The relationship between animal age and the thermal stability and cross-link content of collagen from five goat muscles

Contribution of intramuscular connective tissue and its structural components on meat tenderness-revisited: a review

The tenderness of meat influences consumers' perceptions of its quality. Meat tenderness is a key quality characteristic that influences consumer satisfaction, repeat purchases, and willingness to pay higher prices for meat. Muscle fibers, connective tissues, and adipocytes are the main structural components of meat that contribute to its tenderness and texture. In the present review, we have focused on the role of connective tissue and its components in meat tenderness, specifically perimysial intramuscular connective tissue (IMCT) and its concept as an immutable "background toughness." The collagen contribution to cooked meat toughness can be altered by animal diet, compensatory growth, slaughter age, aging, and cooking. As well, progressive thickening of the perimysium leads to a progressive increase in shear force values in beef, pork, chicken, and this may occur prior to adipocyte formation as cattle finish in feedlots. Conversely, adipocyte accumulation in the perimysium can decrease cooked meat shear force, suggesting that the contribution of IMCT to meat toughness is complex and driven by both collagen structure and content. This review provides a theoretical foundation of information to modify IMCT components to improve meat tenderness.

The Colour, Composition and Eating Quality of Beef from Late- or Early-Maturing Suckler Bulls Finished at Pasture with or without Concentrate Supplementation

Carcasses from pasture-finished early-maturing (EM), rather than late-maturing (LM), breed bulls may be more suited to meet the minimum carcass fatness classification of 2+ (6.0 on a 15-point scale) required for some markets. The comparative colour and eating quality of beef from grass-fed bulls of different maturities are unknown. Sixty yearling suckler-bred bulls were assigned to a 2 (maturities: EM and LM) × 2 (finishing strategies: grass only (G0) or grass + 4.0 kg concentrate daily (GC)) factorial design. Bulls were at pasture from 7 April, concentrates were introduced (or not) 97 days later, and bulls were slaughtered at 192 d post-turnout (approximately 19 mo of age). Carcass fat scores averaged 5.02, 6.20, 6.33 and 7.30 for LMG0, LMGC, EMG0 and EMGC bulls, respectively. Muscle colour did not differ between treatments. Muscle from LM had lower intramuscular fat concentration, collagen solubility and a tendency (p < 0.1) towards lower ratings for tenderness, texture, and acceptability of 14 d aged beef. Concentrate supplementation decreased the ratings for muscle tenderness but ratings for acceptability were not affected. Achieving the minimum carcass fatness was therefore not required to produce beef of acceptable eating quality and suckler bulls can access the “grass-fed” beef market.

Impact of genetic potential for residual feed intake and diet fed during early- to mid-gestation in beef heifers on carcass characteristics and meat quality attributes of their castrated male offspring

Carcass attributes of steers were examined for influences of selection for residual feed intake (RFI), and exposure to different levels of prenatal nutrition. Heifers characterized for RFI corrected for backfat were mated to bulls with genetic potential for either High-RFI or Low-RFI, such that the progeny were expected to be H/H or L/L RFI (sire/dam). Pregnant heifers were assigned to a low diet (Ldiet; 0.40 kg/d ADG), or moderate diet (Mdiet; 0.57 kg/d ADG), from 30 to 150 days of gestation, after which all heifers were managed similarly. Steer offspring (n = 23) were also managed similarly until slaughter. Dressing percentage of steers from H-RFI dams/sires exposed to Ldiet during gestation was lower than all other groups (P = 0.02). Marbling was greater for steers from H-RFI parents, as was fat content of longissimus thoracis et lumborum and triceps brachii (P ≤ 0.02). Results suggest that parental selection for RFI and prenatal maternal diet can influence carcass characteristics of progeny.

Relationship between meat quality and intramuscular collagen characteristics of muscles from calf-fed, yearling-fed and mature crossbred beef cattle

Intramuscular Ehrlich Chromogen (EC) and pyridinoline (Pyr) concentrations in the gluteus medius (GM) and semitendinosus (ST) from crossbred Angus calf- (n = 14) and yearling-fed (n = 14) steer and mature cow (MC, n = 12) carcasses were related to collagen and intramuscular connective tissue (IMCT) thermal stability and peak Warner-Bratzler shear force (WBSF). In both muscles, Pyr density was greater in MC, while EC concentrations were comparable in calf- and yearling-fed steer muscles and lowest in MC muscles. Thermal denaturation temperature and enthalpy of IMCT were highest in both muscles when from MC, although only total collagen was correlated with WBSF in calf fed-yearling fed steer data. Results confirmed that EC concentration contributed to collagen thermal stability in steer muscles, but decreased it in MC muscles, while Pyr was consistently associated with collagen thermal stability.

