Evaluating the potential use of functional fibrosis to facilitate improved outcomes following volumetric muscle loss injury

Optimized Biomanufacturing for Treatment of Volumetric Muscle Loss Enables Physiomimetic Recovery

Volumetric muscle loss (VML) injuries are defined by loss of sufficient skeletal muscle to produce persistent deficits in muscle form and function, with devastating lifelong consequences to both soldiers and civilians. There are currently no satisfactory treatments for VML injuries. The work described herein details the implementation of a fully enclosed bioreactor environment (FEBE) system that efficiently interfaces with our existing automated bioprinting and advanced biomanufacturing methods for cell deposition on sheet-based scaffolds for our previously described tissue-engineered muscle repair (TEMR) technology platform. Briefly, the TEMR technology consists of a porcine bladder acellular matrix seeded with skeletal muscle progenitor cells and preconditioned via 10% uniaxial cyclic stretch in a bioreactor. Overall, TEMR implantation in an established rat tibialis anterior (TA) VML injury model can result in 60 to ∼90% functional recovery. However, our original study documented >50% failure rate. That is, more than half of the implanted TEMR constructs produced no functional improvement beyond no treatment/repair. The high failure rate was attributed to the untoward mechanical disruption of TEMR during surgical implantation. In a follow-up study, adjustments were made to the geometry of both the VML injury and the TEMR construct, and the "nonresponder" group was reduced from over half the TEMR-treated animals to just 33%. Nonetheless, additional improvement is needed for clinical applicability. The main objectives of the current study were twofold: (1) explore the use of advanced biomanufacturing methods (i.e., FEBE bioreactor) to further improve TEMR reliability (i.e., increase functional response rate), (2) determine if previously established bioprinting methods, when coupled to the customized FEBE system would further improve the rate, magnitude or amplitude of functional outcomes following TEMR implantation in the same rat TA VML injury model. The current study demonstrates the unequivocal benefits of a customized bioreactor system that reduces manipulation of TEMR during cell seeding and maturation via bioprinting while simultaneously maximizing TEMR stability throughout the biofabrication process. This new biomanufacturing strategy not only accelerated the rate of functional recovery, but also eliminated all TEMR failures. In addition, implementation of bioprinting resulted in more physiomimetic skeletal muscle characteristics of repaired muscle tissue.

Bioengineered Constructs as a Tissue Engineering-Based Therapy for Volumetric Muscle Loss

Severe skeletal muscle injuries involving substantial tissue loss can significantly impair muscle strength and functionality, reducing the quality of life for affected individuals. Such injuries, termed volumetric muscle loss, require extensive clinical intervention, as the body's innate healing mechanisms are insufficient to regenerate functional muscle. The current standard of care primarily involves autologous muscle tissue transfer, with some consideration of acellular synthetic constructs. However, both approaches have limited therapeutic efficacy, presenting challenges such as donor-site morbidity, infection risks, and suboptimal functional recovery. Over the past decade, skeletal muscle tissue engineering (SMTE) has emerged as a promising strategy for regenerating functional muscle through bioengineered constructs. Advanced biofabrication techniques, including bioprinting, have further enabled the development of synthetic constructs that closely mimic native muscle architecture. Given these advancements, a critical review of recent therapeutic strategies, their achievements, and limitations is necessary. This review examines the spectrum of bioengineered constructs developed from various biomaterials and evaluates their therapeutic potential. Special emphasis is placed on 3D bioprinting strategies and their role in creating physiologically relevant constructs for functional muscle restoration. In addition, the integration of machine learning in optimizing construct design, predicting cellular behavior, and enhancing tissue integration is discussed. The review indicates that despite significant progress in SMTE, key challenges remain, including replicating the complex structural organization of muscle tissue, minimizing fibrosis, and achieving vascularization and innervation to regenerate functional, strengthened muscle. Future research should address these barriers while prioritizing the development of translational, clinically relevant regenerative constructs. In addition, efforts should focus on advancing scalable, construct-based regenerative treatments that are readily available at the point of care and easily managed in surgical settings.

