Prokaryotic Gabija complex senses and executes nucleotide depletion and DNA cleavage for antiviral defense

Recent advancements in bacterial anti-phage strategies and the underlying mechanisms altering susceptibility to antibiotics

The rapid spread of multidrug-resistant bacteria and the challenges in developing new antibiotics have brought renewed international attention to phage therapy. However, in bacteria-phage co-evolution, the rapid development of bacterial resistance to phage has limited its clinical application. This review consolidates the latest advancements in research on anti-phage mechanisms, encompassing strategies such as systems associated with reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+) to halt the propagation of the phage, symbiotic bacteria episymbiont-mediated modulation of gene expression in host bacteria to resist phage infection, and defence-related reverse transcriptase (DRT) encoded by bacteria to curb phage infections. We conduct an in-depth analysis of the underlying mechanisms by which bacteria undergo alterations in antibiotic susceptibility after developing phage resistance. We also discuss the remaining challenges and promising directions for phage-based therapy in the future.

Unveiling the multifaceted domain polymorphism of the Menshen antiphage system

Recent advances have significantly enriched our understanding of complex bacteria-phage interactions. To date, over one hundred bacterial antiphage systems have been identified, yet the mechanisms of many, including the recently discovered Menshen system, remain elusive. We employed comparative genomics and protein bioinformatics for a systematic investigation of the Menshen system, focusing on its organization, structure, function, and evolution. By delineating six primary domain determinants and predicting their functions, we propose that the three components (NsnA-B-C) of Menshen likely act as sensor, transducer, and effector modules, respectively. Notably, we unveil remarkable polymorphism in domain composition within both NsnA and NsnC. NsnA proteins universally share ParB-DUF262 and DNA-binding ParBDB domains, and often include additional DNA-binding modules at their N-termini. NsnC effectors exhibit diverse inactive PIN (inPIN)-like domains for target recognition in their N-termini, and multiple nuclease domains for toxicity in their C-termini. We demonstrate that this multifaceted polymorphism results from the independent integration of various sensor domains into NsnA, alongside constant shuffling and diversification of the inPIN and effector domains in NsnC. These findings not only elucidate the functional diversity and inter-subunit interactions of the Menshen system, but also underscore its exceptional capacity for adaptability and versatility in the ongoing arms race between bacteria and phages.

PglZ from Type I BREX phage defence systems is a metal-dependent nuclease that forms a sub-complex with BrxB

BREX (Bacteriophage Exclusion) systems, identified through shared identity with Pgl (Phage Growth Limitation) systems, are a widespread, highly diverse group of phage defence systems found throughout bacteria and archaea. The varied BREX Types harbour multiple protein subunits (between four and eight) and all encode a conserved putative phosphatase (PglZ aka BrxZ) and an equally conserved, putative ATPase (BrxC). Almost all BREX systems also contain a site-specific methyltransferase (PglX aka BrxX). Despite having determined the structure and fundamental biophysical and biochemical behaviours for the PglX methyltransferase, the BrxL effector, the BrxA DNA-binding protein and the BrxR transcriptional regulator, the mechanism by which BREX impedes phage replication remains largely undetermined. In this study, we identify a stable BREX sub-complex of PglZ:BrxB, validate the structure and dynamic behaviour of that sub-complex, and assess the biochemical activity of PglZ, revealing it to be a metal-dependent nuclease. PglZ can cleave cyclic oligonucleotides, linear oligonucleotides, plasmid DNA and both non-modified and modified linear phage genomes. PglZ nuclease activity has no obvious role in BREX-dependent methylation, but does contribute to BREX phage defence. BrxB binding does not impact PglZ nuclease activity. These data contribute to our growing understanding of the BREX phage defence mechanism.

