Adsorption of ionic surfactants at the air-water interface: The gap between theory and experiment

Probing the interfacial structure of aqueous surfactants through helium atom evaporation

Dissolved helium atoms evaporate from liquids in super-Maxwellian speed distributions because their interactions are too weak to enforce full thermal equilibration at the surface as they are "squeezed" out of solution. The excess speeds of these He atoms reflect their final interactions with solvent and solute molecules at the surfaces of water and other liquids. We extend this observation by monitoring He atom evaporation from salty water solutions coated with surfactants. These surface-active molecules span neutral, anionic, and cationic amphiphiles: butanol, 3-methyl-1-butanol, pentanol, pentanoic acid, pentanoate, tetrabutylammonium, benzyltrimethylammonium, hexyltrimethylammonium, and dodecyltrimethylammonium, each characterized by surface tension measurements. The helium energy distributions, recorded in vacuum using a salty water microjet, reveal a sharp distinction between neutral and ionic surfactant films. Helium atoms evaporate through neutral surfactant monolayers in speed distributions that are similar to a pure hydrocarbon, reflecting the common alkyl chains of both. In contrast, He atoms appear to evaporate through ionic surfactant layers in distributions that are closer to pure salty water. We speculate that the ionic surfactants distribute themselves more loosely and deeply through the top layers of the aqueous solution than do neutral surfactants, with gaps between the surfactants that may be filled with salty water. This difference is supported by prior molecular dynamics simulations and ion scattering measurements of surfactant solutions.

Affinity of Amphiphilic Molecules to Air/Water Surface

The affinity of amphiphiles to the water/air surface was modeled by adapting Eberhart's equation. The proposed method successfully describes surface tension for all amphiphilic structures, including alkanols, carboxylic acids, nonionic, ionic, and Gemini surfactants. The model is more effective than conventional analysis for amphiphiles with multiple ionic states. The prediction was consistently validated at different temperatures and nonaqueous solvents. The modeling results show a linear correlation between surface affinity and hydrophobicity/hydrophilicity. For alkanols, the affinity increment is 2.84 kJ/mol per CH2 group, the same as the reported hydrophobic energy from monomer to aggregate for nonionic surfactants. For carboxylic acids, the affinity increment per CH2 group is 3.18 kJ/mol, incorporating the degree of acid dissociation. The affinity-hydrophilicity correlation is approximately -0.22 kJ/mol per oxyethylene group. The affinity constant can be obtained for all classes of amphiphiles to clarify the relationship between the molecular structure and surface activity.

A many-body dissipative particle dynamics parametrisation scheme to study behaviour at air-water interfaces

In this article, we present a general parametrisation scheme for many-body dissipative particle dynamics (MDPD). The scheme is based on matching model components to experimental surface tensions and chemical potentials. This allows us to obtain the correct surface and mixing behaviours of complex, multicomponent systems. The methodology is tested by modelling the behaviour of nonionic polyoxyethylene alkyl ether surfactants at an air/water interface. In particular, the influence of the number of ethylene oxide units in the surfactant head group is investigated. We find good agreement with many experimentally obtained parameters, such as minimum surface area per molecule; and a decrease in the surface tension with increasing surfactant surface density. Moreover, we observe an orientational transition, from surfactants lying directly on the water surface at low surface coverage, to surfactants lying parallel or tilted with respect to the surface normal at high surface coverage. The parametrisation scheme is also extended to cover the zwitterionic surfactant lauryldimethylamine oxide (LDAO), where we provide good predictions for the surface tension at maximum surface coverage. Here, if we exceed this coverage, we are able to demonstrate the spontaneous production of micelles from the surface surfactant layer.

Momentum-dependent sum-frequency vibrational spectroscopy of bonded interface layer at charged water interfaces

Interface-specific hydrogen (H)-bonding network of water directly controls the energy transfer and chemical reaction pathway at many charged aqueous interfaces, yet to characterize these bonded water layer structures remains a challenge. We now develop a sum-frequency spectroscopic scheme with varying photon momenta as an all-optic solution for retrieving the vibrational spectra of the bonded water layer and the ion diffuse layer and, hence, microscopic structural and charging information about an interface. Application of the method to a model surfactant-water interface reveals a hidden weakly donor H-bonded water species, suggesting an asymmetric hydration-shell structure of fully solvated surfactant headgroups. In another application to a zwitterionic phosphatidylcholine lipid monolayer-water interface, we find a highly polarized bonded water layer structure associating to the phosphatidylcholine headgroup, while the diffuse layer contribution is experimentally proven to be negligible. Our all-optic method offers an in situ microscopic probe of electrochemical and biological interfaces and the route toward future imaging and ultrafast dynamics studies.

