Stable plastid transformation of rice, a monocot cereal crop

Recent trends and advances in chloroplast engineering and transformation methods

Chloroplast transformation technology has become a powerful platform for generating plants that express foreign proteins of pharmaceutical and agricultural importance at high levels. Chloroplasts are often chosen as attractive targets for the introduction of new agronomic traits because they have their own genome and protein synthesis machinery. Certain valuable traits have been genetically engineered into plastid genomes to improve crop yield, nutritional quality, resistance to abiotic and biotic stresses, and the production of industrial enzymes and therapeutic proteins. Synthetic biology approaches aim to play an important role in expressing multiple genes through plastid engineering, without the risk of pleiotropic effects in transplastomic plants. Despite many promising laboratory-level successes, no transplastomic crop has been commercialized to date. This technology is mostly confined to model species in academic laboratories and needs to be expanded to other agronomically important crop species to capitalize on its significant commercial potential. However, in recent years, some transplastomic lines are progressing in field trials, offering hope that they will pass regulatory approval and enter the marketplace. This review provides a comprehensive summary of new and emerging technologies employed for plastid transformation and discusses key synthetic biology elements that are necessary for the construction of modern transformation vectors. It also focuses on various novel insights and challenges to overcome in chloroplast transformation.

Towards assembling functional cyanobacterial β-carboxysomes in Oryza sativa chloroplasts

The major limiting factor of photosynthesis in C3 plants is the enzyme, rubisco which inadequately distinguishes between carbon dioxide and oxygen. To overcome catalytic deficiencies of Rubisco, cyanobacteria utilize advanced protein microcompartments, called the carboxysomes which envelopes the enzymes, Rubisco and Carbonic Anhydrase (CA). These microcompartments facilitate the diffusion of bicarbonate ions which are converted to CO2 by CA, following in an increase in carbon flux near Rubisco boosting CO2 fixation process. Inspired by this mechanism, our study aims to improve photosynthetic efficiency in the C3 model crop, rice (Oryza sativa), by stably engineering the genetic components of the β-carboxysome of Synechococcus elongatus PCC 7942 (hereafter, Syn7942) in the rice genome. We demonstrated this proof of concept by developing two types of transgenic rice plants. The first type involved targeting the chloroplasts with three key carboxysome structural proteins (ccmL, ccmO, and ccmK) and a chimeric protein (ccmC), which integrates domains from four distinct carboxysome proteins. The second type combined these proteins with the introduction of cyanobacterial Rubisco targeted to chloroplasts. Additionally, in the second transgenic background, RNA interference was employed to silence the endogenous rice Rubisco along with stromal carbonic anhydrase gene. The transgenic plants exhibited the assembly of carboxysome-like compartments and aggregated proteins in the chloroplasts and the second type demonstrated reduced plant growth and yield. We have followed a bottom-up approach for targeting the cyanobacterial CCM in rice chloroplast which would help in stacking up the components further required for increasing the photosynthetic efficiency in future.

Genome editing in angiosperm chloroplasts: targeted DNA double-strand break and base editing

Chloroplasts are organelles that are derived from a photosynthetic bacterium and have their own genome. Genome editing is a recently developing technology that allows for specific modifications of target sequences. The first successful application of genome editing in chloroplasts was reported in 2021, and since then, this research field has been expanding. Although the chloroplast genome of several dicot species can be stably modified by a conventional method, which involves inserting foreign DNAs into the chloroplast genome via homologous recombination, genome editing offers several advantages over this method. In this review, we introduce genome editing methods targeting the chloroplast genome and describe their advantages and limitations. So far, CRISPR/Cas systems are inapplicable for editing the chloroplast genome because guide RNAs, unlike proteins, cannot be efficiently delivered into chloroplasts. Therefore, protein-based enzymes are used to edit the chloroplast genome. These enzymes contain a chloroplast-transit peptide, the DNA-binding domain of transcription activator-like effector nuclease (TALEN), or a catalytic domain that induces DNA modifications. To date, genome editing methods can cause DNA double-strand break or introduce C:G-to-T:A and A:T-to-G:C base edits at or near the target sequence. These methods are expected to contribute to basic research on the chloroplast genome in many species and to be fundamental methods of plant breeding utilizing the chloroplast genome.

