GroEL/ES-mediated refolding of human carbonic anhydrase II: role of N-terminal helices as recognition motifs for GroEL

Differential conformational modulations of MreB folding upon interactions with GroEL/ES and TRiC chaperonin components

Here, we study and compare the mechanisms of action of the GroEL/GroES and the TRiC chaperonin systems on MreB client protein variants extracted from E. coli. MreB is a homologue to actin in prokaryotes. Single-molecule fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) and time-resolved fluorescence polarization anisotropy report the binding interaction of folding MreB with GroEL, GroES and TRiC. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements on MreB variants quantified molecular distance changes occurring during conformational rearrangements within folding MreB bound to chaperonins. We observed that the MreB structure is rearranged by a binding-induced expansion mechanism in TRiC, GroEL and GroES. These results are quantitatively comparable to the structural rearrangements found during the interaction of β-actin with GroEL and TRiC, indicating that the mechanism of chaperonins is conserved during evolution. The chaperonin-bound MreB is also significantly compacted after addition of AMP-PNP for both the GroEL/ES and TRiC systems. Most importantly, our results showed that GroES may act as an unfoldase by inducing a dramatic initial expansion of MreB (even more than for GroEL) implicating a role for MreB folding, allowing us to suggest a delivery mechanism for GroES to GroEL in prokaryotes.

Transient conformational remodeling of folding proteins by GroES-individually and in concert with GroEL

The commonly accepted dogma of the bacterial GroE chaperonin system entails protein folding mediated by cycles of several ATP-dependent sequential steps where GroEL interacts with the folding client protein. In contrast, we herein report GroES-mediated dynamic remodeling (expansion and compression) of two different protein substrates during folding: the endogenous substrate MreB and carbonic anhydrase (HCAII), a well-characterized protein folding model. GroES was also found to influence GroEL binding induced unfolding and compression of the client protein underlining the synergistic activity of both chaperonins, even in the absence of ATP. This previously unidentified activity by GroES should have important implications for understanding the chaperonin mechanism and cellular stress response. Our findings necessitate a revision of the GroEL/ES mechanism.

Chaperone activity of Cyp18 through hydrophobic condensation that enables rescue of transient misfolded molten globule intermediates

The single-domain cyclophilin 18 (Cyp18) has long been known to function as a peptidyl-prolyl cis/trans isomerase (PPI) and was proposed by us to also function as a chaperone [Freskgard, P.-O., Bergenhem, N., Jonsson, B.-H., Svensson, M., and Carlsson, U. (1992) Science 258, 466-468]. Later several multidomain PPIs were demonstrated to work as both a peptidyl-prolyl cis/trans isomerase and a chaperone. However, the chaperone ability of Cyp18 has been debated. In this work, we add additional results that show that Cyp18 can both accelerate the rate of refolding and increase the yield of native protein during the folding reaction, i.e., function as both a folding catalyst and a chaperone. Refolding experiments were performed using severely destabilized mutants of human carbonic anhydrase II under conditions where the unfolding reaction is significant and a larger fraction of a more destabilized variant populates molten globule-like intermediates during refolding. A correlation of native state protein stability of the substrate protein versus Cyp18 chaperone activity was demonstrated. The induced correction of misfolded conformations by Cyp18 likely functions through rescue from misfolding of transient molten globule intermediates. ANS binding data suggest that the interaction by Cyp18 leads to an early stage condensation of accessible hydrophobic portions of the misfolding-prone protein substrate during folding. The opposite effect was observed for GroEL known as an unfoldase at early stages of refolding. The chaperone effect of Cyp18 was also demonstrated for citrate synthase, suggesting a general chaperone effect of this PPI.

Thermodynamic interrogation of a folding disease. Mutant mapping of position 107 in human carbonic anhydrase II linked to marble brain disease

Marble brain disease (MBD) also known as Guibaud-Vainsel syndrome is caused by autosomal recessive mutations in the human carbonic anhydrase II (HCA II) gene. HCA II is a 259 amino acid single domain enzyme and is dominated by a 10-stranded beta-sheet. One mutation associated with MBD entails the H107Y substitution where H107 is a highly conserved residue in the carbonic anhydrase protein family. We have previously demonstrated that the H107Y mutation is a remarkably destabilizing folding mutation [Almstedt et al. (2004) J. Mol. Biol. 342, 619-633]. Here, the exceptional destabilization by the H107Y mutation has been further investigated. A mutational survey of position H107 and a neighboring conserved position E117 has been performed entailing the mutants H107A, H107F, H107N, E117A and the double mutants H107A/E117A and H107N/E117A. All mutants were severely destabilized versus GuHCl and heat denaturation. Thermal denaturation and GuHCl phase diagram and ANS analyses showed that the mutants shifted HCA II toward populating ensembles of intermediates of molten globule type under physiological conditions. The native state stability of the mutants was in the following order: wt > H107N > E117A > H107A > H107F > H107Y > H107N/E117A > H107A/E117A.

