Comparison of different orthodontic devices for mandibular symphyseal distraction osteogenesis: A finite element study

A Novel Interdisciplinary Approach for the Management of Micrognathia (Brodie Syndrome)

This study describes a multidisciplinary approach for correcting a severe Class II malocclusion with reduced mandibular transverse dimension. A 35-year-old woman presented with an increased overjet, complaining chiefly of forwardly placed upper front teeth and unpleasant smile esthetics. The patient had a convex profile with severe mentalis strain on lip closure. Intraoral examination indicated a bilateral Class II canine relationship, scissor bite, and narrow lower arch. The skull lateral view assessment revealed a skeletal Class II relationship with reduced lower facial height. According to the diagnostic records and after consultation with the patient, surgically assisted expansion of the mandibular symphysis with a bone distractor, comprehensive orthodontic treatment, and combined jaw surgery were planned, followed by dental implant placement and prosthetic full-mouth rehabilitation. Restorative dentistry, orthodontics, and orthognathic surgery were the 3 disciplines that helped in achieving the best esthetic and functional results in this patient.

Stress effect on the mandibular dental arch by mentalis muscle over activity, finite element analysis

OBJECTIVES

The perioral muscles postural and functional abnormality should be clearly evaluated. The influence of the abnormal function of mentalis muscle on the shape and posture of the mandible was evaluated using a finite element approach.

METHODS

Finite element analysis was used to create a three-dimensional representation of a human mandible that represents a dry normal mandible with teeth (33-36 gm/cm2). Pressures were applied directly to the labial surface of the mandible's lower anterior dento-alveolar structure reflecting the normal lips muscle function. While on abnormal swallowing pattern, lip muscle force (300 gm\cm2) had been assumed.

RESULTS

Shape and postural abnormality of the mandible with malocclusion particularly at the anterior dentoalveolar and basal bone region in sagittal direction as well as inward pressure on the mandibular posterior region.

CONCLUSION

Abnormal perioral muscle function throughout growth and development may result in a shape and postural abnormality of the mandible and a companying malocclusion.

Finite element analysis of the stress released by buccinator muscle in the mandibular dental arch during sucking habits

Objectives

The effect of buccinator muscle on the mandible need to be more clarified. Finite element method used to estimate the effect of the buccinator during abnormal function on the size and shape of the mandible.

Methods

Three-dimensional model of human mandible using Finite element analysis referring to dry normal mandible with teeth as a template, The mechanical characteristic of the materials were supposed to be homogenous, isotropic, and linear elastic. Auto mesh order used to discredit the model under analysis to numerous elements; every element includes numbers of apexes called nodes; the association of elements and nodes called the finite element mesh. The force of (2 ​gm/cm²) had been applied perpendicular to buccal surface of posterior teeth within the mandible representing normal buccinators muscle function on the mandible. While for simulation of abnormal suckling, buccinators muscle force (21 ​gm∖cm²) applied to the same area.

Results

abnormal size and shape of the mandible with malocclusion especially at the posterior teeth area in transverse direction in addition to backward pressure on the chin and anterior teeth result from abnormal suckling force.

Conclusion

It could be concluded that abnormal function of buccinators during growth and development could result in size and shape variation of the mandible with concomitant malocclusion.

Does the flatting of the curve of spee affect the chewing force distribution in the mandible? (3D finite element study)

OBJECTIVE:

To search the effects of Curve of Spee (COS) flatting on the stresses and displacement on the different mandible landmarks and lower teeth during posterior teeth loading using three-dimensional (3D) finite element analysis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS:

Three-dimensional hemi mandibular model was created from real selected mandible. The lower teeth was aligned originally in a curved form with 2.4 mm depth at the cusp tip of the second premolar. Another replica with flat aligned teeth was formed to confirm the analysis by up righting premolars and molars. A load was applied at mesio-buccal cusp of the lower first molar on both models, and the resultant stresses and displacements on the mandibular landmarks and the lower teeth were tested.

RESULTS:

Von mises over the mandible was higher in flat than in curve model. The highest stress levels were detected at the Mesio-buccal cusp tip of first molar for flat and curved simulation (5053, 3304) Mpa respectively. Mesio-distally, the teeth displacement was higher in curve model than in flat one. The maximum distal displacement, in flat model, was seen in central and lateral incisors. While, in curve model, the maximum distal displacement was grasped within first and second premolars.

