Impaired control of weight bearing ankle inversion in subjects with chronic ankle instability

Effects of transcranial direct current stimulation combined with Bosu ball training on the injury potential during drop landing in people with chronic ankle instability

Purpose

To investigate the effects of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) combined with Bosu ball training on the injury potential during drop landing in people with chronic ankle instability (CAI).

Methods

A total of 40 participants with CAI were recruited and randomly divided into the tDCS + Bosu and Bosu groups. The people in the tDCS + Bosu group received intervention of tDCS combined with Bosu ball training, and those in the Bosu group received intervention of sham tDCS and Bosu ball training, for 6 weeks with three 20-min sessions per week. Before (week0) and after (week7) the intervention, all participants drop-landed on a trap-door device, with their affected limbs on a moveable platform, which could be flipped 24° inward and 15° forward to mimic an ankle inversion condition. The kinematic data were captured using a twelve-camera motion capture system. Two-way ANOVA with repeated measures was used to analyze data.

Results

Significant group-by-intervention interactions were detected in the peak ankle inversion angular velocity (p = 0.047, η2 p = 0.118), the time to peak ankle inversion (p = 0.030, η2 p = 0.139), and the plantarflexion angle at the moment of peak ankle inversion (p = 0.014, η2 p = 0.173). Post hoc comparisons showed that compared with week0, the peak ankle inversion angular velocity and the plantarflexion angle at the moment of peak ankle inversion were reduced, the time to peak ankle inversion was advanced in both groups at week7, and the changes were greater in the tDCS + Bosu group compared to the Bosu group. And, a significant intervention main effect was detected in the peak ankle inversion angle in the two groups (p < 0.001, η2 p = 0.337).

Conclusion

Compared with the Bosu ball training, the tDCS combined with Bosu ball training was more effective in reducing the injury potential during drop landing in people with CAI.

Electromyographic Activity of Lower Limb Muscles during Ankle Destabilizing Tests

Ankle destabilizing devices were developed to improve the recruitment of the evertor muscles. Nevertheless, the activity of lower-leg muscles has never been compared to each other during functional tests performed with destabilization. The objectives were i) to compare the electromyographic activity between the lower-leg muscles during four functional tests performed with ankle destabilization, and ii) to determine sex-related differences in neuromuscular activation. Twenty-six healthy volunteers (13 males, 13 females) performed the modified Star Excursion Balance Test (mSEBT), unipedal balance and weight-bearing inversion and eversion tests with a destabilizing device, while recording electromyographic activity of the peroneus longus and brevis, tibialis anterior, gastrocnemius lateralis and gluteus medius. The activity of peroneal muscles was significantly greater than other muscles during all functional tests. Furthermore, the anterior direction of the mSEBT was the one implying the greatest activity of the peroneus longus muscle compared to the posteromedial (p=0.003) or posterolateral (p<0.001) directions. Finally, no significant sex-related differences in neuromuscular activity were reported. This study highlights the effectiveness of the destabilizing device to involve specifically the peroneal muscles when performing various functional tests. This device should be used by clinicians to be more specific to the stabilizers of the ankle joint during functional exercises.

Effects of whole-body vibration on chronic ankle instability: a systematic review

Background and objective

Chronic ankle instability (CAI) is one of the most common sports injuries, and whole-body vibration (WBV) training has been used lately as a potential rehabilitation modality for these patients. The authors conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis to assess whether WBV training positively affects patients with CAI.

Materials and methods

The authors systematically searched four databases, including MEDLINE (PubMed), Scopus, Web of Science, and Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, for randomized and non-randomized trials evaluating the effects of WBV on individuals with CAI. The authors used Cochrane RoB2 to assess the risk of bias in randomized trials. A meta-analysis was conducted if three or more studies measured the same outcome. Effect estimates were pooled using a random-effects model.

Results

Results were retrieved from seven articles encompassing 288 participants who had CAI. The reach distance of the Star Excursion Balance Test (SEBT) was regarded as the study's main finding. The authors saw a significant training effect on certain planes of motion on dynamic balance. The findings showed that the post-intervention measurements in the WBV group compared to control groups showed improvements in the posterolateral, posteromedial, and medial directions, respectively. There were also promising results on improvements in muscle activity, strength, and proprioception sense measurements with a great diversity in the reported parameters.

