Maintenance of identical p53 mutations throughout progression of squamous cell carcinomas of the tongue

The role of HOXB9 and miR-196a in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma

Background

Previous studies have demonstrated that a number of HOX genes, a family of transcription factors with key roles in early development, are up-regulated in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) and other cancers. The loci of several Homeobox (HOX) genes also contain microRNAs (miRs), including miR-196a.

Methods

Global miR expression and expression of all 39 HOX genes in normal oral keratinocytes (NOKs), oral pre-malignant (OPM) and HNSCC cells was assessed by expression microarray and qPCR and in tissues by immunohistochemistry (IHC) and qPCR of laser microdissected (LCM) tissues. Expression of miR196a and HOXB9 was reduced using anti-miR-196a and siRNA, respectively. Expression microarray profiles of anti-miR196a and pre-miR196a transfected cells were compared to parental cells in order to identify novel targets of miR-196a. Putative miR196a targets were validated by qPCR and were confirmed as binding to the 3’UTR of miR196a by a dual luciferase reporter assay combined with mutational analysis of the miR-196a binding site.

Results

miR-196a and HOXB9 are highly expressed in HNSCC compared to NOKs, a pattern also seen in HNSCC tissues by HOXB9 IHC and qPCR of miR-196a in LCM tissue. Knock-down of miR-196a expression decreased HNSCC cell migration, invasion and adhesion to fibronectin, but had no effect on proliferation. Furthermore, knock-down of HOXB9 expression decreased migration, invasion and proliferation but did not alter adhesion. We identified a novel primary mRNA transcript containing HOXB9 and miR196a-1 as predicted from in-silico analysis. Expression array analysis identified a number of miR196a targets, including MAMDC2 and HOXC8. We confirmed that MAMDC2 is a novel miR-196a target using a dual luciferase reporter assay with the effect abolished on mutation of the binding site.

Conclusions

These results show that miR-196a and HOXB9 are overexpressed, perhaps co-ordinately, as HNSCC develops and exert a pro-tumourigenic phenotype in HNSCC and OPM cells.

CDKN2A but not TP53 mutations nor HPV presence predict poor outcome in metastatic squamous cell carcinoma of the skin

Genetic alterations in metastatic cutaneous squamous cell carcinoma (CSCC) which might serve as prognostic biomarkers are not well investigated. We investigated the mutation status and protein expression of the CDKN2A (INK4a-ARF) and TP53 genes in metastatic CSCCs and correlated this with clinicopathological variables, HPV presence, and survival data. Sequence analysis was performed on formalin-fixed and paraffin-embedded tissue of 35 metastases and their primary tumors, and was correlated with immunohistochemical stainings for p53, p16 and p14. Beta-PV and alpha-PV DNA was detected using PCR-based assays. Kaplan-Meier and Cox regression methods were used for survival assessment. CDKN2A was mutated in 31% of the metastases and their primary tumors, while the TP53 gene was mutated in 51% of the metastases. P53 protein expression was significantly associated with missense type of mutations (p = 0.002). No persistent HPV types were detected. CDKN2A mutations were significantly associated with disease-specific death (p = 0.001). A significant difference was observed in disease-specific survival between patients with or without a CDKN2A mutation (p = 0.010), while this was not the case for TP53. At univariate Cox's regression analysis tumor size (p = 0.010), invasion depth (p = 0.030) and CDKN2A mutations (p = 0.040) were significantly related to shorter disease-specific survival. At multivariate Cox's regression only tumor size had an adverse effect on survival (p = 0.002). In conclusion, our study indicates that the CDKN2A mutation status might be of prognostic value in metastatic CSCCs. In most cases, CDKN2A and TP53 mutations are early genetic events in CSCC tumorigenesis. The possible role of HPV in metastatic CSCC needs further exploration.

Prognostic significance of p53 and p63 immunolocalisation in primary and matched lymph node metastasis in oral squamous cell carcinoma

This study evaluates the prognostic significance of p53 and p63 immunolocalisation in oral squamous cell carcinoma samples from 45 matched primary tumors (PT) and lymph node metastases (LNM). Data regarding patient age, gender, primary site, histological differentiation, metastasis, disease-free survival (DFS) and overall survival (OS) were available. p53 and p63 immunolabeling was detected in 17 (37.8%) and 23 (51.1%) of the PT, respectively. For LNM, there was p53 and p63 labeling in 23 (51.1%) and 26 (57.8%) cases, respectively. Most cases showed similar labeling in PT and the corresponding LNM (73.3% for p53 and 53.3% for p63, respectively). No statistically significant associations were found between p53 and p63 immunolabeling and histological differentiation; p63 positive tumors showed higher DFS (p=0.006) and OS (p=0.049); and p53-negative tumors had a higher DFS interval (p=0.009). Our findings suggest that initially p53-negative tumors and initially p63-positive tumors that retain this labeling pattern may follow less aggressive biological courses and present better prognoses.

