Synthesis and characterization of de novo designed peptides modelling the binding sites of [4Fe–4S] clusters in photosystem I

Advanced strategies for enzyme-electrode interfacing in bioelectrocatalytic systems

Advances in protein engineering-enabled enzyme immobilization technologies have significantly improved enzyme-electrode wiring in enzymatic electrochemical systems, which harness natural biological machinery to either generate electricity or synthesize biochemicals. In this review, we provide guidelines for designing enzyme-electrodes, focusing on how performance variables change depending on electron transfer (ET) mechanisms. Recent advancements in enzyme immobilization technologies are summarized, highlighting their contributions to extending enzyme-electrode sustainability (up to months), enhancing biosensor sensitivity, improving biofuel cell performance, and setting a new benchmark for turnover frequency in bioelectrocatalysis. We also highlight state-of-the-art protein-engineering approaches that enhance enzyme-electrode interfacing through three key principles: protein-protein, protein-ligand, and protein-inorganic interactions. Finally, we discuss prospective avenues in strategic protein design for real-world applications.

Iron-Sulfur Peptides Mimicking Ferredoxin for an Efficient Electron Transfer to Hydrogenase

In the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, hydrogenase HydA1 converts protons and electrons to H2 at the H-cluster, which includes a [4Fe-4S] cluster linked to a [2Fe] cluster. The yield of H2 is limited by the electron transfer to HydA1, mediated by the iron-sulfur unit of a photosynthetic electron transfer ferredoxin (PetF). In this study, I have investigated by molecular dynamics and the hybrid quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics method two canonical iron-sulfur peptides (PM1 and FBM) that hold potential as PetF replacements. Using a docking approach, I predict that the distance between the two iron-sulfur clusters in FBM/HydA1 is shorter than in PM1/HydA1, ensuring a greater electron transfer rate. This finding is in line with the reported higher H2 production rates for FBM/HydA1. I also show that the redox potential of these peptides, and therefore their electron transfer properties, can be changed by single-residue mutations in the secondary coordination sphere of their cluster. In particular, I have designed a PM1 variant that disrupts the hydrogen-bonding network between water and the cluster, shifting the redox potential negatively compared to PM1. These results will guide experiments aimed at replacing PetF with peptides that can unlock the biotechnological potential of the alga.

Application of a Synthetic Ferredoxin-Inspired [4Fe4S]-Peptide Maquette as the Redox Partner for an [FeFe]-Hydrogenase

'Bacterial-type' ferredoxins host a cubane [4Fe4S]2+/+ cluster that enables these proteins to mediate electron transfer and facilitate a broad range of biological processes. Peptide maquettes based on the conserved cluster-forming motif have previously been reported and used to model the ferredoxins. Herein we explore the integration of a [4Fe4S]-peptide maquette into a H2 -powered electron transport chain. While routinely formed under anaerobic conditions, we illustrate by electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) analysis that these maquettes can be reconstituted under aerobic conditions by using photoactivated NADH to reduce the cluster at 240 K. Attempts to tune the redox properties of the iron-sulfur cluster by introducing an Fe-coordinating selenocysteine residue were also explored. To demonstrate the integration of these artificial metalloproteins into a semi-synthetic electron transport chain, we utilize a ferredoxin-inspired [4Fe4S]-peptide maquette as the redox partner in the hydrogenase-mediated oxidation of H2 .

Protein Interactions in Rhodopseudomonas palustris TIE-1 Reveal the Molecular Basis for Resilient Photoferrotrophic Iron Oxidation

