Effects of applying different carbon substrates on nutrient removal and greenhouse gas emissions by constructed wetlands treating carbon-depleted hydroponic wastewater

Constructed wetlands for wastewater treatment and reuse: Two decades of experience from China

Constructed wetlands (CWs) can be used for water purification and ecological restoration through the synergistic effects of substrates, aquatic plants, and microorganisms. This study explored a bibliometric approach to quantitatively evaluate the recent research progress and applications of CWs in China by synthetically analyzing publication output characteristics, research hotspots and quantified China's unique contributions to global CW applications. The results indicated that the number of papers published in the field of CWs has shown an overall upward trend in the past two decades, and the research hotspots mainly focus on the nitrogen and phosphorus removal, microbial community. China has actively supported the investigation and application of CWs for wastewater treatment and reuse. More than 40 species of plants and over 30 types of substrates have been employed in CWs for treating different types of wastewater, such as domestic sewage, industrial effluents, river water, and drinking water. Several successful case studies of full-scale CWs have been selected and summarized to highlight the extensive application of CWs in China and provided a CW localized design framework.

Optimization and action mechanism of pollutant removal performance of unsaturated vertical flow constructed wetland (UVFCW) driven by substained-release carbon source

Constructed wetland (CW) technology has attracted much attention due to its economical and environmentally friendly features. The low dissolved oxygen (DO) and low carbon/nitrogen (C/N) ratio in the wetland influent water affect the treatment performance of CW, resulting in a decrease in the removal efficiency of ammonia nitrogen (NH4 +-N) and nitrate nitrogen (NO3 --N). In order to address this problem, this study optimized the pollutants removal performance of unsaturated vertical flow constructed wetland (UVFCW) by adding sustained-release carbon sources (corn cobs + polybutylene adipate terephthalate (PBAT)). The results showed that the sustained-release of carbon source increased the carbon source in UVFCW, thus increasing the abundance and activity of denitrifying microorganisms and enhancing the denitrification reaction, ultimately improving the removal of NO3 --N, with its removal efficiency reaching up to 95.50%. The placement method of sustained-release carbon source mainly affected the distribution of carbon source and DO in water body, thus influencing the relative abundance of microorganisms, finally affecting the removal of pollutants. Among them, the removal efficiency of total nitrogen (TN), NO3 --N, and total phosphorus (TP), and the relative abundance of denitrifying microorganisms in the CWR-Cu (uniform placement of sustained-release carbon source) were significantly higher than those in the CWR-Ca (centralized placement above) and CWR-Cb (centralized placement below) (p < 0.05). The surface C:O (carbon:oxygen) ratio of sustained-release carbon source after water treatment showed a decreasing trend, and CWR-Cu exhibited the greatest decrease in C:O ratio. In summary, CWR-Cu achieved the highest utilization of the carbon source and produced the largest number of heterotrophic microorganisms. This study reveals that CWR-Cu is a structural process for the efficient removal of nitrogen and phosphorus pollutants, and our findings provide theoretical basis and technical support for actual projects.

Study on the carbon source stability of constructed wetland prepared from modified aged straw

The low cost of biomass has made it an important option for providing carbon sources in the treatment of low carbon to nitrogen ratio (C/N) wastewater constructed wetland (CW). However, the unstable release of biomass carbon source reduces utilization and operation efficiency of CW. In this study, aged corn straw was used as raw material, and modification treatments with acid, alkali and oxidant were to optimize the conditions for stable carbon source release. The results showed that the modified straw exhibited three trends (stable release, continuous release, and short-term release) under water immersion conditions. The electrical conductivity (EC) of straw modified by HCl, H2SO4 and low-concentration KMnO4 (0.01 mol L-1) was low, so the supply of carbon sources in CW was obviously insufficient. The straw modified by HNO3 (1.5 or 2.5 mol L-1), KMnO4 (0.05 mol L-1), KMnO4 (0.05 mol L-1) + HCl (0.004 mol L-1) was continuously released chemical oxygen demand during the experiment, the increase in EC was significant, which could be used as an additional carbon source for CW. The research results will promote the improvement of biomass carbon source utilization in CW and improve the utilization value of straw.