Uncoupling of epidermal growth factor-dependent proliferation and invasion in a model of squamous carcinoma progression

Cell lines pairs were established from a primary squamous carcinoma of tongue and a lymph node metastasis and their biological behavior characterized. HN12 cells, derived from metastatic SCC, formed tumors upon subcutaneous transplantation to athymic mice, whereas HN4, derived from a primary lesion in the same individual, were non-tumorigenic in this assay. EGF stimulated proliferation of HN4 cells; in comparison, not only were metastatic HN12 cells refractory to the stimulatory effects of this growth factor but showed inhibition at higher growth factor concentrations. However, in contrast to the effects on proliferation, EGF (10 ng/ml) readily induced HN12 cells to invade in Boyden chamber assays whereas HN4 were non-invasive under these conditions. The invasive properties of HN12 cells were apparently independent of MMP-2 activity, as levels of active MMP-2 were higher in the non-invasive cells. However, EGF stimulated MMP-9 activity in invasive cells. Additionally, HN12 cells expressed constitutively high levels of active MMP-7 and MMP-3/10. The pharmacological agents LY294002, PD098059, SP600125, or SB202190 inhibited invasion of HN12 cells, suggesting requirement for phosphoinositide 3-OH kinase- and mitogen activated protein kinase-dependent pathways in the process. The data indicate that distinct biochemical differences distinguish metastatic squamous carcinoma cells from those derived from corresponding primary tumors, resulting in their contrasting biological properties.

p53 immunoexpression in non-malignant oral mucosa adjacent to oral squamous cell carcinoma: potential consequences for clinical management

p53 is a tumour suppressor gene encoding a protein whose function is impaired in a very large proportion of human cancers. The objectives of this study were to determine the natural history of p53 alterations during stages of oral carcinogenesis, by comparing p53 immunoexpression in oral squamous cell carcinomas (OSCCs), their non-malignant adjacent mucosa, and respective metastases; and to define the potential practical consequences for clinical management of p53 staining in the non-malignant adjacent mucosa. Forty-two samples of non-malignant mucosa adjacent to OSCCs, the respective carcinomas, and six lymph node metastases derived from six of the OSCCs were investigated for p53 protein expression by immunohistochemistry. Seven out of 42 (17%) non-malignant mucosal samples immediately adjacent to OSCC showed suprabasal p53 staining and this was significantly associated with moderate/severe dysplasia (p=0.02). In six of these cases (86%), the respective carcinoma showed p53 immunoexpression in more than 50% of the neoplastic cells and in the remaining case, p53 immunoexpression was found in more than 25% of the neoplastic cells. In all p53-negative carcinomas that showed p53 immunoexpression in the non-malignant adjacent mucosa, p53 staining was never detected above the basal cell layer. Lymph node metastases showed the same patterns of p53 immunoexpression as the carcinomas from which they were derived. When suprabasal p53 staining is present in non-malignant mucosa immediately adjacent to OSCCs, this suggests stable p53 alterations which are maintained upon progression to overt malignancy. The immunostaining in non-malignant mucosa of the resection margins of OSCCs might be a valuable predictor for local recurrences and may therefore have implications for the management of patients who have received surgical treatment for OSCC.

p53 tumor suppressor gene as a clonal marker in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma: p53 mutations in primary tumor and matched lymph node metastases

In order to define the diagnostic value of p53 tumor suppressor gene as a clonal marker in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC), we investigated p53 mutations in primary tumors (PT) and matched lymph node metastases (LNM); the underlying question being whether differentiation between metastatic disease of a known PT or (a metastasis of) a synchronous or metachronous second tumor is possible by means of p53 sequencing-based mutation analysis. In 15 PT, the p53 status was analyzed, following RNA isolation, cDNA synthesis and polymerase chain reaction amplification, by direct sequencing full-length mRNA. Mutations thus found were confirmed by DNA sequencing analysis of the corresponding exon in the PT. When RNA isolation was defective, DNA sequencing analysis of exons 1 through 11 was performed. In the matched LNM, DNA analysis of the corresponding exon was performed to prove the presence of the same p53 mutation. In the event of small clones not detectable by direct sequencing, an oligo ligation assay was developed to detect a specific mutation. The presence of germline mutations was excluded by DNA sequencing analysis of the corresponding exon of peripheral blood leucocytes. In 14 PT (94%), a mutation was identified. In one PT, no p53 mutation could be identified either after full-length mRNA sequencing or after sequencing exons 1 through 11. In all cases of PT and matched LNM, the mutations proved to be identical. We conclude that p53 mutations develop in carcinogenesis before metastases occur and are maintained during metastasis. Consequently, p53 may serve as a clonal marker not susceptible to change during tumor metastasis. This merits further exploration of the application of p53 mutation analysis in differentiating between metastatic disease from a known PT versus a metastasis of another second PT.