Rhodopseudomonas palustris is an alphaproteobacterium with impressive metabolic versatility, capable of oxidizing ferrous iron to fix carbon dioxide using light energy. Photoferrotrophic iron oxidation is one of the most ancient metabolisms, sustained by the pio operon coding for three proteins: PioB and PioA, which form an outer-membrane porin-cytochrome complex that oxidizes iron outside of the cell and transfers the electrons to the periplasmic high potential iron-sulfur protein (HIPIP) PioC, which delivers them to the light-harvesting reaction center (LH-RC). Previous studies have shown that PioA deletion is the most detrimental for iron oxidation, while, the deletion of PioC resulted in only a partial loss. The expression of another periplasmic HiPIP, designated Rpal_4085, is strongly upregulated in photoferrotrophic conditions, making it a strong candidate for a PioC substitute. However, it is unable to reduce the LH-RC. In this work we used NMR spectroscopy to map the interactions between PioC, PioA, and the LH-RC, identifying the key amino acid residues involved. We also observed that PioA directly reduces the LH-RC, and this is the most likely substitute upon PioC deletion. By contrast, Rpal_4085 demontrated significant electronic and structural differences from PioC. These differences likely explain its inability to reduce the LH-RC and highlight its distinct functional role. Overall, this work reveals the functional resilience of the pio operon pathway and further highlights the use of paramagnetic NMR for understanding key biological processes.

Changing the tracks: screening for electron transfer proteins to support hydrogen production

Ferredoxins are essential electron transferring proteins in organisms. Twelve plant-type ferredoxins in the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii determine the fate of electrons, generated in multiple metabolic processes. The two hydrogenases HydA1 and HydA2 of. C. reinhardtii compete for electrons from the photosynthetic ferredoxin PetF, which is the first stromal mediator of the high-energy electrons derived from the absorption of light energy at the photosystems. While being involved in many chloroplast-located metabolic pathways, PetF shows the highest affinity for ferredoxin-NADP+ oxidoreductase (FNR), not for the hydrogenases. Aiming to identify other potential electron donors for the hydrogenases, we screened as yet uncharacterized ferredoxins Fdx7, 8, 10 and 11 for their capability to reduce the hydrogenases. Comparing the performance of the Fdx in presence and absence of competitor FNR, we show that Fdx7 has a higher affinity for HydA1 than for FNR. Additionally, we show that synthetic FeS-cluster-binding maquettes, which can be reduced by NADPH alone, can also be used to reduce the hydrogenases. Our findings pave the way for the creation of tailored electron donors to redirect electrons to enzymes of interest.

Catalysis and Electron Transfer in De Novo Designed Metalloproteins

One of the hallmark advances in our understanding of metalloprotein function is showcased in our ability to design new, non-native, catalytically active protein scaffolds. This review highlights progress and milestone achievements in the field of de novo metalloprotein design focused on reports from the past decade with special emphasis on de novo designs couched within common subfields of bioinorganic study: heme binding proteins, monometal- and dimetal-containing catalytic sites, and metal-containing electron transfer sites. Within each subfield, we highlight several of what we have identified as significant and important contributions to either our understanding of that subfield or de novo metalloprotein design as a discipline. These reports are placed in context both historically and scientifically. General suggestions for future directions that we feel will be important to advance our understanding or accelerate discovery are discussed.

The l-Thr Kinase/l-Thr-Phosphate Decarboxylase (CobD) Enzyme from Methanosarcina mazei Gö1 Contains Metallocenters Needed for Optimal Activity

The MM2060 (cobD) gene from Methanosarcina mazei strain Gö1 encodes a protein (MmCobD) with l-threonine kinase (PduX) and l-threonine-O-3-phosphate decarboxylase (CobD) activities. In addition to the unexpected l-Thr kinase activity, MmCobD has an extended carboxy-terminal (C-terminal) region annotated as a putative metal-binding zinc finger-like domain. Here, we demonstrate that the C-terminus of MmCobD is a ferroprotein containing ∼25 non-heme iron atoms per monomer of protein. The absence of the C-terminus substantially reduces, but does not abolish, enzymatic activities in vitro and in vivo. Single-residue substitutions of C-terminal putative Fe-binding cysteinyl and histidinyl residues resulted in the loss of Fe and changes in enzyme activity levels. Salmonella enterica ΔpduX and ΔcobD strains were used as heterologous hosts to assess coenzyme B12 biosynthesis as a function of 17 MmCobD variants tested. Some of the latter displayed 5-fold higher enzymatic activity in vitro and enhanced the growth rate of the S. enterica strains that synthesized them. Most of the MmCobD variants tested were up to 6-fold less active in vitro and supported slow growth rates of the S. enterica strains that synthesized them; some substitutions abolished enzyme activity. MmCobD exhibited an ultraviolet-visible absorption spectrum consistent with [4Fe-4S] clusters that appeared to be susceptible to oxidation by H2O2 and reduction by sodium dithionite. The presence of FeS clusters in MmCobD was corroborated by electron paramagnetic resonance and magnetic circular dichroism studies. Collectively, our results suggest that MmCobD contains one or more diamagnetic [4Fe-4S]2+ center(s) that may play a structural or regulatory role.