Fibrillar Collagen Organization Associated with Broiler Wooden Breast Fibrotic Myopathy

Wooden breast (WB) is a fibrotic myopathy affecting the pectoralis major (p. major) muscle in fast-growing commercial broiler lines. Birds with WB are phenotypically detected by the palpation of a hard p. major muscle. A primary feature of WB is the fibrosis of muscle with the replacement of muscle fibers with extracellular matrix proteins, such as collagen. The ability of a tissue to be pliable and stretch is associated with the organization of collagen fibrils in the connective tissue areas surrounding muscle fiber bundles (perimysium) and around individual muscle fibers (endomysium). The objective of this study was to compare the structure and organization of fibrillar collagen by using transmission electron microscopy in two fast-growing broiler lines (Lines A and B) with incidence of WB to a slower growing broiler Line C with no phenotypically detectable WB. In Line A, the collagen fibrils were tightly packed in a parallel organization, whereas in Line B, the collagen fibrils were randomly aligned. Tightly packed collagen fibrils arranged in parallel are associated with nonpliable collagen that is highly cross-linked. This will lead to a phenotypically hard p. major muscle. In Line C, the fibrillar collagen was sparse in its distribution. Furthermore, the average collagen fibril diameter and banding D-period length were altered in Line A p. major muscles affected with WB. Taken together, these data are suggestive of different fibrotic myopathies beyond just what is classified as WB in fast-growing broiler lines.

MEAT SCIENCE AND MUSCLE BIOLOGY SYMPOSIUM: BIOLOGICAL INFLUENCERS OF MEAT PALATABILITY: Production factors affecting the contribution of collagen to beef toughness1,2

Intramuscular collagen may affect the value of meat by limiting its tenderness and cooking convenience. Production factors such as age of animal at slaughter, the use of steroids and beta-adrenergic agonists as growth promotants, and cattle breed may affect the contribution of collagen to beef quality. Recent research has indicated that concentrations of the mature collagen cross-link pyridinoline (PYR) are positively correlated with Warner-Bratzler shear force (WBSF) and animal age at slaughter, while contribution of the concentration of a second mature collagen cross-link Ehrlich's Chromogen (EC) to beef toughness declines with cattle age. Cattle breed influences total collagen content of muscle due to differing rates of maturation among breeds. Growth promoting technologies do not appear to affect collagen solubility, but do influence PYR and EC densities and concentrations in some beef muscles. Concentrations of PYR and EC do not account for all the variation in collagen heat solubility in beef muscles, nor do advanced glycation end products given the relative immaturity of cattle at slaughter. In light of this, other collagen cross-links such as heat-stable divalent cross-links may warrant reconsideration with regard to their contribution to cooked beef toughness.

Effects of breed-production system on collagen, textural, and sensory traits of 10 European beef cattle breeds

In the current study the collagen, texture, and sensory characteristics of meat from 712 yearling males of 10 local Spanish and French beef breeds raised in their typical production systems were described. The breed-production system affected collagen and texture variables but affected sensory variables only slightly. There was a large amount of intra breed-production system variation for all the variables. French breeds had lower values for collagen solubility (~12%) than Spanish breeds (~40%). Stress (WB) varied from 36 N/cm² in Casina to 44 N/cm² in Salers, whereas compression stress at 80% ranged from 35 N/cm² in Asturiana de los Valles to 40 N/cm² in Salers. Oven cooking resulted in higher cooking losses (24%) than cooking on a grill (12%). Cooking losses increased as the grill temperature increased. Numerous significant correlations were found among variables. Carcass weight is associated with all the collagen and texture variables. Correlation coefficients among texture and collagen variables were statistically significant and these correlation coefficients were in general higher for solubility percentage than for total collagen content, highlighting the importance of the solubility of collagen rather than total collagen in determining meat textural properties.

PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS

To differentiate a product in the market, it is necessary to define its characteristics. Differentiation allows increasing the added value of products and, therefore, income of the farmers. In addition, it guarantees to the consumers that the product they purchase has the intrinsic and extrinsic quality features that they seek. For consumers, beef texture is one of the most important quality attributes sought, therefore, studying factors that can affect beef texture is a major interest for the industry.

