Testing the paradigm that the denaturing effect of urea on protein stability is offset by methylamines at the physiological concentration ratio of 2:1 (urea:methylamines)

Measuring the Thermal Unfolding of Lysozyme: A Critical Comparison of Differential Scanning Fluorimetry and Differential Scanning Calorimetry

The thermal unfolding of lysozyme in aqueous solution has been analyzed by (nano) differential scanning fluorimetry (nanoDSF) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). In addition, dynamic light scattering (DLS) acquired in parallel to the DSF measurements, was used to confirm that the change in hydrodynamic radius upon unfolding is rather small (RH,f =1.75 nm in the folded state; and RH,u=1.91 nm in the unfolded state). NanoDSF measurements were evaluated to characterize the folding/unfolding transition within the classical two-state folding model. The temperature of unfolding (Tm) is found to be the most robust quantity. The unfolding enthalpyΔ H u ${{\rm \Delta }{H}_{u}}$ and the change of specific heat were also obtained and errors in the range of 5-10 % and 30-50 % were determined, respectively. A comparison of thermodynamic parameters from nanoDSF and DSC measurements provides evidence for an increasing unfolding enthalpyΔ H u ${{\rm \Delta }{H}_{u}}$ with protein concentration. A comparison with data from literature suggests that a weak association in the folded state can lead to the observed change of the unfolding enthalpy. For Δcp significantly higher values is deduced from the analysis of temperature dependent nanoDSF measurements (10 kJ/(K mol)) as compare to DSC (3-5 kJ/(K mol)).

Effect of osmolytes and posttranslational modifications on modulating the chaperone function of α-crystallin

Proteins are responsible for a vast majority of various cellular effector processes. α-crystallin is one of the most important proteins in the lens of the eye, which acts as a molecular chaperone that keeps the lens transparent and refractive. α-crystallin is categorized as an intrinsically disordered protein (IDP), devoid of a stable three-dimensional structure, in contrast to conventional globular proteins. Because of its structural flexibility, it can stop denatured proteins from aggregating and building up within the lens over time. α-crystallin's dynamic quaternary structure, which allows it to exist in a variety of oligomeric forms, from dimers to massive assemblies, improves its chaperone function and flexibility. Its intrinsically disordered nature enables it to interact with a variety of client proteins due to its large non-polar and polar residue content and lack of a hydrophobic core. Furthermore, under physiological stress, osmolytes like sorbitol, TMAO, and urea are essential in regulating the stability and function of α-crystallin. Post-translational modifications (PTMs) such as glycation, in which reducing sugars combine with amino groups on the protein to generate advanced glycation end-products, impair α-crystallin's ability to function. These AGEs can cross-link α-crystallin molecules to prevent protein aggregation, changing their structure and decreasing their chaperone action. Because of their raised blood glucose levels, diabetics have an increased chance of developing cataracts as a result of this process. Comprehending how glycation and other PTMs affect α-crystallin is crucial for formulating treatment plans to maintain lens transparency and fight cataracts linked to aging and metabolic disorders.

TMAO to the rescue of pathogenic protein variants

Trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO) is a chemical chaperone found in various organisms including humans. Various studies unveiled that it is an excellent protein-stabilizing agent, and induces folding of unstructured proteins. It is also well established that it can counteract the deleterious effects of urea, salt, and hydrostatic pressure on macromolecular integrity. There is also existence of large body of data regarding its ability to restore functional deficiency of various mutant proteins or pathogenic variants by correcting misfolding defects and inhibiting the formation of high-order toxic protein oligomers. Since an important class of human disease called "protein conformational disorders" is due to protein misfolding and/or formation of high-order oligomers, TMAO stands as a promising molecule for the therapeutic intervention of such diseases. The present review has been designed to gather a comprehensive knowledge of the TMAO's effect on the functional restoration of various mutants, identify its shortcomings and explore its potentiality as a lead molecule. Future prospects have also been suitably incorporated.