Bacterial Hachiman complex executes DNA cleavage for antiphage defense

Bacteria have developed a variety of immune systems to combat phage infections. The Hachiman system is a novel prokaryotic antiphage defense system comprising HamA and HamB proteins, which contains the DUF1837 and helicase domains, respectively. However, the defense mechanism remains only partially understood. Here, we present the cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) structure of the Hachiman defense system featuring a fusion of Cap4 nuclease domain within HamA. Further structure analysis indicates that the DUF1837 domain on HamA resembles the PD-(D/E)XK nuclease but lacks active sites. Bioinformatics analysis reveals that catalytically inactive DUF1837 domains often recruit other functional domains to fulfill anti-phage defense. HamA interacts with HamB to form a heterodimer HamAB to mediate ATP hydrolysis and execute DNA cleavage, thus implementing antiphage defense. Our findings elucidate the structural basis of the Hachiman defense complex, highlighting the critical roles of the helicase and nuclease in prokaryotic immunity.

Modularity of Zorya defense systems during phage inhibition

Bacteria have evolved an extraordinary diversity of defense systems against bacteriophage (phage) predation. However, the molecular mechanisms underlying these anti-phage systems often remain elusive. Here, we provide mechanistic and structural insights into Zorya phage defense systems. Using cryo-EM structural analyses, we show that the Zorya type I and II core components, ZorA and ZorB, assemble in a 5:2 complex that is similar to inner-membrane ion-driven, rotary motors that power flagellar rotation, type 9 secretion, gliding and the Ton nutrient uptake systems. The ZorAB complex has an elongated cytoplasmic tail assembled by bundling the C-termini of the five ZorA subunits. Mutagenesis demonstrates that peptidoglycan binding by the periplasmic domains of ZorB, the structured cytoplasmic tail of ZorA, and ion flow through the motor is important for function in both type I and II systems. Furthermore, we identify ZorE as the effector module of the Zorya II system, possessing nickase activity. Our work reveals the molecular basis of the activity of Zorya systems and highlights the ZorE nickase as crucial for population-wide immunity in the type II system.

Antiviral defence arsenal across members of the Bacillus cereus group

Bacteria co-evolve with bacteriophages to overcome each other's defence arsenal. Bacillus cereus group gathers bacteria of medical and agricultural importance, including foodborne pathogens. So far, few studies have portrayed a complete defence arsenal of microorganisms, and the role of antiviral systems in the Bacillus cereus group has been overlooked. Here, we investigate the repertoire of defence systems in 6354 B. cereus group's genomic assemblies, using bioinformatics tools DefenseFinder and PADLOC. Our analyses provide an overview of the diversity and abundance of defence systems in this group, with 83,738 systems distributed by 2 to 33 within each assembly. Comparing PADLOC and DefenseFinder predictions showed that the most prevalent strategy is Restriction-Modification, but many abortive infection systems also intervene in the group's defence, such as Septu, Gabija and Lamassu. Most defences were encoded on both plasmids and the chromosome, though some tend to have a preferential genomic location. We also studied the defence systems associations within the genomic assemblies. Overall, our results establish a baseline picturing the rich and complex antiviral arsenal encoded by B. cereus group's species and provide clues for studying co-existing strategies displayed by these bacteria to subvert phages and other MGEs invasions.

Combinatorial phenotypic landscape enables bacterial resistance to phage infection

Success of phage therapies is limited by bacterial defenses against phages. While a large variety of anti-phage defense mechanisms has been characterized, how expression of these systems is distributed across individual cells and how their combined activities translate into protection from phages has not been studied. Using bacterial single-cell RNA sequencing, we profiled the transcriptomes of ~50,000 cells from cultures of a human pathobiont, Bacteroides fragilis, infected with a lytic bacteriophage. We quantified the asynchronous progression of phage infection in single bacterial cells and reconstructed the infection timeline, characterizing both host and phage transcriptomic changes as infection unfolded. We discovered a subpopulation of bacteria that remained uninfected and determined the heterogeneously expressed host factors associated with protection. Each cell's vulnerability to phage infection was defined by combinatorial phase-variable expression of multiple genetic loci, including capsular polysaccharide (CPS) biosynthesis pathways, restriction-modification systems (RM), and a previously uncharacterized operon likely encoding fimbrial genes. By acting together, these heterogeneously expressed phase-variable systems and anti-phage defense mechanisms create a phenotypic landscape where distinct protective combinations enable the survival and re-growth of bacteria expressing these phenotypes without acquiring additional mutations. The emerging model of complementary action of multiple protective mechanisms heterogeneously expressed across an isogenic bacterial population showcases the potent role of phase variation and stochasticity in bacterial anti-phage defenses.

