COVID-19 forecasting using new viral variants and vaccination effectiveness models

Spatio-temporal epidemic forecasting using mobility data with LSTM networks and attention mechanism

The outbreak of infectious diseases can have profound impacts on socio-economic balances globally. Accurate short-term forecasting of infectious diseases is crucial for policymakers and healthcare systems. This study proposes a novel deep learning approach for short-term forecasting of infectious disease trends, using COVID-19 confirmed cases and hospitalizations in Japan as a case study. This method provides weekly updates and forecasts outcomes over 1-4 weeks. The proposed model combines long short-term memory (LSTM) networks and multi-head attention mechanism strengths and is trained on public data sourced from open-access platforms. We conduct a comprehensive and rigorous evaluation of the performance of our model. We assess its weekly predictive capabilities over a long period of time by employing multiple error metrics. Furthermore, we carefully explore how the performance of the model varies over time and across geographical locations. The results demonstrate that the proposed model outperforms baseline approaches, particularly in short-term forecasts, achieving lower error rates across multiple metrics. Additionally, the inclusion of mobility data improves the predictive accuracy of the model, especially for longer-term forecasts, by capturing spatio-temporal dynamics more effectively. The proposed model has the potential to assist in decision-making processes, help develop strategies for controlling the spread of infectious diseases, and mitigate the pandemic's impact.

Forecasting the changes between endemic and epidemic phases of a contagious disease, with the example of COVID-19

BACKGROUND

Predicting the endemic/epidemic transition during the temporal evolution of a contagious disease.

METHODS

Indicators for detecting the transition endemic/epidemic, with four scalars to be compared, are calculated from the daily reported news cases: coefficient of variation, skewness, kurtosis and entropy. The indicators selected are related to the shape of the empirical distribution of the new cases observed over 14 days. This duration has been chosen to smooth out the effect of weekends when fewer new cases are registered. For finding a forecasting variable, we have used the principal component analysis (PCA), whose first principal component (a linear combination of the selected indicators) explains a large part of the observed variance and can then be used as a predictor of the phenomenon studied (here the occurrence of an epidemic wave).

RESULTS

A score has been built from the four proposed indicators using the PCA, which allows an acceptable level of forecasting performance by giving a realistic retro-predicted date for the rupture of the stationary endemic model corresponding to the entrance in the epidemic exponential growth phase. This score is applied to the retro-prediction of the limits of the different phases of the COVID-19 outbreak in successive endemic/epidemic transitions for three countries, France, India and Japan.

CONCLUSION

We provided a new forecasting method for predicting an epidemic wave occurring after an endemic phase for a contagious disease.

Forecasting of hospitalizations for COVID-19: A hybrid intelligence approach for Disease X research

BackgroundThe COVID-19 pandemic underscores the necessity for proactive measures against emerging diseases, epitomized by WHO's "Disease X." Among the myriad of indicators tracking COVID-19 progression, the count of hospitalized patients assumes a pivotal role. This metric facilitates timely responses from government agencies, enabling proactive allocation and management of medical resources.ObjectiveIn this study, we introduce a novel hybrid intelligent approach, the EMD&LSTM-ARIMA model.Method: This model integrates three techniques: Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD) to decompose the data into intrinsic mode functions, Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) neural network for capturing long-term dependencies and nonlinear relationships, and the Auto-Regressive Integrated Moving Average (ARIMA) model for handling linear trends and time series forecasting. We verify its high predictive power and utility through training and forecasting COVID-19 hospitalizations in the UK, Canada, Italy, and Japan.ResultsOur analysis reveals that all forecasted error rates remain below 10%, with Mean Absolute Percentage Error (MAPE) values obtained for these four countries as 2.30%, 3.33%, 1.63%, and 2.89%, respectively.ConclusionOur proposed EMD&LSTM-ARIMA model demonstrates robust forecasting performance, particularly for COVID-19 hospitalization data.

Can the number of confirmed COVID-19 cases be predicted more accurately by including lifestyle data? An exploratory study for data-driven prediction of COVID-19 cases in metropolitan cities using deep learning models

Objective

The COVID-19 outbreak has significantly impacted human lifestyles and life patterns. Therefore, data related to human social life may tell us the increase or decrease in the number of confirmed COVID-19 cases. However, although the number of confirmed cases is affected by social life, it is difficult to find studies that attempt to predict the number of confirmed cases using various lifestyle data. This paper attempted an exploratory data analysis to see if the number of confirmed cases could be predicted more accurately by including various lifestyle data.

Methods

We included taking public transportation, watching a movie at the cinema, and accommodation at a motel in the lifestyle data. Finally, a 'lifestyle addition' set was constructed that added lifestyle data to the number of past confirmed cases and search term frequency data. The deep learning algorithms used in the analysis are deep neural networks (DNNs) and recurrent neural networks (RNNs). Performance differences across data sets and between deep learning models were tested to be statistically significant.