IN CONCLUSION

(i) H107N is least destabilizing likely due to compensatory H-bonding ability of the introduced Asn residue. (ii) Double mutant cycles surprisingly reveal additive destabilization of H107N and E117A showing that H107 and E117 are independently stabilizing the folded protein. (iii) H107Y and H107F are exceptionally destabilizing due to bulkiness of the side chains whereas H107A is more accommodating, indicating long-range destabilizing effects of the natural pathogenic H107Y mutation.

Conformational rearrangements of tail-less complex polypeptide 1 (TCP-1) ring complex (TRiC)-bound actin

The mechanism of chaperonins is still under intense investigation. Earlier studies by others and us on the bacterial chaperonin GroEL points to an active role of chaperonins in unfolding the target protein during initial binding. Here, a natural eukaryotic chaperonin system [tail-less complex polypeptide 1 (TCP-1) ring complex (TRiC) and its target protein actin] was investigated to determine if the active participation of the chaperonin in the folding process is evolutionary-conserved. Using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements on four distinct doubly fluorescein-labeled variants of actin, we have obtained a fairly detailed map of the structural rearrangements that occur during the TRiC-actin interaction. The results clearly show that TRiC has an active role in rearranging the bound actin molecule. The target is stretched as a consequence of binding to TRiC and further rearranged in a second step as a consequence of ATP binding; i.e., the mechanism of chaperonins is conserved during evolution.

Circumnavigating Misfolding Traps in the Energy Landscape through Protein Engineering: Suppression of Molten Globule and Aggregation in Carbonic Anhydrase

The native state of the enzyme human carbonic anhydrase (HCA II) has been stabilized by the introduction of a disulfide bond, the oxidized A23C/L203C mutant. This stabilized protein variant undergoes an apparent two-state unfolding process with suppression of the otherwise stable equilibrium, molten-globule intermediate, which is normally very prone to aggregation. Stopped-flow measurements also showed that lower amounts of the transiently occurring molten globule were formed during refolding. This led to a markedly lowered tendency for aggregation during equilibrium denaturing conditions and, more importantly, to significantly higher reactivation yields upon refolding of the fully denatured protein. Thus, a general strategy to circumvent aggregation during the refolding of proteins could be to stabilize the native state of a protein at the expense of partially folded intermediates, thereby shifting the unfolding behavior from a three-state process to a two-state one.

Reshaping the folding energy landscape by chloride salt: impact on molten-globule formation and aggregation behavior of carbonic anhydrase

During chemical denaturation different intermediate states are populated or suppressed due to the nature of the denaturant used. Chemical denaturation by guanidine-HCl (GuHCl) of human carbonic anhydrase II (HCA II) leads to a three-state unfolding process (Cm,NI=1.0 and Cm,IU=1.9 M GuHCl) with formation of an equilibrium molten-globule intermediate that is stable at moderate concentrations of the denaturant (1-2 M) with a maximum at 1.5 M GuHCl. On the contrary, urea denaturation gives rise to an apparent two-state unfolding transition (Cm=4.4 M urea). However, 8-anilino-1-naphthalene sulfonate (ANS) binding and decreased refolding capacity revealed the presence of the molten globule in the middle of the unfolding transition zone, although to a lesser extent than in GuHCl. Cross-linking studies showed the formation of moderate oligomer sized (300 kDa) and large soluble aggregates (>1000 kDa). Inclusion of 1.5 M NaCl to the urea denaturant to mimic the ionic character of GuHCl leads to a three-state unfolding behavior (Cm,NI=3.0 and Cm,IU=6.4 M urea) with a significantly stabilized molten-globule intermediate by the chloride salt. Comparisons between NaCl and LiCl of the impact on the stability of the various states of HCA II in urea showed that the effects followed what could be expected from the Hofmeister series, where Li+ is a chaotropic ion leading to decreased stability of the native state. Salt addition to the completely urea unfolded HCA II also led to an aggregation prone unfolded state, that has not been observed before for carbonic anhydrase. Refolding from this state only provided low recoveries of native enzyme.

