Interlaboratory evaluation of embryotoxicity in the postimplantation rat embryo culture

An Interlaboratory Evaluation of Five Pairs of Teratogens and Non-teratogens in Post-implantation Rat Embryo Culture

The usefulness of the post-implantation rat embryo culture method in screening xenobiotic compounds for developmental toxicity was validated in four laboratories with five pairs of compounds. This approach was chosen to provide information on the interlaboratory reproducibility of the results and to compare the effects of chemical analogues in embryo culture. By testing analogous compounds which are known to have different embryotoxic potencies in vivo, the discriminating power of the embryo culture method for the compound classes under study could be optimally assessed. The classes selected for testing were triazole antifungals, phthalic ester metabolites, substituted pyridines, sulphonamides and methylated xanthines. In summary, it was possible to distinguish between the compounds in three of the pairs, it was not possible to discriminate between the compounds of one pair, and it was possible to discriminate between the compounds of the other pair at two out of the four laboratories. The embryo culture results generally show a good correspondence with the embryotoxic properties of the compounds tested in vivo, although the embryo culture method appeared to be able to discriminate between only some of the pairs of chemical analogues. Some discrepancies may have arisen among the laboratories, because of methodological differences. These results suggest that the post-implantation rat embryo culture method may be a useful tool for screening xenobiotics within classes of compounds known to interfere with embryogenesis during the period of development represented in culture.

Establishment and assessment of a new human embryonic stem cell-based biomarker assay for developmental toxicity screening

A metabolic biomarker-based in vitro assay utilizing human embryonic stem (hES) cells was developed to identify the concentration of test compounds that perturbs cellular metabolism in a manner indicative of teratogenicity. This assay is designed to aid the early discovery-phase detection of potential human developmental toxicants. In this study, metabolomic data from hES cell culture media were used to assess potential biomarkers for development of a rapid in vitro teratogenicity assay. hES cells were treated with pharmaceuticals of known human teratogenicity at a concentration equivalent to their published human peak therapeutic plasma concentration. Two metabolite biomarkers (ornithine and cystine) were identified as indicators of developmental toxicity. A targeted exposure-based biomarker assay using these metabolites, along with a cytotoxicity endpoint, was then developed using a 9-point dose-response curve. The predictivity of the new assay was evaluated using a separate set of test compounds. To illustrate how the assay could be applied to compounds of unknown potential for developmental toxicity, an additional 10 compounds were evaluated that do not have data on human exposure during pregnancy, but have shown positive results in animal developmental toxicity studies. The new assay identified the potential developmental toxicants in the test set with 77% accuracy (57% sensitivity, 100% specificity). The assay had a high concordance (≥75%) with existing in vivo models, demonstrating that the new assay can predict the developmental toxicity potential of new compounds as part of discovery phase testing and provide a signal as to the likely outcome of required in vivo tests.

Inhibition of vascular endothelial growth factor-mediated angiogenesis involved in reproductive toxicity induced by sesquiterpenoids of Curcuma zedoaria in rats

The use of herbal medicine has rapidly increased in recent decades, prompting an increase in toxicity concerns. Here we investigated whether and how essential oil of Curcuma zedoaria may induce reproductive and developmental toxicity. Whole embryo culture in rats revealed that the essential oil produced a concentration-dependent toxicity ex vivo in the embryos on gestation Day 9.5 (GD9.5). Weight loss, abnormal hematological and biochemical effects on dams and embryos were also observed in GD17 pregnant rats orally administrated with 100mgkg(-1) or 200mgkg(-1) essential oil from GD7 onward. Induction of embryotoxicity may be related to placental calcification attributed to inhibition of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF)-mediated angiogenesis. Analysis by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry demonstrated that the main toxic compounds in essential oil were sesquiterpenoids. Our results suggest that the reproductive toxicity of C. zedoaria may be caused by sesquiterpenoids in the essential oil blocking VEGF-mediated angiogenesis.

