Wastewater treatment using oxygenic photogranule-based process has lower environmental impact than conventional activated sludge process

Impact of ibuprofen on microalgal-bacterial granular sludge: Metabolic pathways, functional gene responses and biodegradation mechanisms

Ibuprofen (IBU), a persistent and toxic emerging pollutant widely used as a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug, poses significant challenges for wastewater treatment. This study investigates the effects of IBU on the microalgal-bacterial granular sludge (MBGS) process, a promising approach for wastewater treatment. Results indicate that MBGS can enhance its resilience by secreting more extracellular polymeric substances for effective adsorption. Proteobacteria displayed high adaptability to IBU, while the abundance of Cyanobacteria exhibited considerable fluctuations, leading to cellular structural deformation and a decrease in abundance under 1 mg/L IBU stress. The abundance of functional genes involved in nitrogen and organic matter metabolism, including GDH2, ACSS1_2, and mqo, was significantly influenced by IBU stress, thereby affecting overall system performance. Additionally, several degradation by-products of IBU which have lower toxicity were identified, suggesting the effective biodegradation within the MBGS system. Structural equation modeling indicated that IBU exerted a greater negative impact on microalgae than on bacteria. This study confirms the adaptability of the MBGS system to wastewater containing IBU, highlighting its promising application in treating wastewater with emerging contaminants.

History of carbon supply shapes the metabolic response of photogranules to light shifts

Oxygenic photogranules mainly composed of cyanobacteria and heterotrophic bacteria, have gained attention for their ability to treat wastewater (removal of C, N, and P) without external aeration. Currently, the metabolic dynamics of photogranules to varying nutrient and light conditions in wastewater treatment systems remains poorly studied. However, understanding how quickly the photogranule metabolism changes, and whether this change is temporary or permanent is important for the optimal use of photogranules. Here, an NMR-based metabolomics approach was applied to investigate the temporal dynamics of photogranule metabolism in the presence or absence of acetate and with or without light. Our findings revealed that under carbon-limited conditions, photogranules relied on alternative carbon sources, such as N-acetylneuraminate (a constituent of EPS) and amino acids like hypotaurine and L-alanine. This adaptation affected key metabolic pathways, including glycolysis, taurine and hypotaurine metabolism, and the tricarboxylic acid cycle. When acetate was provided, both heterotrophic and phototrophic activities were maintained. Notably, the history of carbon supply influenced how photogranules responded to light shifts. Metabolic indicators showed that the lag in carbon addition altered fatty acid metabolism and carbon fixation, leading to shifts in amino acid concentrations and distinct metabolic profiles when the light was turned off. Thus, NMR metabolomics identified metabolic changes, induced by contrasting carbon conditions, lasting for several hours, and significantly affecting the photogranule response to light fluctuations. These results suggest that the history of carbon supplementation may shape metabolic responses of photogranules to other environmental changes or stressors.

Cyanobacteria and Chloroflexota cooperate to structure light-responsive biofilms

Microbial mats are stratified communities often dominated by unicellular and filamentous phototrophs within an exopolymer matrix. It is challenging to quantify the dynamic responses of community members in situ as they experience steep gradients and rapid fluctuations of light. To address this, we developed a binary consortium using two representative isolates from hot spring mats: the unicellular oxygenic phototrophic cyanobacterium Synechococcus OS-B' (Syn OS-B') and the filamentous anoxygenic phototroph Chloroflexus MS-CIW-1 (Chfl MS-1). We quantified the motility of individual cells and entire colonies and demonstrated that Chfl MS-1 formed bundles of filaments that moved in all directions with no directional bias to light. Syn OS-B' was slightly less motile but exhibited positive phototaxis. This binary consortium displayed cooperative behavior by moving further than either species alone and formed ordered arrays where both species aligned with the light source. No cooperative motility was observed when a nonmotile pilB mutant of Syn OS-B' was used instead of Syn OS-B'. The binary consortium also produced more adherent biofilm than individual species, consistent with the close interspecies association revealed by electron microscopy. We propose that cyanobacteria and Chloroflexota cooperate in forming natural microbial mats by colonizing new niches and building robust biofilms.

