneously but that subsequent enhancement is specific for tissue and developmental stage.

Changes in methylation pattern of albumin and alpha-fetoprotein genes in developing rat liver and neoplasia

To determine whether methylation changes in specific DNA sequences of the albumin and AFP genes are implicated in the modulation of transcriptional activity during rat liver development and neoplasia we have analysed the methylation pattern of C-C-G-G sequences within these genes in DNA isolated from fetal and adult hepatocytes, from adult kidney and from a clonal hepatoma cell line which produces AFP but no albumin. We have assayed for methylation of the internal cytosine of this sequence by using the restriction enzyme isoschizomers HpaII and MspI. 32P-labelled cloned cDNA probes were used to reveal the albumin and AFP gene containing fragments. Genomic subclones of the albumin gene were also utilized as molecular probes to measure quantitatively the level of methylation of 6 specific sites within the albumin gene in the different DNA samples. The results indicate that methylation changes at the sites analysed are not responsible for the changes in gene activity during rat liver development. Further they demonstrate that: 1) extensively methylated genes can be actively transcribed; 2) prominent changes in methylation of specific genes during normal development are not necessarily related to alterations in gene activity.