Perimysial collagen crosslinking and meat tenderness in Belgian Blue double-muscled cattle

The relationship between intramuscular collagen and five collagen crosslink concentrations, and the tenderness of meat from Belgian Blue normal, heterozygous double-muscled (DM) and homozygous DM cattle was investigated using M. semitendinosus (St) and M. gluteobiceps (Gb). The histidinohydroxymerodesmosine (HHMD) concentration (per mol collagen) in St was less in DM animals than normal animals. Concentrations (per gram of wet meat) of HHMD and Erlich chromogen (EC) in Gb, and HHMD, EC, dihydroxylysinorleucine (DHLNL) and hydroxylysinorleucine (HLNL) in St were also lower in DM animals than normal animals. Shear force of raw meat was significantly greater in normal animals than DM for both muscles; cooked meat shear force was greater in the normal animals for the Gb muscles only, showing a good correlation with sarcomere length. Most correlations between shear force and collagen or crosslink concentrations were not significant and those that were highly significant were generally weak.

Modification of beef quality through steer age at slaughter, breed cross and growth promotants

Girard, I., Aalhus, J. L., Basarab, J. A., Larsen, I. L. and Bruce, H. L. 2012. Modification of beef quality through steer age at slaughter, breed cross and growth promotants. Can. J. Anim. Sci. 92: 175–188. A 23 factorial experiment tested the interactions of slaughter age (12–13 or 18–20 mo), growth implants use (Component E-S, TE-S), ractopamine hydrochloride (RAC) feed supplementation use and breed cross [Hereford–Aberdeen Angus (HAA) or Charolais–Red Angus (CRA)] on pH, temperature, objective colour measurements, relative myoglobin states, sarcomere lengths, shear force, and water losses of m. semitendinosus (ST) and m. gluteus medius (GM) from 112 crossbred steers. In the ST, age affected objective colour measurements by increasing chroma and decreasing lightness (L*) and hue angle (P<0.05). Metmyoglobin (MMB) content of the ST also increased with steer age (P<0.05). In the GM, yearling-fed steers had greater MMB content than calf-fed steers, while hue angle varied the opposite way (P<0.05). Other variations in meat colour and myoglobin contents were more complex in the GM than the ST as they involved three-way interactions between the different treatments. Shear force and purge loss of the ST increased with implantation (P<0.05) with no change in sarcomere length (P>0.05). Shear force standard deviation was similar for breed crosses when yearling-fed but greatest for CRA breed cross when calf-fed (P<0.05). In both muscles, purge loss was increased by RAC supplementation (P<0.05). RAC supplementation did not affect sarcomere length and shear force in both muscles (P>0.10). In the GM, shear force increased with age and with CRA genetics (P<0.05). Results indicated that producers seeking to reduce beef toughness should consider using British crossbreds, exclude the use of hormonal implants and slaughter process steers at 12 to13 mo of age.

In situ imaging highlights local structural changes during heating: the case of meat

Understanding and monitoring deformation and water content changes in meat during cooking is of prime importance. We show the possibilities offered by nuclear magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) for the in situ dynamic measurement of deformation fields and water content mapping during beef heating from 20 to 75 °C. MRIs were acquired during heating, and image registration was used to calculate the deformation field. The temperature distribution in the sample was simulated numerically to link structural modifications and water transfer to temperature values. During heating, proton density decreases because of a magnetic susceptibility drop with temperature and water expulsion due to muscle contraction. A positive relationship was found between local cumulative deformation and water content. This new approach makes it possible to identify the deformation field and water transfer simultaneously and to trace thermal history to build heuristic models linking these parameters.

Meat Science and Muscle Biology Symposium: manipulating meat tenderness by increasing the turnover of intramuscular connective tissue

Controlled reduction of the connective tissue contribution to cooked meat toughness is an objective that would have considerable financial impact in terms of added product value. The amount of intramuscular connective tissue in a muscle appears connected to its in vivo function, so reduction of the overall connective tissue content is not thought to be a viable target. However, manipulation of the state of maturity of the collagenous component is a biologically viable target; by increasing connective tissue turnover, less mature structures can be produced that are functional in vivo but more easily broken down on cooking at temperatures above 60°C, thus improving cooked meat tenderness. Recent work using cell culture models of fibroblasts derived from muscle and myoblasts has identified a range of factors that alter the activity of the principal enzymes responsible for connective tissue turnover, the matrix metalloproteinases (MMP). Fibroblasts cultured from 3 different skeletal muscles from the same animal show different cell proliferation and MMP activity, which may relate to the different connective tissue content and architecture in functionally different muscles. Expression of MMP by fibroblasts is increased by vitamins that can counter the negative effects of oxidative stress on new collagen synthesis. Preliminary work using in situ zymography of myotubes in culture also indicates increased MMP activity in the presence of epinephrine and reactive oxidative species. Comparison of the relative changes in MMP expression from muscle cells vs. fibroblasts shows that myoblasts are more responsive to a range of stimuli. Muscle cells are likely to produce more of the total MMP in muscle tissue as a whole, and the expression of latent forms of the enzymes (i.e., pro-MMP) may vary between oxidative and glycolytic muscle fibers within the same muscle. The implication is that the different muscle fiber composition of different muscles eaten as meat may influence the potential for manipulation of their connective tissue turnover.