Protein compactness measured by fluorescence resonance energy transfer. Human carbonic anhydrase ii is considerably expanded by the interaction of GroEL

Nine single-cysteine mutants were labeled with 5-(2-iodoacetylaminoethylamino)naphthalene-1-sulfonic acid, an efficient acceptor of Trp fluorescence in fluorescence resonance energy transfer. The ratio between the fluorescence intensity of the 5-(2-acetylaminoethylamino)naphthalene-1-sulfonic acid (AEDANS) moiety excited at 295 nm (Trp absorption) and 350 nm (direct AEDANS absorption) was used to estimate the average distances between the seven Trp residues in human carbonic anhydrase II (HCA II) and the AEDANS label. Guanidine HCl denaturation of the HCA II variants was also performed to obtain a curve that reflected the compactness of the protein at various stages of the unfolding, which could serve as a scale of the expansion of the protein. This approach was developed in this study and was used to estimate the compactness of HCA II during heat denaturation and interaction with GroEL. It was shown that thermally induced unfolding of HCA II proceeded only to the molten globule state. Reaching this state was sufficient to allow HCA II to bind to GroEL, and the volume of the molten globule intermediate increased approximately 2.2-fold compared with that of the native state. GroEL-bound HCA II expands to a volume three to four times that of the native state (to approximately 117,000 A(3)), which correlates well with a stretched and loosened-up HCA II molecule in an enlarged GroEL cavity. Recently, we found that HCA II binding causes such an inflation of the GroEL molecule, and this probably represents the mechanism by which GroEL actively stretches its protein substrates apart (Hammarström, P., Persson, M., Owenius, R., Lindgren, M., and Carlsson, U. (2000) J. Biol. Chem. 275, 22832-22838), thereby facilitating rearrangement of misfolded structure.

Protein substrate binding induces conformational changes in the chaperonin GroEL. A suggested mechanism for unfoldase activity

Chaperonins are molecules that assist proteins during folding and protect them from irreversible aggregation. We studied the chaperonin GroEL and its interaction with the enzyme human carbonic anhydrase II (HCA II), which induces unfolding of the enzyme. We focused on conformational changes that occur in GroEL during formation of the GroEL-HCA II complex. We measured the rate of GroEL cysteine reactivity toward iodo[2-(14)C]acetic acid and found that the cysteines become more accessible during binding of a cysteine free mutant of HCA II. Spin labeling of GroEL with N-(1-oxyl-2,2,5, 5-tetramethyl-3-pyrrolidinyl)iodoacetamide revealed that this additional binding occurred because buried cysteine residues become accessible during HCA II binding. In addition, a GroEL variant labeled with 6-iodoacetamidofluorescein exhibited decreased fluorescence anisotropy upon HCA II binding, which resembles the effect of GroES/ATP binding. Furthermore, by producing cysteine-modified GroEL with the spin label N-(1-oxyl-2,2,5, 5-tetramethyl-3-pyrrolidinyl)iodoacetamide and the fluorescent label 5-((((2-iodoacetyl)amino)ethyl)amino)naphthalene-1-sulfonic acid, we detected increases in spin-label mobility and fluorescence intensity in GroEL upon HCA II binding. Together, these results show that conformational changes occur in the chaperonin as a consequence of protein substrate binding. Together with previous results on the unfoldase activity of GroEL, we suggest that the chaperonin opens up as the substrate protein binds. This opening mechanism may induce stretching of the protein, which would account for reported unfoldase activity of GroEL and might explain how GroEL can actively chaperone proteins larger than HCA II.

Structural mapping of an aggregation nucleation site in a molten globule intermediate

Protein aggregation plays an important role in biotechnology and also causes numerous diseases. Human carbonic anhydrase II is a suitable model protein for studying the mechanism of aggregation. We found that a molten globule state of the enzyme formed aggregates. The intermolecular interactions involved in aggregate formation were localized in a direct way by measuring excimer formation between each of 20 site-specific pyrene-labeled cysteine mutants. The contact area of the aggregated protein was very specific, and all sites included in the intermolecular interactions were located in the large beta-sheet of the protein, within a limited region between the central beta-strands 4 and 7. This substructure is very hydrophobic, which underlines the importance of hydrophobic interactions between specific beta-sheet containing regions in aggregate formation.