Conclusion

The authors observed a significant WBV training effect on dynamic balance over posterolateral, posteromedial, and medial reach distances. These findings suggest future studies on the effects of WBV on muscle activity, strength, and proprioception in addition to dynamic and static balance.

The correlation of centre of mass evaluation utilising accelerometry-based measurement and the clinical dynamic balance test in professional football athletes with chronic ankle instability

Background

Similar to a modified star excursion balance test, the Y-balance test is recommended for use in clinical settings to evaluate dynamic balance, particularly in athletes with chronic ankle instability. However, due to the testing errors, there are certain restrictions. As a result, the modification of the centre of mass tracking system was developed in order to aid in the detection of the ability to control the dynamic balance. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to correlate the usage of an accelerometer for the shifting of the centre of mass during a dynamic balance test with a Y-balance test reach distance score.

Methodology

Forty professional football athletes with CAI participated in this study by performing the Y-balance test three times while wearing an accelerometer. The jerk, RMS sway amplitude, mean velocity from the time domain, and the normalised reach distance scores of the Y-balance test in the anterior, posteromedial, and posterolateral directions were all collected.

Results

There was a strong positive correlation of jerk and RMS sway amplitude with the normalised reach distance scores in the posteromedial direction (r = 0.706 and 0.777, respectively), a moderate positive correlation of jerk and RMS sway amplitude with the normalised reach distance scores in the posterolateral direction (r = 0.609 and 0.606, respectively), a moderate positive correlation of jerk and RMS sway amplitude with the composite reach distance scores (r = 0.531 and 0.573, respectively) and significant differences in the posteromedial, posterolateral and overall directions (p-value < 0.001).

Conclusion

These findings indicate that the area of the centre of mass shifting as represented by the accelerometer can disclose the body's ability to control the centre of mass over the base of support when the body is moving. Furthermore, in this study, the RMS sway variable in the posteromedial direction appears to be the most prominent.

Effect of Different Protection on Lateral Ankle during Landing: An Instantaneous Impact Analysis

Ankle sprain is the most common injury during parachute landing. The biomechanical behavior of the tissues can help us understand the injury mechanism of ankle inversion. To accurately describe the injury mechanism of tissues and assess the effect of ankle protection, a stable time of landing was obtained through the dynamic stability test. It was used for the boundary condition of the foot finite element (FE). The FE model was provided a static load equal to half of the bodyweight applied at the distal tibia and fibula; a foot-boot-brace FE model was established to simulate the landing of subjects on an inversion inclined platform of 0-20°, including non-, external, and elastic ankle braces. Compared with the non-ankle brace, both the external and elastic ankle braces decreased the peak strains of the cal-fibular, anterior Ta-fibular, and posterior Ta-fibular ligaments (15.2-33.0%), and of the peak stress of the fibula (15.2-24.5%). For the strain decrement of the aforementioned ligaments, the elastic brace performed better than the external ankle brace under the inversion of the 10° condition. The peak stress of the fibula (15.6 MPa) decreased up to 24.5% with an elastic brace and 5.6-10.3% with an external brace. The findings suggested that the behaviors of lateral ankle ligaments and fibula were meaningful for the functional ability of the ankle. This provides some suggestions regarding the optimal design of ankle protection.

Which Functional Tests and Self-Reported Questionnaires Can Help Clinicians Make Valid Return to Sport Decisions in Patients With Chronic Ankle Instability? A Narrative Review and Expert Opinion