Freeze-Dried Porous Collagen Scaffolds for the Repair of Volumetric Muscle Loss Injuries

Volumetric muscle loss (VML) injuries are characterized by the traumatic loss of skeletal muscle, resulting in permanent damage to both tissue architecture and electrical excitability. To address this challenge, we previously developed a three-dimensional (3D) aligned collagen-glycosaminoglycan (CG) scaffold platform that supported in vitro myotube alignment and maturation. In this work, we assessed the ability of CG scaffolds to facilitate functional muscle recovery in a rat tibialis anterior (TA) model of VML. Functional muscle recovery was assessed following implantation of either nonconductive CG or electrically conductive CG-polypyrrole (PPy) scaffolds at 4, 8, and 12 weeks postinjury by in vivo electrical stimulation of the peroneal nerve. After 12 weeks, scaffold-treated muscles produced maximum isometric torque that was significantly greater than nontreated tissues. Histological analysis further supported these reparative outcomes with evidence of regenerating muscle fibers at the material-tissue interface in scaffold-treated tissues that were not observed in nonrepaired muscles. Scaffold-treated muscles possessed higher numbers of M1 and M2 macrophages at the injury, while conductive CG-PPy scaffold-treated muscles showed significantly higher levels of neovascularization as indicated by the presence of pericytes and endothelial cells, suggesting a persistent wound repair response not observed in nontreated tissues. Finally, only tissues treated with nonconductive CG scaffolds displayed neurofilament staining similar to native muscle, further corroborating isometric contraction data. Together, these findings show that both conductive and nonconductive CG scaffolds can facilitate improved skeletal muscle function and endogenous cellular repair, highlighting their potential use as therapeutics for VML injuries.

Hyaluronic Acid-Coated Melt Electrowritten Scaffolds Promote Myoblast Attachment, Alignment, and Differentiation

Purpose

In muscle tissues, anisotropic cell alignment is essential for optimal muscle fiber development and function. Biomaterials for muscle tissue engineering must guide cellular alignment while supporting cell proliferation and myogenic differentiation.

Methods

Here, we describe the fabrication of a tissue-engineered construct consisting of a scaffold of aligned poly(ε-caprolactone) (PCL) microfibers coated in a dynamic covalent hydrazone crosslinked hyaluronic acid (HA) hydrogel to support myoblast attachment, alignment, and differentiation. Norbornene modification of HA further enabled functionalization with fibronectin-derived arginine-glycine-aspartic acid (RGD) peptide. Scaffolds were fabricated using melt electrowriting (MEW), a three-dimensional (3D)-printing technique that uses stabilization of fluid columns to produce precisely aligned polymeric microfibers. We evaluated scaffolds with fiber diameters of 10 μm, 20 μm, and 30 μm of non-coated, HA-coated, and HA-RGD-coated MEW scaffolds through immunocytochemistry and creatine kinase activity assays.

Results

HA-coated and HA-RGD-coated scaffolds showed increased cellular attachment of C2C12 mouse skeletal myoblasts on all fiber diameters compared to non-coated scaffolds, with HA-RGD-coated scaffolds demonstrating the highest cell attachment. All scaffolds supported cellular alignment along the fibers. Cells differentiated on scaffolds showed anisotropic alignment with increased myotube formation on HA-RGD-coated scaffolds as seen by myosin heavy chain (MHC) staining. Highest creatine kinase (CK) activity on day 5 signified the successful differentiation of C2C12 cells into mature myotubes.

Conclusion

This unique combination of tunable biophysical and biochemical cues enables the creation of a biomimetic tissue engineered scaffold, providing a platform for new therapeutic approaches for muscle regeneration.

Low intensity, high frequency vibration training to improve musculoskeletal function in a mouse model of volumetric muscle loss

This study's objective was to investigate the extent to which two different levels of low-intensity vibration training (0.6 g or 1.0 g) affected musculoskeletal structure and function after a volumetric muscle loss (VML) injury in male C57BL/6J mice. All mice received a unilateral VML injury to the posterior plantar flexors. Mice were randomized into a control group (no vibration; VML-noTX), or one of two experimental groups. The two experimental groups received vibration training for 15-min/day, 5-days/week for 8 weeks at either 0.6 g (VML-0.6 g) or 1.0 g (VML-1.0 g) beginning 3-days after induction of VML. Muscles were analyzed for contractile and metabolic adaptations. Tibial bone mechanical properties and geometric structure were assessed by a three-point bending test and microcomputed tomography (µCT). Body mass-normalized peak isometric-torque was 18% less in VML-0.6 g mice compared with VML-noTx mice (p = 0.030). There were no statistically significant differences of vibration intervention on contractile power or muscle oxygen consumption (p ≥ 0.191). Bone ultimate load, but not stiffness, was ~16% greater in tibias of VML-1.0 g mice compared with those from VML-noTx mice (p = 0.048). Cortical bone volume was ~12% greater in tibias of both vibration groups compared with VML-noTx mice (p = 0.003). Importantly, cross-section moment of inertia, the primary determinant of bone ultimate load, was 44% larger in tibias of VML-0.6 g mice compared with VML-noTx mice (p = 0.006). These changes indicate that following VML, bones are more responsive to the selected vibration training parameters than muscle. Vibration training represents a possible adjuvant intervention to address bone deficits following VML.

