Ex Vivo Allograft Perfusion for Complex Pediatric Heart Transplant Recipients

Clinical Outcomes of Machine Perfusion and Temperature Control Systems in Heart Transplantation: Where We Stand

Heart transplantation remains the preferred treatment for carefully selected patients with end-stage heart failure refractory to medical therapy. Advances in donor management, organ preservation, donor and recipient selection, immunosuppressive strategies, and mechanical circulatory support have significantly improved the safety and efficacy of heart transplantation. However, the persistent shortage of donor hearts and their limited preservation period continues to restrict access to this lifesaving procedure. The advent of innovative machine perfusion and temperature control systems for heart allograft preservation offers a promising avenue to address these challenges. These technologies aim to extend preservation times and enable the use of extended-criteria donors, thereby expanding the donor pool. In this review, we examine the outcomes from clinical trials, registry data, and single-center studies, utilizing the TransMedics Organ Care System Heart, Paragonix SherpaPak Cardiac Transport System, and XVIVO Heart Preservation System. As the field of heart transplantation evolves to accommodate longer ischemia times, expand organ sharing, and utilize donors previously considered marginal, the integration of these advanced technologies will be essential for optimizing post-transplant outcomes.

Severe primary graft failure: Are there lasting impacts? Analysis from the PHTS Database

Background

Primary graft failure (PGF) is a leading cause of early morbidity and mortality after heart transplantation (HTx). PGF is secondary to graft ischemia and ischemia-reperfusion injuries to the cardiomyocytes and vasculature of the donor heart after transplantation. Longer-term outcomes after PGF are not well studied.

Methods

Patients with an HTx (January 1, 2010 to June 30, 2022) were identified using the Pediatric Heart Transplant Society registry. PGF was defined as death, retransplantation, or need for mechanical circulatory support within 72 hours of HTx. Kaplan-Meier analysis and Cox proportional hazard modeling were utilized.

Results

Of the 4,982 patients with a primary HTx, 5.4% (n = 269) met criteria for PGF. Patients with PGF were younger, with higher proportion of congenital heart disease, longer cardiopulmonary bypass and ischemic times (IT), and more likely to be on extracorporeal membrane oxygenation or ventilator at HTx (all p < 0.0001, IT p = 0.0006). PGF resulted in lower overall survival (1 year: 54% vs 94%, p < 0.001). This remained true when conditional survival was examined at 30 and 90 days but not at 1 year (p = 0.1143). Freedom from rejection did not differ between the groups at overall or conditional on 30 days but was slightly higher for those with PGF at 90 and 365 days. There was no difference in freedom from coronary allograft vasculopathy (CAV). PGF was an independent predictor of overall graft loss (hazard ratios [HR] 4.7, p < 0.0001) and conditional survival to 30 days (HR 2.47, p < 0.0001) and 90 days (HR 1.6, p = 0.012) but not beyond 1 year.

Conclusions

Severe PGF is an independent predictor of early mortality post-HTx but subsequently does not further impact long-term survival, overall risk of rejection, or CAV. Understanding the impact of milder forms of PGF on survival and long-term outcomes is still needed. Methods to decrease the risk of PGF, such as alternative preservation and storage techniques, may impact early mortality post-HTx.

Ex vivo heart perfusion: an updated systematic review

Due to the discrepancy between patients awaiting a heart transplant and the availability of donor hearts, strategies to expand the donor pool and improve the transplant's success are crucial. This review aims to summarize current knowledge on the ex vivo heart preservation (EVHP) experience as an alternative to standard cold static storage (CSS). EVHP techniques can improve the preservation of the donor's heart before transplantation and allow for pre-transplant organ evaluation.

Preservation of human heart valves for replacement in children with heart valve disease: past, present and future

Valvular heart disease affects 30% of the new-borns with congenital heart disease. Valve replacement of semilunar valves by mechanical, bioprosthetic or donor allograft valves is the main treatment approach. However, none of the replacements provides a viable valve that can grow and/or adapt with the growth of the child leading to re-operation throughout life. In this study, we review the impact of donor valve preservation on moving towards a more viable valve alternative for valve replacements in children or young adults.