CONCLUSIONS:

Flatting the COS magnify the stresses over whole mandible and reduce lower teeth displacement mesio-distally. We speculated that the readjustment of the COS after orthodontic treatment could reduce the stress and displacements on the lower anterior teeth and decrease the lower anterior teeth crowding relapse.

Reconstruction of mandible using a computer-designed 3D-printed patient-specific titanium implant: a case report

Reconstruction of mandibular defects after trauma or tumor resection is one of the most challenging problems facing maxillofacial surgeons. Historically, various autografts and alloplastic materials have been used in the reconstruction of these types of defects. The use of individualized designed biomaterials has opened new possibilities in reconstructive surgery, and now, it is possible to use the patient's computed tomography (CT) to construct patient-specific implants (PSIs). A case of a large mandibular tumor resection and reconstruction of the defect using a customized 3D-printed titanium implant is described. The treatment had excellent postoperative esthetic and functional results without complications. CONCLUSION: Because titanium implants are customizable, easily workable especially with help of 3D virtual planning techniques, bioinert, and nonporous, they represent an ideal alloplastic material for mandibular reconstruction.

Three-dimensional evaluation of mandibular midline distraction: A systematic review

OBJECTIVE

To provide a literature overview on mandibular midline distraction (MMD) using three-dimensional (3D) imaging analysis techniques. Regarding different distractor types, the focus was on changes in position and/or morphology of the mandibular condyle and temporomandibular joint (TMJ), skeletal effects, dental effects, soft tissue effects, and biomechanical and masticatory effects, specifically on the mandible and TMJ.

METHODS

Studies up to March 27 2017 were included, in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) statement guidelines, using Embase, Medline OvidSP, Web-of-science, Scopus, Cochrane, and Google Scholar.

RESULTS

Thirty-one full-text papers were assessed for eligibility and 15 met the inclusion criteria: prospective (2), retrospective (2), case-report (1) and computational analysis (10). All included studies were graded low (level 4-5) for quality of evidence, using the Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine criteria.

CONCLUSION

There is a limited number of studies available, with low levels of evidence and small sample sizes. Bone-borne distraction seems preferable when taking skeletal effects into account. Tooth-borne distraction leads to significant dental tipping. Hybrid distractors combined with parasymphyseal step osteotomy seem to be the most stable under functional masticatory loads. The effects of chewing appeared to be marginal during the latency period. No permanent TMJ symptoms were reported, and little is known about soft tissue effects.

SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION

International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews, PROSPERO CRD42014010010.

A REVIEW OF FINITE ELEMENT APPLICATIONS IN ORAL AND MAXILLOFACIAL BIOMECHANICS

Finite element method (FEM) is preferred to carry out mechanical analyses for many complex biomechanical structures. For most of the biomechanical models such as oral and maxillofacial structures or patient-specific dental instruments, including nonlinearities, complicated geometries, complex material properties, or loading/boundary conditions, it is not possible to accomplish an analytical solution. The FEM is the most widely used numerical approach for such cases and found a wide range of application fields for investigating the biomechanical characteristics of oral and maxillofacial structures that are exposed to external forces or torques. The numerical results such as stress or strain distributions obtained from finite element analysis (FEA) enable dental researchers to evaluate the bone tissues subjected to the implant or prosthesis fixation from the viewpoint of (i) mechanical strength, (ii) material properties, (iii) geometry and dimensions, (iv) structural properties, (v) loading or boundary conditions, and (vi) quantity of implants or prostheses. This review paper evaluates the process of the FEA of the oral and maxillofacial structures step by step as followings: (i) a general perspective on the techniques for creating oral and maxillofacial models, (ii) definitions of material properties assigned to oral and maxillofacial tissues and related dental materials, (iii) definitions of contact types between tissue and dental instruments, (iv) details on loading and boundary conditions, and (v) meshing process.

Comparison of two preoperative protocols for mandibular symphyseal distraction osteogenesis to reduce the risk of tooth damage

Two techniques to separate the lower incisors prior to mandibular symphyseal distraction osteogenesis (MSDO) were evaluated with respect to avoiding tooth damage.

METHODS

Fifty patients (20.2 ± 7.0 years) requiring MSDO were treated with a tooth-borne appliance by utilizing two preoperative protocols to separate the central incisors: i) brackets and a V-bent wire with an open coil spring (two-step; TS; n = 24) and ii) a wire attached from the appliance to the central incisors with subsequent dento-alveolar expansion prior to surgery (one-step; OS; n = 26). The distance between the lower incisors was measured preoperatively on radiographs and measurements at the cast models were performed. Complications and radiographs were analyzed.

