Linking algal growth inhibition to chemical activity: Excess toxicity below 0.1% of saturation

Optimizing concentration and interaction mechanism of Demodesmus sp. and Achromobacter pulmonis sp. consortium to evaluate their potential for dibutyl phthalate removal from synthetic wastewater

A green approach of Desmodesmus sp. to Achromobacter pulmonis (1:1) coculture ratios was optimized to improve the removal efficiency of dibutyl phthalate (DBP) from simulated wastewater. High DBP resistance bacterial strains and microalgae was optimized from plastic contaminated water and acclimation process respectively. The influence of various factors on DBP removal performance was comprehensively investigated. Highest DBP removal 93 % was recorded, when the ratios algae-bacteria 1:1, with sodium acetate, pH-6, shaking speed-120 rpm and lighting periods L:D-12:12. Enough nutrient (TN/TP/TOC) availability and higher protein-108 mg/L and sugar-40 mg/L were observed in presences of 50 mg/L DBP. The degradation and sorption were calculated 81,12; 27,39 & 43,12 % in algae-bacteria, only algae and only bacteria system respectively. The degradation kinetics t1/2 3.74,22.15,12.86 days were evaluated, confirming that algae-bacteria effectively degrade the DBP. This outcome leading to promote a green sustainable approach to remove the emerging contamination from wastewater.

Determining the toxicity of organic compounds to the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans based on aqueous concentrations

Caenorhabditis elegans is used for assessing the toxicity of chemicals in aqueous medium. However, chemicals can absorb to the bacterial food, which reduces the freely dissolved concentrations of the tested compounds. Thus, based on total or nominal concentrations, toxicity is underestimated, resulting in misleading assumptions on toxicity mechanisms or comparisons to other test organisms. As the verification of freely dissolved exposure concentrations (Cfree) is challenging in small test systems, simple partitioning models might by a good option for estimating Cfree. Therefore, C. elegans was exposed to seven differently acting organic chemicals with varying hydrophobicities, thus also different affinities to bind to the food of C. elegans. Measured concentrations of the dissolved aqueous and the bacterial-bound fraction allowed the calculation of binding constants (Kb). Experimental Kb were comparable to literature data of hydrophobic chemicals and correlated well with their hydrophobicity, expressed as log KOW. The chronic toxicity of the various compounds on C. elegans' reproduction, based on their aqueous concentration, was weakly related to their log KOW. Toxicity expressed based on chemical activity and comparisons with a baseline toxicity model, nevertheless, suggested a narcotic mode of action for most hydrophobic compounds (except methylisothiazolinone and trichlorocarbanilide). Although revealing a similar toxicity ranking than Daphnia magna, C. elegans was less sensitive, probably due to its ability to reduce its internal concentrations by means of its very impermeable cuticle or by efficient detoxification mechanisms. It could be shown that measured aqueous concentrations in the nematode test system corresponded well with freely dissolved concentrations that were modeled using simple mass-balance models from nominal concentrations. This offers the possibility to estimate freely dissolved concentrations of chemicals from nominal concentrations, making routine testing of chemicals and their comparison to other species more accurate.

Assessment of toxic mechanisms and mode of action to three different levels of species for 14 antibiotics based on interspecies correlation, excess toxicity, and QSAR