An integrated program to expand donor utilization in pediatric heart transplantation: Case report of successful transplant with multiple donor risk factors

BACKGROUND

Pediatric heart transplantation (HT) continues to be limited by the shortage of donor organs, distance constraints, and the number of potential donor offers that are declined due to the presence of multiple risk factors.

METHODS

We report a case of successful pediatric HT in which multiple risk factors were mitigated through a combination of innovative donor utilization improvement strategies.

RESULTS

An 11-year-old, 25-kilogram child with cardiomyopathy and pulmonary hypertension, on chronic milrinone therapy and anticoagulated with apixaban, was transplanted with a heart from a Hepatitis C virus positive donor and an increased donor-to-recipient weight ratio. Due to extended geographic distance, an extracorporeal heart preservation system (TransMedics™ OCS Heart) was used for procurement. No significant bleeding was observed post-operatively, and she was discharged by post-operative day 15 with normal biventricular systolic function. Post-transplant Hepatitis C virus seroconversion was successfully treated.

CONCLUSIONS

Heart transplantation in donors with multiple risk factor can be achieved with an integrative team approach and should be taken into consideration when evaluating marginal donors in order to expand the current limited donor pool in pediatric patients.

Family perspectives of ex situ heart perfusion

BACKGROUND

Pediatric patients awaiting a heart transplant have high waitlist mortality. Several strategies have been utilized to decrease waiting times, but a mortality risk still exists. New medical technologies may improve waiting times and associated mortality. Ex situ heart perfusion (ESHP) is one such technology, which can decrease the impact of cold ischemia on the donor heart and allow for a longer out-of-body time. Adoption of such technology in pediatric heart transplantation will require support from end users, including patient and families. The aim of this qualitative study was to report the perspectives of families with experience related to pediatric HTx toward ESHP.

METHODS

Semistructured interviews were conducted with 12 parents or guardians of children who were awaiting or received heart transplantation. Interviews were transcribed, and data were analyzed using qualitative content analysis.

RESULTS

Participants expressed varied awareness and knowledge of ESHP. Independent of their understanding of ESHP, all purported that ESHP was an excellent idea and that this technology should be implemented in the pediatric population. They did not identify fundamentally different ethical issues or concerns for ESHP being used relative to other medical technologies. Overall, most participants described consent processes for ESHP should be like any other procedure. All agreed that the surgeon should continue to describe the overall health of the donor heart, provide their medical recommendations, and allow families to have the final say.

CONCLUSIONS

The concepts described by the parents and guardians are important in moving this novel technology forward. This information will serve the basis for knowledge translation that will provide educational resources to broaden the understanding and reach of ESHP.

The Impact of Ex Situ Heart Perfusion in Pediatric Transplantation: An Analysis of the OPTN Database

Ex situ heart perfusion (ESHP) has increased the pool of donors in adults. However, this is not true in pediatrics due to lack of devices. Therefore, we sought to understand organ refusal in pediatrics and estimate donor heart usage with ESHP. Donor hearts offered to pediatrics were identified from the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network Database (2000-2019). A linear regression model was built to predict average travel speed, and the extended maximum permitted distance with ESHP was calculated. This extended distance was compared with the policy for maximum travel distance. There were 33,708 donor offers (n = 10,807 hearts) to pediatric programs [24.1% (n = 2,604) transplanted]. Six percent of the offers (n = 1,832) (n = 771 hearts) were turned down due to distance, with 676 of the hearts never transplanted. Based on the modeling and using an ESHP time of 5.5 hours, 84% (n = 570/676) of hearts turned down due to distance could be utilized by pediatric programs. This proportion increased to 100% with 10 hours of support time. By addressing prolonged ischemic time due to distance, ESHP has the potential to increase the number of donors utilized in pediatric candidates. Although no device exists for pediatrics, this analysis lends support to the importance of developing this technology.