Achieving efficient autotrophic nitrogen removal in anaerobic membrane bioreactor plus membrane aerated biofilm reactor by regulating nutrient ratios

It is feasible to integrate an anaerobic membrane bioreactor with a membrane aerated biofilm reactor to efficiently implement the sulfate reduction, simultaneous nitrification and autotrophic denitrification process. However, the effect of parameters on nutrient removal and environmental impacts of the process are unclear. In this study, the reactor performance was mainly influenced by the chemical oxygen demand to sulfate (COD/S) ratio and the ammonium to sulfate (N/S) ratio in long-term operation. Significant models were developed to optimize the two factors using the response surface methodology. Under optimal conditions (COD/S ratio of 2.5 and N/S ratio of 0.3), the system could remove above 86 % COD, 99 % ammonium, and 92 % total inorganic nitrogen. Moreover, this process could reduce energy consumption by 30 % and global warming potential by 50 % compared with traditional anaerobic/oxic activated sludge process. These findings provide guidance for the application of this technology in sulfate-containing municipal sewage treatment.

Illuminating microbial mat assembly: Cyanobacteria and Chloroflexota cooperate to structure light-responsive biofilms

Microbial mats are stratified communities often dominated by unicellular and filamentous phototrophs within an exopolymer matrix. It is challenging to quantify the dynamic responses of community members in situ as they experience steep gradients and rapid fluctuations of light. To address this, we developed a binary consortium using two representative isolates from hot spring mats: the unicellular oxygenic phototrophic cyanobacterium Synechococcus OS-B' (Syn OS-B') and the filamentous anoxygenic phototroph Chloroflexus MS-CIW-1 (Chfl MS-1). We quantified the motility of individual cells and entire colonies and demonstrated that Chfl MS-1 formed bundles of filaments that moved in all directions with no directional bias to light. Syn OS-B' was slightly less motile but exhibited positive phototaxis. This binary consortium displayed cooperative behavior by moving further than either species alone and formed ordered arrays where both species aligned with the light source. No cooperative motility was observed when a non-motile pilB mutant of Syn OS-B' was used instead of Syn OS-B'. The binary consortium also produced more adherent biofilm than individual species, consistent with the close interspecies association revealed by electron microscopy. We propose that cyanobacteria and Chloroflexota cooperate in forming natural microbial mats, by colonizing new niches and building robust biofilms.

Co-culture systems of microalgae and heterotrophic microorganisms: applications in bioproduction and wastewater treatment and elucidation of mutualistic interactions

In recent years, reducing the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere has become an important issue. Microalgae have a higher photosynthetic efficiency and growth rate than higher plants; thus, biological carbon dioxide fixation using microalgae is attracting particular attention as an efficient carbon dioxide fixation method. However, under dilute atmospheric conditions, microalgae exhibit lower growth rates and reduced carbon dioxide fixation efficiency. In recent years, technology that can efficiently fix carbon dioxide, even in the atmosphere, using a microalgae co-culture system that co-cultivates microalgae and heterotrophic microorganisms has attracted attention. In such a co-culture system, it is believed that a mutualistic relationship is established between microorganisms through the exchange of various compounds. This review focuses on the application of a co-culture system of microalgae and heterotrophic microorganisms for bioproduction and wastewater treatment. In addition, research to elucidate the mutualistic relationships in microalgal co-culture systems using analytical methods that have been widely used in recent years, such as next-generation sequencing technology, is also discussed. In the future, it is expected that the use of microalgae co-culture systems will expand on an industrial scale through the development of key technologies, such as efficient genetic modification techniques for microalgae and their heterotrophic microorganism partners, large-scale cultivation facilities that can efficiently cultivate microalgae, and stable control techniques for co-culture systems using advanced technology.