OsG6PGH1 affects various grain quality traits and participates in the salt stress response of rice

Cytoplasmic 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase (G6PGH) is a key enzyme in the pentose phosphate pathway that is involved in regulating various biological processes such as material metabolism, and growth and development in plants. However, it was unclear if OsG6PGH1 affected rice grain quality traits. We perform yeast one-hybrid experiments and reveal that OsG6PGH1 may interact with OsAAP6. Subsequently, yeast in vivo point-to-point experiments and local surface plasmon resonance experiments verified that OsG6PGH1 can bind to OsAAP6. OsG6PGH1 in rice is a constitutive expressed gene that may be localized in the cytoplasm. OsAAP6 and protein-synthesis metabolism-related genes are significantly upregulated in OsG6PGH1 overexpressing transgenic positive endosperm, corresponding to a significant increase in the number of protein bodies II, promoting accumulation of related storage proteins, a significant increase in grain protein content (GPC), and improved rice nutritional quality. OsG6PGH1 positively regulates amylose content, negatively regulates chalkiness rate and taste value, significantly affects grain quality traits such as appearance, cooking, and eating qualities of rice, and is involved in regulating the expression of salt stress related genes, thereby enhancing the salt-stress tolerance of rice. Therefore, OsG6PGH1 represents an important genetic resource to assist in the design of high-quality and multi-resistant rice varieties.

Chloroplast transformation in new cultivars of tomato through particle bombardment

A protocol has been established for genetic transformation of the chloroplasts in two new cultivars of tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.) grown in India and Australia: Pusa Ruby and Yellow Currant. Tomato cv. Green Pineapple was also used as a control that has previously been used for establishing chloroplast transformation by other researchers. Selected tomato cultivars were finalized from ten other tested cultivars (Green Pineapple excluded) due to their high regeneration potential and better response to chloroplast transformation. This protocol was set up using a chloroplast transformation vector (pRB94) for tomatoes that is made up of a synthetic gene operon. The vector has a chimeric aadA selectable marker gene that is controlled by the rRNA operon promoter (Prrn). This makes the plant or chloroplasts resistant to spectinomycin and streptomycin. After plasmid-coated particle bombardment, leaf explants were cultured in 50 mg/L selection media. Positive explant selection from among all the dead-appearing (yellow to brown) explants was found to be the major hurdle in the study. Even though this study was able to find plastid transformants in heteroplasmic conditions, it also found important parameters and changes that could speed up the process of chloroplast transformation in tomatoes, resulting in homoplasmic plastid-transformed plants.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s13205-024-03954-3.

Prospects of chloroplast metabolic engineering for developing nutrient-dense food crops

Addressing nutritional deficiencies in food crops through biofortification is a sustainable approach to tackling malnutrition. Biofortification is continuously being attempted through conventional breeding as well as through various plant biotechnological interventions, ranging from molecular breeding to genetic engineering and genome editing for enriching crops with various health-promoting metabolites. Genetic engineering is used for the rational incorporation of desired nutritional traits in food crops and predominantly operates through nuclear and chloroplast genome engineering. In the recent past, chloroplast engineering has been deployed as a strategic tool to develop model plants with enhanced nutritional traits due to the various advantages it offers over nuclear genome engineering. However, this approach needs to be extended for the nutritional enhancement of major food crops. Further, this platform could be combined with strategies, such as synthetic biology, chloroplast editing, nanoparticle-mediated rapid chloroplast transformation, and horizontal gene transfer through grafting for targeting endogenous metabolic pathways for overproducing native nutraceuticals, production of biopharmaceuticals, and biosynthesis of designer nutritional compounds. This review focuses on exploring various features of chloroplast genome engineering for nutritional enhancement of food crops by enhancing the levels of existing metabolites, restoring the metabolites lost during crop domestication, and introducing novel metabolites and phytonutrients needed for a healthy daily diet.

