Enhanced anaerobic treatment of sulfate-rich wastewater by electrical voltage application

An observed "sandwich" framework mediated via sulfate ions as electron shuttle for efficient electro-oxidation of organic pollutants

"Electro-oxidation processes are effective in treating sulfate-rich organic wastewater. However, this technology development has been hindered by the poor understanding of the role of sulfate ions. This paper reports that high concentration of sulfate ions significantly enhanced the electro-oxidation of organic pollutants. High sulfate concentration did not affect radical activity or organic pollutant coverage on the electrode surface. We propose that the electrode interface forms a "sandwich" framework mediated by sulfate ions, consisting of the electrode surface, the sulfate ion layer, and the organic pollutant layer. High concentrations of sulfate ions selectively promote the protonated organic pollutant into the framework via electrostatic attraction when the solution pH is lower than the pKa of the organic pollutants. In this framework, the sulfate ion layer acts as an electron shuttle, creating a smooth electron transfer pathway between the electrode surface and the organic maters. In this way, the "sandwich" framework can efficiently electro-oxidize organic pollutants. This study offers new insights into the role of sulfate ions in electro-oxidation processes, redefining their role in pollutant degradation, and guiding the design of sulfate-rich wastewater treatment."

Strategies for enriching targeted sulfate-reducing bacteria and revealing their microbial interactions in anaerobic digestion ecosystems

Deciphering relationships between sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB) and other microorganisms is crucial for stable operation of anaerobic digestion systems when treating sulfate-containing wastewater. However, few studies have differentiated the incomplete oxidizing SRB (IO-SRB) and complete oxidizing SRB (CO-SRB) in anaerobic digestion ecosystems. Four ethanol-fed bioreactors were operated under two operational modes (sequencing batch reactor, SBR; and continuous-flow reactor, CFR) and two chemical oxygen demand (COD) to sulfate ratios (1 and 2) to systematically explore strategies for enriching IO-SRB and/or CO-SRB and their microbial interactions with other microorganisms. Compared to SBRs, CFRs could enhance sulfate removal and demonstrated higher microbial activities in sulfate and ethanol degradation. IO-SRB competed with ethanol oxidizing bacteria in all reactors, and IO-SRB's contribution to ethanol degradation increased from 62.9 %-67.1 % to 69.0 %-82.1 % as the COD/sulfate ratio decreased from 2 to 1. Moreover, CO-SRB competed acetotrophic methanogens exclusively in CFRs, as CO-SRB could not be efficiently enriched in SBRs. Low COD/sulfate ratios facilitated the enrichment of Desulfococcus (CO-SRB), and the CFR operational mode further strengthened its enrichment. Additionally, hydrogenotrophic SRB outperformed hydrogenotrophic methanogens in all four reactors. In general, IO-SRB and CO-SRB possessed distinct microbial interactions with methanogens, with potential syntrophic relationships between IO-SRB and acetotrophic methanogens while competitive relationships between CO-SRB and acetotrophic methanogens.

Illuminating bioprocess responses to metal-based nanoparticles addition along hydrogen and methane production pathways: A review

Recent research has discussed the positive impacts of metal-based nanoparticles (NPs) on bioprocesses producing either hydrogen (H2) or methane (CH4). The enhancement has been explained by mechanisms such as direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET), metal corrosion, and dissimilatory reduction. Such interactions could induce further benefits, such as controlling oxidation-reduction potential (ORP), mitigating toxicants, promoting enzymatic activity, and altering the microbiome, which have not yet been comprehensively discussed. Factors like metal type, oxidation state, and size of NPs are crucial for their reactivity and corresponding responses. This review discusses how different redox potentials of metals can regulate metabolic pathways and how NPs and their reactive ions can eliminate toxicants (e.g., sulfate) and enhance the activity of intra- and extracellular enzymes. The enrichment of responsive microorganisms in correlation with NPs is further discussed. A better understanding of the multifaceted role of metal-based NPs can guide potential new incorporation strategies to improve bioprocesses.

Deciphering the microbial interactions and metabolic shifts at different COD/sulfate ratios in electro-assisted anaerobic digestion

This research aims to investigate the influence of sulfate on the performance of microbial electrolysis cell-assisted anaerobic digester (MEC-AD) across varying sulfate conditions, including no sulfate and reduced COD/sulfate ratios from 20 to 1. The principal results indicate a gradual decline in methane yield in the MEC-AD from 78.7 ± 2.3 % under no sulfate conditions to 56.2 ± 2.0 % at a COD/sulfate ratio of 1, contrasting with a more substantial decrease in the control reactor (69.9 ± 3.6 % to 32.8 ± 1.5 %). The MEC-AD reactor exhibits heightened resilience to sulfide toxicity, showcasing higher specific methanogenic activities. Key findings suggest that the MEC-AD reactor maintains lower free sulfide concentrations, attributed to its higher pH and potential anodic sulfide oxidation. Additionally, the study reveals the promotion of syntrophic partnerships in the MEC-AD reactor, particularly between sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB) such as Desulfovibrio, Desulfomicrobium, and Desulfobulbus, and other microbial groups, including hydrogenotrophic methanogens and electroactive bacteria. The integration of these mechanisms highlights the MEC-AD reactor's ability to effectively mitigate sulfate-induced challenges and enhance overall anaerobic digestion performance. This study presents a significant step forward in the development of resilient anaerobic digestion systems capable of efficiently handling sulfate stress.