EPR mapping of interactions between spin-labeled variants of human carbonic anhydrase II and GroEL: evidence for increased flexibility of the hydrophobic core by the interaction

Human carbonic anhydrase II (HCA II) interacts weakly with GroEL at room temperature. To further investigate this interaction we used electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy to study HCA II cysteine mutants spin-labeled at selected positions. From our results it is evident that protein-protein interactions can be specifically mapped by site-directed spin-labeling and EPR measurements. HCA II needs to be unfolded to about the same extent as a GuHCl-induced molten-globule intermediate of the enzyme to interact with GroEL. The interaction with GroEL includes interactions with outer parts of the HCA II molecule, such as peripheral beta-strands and the N-terminal domain, which have previously been shown to be rather unstable. As a result of the interaction, the rigid and compact hydrophobic core exhibits higher flexibility than in the molten globule, which is likely to facilitate rearrangements of misfolded structure during the folding process. The degree of binding to GroEL and accompanying inactivation of the enzyme depend on the stability of the HCA II variant, and nonspecific hydrophobic interactions appear to be most important in stabilizing the GroEL-substrate complex.

Participation of chaperonin GroEL in the folding of D-glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase. An approach based on the use of different oligomeric forms of the enzyme immobilized on sepharose

The binding of denatured B. stearothermophilus D-glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) to the E. coli chaperonin GroEL was investigated in two systems: (1) GroEL immobilized on Sepharose via a single subunit was titrated with urea-denatured soluble GAPDH and (2) a Sepharose-bound denatured GAPDH monomer was titrated with soluble GroEL. Similar apparent KD values for the complex GroEL x GAPDH were obtained in both cases (0.04 and 0.03 microM, respectively), the stoichiometry being 1.0 mol chaperonin per GAPDH subunit in the system with the immobilized GroEL and 0.2 mol chaperonin per Sepharose-bound GAPDH monomer. Addition of GroEL and Mg x ATP to a reactivation mixture increased the yield of reactivation of both E. coli and B. stearothermophilus GAPDHs. Incubation of the Sepharose-bound catalytically active tetrameric and dimeric GAPDH forms with the protein fraction of a wild-type E. coli cell extract resulted in the binding of GroEL to the dimer and no interaction with the tetrameric form. These data suggest that GroEL may be capable of interacting with the interdimeric contact regions of the folded GAPDH dimers.

GroEL provides a folding pathway with lower apparent activation energy compared to spontaneous refolding of human carbonic anhydrase II

The kinetics of the refolding of the enzyme, human carbonic anhydrase II (HCA II), at different temperatures, together with the Escherichia coli chaperonin GroEL, has been studied. The Arrhenius plots for the spontaneous, GroEL-assisted, and GroEL/ES-assisted refolding of HCA II show that the apparent activation energy (E(a)) is lower in the presence of the chaperonin GroEL alone than for the spontaneous reaction, whereas the apparent activation energy for the GroEL/ES-assisted reaction is almost the same as for the spontaneous reaction (85, 46, and 72 kJ/mol, for the spontaneous, GroEL, and GroEL/ES-assisted reactions, respectively).

Bovine and human alpha-crystallins as molecular chaperones: prevention of the inactivation of glutathione reductase by fructation

With no measurable protein synthesis occurring in the centre of the lens, structural proteins and enzymes there will need to be stable for many years, if not decades, in order to maintain lens integrity and function. Recent work has indicated that alpha-crystallin, which is sequentially related to heat shock proteins, has chaperone-like properties in that it is capable of preventing heat-induced aggregation of various proteins, including other crystallins. Thus this universal vertebrate lens protein may contribute to maintenance of lens integrity by protecting other lens proteins from non-enzymic insults or the consequences thereof. We previously showed that the enzyme glutathione reductase was inactivated in a time-dependent manner when incubated with various sugars, suggesting glycation was responsible for this effect. In this paper we confirmed that this was the case. Using this enzyme model system, the inclusion of either bovine or human alpha-crystallin protected against the inactivation of glutathione reductase by fructation. This action was specific, with control proteins displaying no such protection. Use of high performance liquid chromatography supported the fact that alpha-crystallin did not act simply by mopping up free sugar but rather maintained the activity of the modified enzyme. Dose-dependent experiments indicated that human alpha-crystallin was more effective than its bovine counterpart, which might be expected considering the much longer lifespan of humans. The stoichiometry of the protection by both alpha-crystallins indicated that alpha-crystallin with glutathione reductase was not acting like GroEL as a large complex with a hydrophobic pore, but rather that individual subunits may be capable of acting as chaperones.