High methane potential of oxygenic photogranules decreases after starvation

Oxygenic photogranules (OPG) are granular biofilms that can treat wastewater without external aeration, making it an advantage over activated sludge. Excess of OPG biomass can serve as energy source through anaerobic digestion. Two sequencing batch photoreactors were operated over 400 days to grow OPG. Biochemical methane potentials (BMP) were obtained from near-infrared spectroscopy. OPGs had an average BMP of 356 mL CH4·gVS-1, much higher than typical BMP from activated sludge. A partial least squares analysis could relate BMP with reactor operating conditions, like light regime, load or biomass concentration. Since organic load was the most influential parameter on BMP, three starvation experiments were set up. An average decrease of BMP by 18.4 % was observed. However, the unexpected growth of biomass during starvation resulted in a higher total methane volume. In conclusion, starvation reduces the BMP of OPGs but anaerobic digestion of OPG biomass remains a promising route for biomass valorization.

Beyond feast and famine: Cultivating hydrodynamic oxygenic photogranules with better performances under permanent feast regime

Oxygenic photogranules (OPGs) are currently obtained in permanent famine or cyclic feast-famine regimes. Whether photogranulation occurs under a permanent feast regime and how these regimes impact OPGs are unknown. Herein, the three regimes, each applied in two replicate hydrodynamic reactors, were established by different feeding frequencies. Results showed that OPGs were successfully cultivated in all regimes after 24-36 days of photogranulation phases with similar microbial community functions, including filamentous gliding, extracellular polymeric substances production, and carbon/nitrogen metabolism. The OPGs were then operated under the same sequencing batch mode and all achieved efficient removal of chemical oxygen demand (>91 %), ammonium (>96 %), and total nitrogen (>76 %) after different adaptation periods (19-41 days). Notably, the permanent feast regime obtained OPGs with the best physicochemical properties, the shortest adaptation period, and the lowest effluent turbidity, thus representing a novel means of hydrodynamic cultivating OPGs with better performances for sustainable wastewater treatment.

Hydrodynamic cultivation of aeration-free oxygenic photogranules is favored by sufficient amounts of organic carbon

Oxygenic photogranules (OPGs) have great potential for the aeration-free treatment of various wastewater, however, the effects of wastewater carbon composition on OPGs remain unknown. This study investigated the hydrodynamic photogranulation in three types of wastewater with the same total carbon concentration but different inorganic/organic carbon compositions, each operated at two replicated reactors. Results showed that photogranulation failed in reactors fed with only inorganic carbon. In reactors with equal inorganic and organic carbon, loose-structured OPGs formed but then disintegrated. Comparatively, reactors treating organic carbon-based wastewater obtained regular and dense OPGs with better settleability, lower effluent turbidity, excellent structural stability, and higher carbon assimilation rate. Sufficient amounts of organic carbon were crucial for the formation and stability of OPGs as they promoted the secretion of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) and the growth of filamentous cyanobacteria. This study provides a basis for the startup of OPGs process and facilitates its large-scale application.

Bacteria, Fungi, and Protists Exhibit Distinct Responses to Managed Vegetation Restoration in the Karst Region