Repeat proteins as versatile scaffolds for arrays of redox-active FeS clusters

Molecular string of beads: modular extension of a protein backbone builds a chain of electroactive clusters.

Arrays of one, two and four electron-transfer active [4Fe–4S] clusters were constructed on modular tetratricopeptide repeat protein scaffolds, with the number of clusters determined solely by the size of the scaffold. The constructs show reversible redox activity and transient charge stabilization necessary to facilitate charge transfer.

Presence of a [3Fe-4S] cluster in a PsaC variant as a functional component of the photosystem I electron transfer chain in Synechococcus sp. PCC 7002

A site-directed C14G mutation was introduced into the stromal PsaC subunit of Synechococcus sp. strain PCC 7002 in vivo in order to introduce an exchangeable coordination site into the terminal F_B [4Fe-4S] cluster of Photosystem I (PSI). Using an engineered PSI-less strain (psaAB deletion), psaC was deleted and replaced with recombinant versions controlled by a strong promoter, and the psaAB deletion was complemented. Modified PSI accumulated at lower levels in this strain and supported slower photoautotrophic growth than wild type. As-isolated PSI complexes containing PsaC_C14G showed resonances with g values of 2.038 and 2.007 characteristic of a [3Fe-4S]¹⁺ cluster. When the PSI complexes were illuminated at 15 K, these resonances partially disappeared and two new sets of resonances appeared. The majority set had g values of 2.05, 1.95, and 1.85, characteristic of F_A^-, and the minority set had g values of 2.11, 1.90, and 1.88 from F_B' in the modified site. The S = 1/2 spin state of the latter implied the presence of a thiolate as the terminal ligand. The [3Fe-4S] clusters could be partially reconstituted with iron, producing a larger population of [4Fe-4S] clusters. Rates of flavodoxin reduction were identical in PSI complexes isolated from wild type and the PsaC_C14G variant strain; this implied equivalent capacity for forward electron transfer in PSI complexes that contained [3Fe-4S] and [4Fe-4S] clusters. The development of this cyanobacterial strain is a first step toward translation of in vitro PSI-based biosolar molecular wire systems in vivo and provides new insights into the formation of Fe/S clusters.

Biochemical characterization and essentiality of fumarate hydratase

Plasmodium falciparum (Pf), the causative agent of malaria, has an iron-sulfur cluster-containing class I fumarate hydratase (FH) that catalyzes the interconversion of fumarate to malate, a well-known reaction in the tricarboxylic acid cycle. In humans, the same reaction is catalyzed by class II FH that has no sequence or structural homology with the class I enzyme from Plasmodium Fumarate is generated in large quantities in the parasite as a by-product of AMP synthesis and is converted to malate by FH and then used in the generation of the key metabolites oxaloacetate, aspartate, and pyruvate. Previous studies have identified the FH reaction as being essential to P. falciparum, but biochemical characterization of PfFH that may provide leads for the development of specific inhibitors is lacking. Here, we report on the kinetic characterization of purified recombinant PfFH, functional complementation of fh deficiency in Escherichia coli, and mitochondrial localization in the parasite. We found that the substrate analog mercaptosuccinic acid is a potent PfFH inhibitor, with a K_i value in the nanomolar range. The fh gene could not be knocked out in Plasmodium berghei when transfectants were introduced into BALB/c mice; however, fh knockout was successful when C57BL/6 mice were used as host, suggesting that the essentiality of the fh gene to the parasite was mouse strain-dependent.