RESULTS

The mean distance (±SD) between the lower central incisors for OS and TS prior to surgery was 3.44 ± 1.05 and 3.18 ± 1.13 mm, respectively. The mean expansion for OS and TS was 4.3 ± 2.9 and 4.3 ± 2.7 mm at the dental level and 3.8 ± 3.2 and 4.0 ± 2.1 mm at the bone level, respectively. Four patients undergoing the TS and one patient undergoing the OS showed transient dental complications.

CONCLUSION

Pre-surgical dento-alveolar expansion by utilizing a one-step technique to separate the lower central incisors reduces the risk of permanent tooth damage and weakens the mandibular bone in the midline.

Skeletal and dental effects of tooth-borne versus hybrid devices for mandibular symphyseal distraction osteogenesis

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate and compare, retrospectively, the skeletal and dental effects of mandibular symphyseal distraction osteogenesis (MSDO) achieved through the use of tooth-borne versus hybrid distractors.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Pretreatment (T1), predistraction (T2), postdistraction (T3), and posttreatment (T4) orthodontic records were collected and analyzed for 47 patients (20 tooth-borne, 27 hybrid). At each time point, records included intraoral photographs, study models, postero-anterior cephalometric radiographs, and lateral cephalometric radiographs. Submental vertex radiographs were taken at T2, T3, and T4. Changes in a total of 18 measurements were analyzed to compare patients undergoing tooth-borne versus hybrid distraction.

RESULTS

The cumulative effects of orthodontics and MSDO produced similar gains in measured arch widths, with a decreased irregularity index in both groups (P > .05). However, there were differences in the timing during which the expansion was achieved. The hybrid distractor group gained space during the distraction phase of treatment. The tooth-borne group showed greater gains during pre- and postdistraction orthodontics. Comparisons of intercanine and interbone marker widths demonstrated a more parallel separation of bone during distraction with the hybrid distractor (P < .001). Distraction with the tooth-borne distractor was disproportionate, with greater separation of the canines in alveolar bone than of the bone markers in basal bone. During postdistraction orthodontics, the tooth-borne distractor group showed statistically greater increases in measurements.

CONCLUSION

Both skeletal and dental expansion was achieved with both appliances. Greater skeletal expansion was achieved with a hybrid distractor. Greater dental expansion was achieved with a tooth-borne distractor.

Anionic carbohydrate-containing chitosan scaffolds for bone regeneration

Scaffolds derived from naturally occurring polysaccharides have attracted significant interest in bone tissue engineering due to their excellent biocompatibility and hydrophilic nature favorable for cell attachment. In this study, we developed composite chitosan (CH) scaffolds containing anionic carbohydrate, such as chondroitin 4-sulfate (CS) or alginate (AG), with biomimetic apatite layer on their surfaces, and investigate their capacity to deliver progenitor cells (bone marrow stromal cells, BMSC) and model proteins with net-positive (histone) and net-negative charge (bovine serum albumin, BSA). The incorporation of CS or AG in CH scaffolds increased compressive modulus of the scaffolds and enhanced apatite formation. Initial burst release of histone was significantly higher than that of BSA from CH scaffold, while the addition of CS or AG in the scaffolds significantly reduced the initial burst release of histone, indicating strong electrostatic interaction between histone and negatively charged CS or AG. The apatite layer created on scaffold surfaces significantly reduced the initial burst release of both BSA and histone. Furthermore, apatite-coated scaffolds enhanced spreading, proliferation, and osteogenic differentiation of BMSC seeded on the scaffolds compared to non-coated scaffolds as assessed by live/dead and alamarBlue assays, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity, and Picrosirius red staining. This study suggests that apatite-coated CH/CS composite scaffolds have the potential as a promising osteogenic system for bone tissue engineering applications.

Comparison of stress distribution in the temporomandibular joint during jaw closing before and after symphyseal distraction: a finite element study

The aim of this study was to predict stress modification in the temporomandibular joint (TMJ) after symphyseal distraction (SD). The study was performed using three-dimensional finite element analysis using a complete mastication model. Geometric data were obtained from MRI and CT scans of a healthy male patient and each component was meshed as various regions. The distraction was performed with a 10mm expansion after simulation of a surgical vertical osteotomy line on the model in the mandibular midline region. The geometry and mesh of the bone callus were constructed. The bone callus was modelled as a strengthened region characterized by a Young's modulus corresponding to consolidated bone to predict the long-term biomechanical effect of SD. Boundary conditions for jaw closing simulations were represented by different jaw muscle load directions. The von Mises stress distributions in both joint discs and condyles during closing conditions were analysed and compared before and after SD. Stress distribution was similar in discs and on condylar surfaces in the pre- and post-distraction models. The outcomes of this study suggest that anatomical changes in TMJ structures should not predispose to long-term tissue fatigue and demonstrate the absence of clinical permanent TMJ symptoms after SD.

