Effect of CpG methylation on gene expression in transfected plant protoplasts

Development of useful recombinant promoter and its expression analysis in different plant cells using confocal laser scanning microscopy

BACKGROUND

Designing functionally efficient recombinant promoters having reduced sequence homology and enhanced promoter activity will be an important step toward successful stacking or pyramiding of genes in a plant cell for developing transgenic plants expressing desired traits(s). Also basic knowledge regarding plant cell specific expression of a transgene under control of a promoter is crucial to assess the promoter's efficacy.

METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS

We have constructed a set of 10 recombinant promoters incorporating different up-stream activation sequences (UAS) of Mirabilis mosaic virus sub-genomic transcript (MS8, -306 to +27) and TATA containing core domains of Figwort mosaic virus sub-genomic transcript promoter (FS3, -271 to +31). Efficacies of recombinant promoters coupled to GUS and GFP reporter genes were tested in tobacco protoplasts. Among these, a 369-bp long hybrid sub-genomic transcript promoter (MSgt-FSgt) showed the highest activity in both transient and transgenic systems. In a transient system, MSgt-FSgt was 10.31, 2.86 and 2.18 times more active compared to the CaMV35S, MS8 and FS3 promoters, respectively. In transgenic tobacco (Nicotiana tabaccum, var. Samsun NN) and Arabidopsis plants, the MSgt-FSgt hybrid promoter showed 14.22 and 7.16 times stronger activity compared to CaMV35S promoter respectively. The correlation between GUS activity and uidA-mRNA levels in transgenic tobacco plants were identified by qRT-PCR. Both CaMV35S and MSgt-FSgt promoters caused gene silencing but the degree of silencing are less in the case of the MSgt-FSgt promoter compared to CaMV35S. Quantification of GUS activity in individual plant cells driven by the MSgt-FSgt and the CaMV35S promoter were estimated using confocal laser scanning microscopy and compared.

CONCLUSION AND SIGNIFICANCE

We propose strong recombinant promoter MSgt-FSgt, developed in this study, could be very useful for high-level constitutive expression of transgenes in a wide variety of plant cells.

The binding of nuclear factors to the as-1 element in the CaMV 35S promoter is affected by cytosine methylation in vitro

Transcriptional gene silencing (TGS) is often associated with an increased level of cytosine methylation in the affected promoters. The effect of methylation of the cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) 35S promoter sequence on its binding to factors present in the nuclei was analyzed by electrophoretic mobility shift assays using extracts of petunia flowers. Specific DNA-protein interactions were detected in the region of the CaMV 35S promoter that contains the as-1 element and the region between - 345 and - 208. The binding of protein factor(s) to the as-1 element was influenced by cytosine methylation, whereas the binding to the region between - 345 and - 208 was unaffected. The results suggest that cytosine methylation of the as-1 element potentially affects the activity of the CaMV 35S promoter.

Computational approaches to identify promoters and cis-regulatory elements in plant genomes

The identification of promoters and their regulatory elements is one of the major challenges in bioinformatics and integrates comparative, structural, and functional genomics. Many different approaches have been developed to detect conserved motifs in a set of genes that are either coregulated or orthologous. However, although recent approaches seem promising, in general, unambiguous identification of regulatory elements is not straightforward. The delineation of promoters is even harder, due to its complex nature, and in silico promoter prediction is still in its infancy. Here, we review the different approaches that have been developed for identifying promoters and their regulatory elements. We discuss the detection of cis-acting regulatory elements using word-counting or probabilistic methods (so-called "search by signal" methods) and the delineation of promoters by considering both sequence content and structural features ("search by content" methods). As an example of search by content, we explored in greater detail the association of promoters with CpG islands. However, due to differences in sequence content, the parameters used to detect CpG islands in humans and other vertebrates cannot be used for plants. Therefore, a preliminary attempt was made to define parameters that could possibly define CpG and CpNpG islands in Arabidopsis, by exploring the compositional landscape around the transcriptional start site. To this end, a data set of more than 5,000 gene sequences was built, including the promoter region, the 5'-untranslated region, and the first introns and coding exons. Preliminary analysis shows that promoter location based on the detection of potential CpG/CpNpG islands in the Arabidopsis genome is not straightforward. Nevertheless, because the landscape of CpG/CpNpG islands differs considerably between promoters and introns on the one side and exons (whether coding or not) on the other, more sophisticated approaches can probably be developed for the successful detection of "putative" CpG and CpNpG islands in plants.

Transposable elements as a molecular evolutionary force

This essay addresses the paradoxes of the complex and highly redundant genomes. The central theses developed are that: (1) the distinctive feature of complex genomes is the existence of epigenetic mechanisms that permit extremely high levels of both tandem and dispersed redundancy; (2) the special contribution of transposable elements is to modularize the genome; and (3) the labilizing forces of recombination and transposition are just barely contained, giving a dynamic genetic system of ever increasing complexity that verges on the chaotic.