Coupling Effects of Ionic Surfactants and Electrolytes on the Stability of Bulk Nanobubbles

As interest in the extensive application of bulk nanobubbles increases, it is becoming progressively important to understand the key factors affecting their anomalous stability. The scientific intrigue over nanobubbles originates from the discrepancy between the Epstein-Plesset prediction and experimental observations. Herein, the coupling effects of ionic surfactants and electrolytes on the stability of bulk nanobubbles is studied. Experimental results show that ionic surfactants not only reduce the surface tension but also promote the accumulation of net charges, which facilitate the nucleation and stabilization of bulk nanobubbles. The addition of an electrolyte in a surfactant solution further results in a decrease in the zeta potential and the number concentration of nanobubbles due to the ion shielding effect, essentially colloidal stability. An adsorption model for the coexistence of ionic surfactants and electrolytes in solution, that specifically considers the effect of the adsorption layer thickness within the framework of the modified Poisson-Boltzmann equation, is developed. A quantitative agreement between the predicted and experimental surface tension is found in a wide range of bulk concentrations. The spatial distribution of the surface potential, surfactant ions and counterions in the vicinity of the interface of bulk nanobubbles are described. Our study intrinsically paves a route to investigate the stability of bulk nanobubbles.

Flotation surface chemistry of water-soluble salt minerals: from experimental results to new perspectives

The flotation separation of water-soluble salt minerals has to be conducted under the condition of saturation in brines which represents a challenging but exciting topic of colloid and surface chemistry. Despite several proposals on explaining the success of this industrial application for many decades, our understanding of the flotation separation is still far from complete yet, owing to the complexity of the highly selective collection of salt crystals by air bubbles in brines. Here, we thoroughly review the experimental results for halogen, oxyanion, and double salts and match them with the proposed theories on the flotation of soluble salts to identify the agreed and disagreed cases. The experimental results show that the flotation of these salts varies from collectors (surfactants applied to control the crystal hydrophobicity) to collectors and is strongly affected by the brine ion composition and pH conditions. We find some exceptional flotation results that cannot be simply explained by the crystal surface charge and wettability. Furthermore, we outline several disputes and discrepancies between the experiments and the theories when different collectors are applied. Apart from the extensive consideration of surface hydration, the presence of external ion species exhibits ubiquitous effects on the surface properties of salt crystals and the colloidal properties of collectors. We conclude that the interactions between salt ions, water molecules, collectors, and salt crystals must be considered more thoroughly, and the activity of collectors at the air-liquid interface should also be the focus. Advanced techniques such as molecular dynamics simulation, atomic force microscopy, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, and sum-frequency generation spectroscopy are expected to be promising research tools for future studies.

Modeling the Phase Equilibria of Associating Polymers in Porous Media with Respect to Chromatographic Applications

Associating copolymers self-assemble during their passage through a liquid chromatography (LC) column, and the elution differs from that of common non-associating polymers. This computational study aims at elucidating the mechanism of their unique and intricate chromatographic behavior. We focused on amphiphilic diblock copolymers in selective solvents, performed the Monte Carlo (MC) simulations of their partitioning between a bulk solvent (mobile phase) and a cylindrical pore (stationary phase), and investigated the concentration dependences of the partition coefficient and of other functions describing the phase behavior. The observed abruptly changing concentration dependences of the effective partition coefficient demonstrate the significant impact of the association of copolymers with their partitioning between the two phases. The performed simulations reveal the intricate interplay of the entropy-driven and the enthalpy-driven processes, elucidate at the molecular level how the self-assembly affects the chromatographic behavior, and provide useful hints for the analysis of experimental elution curves of associating polymers.