Bacteria, fungi, and protists occupy a pivotal position in maintaining soil ecology. Despite limited knowledge on their responses to managed vegetation restoration strategies in karst regions, we aimed to study the essential microbial communities involved in the process of vegetation restoration. We compared microbial characteristics in four land use types: planted forests (PF), forage grass (FG), a mixture of plantation forest and forage grass (FF), and cropland (CR) as a reference. Our findings revealed that the richness of bacteria and protists was higher in FF compared to PF, while fungal richness was lower in both PF and FF than in CR. Additionally, the bacterial Shannon index in FF was higher than that in CR and PF, while the fungal and protist Shannon indices were similar across all four land use types. Significant differences were observed in the compositions of bacterial, fungal, and protist communities between FF and the other three land use types, whereas bacterial, fungal, and protist communities were relatively similar in PF and FG. In FF, the relative abundance of bacterial taxa Acidobacteria, Firmicutes, and Gemmatimonadetes was significantly higher than in PF and CR. Fungal communities were dominated by Ascomycota and Basidiomycota, with the relative abundance of Ascomycota significantly higher in FF compared to other land use types. Regarding protistan taxa, the relative abundance of Chlorophyta was higher in FF compared to CR, PF, and FG, while the relative abundance of Apicomplexa was higher in CR compared to FF. Importantly, ammonium nitrogen, total phosphorus, and microbial biomass nitrogen were identified as key soil properties predicting changes in the diversity of bacteria, fungi, and protists. Our results suggest that the microbial community under FF exhibits greater sensitivity to vegetation restoration compared to PF and FG. This sensitivity may stem from differences in soil properties, the formation of biological crusts and root systems, and management activities, resulting in variations in bacterial, fungal, and protist diversity and taxa in PF. As a result, employing a combination restoration strategy involving plantation forest and forage grass proves to be an effective approach to enhance the microbial community and thereby improve ecosystem functionality in ecologically fragile areas.

In-depth insight on microbial electrochemical systems coupled with membrane bioreactors for performance enhancement: a review

A conventional activated sludge (CAS) system has traditionally been used for secondary treatment in wastewater treatment plants. Due to the high cost of aeration and the problem of sludge treatment, researchers are developing alternatives to the CAS system. A membrane bioreactor (MBR) is a technology with higher solid-liquid separation efficiency. However, the use of MBR is limited due to inevitable membrane fouling and high energy consumption. Membrane fouling requires frequent cleaning, and MBR components must be replaced, which reduces membrane lifetime and operating costs. To overcome the limitations of the MBR system, a microbial fuel cell-membrane bioreactor (MFC-MBR) coupling system has attracted the interest of researchers. The design of the novel bioelectrochemical membrane reactor (BEMR) can effectively couple microbial degradation in the microbial electrochemical system (MES) and generate a microelectric field to reduce and alleviate membrane fouling in the MBR system. In addition, the coupling system combining an MES and an MBR can improve the efficiency of COD and ammonium removal while generating electricity to balance the energy consumption of the system. However, several obstacles must be overcome before the MFC-MBR coupling system can be commercialised. The aim of this study is to provide critical studies of the MBR, MES and MFC-MBR coupling system for wastewater treatment. This paper begins with a critical discussion of the unresolved MBR fouling problem. There are detailed past and current studies of the MES-MBR coupling system with comparison of performances of the system. Finally, the challenges faced in developing the coupling system on a large scale were discussed.

Development, performance and microbial community analysis of a continuous-flow microalgal-bacterial biofilm photoreactor for municipal wastewater treatment

This work reported the development, performance and microbial community of microalgal-bacterial biofilms cultivated in a continuous-flow photoreactor for municipal wastewater treatment under various conditions. Results showed that microalgal-bacterial biofilms were successfully developed at a HRT of 9 h without external aeration, with a biofilm concentration of around 4690 mg/L being achieved in the steady-state. It was found that further increase of HRT to 12 h did not improve the overall accumulation of biofilm, whereas the growth of microalgae in biofilms was faster than bacteria in the initial stage, indicated by an increased chlorophyll-a&b content in biofilms. After which, the chlorophyll-a&b content in biofilms gradually stabilized at the level comparable with the seed, suggesting that there was a balanced distribution of microalgae and bacteria in biofilms. About 90% of TOC, 71.4% of total nitrogen and 72.6% of phosphorus were removed by microalgal-bacterial biofilms mainly through assimilation in the steady-state photoreactor run at the HRT of 12 h with external aeration. The community analysis further revealed that Cyanobacteria and Chloroflexi were the main components, while Chlorophyta appeared to be the dominant eukaryotic algal community in biofilms. This study could offer new insights into the development of microalgal-bacterial biofilms in a continuous-flow photoreactor for sustainable low-carbon municipal wastewater treatment.