Results

Among metropolitan cities in South Korea, Seoul (9.6 million) with the largest population and Busan (3.4 million) with the second largest population had the lowest error rate in 'lifestyle addition' set. When predicting with the 'lifestyle addition' set, in Seoul, the error rate was reduced to 20.1%, and in Busan, the graph of the actual number of confirmed cases and the predicted graph were almost identical.

Conclusions

Through this study, we were able to identify three notable results that could contribute to predicting the number of patients infected with epidemic in the future.

A novel multivariate time series forecasting dendritic neuron model for COVID-19 pandemic transmission tendency

A novel coronavirus discovered in late 2019 (COVID-19) quickly spread into a global epidemic and, thankfully, was brought under control by 2022. Because of the virus's unknown mutations and the vaccine's waning potency, forecasting is still essential for resurgence prevention and medical resource management. Computational efficiency and long-term accuracy are two bottlenecks for national-level forecasting. This study develops a novel multivariate time series forecasting model, the densely connected highly flexible dendritic neuron model (DFDNM) to predict daily and weekly positive COVID-19 cases. DFDNM's high flexibility mechanism improves its capacity to deal with nonlinear challenges. The dense introduction of shortcut connections alleviates the vanishing and exploding gradient problems, encourages feature reuse, and improves feature extraction. To deal with the rapidly growing parameters, an improved variation of the adaptive moment estimation (AdamW) algorithm is employed as the learning algorithm for the DFDNM because of its strong optimization ability. The experimental results and statistical analysis conducted across three Japanese prefectures confirm the efficacy and feasibility of the DFDNM while outperforming various state-of-the-art machine learning models. To the best of our knowledge, the proposed DFDNM is the first to restructure the dendritic neuron model's neural architecture, demonstrating promising use in multivariate time series prediction. Because of its optimal performance, the DFDNM may serve as an important reference for national and regional government decision-makers aiming to optimize pandemic prevention and medical resource management. We also verify that DFDMN is efficiently applicable not only to COVID-19 transmission prediction, but also to more general multivariate prediction tasks. It leads us to believe that it might be applied as a promising prediction model in other fields.

Data-driven mathematical modeling approaches for COVID-19: A survey

In this review, we successively present the methods for phenomenological modeling of the evolution of reported and unreported cases of COVID-19, both in the exponential phase of growth and then in a complete epidemic wave. After the case of an isolated wave, we present the modeling of several successive waves separated by endemic stationary periods. Then, we treat the case of multi-compartmental models without or with age structure. Eventually, we review the literature, based on 260 articles selected in 11 sections, ranging from the medical survey of hospital cases to forecasting the dynamics of new cases in the general population. This review favors the phenomenological approach over the mechanistic approach in the choice of references and provides simulations of the evolution of the number of observed cases of COVID-19 for 10 states (California, China, France, India, Israel, Japan, New York, Peru, Spain and United Kingdom).

Exploring the potential of learning methods and recurrent dynamic model with vaccination: A comparative case study of COVID-19 in Austria, Brazil, and China

In order to effectively manage infectious diseases, it is crucial to understand the interplay between disease dynamics and human conduct. Various factors can impact the control of an epidemic, including social interventions, adherence to health protocols, mask-wearing, and vaccination. This article presents the development of an innovative hybrid model, known as the Combined Dynamic-Learning Model, that integrates classical recurrent dynamic models with four different learning methods. The model is composed of two approaches: The first approach introduces a traditional dynamic model that focuses on analyzing the impact of vaccination on the occurrence of an epidemic, and the second approach employs various learning methods to forecast the potential outcomes of an epidemic. Furthermore, our numerical results offer an interesting comparison between the traditional approach and modern learning techniques. Our classic dynamic model is a compartmental model that aims to analyze and forecast the diffusion of epidemics. The model we propose has a recurrent structure with piecewise constant parameters and includes compartments for susceptible, exposed, vaccinated, infected, and recovered individuals. This model can accurately mirror the dynamics of infectious diseases, which enables us to evaluate the impact of restrictive measures on the spread of diseases. We conduct a comprehensive dynamic analysis of our model. Additionally, we suggest an optimal numerical design to determine the parameters of the system. Also, we use regression tree learning, bidirectional long short-term memory, gated recurrent unit, and a combined deep learning method for training and evaluation of an epidemic. In the final section of our paper, we apply these methods to recently published data on COVID-19 in Austria, Brazil, and China from 26 February 2021 to 4 August 2021, which is when vaccination efforts began. To evaluate the numerical results, we utilized various metrics such as RMSE and R-squared. Our findings suggest that the dynamic model is ideal for long-term analysis, data fitting, and identifying parameters that impact epidemics. However, it is not as effective as the supervised learning method for making long-term forecasts. On the other hand, supervised learning techniques, compared to dynamic models, are more effective for predicting the spread of diseases, but not for analyzing the behavior of epidemics.