Recycling various wastes as substrates in constructed wetlands: A review on enhancing contaminants removal and potential risks

Under the perspectives of circular economy, coupling waste management and environmental engineering to foster sustainable pollution control solutions has gained particular attention. Particularly in constructed wetlands (CWs) as a nature-based solution, recycling various wastes as substrates for enhancing the removal of various pollutants have become a recent hotspot in recent years. In this review, physicochemical properties, enhanced removal performance and mechanism of various pollutants, and potential risks of waste-derived substrates including industrial and municipal wastes, agricultural by-products, and waste synthetic substrates were summarized comprehensively. It is indicated that agricultural by-products have the best chemical oxygen demand (COD) and total nitrogen (TN) removal with the average removal efficiency of 91.23 % and 83.68 %, while industrial and municipal wastes have the best total phosphorus (TP) removal efficiency (86.70 %). The main impacts and risks of waste-derived substrates included: the secondary pollution, toxic to plants and microorganisms, and potential clogging. This review could provide theoretical basis for the future exploration and application of recycling waste as substrates in CWs.

Mitigating N2O emissions in land treatment systems: Mechanisms, influences, and future directions

Land treatment systems (LTS) are widely used in decentralized domestic wastewater treatment due to low energy requirements and effective treatment outcomes. However, LTS operations are also a significant source of N2O emissions, a potent greenhouse gas threatening the ozone layer and posing risks to human health. Despite the importance of understanding and controlling N2O emissions, existing literature lacks comprehensive analyses of the mechanisms driving N2O generation and effective control strategies within LTS. This study addresses this gap by reviewing current research and identifying key factors influencing N2O emissions in LTS. This review reveals that in addition to traditional nitrification and denitrification processes, co-denitrification and complete ammonia oxidation are crucial for microbial nitrogen removal in LTS. Plant selection is primarily based on their nitrogen absorption capacity while using materials such as biochar and iron can provide carbon sources or electrons to support microbial activities. Optimizing operational parameters is essential for reducing N2O emissions and enhancing nitrogen removal efficiency in LTS. Specifically, the carbon-to‑nitrogen ratio should be maintained between 5 and 12, and the hydraulic loading rate should be kept within 0.08-0.2 m3/(m2·d). Dissolved oxygen and oxidation-reduction potential should be adjusted to meet the aerobic or anaerobic conditions the microorganisms require. Additionally, maintaining a pH range of 6.5-7.5 by adding alkaline substances is crucial for sustaining nitrous oxide reductase activity. The operating temperature should be maintained between 20 and 30 °C to support optimal microbial activity. This review further explores the relationship between environmental factors and microbial enzyme activity, community structure changes, and functional gene expression related to N2O production. Future research directions are proposed to refine N2O flux control strategies. By consolidating current knowledge and identifying research gaps, this review advances LTS management strategies that improve wastewater treatment efficiency while mitigating the environmental and health impacts of N2O emissions.

Optimizing nitrogen removal in constructed wetlands for low C/N ratio wastewater treatment: Insights from fermentation liquid utilization

The inefficient nitrogen removal in constructed wetlands (CWs) can be attributed to insufficient carbon sources for low carbon-to-nitrogen (C/N) ratio wastewater. In this study, sugarcane bagasse fermentation liquid (SBFL) was used as a supplemental carbon source in intermittently aerated CWs to enhance nitrogen removal. The impact of different regulated influent C/N ratios on nitrogen removal and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions was investigated. Results demonstrated that SBFL addition significantly enhanced the denitrification capacity, resulting in faster NO3--N removal compared to sucrose. Moreover, intermittently aerated CWs significantly improved NH4+-N removal efficiency compared to non-aerated CWs. The highest total nitrogen removal efficiency (98.3 %) was achieved at an influent C/N ratio of 5 in intermittently aerated CWs with SBFL addition. The addition of SBFL resulted in a reduction of N2O emissions by 17.8 %-43.7 % compared to sucrose. All CWs exhibited low CH4 emissions, with SBFL addition (0.035-0.066 mg·m-2h-1) resulting in lower emissions compared to sucrose. Additionally, higher abundance of denitrification (nirK, nirS and nosZ) genes as well as more abundant denitrifying bacteria were shown in CWs of SBFL inputs. The results of this study provide a feasible strategy for applying SBFL as a carbon source to improve nitrogen removal efficiency and mitigate GHG emissions in CWs.

