Phase II study of tauromustine in malignant glioma

Assessment of neurological function using the National Institute of Health Stroke Scale in patients with gliomas

Background

The evaluation of treatment response in patients with gliomas is performed using the Response Assessment in Neuro-Oncology (RANO) criteria. These criteria are based on cerebral magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), steroid use, and neurological function. However, a standardized tool for evaluating neurological function was lacking. We compared changes in the National Institute of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS) to changes in the RANO categories to determine the relationship between clinical and neuroradiological findings.

Methods

We reviewed data on all adult patients with supratentorial gliomas WHO grade II-IV who were treated at the Cantonal Hospital St. Gallen from 2008 to 2015. The NIHSS was performed prospectively at baseline and at 3-month intervals simultaneously to MRI. Associations between changes in the NIHSS and RANO categories were assessed using the Stuart-Maxwell test.

Results

Our cohort consisted of 61 patients from which 471 observations were analyzed. The most common histological diagnosis was glioblastoma (49.2%). In total, 74% of RANO categories and 81% of the NIHSS scores remained stable on follow-up. Statistically, contemporaneous changes in the RANO category did not correlate with changes in the NIHSS (P < .0001).

Conclusion

The application of the NIHSS is easy and feasible in the heterogeneous population of glioma patients. In our cohort, the RANO categories did not reflect contemporaneous changes in the NIHSS. A validated clinical outcome measure with a well-defined minimal clinically important difference is warranted in neuro-oncological research and clinical practice.

Imaging response to chemotherapy with RMP-7 and carboplatin in malignant glioma: size matters but speed does not

INTRODUCTION

In recurrent malignant glioma, early imaging response to two courses of chemotherapy is generally considered to be predictive of good survival. We studied the relationships between initial tumour volume and speed of imaging response to chemotherapy in malignant glioma.

METHODS

In 43 chemotherapy naïve patients, 26 glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) + 17 anaplastic astrocytoma (AA), median age 45 years, MRI responses to intravenous cereport and carboplatin were assessed at baseline, then at 2 monthly intervals. Patients were classified as fast responders if they had reached a partial response (PR) after two courses, and slow responders if PR was achieved after three or more courses of chemotherapy.

RESULTS

PR occurred in four patients with GBM (15%) and nine patients with AA (53%). Likelihood of response was related to initial tumour enhancing volume in GBM but not in AA. PR occurred in four of five GBM patients (80%) with initial volume < 15,000 mm3 and none of the 21 cases with an initial volume > 15,000 mm3. In patients achieving a PR, there was no association between speed or duration of response and eventual survival. Fast responders with AA were significantly older than slow responders (p = 0.033).

CONCLUSIONS

Initial enhancing volume of GBMs may be an important predictor of imaging response. This has implications where response rates of phase II studies are reported and in stratification for phase III trials. Further work is necessary to confirm these findings with other types of chemotherapy and examine the relationship between proliferation markers and speed of response.

Significant change in tests of neurological impairment in patients with brain tumours

There is a need for valid objective tests of neurological improvement or deterioration to more accurately define response or progression in phase II studies of malignant glioma. The Edinburgh Functional Impairment Tests (EFIT) incorporate objective measures of upper and lower limb function, memory and a rating scale for dysphasia. We examined the intra-observer repeatability of the (EFIT) 24 hours apart in 55 patients with brain tumors and stable neurological disease and the inter-rater repeatability in 33 patients in the perioperative period (54 dual assessments). Intra-observer studies of the four subtests, failed to demonstrate any learning effect and showed close agreement. Inter-rater studies were affected by a treatment effect (steroids) and identified slight inter-rater bias for the ten meter walk. Altman-Bland plots showed that the level of agreement was less good in patients with more severe impairment. Correction for the severity of handicap was possible using a simple formulae: (timed tests: [rater 1 - rater 2]/[rater 1 + rater 2], Williams Delayed Recall Test [WDRT] (rater 1 - 2/81). Using this correction, all intra- and inter-rater variance of patients tested within 12 hours were < 0.2. A change of > or = 0.2 for the timed tests and WDRT, and a change in dysphasia score of > or = 2, represent a significant change in impairment using the EFIT. The EFIT should be a useful addition in phase II studies where objectively recording response or time to progression is important.

Application of the MRC brain tumour prognostic index to patients with malignant glioma not managed in randomised control trial

OBJECTIVES

The MRC brain tumour prognostic index, which uses clinical variables to place patients in different outcome categories, has not been evaluated on a cohort outside a randomised controlled trial. The aims of this study were to (a) determine in a large cohort of patients, derived solely from one centre and not in a clinical trial, whether the MRC prognostic index stratified patients for outcome; (b) compare actual outcomes with those obtained in the original studies; and (c) examine whether neuropathological diagnosis was an independent prognostic variable.

METHODS

The MRC prognostic index was calculated for 236 patients with either glioblastoma or anaplastic astrocytoma managed at a dedicated neuro-oncology clinic in Edinburgh between 1989 and 1995.

RESULTS

For this mixed population of malignant glioma the median survival was 8.6 months. Two year survival was 72.2% for patients with an MRC index score of 1-10; 36.3% for those with an index score of 11-15; 25.1% for those scoring 16-20; 20.4% with those scoring 21-25; 4.8% with those scoring 26-33; and 0% for those scoring 34-38. Exclusion of 79 patients who would not have been eligible for the MRC studies from which the index was derived, because they were either too old or did not receive radiotherapy, still resulted in a similar pattern of stratification but with significantly improved median survival times for the lowest two categories. Multivariate analysis of prognostic variables in the Edinburgh cohort showed that patients with anaplastic astrocytoma did significantly better than those with glioblastoma (p<0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Although there were some differences in median survival times between the patients in the original MRC studies and the Edinburgh cohort in similar prognostic categories and a tendency to improved two year survivorship in the Edinburgh cohort these differences have arisen because (a) the Edinburgh cohort was accrued about 10 years later than the study has shown that even outside the setting of a prospective controlled trial and with relaxed inclusion criteria the Medical Research Council (MRC) prognostic index is a robust predictor of outcome in patients with malignant glioma. Survival clearly declines as the prognostic index increases. Moreover, the prognostic model can be substantially improved by the addition of histology data, although there is some evidence that this will require complex modelling procedures.