Time series forecasting of COVID-19 infections and deaths in Alpha and Delta variants using LSTM networks

Since the beginning of the rapidly spreading COVID-19 pandemic, several mutations have occurred in the genetic sequence of the virus, resulting in emerging different variants of concern. These variants vary in transmissibility, severity of infections, and mortality rate. Designing models that are capable of predicting the future behavior of these variants in the societies can help decision makers and the healthcare system to design efficient health policies, and to be prepared with the sufficient medical devices and an adequate number of personnel to fight against this virus and the similar ones. Among variants of COVID-19, Alpha and Delta variants differ noticeably in the virus structures. In this paper, we study these variants in the geographical regions with different size, population densities, and social life styles. These regions include the country of Iran, the continent of Asia, and the whole world. We propose four deep learning models based on Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM), and examine their predictive power in forecasting the number of infections and deaths for the next three, next five, and next seven days in each variant. These models include Encoder Decoder LSTM (ED-LSTM), Bidirectional LSTM (Bi-LSTM), Convolutional LSTM (Conv-LSTM), and Gated Recurrent Unit (GRU). Performance of these models in predictions are evaluated using the root mean square error, mean absolute error, and mean absolute percentage error. Then, the Friedman test is applied to find the leading model for predictions in all conditions. The results show that ED-LSTM is generally the leading model for predicting the number of infections and deaths for both variants of Alpha and Delta, with the ability to forecast long time intervals ahead.

Forecasting the Endemic/Epidemic Transition in COVID-19 in Some Countries: Influence of the Vaccination

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this article is to develop a robust method for forecasting the transition from endemic to epidemic phases in contagious diseases using COVID-19 as a case study.

METHODS

Seven indicators are proposed for detecting the endemic/epidemic transition: variation coefficient, entropy, dominant/subdominant spectral ratio, skewness, kurtosis, dispersion index and normality index. Then, principal component analysis (PCA) offers a score built from the seven proposed indicators as the first PCA component, and its forecasting performance is estimated from its ability to predict the entrance in the epidemic exponential growth phase.

RESULTS

This score is applied to the retro-prediction of endemic/epidemic transitions of COVID-19 outbreak in seven various countries for which the first PCA component has a good predicting power.

CONCLUSION

This research offers a valuable tool for early epidemic detection, aiding in effective public health responses.

Population-Level Immunity for Transient Suppression of COVID-19 Waves in Japan from April 2021 to September 2022

Multiple COVID-19 waves have been observed worldwide, with varying numbers of positive cases. Population-level immunity can partly explain a transient suppression of epidemic waves, including immunity acquired after vaccination strategies. In this study, we aimed to estimate population-level immunity in 47 Japanese prefectures during the three waves from April 2021 to September 2022. For each wave, characterized by the predominant variants, namely, Delta, Omicron, and BA.5, the estimated rates of population-level immunity in the 10-64-years age group, wherein the most positive cases were observed, were 20%, 35%, and 45%, respectively. The number of infected cases in the BA.5 wave was inversely associated with the vaccination rates for the second and third injections. We employed machine learning to replicate positive cases in three Japanese prefectures to validate the reliability of our model for population-level immunity. Using interpolation based on machine learning, we estimated the impact of behavioral factors and vaccination on the fifth wave of new positive cases that occurred during the Tokyo 2020 Olympic Games. Our computational results highlighted the critical role of population-level immunity, such as vaccination, in infection suppression. These findings underscore the importance of estimating and monitoring population-level immunity to predict the number of infected cases in future waves. Such estimations that combine numerical derivation and machine learning are of utmost significance for effective management of medical resources, including the vaccination strategy.

A new RNN based machine learning model to forecast COVID-19 incidence, enhanced by the use of mobility data from the bike-sharing service in Madrid

As a respiratory virus, COVID-19 propagates based on human-to-human interactions with positive COVID-19 cases. The temporal evolution of new COVID-19 infections depends on the existing number of COVID-19 infections and the people's mobility. This article proposes a new model to predict upcoming COVID-19 incidence values that combines both current and near-past incidence values together with mobility data. The model is applied to the city of Madrid (Spain). The city is divided into districts. The weekly COVID-19 incidence data per district is used jointly with a mobility estimation based on the number of rides reported by the bike-sharing service in the city of Madrid (BiciMAD). The model employs a Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) to detect temporal patterns for COVID-19 infections and mobility data, and combines the output of the LSTM layers into a dense layer that can learn the spatial patterns (the spread of the virus between districts). A baseline model that employs a similar RNN but only based on the COVID-19 confirmed cases with no mobility data is presented and used to estimate the model gain when adding mobility data. The results show that using the bike-sharing mobility estimation the proposed model increases the accuracy by 11.7% compared with the baseline model.