A Class 1 OLD family nuclease encoded by Vibrio cholerae is countered by a vibriophage-encoded direct inhibitor

Bacteria are constantly threatened by their viral predators (phages), which has resulted in the development of defense systems for bacterial survival. One family of defense systems found widely across bacteria are OLD (for overcoming lysogeny defect) family nucleases. Despite recent discoveries regarding Class 2 and 4 OLD family nucleases and how phages overcome them, Class 1 OLD family nucleases warrant further study as there has only been one anti-phage Class 1 OLD family nuclease described to date. Here, we identify the Vibrio cholerae-encoded Class 1 OLD family nuclease Vc OLD and describe its disruption of genome replication of the lytic vibriophage ICP1. Furthermore, we examine its in vitro activity, identifying Vc OLD as a DNA nickase. Finally, we identify the first direct inhibitor of a Class 1 OLD family nuclease, the ICP1-encoded Oad1. Our research further illuminates Class 1 OLD family nucleases' role in phage defense and explores the dynamic arms race between V. cholerae and its predatory phage ICP1.

HAMpering infection: Helicase ratcheting emerges as a phage-sensing mechanism

The sensing of pathogens is the first step for any immune response. A recent paper in Cell reveals that the bacterial Hachiman anti-phage defense system deploys a helicase subunit to sense phage invasion via 3' DNA recognition and subsequent domain rotation to enable nuclease activation.

The growing repertoire of phage anti-defence systems

The biological interplay between phages and bacteria has driven the evolution of phage anti-defence systems (ADSs), which evade bacterial defence mechanisms. These ADSs bind and inhibit host defence proteins, add covalent modifications and deactivate defence proteins, degrade or sequester signalling molecules utilised by host defence systems, synthesise and restore essential molecules depleted by bacterial defences, or add covalent modifications to phage molecules to avoid recognition. Overall, 145 phage ADSs have been characterised to date. These ADSs counteract 27 of the 152 different bacterial defence families, and we hypothesise that many more ADSs are yet to be discovered. We discuss high-throughput approaches (computational and experimental) which are indispensable for discovering new ADSs and the limitations of these approaches. A comprehensive characterisation of phage ADSs is critical for understanding phage-host interplay and developing clinical applications, such as treatment for multidrug-resistant bacterial infections.

DNA Phosphorothioate Modification Systems and Associated Phage Defense Systems

In contrast to the well-known DNA methylation of nucleobases, DNA phosphorothioate (PT) modification occurs in the DNA sugar-phosphate backbone. The non-bridging oxygen is replaced by a sulfur atom, which increases the nuclease tolerance of the DNA. In recent years, we have witnessed advances in understanding of PT modification enzymes, the features of PT modification across prokaryotic genomes, and PT-related physiological functions. Although only a small fraction of modifiable recognition sites across bacterial genomes undergo PT modification, enzymes such as DndFGH and SspE can use this modification as a recognition marker to differentiate between self- and non-self-DNA, thus destroying PT-lacking invasive DNA and preventing autoimmunity. We highlight the molecular mechanisms of PT modification-associated defense systems. We also describe notable applications of PT systems in the engineering of phage-resistant bacterial strains, RNA editing, and nucleic acid detection.

Phage defence loci of Streptococcus thermophilus-tip of the anti-phage iceberg?

Bacteria possess (bacterio)phage defence systems to ensure their survival. The thermophilic lactic acid bacterium, Streptococcus thermophilus, which is used in dairy fermentations, harbours multiple CRISPR-Cas and restriction and modification (R/M) systems to protect itself against phage attack, with limited reports on other types of phage-resistance. Here, we describe the systematic identification and functional analysis of the phage resistome of S. thermophilus using a collection of 27 strains as representatives of the species. In addition to CRISPR-Cas and R/M systems, we uncover nine distinct phage-resistance systems including homologues of Kiwa, Gabija, Dodola, defence-associated sirtuins and classical lactococcal/streptococcal abortive infection systems. The genes encoding several of these newly identified S. thermophilus antiphage systems are located in proximity to the genetic determinants of CRISPR-Cas systems thus constituting apparent Phage Defence Islands. Other phage-resistance systems whose encoding genes are not co-located with genes specifying CRISPR-Cas systems may represent anchors to identify additional Defence Islands harbouring, as yet, uncharacterised phage defence systems. We estimate that up to 2.5% of the genetic material of the analysed strains is dedicated to phage defence, highlighting that phage-host antagonism plays an important role in driving the evolution and shaping the composition of dairy streptococcal genomes.