Genotoxicity assessment of amaranth and allura red using Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Amaranth (E123) and Allura red (E129), very important food azo dyes used in food, drug, paper, cosmetic and textile industries, were assessed for their genotoxic potential through comet assay in yeast cells. Comet assay was standardized by with different concentration of H(2)O(2). Concentrations of Amaranth and Allura red were maintained in sorbitol buffer starting from 9.76 to 5,000 μg/mL and 1 × 10(4) cells were incubated at two different incubation temperatures 28 and 37°C. Amaranth (E123) and Allura red (E129) were found to exhibit their genotoxic effect directly in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. No significant genotoxic activity was observed for Amaranth and Allura red at 28°C but at 37°C direct relation of Amaranth concentration with comet tail was significant and no positive relation was seen with time exposure factor. At 37°C the minimum concentration of Amaranth and Allura red at which significant DNA damage observed through comet assay was 1,250 μg/mL in 2nd h post exposure time. The results indicated that food colors should be carefully used in baking products as heavy concentration of food colors could affect the fermentation process of baking.

Testing strategies for embryo-fetal toxicity of human pharmaceuticals. Animal models vs. in vitro approaches: a workshop report

Reproductive toxicity testing is characterized by high animal use. For registration of pharmaceutical compounds, developmental toxicity studies are usually conducted in both rat and rabbits. Efforts have been underway for a long time to design alternatives to animal use. Implementation has lagged, partly because of uncertainties about the applicability domain of the alternatives. The reproductive cycle is complex and not all mechanisms of development can be mimicked in vitro. Therefore, efforts are underway to characterize the available alternative tests with regard to the mechanism of action they include. One alternative test is the mouse embryonic stem cell test (EST), which has been studied since the late 1990s. It is a genuine 3R "alternative" assay as it is essentially animal-free. A meeting was held to review the state-of-the-art of various in vitro models for prediction of developmental toxicity. Although the predictivity of individual assays is improving, a battery of several assays is likely to have even higher predictivity, which is necessary for regulatory acceptance. The workshop concluded that an important first step is a thorough survey of the existing rat and rabbit studies, to fully characterize the frequency of responses and the types of effects seen. At the same time, it is important to continue the optimization of in vitro assays. As more experience accumulates, the optimal conditions, assay structure, and applicability of the alternative assays are expected to emerge.

Cytogenetic evaluation and DNA interaction studies of the food colorants amaranth, erythrosine and tartrazine

Food coloring agents, amaranth, erythrosine and tartrazine have been tested at 0.02-8mM in human peripheral blood cells in vitro, in order to investigate their genotoxic, cytotoxic and cytostatic potential. Amaranth at the highest concentration (8mM) demonstrates high genotoxicity, cytostaticity and cytotoxicity. The frequency of SCEs/cell was increased 1.7 times over the control level. Additionally, erythrosine at 8, 4 and 2mM shows a high cytotoxicity and cytostaticity. Finally, tartrazine seems to be toxic at 8 and 4mM. No signs of genotoxicity were observed. Reversely, tartrazine showed cytotoxicity at 1 and 2mM. Furthermore, spectroscopic titration studies for the interaction of these food additives with DNA showed that these dyes bind to calf thymus DNA and distinct isosbestic points are observed clearly suggesting binding of the dyes to DNA. Additionally DNA electrophoretic mobility experiments showed that these colorants are obviously capable for strong binding to linear dsDNA causing its degradation. PCR amplification of all DNA fragments (which previously were pre-treated with three different concentrations of the colorants, extracted from agarose gel after separation and then purified), seems to be attenuated with a manner dye concentration-dependent reflecting in a delayed electrophoretic mobility due to the possible binding of some molecules of the dyes. Evaluation of the data and curves were obtained after quantitative and qualitative analysis of the lanes of the gel by an analyzer computer program. Our results indicate that these food colorants had a toxic potential to human lymphocytes in vitro and it seems that they bind directly to DNA.