Effects of jump training on passive mechanical stress and stiffness in rabbit skeletal muscle: role of collagen

AIMS

This study evaluated the effect of a 15-week jump training period on mechanical parameters and collagen concentration of different muscle types in rabbits, at 50, 90 and 140 days of age.

METHODS

Trained (T) animals were made to jump over obstacles in order to get food and water. The height of the obstacle was increased according to the animal's age. Control (C) animals were sedentary. Mechanical parameters (force, stress, stiffness) and collagen concentration were measured in Extensor Digitorum Longus (EDL), Rectus Femoris (RF), Semimembranosus Proprius (SMP) and Psoas Major (PSOAS).

RESULTS

Both EDL and RF collagen concentrations and passive mechanical parameters increased between 50 and 140 days of age (P<0.001), whereas SMP and PSOAS collagen concentrations decreased (P<0.001). Soluble collagen concentration decreased similarly with age in all muscles and groups. Exercise training at 140 days induced a significant increase in force (EDL 20.4% and RF 15.3%, 0.01<P<0.05), stress (EDL 26.8% and RF 22.6%, P<0.001), and stiffness (EDL 13.2% and RF 16%, 0.001<P<0.05) with a greater collagen concentration (EDL 16.1% and RF 19.1%, 0.001<P<0.05). Finally, stiffness and stress are well correlated with collagen concentration in EDL and RF muscles at 140 days (0.74<r<0.84, P<0.05).

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that jump training can increase muscle capabilities of strength and stiffness in fast-twitch mixed muscles with pennate architecture (EDL, RF). This increase is essentially mediated by a rise in cross-linked collagen fraction, coupled with a relative decrease in soluble collagen. The collagen covalent cross-links improve resistance and stability in force transmission processes during stretching.

Structural characterization of pyrrolic cross-links in collagen using a biotinylated Ehrlich's reagent

The structures of pyrrolic forms of cross-links in collagen have been confirmed by reacting collagen peptides with a biotinylated Ehrlich's reagent. This reagent was synthesized by converting the cyano group of N-methyl-N-cyanoethyl-4-aminobenzaldehyde to a carboxylic acid, followed by conjugation with biotin pentyl-amine. Derivatization of peptides from bone collagen both stabilized the pyrroles and facilitated selective isolation of the pyrrole-containing peptides using a monomeric avidin column. Reactivity of the biotinylated reagent with collagen peptides was similar to that of the standard Ehrlich reagent, but heat denaturation of the tissue before enzyme digestion resulted in the loss of about 50% of the pyrrole cross-links. Identification of a series of peptides by mass spectrometry confirmed the presence of derivatized pyrrole structures combined with between 1 and 16 amino acid residues. Almost all of the pyrrole-containing peptides appeared to be derived from N-terminal telopeptide sequences, and the nonhydroxylated (lysine-derived) form predominated over pyrrole cross-links derived from helical hydroxylysine.

Growth, slaughter and intra-muscular collagen characteristics in Garganica kids

Growth performance, ossification of metacarpal growth plate, and intra-muscular collagen characteristics in three muscles of 10 intact male Garganica kids were studied. Each week, starting from the 47th day of age to slaughter (75th day of age), kids were weighed and blood samples taken for plasma non-protein hydroxyproline analysis. At slaughter, metacarpal, metatarsal bones and metacarpal growth plate thickness were measured. The semitendinosus (ST), semimembranosus (SM), and rectus medialis (RM) muscle samples were analysed for collagen concentration and hydroxylysyl pyridinoline (HP) cross-links. ST muscle had a collagen amount higher than SM and RM (P<0.01), and RM muscle had the highest (P<0.01) HP concentration. Tenderness index was the highest (P<0.01) in RM muscle. Animal growth rates slowed, starting from 61st day of age (P<0.01); this trend coincided with a marked reduction in concentration of plasma non-protein hydroxyproline (P<0.01). In addition, plasma non-protein hydroxyproline concentration was positively correlated (r=0.61, P=0.001) with growth rate of animals, suggesting that collagen turnover decreases during a slow growth phase. Based on the metacarpal growth plate width, the rate of bone ossification appears to be slower in goats than sheep.