Clinical features of prolonged tilt-induced hypotension with an apparent vasovagal mechanism, but without syncope

Haemodynamic Patterns in Reflex Syncope: Insights from Head-Up Tilt Tests in Adults and Children

Introduction: Vasovagal syncope is a prevalent condition marked by transient loss of consciousness due to abrupt decreases in systemic blood pressure and/or heart rate. Despite its clinical impact, the underlying haemodynamic mechanisms remain poorly defined, and data on age-related differences are limited and sometimes contradictory. Objectives: This study aimed to characterise haemodynamic adaptation patterns during a head-up tilt (HUT) test in adult (≥18 years) and paediatric (<18 years) patients with recurrent reflex syncope, compared with healthy adult controls. We sought to identify distinct temporal haemodynamic signatures and clarify potential age-related differences in syncope mechanisms. Methods: In this prospective observational study, participants underwent continuous beat-to-beat monitoring of cardiac output (CO), stroke volume (SV), heart rate (HR), and total peripheral resistance (TPR) during HUT. Linear mixed-effects models were used to examine time-by-group interactions, and post-hoc analyses were adjusted for multiple comparisons. Effect sizes and confidence intervals (CIs) were reported to quantify the magnitude of differences. Results: A total of 187 fainters (paediatric n = 81, adult n = 106) and 108 non-fainters (including 30 healthy controls) were studied. Compared to adult fainters, paediatric fainters showed a 24% larger decline in CO from baseline (mean difference of 1.1 L/min [95% CI: 0.5-1.7], p = 0.003) and a 15-20 bpm higher peak HR (p = 0.001) during presyncope. Both subgroups experienced significant drops in TPR, which were more pronounced in paediatric fainters (effect size = 0.27, 95% CI: 0.12-0.42). Non-fainters (including controls) maintained relatively stable haemodynamics, with no significant decrease in CO or TPR (p > 0.05). Age-related comparisons indicated a heavier reliance on HR modulation in paediatric fainters, leading to an earlier transition from compensated to pre-syncopal states. Conclusions: These findings demonstrate that paediatric fainters exhibit more abrupt decreases in CO and TPR than adults, alongside higher HR responses during orthostatic stress. Targeted interventions that address this heightened chronotropic dependency-such as tilt-training protocols or strategies to improve venous return-may be particularly beneficial in younger patients. An age-specific approach to diagnosis and management could improve risk stratification, minimise recurrent episodes, and enhance patient outcomes.

New hemodynamic criteria to separate classical orthostatic hypotension from vasovagal syncope

OBJECTIVE

To define and evaluate hemodynamic criteria to distinguish between classical orthostatic hypotension (cOH) and vasovagal syncope (VVS) in tilt table testing (TTT).

METHODS

Inclusion criteria for VVS were a history of VVS and tilt-induced syncope defined as a blood pressure (BP) decrease and electroencephalographic changes during syncope with complaint recognition. Criteria for cOH were a history of cOH and a BP decrease meeting published criteria. Clinical diagnoses were established prior to TTT. We assessed (1) whether the decrease of systolic BP accelerated, "convex," or decelerated, "concave"; (2) the time from head-up tilt to when BP reached one-half its maximal decrease; (3) the difference between baseline heart rate (HR) and HR at BP nadir. We calculated the diagnostic yield of optimized thresholds of these features and their combinations.

RESULTS

We included 82 VVS cases (40% men, median age 44 years) and 65 cOH cases (66% men, median age 70 years). BP decrease was concave in cOH in 79% and convex in VVS in 94% (p < 0.001). The time to reach half the BP decrease was shorter in cOH (median 34 sec, interquartile range (IQR) 19-98 sec) than in VVS (median 1571 sec, IQR 1381-1775 sec, p < 0.001). Mean HR increased by 11 ± 11 bpm in cOH and decreased by 20 ± 19 bpm in VVS (p < 0.001). When all three features pointed to VVS, sensitivity for VVS was 82% and specificity was 100%. When all three pointed to cOH, sensitivity for cOH was 71% and specificity was 100%.

INTERPRETATION

These new hemodynamic criteria reliably differentiate cOH from VVS.

The predictive value of urine specific gravity in the diagnosis of vasovagal syncope in children and adolescents

BACKGROUND

Vasovagal syncope (VVS) is a kind of common neurally mediated syncope in children and adolescents. Decreased blood volume is one of the pathogenesis of VVS. The diagnosis of VVS is mainly based on head-up tilt test (HUTT), but some complications may easily occur when HUTT induces syncope. To find a simple and safe VVS diagnosis method can improve the VVS diagnosis efficiency.

AIMS OF THE STUDY

This was a prospective study. The study will explore the predictive value of urine specific gravity (USG) in the diagnosis of VVS in children and adolescents.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Ninety-seven cases (43 males and 54 females, aged 4 to 16 years old, with an average age of 10.91 ± 2.18 years old) hospitalized due to unexplained premonitory syncope or syncope and diagnosed with VVS through HUTT from September 2014 to September 2018 were selected as VVS group. During the same period, 91 cases of children and adolescents, including 45 males and 46 females, aged from 5 to 15 years old, who underwent a healthy examination were matched as a control (control group). USG was measured in both groups.