The suppressor-mutator element and the evolutionary riddle of transposons

This review focuses on the epigenetic control of the maize Suppressor-mutator (Spm) transposon and the evolutionary origin of epigenetic mechanisms. Methylation of the Spm promoter prevents transcription and transposition, and the methylation of the adjacent GC-rich sequence renders the inactive state heritable. Spm encodes an epigenetic activator, TnpA, one of the two Spm-encoded transposition proteins. TnpA can reactivate an inactive, methylated Spm both transiently and heritably, and it is also a transcriptional repressor of the unmethylated Spm promoter. Features common to epigenetic mechanisms in general suggest that they originated as a means of decreasing the recombinogenicity of duplicated sequences.

Methylation of coding region alone inhibits gene expression in plant protoplasts

Derivatives of the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter lacking CG and CNG methylation targets were constructed and used to direct transcription of reporter gene constructs in transiently transformed protoplasts. Such methylation-target-free (MTF) promoters, although weaker than the 35S promoter, retain significant activity despite mutation of the as-1 element. The effect of methylation on gene expression in MTF- and 35S-promoter driven constructs was examined. Even when the promoter region was free of methylation targets, reporter gene expression was markedly reduced when cytosine residues in CG dinucleotides were methylated in vitro prior to transformation. Mosaic methylation experiments, in which only specific parts of the plasmids were methylated, revealed that methylation of the coding region alone has a negative effect on reporter gene expression. Methylation nearer the 5' end of the coding region was more inhibitory, consistent with inhibition of transcription elongation.

Hordein promoter methylation and transcriptional activity in wild-type and mutant barley endosperm

B- and C-hordein gene transcription is severely reduced in the endosperm of the regulatory barley mutant lys3a, and this is correlated with persistent hypermethylation of the promoters. In contrast, D-hordein is expressed at normal levels in the mutant. To confirm the connection between methylation and transcriptional activity, a genomic D-hordein clone was isolated and sequenced. The nucleotide composition of the promoter region revealed a CpG island and methylation analysis, using bisulphite treatment of genomic DNA, confirmed that the D-hordein promoter is unmethylated in endosperm and leaf tissue. Immunocytochemical studies localized D-hordein to the reticular component of protein bodies in both the wild-type Bomi and lys3a. Transient expression of GUS reporter gene constructs in barley endosperm, following transfection by particle bombardment revealed the D-hordein promotors. Comparison of transient expression in Bomi and lys3a endosperm demonstrated that the activities of the unmethylated D-hordein and the Hor1-14 C-hordein promoters were equivalent, while the activities in the mutant of the Horl-17 C-hordein and the Hor2-4 B-hordein promoters were reduced two- and tenfold, respectively. Methylation of plasmids in vitro prior to expression severely inhibited B- and D-hordein promoter activities. Based on these observations two categories of promoters for endosperm-specific expression of storage proteins are recognized and a model involving methylation and modulation of chromatin structure in the regulation by the Lys3 gene is presented.

Effect of the M-EcoRII methyltransferase-encoding gene on the phenotype of Nicotiana tabacum transgenic cells

The EcoRII DNA methyltransferase (M-EcoRII; MTase) modifies a cytosine in the DNA sequence CCWGG which contains a CNG methylation motif characteristic of plant DNA. The gene (ecoRIIM) encoding this MTase has been cloned into the T-DNA of the wild-type Agrobacterium Ti-plasmid pTiC58 downstream from the plant expression nopaline synthase-encoding gene promoter. Nicotiana tabacum cells have been transformed with Agrobacterium tumefaciens harbouring this recombinant Ti-plasmid. The primary transformed tabacco tissue line has given rise to novel stable lines which are morphologically distinctive. Southern hybridization analysis of all transformed tissue lines has shown the presence, in each of them, of ecoRIIM. The tissue studied differed in morphology in callus culture, dependence on phytohormones and the ability to synthesize nopaline.

DNA substrate specificity of pea DNA methylase

DNA methylase, present in low-salt extracts of nuclei prepared from Pisum sativum shoot tips, methylates model DNA substrates containing CNG trinucleotides or CI dinucleotides only. The binding to the hemimethylated trinucleotide substrates is very much stronger and more persistent than the binding to the unmethylated substrates or to the hemimethylated dinucleotide substrate. When the DNA concentration is limiting, the rate of methyl-group transfer with the hemimethylated CNG substrate is much greater than that with the unmethylated CNG. However, the Vmax. is similar for the two CNG substrates. On fractionation using Q-Sepharose, two peaks of activity are seen with different relative activities using the di- and trinucleotide substrates. The relative activity with these substrates changes during purification, during plant growth and on heating at 35 degrees C as well, indicating that more than one enzyme or more than one form of the enzyme may be present.