Effect of pH on Diclofenac-Lysozyme Interaction: Structural and Functional Aspect

As a nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drug, diclofenac (DCF) is used in the treatment of a variety of human ailments. It has already been reported that the use of this class of drugs for a longer duration is associated with numerous side effects such as cardiovascular implications, reno-medullary complications, etc. In the present study, the effect of DCF on the structure, stability, and function of lysozyme was studied. The study was designed to examine the effect of DCF only at various pH values. Heat-induced denaturation of lysozyme was analyzed in the presence and absence of various molar concentrations of DCF at different pH values. The values of thermodynamic parameters, the midpoint of denaturation (T m), enthalpy change at T m (ΔH m), constant pressure heat capacity change (ΔC p), and Gibbs energy change at 25°C (ΔG D o), thus obtained under a given set of conditions (pH and molar concentration of DCF), demonstrated the following 1) DCF destabilized lysozyme with respect of T m and ΔG D o at all the pH values, 2) the magnitude of protein destabilization is lesser at acidic pH than at physiological pH, 3) structural changes in lysozyme are less projecting at pH 2.0 than at pH 7.0, and 4) quenching is observed at both pH values. Furthermore, the process of protein destabilization in the presence of DCF is entropically driven.

Urea ameliorates trimethylamine N-oxide-Induced aggregation of intrinsically disordered α-casein protein: the other side of the urea-methylamine counteraction

Trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO) is generally accumulated by organisms and cells to cope with denaturing effects of urea/hydrodynamic pressure on proteins and can even reverse misfolded or aggregated proteins so as to sustain proteostasis. However, most of the work regarding this urea-TMAO counteraction has been performed on folded proteins. Compelling evidence of aggregation of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) like tau, α-synuclein, amyloid β etc., by TMAO and its potential to impact various protein processes in absence of stressing agents (such as urea) suggests that the contrary feature of interaction profiles of urea and TMAO maximizes their chances of offsetting the perturbing effects of each other. Recently, our lab observed that TMAO induces aggregation of α-casein, a model IDP. In this context, the present study, for the first time, evaluated urea for its potential to counteract the TMAO-induced aggregation of α-casein. It was observed that, at the biologically relevant ratios of 2:1 or 3:1 (urea:TMAO), urea was able to inhibit TMAO-induced aggregation of α-casein. However, urea did not reverse the effects of TMAO on α-casein. In addition to this, α-casein in presence of 1:1 and 2:1 urea:TMAO working ratios show aggregation-induced cytotoxic effect on HEK-293, Neuro2A and HCT-116 cell lines but not in presence of 3:1 working ratio, as there was no aggregation at all. The study infers that the accumulation of TMAO alone in the cells, in absence of stress (such as urea), might result in loss of conformational flexibility and aggregation of IDPs in TMAO accumulating organisms.Communicated by Ramaswamy H. Sarma.

Protecting thermodynamic stability of protein: The basic paradigm against stress and unfolded protein response by osmolytes

Organic osmolytes are known to play important role in stress protection by stabilizing macromolecules and suppressing harmful effects on functional activity. There is existence of several reports in the literature regarding their effects on structural, functional and thermodynamic aspects of many enzymes and the interaction parameters with proteins have been explored. Osmolytes are compatible with enzyme function and therefore, can be accumulated up to several millimolar concentrations. From the thermodynamic point of view, osmolyte raises mid-point of thermal denaturation (T_m) of proteins while having no significant effect on ΔG_D° (free energy change at physiological condition). Unfavorable interaction with the peptide backbone due to preferential hydration is the major driving force for folding of unfolded polypeptide in presence of osmolyte. However, the thermodynamic basis of stress protection and origin of compatibility paradigm has been a debatable issue. In the present manuscript, we attempt to elaborate the origin of stress protection and compatibility paradigm of osmolytes based on the effect on thermodynamic stability of proteins. We also infer that protective effects of osmolytes on ΔG_D° (of proteins) could also indicate its potential involvement in unfolded protein response and overall stress biology on macromolecular level.