Characterization and development of a plastid genome base editor, ptpTALECD

The modification of photosynthesis-related genes in plastid genomes may improve crop yields. Recently, we reported that a plastid-targeting base editor named ptpTALECD, in which a cytidine deaminase DddA functions as the catalytic domain, can homoplasmically substitute a targeted C to T in plastid genomes of Arabidopsis thaliana. However, some target Cs were not substituted. In addition, although ptpTALECD could substitute Cs on the 3' side of T and A, it was unclear whether it could also substitute Cs on the 3' side of G and C. In this study, we identified the preferential positions of the substituted Cs in ptpTALECD-targeting sequences in the Arabidopsis plastid genome. We also found that ptpTALECD could substitute Cs on the 3' side of all four bases in plastid genomes of Arabidopsis. More recently, a base editor containing an improved version of DddA (DddA11) was reported to substitute Cs more efficiently, and to substitute Cs on the 3' side of more varieties of bases in human mitochondrial genomes than a base editor containing DddA. Here, we also show that ptpTALECD_v2, in which a modified version of DddA11 functions as the catalytic domain, more frequently substituted Cs than ptpTALECD in the Arabidopsis plastid genome. We also found that ptpTALECD_v2 tended to substitute Cs at more positions than ptpTALECD. Our results reveal that ptpTALECD can cause a greater variety of codon changes and amino acid substitutions than previously thought, and that ptpTALECD and ptpTALECD_v2 are useful tools for the targeted base editing of plastid genomes.

Achieving High Expression of Cry in Green Tissues and Negligible Expression in Endosperm Simultaneously via rbcS Gene Fusion Strategy in Rice

To allay excessive public concern about the safety of transgenic foods, and to optimize insect-resistant genes expression to delay the evolution of resistance in pests, we developed a promising strategy to fuse the GOI (gene of interest) with OsrbcS (rice small subunit of ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase) in transgenic rice, which acted as a carrier, driven by the OsrbcS native promoter to sequester its expression in green tissues. Using eYFP as a trial, we reported a high-level accumulation of eYFP in green tissue and almost none in the seed and root of the fused construct compared to the non-fused construct. After applying this fusion strategy in insect-resistant rice breeding, recombinant OsrbcS-Cry1Ab/Cry1Ac expressed rice plants conferred high resistance to leaffolders and striped stem borers, among which two single-copy lines possessed normal agronomic performance in the field. Specifically, Cry1Ab/Cry1Ac protein levels in single-copy construct transgenic lines ranged from 1.8 to 11.5 µg g^-1 in the leaf, higher than the Actin I promoter-driven control, T51-1, about 1.78 µg g^-1 in the leaf, but negligible (only 0.00012-0.00117 µg g^-1) in endosperm by ELISA analysis. Our study provided a novel approach to creating Cry1Ab/Cry1Ac-free endosperm rice with a high level of insect-resistant protein in green tissues through the simultaneous usage of the OsrbcS promoter and OsrbcS as a fusion partner.

Molecular determinants of protein half-life in chloroplasts with focus on the Clp protease system

Proteolysis is an essential process to maintain cellular homeostasis. One pathway that mediates selective protein degradation and which is in principle conserved throughout the kingdoms of life is the N-degron pathway, formerly called the ‘N-end rule’. In the cytosol of eukaryotes and prokaryotes, N-terminal residues can be major determinants of protein stability. While the eukaryotic N-degron pathway depends on the ubiquitin proteasome system, the prokaryotic counterpart is driven by the Clp protease system. Plant chloroplasts also contain such a protease network, which suggests that they might harbor an organelle specific N-degron pathway similar to the prokaryotic one. Recent discoveries indicate that the N-terminal region of proteins affects their stability in chloroplasts and provides support for a Clp-mediated entry point in an N-degron pathway in plastids. This review discusses structure, function and specificity of the chloroplast Clp system, outlines experimental approaches to test for an N-degron pathway in chloroplasts, relates these aspects into general plastid proteostasis and highlights the importance of an understanding of plastid protein turnover.

Poaceae Chloroplast Genome Sequencing: Great Leap Forward in Recent Ten Years

The first complete chloroplast genome of rice (Oryza sativa) was published in 1989, ushering in a new era of studies of chloroplast genomics in Poaceae. Progresses in Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) and Third-Generation Sequencing (TGS) technologiesand in the development of genome assembly software, have significantly advanced chloroplast genomics research. Poaceae is one of the most targeted families in chloroplast genome research because of its agricultural, ecological, and economic importance. Over the last 30 years, 2,050 complete chloroplast genome sequences from 40 tribes and 282 genera have been generated, most (97%) of them in the recent ten years. The wealth of data provides the groundwork for studies on species evolution, phylogeny, genetic transformation, and other aspects of Poaceae chloroplast genomes. As a result, we have gained a deeper understanding of the properties of Poaceae chloroplast genomes. Here, we summarize the achievements of the studies of the Poaceae chloroplast genomes and envision the challenges for moving the area ahead.

Stable and efficient expression of human brain-derived neurotrophic factor in tobacco chloroplasts

BACKGROUND

Brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) is an intensively studied neurotrophin that promotes various physiological processes, such as acceleration of cell proliferation and differentiation, and is, therefore widely used in clinical applications.