Cytosine methylation inhibits replication of African cassava mosaic virus by two distinct mechanisms

Extrachromosomally replicating viral DNA is usually free of cytosine methylation and viral templates methylated in vitro are poor substrates when used in replication assays. We have investigated the mechanism of inhibition of viral replication by DNA methylation using as a model the DNA A of African cassava mosaic virus. We have constructed two component helper systems which allow for separation of the transcriptional inhibition of viral genes necessary for replication from replication inhibition due to altered interaction between the replication complex and methylated viral DNA. Our results suggest that methylation-mediated reduction of viral replication is due to both repression mechanisms and that this provides two independent selection pressures for the maintenance of methylation-free replicons in infected cells.

Extrachromosomal homologous DNA recombination in plant cells is fast and is not affected by CpG methylation

Using a sensitive transient assay, we investigated extrachromosomal homologous DNA recombination (ECR) in plant cells. As the plant genome is highly C methylated, we addressed the question of whether CpG methylation has an influence on DNA recombination efficiencies. Whereas the expression level of the fully CpG-methylated DNA molecules was reduced drastically, we found no significant changes in ECR efficiencies between two partly CpG-methylated plasmids or between one fully CpG-methylated and one nonmethylated plasmid. Using a modified polymerase chain reaction analysis, we were able to detect recombination between two fully CpG-methylated plasmids. Furthermore, we characterized the kinetics of the ECR reaction. Cotransfection of plasmids carrying truncated copies of the beta-glucuronidase (GUS) gene resulted in enzyme activity with a delay of only half an hour compared with that of the plasmid carrying the functional marker gene. This indicates that the ECR reaction itself requires no more than 30 min. By polymerase chain reaction, we were able to detect the recombined GUS gene as early as 2 h after transfection. This result and the time course of the transient GUS activity indicate that ECR occurs mainly early after transfection. The biological significance of this finding is discussed, and properties of ECR and intrachromosomal recombination are compared.

Extrachromosomal homologous DNA recombination in plant cells is fast and is not affected by CpG methylation

Using a sensitive transient assay, we investigated extrachromosomal homologous DNA recombination (ECR) in plant cells. As the plant genome is highly C methylated, we addressed the question of whether CpG methylation has an influence on DNA recombination efficiencies. Whereas the expression level of the fully CpG-methylated DNA molecules was reduced drastically, we found no significant changes in ECR efficiencies between two partly CpG-methylated plasmids or between one fully CpG-methylated and one nonmethylated plasmid. Using a modified polymerase chain reaction analysis, we were able to detect recombination between two fully CpG-methylated plasmids. Furthermore, we characterized the kinetics of the ECR reaction. Cotransfection of plasmids carrying truncated copies of the beta-glucuronidase (GUS) gene resulted in enzyme activity with a delay of only half an hour compared with that of the plasmid carrying the functional marker gene. This indicates that the ECR reaction itself requires no more than 30 min. By polymerase chain reaction, we were able to detect the recombined GUS gene as early as 2 h after transfection. This result and the time course of the transient GUS activity indicate that ECR occurs mainly early after transfection. The biological significance of this finding is discussed, and properties of ECR and intrachromosomal recombination are compared.

Methylation of B-hordein genes in barley endosperm is inversely correlated with gene activity and affected by the regulatory gene Lys3

The methylation status of B-hordein genes in the developing barley endosperm was analyzed by digestion with methylation-sensitive restriction enzymes. Southern blotting revealed specific demethylation of Hpa II sites in DNA from wild-type endosperm, whereas leaf DNA and lys3a mutant endosperm DNA were highly methylated at these sites. Similar methylation patterns were observed at an Ava I site situated at position -260 in the B-hordein promoter. This differential methylation was confirmed by genomic sequencing with ligation-mediated PCR. The analyzed sequence covers most of the B-hordein promoter and includes 10 CpGs from the promoter and 4 CpGs from the adjacent coding region. These sites were all hypomethylated in wild-type endosperm, whereas--except for three partially methylated sites--full methylation was seen in leaf DNA. The four sites in the coding region were partially methylated in lys3a endosperm DNA, but the promoter sites remained highly methylated. The possible role of methylation in the regulatory function of the Lys3 gene product is discussed.

Transcriptional and translational control of gene expression in cauliflower mosaic virus

Cauliflower mosaic virus sequences have developed as a powerful tool for the study of various aspects of gene expression in plants. Analysis of the promoter/enhancer region has led to the discovery of several transcription factors and factor-binding sites. Studies on RNA processing and polyadenylation reveal a viral strategy to obtain terminal redundancy of retrovirus pregenomic RNA. Striking differences between plant and vertebrate polyadenylation signals have been disclosed. The mechanisms for translation of the polycistronic 35S RNA are novel in the eukaryotic field and may give new insight to translational control in general.