N-Acetylaspartate Is an Important Brain Osmolyte

Most of the human diseases related to various proteopathies are confined to the brain, which leads to the development of various forms of neurological disorders. The human brain consists of several osmolytic compounds, such as N-Acetylaspartate (NAA), myo-inositol (mI), glutamate (Glu), glutamine (Gln), creatine (Cr), and choline-containing compounds (Cho). Among these osmolytes, the level of NAA drastically decreases under neurological conditions, and, hence, NAA is considered to be one of the most widely accepted neuronal biomarkers in several human brain disorders. To date, no data are available regarding the effect of NAA on protein stability, and, therefore, the possible effect of NAA under proteopathic conditions has not been fully uncovered. To gain an insight into the effect of NAA on protein stability, thermal denaturation and structural measurements were carried out using two model proteins at different pH values. The results indicate that NAA increases the protein stability with an enhancement of structure formation. We also observed that the stabilizing ability of NAA decreases in a pH-dependent manner. Our study indicates that NAA is an efficient protein stabilizer at a physiological pH.

Counteracting Effect of Charged Amino Acids Against the Destabilization of Proteins by Arginine

Studies on osmolyte-induced effects on proteins help in enhancing protein stability under stressed conditions for various applications. Using mixtures of osmolytes could indeed widen their applications. The combinatorial effects of osmolytes with methylamines are majorly found in the literature; however, such studies are limited on the amino acid class of osmolytes. The present study examines the effect of charged amino acids Arg, Asp, and Lys on the stability of RNase A and α-LA. The thermal stabilities of the proteins in the presence of osmolytes are monitored by absorption changes, and the structural changes are analyzed using fluorescence quenching and near-UV circular dichroism (CD). These results are compared with our previous report on the effect of Glu. Arg destabilizes both the proteins whereas Asp, Lys, and Glu stabilize the proteins. The extent of stability provided by Asp and Glu is almost same and higher than Lys in RNase A. However, the stability acquired in the presence of Asp and Lys is comparable for α-LA and Glu provides higher stability. Further, the quenching and CD results suggest that the addition of amino acids do not alter the structure of the proteins significantly. The counteracting abilities of the stabilizing amino acids (stAAs) against Arg are then investigated. The results show that Glu could counteract Arg at the lowest fraction in the mixture. Lys requires nearly equimolar concentration whereas Asp needs almost double the concentration to counteract Arg induced destabilization of the proteins. At higher concentrations, the counteracting ability of Asp and Lys is similar for both the proteins. The counteracting ratio might slightly vary among the proteins, and it is not necessary that the amino acid providing higher stability to the protein could more effectively counteract Arg. This could be due to the change in the extent of preferential hydration of the proteins by stAAs in the presence of Arg. The results suggest that the addition of stAAs could be an effective strategy to increase the protein stability in biotechnology and biopharma applications.

Unfoldness of the denatured state of proteins determines urea: Methylamine counteraction in terms of Gibbs free energy of stabilization

In many tissues and organisms, large amount of urea gets accumulated to maintain osmotic balance. To evade the threatening impact of urea, living organisms accumulate methylamines, a class of osmolytes, in proportion of 2:1 (urea:methylamine). To understand underlying cause(s) for protein-specific counteraction behavior, thermodynamic stability (ΔG_D^o) of three disulfide free proteins (myoglobin, bovine cytochrome c and barstar) in the mixture of urea and methylamine has been estimated from guanidinium chloride-(GdmCl) driven denaturation curves. Using the experimentally measured values of ΔG_D^o obtained in the presence of individual methylamines and urea, we predicted the molar ratio of urea and a methylamine required for perfect compensation for each of the proteins. Interestingly, for all proteins studied, a similar ratio has been observed for perfect compensation. The predicted ratio for perfect compensation in terms of thermodynamic parameters was about 2:1 M ratio of urea to methylamine. Furthermore, a partial counteraction was observed in the myoglobin and barstar. However, for bovine cytochrome c, perfect compensation was observed in both GdmCl- and heat-driven denaturations. Our observations clearly suggest that the counteraction phenomenon depends on the extent of the unfolding of the denatured states of proteins.