Cell-scale porosity minimizes foreign body reaction and promotes innervated myofiber formation after volumetric muscle loss

Volumetric muscle loss (VML) from severe traumatic injuries results in irreversible loss of contractile tissue and permanent functional deficits. These injuries resist endogenous healing and clinical treatment due to excessive inflammation, leading to fibrosis, muscle fiber denervation, and impaired regeneration. Using a rodent tibialis anterior VML model, this study demonstrates microporous annealed particle (MAP) hydrogel scaffolds as a biomaterial platform for improved muscle regeneration. Unlike bulk (nanoporous) hydrogel scaffolds, MAP scaffolds enhance integration by preventing a foreign body reaction, slowing implant degradation, and promoting regenerative macrophage polarization. Cell migration and angiogenesis occur throughout the implant before MAP scaffold degradation, with muscle fibers and neuromuscular junctions forming within the scaffolds. These structures continue developing as the implant degrades, suggesting MAP hydrogel scaffolds offer a promising therapeutic approach for VML injuries.

Freeze-dried porous collagen scaffolds for the repair of volumetric muscle loss injuries

Volumetric muscle loss (VML) injuries are characterized by the traumatic loss of skeletal muscle resulting in permanent damage to both tissue architecture and electrical excitability. To address this challenge, we previously developed a 3D aligned collagen-glycosaminoglycan (CG) scaffold platform that supported in vitro myotube alignment and maturation. In this work, we assessed the ability of CG scaffolds to facilitate functional muscle recovery in a rat tibialis anterior (TA) model of VML. Functional muscle recovery was assessed following implantation of either non-conductive CG or electrically conductive CG-polypyrrole (PPy) scaffolds at 4, 8, and 12 weeks post-injury by in vivo electrical stimulation of the peroneal nerve. After 12 weeks, scaffold-treated muscles produced maximum isometric torque that was significantly greater than non-treated tissues. Histological analysis further supported these reparative outcomes with evidence of regenerating muscle fibers at the material-tissue interface in scaffold-treated tissues that was not observed in non-repaired muscles. Scaffold-treated muscles possessed higher numbers of M1 and M2 macrophages at the injury while conductive CG-PPy scaffold-treated muscles showed significantly higher levels of neovascularization as indicated by the presence of pericytes and endothelial cells, suggesting a persistent wound repair response not observed in non-treated tissues. Finally, only tissues treated with non-conductive CG scaffolds displayed neurofilament staining similar to native muscle, further corroborating isometric contraction data. Together, these findings show that CG scaffolds can facilitate improved skeletal muscle function and endogenous cellular repair, highlighting their potential use as therapeutics for VML injuries.

Biomaterials-Based Technologies in Skeletal Muscle Tissue Engineering

For many clinically prevalent severe injuries, the inherent regenerative capacity of skeletal muscle remains inadequate. Skeletal muscle tissue engineering (SMTE) seeks to meet this clinical demand. With continuous progress in biomedicine and related technologies including micro/nanotechnology and 3D printing, numerous studies have uncovered various intrinsic mechanisms regulating skeletal muscle regeneration and developed tailored biomaterial systems based on these understandings. Here, the skeletal muscle structure and regeneration process are discussed and the diverse biomaterial systems derived from various technologies are explored in detail. Biomaterials serve not merely as local niches for cell growth, but also as scaffolds endowed with structural or physicochemical properties that provide tissue regenerative cues such as topographical, electrical, and mechanical signals. They can also act as delivery systems for stem cells and bioactive molecules that have been shown as key participants in endogenous repair cascades. To achieve bench-to-bedside translation, the typical effect enabled by biomaterial systems and the potential underlying molecular mechanisms are also summarized. Insights into the roles of biomaterials in SMTE from cellular and molecular perspectives are provided. Finally, perspectives on the advancement of SMTE are provided, for which gene therapy, exosomes, and hybrid biomaterials may hold promise to make important contributions.

Recent Advances in Implantable Biomaterials for the Treatment of Volumetric Muscle Loss

BACKGROUND

Volumetric muscle loss (VML) causes pain and disability in patients who sustain traumatic injury from invasive surgical procedures, vehicle accidents, and battlefield wounds. Clinical treatment of VML injuries is challenging, and although options such as free-flap autologous grafting exist, patients inevitably develop excessive scarring and fatty infiltration, leading to muscle weakness and reduced quality of life.