Interfacial protein-protein displacement at fluid interfaces

Protein blends are used to stabilise many traditional and emerging emulsion products, resulting in complex, non-equilibrated interfacial structures. The interface composition just after emulsification is dependent on the competitive adsorption between proteins. Over time, non-adsorbed proteins are capable of displacing the initially adsorbed ones. Such rearrangements are important to consider, since the integrity of the interfacial film could be compromised after partial displacement, which may result in the physical destabilisation of emulsions. In the present review, we critically describe various experimental techniques to assess the interfacial composition, properties and mechanisms of protein displacement. The type of information that can be obtained from the different techniques is described, from which we comment on their suitability for displacement studies. Comparative studies between model interfaces and emulsions allow for evaluating the impact of minor components and the different fluid dynamics during interface formation. We extensively discuss available mechanistic physical models that describe interfacial properties and the dynamics of complex mixed systems, with a focus on protein in-plane and bulk-interface interactions. The potential of Brownian dynamic simulations to describe the parameters that govern interfacial displacement is also addressed. This review thus provides ample information for characterising the interfacial properties over time in protein blend-stabilised emulsions, based on both experimental and modelling approaches.

Predicting the impact of salt mixtures on the air-water interfacial behavior of PFAS

Salts are known to have strong impacts on environmental behavior of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) including air-water interfacial adsorption. Multivalent salts impact interfacial adsorption to a greater extent than monovalent salts. Models to make a priori predictions of PFAS interfacial adsorption in the presence of multiple salts with different ionic charges are needed given the need to predict PFAS environmental fate. This study further develops a mass-action model to predict the interfacial behavior of PFAS as a function of both salt valency and concentration. The model is validated using surface tension data for a series of monovalent and divalent salt mixtures over a wide range of ionic strengths (i.e., from no added salt to 0.5 M) as well as comparison to data from literature. This model highlights the disproportionate impact of multivalent salts on interfacial adsorption and the practical utility of the model for predicting interfacial adsorption in the presence of multiple monovalent and multivalent inorganic salts. Results suggest that failure to account for divalent salt, even when concentrations are much smaller than monovalent salt, under most environmentally relevant aqueous phase conditions will result in significant underpredictions of PFAS interfacial adsorption. Simple examples of PFAS distribution in a range of salt conditions in the vadose zone and in aerated-water treatment reactors highlight the predictive utility of the model.

Single-Molecule Interactions at a Surfactant-Modified H2 Surface Nanobubble

In schematics and cartoons, the gas-liquid interface is often drawn as solid lines that aid in distinguishing the separation of the two phases. However, on the molecular level, the structure, shape, and size of the gas-liquid interface remain elusive. Furthermore, the interactions of molecules at gas-liquid interfaces must be considered in various contexts, including atmospheric chemical reactions, wettability of surfaces, and numerous other relevant phenomena. Hence, understanding the structure and interactions of molecules at the gas-liquid interface is critical for further improving technologies that operate between the two phases. Electrochemically generated surface nanobubbles provide a stable, reproducible, and high-throughput platform for the generation of a nanoscale gas-liquid boundary. We use total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy to image single-fluorophore labeling of surface nanobubbles in the presence of a surfactant. The accumulation of a surfactant on the nanobubble surface changes the interfacial properties of the gas-liquid interface. The single-molecule approach reveals that the fluorophore adsorption and residence lifetime at the interface is greatly impacted by the charge of the surfactant layer at the bubble surface. We demonstrate that the fluorescence readout is either short- or long-lived depending on the repulsive or attractive environment, respectively, between fluorophores and surfactants. Additionally, we investigated the effect of surfactant chain length and salt type and concentration on the fluorophore lifetime at the nanobubble surface.

From Surface Tension to Molecular Distribution: Modeling Surfactant Adsorption at the Air-Water Interface

Surfactants are centrally important in many scientific and engineering fields and are used for many purposes such as foaming agents and detergents. However, many challenges remain in providing a comprehensive understanding of their behavior. Here, we provide a brief historical overview of the study of surfactant adsorption at the air-water interface, followed by a discussion of some recent advances in this area from our group. The main focus is on incorporating an accurate description of the adsorption layer thickness of surfactant at the air-water interface. Surfactants have a wide distribution at the air-water interface, which can have a significant effect on important properties such as the surface excess, surface tension, and surface potential. We have developed a modified Poisson-Boltzmann (MPB) model to describe this effect, which we outline here. We also address the remaining challenges and future research directions in this area. We believe that experimental techniques, modeling, and simulation should be combined to form a holistic picture of surfactant adsorption at the air-water interface.