Bacterial homologs of innate eukaryotic antiviral defenses with anti-phage activity highlight shared evolutionary roots of viral defenses

Prokaryotes have evolved a multitude of defense systems to protect against phage predation. Some of these resemble eukaryotic genes involved in antiviral responses. Here, we set out to systematically project the current knowledge of eukaryotic-like antiviral defense systems onto prokaryotic genomes, using Pseudomonas aeruginosa as a model organism. Searching for phage defense systems related to innate antiviral genes from vertebrates and plants, we uncovered over 450 candidates. We validated six of these phage defense systems, including factors preventing viral attachment, R-loop-acting enzymes, the inflammasome, ubiquitin pathway, and pathogen recognition signaling. Collectively, these defense systems support the concept of deep evolutionary links and shared antiviral mechanisms between prokaryotes and eukaryotes.

Molecular basis of Gabija anti-phage supramolecular assemblies

As one of the most prevalent anti-phage defense systems in prokaryotes, Gabija consists of a Gabija protein A (GajA) and a Gabija protein B (GajB). The assembly and function of the Gabija system remain unclear. Here we present cryo-EM structures of Bacillus cereus GajA and GajAB complex, revealing tetrameric and octameric assemblies, respectively. In the center of the complex, GajA assembles into a tetramer, which recruits two sets of GajB dimer at opposite sides of the complex, resulting in a 4:4 GajAB supramolecular complex for anti-phage defense. Further biochemical analysis showed that GajA alone is sufficient to cut double-stranded DNA and plasmid DNA, which can be inhibited by ATP. Unexpectedly, the GajAB displays enhanced activity for plasmid DNA, suggesting a role of substrate selection by GajB. Together, our study defines a framework for understanding anti-phage immune defense by the GajAB complex.

A nuclease domain fused to the Snf2 helicase confers antiphage defence in coral-associated Halomonas meridiana

The coral reef microbiome plays a vital role in the health and resilience of reefs. Previous studies have examined phage therapy for coral pathogens and for modifying the coral reef microbiome, but defence systems against coral-associated bacteria have received limited attention. Phage defence systems play a crucial role in helping bacteria fight phage infections. In this study, we characterized a new defence system, Hma (HmaA-HmaB-HmaC), in the coral-associated Halomonas meridiana derived from the scleractinian coral Galaxea fascicularis. The Swi2/Snf2 helicase HmaA with a C-terminal nuclease domain exhibits antiviral activity against Escherichia phage T4. Mutation analysis revealed the nickase activity of the nuclease domain (belonging to PDD/EXK superfamily) of HmaA is essential in phage defence. Additionally, HmaA homologues are present in ~1000 bacterial and archaeal genomes. The high frequency of HmaA helicase in Halomonas strains indicates the widespread presence of these phage defence systems, while the insertion of defence genes in the hma region confirms the existence of a defence gene insertion hotspot. These findings offer insights into the diversity of phage defence systems in coral-associated bacteria and these diverse defence systems can be further applied into designing probiotics with high-phage resistance.