METHODS AND RESULTS

In this study, an expression vector with a codon-optimized hBDNF gene was constructed and transferred into chloroplasts of tobacco by gene-gun. After three or four rounds of selection with optimal spectinomycin concentration, hBDNF was integrated into the chloroplast genome of homoplastomic plants, as confirmed by PCR and Southern hybridization. ELISA indicated that hBDNF fused with GFP represented approximately 15.72% ± 0.33% of total soluble protein in the leaves of transplastomic plants. Moreover, the chloroplast-derived hBDNF displayed biological activity similar to the commercial product.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first case report of hBDNF expression by chloroplast transformation in the plant model, providing an additional pathway for the production of chloroplast-expressed therapeutic proteins.

Functional peptide-mediated plastid transformation in tobacco, rice, and kenaf

In plant engineering, plastid transformation is more advantageous than nuclear transformation because it results in high levels of protein expression from multiple genome copies per cell and is unaffected by gene silencing. The common plastid transformation methods are biolistic bombardment that requires special instruments and PEG-mediated transformation that is only applicable to protoplast cells. Here, we aimed to establish a new plastid transformation method in tobacco, rice, and kenaf using a biocompatible fusion peptide as a carrier to deliver DNA into plastids. We used a fusion peptide, KH-AtOEP34, comprising a polycationic DNA-binding peptide (KH) and a plastid-targeting peptide (AtOEP34) to successfully deliver and integrate construct DNA into plastid DNA (ptDNA) via homologous recombination. We obtained transformants in each species using selection with spectinomycin/streptomycin and the corresponding resistance gene aadA. The constructs remained in ptDNA for several months after introduction even under non-selective condition. The transformants normally flowered and are fertile in most cases. The offspring of the transformants (the T₁ generation) retained the integrated construct DNA in their ptDNA, as indicated by PCR and DNA blotting, and expressed GFP in plastids from the integrated construct DNA. In summary, we successfully used the fusion peptide method for integration of foreign DNA in tobacco, rice, and kenaf ptDNA, and the integrated DNA was transmitted to the next generations. Whereas optimization is necessary to obtain homoplasmic plastid transformants that enable stable heterologous expression of genes, the plastid transformation method shown here is a novel nanomaterial-based approach distinct from the conventional methods, and we propose that this easy method could be used to target a wide variety of plants.

Sorting of mitochondrial and plastid heteroplasmy in Arabidopsis is extremely rapid and depends on MSH1 activity

The fate of new mitochondrial and plastid mutations depends on their ability to persist and spread among the numerous organellar genome copies within a cell (heteroplasmy). The extent to which heteroplasmies are transmitted across generations or eliminated through genetic bottlenecks is not well understood in plants, in part because their low mutation rates make these variants so infrequent. Disruption of MutS Homolog 1 (MSH1), a gene involved in plant organellar DNA repair, results in numerous de novo point mutations, which we used to quantitatively track the inheritance of single nucleotide variants in mitochondrial and plastid genomes in Arabidopsis. We found that heteroplasmic sorting (the fixation or loss of a variant) was rapid for both organelles, greatly exceeding rates observed in animals. In msh1 mutants, plastid variants sorted faster than those in mitochondria and were typically fixed or lost within a single generation. Effective transmission bottleneck sizes (N) for plastids and mitochondria were N ∼ 1 and 4, respectively. Restoring MSH1 function further increased the rate of heteroplasmic sorting in mitochondria (N ∼ 1.3), potentially because of its hypothesized role in promoting gene conversion as a mechanism of DNA repair, which is expected to homogenize genome copies within a cell. Heteroplasmic sorting also favored GC base pairs. Therefore, recombinational repair and gene conversion in plant organellar genomes can potentially accelerate the elimination of heteroplasmies and bias the outcome of this sorting process.

Plastid Transformation in Potato: An Important Source of Nutrition and Industrial Materials

For a long time, plastid transformation has been a routine technology only in tobacco due to lack of effective selection and regeneration protocols, and, for some species, due to inefficient recombination using heterologous flanking regions in transformation vectors. Nevertheless, the availability of this technology to economically important crops offers new possibilities in plant breeding to manage pathogen resistance or improve nutritional value. Herein we describe an efficient plastid transformation protocol for potato (Solanum tuberosum subsp. tuberosum), achieved by the optimization of the tissue culture procedures and using transformation vectors carrying homologous potato flanking sequences. This protocol allowed to obtain up to one shoot per shot, an efficiency comparable to that usually accomplished in tobacco. Further, the method described in this chapter has been successfully used to regenerate potato transplastomic plants expressing recombinant GFP protein in chloroplasts and amyloplasts or long double-stranded RNAs for insect pest control.