Antibiotics have received much attention owing to their ecotoxicity toward nontarget aquatic creatures. However, the mode of action (MOA) of toxicity against nontarget organisms is unclear in some aquatic organisms. In this study, the comparison of toxicities through interspecies correlations, excess toxicity calculated from toxicity ratio, and quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) was carried out to investigate the MOAs for 14 antibiotics among Daphnia magna, Vibrio fischeri, and Pseudokirchneriella subcapitata. The results showed that interspecies toxicity correlations were very poor between any two of the three species for the 14 antibiotics. The toxicity ratio revealed that most antibiotics exhibited excess toxicity to algae and Daphnia magna but not to V. fischeri, demonstrating that some antibiotics share the same MOA, but some antibiotics share different MOAs among the three different levels of species. P. subcapitata was the most sensitive species, and V. fischeri was the least sensitive species. This is because of the differences in the biouptake and interactions of antibiotics with the target receptors between the three different trophic levels of the species. Molecular docking simulations suggested that the toxicity of antibiotics depends highly on their interactions with target receptors through hydrogen bonds, electrostatic or polar interactions, π bond interactions, and van der Waals forces. QSAR models demonstrated that hydrogen bonding and electrophilicity/nucleophilicity play key roles in the interaction of antibiotics with different receptors in the three species. The toxic mechanisms of antibiotics are attributed to the interactions between electrophilic antibiotics and biological nucleophiles, and hydrogen-bond interactions. These results are valuable for understanding the toxic mechanisms and MOA of the three different levels of species.

Effect of dibutyl phthalate on microalgal growth kinetics, nutrients removal, and stress enzyme activities

The dibutyl phthalate (DPB) is an emerging plasticizer contaminant that disrupts the biological processes of primary producers, especially phytoplankton. In this study, two microalgal species (Chlorella sp. GEEL-08 and Tetradesmus dimorphus GEEL-04) were exposed to various concentrations of DBP extending from 0 to 100 mg/L. The growth kinetics, N-nitrate, and P-phosphate removal efficiency were assessed. The response enzymes such as malonaldehyde (MDA) and superoxide dismutase (SOD) were also investigated. The results revealed that the Chlorella sp. GEEL-08 at 10 mg/L concentration of DBP exhibited higher growth (0.88 OD680nm) compared to T. dimorphus GEEL-04 (0.80 OD680nm). More than 94% of N and P were removed from culture media by both microalgal species. The DBP (>50 mg/L) significantly exacerbates the growth of both microalgae species and the growth inhibition ratio was in the range of 3.6%-25.9%. The SOD activity and MDA were higher in T. dimorphus culture media than in the culture media of Chlorella sp. The results reflect the hazard and the risk of plasticizers on primary producers in the ecosystem.

Effects of graphene oxide on algal cellular stress response: Evaluating metabolic characters of carbon fixation and nutrient removal

The effects of different concentrations of graphene oxide (GO) on intracellular metabolism in Chlorella vulgaris (C. vulgaris) and removal of nitrogen and phosphorus nutrients by C. vulgaris from synthetic wastewater were studied. The results demonstrated that cell division of Chlorella vulgaris increased at 24 h and decreased at 96 h after exposure to different concentrations of GO. The removal rates of total nitrogen (TN), ammoniacal nitrogen (NH₃-N), phosphate (PO₄^3--P), and chemical oxygen demand (COD) were 24.1%, 70.0%, 37.0%, and 39.6%, respectively, when the concentration of GO was 0.01 mg/L 10 mg/L GO induced severe plasmolysis and cytoplasmic contraction. Furthermore, the protein-like exopolysaccharide (EPS) content of algal cells exposed to 10 mg/L GO decrease to 10.8% of the control group. Simultaneously, the reactive oxygen species (ROS) level was 175.4% of control group. The biological responses to 10 mg/L GO included increase in ROS level, inhibition of saccharide metabolism, and degradation of amino acids. In addition, high concentrations of 10 mg/L GO weakened the carbon fixation process in algal cells. These stress-response behaviors increased cell permeability and oxidative stress. Overall, these findings provide new insights regarding the effects of GO on algal cellular stress responses.