A Mathematical Study of Metal Biosorption on Algal-Bacterial Granular Biofilms

A multiscale mathematical model describing the metals biosorption on algal-bacterial photogranules within a sequencing batch reactor (SBR) is presented. The model is based on systems of partial differential equations (PDEs) derived from mass conservation principles on a spherical free boundary domain with radial symmetry. Hyperbolic PDEs account for the dynamics of sessile species and their free sorption sites, where metals are adsorbed. Parabolic PDEs govern the diffusion, conversion and adsorption of nutrients and metals. The dual effect of metals on photogranule ecology is also modelled: metal stimulates the production of EPS by sessile species and negatively affects the metabolic activities of microbial species. Accordingly, a stimulation term for EPS production and an inhibition term for metal are included in all microbial kinetics. The formation and evolution of the granule domain are governed by an ordinary differential equation with a vanishing initial value, accounting for microbial growth, attachment and detachment phenomena. The model is completed with systems of impulsive differential equations describing the evolution of dissolved substrates, metals, and planktonic and detached biomasses within the granular-based SBR. The model is integrated numerically to examine the role of the microbial species and EPS in the adsorption process, and the effect of metal concentration and adsorption properties of biofilm components on the metal removal. Numerical results show an accurate description of the photogranules evolution and ecology and confirm the applicability of algal-bacterial photogranule technology for metal-rich wastewater treatment.

Understanding the greenhouse gas emissions from China's wastewater treatment plants: Based on life cycle assessment coupled with statistical data

Wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) are significant contributors to energy consumption and anthropogenic greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. For achieving carbon reduction in the wastewater treatment industry, the direct and indirect GHG emissions generated by WWTPs need to be understood from a holistic perspective. This study estimated GHG emissions from WWTPs at the country scale by integrating process-based life cycle assessment and statistical data. On-site data were collected from 17 WWTPs of various regions in China. Uncertainty analysis based on Monte Carlo was also performed, so as to provide more reliable results. The results show that life cycle GHG emissions generated from the wastewater treatment process vary from 0.29 kg CO₂ eq/m³ to 1.18 kg CO₂ eq/m³ based on 17 sample WWTPs. The key factors contributing to overall GHG emissions are also identified as carbon dioxide (fossil) and methane (fossil) to air mainly generated from electricity generation, and methane (biogenic) and nitrous oxide (biogenic) to air mainly generated from wastewater treatment. National average GHG emissions was evaluated with the value of 0.88 kg CO₂ eq/m³, with on-site GHG emissions and off-site electricity-based GHG emissions accounting for 32% and 34%, respectively. The total GHG emissions generated from wastewater treatment are 56.46 billion kg CO₂ eq in 2020, with Guangdong province having the dominant contribution. Policy suggestions (e.g., further adjusting the electricity grid toward a low carbon structure, improving technology to promote treatment efficiency and energy recovery) were highly recommended so that national GHG emissions of WWTPs can be reduced. In order to achieve the synergy of pollutant removal and GHG emission reduction, policy-making on wastewater treatment should be tailored to specific local conditions.

Enhancing phosphorus removal of photogranules by incorporating polyphosphate accumulating organisms

Photogranules are a novel wastewater treatment technology that can utilize the sun's energy to treat water with lower energy input and have great potential for nutrient recovery applications. They have been proven to efficiently remove nitrogen and carbon but show lower conversion rates for phosphorus compared to established treatment systems, such as aerobic granular sludge. In this study, we successfully introduced polyphosphate accumulating organisms (PAOs) to an established photogranular culture. We operated photobioreactors in sequencing batch mode with six cycles per day and alternating anaerobic (dark) and aerobic (light) phases. We were able to increase phosphorus removal/recovery by 6 times from 5.4 to 30 mg/L/d while maintaining similar nitrogen and carbon removal compared to photogranules without PAOs. To maintain PAOs activity, alternating anaerobic feast and aerobic famine conditions were required. In future applications, where aerobic conditions are dependent on in-situ oxygenation via photosynthesis, the process will rely on sunlight availability. Therefore, we investigated the feasibility of the process under diurnal cycles with a 12-h anaerobic phase during nighttime and six short cycles during the 12 h daytime. The 12-h anaerobic phase had no adverse effect on the PAOs and phototrophs. Due to the extension of one anaerobic phase to 12 h the six aerobic phases were shortened by 47% and consequently decreased the light hours per day. This resulted in a decrease of phototrophs, which reduced nitrogen removal and biomass productivity up to 30%. Finally, we discuss and suggest strategies to apply PAO-enriched photogranules at large-scale.