p53 expression above the basal cell layer in oral mucosa is an early event of malignant transformation and has predictive value for developing oral squamous cell carcinoma

Epithelial dysplasia is usually used to establish the prognosis of oral premalignant lesions. Its assessment, however, is subjective and does not always correctly predict the outcome of the lesions in terms of malignant transformation. Early molecular alteration(s) that dictate the development of cancer should be identified and used to evaluate oral premalignant lesions. In this context, alterations in the expression of p53 were investigated. Thirty-five oral premalignant lesions and 11 carcinomas that developed from them in a period of 16 years were investigated for p53 expression by immunohistochemistry. Normal oral mucosa from healthy individuals and oral benign lesions were used as controls. In benign lesions and normal mucosa, p53 staining, when present, was confined to the basal cell layer. Seven out of 35 (20 per cent) premalignant lesions showed p53 expression clearly above the basal cell layer and six of these (86 per cent) developed carcinomas. Suprabasal p53 expression was found in three lesions with no or mild dysplasia that developed carcinomas. All carcinomas derived from premalignant lesions with p53 suprabasal expression showed p53 expression in neoplastic cells. The combined use of histological parameters (presence of moderate or severe dysplasia) with p53 expression patterns (p53 staining above the basal cell layer) showed the highest sensitivity for the detection of lesions that progressed to carcinoma (91 per cent). When used individually, the p53 expression pattern showed higher specificity than assessment of dysplasia (96 per cent vs. 54 per cent) and higher positive predictive value (86 per cent vs. 44 per cent) for correct prediction of the malignant transformation of the lesions. The results suggest that clear expression of p53 above the basal cell layer is an early event in oral carcinogenesis and an indicator of a developing carcinoma, even preceding morphological tissue alterations. However, since immunohistochemistry cannot always detect changes in p53 expression in lesions preceding carcinoma, p53 immunohistochemical analysis is strongly recommended in conjunction with histological parameters, to increase the sensitivity of detection of cases that will progress to carcinoma.

Discordance of p53 status in matched primary tumours and metastases in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma patients

To study the use of p53 as a diagnostic tool in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC), we analysed 15 primary tumours (PT) and matched lymph node metastases (LNM) for overexpression and mutations of p53. The primary goal was to study whether differentiation between primary and metastatic disease through their p53 status would be possible. Immunohistochemistry for p53 protein (antibody BP 53-12-1) was performed. Mutations of the p53 gene were detected by exon-specific amplification of DNA (exons 4-9), followed by exon analysis using denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE). Mutant exons were sequenced. p53 overexpression was detected in seven (47%) of the PT and in seven (47%) of the LNM. 6 patients (40%) exhibited p53 protein overexpression in both PT and LNM. 2 patients had a different p53 protein expression in each sample. Mutations in the p53 gene were detected in 6 patients (40%) in the PT and in 7 patients (47%) in the LNM. In 2 patients (13%), the same mutation was found in the PT and in the LNM. 9 patients (60%) had a different mutation in each sample. We conclude that a poor correlation exists between p53 protein overexpression and p53 gene mutation in HNSCC. Also, a poor correlation for both detection techniques exists, when PT and LNM are compared. The p53 status may seem to differ between PT and LNM because of polyclonality in the PT. More sensitive detection techniques could be promising.

p53 overexpression in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma: review of the literature