Structures and activation mechanism of the Gabija anti-phage system

Prokaryotes have evolved intricate innate immune systems against phage infection1-7. Gabija is a highly widespread prokaryotic defence system that consists of two components, GajA and GajB8. GajA functions as a DNA endonuclease that is inactive in the presence of ATP9. Here, to explore how the Gabija system is activated for anti-phage defence, we report its cryo-electron microscopy structures in five states, including apo GajA, GajA in complex with DNA, GajA bound by ATP, apo GajA-GajB, and GajA-GajB in complex with ATP and Mg2+. GajA is a rhombus-shaped tetramer with its ATPase domain clustered at the centre and the topoisomerase-primase (Toprim) domain located peripherally. ATP binding at the ATPase domain stabilizes the insertion region within the ATPase domain, keeping the Toprim domain in a closed state. Upon ATP depletion by phages, the Toprim domain opens to bind and cleave the DNA substrate. GajB, which docks on GajA, is activated by the cleaved DNA, ultimately leading to prokaryotic cell death. Our study presents a mechanistic landscape of Gabija activation.

Bacterial defense systems exhibit synergistic anti-phage activity

Bacterial defense against phage predation involves diverse defense systems acting individually and concurrently, yet their interactions remain poorly understood. We investigated >100 defense systems in 42,925 bacterial genomes and identified numerous instances of their non-random co-occurrence and negative association. For several pairs of defense systems significantly co-occurring in Escherichia coli strains, we demonstrate synergistic anti-phage activity. Notably, Zorya II synergizes with Druantia III and ietAS defense systems, while tmn exhibits synergy with co-occurring systems Gabija, Septu I, and PrrC. For Gabija, tmn co-opts the sensory switch ATPase domain, enhancing anti-phage activity. Some defense system pairs that are negatively associated in E. coli show synergy and significantly co-occur in other taxa, demonstrating that bacterial immune repertoires are largely shaped by selection for resistance against host-specific phages rather than negative epistasis. Collectively, these findings demonstrate compatibility and synergy between defense systems, allowing bacteria to adopt flexible strategies for phage defense.

Accumulation of defense systems in phage-resistant strains of Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Prokaryotes encode multiple distinct anti-phage defense systems in their genomes. However, the impact of carrying a multitude of defense systems on phage resistance remains unclear, especially in a clinical context. Using a collection of antibiotic-resistant clinical strains of Pseudomonas aeruginosa and a broad panel of phages, we demonstrate that defense systems contribute substantially to defining phage host range and that overall phage resistance scales with the number of defense systems in the bacterial genome. We show that many individual defense systems target specific phage genera and that defense systems with complementary phage specificities co-occur in P. aeruginosa genomes likely to provide benefits in phage-diverse environments. Overall, we show that phage-resistant phenotypes of P. aeruginosa with at least 19 phage defense systems exist in the populations of clinical, antibiotic-resistant P. aeruginosa strains.

Structural and biochemical insights into the mechanism of the Gabija bacterial immunity system

The Gabija system is a newly discovered bacterial immune system that consists of GajA and GajB. Here we report the cryo-EM structure of the Gabija complex from Bacillus cereus VD045 at 3.6 Å, which provides the direct evidence of interactions between GajA and GajB. The Gabija complex is an octameric ring structure with four GajA and four GajB. GajA is an OLD nucleases family protein, while GajB belongs to the SF1 helicases. The Gabija complex has sequence-specific DNA nuclease activity and prefers circular rather than linear DNA as substrate, its activity is more sensitive to concentrations change of nucleotides compared to GajA alone. Our data suggest a mechanism of Gabija immunity: the nuclease activity of Gabija complex is inhibited under physiological conditions, while it is activated by depletion of NTP and dNTP upon the replication and transcription of invading phages and cleave the circular DNA to prevent phage DNA replication.

Structural basis of Gabija anti-phage defence and viral immune evasion

Bacteria encode hundreds of diverse defence systems that protect them from viral infection and inhibit phage propagation1-5. Gabija is one of the most prevalent anti-phage defence systems, occurring in more than 15% of all sequenced bacterial and archaeal genomes1,6,7, but the molecular basis of how Gabija defends cells from viral infection remains poorly understood. Here we use X-ray crystallography and cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) to define how Gabija proteins assemble into a supramolecular complex of around 500 kDa that degrades phage DNA. Gabija protein A (GajA) is a DNA endonuclease that tetramerizes to form the core of the anti-phage defence complex. Two sets of Gabija protein B (GajB) dimers dock at opposite sides of the complex and create a 4:4 GajA-GajB assembly (hereafter, GajAB) that is essential for phage resistance in vivo. We show that a phage-encoded protein, Gabija anti-defence 1 (Gad1), directly binds to the Gabija GajAB complex and inactivates defence. A cryo-EM structure of the virally inhibited state shows that Gad1 forms an octameric web that encases the GajAB complex and inhibits DNA recognition and cleavage. Our results reveal the structural basis of assembly of the Gabija anti-phage defence complex and define a unique mechanism of viral immune evasion.