Heart Transplantation in High-Risk Recipients Employing Donor Marginal Grafts Preserved With Ex-Vivo Perfusion

Extending selection criteria to face donor organ shortage in heart transplantation (HTx) may increase the risk of mortality. Ex-vivo normothermic perfusion (EVP) limits ischemic time allowing assessment of graft function. We investigated the outcome of HTx in 80 high-risk recipients transplanted with marginal donor and EVP-preserved grafts, from 2016 to 2021. The recipients median age was 57 years (range, 13-75), with chronic renal failure in 61%, impaired liver function in 11% and previous cardiac surgery in 90%; 80% were mechanically supported. Median RADIAL score was 3. Mean graft ischemic time was 118 ± 25 min, "out-of-body" time 420 ± 66 min and median cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) time 228 min (126-416). In-hospital mortality was 11% and ≥moderate primary graft dysfunction 16%. At univariable analysis, CPB time and high central venous pressure were risk factors for mortality. Actuarial survival at 1 and 3 years was 83% ± 4%, and 72% ± 7%, with a median follow-up of 16 months (range 2-43). Recipient and donor ages, pre-HTx extracorporeal life support and intra-aortic balloon pump were risk factors for late mortality. In conclusion, the use of EVP allows extension of the graft pool by recruitment of marginal donors to successfully perform HTx even in high-risk recipients.

Thoracic organ machine perfusion: A review of concepts with a focus on reconditioning therapies

Thoracic organ transplantation, including lung, heart, and heart-lung transplants are highly regarded as gold standard treatments for patients suffering from heart failure or chronic end stage lung conditions. The relatively high prevalence of conditions necessitating thoracic organ transplants combined with the lack of available organs has resulted in many either dying or becoming too ill to receive a transplant while on the waiting list. There is a dire need to increase both the number of organs available and the utilization of such organs. Improved preservation techniques beyond static storage have shown great potential to lengthen the current period of viability of thoracic organs while outside the body, promising better utilization rates, increased donation distance, and improved matching of donors to recipients. Ex-situ organ perfusion (ESOP) can also make some novel therapeutic strategies viable, and the combination of the ESOP platform with such reconditioning therapies endeavors to better improve functional preservation of organs in addition to making more organs viable for transplantation. Given the abundance of clinical and pre-clinical studies surrounding reconditioning of thoracic organs in combination with ESOP, we summarize in this review important concepts and research regarding thoracic organ machine perfusion in combination with reconditioning therapies.

The Impact of Ex Situ Heart Perfusion in Pediatric Transplantation: An Analysis of the United Network for Organ Sharing Registry

Ex situ heart perfusion (ESHP) has increased the pool of donors in adults. However, this is not true in pediatrics due to lack of devices. Therefore, we sought to understand organ refusal in pediatrics and estimate donor heart usage with ESHP. Donor hearts offered to pediatrics were identified from the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) Database (2000-2019). A linear regression model was built to predict average travel speed, and the extended maximum permitted distance with ESHP was calculated. This extended distance was compared with the policy for maximum travel distance. There were 33,708 donor offers (n = 10,807 hearts) to pediatric programs (24.1% [n = 2,604] transplanted). Six percent of the offers (n = 1,832) (n = 771 hearts) were turned down due to distance, with 676 of the hearts never transplanted. Based on the modeling and using an ESHP time of 5.5 hours, 84% (n = 570/676) of hearts turned down as distance could be utilized by pediatric programs. This proportion increased to 100% with 10 hours of support time. By addressing prolonged ischemic time due to distance, ESHP has the potential to increase the number of donors utilized in pediatric candidates. While no device exists for pediatrics, this analysis lends support to the importance of developing this technology.

Barriers and misconceptions of ex situ heart perfusion in pediatric donation

BACKGROUND

Despite efforts, pediatric HTx candidates continue to have high waitlist mortality due to limited donor availability. However, there is a significant number of offered hearts not used due to concerns of viability. ESHP is a method for continuous perfusion of the donor heart that allows assessment and extended out-of-body time. It is imperative to understand healthcare stakeholders' perspectives on ESHP for implementation. Therefore, the aims of this qualitative study were to: (1) Explore pediatric stakeholders' perspectives toward ESHP; and (2) Identify barriers to widespread adoption of this technology.