As a tumour suppressor gene, the inactivation of p53 induces the development of numerous human cancers. Mutations of p53 have been implicated in the pathogenesis of head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HN-SCC) at a high incidence. In premalignant lesions and in situ carcinomas, p53 overexpression is not exclusively restricted to neoplastic cells, but frequently affects the normal appearing keratinocytes adjacent to p53 positive neoplasms or present in dysplastic areas. These results suggest that as contributors to the early phases of HN-SCC development, p53 alterations may be excellent biomarkers that indicate the predisposition of a particular oral cavity premalignant lesion toward malignancy. In most cases, the p53 overexpression status of a tumour metastasis is identical to that of a primary tumour, indicating that a p53 mutation precedes metastatic spread. In patients with multiple primary tumours, multiple foci of p53 overexpression are observed in epithelia distant from the tumour. So the expression of p53 in normal epithelium would indicate an increased risk for transformation to second or third primary cancers. Distinct p53 mutations in different primary tumours of the same patient indicate that these cancers arise as independent events; these results support the existence of multifocal polyclonal processes. Regardless of the aforementioned results that support p53 as a valid tumour biomarker, most studies have shown no relationship between the expression of p53 and clinical and histopathological parameters. The role played by p53 mutations in the progression and vital prognosis of HN-SCC has not yet been demonstrated.

Recurrences and second primary tumours in the head and neck region: differentiation by p53 mutation analysis

BACKGROUND

Patients with head and neck cancer are at high risk of developing additional primary tumours in the aerodigestive tract as a result of field cancerization phenomena. In this context, the appearance of a new neoplasm often poses a problem of differential diagnosis between recurrence and new primary tumour. The differentiation between the two entities in essentially clinical and conventionally based on the histological and spatio-temporal relations between the two lesions; however, the validity of these criteria has still to be assessed.

DESIGN

To evaluate whether field cancerization phenomena may affect the clinical diagnosis of relapse/metastasis in the head and neck region, p53 mutation pattern was analysed in a series of primary tumours and corresponding recurrences/metastases. The rationale was that, since p53 mutations are a very early and polymorphic phenomenon, a recurrence/metastasis must retain the same mutation as the the primary tumour, whereas independent tumours are likely to display a different p53 gene status.

RESULTS

Molecular analysis provided conclusive results in 9 of 12 cases analysed. The clinical diagnosis of recurrence was confirmed by molecular analysis in 4 of these cases. In contrast, a differential p53 mutation pattern supported an independent origin for 3 presumed local recurrences and 2 lung lesions.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of p53 mutation analysis as a clonality marker allowed us to ascertain the inadequacy of the current diagnostic criteria for the differentiation between a new independent tumour and recurrence/metastasis. These findings substantiate the relevance of field cancerization phenomena in the head and neck region and prompt the use of p53 mutation analysis as a fundamental tool to improve the diagnosis and management of head and neck cancers.

Review article: The role of oncogenes, tumour suppressor genes and growth factors in oral squamous cell carcinoma: a case of apoptosis versus proliferation

Mutation, deactivation and disregulated expression of oncogenes and tumour-suppressor genes may be involved in the pathogenesis of oral squamous cell carcinoma (SCC). Deactivation of the p53 tumour-suppressor gene allows cell proliferation and blocks apoptosis of malignant oral keratinocytes. Mutation in the ras oncogene results in persistent mitogenic signalling. Upregulatioed c-Myc expression, in the presence of growth factors, provides an additional proliferative signal. Loss of retinoblastoma tumour-suppressor gene (Rb) function may contribute to oral keratinocyte hyperproliferation and recent evidence suggests that simultaneous deactivation of both p53 and Rb is required for tumourigenesis. Enhanced Bcl-2 and reduced Fas expression inhibit tumour cell apoptosis and may convey resistance to cytotoxic drugs and T cell-mediated cytotoxicity, respectively. Exogenous mutagens such as tobacco, alcohol and viral oncogenes may cause altered expression of oncogenes and tumour-suppressor genes in some cases of oral SCC. The impact of these mechanisms on future therapies for oral SCC is highlighted.

Cellular immortality: a late event in the progression of human squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck associated with p53 alteration and a high frequency of allele loss

Many human tumors contain variant cells that, unlike their normal counterparts, possess indefinite proliferative potential in vitro. However, little is known of the relevance of these immortal cells to human carcinomas in vivo. To investigate immortality in a human tumor system, we established cultures from different stages of head and neck squamous carcinoma (SCC-HN). All the neoplastic cultures were transformed because they showed very low cornification in surface or suspension culture and were partially or completely resistant to suspension-induced death. Immortal variants were not detected in premalignant erythroplakia cultures, but their frequency increased with tumor progression, indicating that immortality is a late event in carcinogenesis. Some late-stage carcinomas still produced senescent cultures, but, significantly, all recurrent tumors were immortal. Immortal but not senescent carcinoma cultures were associated with p53 dysfunction and a high frequency of allele loss, indicative of tumor suppressor gene inactivation. These results show that there are at least two classes of human SCC-HN that are phenotypically and genotypically distinct and that the pathological stage of a given tumor is not necessarily indicative of the kind of cells it contains.