Mitigating nitrous oxide emissions from low carbon to nitrogen ratio wastewater treatment: Utilizing sugarcane bagasse fermentation liquid for constructed wetlands

Sugarcane bagasse was recycled to produce fermentation liquid (FL) as a supplementary carbon source that was added to constructed wetlands (CWs) for regulating influent carbon to nitrogen ratio (C/N), and then being applied to investigate nitrogen transformations and greenhouse gas emissions. Results showed that this FL achieved faster NO3--N removal and lower N2O fluxes than sucrose did, and the lowest N2O flux (67.6 μg m-2h-1) was achieved when FL was added to CWs in a C/N of 3. In contrast, CH4 emissions were higher by the FL addition than by the sucrose addition, although the fluxes under both additions were in a lower range of 0.06-0.17 mg m-2h-1. The utilization of FL also induced significant variations in microbial communities and increased the abundance of denitrification genes. Results showed the application of FL from sugarcane bagasse can be an effective strategy for improving nitrogen removal and mitigating N2O emissions in CWs.

Interaction of reed litter and biochar presences on performances of constructed wetlands

Constructed wetlands (CWs) are frequently used for effective biological treatment of nitrogen-rich wastewater with external carbon source addition; however, these approaches often neglect the interaction between plant litter and biochar in biochar-amended CW environments. To address this, we conducted a comprehensive study to assess the impacts of single or combined addition of common reed litter and reed biochar (pyrolyzed at 300 and 500 °C) on nitrogen removal, greenhouse gas emission, dissolved organic matter (DOM) dynamics, and microbial activity. The results showed that combined addition of reed litter and biochar to CWs significantly improved nitrate and total nitrogen removal compared with biochar addition alone. Compared to those without reed litter addition, CWs with reed litter addition had more low-molecular-weight and less aromatic DOM and more protein-like fluorescent DOM, which favored the enrichment of bacteria associated with denitrification. The improved nitrogen removal could be attributed to increases in denitrifying microbes and the relative abundance of functional denitrification genes with litter addition. Moreover, the combined addition of reed litter and 300 °C-heated biochar significantly decreased nitrous oxide (30.7 %) and methane (43.9 %) compared to reed litter addition alone, while the combined addition of reed litter and 500 °C-heated biochar did not. This study demonstrated that the presences of reed litter and biochar in CWs could achieve both high microbial nitrogen removal and relatively low greenhouse gas emissions.

Greenhouse gas emissions from constructed wetlands: A bibliometric analysis and mini-review

Constructed wetlands (CWs) have been widely applied in wastewater treatment; however, the degradation of organic pollutants within CWs leads to substantial emissions of greenhouse gases (GHGs), such as carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide. Under the low-carbon economy, GHG emissions have emerged as a major concern, and have been intensively studied in the CW field. In this study, we conducted a bibliometric review using CiteSpace and a global-scale analysis of GHG emission levels based on 286 records and proposed potential approaches for the future control of GHG emissions in CWs. We found that the research has generally evolved through three stages over the past 15 years: GHG emission level assessment (2007-2010), mechanisms (2011-2016), and control (2017-2022). The type of CWs is closely related to GHG emissions, with free water surface CWs emitting higher levels of methane and vertical subsurface flow CWs emitting higher levels of carbon dioxide and nitrous oxide. By optimizing CW operation, it is conceivable to synergistically reduce GHG emissions while enhancing pollutant removal.

Dominant factors analyses and challenges of anaerobic digestion under cold environments

With the development of fermentation technology and the improvement of efficiency, anaerobic digestion (AD) has been playing an increasingly primary role in waste treatment and resource recovery. Temperature is undoubtedly the most important factor because it shapes microbial habitats, changes the composition of the microbial community structure, and even affects the expression of related functional genes. More than half of the biosphere is in a long-term or seasonal low-temperature environment (<20 °C), which makes psychrophilic AD have broad application prospects. Therefore, this review discusses the influencing factors and enhancement strategies of psychrophilic AD, which may provide a corresponding reference for future research on low-temperature fermentation. First, the occurrence of AD has been discussed. Then, the adaptation of microorganisms to the low-temperature environment was analyzed. Moreover, the challenges of psychrophilic AD have been reviewed. Meanwhile, the strategies for improving psychrophilic AD are presented. Further, from technology to application, the current situation of psychrophilic AD in pilot-scale tests is described. Finally, the economic and environmental feasibility of psychrophilic AD has been highlighted. In summary, psychrophilic AD is technically feasible, while economic analysis shows that the output benefits cannot fully cover the input costs, and the large-scale practical application of psychrophilic AD is still in its infancy. More research should focus on how to improve fermentation efficiency and reduce the investment cost of psychrophilic AD.