Public perceptions of brain tumours in Scotland: the need for access to appropriate information

The aim of the study was to evaluate knowledge and perceptions of brain tumours in a heterogeneous, highly educated group of adults living in Edinburgh. Two hundred and forty four respondents answered a questionnaire about the causes, effects and treatments of brain tumours. There were misconceptions about several clinical and biological aspects of intracranial tumours although most respondents were aware of the bleak prognosis associated with many neoplasms. These results, from the intellectual elite of Scotland's capital, suggest that access to information about brain tumours should be readily available. Five leaflets, covering various aspects of brain tumours, that are available through the recently established Scottish charity Brain Tumour Action seem well formulated to address areas of concern and misconception.

Management of primary malignant brain tumours

Images

The role of chemotherapy in recurrent malignant gliomas: an overview

First-line treatment of malignant gliomas invariably includes surgery when feasible, and often adjuvant radiotherapy with or without chemotherapy; at progression or recurrence, the only remaining possibility is chemotherapy. While the role of first-line treatment has been established by many randomized studies, second-line treatment is not as well defined. To analyze the difficulties encountered with cytotoxic drugs in relation to both the blood-brain barrier and drug resistance, we examined the results obtained by single-agent chemotherapy, drug combinations, and biological response modifiers. Our findings confirmed that the nitrosoureas are the most active substances at the time of recurrence; these agents give an approximately 30% global response rate, with about 20 weeks' survival. Although no comparative randomized studies regarding single- versus multiple-agent chemotherapy are available, the latter approach, including nitrosourea, can obtain an up to 40% rate of response, with survival ranging from 30 to 50 weeks. The role of interferons has been very controversial; individually, alpha- and beta-interferons seem to give a 20% response rate, with 20 weeks' survival. To date, they have never been used in combination with cytotoxic drugs, but they may prove synergistic without increasing toxicity. Studies addressing the quality of life of these patients are not available, and it is clear that we need more basic research in this field.

rhGM-CSF ameliorates neutropenia in patients with malignant glioma treated with BCNU

Nitrosoureas are the drugs most effective in the treatment of patients with intracerebral malignant glioma. Their limiting toxicity is delayed myelosuppression. A prospective, randomised crossover study of recombinant human granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (rhGM-CSF) was performed in patients receiving BCNU for relapsed glioblastoma, to investigate whether the resulting haematological toxicity profile could be modified by rhGM-CSF. Adequate data for analysis were obtained in 13 patients. Following BCNU, the nadir neutrophil count was higher in 12 out of 13 patients during the rhGM-CSF-protected cycles compared with the unprotected cycles. The median nadir was also significantly higher (1.79, CI 0.76-3.52, P < 0.005). Five episodes of neutropenia (< 2 x 10(9) l-1) occurred during the unprotected cycles compared with none in the rhGM-CSF-protected cycles (P = 0.076). There was no evidence of any effect on platelets. This result shows that the haematological toxicity profile following therapeutic doses of BCNU can be modified. It suggests that rhGM-CSF and other growth factors should be investigated for clinical efficacy in chemotherapy using nitrosoureas.

Recording neurological impairment in clinical trials of glioma

The criteria for clinical response to treatment in cerebral glioma remain poorly defined, but could be made more objective if simple measures of neurological impairments were included in the definitions. We assessed the utility of simple fast previously validated tests of limb impairment (Timed nine hole peg test and 10 meter walk), memory (Williams delayed recall test) and language (Boston Aphasia Severity Rating Scale) in fifty patients with primary brain tumours to see if they could act as a surrogate for neurological impairment. The tests were compared with established measures of physical disability (Barthel Disability Index [BDI]) and handicap. Timed tests of hand function and gait were sensitive to minor impairments and were abnormal in patients with physical disability on BDI. Timed tests correlated well with handicap (rank correlation 0.734). Short term memory was impaired more commonly with tumours involving the left hemisphere (p < 0.01). Dysphasia limited testing of memory in 8%. Depression was associated with problems in limb function (p < 0.01), memory (p < 0.001), language (p < 0.001), BDI (p < 0.001) and handicap (p < 0.001). The number of abnormal fast tests also correlated with the severity of handicap (rank correlation 0.786) indicating that memory impairment and aphasia contribute to handicap and should be assessed. Median time to complete all assessments was 7 minutes 20 seconds. Utilization of these simple tests will add sensitivity and objectivity to evaluation of neurological response in clinical trials and can be performed quickly by non medical staff.

New agents in the treatment of primary brain tumors

A review of single agent trials of cytotoxic agents in adults with high grade gliomas is presented. The rationale for testing these agents in patients with brain tumors was variable and is discussed. The criteria to evaluate responses were also variable ranging from subjective evaluation of clinical improvement with a stable radiographic assessment to the same objective response criteria utilized for solid tumors. Trials of agents specifically designed for brain tumors such as AZQ and spiromustine have been disappointing. There are encouraging results being seen in early trials of newer agents which await confirmation in larger trials but which hold promise for improving the disappointing results seen so far with chemotherapy in primary brain tumors.