Genetic, Biochemical, and Biophysical Methods for Studying FeS Proteins and Their Assembly

FeS clusters containing proteins are structurally and functionally diverse and present in most organisms. Our understanding of FeS cluster production and insertion into polypeptides has benefited from collaborative efforts between in vitro and in vivo studies. The former allows a detailed description of FeS-containing protein and a deep understanding of the molecular mechanisms catalyzing FeS cluster assembly. The second allows to include metabolic and environmental constraints within the analysis of FeS homeostasis. The interplay and the cross talk between the two approaches have been a key strategy to reach a multileveled integrated understanding of FeS cluster homeostasis. In this chapter, we describe the genetic and biochemical/biophysical strategies that were used in the field of FeS cluster biogenesis, with the aim of providing the reader with a critical view of both approaches. In addition to the description of classic tricks and a series of recommendations, we will also discuss models as well as spectroscopic techniques useful to characterize FeS clusters such as UV-visible, Mössbauer, electronic paramagnetic resonance, resonance Raman, circular dichroism, and nuclear magnetic resonance.

Functional Proteins from Short Peptides: Dayhoff's Hypothesis Turns 50

First and foremost: Margaret Dayhoff's 1966 hypothesis on the origin of proteins is now an accepted model for the emergence of large, globular, functional proteins from short, simple peptides. However, the fundamental question of how the first protein(s) emerged still stands. The tools and hypotheses pioneered by Dayhoff, and the over 65 million protein sequences and 12 000 structures known today, enable those who follow in her footsteps to address this question.

Design of Redox-Active Peptides: Towards Functional Materials

In nature, the majority of processes that occur in the cell involve the cycling of electrons and protons, changing the reduction and oxidation state of substrates to alter their chemical reactivity and usefulness in vivo. One of the most relevant examples of these processes is the electron transport chain, a series of oxidoreductase proteins that shuttle electrons through well-defined pathways, concurrently moving protons across the cell membrane. Inspired by these processes, researchers have sought to develop materials to mimic natural systems for a number of applications, including fuel production. The most common cofactors found in proteins to carry out electron transfer are iron sulfur clusters and porphyrin-like molecules. Both types have been studied within natural proteins, such as in photosynthetic machinery or soluble electron carriers; in parallel, an extensive literature has developed over recent years attempting to model and study these cofactors within peptide-based materials. This chapter will focus on major designs that have significantly advanced the field.

Modulation of cluster incorporation specificity in a de novo iron-sulfur cluster binding peptide

iron-sulfur cluster binding proteins perform an astounding variety of functions, and represent one of the most abundant classes of metalloproteins. Most often, they constitute pairs or chains and act as electron transfer modules either within complex redox enzymes or within small diffusible proteins. We have previously described the design of a three-helix bundle that can bind two clusters within its hydrophobic core. Here, we use single-point mutations to exchange one of the Cys ligands coordinating the cluster to either Leu or Ser. We show that the mutants modulate the redox potential of the clusters and stabilize the [3Fe-4S] form over the [4Fe-4S] form, supporting the use of model iron-sulfur cluster proteins as modules in the design of complex redox enzymes.

Design Strategies for Redox Active Metalloenzymes: Applications in Hydrogen Production

The last decades have seen an increased interest in finding alternative means to produce renewable fuels in order to satisfy the growing energy demands and to minimize environmental impact. Nature can serve as an inspiration for development of these methodologies, as enzymes are able to carry out a wide variety of redox processes at high efficiency, employing a wide array of earth-abundant transition metals to do so. While it is well recognized that the protein environment plays an important role in tuning the properties of the different metal centers, the structure/function relationships between amino acids and catalytic centers are not well resolved. One specific approach to study the role of proteins in both electron and proton transfer is the biomimetic design of redox active peptides, binding organometallic clusters in well-understood protein environments. Here we discuss different strategies for the design of peptides incorporating redox active FeS clusters, [FeFe]-hydrogenase organometallic mimics, and porphyrin centers into different peptide and protein environments in order to understand natural redox enzymes.