Sugar osmolytes-induced stabilization of RNase A in macromolecular crowded cellular environment

Organisms synthesize sugar osmolytes during environmental stresses to protect proteins against denaturation. These studies were carried out in dilute buffer whereas intracellular milieu within cells has cytoplasmic concentration of macromolecules in the range of 80-400 mg ml^-1. Is the stabilizing effect of sugar osmolytes on the protein in dilute buffer different from that when protein is in cellular environment? To answer this question, we have measured and analysed the effect of sugar osmolytes on the structural and thermodynamic stability of ribonuclease A in the presence of dextran 70 at multiple concentrations of six sugars at different pH values. It was found that (i) each sugar osmolyte in the crowded environment provides stability to the protein in terms of T_m (midpoint of denaturation) and ∆G_D° (Gibbs energy change) and this stabilizing effect is under entropic control, (ii) the extent of osmolyte-induced stabilization of RNase A is pH dependent, and (iii) effect of sugars on the stability of protein in presence of the crowding agent remains unchanged. This study concludes that crowding does not affect the efficacy of osmolytes and vice versa; and emphasizes on understanding of internal architecture of the cellular environment with respect to molecular and macromolecular crowding.

Changing relations between proteins and osmolytes: a choice of nature

The stabilization and destabilization of the protein in the presence of any additive is mainly attributed to its preferential exclusion from protein surface and its preferential binding to the protein surface, respectively.

A current perspective on the compensatory effects of urea and methylamine on protein stability and function

Urea is a strong denaturant and inhibits many enzymes but is accumulated intracellularly at very high concentrations (up to 3-4 M) in mammalian kidney and in many marine fishes. It is known that the harmful effects of urea on the macromolecular structure and function is offset by the accumulation of an osmolytic agent called methylamine. Intracellular concentration of urea to methylamines falls in the ratio of 2:1 to 3:2 (molar ratio). At this ratio, the thermodynamic effects of urea and methylamines on protein stability and function are believed to be algebraically additive. The mechanism of urea-methylamine counteraction has been widely investigated on various approaches including, thermodynamic, structural and functional aspects. Recent advances have also revealed atomic level insights of counteraction and various molecular dynamic simulation studies have yielded significant molecular level informations on the interaction between urea and methylamines with proteins. It is worthwhile that urea-methylamine system not only plays pivotal role for the survival and functioning of the renal medullary cells but also is a key osmoregulatory component of the marine elasmobranchs, holocephalans and coelacanths. Therefore, it is important to combine all discoveries and discuss the developments in context to physiology of the mammalian kidney and adaptation of the marine organisms. In this article we have for the first time reviewed all major developments on urea-counteraction systems to date. We have also discussed about other additional urea-counteraction systems discovered so far including urea-NaCl, urea-myoinsoitol and urea-molecular chaperone systems. Insights for the possible future research have also been highlighted.

Salt potentiates methylamine counteraction system to offset the deleterious effects of urea on protein stability and function

Cellular methylamines are osmolytes (low molecular weight organic compounds) believed to offset the urea’s harmful effects on the stability and function of proteins in mammalian kidney and marine invertebrates. Although urea and methylamines are found at 2:1 molar ratio in tissues, their opposing effects on protein structure and function have been questioned on several grounds including failure to counteraction or partial counteraction. Here we investigated the possible involvement of cellular salt, NaCl, in urea-methylamine counteraction on protein stability and function. We found that NaCl mediates methylamine counteracting system from no or partial counteraction to complete counteraction of urea’s effect on protein stability and function. These conclusions were drawn from the systematic thermodynamic stability and functional activity measurements of lysozyme and RNase-A. Our results revealed that salts might be involved in protein interaction with charged osmolytes and hence in the urea-methylamine counteraction.

Structural characteristic of the initial unfolded state on refolding determines catalytic efficiency of the folded protein in presence of osmolytes

Osmolytes are low molecular weight organic molecules accumulated by organisms to assist proper protein folding, and to provide protection to the structural integrity of proteins under denaturing stress conditions. It is known that osmolyte-induced protein folding is brought by unfavorable interaction of osmolytes with the denatured/unfolded states. The interaction of osmolyte with the native state does not significantly contribute to the osmolyte-induced protein folding. We have therefore investigated if different denatured states of a protein (generated by different denaturing agents) interact differently with the osmolytes to induce protein folding. We observed that osmolyte-assisted refolding of protein obtained from heat-induced denatured state produces native molecules with higher enzyme activity than those initiated from GdmCl- or urea-induced denatured state indicating that the structural property of the initial denatured state during refolding by osmolytes determines the catalytic efficiency of the folded protein molecule. These conclusions have been reached from the systematic measurements of enzymatic kinetic parameters (Km and kcat), thermodynamic stability (Tm and ΔHm) and secondary and tertiary structures of the folded native proteins obtained from refolding of various denatured states (due to heat-, urea- and GdmCl-induced denaturation) of RNase-A in the presence of various osmolytes.