Evaluation of the embryotoxic potency of compounds in a newly revised high throughput embryonic stem cell test

The ability of murine-derived embryonic stem cells (D3) to differentiate into cardiomyocytes is the basis of the embryonic stem cell test (EST). With the EST, chemicals and pharmaceuticals can be assessed for their embryotoxic potency early on in the development process. In order to come to a higher throughput EST, a 96-well based method was developed based on low attachment well plates that allow for the formation of embryonic bodies from which the stem cells can differentiate. Twelve test compounds were selected based on their reported in vitro and in vivo embryotoxic potency. In the 96-well based EST, reportedly strong embryotoxic compounds 5-fluorouracil, 6-aminonicotinamide (6AN), methylmercury chloride, and hydroxyurea were correctly ranked with corresponding Relative Embryotoxic Potency values (REP, based on the EC(50) (microM) value of 6AN) of 2.6 +/- 2.9, 1, 2.0 +/- 3.1, and 0.07 +/- 0.05, respectively. Moderately embryotoxic compounds valproic acid, boric acid, methoxyacetic acid, and lithium chloride resulted in a correct ranking with REP values of 0.01 +/- 0.003, 0.001 +/- 0.001, 0.0007 +/- 0.001, and 0.0006 +/- 0.0004, respectively. The included nonembryotoxic compounds Penicillin G, acrylamide, and saccharin did not result in an inhibition of D3 cells to differentiate into cardiomyocytes, other than related to cytotoxicity (REP value of 0.00001). However, diphenhydramine resulted in an inhibitory effect similarly to the strong embryotoxic compound hydroxyurea, with a REP value of 0.40 +/- 0.36. However, further evaluation suggested this was due to direct inhibition of the contractile capacity of the D3 cardiomyocytes, rather than an embryotoxic mechanism. The 96-well based EST is a promising addition to the screening process of newly developed chemicals and pharmaceuticals.

Reproductive safety studies with genistein in rats

Genistein is a phytoestrogen that occurs naturally in the diet and is found in a wide variety of plant-derived foods especially in soybeans and soy-based foods. There is wide spread interest in genistein and related phytoestrogens as chemopreventive agents for a variety of human diseases and cancers based on epidemiologic evidence of reduced cancer rates in populations with a high intake of soy. Soy, and hence its constituents, such as genistein, have been consumed at high levels in several Asian populations for many centuries without any apparent adverse effects and to the contrary, many health benefits have been associated with the ingestion of soy based foods. Concern has been raised, however, of potential adverse effects due to the estrogenic and other activities of the isoflavones and thus a comprehensive series of safety studies was performed with genistein. To assess the teratogenic and fetal toxic potential of genistein, several studies were conducted. Genistein was tested in an in vitro rat whole embryo culture assay (WEC), which is a preliminary screen, for fetotoxic and teratogenic potential, over a concentration range of from 1 to 100 microg/mL. Treatment related anomalies were observed at concentrations of >or= 10 microg and at 100 microg/mL, all embryos were malformed. Two in vivo embryo fetal developmental safety studies were conducted with genistein by oral administration (gavage and dietary admix) in which there was no evidence for a teratogenic effect. In an oral (gavage) embryonic and fetal development pilot study, genistein was administered to rats at dose levels of 0, 20, 150 and 1000 mg/kg/day from days 6-20 of gestation to females that were allowed to litter and rear their offspring up to day 7 of lactation. A slight maternal toxicity at 1000 mg/kg/day was observed as indicated by decreased body weight and food consumption and at this dose, adverse effects in the pups were observed including increased pup mortality, poor general condition, reduced pup body weights, and reduced pup milk uptake. At the high dose of 1000 mg/kg, no external malformations were noted, however some minor visceral and skeletal variations were observed. At the low dose of 20 mg/kg/day, an increased mortality, reduced milk uptake, a decreased % male sex ratio, and decreased body weights during lactation were observed. Due to lack of effects at the mid dose and the small number of animals, a relationship to treatment was considered unlikely. In an oral (dietary admix) Prenatal developmental safety study, genistein was administered to rats at dose levels of 0, 5, 50, 100 and 500 mg/kg/day from day 5-21 of gestation. At 500 mg/kg, maternal body weight and food consumption were markedly reduced. The incidence of resorptions was markedly increased with a corresponding decrease in the number of live fetuses per dam. Fetal body weights were also reduced. No treatment-related teratogenic effects were noted during external, visceral and skeletal examination of fetuses or in body weight normalized anogenital distance. On the basis of these studies, it is concluded that genistein has no teratogenic potential in vivo at very high doses of up to 1000 mg/kg/day by oral gavage in the embryo-fetal toxicity pilot study or up to 500 mg/kg/day by dietary admix in the Prenatal developmental study even though these doses were maternally toxic and fetal-toxic. In vitro, genistein had teratogenic potential at high concentrations in the WEC screening assay, however this was not predictive of the in vivo findings. On the basis of the definitive Prenatal development study, the NOAEL for maternal toxicity and adverse effects on embryonic development was considered to be 100 mg/kg/day when administered orally by dietary admix.