METHODS

Virtual focus groups were completed with pediatric HTx healthcare professional stakeholders. Following transcription of audio-recordings, the material was analyzed using content analysis.

RESULTS

Four focus groups were completed with 17 participants, representing 12 institutions and three countries. Focus groups revealed varied understanding of both current and potential uses of ESHP. Participants did see the potential benefits of extending out-of-body time for and the ability to evaluate donor heart quality. However, concerns were expressed relating to patient selection, wait-list times, post-HTx outcomes, adverse events, and technical issues. These were felt to be important to understand in order to justify the costs of ESHP and impact on the healthcare system.

CONCLUSIONS

This project represents the first qualitative formative evaluation of ESHP in pediatrics. The knowledge gained from stakeholders will form the basis for education initiatives, clinical trial design, and roll-out of new ESHP technologies designed for pediatrics.

Expanding Donor Heart Utilization Through Machine Perfusion Technologies

Purpose of Review

Recent advances in donor heart preservation have allowed the utilization of hearts that would typically be discarded due to prolonged ischemic times or donation via the circulatory death pathway. This review will discuss recent advances in donor heart preservation including optimization of machine perfusion technologies and future strategies of potential benefit for the donor heart and transplant outcomes.

Recent Findings

Improvements in organ preservation strategies have enabled retrieval of donor hearts that were not ideal for static cold storage. Machine perfusion (normothermic and hypothermic) and normothermic regional perfusion have ultimately expanded the donor pool for adult heart transplantation. Xenotransplantation has also incorporated machine perfusion for porcine donor heart preservation.

Summary

Traditional static cold storage is feasible for non-complex donors and transplants. Machine perfusion has enabled increased donor heart utilization however optimal preservation strategies are dependent on the donor criteria, predicted ischemic times and surgical complexity.

Is the Organ Care System (OCS) Still the First Choice With Emerging New Strategies for Donation After Circulatory Death (DCD) in Heart Transplant?

The scarcity of donor hearts continues to be a challenge in transplants for advanced heart failure patients. With an increasing number of patients on the waiting list for a heart transplant, the discrepancy in the number between donors and recipients is gradually increasing and poses a new challenge that plagues the healthcare systems when it comes to the heart. Several technologies have been developed to expand the donor pool in recent years. One such method is the organ care system (OCS). The standard method of organ preservation is the static cold storage (SCS) method which allows up to four hours of safe preservation of the heart. However, beyond four hours of cold ischemia, the incidence of primary graft dysfunction increases significantly. OCS keeps the heart perfused close to the physiological state beyond the four hours with superior results, which allows us to travel further and longer distances, leading to expansion in the donor pool. In this review, we discuss the OCS system, its advantages, and shortcomings.

Normothermic Ex Situ Heart Perfusion With the Organ Care System for Cardiac Transplantation: A Meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Heart transplantation (HTx) is, at present, the most effective therapy for end-stage heart failure patients; however, the number of patients on the waiting list is rising globally, further increasing the gap between demand and supply of donors for HTx. First studies using the Organ Care System (OCS) for normothermic machine perfusion show promising results yet are limited in sample size. This article presents a meta-analysis of heart donation either after brain death (OCS-DBD) or circulatory death (OCS-DCD) on using OCS versus static cold storage used for HTx.

METHODS

A systematic literature search was performed for articles discussing the use of normothermic ex situ heart perfusion in adult patients. Thirty-day survival outcomes were pooled, and odds ratios were calculated using random-effects models. Long-term survival was visualized with Kaplan-Meier curves, hazard ratios were calculated and pooled using fixed-effects models, and secondary outcomes were analyzed.

RESULTS

A total of 12 studies were included, with 741 patients undergoing HTx, of which 260 with the OCS (173 DBD and 87 DCD). No differences were found between the 3 groups for early and late survival outcomes or for secondary outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

OCS outcomes, for both DBD and DCD hearts, appeared similar as for static cold storage. Therefore, OCS is a safe and effective technique to enlarge the cardiac donor pool in both DBD and DCD, with additional benefits for long-distance transport and surgically complex procedures.