Resource recovery from municipal wastewater: A critical paradigm shift in the post era of activated sludge

The conventional activated sludge (CAS) process as one of the greatest engineering marvels has made irreplaceable contributions towards the human development in the past one hundred years. However, the underlying principle of CAS which is primarily based on biological oxidation has been challenged by accelerating global climate change. In such a situation, a fundamental question that urgently needs to be answered is what wastewater treatment technology would be in the post era of activated sludge? Thus, this article illustrates the necessity of a technology paradigm shift from the current linear economy to circular economy with the energy and resource recovery from municipal wastewater being a major driver. It is argued that ammonium recovery should be considered towards the sustainable municipal wastewater reclamation. Meanwhile, the potential novel processes with enhanced energy and resource recovery are also discussed, which may offer useful insights into the ways to achieve the carbon-neutral municipal wastewater reclamation.

Current Progress, Challenges and Perspectives in the Microalgal-Bacterial Aerobic Granular Sludge Process: A Review

Traditional wastewater treatment technologies have become increasingly inefficient to meet the needs of low-consumption and sustainable wastewater treatment. Researchers are committed to seeking new wastewater treatment technologies, to reduce the pressure on the environment caused by resource shortages. Recently, a microalgal-bacterial granular sludge (MBGS) technology has attracted widespread attention due to its high efficiency wastewater treatment capacity, low energy consumption, low CO₂ emissions, potentially high added values, and resource recovery capabilities. This review focused primarily on the following aspects of microalgal-bacterial granular sludge technology: (1) MBGS culture and maintenance operating parameters, (2) MBGS application in different wastewaters, (3) MBGS additional products: biofuels and bioproducts, (4) MBGS energy saving and consumption reduction: greenhouse gas emission reduction, and (5) challenges and prospects. The information in this review will help us better understand the current progress and future direction of the MBGS technology development. It is expected that this review will provide a sound theoretical basis for the practical applications of a MBGS technology in environmentally sustainable wastewater treatment, resource recovery, and system optimization.

Microalgal-bacterial granular sludge for municipal wastewater treatment: From concept to practice

Recently, increasing interest has been placed in microalgal-bacterial granular sludge (MBGS) in the journey towards the energy and carbon neutrality of municipal wastewater treatment. Different from aerobic granular sludge, the performance of MBGS is mainly determined by the mutualism and symbiosis between coexisting microalgae and bacteria. It appears from the literature that most of studies on MBGS were conducted at small benchtop scales under controlled conditions with synthetic wastewater. Therefore, this article attempts to look into the major engineering gaps between the knowledge generated from numerous laboratory research works and the large-scale application of MBGS, including massive production of MBGS, type of bioreactor, effect of alternate photo and dark metabolisms on effluent quality, resource recovery from waste MBGS, etc. It is clearly demonstrated that MBGS is still at its infant stage, and more effort is strongly needed to identify the technological bottlenecks of full-scale applications, while providing corresponding engineering solutions.

Emerging biological wastewater treatment using microalgal-bacterial granules: A review

Aiming at deepening the understanding of the formation and evolution of emerging microalgal-bacterial granule (MBG)-based wastewater treatment systems, the recent advances regarding the formation processes, transfer phenomena, innovative bioreactors development and wastewater treatment performance of MBG-based systems are comprehensively reviewed in this work. Particularly, the successful establishments of MBG-based systems with various inocula are summarized. Besides, as the indispensable factors for biochemical reactions in MBGs, the light and substrates (organic matters, inorganic nutrients, etc) need to undergo complicated and multi-scale transfer processes before being assimilated by microorganisms within MBGs. Therefore, the involved transfer phenomena and mechanisms in MBG-based bioreactors are critically discussed. Subsequently, some recent advances of MBG-based bioreactors, the application of MBG-based systems in treating various synthetic and real wastewater, and the future development directions are discussed. In short, this review helps in promoting the development of MBG-based systems by presenting current research status and future perspectives.