SUMMARY

New bioengineering approaches, including cell therapy, drug delivery, and biomaterial implantation, have emerged as therapies to restore muscle function and structure to pre-injury levels. Of these, acellular biomaterial implants have attracted wide interest owing to their broad potential design space and high translational potential as medical devices. Implantable biomaterials fill the VML defect and create a conduit that permits the migration of regenerative cells from the intact muscle tissue to the injury site. Invading cells and regenerating myofibers are sensitive to the biomaterial's structural and biochemical properties, which can play instructive roles in guiding cell fate and organization into functional tissue.

KEY MESSAGES

Many diverse biomaterials have been developed for skeletal muscle regeneration with variations in biophysical and biochemical properties, and while many have been tested in vitro, few have proven their regenerative potential in clinically relevant in vivo models. Here, we provide an overview of recent advances in the design, fabrication, and application of acellular biomaterials made from synthetic or natural materials for the repair of VML defects. We specifically focus on biomaterials with rationally designed structural (i.e., porosity, topography, alignment) and biochemical (i.e., proteins, peptides, growth factors) components, highlighting their regenerative effects in clinically relevant VML models.

Tibial bone strength is negatively affected by volumetric muscle loss injury to the adjacent muscle in male mice

This study's objective was to investigate how contractile strength loss associated with a volumetric muscle loss (VML) injury affects the adjacent tibial bone structural and functional properties in male C57BL/6J mice. Mice were randomized into one of two experimental groups: VML-injured mice that were injured at age 12 weeks and aged to 20 weeks (8 weeks postinjury, VML) and 20-week-old age-matched uninjured mice (Uninjured-20). Tibial bone strength, mid-diaphysis cortical geometry, intrinsic material properties, and metaphyseal trabecular bone structure were assessed by three-point bending and microcomputed tomography (µCT). The plantar flexor muscle group (gastrocnemius, soleus, plantaris) was analyzed for its functional capacities, that is, peak-isometric torque and peak-isokinetic power. VML-injured limbs had 25% less peak-isometric torque and 31% less peak-isokinetic power compared to those of Uninjured-20 mice (p < 0.001). Ultimate load, but not stiffness, was significantly less (10%) in tibias of VML-injured limbs compared to those from Uninjured-20 (p = 0.014). µCT analyses showed cortical bone thickness was 6% less in tibias of VML-injured limbs compared to Uninjured-20 (p = 0.001). Importantly, tibial bone cross-section moment of inertia, the primary determinant of bone ultimate load, was 16% smaller in bones of VML-injured limbs compared to bones from Uninjured-20 (p = 0.046). Metaphyseal trabecular bone structure was also altered up to 23% in tibias of VML-injured limbs (p < 0.010). These changes in tibial bone structure and function after a VML injury occur during a natural maturation phase between the age of 12 and 20 weeks, as evidenced by Uninjured-20 mice having greater tibial bone size and strength compared to uninjured-aged 12-week mice.

Effects of Adjunct Antifibrotic Treatment within a Regenerative Rehabilitation Paradigm for Volumetric Muscle Loss

The use of a rehabilitation approach that promotes regeneration has the potential to improve the efficacy of pro-regenerative therapies and maximize functional outcomes in the treatment of volumetric muscle loss (VML). An adjunct antifibrotic treatment could further enhance functional gains by reducing fibrotic scarring. This study aimed to evaluate the potential synergistic effects of losartan, an antifibrotic pharmaceutical, paired with a voluntary wheel running rehabilitation strategy to enhance a minced muscle graft (MMG) pro-regenerative therapy in a rodent model of VML. The animals were randomly assigned into four groups: (1) antifibrotic with rehabilitation, (2) antifibrotic without rehabilitation, (3) vehicle treatment with rehabilitation, and (4) vehicle treatment without rehabilitation. At 56 days, the neuromuscular function was assessed, and muscles were collected for histological and molecular analysis. Surprisingly, we found that the losartan treatment decreased muscle function in MMG-treated VML injuries by 56 days, while the voluntary wheel running elicited no effect. Histologic and molecular analysis revealed that losartan treatment did not reduce fibrosis. These findings suggest that losartan treatment as an adjunct therapy to a regenerative rehabilitation strategy negatively impacts muscular function and fails to promote myogenesis following VML injury. There still remains a clinical need to develop a regenerative rehabilitation treatment strategy for traumatic skeletal muscle injuries. Future studies should consider optimizing the timing and duration of adjunct antifibrotic treatments to maximize functional outcomes in VML injuries.