Competing Segregation of Br- and Cl- to a Surface Coated with a Cationic Surfactant: Direct Measurements of Ion and Solvent Depth Profiles

Ion-surface scattering experiments can be used to measure elemental depth profiles on the angstrom scale in complex liquid mixtures. We employ NICISS (neutral impact collision ion scattering spectroscopy) to measure depth profiles of dissolved ions and solvent in liquid glycerol containing the cationic surfactant tetrahexylammonium bromide (THA⁺/Br^-) at 0.013 M and mixtures of NaBr + NaCl at 0.4 M total concentration. The experiments reveal that Br^- outcompetes Cl^- in its attraction to surface THA⁺, and that THA⁺ segregates more extensively when more Br^- ions are present. Intriguingly, the depths spanned by THA⁺, Br^-, and Cl^- ions generally increase with Br^- bulk concentration, expanding from ∼10 to ∼25 Å for both Br^- and Cl^- depth profiles. This broadening likely occurs because of an increasing pileup of THA⁺ ions in a multilayer region that spreads the halide ions over a wider depth. The experiments indicate that cationic surfactants enhance Br^- and Cl^- concentrations in the surface region far beyond their bulk-phase values, making solutions coated with these surfactants potentially more reactive toward gases that can oxidize the halide ions.

Adsorption of Photoresponsive Surfactants at Solid-Liquid Interfaces

We report on the adsorption kinetics of azobenzene-containing surfactants on solid surfaces of different hydrophobicity. The understanding of this processes is of great importance for many interfacial phenomena that can be actuated and triggered by light, since the surfactant molecules contain a photoresponsive azobenzene group in their hydrophobic tail. Three surfactant types are studied, differing in the spacer connecting the headgroup and the azobenzene unit by between 6 and 10 CH₂ groups. Under irradiation with light of a suitable wavelength, the azobenzene undergoes reversible photoisomerization between two states, a nonpolar trans-state and a highly polar cis-state. Consequently, the surfactant molecule changes its hydrophobicity and thus affinity to a surface depending on the photoisomerization state of the azobenzene. The adsorption behavior on hydrophilic (glass) and hydrophobic (TeflonAF) surfaces is analyzed using quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation (QCM-D) and ζ-potential measurements. At equilibrium, the adsorbed surfactant amount is almost twice as large on glass compared to TeflonAF for both isomers. The adsorption rate for the trans-isomers on both surfaces is similar, but the desorption rate of the trans-isomers is faster at the glass-water interface than at the Teflon-water interface. This result demonstrates that the trans-isomers have higher affinity for the glass surface, so the trans-to-cis ratios on glass and TeflonAF are 80/1 and 2/1, respectively, with similar trends for all three surfactant types.

Orientation of adsorbed polar molecules (dipoles) in external electrostatic field

A model is proposed in the framework of classical electrostatics to describe the behavior of an adsorbed polar molecule near the plane interface between two insulators under the action of an external electrostatic field. The molecule is considered as a permanent point dipole that polarizes the interface and interacts with it through electrostatic image forces. The latter and the applied field try to reorient the dipole in a competitive manner. The system behavior turns out to be rather complicated: it may show a bistable character with a hysteresis (a switch). Such a switch can serve as an element in a memory network made of adsorbed molecules.

Significant Effect of Surfactant Adsorption Layer Thickness in Equilibrium Foam Films

Foam films formed at the air-water interface do not have fixed adsorption sites where adsorbed surfactants can arrange themselves, resulting in the formation of thick adsorption layers. Current theories of equilibrium foam films fail to account for this feature and significantly underestimate the adsorption layer thickness. Here we show that this thickness has a significant effect on the disjoining pressure in foam films. If ignored, the theory predicts unphysical electrostatic potential profiles, which underestimate the disjoining pressure. We apply a previously developed adsorption model that incorporates a realistic thickness for the adsorption layer. This new model reproduces experimental measurements of the disjoining pressure of foam films very well over a wide surfactant concentration range without fitting parameters. Our work shows that a thick adsorption layer is less effectively screened by counterions, resulting in a higher electrostatic potential inside the film and therefore a higher disjoining pressure.