The limitations of bioeconomy LCA studies for understanding the transition to sustainable bioeconomy

Purpose

Transition to bioeconomy requires all actors and stakeholders to measure the impact of systems that use bioresources and technologies to provision society. There are however some challenges with integrating LCA into business development and management, which have important implications for bioeconomy. There have been many LCA studies published in the twenty-first century, but the question must be answered: how useful are these LCA studies to help understand and manage transition to sustainable bioeconomy?

Method

This research used a structured literature review to identify 83 bioeconomy LCA studies published from January 2006 to June 2021 (excluding bioenergy). The studies were analysed for compliance with the ISO 14044 standard, with specific reference to the goal, commissioning perspective, system boundary, function and functional unit, impact methods and categories.

Results and discussions

It was found that more than 85% of the studies reviewed failed to present the required goal statement and a description of the function of the system. Nearly 13% of the studies did not define the system boundary, and only 17% included a full life cycle including raw material extraction, production, use and end-of-life stages. The majority of the LCA studies surveyed from 2006 to 2021 were either (i) not in compliance with the ISO standards or (ii) space and style limitations of the publication process prevented competent practitioners from properly conveying their work. This suggests that the value and integrity of the literature are undermined by not rigorously addressing the first and most important stage of an LCA study.

Conclusion

When interpreting the results, a major shortcoming noted was that most studies did not consider the industrial symbiosis needed between feedstock, technology, primary products, side streams, downstream valorisation and long-term circularity in order to properly understand the transition pathways required. Bioeconomy technologies were imagined as displacers for feedstocks and processes to adapt business as usual, rather than as transformers of the system to a sustainable footing.

Recommendation

If LCA studies are going to provide meaningful information for actors and stakeholders to assess whether a system will be able to operate sustainably, studies should include a full, integrated system, standards should be adhered to and approaches should perhaps go beyond mere eco-efficiency, or doing less harm, as these are not necessarily indicative of sustainability. Historical bioeconomy LCA studies do not provide great insight into the transition to sustainable bioeconomy.

Supplementary information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s11367-022-02053-w.

Shining a Light on Wastewater Treatment with Microalgae

Microalgae can produce biofuels, nutriceuticals, pigments and many other products, but commercialization has been limited by the cost of growing, harvesting and processing algal biomass. Nutrients, chiefly nitrogen and phosphorus, are a key cost for growing microalgae, but these nutrients are present in abundance in municipal wastewater where they pose environmental problems if not removed. This is not a traditional review article; rather, it is a fact-based set of suggestions that will have to be investigated by scientists and engineers. It is suggested that if microalgae were grown as biofilms rather than as planktonic cells, and if internal illumination rather than external illumination were employed, then the use of microalgae may provide useful improvements to the wastewater treatment process. The use of microalgae to remove nutrients from wastewater has been demonstrated, but has not yet been widely implemented due to cost, and because microalgae derived from wastewater treatment has not yet been demonstrated as a commercial source for value-added products. Future facilities are likely to be called Municipal Resource Recovery Facilities as wastewater will increasingly be viewed as a resource for water, biofuels, fertilizer, monitoring public health and value-added products. Advances in photonics will accelerate this transition.