Generation, analysis, and transformation of macro-chloroplast Potato (Solanum tuberosum) lines for chloroplast biotechnology

Chloroplast biotechnology is a route for novel crop metabolic engineering. The potential bio-confinement of transgenes, the high protein expression and the possibility to organize genes into operons represent considerable advantages that make chloroplasts valuable targets in agricultural biotechnology. In the last 3 decades, chloroplast genomes from a few economically important crops have been successfully transformed. The main bottlenecks that prevent efficient transformation in a greater number of crops include the dearth of proven selectable marker gene-selection combinations and tissue culture methods for efficient regeneration of transplastomic plants. The prospects of increasing organelle size are attractive from several perspectives, including an increase in the surface area of potential targets. As a proof-of-concept, we generated Solanum tuberosum (potato) macro-chloroplast lines overexpressing the tubulin-like GTPase protein gene FtsZ1 from Arabidopsis thaliana. Macro-chloroplast lines exhibited delayed growth at anthesis; however, at the time of harvest there was no significant difference in height between macro-chloroplast and wild-type lines. Macro-chloroplasts were successfully transformed by biolistic DNA-delivery and efficiently regenerated into homoplasmic transplastomic lines. We also demonstrated that macro-chloroplasts accumulate the same amount of heterologous protein than wild-type organelles, confirming efficient usage in plastid engineering. Advantages and limitations of using enlarge compartments in chloroplast biotechnology are discussed.

Plastid Transformation: How Does it Work? Can it Be Applied to Crops? What Can it Offer?

In recent years, plant genetic engineering has advanced agriculture in terms of crop improvement, stress and disease resistance, and pharmaceutical biosynthesis. Cells from land plants and algae contain three organelles that harbor DNA: the nucleus, plastid, and mitochondria. Although the most common approach for many plant species is the introduction of foreign DNA into the nucleus (nuclear transformation) via Agrobacterium- or biolistics-mediated delivery of transgenes, plastid transformation offers an alternative means for plant transformation. Since there are many copies of the chloroplast genome in each cell, higher levels of protein accumulation can often be achieved from transgenes inserted in the chloroplast genome compared to the nuclear genome. Chloroplasts are therefore becoming attractive hosts for the introduction of new agronomic traits, as well as for the biosynthesis of high-value pharmaceuticals, biomaterials and industrial enzymes. This review provides a comprehensive historical and biological perspective on plastid transformation, with a focus on current and emerging approaches such as the use of single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWNTs) as DNA delivery vehicles, overexpressing morphogenic regulators to enhance regeneration ability, applying genome editing techniques to accelerate double-stranded break formation, and reconsidering protoplasts as a viable material for plastid genome engineering, even in transformation-recalcitrant species.

A novel strategy for promoting homoplasmic plastid transformant production using the barnase-barstar system

Plastid transformants form biofactories that are able to produce extra proteins in plastids when they are in a homoplasmic state. To date, plastid transformation has been reported in about twenty plant species; however, the production of homoplasmic plastid transformants is not always successful or easy. Heteroplasmic plants that contain wild-type plastids produce fewer target proteins and do not always successfully transfer transgenes to progeny. In order to promote the generation of homoplasmic plants, we developed a novel system using barnase-barster to eliminate wild-type plastids from heteroplasmic cells systematically. In this system, a chemically inducible cytotoxic barnase under a plastid transit signal was introduced into nuclear DNA and barster, which inhibits barnase, was integrated into plastid DNA with the primary selection markers aminoglycoside 3'-adenylyltransferase (aadA) and green fluorescence protein (GFP) gene. As expected, the expression of the plastid barnase was lethal to cells as seen in leaf segments, but barster expression in plastids rescued them. We then investigated the regeneration frequency of homoplasmic shoots from heteroplasmic leaf segments with or without barnase expression. The regeneration frequency of homoplasmic-like shoots expressing barnase-barster system was higher than that of shoots not expressing this. We expect that the application of this novel strategy for transformation of plastids will be supportive to generate homoplasmic plastid transformants in other plant species.