Design and fine-tuning redox potentials of metalloproteins involved in electron transfer in bioenergetics

Redox potentials are a major contributor in controlling the electron transfer (ET) rates and thus regulating the ET processes in the bioenergetics. To maximize the efficiency of the ET process, one needs to master the art of tuning the redox potential, especially in metalloproteins, as they represent major classes of ET proteins. In this review, we first describe the importance of tuning the redox potential of ET centers and its role in regulating the ET in bioenergetic processes including photosynthesis and respiration. The main focus of this review is to summarize recent work in designing the ET centers, namely cupredoxins, cytochromes, and iron-sulfur proteins, and examples in design of protein networks involved these ET centers. We then discuss the factors that affect redox potentials of these ET centers including metal ion, the ligands to metal center and interactions beyond the primary ligand, especially non-covalent secondary coordination sphere interactions. We provide examples of strategies to fine-tune the redox potential using both natural and unnatural amino acids and native and nonnative cofactors. Several case studies are used to illustrate recent successes in this area. Outlooks for future endeavors are also provided. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Biodesign for Bioenergetics--the design and engineering of electronic transfer cofactors, proteins and protein networks, edited by Ronald L. Koder and J.L. Ross Anderson.

Proteins as templates for complex synthetic metalloclusters: towards biologically programmed heterogeneous catalysis

Despite nature's prevalent use of metals as prosthetics to adapt or enhance the behaviour of proteins, our ability to programme such architectural organization remains underdeveloped. Multi-metal clusters buried in proteins underpin the most remarkable chemical transformations in nature, but we are not yet in a position to fully mimic or exploit such systems. With the advent of copious, relevant structural information, judicious mechanistic studies and the use of accessible computational methods in protein design coupled with new synthetic methods for building biomacromolecules, we can envisage a 'new dawn' that will allow us to build de novo metalloenzymes that move beyond mono-metal centres. In particular, we highlight the need for systems that approach the multi-centred clusters that have evolved to couple electron shuttling with catalysis. Such hybrids may be viewed as exciting mid-points between homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysts which also exploit the primary benefits of biocatalysis.

Structure and Function of a Bacterial Microcompartment Shell Protein Engineered to Bind a [4Fe-4S] Cluster

Bacterial microcompartments (BMCs) are self-assembling organelles composed of a selectively permeable protein shell and encapsulated enzymes. They are considered promising templates for the engineering of designed bionanoreactors for biotechnology. In particular, encapsulation of oxidoreductive reactions requiring electron transfer between the lumen of the BMC and the cytosol relies on the ability to conduct electrons across the shell. We determined the crystal structure of a component protein of a synthetic BMC shell, which informed the rational design of a [4Fe-4S] cluster-binding site in its pore. We also solved the structure of the [4Fe-4S] cluster-bound, engineered protein to 1.8 Å resolution, providing the first structure of a BMC shell protein containing a metal center. The [4Fe-4S] cluster was characterized by optical and EPR spectroscopies; it has a reduction potential of -370 mV vs the standard hydrogen electrode (SHE) and is stable through redox cycling. This remarkable stability may be attributable to the hydrogen-bonding network provided by the main chain of the protein scaffold. The properties of the [4Fe-4S] cluster resemble those in low-potential bacterial ferredoxins, while its ligation to three cysteine residues is reminiscent of enzymes such as aconitase and radical S-adenosymethionine (SAM) enzymes. This engineered shell protein provides the foundation for conferring electron-transfer functionality to BMC shells.