CO2 improves the microalgal-bacterial granular sludge towards carbon-negative wastewater treatment

As a promising wastewater treatment technology, little is known about whether the greenhouse gas CO₂ can be applied for microalgal-bacterial granular sludge (MBGS) process. This article applied CO₂ for improving MBGS process. It was found that the physical structure of MBGS with no CO₂ addition appeared to have a trend to be loose and disintegrated, with a sludge volume index at 5 min (SVI₅) of over 150 mL/g and an average pore size of 35 nm in 60 d operation. However, CO₂ could maintain the compact and integrated structure of MBGS with a SVI₅ lower than 50 mL/g and an average pore size ranging from 10 to 13 nm. CO₂ could enhance the production of extracellular polysaccharides and aromatic protein, thus favoring the granular stability of MBGS. CO₂ could change the aqueous environment, e.g. lowering the pH values, which resulted in different microbial communities as well as metabolic potentials of MBGS. As for the reactor performance, CO₂ could significantly improve the removals of organics and phosphorus, evidenced by the enhancement of genes encoding acetate-CoA ligase and ATPase, respectively. Although the mass ratio of algae to bacteria was elevated by CO₂ addition, the ammonia removal related enzymes of glutamate dehydrogenase and glutamine synthetase could be negatively and positively impacted by CO₂, respectively. Mass balance analysis of carbon indicated that CO₂ could provide additional carbon source as well as enhance the buffering capacity for the MBGS system. Further estimations suggested that the MBGS process could achieve a carbon-negative objective for municipal wastewater treatment by supplying CO₂ as additional carbon source. Hence, CO₂ supply for MBGS process in municipal wastewater treatment can be deemed as a two-birds-one-stone strategy, i.e. maintaining the granular stability and eliminating the carbon emission. This article can advance our basic knowledge on MBGS process towards environment-sustainable wastewater treatment.

Assessing the environmental impacts and greenhouse gas emissions from the common municipal wastewater treatment systems

This study measured the environmental impacts from three same-size wastewater treatment systems, specifically activated sludge, a constructed wetland, and a high rate algal pond. Detailed data inventories were employed using SimaPro 9 software to calculate the entire consequences by ReCiPe 2016 and Greenhouse Gas Protocol method. The environmental outcomes caused by substance emissions and resource extraction are presented in several impact categories at the endpoint level. For a better comparison, the single score tool was applied to aggregate all factors into three areas of protection: human health, ecosystem, and resource shortage. Results showed that concrete and steel are the main contributors to the construction phase, while electricity is responsible for the operation stage. The single score calculation indicates that the proportion of construction activities could be equal to or even higher than the operation stage for a small capacity plant. The total environmental impact of the conventional system was 2.3-fold and 3-fold higher than that of constructed wetland and high rate algal pond, respectively. High rate algal pond has the best environmental performance when generating the least burdens and greenhouse gas emissions of 0.72 kg CO₂ equivalent per m³. Constructed wetland produces 5.69 kg CO_2, higher than an algal pond but much lower than activated sludge plant, emitting 11.42 kg CO₂ per m³.

Assuaging Microalgal Harvesting Woes via Attached Growth: A Critical Review to Produce Sustainable Microalgal Feedstock

Third-generation biofuels that are derived from microalgal biomass have gained momentum as a way forward in the sustainable production of biodiesel. Such efforts are propelled by the intention to reduce our dependence on fossil fuels as the primary source of energy. Accordingly, growing microalgal biomass in the form of suspended cultivation has been a conventional technique for the past few decades. To overcome the inevitable harvesting shortcomings arising from the excessive energy and time needed to separate the planktonic microalgal cells from water medium, researchers have started to explore attached microalgal cultivation systems. This cultivation mode permits the ease of harvesting mature microalgal biomass, circumventing the need to employ complex harvesting techniques to single out the cells, and is economically attractive. However, the main bottleneck associated with attached microalgal growth is low biomass production due to the difficulties the microalgal cells have in forming attachment and populating thereafter. In this regard, the current review encompasses the novel techniques adopted to promote attached microalgal growth. The physicochemical effects such as the pH of the culture medium, hydrophobicity, as well as the substratum surface properties and abiotic factors that can determine the fate of exponential growth of attached microalgal cells, are critically reviewed. This review aims to unveil the benefits of an attached microalgal cultivation system as a promising harvesting technique to produce sustainable biodiesel for lasting applications.