Testing the ability of non-methylamine osmolytes present in kidney cells to counteract the deleterious effects of urea on structure, stability and function of proteins

Human kidney cells are under constant urea stress due to its urine concentrating mechanism. It is believed that the deleterious effect of urea is counteracted by methylamine osmolytes (glycine betaine and glycerophosphocholine) present in kidney cells. A question arises: Do the stabilizing osmolytes, non-methylamines (myo-inositol, sorbitol and taurine) present in the kidney cells also counteract the deleterious effects of urea? To answer this question, we have measured structure, thermodynamic stability (ΔG D (o)) and functional activity parameters (K m and k cat) of different model proteins in the presence of various concentrations of urea and each non-methylamine osmolyte alone and in combination. We observed that (i) for each protein myo-inositol provides perfect counteraction at 1∶2 ([myo-inositol]:[urea]) ratio, (ii) any concentration of sorbitol fails to refold urea denatured proteins if it is six times less than that of urea, and (iii) taurine regulates perfect counteraction in a protein specific manner; 1.5∶2.0, 1.2∶2.0 and 1.0∶2.0 ([taurine]:[urea]) ratios for RNase-A, lysozyme and α-lactalbumin, respectively.

Relationship between functional activity and protein stability in the presence of all classes of stabilizing osmolytes

We report the effects of stabilizing osmolytes (low molecular mass organic compounds that raise the midpoint of thermal denaturation) on the stability and function of RNase-A under physiological conditions (pH 6.0 and 25 degrees C). Measurements of Gibbs free energy change at 25 degrees C (DeltaG(D) degrees ) and kinetic parameters, Michaelis constant (K(m)) and catalytic constant (k(cat)) of the enzyme mediated hydrolysis of cytidine monophosphate, enabled us to classify stabilizing osmolytes into three different classes based on their effects on kinetic parameters and protein stability. (a) Polyhydric alcohols and amino acids and their derivatives do not have significant effects on DeltaG(D) degrees and functional activity (K(m) and k(cat)). (b) Methylamines increase DeltaG(D) degrees and k(cat), but decrease K(m). (c) Sugars increase DeltaG(D) degrees , but decrease both K(m) and k(cat). These findings suggest that, among the stabilizing osmolytes, (a) polyols, amino acids and amino acid derivatives are compatible solutes in terms of both stability and function, (b) methylamines are the best refolders (stabilizers), and (c) sugar osmolytes stabilize the protein, but they apparently do not yield functionally active folded molecules.

Osmolyte counteracts urea-induced denaturation of alpha-chymotrypsin

The stability of proteins is reduced by urea, which is methylamine and nonprotecting osmolyte; eventually urea destabilizes the activity and function and alters the structure of proteins, whereas the stability of proteins is raised by the osmolytes, which are not interfering with the functional activity of proteins. The deleterious effect of urea on proteins has been counteracted by methylamines (osmolytes), such as trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO), betaine, and sarcosine. To distinctly enunciate the comparison of the counteracting effects between these methylamines on urea-induced denaturation of alpha-chymotrypsin (CT), we measured the hydrodynamic diameter (d(H)) and the thermodynamic properties (T(m), DeltaH, DeltaG(U), and DeltaC(p)) with dynamic light scattering (DLS) and differential scanning calorimeter (DSC), respectively. The present investigation compares the compatibility and counteracting hypothesis by determining the effects of methylamines and urea, as individual components and in combination at a concentration ratio of 1:2 (methylamine:urea) as well as various urea concentrations (0.5-5 M) in the presence of 1 M methylamine. The experimental results revealed that the naturally occurring osmolytes TMAO, betaine, and sarcosine strongly counteracted the urea actions on alpha-chymotrypsin. The results also indicated that TMAO counteracting the urea effects on CT was much stronger than betaine or sarcosine.