Alternative methods for developmental toxicity testing

Alternatives to animal testing in developmental toxicology have been the subject of three decades of research. The aims of these investigations have been to reduce animal experimentation, to refine effect assessment and mechanistic studies, and to accelerate and simplify safety testing in an area of toxicology that uses relatively many animals. Many alternatives have been developed over the years with different compexities, using biologic material ranging from continuous cell lines to complete embryos. The validation of alternatives and their application in testing strategies is still in its infancy, although significant steps towards these aims are currently being made. The introduction of the genomics technology is a promising emerging area in developmental toxicity testing in vitro. Future application of alternatives in testing strategies for developmental toxicity may significantly gain from the inclusion of gene expression studies, given the unique programme of gene expression changes in embryonic and foetal development.

Teratogenic effects of nitroimidazopyridazine on the CNS in fetal Wistar (WU) rats

Teratogenic effects caused by a new nitroimidazopyridazine were examined in Wistar (WU) rats after repeated oral administration of 0, 2.5, 10, and 40 mg/kg, given on days 6-17 post coitum (p.c.) (Day of mating = Day 0) in a regular study on embryo-fetal development according to ICH S5A. At day 20 p.c., fetuses were removed and carefully examined under a dissecting microscope for external, visceral and skeletal malformations. The exposure to the high dose of the test compound during the organogenesis and early histogenesis periods of prenatal development induced prominent CNS malformations (exencephaly, neural tube defects (NTD)) associated with external malformations (hyperflexion of the forelimbs). To support the data from this study additional histological evaluation of the brains was performed with the following results: disorganization of the cerebral cortex associated with ectopic subcommissural organs. Additionally, an in vitro test (whole embryo culture, WEC) showed alterations of the developing neural tube after the incubation of rat embryos with the test compound on gestation days 9.5-11.5. Our data demonstrated that nitroimidazopyridazine caused NTDs and limb malformations during organogenesis. Based on these data the further development of the test compound was stopped.

The ECVAM international validation study on in vitro embryotoxicity tests: results of the definitive phase and evaluation of prediction models. European Centre for the Validation of Alternative Methods