Lateral ankle sprain is the most common injury in sports, with up to 40% of patients developing chronic ankle instability (CAI). One possible cause underlying this high rate of recurrence or feeling of giving way may be a premature return to sport (RTS). Indeed, except for time-based parameters, there are no specific criteria to guide clinicians in their RTS decisions in patients with CAI. A recent international consensus highlighted the relevance and importance of including patient-reported ankle function questionnaires combined with functional tests targeting ankle impairments in this population. Thus, the aim of this narrative review and expert opinion was to identify the most relevant functional performance tests and self-reported questionnaires to help clinicians in their RTS decision-making process following recurrent ankle sprains or surgical ankle stabilization. The PubMed (MEDLINE), PEDro, Cochrane Library and ScienceDirect databases were searched to identify published articles. Results showed that the single leg stance test on firm surfaces, the modified version of the star excursion balance test, the side hop test and the figure-of-8 test appeared to be the most relevant functional performance tests to target ankle impairments in patients with CAI. A combination of the Foot and Ankle Ability Measure (FAAM) and the Ankle Ligament Reconstruction-Return to Sport after Injury (ALR-RSI) questionnaires were the most relevant self-reported questionnaires to assess patient function in the context of CAI. Although these functional tests and questionnaires provide a solid foundation for clinicians to validate their RTS decisions in patient with CAI, objective scientific criteria with cut-off scores are still lacking. In addition to the proposed test cluster, an analysis of the context, in particular characteristics related to sports (e.g., fatigue, cognitive constraints), to obtain more information about the patient's risk of recurrent injury could be of added value when making a RTS decision in patients with CAI. In order to evaluate the strength of evertors under ecological conditions, it would also be interesting to assess the ability to control weight-bearing ankle inversion in a unipodal stance. Further studies are needed to assess the relevance of this proposed test cluster in RTS decision-making following lateral ankle sprain injury and CAI.

Assessment of Evertor Strength Following Inferior Extensor Retinaculum Flap Ligamentoplasty in Patients With Chronic Lateral Ankle Instability

The primary aim of our study was to evaluate the strength of ankle evertor muscles in patients who have undergone a lateral ankle ligamentoplasty (which combined tensioning of the primary ligament group and reinforcing it with a pediculated extensor retinaculum flap), using 2 measurement systems (isokinetic and the functional weightbearing test [MyoLux). Our hypothesis was the strength of evertor muscles on the treated side was comparable to that of the contralateral healthy side. This prospective study included 23 patients who had chronic ankle instability and underwent an inferior extensor retinaculum flap ligamentoplasty. Clinical and functional results were assessed using the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society and Karlsson scores. The evertor muscle strength was analyzed, in both treated and healthy contralateral ankles, using isokinetic testing (gold standard) - an open kinetic chain test and a functional closed kinetic chain test (MyoLux). Data were interpreted using the Stata 14.0 software. The American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society score was 88.1 ± 4.5, and the Karlsson score was 89.6 ± 4.0. Isokinetic tests did not show any significant difference between the treated ankles and the healthy one. Functional tests measuring inversion control at the ankle did not demonstrate any functional differences between the 2 ankles. As confirmed by good functional scores and the lack of difference in evertor muscle strength, this study reports that the inferior extensor retinaculum flap ligamentoplasty is a satisfactory treatment of chronic ankle instability. In addition, the MyoLux is a reliable and effective test to properly assess proprioception at the ankle.

Weight, BMI and stability are risk factors associated with lateral ankle sprains and chronic ankle instability: a meta-analysis

IMPORTANCE

Lateral ankle sprains (LAS) are common in the general population and may lead to chronic ankle instability (CAI). If patients at risk could be identified, they could receive adequate and on-time treatment.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of the current review was to identify all reported intrinsic factors associated with sustaining a LAS or progressing to CAI after an initial sprain.

EVIDENCE REVIEW

PubMed, Embase, MEDline, Cochrane and PEDro were searched for studies published until July 2019. Articles were selected if they included intrinsic factors related to LAS or CAI, subjects of at least 16 years old, and contained a minimum of 10 patients and 10 controls. Studies were excluded if they concerned reviews or case reports, included patients with previous surgical interventions, concomitant injuries or joint pathology other than ankle instability. Quality of included studies was assessed using the Quality in Prognostic Studies tool and quality of evidence was assessed using the GRADEpro tool. In case outcomes were described by at least three studies, data were pooled and assessed by performing a meta-analysis. Based on the pooled data, either a fixed-effects model or random-effects model was selected to correct for the degree of heterogeneity.

FINDINGS

The search resulted in a total of 4154 studies. After title and abstract screening and subsequent full-text screening, 80 relevant studies were included. Results of the meta-analyses indicated that, compared with healthy controls, patients with LAS had a higher mean body mass index (BMI). In patients with CAI, a higher weight and a longer time to stabilise after performing a task (eg, jumping) were found compared with healthy controls. Other outcomes could not be compared using a meta-analysis due to heterogeneity in outcome measurement and the great number of different outcomes reported. Identification of the risk factors when patients present themselves after a LAS may help to determine which patients are at risk of recurrent sprains or developing CAI.

CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE

Based on the findings in this review, a higher BMI, and a higher weight and neuromuscular stability deficits may be regarded risk factors for sustaining a LAS or developing CAI, respectively.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

Ankle Strength Deficits in a Cohort of College Athletes With Chronic Ankle Instability

Context: Lateral ankle sprains commonly occur in an athletic population and can lead to chronic ankle instability. Objective: To compare ankle strength measurements in athletes who have mechanical laxity and report functional instability after a history of unilateral ankle sprains. Design: Retrospective cohort. Setting: Athletic Training Research Lab. Participants: A total of 165 National Collegiate Athletic Association Division I athletes, 97 males and 68 females, with history of unilateral ankle sprains participated. Main Outcome Measures: Functional ankle instability was determined by Cumberland Ankle Instability Tool scores and mechanical ankle instability by the participant having both anterior and inversion/eversion laxity. Peak torque strength measures, concentric and eccentric, in 2 velocities were measured. Results: Of the 165 participants, 24 subjects had both anterior and inversion/eversion laxity and 74 self-reported functional ankle instability on their injured ankle. The mechanical ankle instability group presented with significantly lower plantar flexion concentric strength at 30°/s (139.7 [43.7] N·m) (P = .01) and eversion concentric strength at 120°/s (14.8 [5.3] N·m) (P = .03) than the contralateral, uninjured ankle (166.3 [56.8] N·m, 17.4 [6.2] N·m, respectively). Conclusion: College athletes who present with mechanical laxity on a previously injured ankle exhibit plantar flexion and eversion strength deficits between ankles.

Altered Movement Biomechanics in Chronic Ankle Instability, Coper, and Control Groups: Energy Absorption and Distribution Implications

CONTEXT

Patients with chronic ankle instability (CAI) exhibit deficits in neuromuscular control, resulting in altered movement strategies. However, no researchers have examined neuromuscular adaptations to dynamic movement strategies during multiplanar landing and cutting among patients with CAI, individuals who are ankle-sprain copers, and control participants.

OBJECTIVE

To investigate lower extremity joint power, stiffness, and ground reaction force (GRF) during a jump-landing and cutting task among CAI, coper, and control groups.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional study.

SETTING

Laboratory.

PATIENTS OR OTHER PARTICIPANTS

A total of 22 patients with CAI (age = 22.7 ± 2.0 years, height = 174.6 ± 10.4 cm, mass = 73.4 ± 12.1 kg), 22 ankle-sprain copers (age = 22.1 ± 2.1 years, height = 173.8 ± 8.2 cm, mass = 72.6 ± 12.3 kg), and 22 healthy control participants (age = 22.5 ± 3.3 years, height = 172.4 ± 13.3 cm, mass = 72.6 ± 18.7 kg).

INTERVENTION(S)

Participants performed 5 successful trials of a jump-landing and cutting task.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Using motion-capture cameras and a force plate, we collected lower extremity ankle-, knee-, and hip-joint power and stiffness and GRFs during the jump-landing and cutting task. Functional analyses of variance were used to evaluate between-groups differences in these dependent variables throughout the contact phase of the task.

RESULTS

Compared with the coper and control groups, the CAI group displayed (1) up to 7% of body weight more posterior and 52% of body weight more vertical GRF during initial landing followed by decreased GRF during the remaining stance and 22% of body weight less medial GRF across most of stance; (2) 8.8 W/kg less eccentric and 3.2 W/kg less concentric ankle power, 6.4 W/kg more eccentric knee and 4.8 W/kg more eccentric hip power during initial landing, and 5.0 W/kg less eccentric knee and 3.9 W/kg less eccentric hip power; and (3) less ankle- and knee-joint stiffness during the landing phase. Concentric power patterns were similar to eccentric power patterns.

CONCLUSIONS

The CAI group demonstrated altered neuromechanics, redistributing energy absorption from the distal (ankle) to the proximal (knee and hip) joints, which coincided with decreased ankle and knee stiffness during landing. Our data suggested that although the coper and control groups showed similar landing and cutting strategies, the CAI group used altered strategies to modulate impact forces during the task.