Toxicity of dodecylbenzene to algae, crustacean, and fish - Passive dosing of highly hydrophobic liquids at the solubility limit

In the current study, improved exposure control and measurements were applied for the aquatic toxicity testing of a highly hydrophobic organic compound. The aim was to reliably determine the ecotoxicity of the model compound dodecylbenzene (DDB, Log K_OW = 8.65) by applying passive dosing for aquatic toxicity testing exactly at the solubility limit. Methodologically, silicone O-rings were saturated by immersion in pure liquid DDB (i.e., "loading by swelling") and then used as passive dosing donors. Daphnia immobilization and fish embryo toxicity tests were successfully conducted and provide, together with recently reported algal growth inhibition data, a full base-set of ecotoxicological data according to REACH. All tests were conducted in closed test systems to avoid evaporative losses, and exposure concentrations were measured throughout test durations. The Daphnia test was optimized by placing the O-rings in cages to prevent direct contact between daphnids and the passive dosing donor. Toxicologically, Daphnia magna immobilization was 19.3 ± 8% (mean ± 95% CI; 6 tests) within 72 h, whereas Danio rerio fish embryos did not show any significant lethal or sublethal toxic responses within 96 h. Growth rate inhibition for the algae Raphidocelis subcapitata was previously reported to be 13 ± 5% in a first and 8 ± 3% in a repeated test. These results for aquatic organisms, spanning three trophic levels, demonstrate toxicity of a highly hydrophobic compound and suggest that improvements of the current ecotoxicological standard tests are needed for these "difficult-to-test" chemicals. Furthermore, the obtained toxicity results significantly question the existence of a generic Log K_OW cut-off in baseline toxicity.

Headspace Passive Dosing of Volatile Hydrophobic Organic Chemicals from a Lipid Donor-Linking Their Toxicity to Well-Defined Exposure for an Improved Risk Assessment

High hydrophobicity and volatility of chemicals often lead to substantial experimental challenges but were here utilized in headspace passive dosing (HS-PD) to establish and maintain exposure: the pure chemical served as a passive dosing donor for controlling exposure at saturation, whereas triglyceride oil containing the chemical was used to control lower exposure levels. These donor solutions were added to glass inserts placed in the closed test systems. Mass balance calculations confirmed a dominant donor capacity for all chemicals except isooctane. This HS-PD method was applied to algal growth inhibition and springtail lethality tests with terpenes, alkanes, and cyclic siloxanes. Headspace concentrations above the lipid donors were measured for three chemicals to determine their chemical activity, using saturated vapor as the analytical standard and thermodynamic reference. Toxicity was related to chemical activity and calculated concentrations in membranes at equilibrium with the lipid donor. For both tests and all chemicals, toxic effects were observed within or above the reported range for baseline toxicity, meaning that no excess toxicity was observed. The toxicity of siloxanes was markedly higher to the terrestrial springtail than the aquatic algae, which is consistent with a more efficient mass transfer of these volatile hydrophobic chemicals in air compared to water.

Soil bacteria and protists show different sensitivity to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons at controlled chemical activity

This study linked growth inhibition of soil bacteria and protists to the chemical activity (a) of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and compared the sensitivities of bacteria and protists. Passive dosing from pre-loaded silicone provided well-defined and constant a of PAHs in independent tests. Single-species growth inhibition with two bacterial (Pseuodomonas fluorescens DR54 and Sinorhizobium meliloti) and two protist (Cercomonas longicauda and Acanthamoeba castellanii) strains at maximum a (amax) of nine and four PAHs, respectively, showed no inhibition of PAHs with amax below 0.1 (pyrene and anthracene), while growth inhibition was observed for PAHs with amax above 0.1 (e.g. fluorene, fluoranthene and naphthalene). The bacteria were less sensitive than the protists. Soil bacterial community-level growth inhibition by naphthalene was in good agreement with single-species data, but also indicated the presence of sensitive bacteria that were inhibited by a below 0.05 and increasing pre-exposure time giving higher inhibition. The a of 50% inhibition (Ea50) was 0.434 and 0.329 for 0.5 and 4 h pre-exposure time, respectively. Invertebrates tended to be more sensitive than single-celled organisms tested here. This suggests that PAH exposure leads to differential toxicity in soil biota, which may affect soil food web structure and cycling of organic matter.