The impact of bilateral injuries on the pathophysiology and functional outcomes of volumetric muscle loss

Volumetric muscle loss (VML)-defined as the irrecoverable loss of skeletal muscle tissue with associated persistent functional deficits-is among the most common and highly debilitating combat-related extremity injuries. This is particularly true in cases of severe polytrauma wherein multiple extremities may be involved as a result of high energy wounding mechanisms. As such, significant investment and effort has been made toward developing a clinically viable intervention capable of restoring the form and function of the affected musculature. While these investigations conducted to date have varied with respect to the species, breed, and sex of the chosen pre-clinical in-vivo model system, the majority of these studies have been performed in unilateral injury models, an aspect which may not fully exemplify the clinical representation of the multiply injured patient. Furthermore, while various components of the basal pathophysiology of VML (e.g., fibrosis and inflammation) have been investigated, relatively little effort has focused on how the pathophysiology and efficacy of pro-regenerative technologies is altered when there are multiple VML injuries. Thus, the purpose of this study was two-fold: (1) to investigate if/how the pathophysiology of unilateral VML injuries differs from bilateral VML injuries and (2) to interrogate the effect of bilateral VML injuries on the efficacy of a well-characterized regenerative therapy, minced muscle autograft (MMG). In contrast to our hypothesis, we show that bilateral VML injuries exhibit a similar systemic inflammatory response and improved muscle functional recovery, compared to unilateral injured animals. Furthermore, MMG treatment was found to only be effective at promoting an increase in functional outcomes in unilateral VML injuries. The findings presented herein add to the growing knowledge base of the pathophysiology of VML, and, importantly, reiterate the importance of comprehensively characterizing preclinical models which are utilized for early-stage screening of putative therapies as they can directly influence the translational research pipeline.

Pharmaceutical Agents for Contractile-Metabolic Dysfunction After Volumetric Muscle Loss

Volumetric muscle loss (VML) injuries represent a majority of military service member casualties and are common in civilian populations following blunt and/or penetrating traumas. Characterized as a skeletal muscle injury with permanent functional impairments, there is currently no standard for rehabilitation, leading to lifelong disability. Toward developing rehabilitative strategies, previous research demonstrates that the remaining muscle after a VML injury lacks similar levels of plasticity or adaptability as healthy, uninjured skeletal muscle. This may be due, in part, to impaired innervation and vascularization of the remaining muscle, as well as disrupted molecular signaling cascades commonly associated with muscle adaptation. The primary objective of this study was to assess the ability of four pharmacological agents with a strong record of modulating muscle contractile and metabolic function to improve functional deficits in a murine model of VML injury. Male C57BL/6 mice underwent a 15% multimuscle VML injury of the posterior hindlimb and were randomized into drug treatment groups (formoterol [FOR], 5-aminoimidazole-4-carboxamide riboside [AICAR], pioglitazone [PIO], or sildenafil [SIL]) or untreated VML group. At the end of 60 days, the injury model was first validated by comparison to age-matched injury-naive mice. Untreated VML mice had 22% less gastrocnemius muscle mass, 36% less peak-isometric torque, and 27% less maximal mitochondrial oxygen consumption rate compared to uninjured mice (p < 0.01). Experimental drug groups were, then, compared to VML untreated, and there was minimal evidence of efficacy for AICAR, PIO, or SIL in improving contractile and metabolic functional outcomes. However, FOR-treated VML mice had 18% greater peak isometric torque (p < 0.01) and permeabilized muscle fibers had 36% greater State III mitochondrial oxygen consumption rate (p < 0.01) compared to VML untreated mice, suggesting an overall improvement in muscle condition. There was minimal evidence that these benefits came from greater mitochondrial biogenesis and/or mitochondrial complex protein content, but could be due to greater enzyme activity levels for complex I and complex II. These findings suggest that FOR treatment is candidate to pair with a rehabilitative approach to maximize functional improvements in VML-injured muscle. Impact statement Volumetric muscle loss (VML) injuries result in deficiencies in strength and mobility, which have a severe impact on patient quality of life. Despite breakthroughs in tissue engineering, there are currently no treatments available that can restore function to the affected limb. Our data show that treatment of VML injuries with clinically available and FDA-approved formoterol (FOR), a beta-agonist, significantly improves strength and metabolism of VML-injured muscle. FOR is therefore a promising candidate for combined therapeutic approaches (i.e., regenerative rehabilitation) such as pairing FOR with structured rehabilitation or cell-seeded biomaterials as it may provide greater functional improvements than either strategy alone.