A finite element study on the effects of midsymphyseal distraction osteogenesis on the mandible and articular disc

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the biomechanical effect of midsymphyseal distraction osteogenesis with three types of distractors on the mandible and articular disc using a three-dimensional finite element model analysis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A virtual model of the mandible was produced from computed tomography scan images of a healthy 27-year-old man. On the finite element model of the mandible, expansion of the bone-borne, tooth-borne, and hybrid type distractors were simulated with the jaw-closing muscles. The displacement and stress distribution of the mandible and articular disc were analyzed.

RESULTS

With the bone-borne appliance the alveolar process area was displaced more than the basal bone area. The tooth-borne appliance displaced the mandibular body in a parallel manner and showed high level of the von Mises stress in the alveolar process and the ramal region as well as in the condylar neck area. The hybrid type showed medium amount of displacement and stress distribution compared with the bone-borne and tooth-borne type. At the articular disc the compressive stress was concentrated in the anteromedial and posterolateral area, and it was highest in the tooth-borne distractor, followed by hybrid appliance and bone-borne appliance.

CONCLUSIONS

The tooth-borne distractor produced more parallel bony widening in the midsymphyseal area and larger expansion in the molar region; however, it induced higher stress concentration on the articular disc than the hybrid appliance and bone-borne appliance. Whether any long-term side effects on the temporomandibular joint are anticipated, especially in tooth-borne distractor, remains to be investigated.

Introduction of the "Rotterdam mandibular distractor" and a biomechanical skull analysis of mandibular midline distraction

The Rotterdam mandibular distractor (RMD) is a slim, rigid, boneborne distractor for use in midline distraction of the mandible. We did a biomechanical study to compare the RMD with the Trans Mandibular Distractor-flex (TMD-flex). This included an anatomical biomechanical study that was conducted on 9 dentate human cadaveric heads using both the RMD and the TMD-flex. In the vertical plane less tipping was measured in the RMD group than in the TMD-flex group. Significantly less skeletal tipping was found in the horizontal plane in the RMD group (P=0.021). There was minimal difference in the intercondylar distance between the groups. As the amount of lateral displacement of the condyle was similar in both groups and there was less rotational movement in the RMD group, the TMD-flex would be expected to increase stress on the temporomandibular joint. As a result of the increased parallel widening in the vertical plane, more basal bone is being created and less relapse is expected using the RMD. The study design involves an in vitro anatomical model and conclusions must be drawn with care. At present clinical studies are under way and results will follow.

Finite element method (FEM), mechanobiology and biomimetic scaffolds in bone tissue engineering

Techniques of bone reconstructive surgery are largely based on conventional, non-cell-based therapies that rely on the use of durable materials from outside the patient's body. In contrast to conventional materials, bone tissue engineering is an interdisciplinary field that applies the principles of engineering and life sciences towards the development of biological substitutes that restore, maintain, or improve bone tissue function. Bone tissue engineering has led to great expectations for clinical surgery or various diseases that cannot be solved with traditional devices. For example, critical-sized defects in bone, whether induced by primary tumor resection, trauma, or selective surgery have in many cases presented insurmountable challenges to the current gold standard treatment for bone repair. The primary purpose of bone tissue engineering is to apply engineering principles to incite and promote the natural healing process of bone which does not occur in critical-sized defects. The total market for bone tissue regeneration and repair was valued at $1.1 billion in 2007 and is projected to increase to nearly $1.6 billion by 2014.Usually, temporary biomimetic scaffolds are utilized for accommodating cell growth and bone tissue genesis. The scaffold has to promote biological processes such as the production of extra-cellular matrix and vascularisation, furthermore the scaffold has to withstand the mechanical loads acting on it and to transfer them to the natural tissues located in the vicinity. The design of a scaffold for the guided regeneration of a bony tissue requires a multidisciplinary approach. Finite element method and mechanobiology can be used in an integrated approach to find the optimal parameters governing bone scaffold performance.In this paper, a review of the studies that through a combined use of finite element method and mechano-regulation algorithms described the possible patterns of tissue differentiation in biomimetic scaffolds for bone tissue engineering is given. Firstly, the generalities of the finite element method of structural analysis are outlined; second, the issues related to the generation of a finite element model of a given anatomical site or of a bone scaffold are discussed; thirdly, the principles on which mechanobiology is based, the principal theories as well as the main applications of mechano-regulation models in bone tissue engineering are described; finally, the limitations of the mechanobiological models and the future perspectives are indicated.