Application of alkali-heated corncobs enhanced nitrogen removal and microbial diversity in constructed wetlands for treating low C/N ratio wastewater

Lack of carbon source is the main limiting factor in the denitrification of low C/N ratio wastewater in the constructed wetlands (CWs). Agricultural waste has been considered as a supplementary carbon source but research is still limited. To solve this problem, ferric carbon (Fe-C) + zeolite, Fe-C + gravel, and gravel were used as substrates to build CWs in this experiment, aiming to investigate the effects of different carbon sources (rice straw, corncobs, alkali-heated corncobs) on nitrogen removal performance and microbial community structure in CWs for low C/N wastewater. The results demonstrated that the microbial community and effluent nitrogen concentration of CWs were mainly influenced by the carbon source rather than the substrate. Alkali-heated corncobs significantly enhanced the removal of NO2--N, NH4+-N, NO3-N, and TN. Carbon sources addition increased microbial diversity. Alkali-heated corncobs addition significantly increased the abundance of heterotrophic denitrifying bacteria (Proteobacteria and Bacteroidota). Furthermore, alkali-heated corncobs addition increased the copy number of nirS, nosZ, and nirK genes while greenhouse gas fluxes were lower than common corncobs. In summary, alkali-heated corncobs can be considered as an effective carbon source.

Is constructed wetlands carbon source or carbon sink? Case analysis based on life cycle carbon emission accounting

Constructed wetlands (CWs) are widely used to polish the effluent of wastewater treatment plants and micro-polluted river or lake water. However, the impact of large-scale applications of CWs on carbon emissions is unclear. In this study, the carbon footprints of two full-scale hybrid CWs were determined based on life cycle assessment (LCA). Results showed that the carbon emission of CW ranged from 0.10 to 0.14 kg CO2-eq/m3, and was significantly correlated with the influent chemical oxygen demand loads and electricity consumption. However, CW would approach carbon neutrality during the service period when taking plant carbon sequestration into consideration. Compared with other advanced wastewater treatment technologies, CWs showed significant low-carbon emission and cost-effective benefits. This study clarified the role of CWs in the carbon cycle and would provide guidance for the construction and management of CWs.

Role of hydrophytes in constructed wetlands for nitrogen removal and greenhouse gases reduction

With the prominence of global climate change and proposal of carbon reduction concept, how to maximize the comprehensive effect of nitrogen removal and greenhouse gases (GHGs) reduction in constructed wetlands (CWs) has become crucial. As indispensable biological component of CWs, hydrophytes have received extensive attention owing to their application potential. This review comprehensively evaluates the functions of hydrophytes in nitrogen removal and GHGs reduction in CWs in terms of plants themselves, plant-mediated microbes and plant residues (hydrophyte carbon sources and hydrophyte-derived biochars). On this basis, the strategies for constructing an ideal CW system are put forward from the perspective of full life-cycle utilization of hydrophytes. Finally, considering the variability of plant species composition in CWs, outlooks for future research are specifically proposed. This review provides guidance and novel perspectives for the full life-cycle utilization of hydrophytes in CWs, as well as for the construction of an ideal CW system.

Effect of plant-self debris on nitrogen removal, transformation and microbial community in mesocosm constructed wetlands planted with Myriophyllum aquaticum

Aquatic macrophytes debris decomposition could release pollutants and nutrients into the water of constructed wetlands (CWs), but their role in nitrogen removal and transformation remains poorly understood. The present study investigated the effects of plant-self debris on nitrogen removal and microbial communities in mesocosm CWs planted with Myriophyllum aquaticum. During the 68-day operation, the plant debris addition did not change the mean removal efficiency of ammonium (NH₄⁺-N) and total nitrogen (TN) of CWs but showed significant differences over the operation time. The NH₄⁺-N and organic nitrogen released from the plant debris decomposition affected the nitrogen removal. The plant debris decreased the effluent nitrate concentration and N₂O emission fluxes of the CWs with the increased abundance of denitrifying bacterial genera, indicating that plant debris decomposition increased the denitrification activities via dissolved organic carbon release. High-throughput sequencing indicated that the plant debris altered the distribution and composition of the microbial community in the sediments. Proteobacteria was the dominant phylum (28-52%), and the relative abundance of denitrifying bacteria genera was significantly higher in the sediments with debris addition (37-40%) than in the non-addition (6.6-7.7%). The present study provided new insights into the role of macrophytes in pollutant removal and the plant management strategy of CWs.