GroEL reversibly binds to, and causes rapid inactivation of, human carbonic anhydrase II at high temperatures

The initial yield of reactivation of GuHCl denatured human carbonic anhydrase II does not change with temperature between 3 and 35 degrees C. At temperatures above 35 degrees C, the enzymatic activity is not stable, but decreases over time. If the bacterial chaperonin GroEL is present during reactivation, the initial yield is lower compared to the spontaneous reaction at temperatures of 35-50 degrees C. However, unlike the spontaneous reactivation, the enzymatic activity with time in the presence of GroEL. In the presence of GroEL, native HCA II incubated at elevated temperatures will rapidly loose enzymatic activity to the same value as during reactivation at that particular temperature; most of the activity will recover if the temperature is lowered when GroEL is present. It is evident that there is an equilibrium between an inactive intermediate of HCA II, probably bound to GroEL, and active enzyme. Furthermore, proline isomerization is part of the rate-limiting step of refolding even in the presence of GroEL, and it is very noteworthy that prolyl isomerase will influence the refolding of HCA II in the presence of GroEL.

Refolding and reassociation of glycerol dehydrogenase from Bacillus stearothermophilus in the absence and presence of GroEL

The refolding of the tetrameric, metalloenzyme glycerol dehydrogenase (GDH) from Bacillus stearothermophilus has been investigated using stopped-flow fluorescence and circular dichroism spectroscopy. The effects of metal ions on the refolding of the native enzyme and the refolding of a monomeric mutant ([A208]GDH) have also been studied. The refolding process of the wild-type enzyme is at least biphasic; 70% of the respective signal changes occur in the first 2 ms followed by a slower process with a half-life of 3 s. The presence of the metal ion does not affect the slowest biphasic refolding rate, which is virtually the same for all three versions of the enzyme. The presence of GroEL slows down the first phase of refolding. The reassociation of subunits was examined by measuring the regain in catalytic activity and the enhancement in the fluorescence emission from NADH on binding to the oligomeric form of the enzyme. The rate and extent of reassociation is dependent on enzyme concentration and the extent of reactivation is dependent on the presence of the metal ion. The reassociation process was more efficient in the presence of NADH particularly for the metal-depleted enzyme (apo-GDH). The presence of GroEL or GroEL plus ATP leads to a higher yield of reassociation and therefore catalytically active enzyme. The additional presence of Mg-ATP does not affect the extent of reassociation, but has a small positive effect on the rate of reassociation. These data suggest that GDH is bound weakly to GroEL and that GroES is not required for release of the protein.

Isolation and biochemical characterization of highly purified Escherichia coli molecular chaperone Cpn60 (GroEL) by affinity chromatography and urea-induced monomerization

Isolated Escherichia coli molecular chaperone Cpn60 (GroEL) has been further purified from tightly bound substrate polypeptides by two different procedures: (i) group-specific affinity chromatography by using the triazine dye Procion yellow HE-3G as affinity ligand, and (ii) urea-induced monomerization and subsequent chromatography. Procion yellow binds specifically to aromatic amino-acid side chains present in the majority of proteins, but has no affinity to GroEL because of its low content of aromatic residues. Some GroEL-bound polypeptides are buried within the aqueous cavity of the GroEL oligomer, whereas others are exposed on its surface and available for affinity-ligand interactions and the complex is thereby retarded on Procion yellow columns. Pure substrate-free GroEL was obtained after ion-exchange chromatography of GroEL monomers followed by reassembly of the purified monomers into functional GroEL oligomers. The final preparation contained no substrate polypeptides bound to GroEL as judged by electrophoretic analysis and lack of tryptophan fluorescence. GroEL preparations also displayed two equally strong bands on native electrophoresis suggesting the presence of two conformers. Monomers of GroEL showed heterogeneity with respect to isoelectric point and molecular mass when analysed by MALDI-MS and electrophoresis under native and denaturing conditions respectively. By use of MALDI-MS, highly accurate molecular masses of wild-type and a truncated form of GroEL were determined and verified, by comparison with their respective gene sequences.