Current computational modelling trends in craniomandibular biomechanics and their clinical implications

Computational models of interactions in the craniomandibular apparatus are used with increasing frequency to study biomechanics in normal and abnormal masticatory systems. Methods and assumptions in these models can be difficult to assess by those unfamiliar with current practices in this field; health professionals are often faced with evaluating the appropriateness, validity and significance of models which are perhaps more familiar to the engineering community. This selective review offers a foundation for assessing the strength and implications of a craniomandibular modelling study. It explores different models used in general science and engineering and focuses on current best practices in biomechanics. The problem of validation is considered at some length, because this is not always fully realisable in living subjects. Rigid-body, finite element and combined approaches are discussed, with examples of their application to basic and clinically relevant problems. Some advanced software platforms currently available for modelling craniomandibular systems are mentioned. Recent studies of the face, masticatory muscles, tongue, craniomandibular skeleton, temporomandibular joint, dentition and dental implants are reviewed, and the significance of non-linear and non-isotropic material properties is emphasised. The unique challenges in clinical application are discussed, and the review concludes by posing some questions which one might reasonably expect to find answered in plausible modelling studies of the masticatory apparatus.

Analysis of the performance of different orthodontic devices for mandibular symphyseal distraction osteogenesis

The aim of this study was to investigate the performance of different orthodontic devices for mandibular symphyseal distraction osteogenesis (MSDO). Two performance parameters were analysed, the first of which concerned the stability guaranteed by a distractor in the fracture gap under mastication loads and the second the level of reliability with which a distractor transfers a given expansion to the mandibular bone, inasmuch as the more reliable the device the smaller the difference between the degree of expansion provided to the device and the displacement achieved on the mandibular arch. Hence, a non-linear finite element (FE) model of a human mandible with different devices (tooth-borne, bone-borne, and hybrid) was constructed and then utilized to assess the structural behaviour of the mandibular bone under distraction and mastication loads. An ad hoc algorithm was developed to simulate progressive expansion of the devices; a distraction protocol comprising a 10 day latency period and a 6 day distraction period was hypothesized. The first hypothetical expansion given to the device was 2 mm, and the five subsequent expansions were 1 mm. The results showed that the hybrid device was the most stable appliance under mastication loads, followed by the tooth- and bone-borne devices. However, parasitic rotations of the mandibular arms caused by mastication might counteract the benefits of distraction. The tooth-borne device was found to have the highest reliability in transferring expansion to the mandibular bone. For this device, mandibular expansion was less than the nominal aperture of the distractor by no more than 15 per cent. Lower values of reliability were achieved with the bone-borne device. As the values of the aperture of the appliances increased, the stability guaranteed in the fracture gap increased while the reliability in transferring expansion to the mandibular arch decreased.

Mechano-regulation of mesenchymal stem cell differentiation and collagen organisation during skeletal tissue repair

A number of mechano-regulation theories have been proposed that relate the differentiation pathway of mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) to their local biomechanical environment. During spontaneous repair processes in skeletal tissues, the organisation of the extracellular matrix is a key determinant of its mechanical fitness. In this paper, we extend the mechano-regulation theory proposed by Prendergast et al. (J Biomech 30(6):539-548, 1997) to include the role of the mechanical environment on the collagen architecture in regenerating soft tissues. A large strain anisotropic poroelastic material model is used in a simulation of tissue differentiation in a fracture subject to cyclic bending (Cullinane et al. in J Orthop Res 20(3):579-586, 2002). The model predicts non-union with cartilage and fibrous tissue formation in the defect. Predicted collagen fibre angles, as determined by the principal decomposition of strain- and stress-type tensors, are similar to the architecture seen in native articular cartilage and neoarthroses induced by bending of mid-femoral defects in rats. Both stress and strain-based remodelling stimuli successfully predicted the general patterns of collagen fibre organisation observed in vivo. This provides further evidence that collagen organisation during tissue differentiation is determined by the mechanical environment. It is envisioned that such predictive models can play a key role in optimising MSC-based skeletal repair therapies where recapitulation of the normal tissue architecture is critical to successful repair.