Acorus calamus recycled as an additional carbon source in a microbial fuel cell-constructed wetland for enhanced nitrogen removal

Acorus calamus was recycled as an additional carbon source in microbial fuel cell-constructed wetlands (MFC-CWs), for efficient nitrogen removal of low carbon wastewater. The pretreatment methods, adding positions, and nitrogen transformations were investigated. Results indicated that alkali-pretreatment cleaved the benzene rings in dominant released organics, producing chemical oxygen demand of 164.5 mg from per gram of A. calamus. Pretreated biomass addition in the anode of MFC-CW attained the maximum total nitrogen removal of 97.6% and power generation of 12.5 mW/m², which were higher than those with biomass in the cathode (97.6% and 1.6 mW/m², respectively). However, the duration of a cycle with biomass in the cathode (20-25 days) was longer than that in the anode (10-15 days). Microbial metabolisms related to organics degradation, nitrification, denitrification, and anammox were intensified after biomass recycling. This study provides a promising method to improve nitrogen removal and energy recovery in MFC-CWs.

Identification of microbial consortia for sustainable disposal of constructed wetland reed litter wastes

Reed is a typical emerged plant in constructed wetlands (CWs). Its litters were used as raw materials for preparing Fe-C ceramic-filler (Fe-C-CF). The physical and chemical properties of Fe-C-CF were studied under different conditions, including the mass ration of Fe to carbon (Fe/C ratio), sintering temperature, and time, to determine the optimum preparing conditions. Meanwhile, the denitrification performance and CO₂ emission flux of the surface flow constructed wetland (SFCW) systems were investigated when using Fe-C-CF as the matrix. The optimum preparing conditions for Fe-C-CF were Fe/C ratio of 1:1, sintering temperature and time of 500 °C and 20 min, respectively. The SFCW system with Fe-C-CF obtained a higher total nitrogen (TN), nitrate nitrogen (NO₃^--N), and ammonia nitrogen (NH₃-N) removal efficiencies than the control SFCW system without Fe-C-CF. Compared with the heterotrophic denitrification process, the SFCW system with Fe-C-CF decreased CO₂ emission by 67.9 g m^-2 per year. The results of microbial community analysis indicated that addition of Fe-C-CF increased the diversity and abundance of microbial communities in the SFCW systems. The dominant genus of the SFCW system with Fe-C-CF was Bacillus, while Uliginosibacterium was the dominant genus in the system without the filler.

Sustainability assessment of wastewater reuse in a Portuguese military airbase

The current water-scarcity crisis that is being felt in Europe, namely in the southern region, has leveraged the development and implementation of national and regional water management plans. These policies aim to promote efficient wastewater reuse in industrial and urban sectors. Thus, stakeholders are now seeking strategies to enhance the sustainability of their wastewater treatment processes. The present work details the evaluation of the wastewater treatment methods used at an Air Force Base located in Portugal. In addition, this study also intended to determine how wastewater reuse can be implemented and add value to the environmental protection mission of the military airbase. Hence, an assessment of wastewater treatment practices was carried out, considering primary and secondary treatments. The chemical, physical, and biological indicators of samples collected over two consecutive years were analyzed to determine trends and fluctuations. The results revealed that the overall effectiveness of nutrient removal is low due to the oversized nature of the treatment plant, the age of the facility, and the composition of the wastewater. The effluent produced meets standards for non-potable reuse and could be used on base for aircraft maintenance and the cleaning of facilities. Nonetheless, the effectiveness of the plant could be improved by implementing a more advanced tertiary wastewater treatment to decrease the concentration of undesired compounds (e.g., total nitrogen), enabling the reuse of water in a broader range of activities.