Bioelectrochemically altering microbial ecology in upflow anaerobic sludge blanket to enhance methanogenesis fed with high-sulfate methanolic wastewater

A bioelectrochemical upflow anaerobic sludge blanket (BE-UASB) was constructed and compared with the traditional UASB to investigate the role of bioelectrocatalysis in modulating methanogenesis and sulfidogensis involved within anaerobic treatment of high-sulfate methanolic wastewater (COD/SO42- ratio ≤ 2). Methane production rate for BE-UASB was 1.4 times higher than that of the single UASB, while SO42- removal stabilized at 16.7%. Bioelectrocatalysis selectively enriched key functional anaerobes and stimulated the secretion of extracellular polymeric substances, especially humic acids favoring electron transfer, thereby accelerating the electroactive biofilms development of electrodes. Methanomethylovorans was the dominant genus (35%) to directly convert methanol to CH4. Methanobacterium as CO2 electroreduction methane-producing archaea appeared only on electrodes. Acetobacterium exhibited anode-dependence, which provided acetate for sulfate-reducing bacteria (norank Syntrophobacteraceae and Desulfomicrobium) through synergistic coexistence. This study confirmed that BE-UASB regulated the microbial ecology to achieve efficient removal and energy recovery of high-sulfate methanolic wastewater.

Deciphering Fe@C amendment on long-term anaerobic digestion of sulfate and propionate rich wastewater: Driving microbial community succession and propionate metabolism

This study evaluated the reflection of long-term anaerobic system exposed to sulfate and propionate. Fe@C was found to efficiently mitigate anaerobic sulfate inhibition and enhance propionate degradation. With influent propionate of 12000mgCOD/L and COD/SO42- ratio of 3.0, methane productivity and sulfate removal were only 0.06 ± 0.02L/gCOD and 63 %, respectively. Fe@C helped recover methane productivity to 0.23 ± 0.03L/gCOD, and remove sulfate completely. After alleviating sulfate stress, less organic substrate was utilized to form extracellular polymeric substances for self-protection, which enhanced mass transfer in anaerobic sludge. Microbial community succession, especially for alteration of key sulfate-reducing bacteria and propionate-oxidizing bacteria, was driven by Fe@C, thus enhancing sulfate reduction and propionate degradation. Acetotrophic Methanothrix and hydrogenotrophic unclassified_f_Methanoregulaceae were enriched to promote methanogenesis. Regarding propionate metabolism, inhibited methylmalonyl-CoA degradation was a limiting step under sulfate stress, and was mitigated by Fe@C. Overall, this study provides perspective on Fe@C's future application on sulfate and propionate rich wastewater treatment.

Intermittent electrostimulation-modified direct interspecies electron transfer for enhanced methanogenesis in anaerobic digestion of sulfate-rich wastewater

Methane recovery and organics removal in sulfate (SO42-)-rich wastewater anaerobic digestion are hindered by electron competition between methanogenesis and sulfidogenesis. Here, intermittently electrostimulated bioelectrodes were developed to facilitate direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET)-driven syntrophic methanogenesis, increasing substrate competition among methanogenic archaea (MA). By optimising the electrochemical environment, MA was able to employ electron transfer more efficiently than sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB), resulting in significant methane accumulation (58.1 ± 1.0 mL-CH4/m3reactor) and COD removal (90.5 ± 0.5 %) at lower COD/SO42- ratio. Intermittent electrostimulation improved the metabolic pathway for electroactive bacteria to utilize acetate and direct electrons to electrotrophic MA, decreasing SRB abundance and affecting the sulfate reduction pathway. Intermittently electrostimulated biofilms significantly increased gene levels of key enzymes in electron transport for cytochrome and e-pili biosynthesis, crucial for DIET, demonstrating enhanced DIET-driven syntrophic methanogenesis. This study provides a strategic approach to optimize methanogenesis in sulfate-rich wastewater anaerobic digestion.