RESULTS

The USG of VVS group was significantly lower than that of the control group (P < 0.01), and USG of females was lower than that of males in VVS group (P = 0.045). The sensitivity and specificity of USG in predicting VVS were evaluated by ROC curve. The area under the ROC curve was 0.751, standard error was 0.035, and 95% CI (0.683, 0.819) suggested that USG was of moderate predictive value in the diagnosis of VVS. As cut-off value of USG was 1.0185, the sensitivity and specificity and diagnostic coincidence rate of VVS were 74.39, 66.04 and 69.68%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

There are less USG in children and adolescents with VVS, especially lower USG in females. Therefore, USG has predictive value in the diagnosis of VVS in children and adolescents.

Novel Methods for Quantification of Vasodepression and Cardioinhibition During Tilt-Induced Vasovagal Syncope

Rationale:

Assessing the relative contributions of cardioinhibition and vasodepression to the blood pressure (BP) decrease in tilt-induced vasovagal syncope requires methods that reflect BP physiology accurately.

Objective:

To assess the relative contributions of cardioinhibition and vasodepression to tilt-induced vasovagal syncope using novel methods.

Methods and Results:

We studied the parameters determining BP, that is, stroke volume (SV), heart rate (HR), and total peripheral resistance (TPR), in 163 patients with tilt-induced vasovagal syncope documented by continuous ECG and video EEG monitoring. We defined the beginning of cardioinhibition as the start of an HR decrease (HR) before syncope and used logarithms of SV, HR, and TPR ratios to quantify the multiplicative relation BP=SV·HR·TPR. We defined 3 stages before syncope and 2 after it based on direction changes of these parameters. The earliest BP decrease occurred 9 minutes before syncope. Cardioinhibition was observed in 91% of patients at a median time of 58 seconds before syncope. At that time, SV had a strong negative effect on BP, TPR a lesser negative effect, while HR had increased (all P <0.001). At the onset of cardioinhibition, the median HR was at 98 bpm higher than baseline. Cardioinhibition thus initially only represented a reduction of the corrective HR increase but was nonetheless accompanied by an immediate acceleration of the ongoing BP decrease. At syncope, SV and HR contributed similarly to the BP decrease ( P <0.001), while TPR did not affect BP.

Conclusions:

The novel methods allowed the relative effects of SV, HR, and TPR on BP to be assessed separately, although all act together. The 2 major factors lowering BP in tilt-induced vasovagal syncope were reduced SV and cardioinhibition. We suggest that the term vasodepression in reflex syncope should not be limited to reduced arterial vasoconstriction, reflected in TPR, but should also encompass venous pooling, reflected in SV.

Timing of Circulatory and Neurological Events in Syncope

Syncope usually lasts less than a minute, in which short time arterial blood pressure temporarily falls enough to decrease brain perfusion so much that loss of consciousness ensues. Blood pressure decreases quickest when the heart suddenly stops pumping, which happens in arrhythmia and in severe cardioinhibitory reflex syncope. Loss of consciousness starts about 8 s after the last heart beat and circulatory standstill occurs after 10-15 s. A much slower blood pressure decrease can occur in syncope due to orthostatic hypotension Standing blood pressure can then stabilize at low values often causing more subtle signs (i.e., inability to act) but often not low enough to cause loss of consciousness. Cerebral autoregulation attempts to keep cerebral blood flow constant when blood pressure decreases. In reflex syncope both the quick blood pressure decrease and its low absolute value mean that cerebral autoregulation cannot prevent syncope. It has more protective value in orthostatic hypotension. Neurological signs are related to the severity and timing of cerebral hypoperfusion. Several unanswered pathophysiological questions with possible clinical implications are identified.

Cardiovascular and Cerebral Responses During a Vasovagal Reaction Without Syncope

This clinical case report presents synchronous physiological data from an individual in whom a spontaneous vasovagal reaction occurred without syncope. The physiological data are presented for three main phases: Baseline (0–200 s), vasovagal reaction (200–600 s), and recovery period (600–1200 s). The first physiological changes occurred at around 200 s, with a decrease in blood pressure, peak in heart rate and vastus lateralis tissue oxygenation, and a drop in alpha power. The vasovagal reaction was associated with a progressive decrease in blood pressure, heart rate and cerebral oxygenation, whilst the mean middle cerebral artery blood flow velocity and blood oxygen saturation remained unchanged. Heart rate variability parameters indicated significant parasympathetic activation with a decrease in sympathetic tone and increased baroreflex sensitivity. The total blood volume and tissue oxygenation index (TOI) dropped in the brain but slightly increased in the vastus lateralis, suggesting cerebral hypoperfusion with blood volume pooling in the lower body part. Cerebral hypoperfusion during the vasovagal reaction was associated with electroencephalography (EEG) flattening (i.e., decreased power in beta and theta activity) followed by an EEG high-amplitude “slow” phase (i.e., increased power in theta activity). The subject developed signs and symptoms of pre-syncope with EEG flattening and slowing during prolonged periods of symptomatic hypotension, but did not lose consciousness.