Genomic insights into the phage-defense systems of Stenotrophomonas maltophilia clinical isolates

Stenotrophomonas maltophilia is a rapidly evolving multidrug-resistant opportunistic pathogen that can cause serious infections in immunocompromised patients. Although phage therapy is one of promising strategies for dealing with MDR bacteria, the main challenges of phage therapeutics include accumulation of phage resistant mutations and acquisition of the phage defense systems. To systematically evaluate the impact of (pro)phages in shaping genetic and evolutionary diversity of S. maltophilia, we collected 166 S. maltophilia isolates from three hospitals in southern China to analyze its pangenome, virulence factors, prophage regions, and anit-viral immune systems. Pangenome analysis indicated that there are 1328 saturated core genes and 26961 unsaturated accessory genes in the pangenome, suggesting existence of highly variable parts of S. maltophilia genome. The presence of genes in relation to T3SS and T6SS mechanisms suggests the great potential to secrete toxins by the S. maltophilia population, which is contrary to the conventional notion of low-virulence of S. maltophilia. Additionally, we characterized the pan-immune system maps of these clinical isolates against phage infections and revealed the co-harboring of CBASS and anti-CBASS in some strains, suggesting a never-ending arms race and the co-evolutionary dynamic between bacteria and phages. Furthermore, our study predicted 310 prophage regions in S. maltophilia with high genetic diversity. Six viral defense systems were found to be located at specific position of the S. maltophilia prophage genomes, indicating potential evolution of certain site/region similar to bacterial 'defense islands' in prophage. Our study provides novel insights into the S. maltophilia pangenome in relation to phage-defense mechanisms, which extends our understanding of bacterial-phage interactions and might guide the application of phage therapy in combating S. maltophilia infections.

Structural and functional investigation of GajB protein in Gabija anti-phage defense

Bacteriophages (phages) are viruses that infect bacteria and archaea. To fend off invading phages, the hosts have evolved a variety of anti-phage defense mechanisms. Gabija is one of the most abundant prokaryotic antiviral systems and consists of two proteins, GajA and GajB. GajA has been characterized experimentally as a sequence-specific DNA endonuclease. Although GajB was previously predicted to be a UvrD-like helicase, its function is unclear. Here, we report the results of structural and functional analyses of GajB. The crystal structure of GajB revealed a UvrD-like domain architecture, including two RecA-like core and two accessory subdomains. However, local structural elements that are important for the helicase function of UvrD are not conserved in GajB. In functional assays, GajB did not unwind or bind various types of DNA substrates. We demonstrated that GajB interacts with GajA to form a heterooctameric Gabija complex, but GajB did not exhibit helicase activity when bound to GajA. These results advance our understanding of the molecular mechanism underlying Gabija anti-phage defense and highlight the role of GajB as a component of a multi-subunit antiviral complex in bacteria.

OLD family nuclease function across diverse anti-phage defense systems

Bacteriophages constitute a ubiquitous threat to bacteria, and bacteria have evolved numerous anti-phage defense systems to protect themselves. These systems include well-studied phenomena such as restriction endonucleases and CRISPR, while emerging studies have identified many new anti-phage defense systems whose mechanisms are unknown or poorly understood. Some of these systems involve overcoming lysogenization defect (OLD) nucleases, a family of proteins comprising an ABC ATPase domain linked to a Toprim nuclease domain. Despite being discovered over 50 years ago, OLD nuclease function remained mysterious until recent biochemical, structural, and bioinformatic studies revealed that OLD nucleases protect bacteria by functioning in diverse anti-phage defense systems including the Gabija system and retrons. In this review we will highlight recent discoveries in OLD protein function and their involvement in multiple discrete anti-phage defense systems.