Assessment of evertor weakness in patients with chronic ankle instability: Functional versus isokinetic testing

BACKGROUND

Ankle sprain is the most common sport-related injury and eccentric weakness of ankle evertors is regarded as a significant muscular deficit related to chronic ankle instability. However, the eccentric performance of the evertors is rarely assessed by clinicians because procedures used for research purposes (i.e. isokinetic tests) are not easily applicable in daily practice.

METHODS

The present study assessed the ability of two different testing procedures to distinguish between groups of 12 healthy subjects or 12 patients suffering from chronic ankle instability. On the one hand, the strength of evertors was assessed with a goldstandard isokinetic procedure. On the other hand, we assessed the ability of the subjects to control ankle inversion during weight bearing (functional standing test).

FINDINGS

Data showed no significant difference between groups for isokinetic peak torque values normalized to body weight. Conversely, the functional test revealed a significantly impaired ability to control ankle inversion during weight bearing in subjects with chronic ankle instability.

INTERPRETATION

This suggests that this easy-to-apply functional test is better suited compared to isokinetic testing procedures to assess weakness of evertors in patients suffering from chronic ankle instability. Moreover, this test may also be used to objectively monitor improvements during rehabilitation or progression in prevention protocols.

Rehabilitation after anatomical ankle ligament repair or reconstruction

The selection, implementation of and adherence to a post-operative regimen are all essential in order to achieve the best outcomes after ankle ligament surgery. The purpose of this paper is to present a best-evidence approach to this, with grounding in basic science and a consensus opinion from the members of the ESSKA-AFAS Ankle Instability Group. Basic science and clinical evidence surrounding tissue healing after surgical repair or reconstruction of the ligaments as well as around the re-establishment of sensorimotor control are reviewed. A consensus opinion based on this evidence as to the recommended rehabilitation protocol after ankle ligament surgery was then obtained from the members of the ESSKA-AFAS Ankle Instability Group. Rehabilitation recommendations are presented for the initial post-operative period, the early recovery phase and a goal-orientated late rehabilitation and return-to-sport phase. This paper presents practical, evidenced-based guidelines for rehabilitation and return to activity after lateral ankle ligament surgery.

Rehabilitation after anatomical ankle ligament repair or reconstruction

The selection, implementation of and adherence to a post-operative regimen are all essential in order to achieve the best outcomes after ankle ligament surgery. The purpose of this paper is to present a best-evidence approach to this, with grounding in basic science and a consensus opinion from the members of the ESSKA-AFAS Ankle Instability Group. Basic science and clinical evidence surrounding tissue healing after surgical repair or reconstruction of the ligaments as well as around the re-establishment of sensorimotor control are reviewed. A consensus opinion based on this evidence as to the recommended rehabilitation protocol after ankle ligament surgery was then obtained from the members of the ESSKA-AFAS Ankle Instability Group. Rehabilitation recommendations are presented for the initial post-operative period, the early recovery phase and a goal-orientated late rehabilitation and return-to-sport phase. This paper presents practical, evidenced-based guidelines for rehabilitation and return to activity after lateral ankle ligament surgery.

Effects of virtual reality programs on balance in functional ankle instability

[Purpose] The aim of present study was to identify the impact that recent virtual reality training programs used in a variety of fields have had on the ankle’s static and dynamic senses of balance among subjects with functional ankle instability. [Subjects and Methods] This study randomly divided research subjects into two groups, a strengthening exercise group (Group I) and a balance exercise group (Group II), with each group consisting of 10 people. A virtual reality program was performed three times a week for four weeks. Exercises from the Nintendo Wii Fit Plus program were applied to each group for twenty minutes along with ten minutes of warming up and wrap-up exercises. [Results] Group II showed a significant decrease of post-intervention static and dynamic balance overall in the anterior-posterior, and mediolateral directions, compared with the pre-intervention test results. In comparison of post-intervention static and dynamic balance between Group I and Group II, a significant decrease was observed overall. [Conclusion] Virtual reality programs improved the static balance and dynamic balance of subjects with functional ankle instability. Virtual reality programs can be used more safely and efficiently if they are implemented under appropriate monitoring by a physiotherapist.