Bioelectrochemical system for enhancing anaerobic digestion of pharmaceutical-containing domestic wastewater

The unprecedented recent expansion in usage of paracetamol (AAP) has increased the need for suitable wastewater treatment technology. Furthermore, direct interspecies electron transfer promotion (DIET) offers simple and efficient approach for enhancing anaerobic digestion (AD). In this work, using AAP-containing domestic wastewater as feed, control AD reactor (RC) was operated, besides three DIET-promoted AD reactors (REV, RMC and REVMC, referring to electrical voltage "EV"-applied, nFe3O4-multiwall carbon nanotube (MCNT)-supplemented, and "EV applied + MCNT supplemented" reactor, respectively). Maximal treatable organic loading rates by RC, REV, RMC and REVMC were 3.9, 3.9, 7.8 and 15.6 g COD/L/d, corresponding to AAP loading rate of 26, 78, 156 and 312 μg/L/d, respectively. Methane production rate generated by RC, REV, RMC and REVMC reached 0.80 ± 0.01, 0.86 ± 0.04, 1.40 ± 0.07, and 3.01 ± 0.17 L/L/d, respectively. AAP expectedly followed hydroquinone degradation pathway, causing AD failure by acetate accumulation. However, this performance deterioration could be mitigated by DIET-promoted microbes with higher methanogenic activity and advanced electric conductivity. Economic evaluation revealed the favourability of MCNT addition over EV application, since payback periods for RC, REV, RMC and REVMC were 6.2, 7.7, 4.2 and 5.0 yr, respectively.

Revealing impacts of operational modes on anaerobic digestion systems coupling with sulfate reduction

Anaerobic digestion (AD) is promising for treating high-strength wastewater. However, the effect of operational parameters on microbial communities of AD with sulfate is not yet fully understood. To explore this, four reactors were operated under rapid- and slow-filling modes with different organic carbons. Reactors in the rapid-filling mode generally exhibited a fast kinetic property. For example, the degradation of ethanol was 4.6 times faster in ASBR_ER than in ASBR_ES, and the degradation of acetate was 11.2 times faster in ASBR_AR than in ASBR_AS. Nevertheless, reactors in the slow-filling mode could mitigate propionate accumulation when using ethanol as organic carbon. Taxonomic and functional analysis further supported that rapid- and slow-filling modes were suitable for the growth of r-strategists (e.g., Desulfomicrobium) and K-strategists (e.g., Geobacter), respectively. Overall, this study provides valuable insights into microbial interactions of AD processes with sulfate through the application of the r/K selection theory.

Use of reverse osmosis concentrate for mitigating greenhouse gas emissions from pig slurry

Due to the high global warming potential (GWP) in a short time scale (GWP100 = 28 vs. GWP20 = 86), mitigating CH4 emissions could have an early impact on reducing current global warming effects. The manure storage tank emits a significant amount of CH4, which can diminish the environmental benefit resulting from the anaerobic digestion of manure that can generate renewable energy. In the present study, we added the reverse osmosis concentrate (ROC) rich in salt to the pig slurry (PS) storage tank to reduce CH4 emissions. Simultaneously, pure NaCl was tested at the same concentration to compare and verify the performance of ROC addition. During 40 days of storage, 1.83 kg CH4/ton PS was emitted, which was reduced by 7-75% by the addition of ROC at 1-9 g Na+/L. This decrease was found to be more intensive than that found upon adding pure sodium, which was caused by the presence of sulfate rich in ROC, resulting in synergistic inhibition. The results of the microbial community and activity test showed that sodium directly inhibited methanogenic activity rather than acidogenic activity. In the subsequent biogas production from the stored PS, more CH4 was obtained by ROC addition due to the preservation of organic matter during storage. Overall, 51.2 kg CO2 eq./ton PS was emitted during the storage, while 8 kg CO2 eq./ton PS was reduced by biogas production in the case of control, resulting in a total of 43.2 kg CO2 eq./ton PS. This amount of greenhouse gas emissions was reduced by ROC addition at 5 g Na+/L by 22 and 65 kg CO2 eq./ton PS, considering GWP100 and GWP20 of CH4, respectively, where most of the reduction was achieved during the storage process. To the best of our knowledge, this was the first report using salty waste to reduce GHG emissions in a proper place, e.g., a manure storage tank.

Upflow anaerobic sludge blanket reactor operation under high pressure for energy-rich biogas production

Autogenerative high-pressure digestion has an advantage of producing CH₄-rich biogas directly from the reactor. However, its continuous operation has rarely been reported, and has never been attempted in an upflow anaerobic sludge blanket reactor (UASB). Here, UASB was continuously operated at 10 g COD/L/d with increasing pressure from 1 to 8 bar. As the pressure increased, the CH₄ content in the biogas increased gradually, reaching 96.7 ± 0.8% at 8 bar (309 MJ/m³ biogas). The pH was dropped from 8.2 to 7.2 with pressure increase, but COD removal efficiency was maintained > 90%. The high pressure up to 8 bar did not adversely impact the physicochemical properties of granules, which was due to the increased production of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS), particularly, tightly bound EPS (34% increase). With pressure increase, there was no changes in the microbial community and ATPase gene expression, but 41% increase in carbonic anhydrase gene expression was observed.