Spectroscopic Investigations of [FeFe] Hydrogenase Maturated with [(57)Fe2(adt)(CN)2(CO)4](2-)

The preparation and spectroscopic characterization of a CO-inhibited [FeFe] hydrogenase with a selectively (57)Fe-labeled binuclear subsite is described. The precursor [(57)Fe2(adt)(CN)2(CO)4](2-) was synthesized from the (57)Fe metal, S8, CO, (NEt4)CN, NH4Cl, and CH2O. (Et4N)2[(57)Fe2(adt)(CN)2(CO)4] was then used for the maturation of the [FeFe] hydrogenase HydA1 from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, to yield the enzyme selectively labeled at the [2Fe]H subcluster. Complementary (57)Fe enrichment of the [4Fe-4S]H cluster was realized by reconstitution with (57)FeCl3 and Na2S. The Hox-CO state of [2(57)Fe]H and [4(57)Fe-4S]H HydA1 was characterized by Mössbauer, HYSCORE, ENDOR, and nuclear resonance vibrational spectroscopy.

Probing the Solvent Accessibility of the [4Fe-4S] Cluster of the Hydrogenase Maturation Protein HydF from Thermotoga neapolitana by HYSCORE and 3p-ESEEM

The catalytic site of [FeFe]-hydrogenase, the "H-cluster", composed of a [4Fe-4S] unit connected by a cysteinyl residue to a [2Fe] center coordinated by three CO, two CN(-), and a bridging dithiolate, is assembled in a complex maturation pathway, at present not fully characterized, involving three conserved proteins, HydG, HydE, and HydF. HydF is a complex enzyme, which is thought to act as a scaffold and carrier for the [2Fe] subunit of the H-cluster. This maturase protein contains itself a [4Fe-4S] cluster binding site, with three conserved cysteine residues and a noncysteinyl fourth ligand. In this work, we have exploited 3p-ESEEM and HYSCORE spectroscopies to get insight into the structure and the chemical environment of the [4Fe-4S] cluster of HydF from the hyperthermophilic organism Thermotoga neapolitana. The nature of the fourth ligand and the solvent accessibility of the active site comprising the [4Fe-4S] cluster are discussed on the basis of the spectroscopic results obtained upon H/D exchange. We propose that the noncysteinyl ligated Fe atom of the [4Fe-4S] cluster is the site where the [2Fe] subcluster precursor is anchored and finally processed to be delivered to the hydrogenase (HydA).

Control of proton and electron transfer in de novo designed, biomimetic β hairpins

Tyrosine side chains are involved in proton coupled electron transfer reactions (PCET) in many complex proteins, including photosystem II (PSII) and ribonucleotide reductase. For example, PSII contains two redox-active tyrosines, TyrD (Y160D2) and TyrZ (Y161D1), which have different protein environments, midpoint potentials, and roles in catalysis. TyrD has a midpoint potential lower than that of TyrZ, and its protein environment is distinguished by potential π-cation interactions with arginine residues. Designed biomimetic peptides provide a system that can be used to investigate how the protein matrix controls PCET reactions. As a model for the redox-active tyrosines in PSII, we are employing a designed, 18 amino acid β hairpin peptide in which PCET reactions occur between a tyrosine (Tyr5) and a cross-strand histidine (His14). In this peptide, the single tyrosine is hydrogen-bonded to an arginine residue, Arg16, and a second arginine, Arg12, has a π-cation interaction with Tyr5. In this report, the effect of these hydrogen bonding and electrostatic interactions on the PCET reactions is investigated. Electrochemical titrations show that histidine substitutions change the nature of PCET reactions, and optical titrations show that Arg16 substitution changes the pK of Tyr5. Removal of Arg16 or Arg12 increases the midpoint potential for tyrosine oxidation. The effects of Arg12 substitution are consistent with the midpoint potential difference, which is observed for the PSII redox-active tyrosine residues. Our results demonstrate that a π-cation interaction, hydrogen bonding, and PCET reactions alter redox-active tyrosine function. These interactions can contribute equally to the control of midpoint potential and reaction rate.