From 1996 to 2000, ZEBET (Centre for Documentation and Evaluation of Alternative Methods to Animal Experiments at the BgVV, Berlin, Germany) coordinated the European Centre for the Validation of Alternative Methods (ECVAM) prevalidation and validation study on three embryotoxicity tests: a) a test employing embryonic stem cell lines (EST); b) the micromass (MM) test; and c) the postimplantation rat whole-embryo culture assay (WEC test). The main objectives of the study were to assess the performance of these three in vitro tests in discriminating between non- embryotoxic, weakly embryotoxic and strongly embryotoxic compounds. Phase I of the study (1997) was designed as a prevalidation phase, for test protocol optimisation, and for the establishment of a comprehensive database of in vivo and in vitro data on embryotoxic compounds. Phase II (1998-2000) involved a formal validation trial, conducted under blind conditions on 20 test compounds selected from the database, which were coded and distributed to the participating laboratories. In the preliminary phase of the validation study, six chemicals out of the 20, which showed embryotoxic potential, were tested. These results were used to define new biostatistically based prediction models (PMs) for the MM and WEC tests, and to evaluate those developed previously for the EST. As a next step, the PMs were evaluated by using the results for the remaining 14 chemicals of the definitive phase of the validation study. The three in vitro embryotoxicity tests proved to be applicable to testing a diverse group of chemicals with different embryotoxic potentials (non-embryotoxic, weakly embryotoxic, and strongly embryotoxic). The reproducibility of the three in vitro embryotoxicity tests were acceptable according to the acceptance criteria defined by the Management Team. The concordances between the embryotoxic potentials derived from the in vitro data and from the in vivo data were good for the EST and the WEC (PM2) test, and sufficient for the MM test and the WEC (PM1) tests according to the performance criteria defined by the Management Team before the formal validation study. When applying the PM of the EST to the in vitro data obtained in the definitive phase of the formal validation study, chemicals were classified correctly in 78% of the experiments. For the MM and the WEC tests, the PMs provided 70% and 80% (PM2) correct classifications, respectively. And, very importantly, an excellent predictivity (100%, except for PM1 of the WEC test, with 79%, considered as good) was obtained with strong embryotoxic chemicals in each of the three in vitro tests.

Methods of in vitro toxicology

In vitro methods are common and widely used for screening and ranking chemicals, and have also been taken into account sporadically for risk assessment purposes in the case of food additives. However, the range of food-associated compounds amenable to in vitro toxicology is considered much broader, comprising not only natural ingredients, including those from food preparation, but also compounds formed endogenously after exposure, permissible/authorised chemicals including additives, residues, supplements, chemicals from processing and packaging and contaminants. A major promise of in vitro systems is to obtain mechanism-derived information that is considered pivotal for adequate risk assessment. This paper critically reviews the entire process of risk assessment by in vitro toxicology, encompassing ongoing and future developments, with major emphasis on cytotoxicity, cellular responses, toxicokinetics, modelling, metabolism, cancer-related endpoints, developmental toxicity, prediction of allergenicity, and finally, development and application of biomarkers. It describes in depth the use of in vitro methods in strategies for characterising and predicting hazards to the human. Major weaknesses and strengths of these assay systems are addressed, together with some key issues concerning major research priorities to improve hazard identification and characterisation of food-associated chemicals.

Evaluation of various toxicants in rabbit whole-embryo culture using a new morphologically-based evaluation system

In an effort to advance the use of whole-embryo culture (WEC) techniques in the rabbit, we recently developed a gestational-age-based quantitative morphologic evaluation system for rabbit embryos. In the current study, we applied this new morphological scoring system to assess the development of rabbit gestational day (gd) 9 embryos exposed for 48 hr in WEC to the teratogens ethanol (EtOH, 154 mM), 6-aminonicotinamide (6AN, 0.15 mM), and methoxyacetic acid (MAA, 5.0 mM), and the nonteratogen penicillin G (PG, 2.0 mM). Each teratogen at the concentration tested markedly inhibited morphological development, as indicated by significantly lower morphologic scores (10.1+/-0.05, EtOH; 10.2+/-0.05, 6AN; and 9.8, MAA) relative to controls (10.6+/-0.04), and resulted in an increased percentage of malformed embryos (53%, EtOH; 57%, 6AN; 90%, MAA; and 3%, control). Embryonic growth, as measured by head length, somite number, and total embryonic protein, was significantly decreased by each teratogen. The abnormalities produced by teratogen exposure, which included brain, somite, and facial defects, were often similar to those produced following in vivo exposure in rabbits and rodents, and/or in vitro exposure in rodents. In contrast to the teratogen exposure groups, PG had no effect on embryo growth parameters, or on malformation rate (6%), although a slight but statistically significant decrease in morphology score (10.5+/-0.03) was noted. Our preliminary studies demonstrate the usefulness of the morphology evaluation system by quantifying graded differences in development, and indicate that rabbit WEC may be a useful adjunct to rodent WEC in gaining insights regarding differential interspecies sensitivity.