The qualitative approach in investigating the role of species interactions on stability of natural communities

Temporal Variation in the Abundance and Richness of Foliage-Dwelling Ants Mediated by Extrafloral Nectar

Plants bearing extrafloral nectaries (EFNs) are common in the Brazilian cerrado savanna, where climatic conditions having marked seasonality influence arboreal ant fauna organization. These ant-plant interactions have rarely been studied at community level. Here, we tested whether: 1) EFN-bearing plants are more visited by ants than EFN-lacking plants; 2) ant visitation is higher in the rainy season than in dry season; 3) plants producing young leaves are more visited than those lacking young leaves in the rainy season; 4) during the dry season, plants with old leaves and flowers are more visited than plants with young leaves and bare of leaves or flowers; 5) the composition of visiting ant fauna differs between plants with and without EFNs. Field work was done in a cerrado reserve near Uberlândia, MG State, Brazil, along ten transects (total area 3,000 m²), in the rainy (October-January) and dry seasons (April-July) of 2010–2011. Plants (72 species; 762 individuals) were checked three times per season for ant presence. Results showed that 21 species (29%) and 266 individuals (35%) possessed EFNs. These plants attracted 38 ant species (36 in rainy, 26 in dry season). In the rainy season, plants with EFNs had higher ant abundance/richness than plants without EFNs, but in the dry season, EFN presence did not influence ant visitation. Plant phenology affected ant richness and abundance in different ways: plants with young leaves possessed higher ant richness in the rainy season, but in the dry season ant abundance was higher on plants possessing old leaves or flowers. The species composition of plant-associated ant communities, however, did not differ between plants with and without EFNs in either season. These findings suggest that the effect of EFN presence on a community of plant-visiting ants is context dependent, being conditioned to seasonal variation.

Stability patterns and trophic structure in a Delaware Bay plankton community

Using qualitative loop analysis we have extended our examination of a Delaware Bay plankton community to include an investigation of the roles played by the various entities (population, guild or nutrient) in the community. In an entity removal exercise, we used stability relationships as a probe into community structure. Six types of stability change are possible as a result of entity removal from the system: stable to stable (s-->s); stable to unstable (s-->u); stable to disconnected (s-->d); unstable to stable (u-->s); unstable to unstable (u-->u); unstable to disconnected (u-->d). Using these changes as an investigative tool, we found that in order to account for the stability-instability patterns, it was necessary to construct a refined trophic structure model. The observed connections between the entities in the larger model could be grouped into two different types of stability substructures: a simple pattern and a more complex branching pattern. These patterns map easily onto the refined trophic structure model. Using stability analysis it is also possible to model community structure in ways other than the traditional trophic approach. Patterns of system necessity and relative contribution to stability are observed. These patterns match the refined trophic structure model derived previously. The roles that the various entities play in the overall community were followed over an annual cycle. Entities were seen to change their roles as a function of time and status within a subgroup. These results show that stability determinations have the potential to be used as a valuable tool in community analysis.