Modeling COVID-19 transmission dynamics incorporating media coverage and vaccination

The COVID-19 pandemic has caused widespread concern around the world. In order to study the impact of media coverage and vaccination on the spread of COVID-19, we establish an SVEAIQR infectious disease model, and fit the important parameters such as transmission rate, isolation rate and vaccine efficiency based on the data from Shanghai Municipal Health Commission and the National Health Commission of the People's Republic of China. Meanwhile, the control reproduction number and the final size are derived. Moreover, through sensitivity analysis by PRCC (partial rank correlation coefficient), we discuss the effects of both the behavior change constant $ k $ according to media coverage and the vaccine efficiency $ \varepsilon $ on the transmission of COVID-19. Numerical explorations of the model suggest that during the outbreak of the epidemic, media coverage can reduce the final size by about 0.26 times. Besides that, comparing with $ 50\% $ vaccine efficiency, when the vaccine efficiency reaches $ 90\% $, the peak value of infected people decreases by about 0.07 times. In addition, we simulate the impact of media coverage on the number of infected people in the case of vaccination or non-vaccination. Accordingly, the management departments should pay attention to the impact of vaccination and media coverage.

AI and data science for smart emergency, crisis and disaster resilience

The uncertain world has seen increasing emergencies, crises and disasters (ECDs), such as the COVID-19 pandemic, hurricane Ian, global financial inflation and recession, misinformation disaster, and cyberattacks. AI for smart disaster resilience (AISDR) transforms classic reactive and scripted disaster management to digital proactive and intelligent resilience across ECD ecosystems. A systematic overview of diverse ECDs, classic ECD management, ECD data complexities, and an AISDR research landscape are presented in this article. Translational disaster AI is essential to enable smart disaster resilience.

Global analysis and prediction scenario of infectious outbreaks by recurrent dynamic model and machine learning models: A case study on COVID-19

It is essential to evaluate patient outcomes at an early stage when dealing with a pandemic to provide optimal clinical care and resource management. Many methods have been proposed to provide a roadmap against different pandemics, including the recent pandemic disease COVID-19. Due to recurrent epidemic waves of COVID-19, which have been observed in many countries, mathematical modeling and forecasting of COVID-19 are still necessary as long as the world continues to battle against the pandemic. Modeling may aid in determining which interventions to try or predict future growth patterns. In this article, we design a combined approach for analyzing any pandemic in two separate parts. In the first part of the paper, we develop a recurrent SEIRS compartmental model to predict recurrent outbreak patterns of diseases. Due to its time-varying parameters, our model is able to reflect the dynamics of infectious diseases, and to measure the effectiveness of the restrictive measures. We discuss the stable solutions of the corresponding autonomous system with frozen parameters. We focus on the regime shifts and tipping points; then we investigate tipping phenomena due to parameter drifts in our time-varying parameters model that exhibits a bifurcation in the frozen-in case. Furthermore, we propose an optimal numerical design for estimating the system’s parameters. In the second part, we introduce machine learning models to strengthen the methodology of our paper in data analysis, particularly for prediction scenarios. We use MLP, RBF, LSTM, ANFIS, and GRNN for training and evaluation of COVID-19. Then, we compare the results with the recurrent dynamical system in the fitting process and prediction scenario. We also confirm results by implementing our methods on the released data on COVID-19 by WHO for Italy, Germany, Iran, and South Africa between 1/22/2020 and 7/24/2021, when people were engaged with different variants including Alpha, Beta, Gamma, and Delta. The results of this article show that the dynamic model is adequate for long-term analysis and data fitting, as well as obtaining parameters affecting the epidemic. However, it is ineffective in providing a long-term forecast. In contrast machine learning methods effectively provide disease prediction, although they do not provide analysis such as dynamic models. Finally, some metrics, including RMSE, R-Squared, and accuracy, are used to evaluate the machine learning models. These metrics confirm that ANFIS and RBF perform better than other methods in training and testing zones.

Projection of COVID-19 Positive Cases Considering Hybrid Immunity: Case Study in Tokyo

Since the emergence of COVID-19, the forecasting of new daily positive cases and deaths has been one of the essential elements in policy setting and medical resource management worldwide. An essential factor in forecasting is the modeling of susceptible populations and vaccination effectiveness (VE) at the population level. Owing to the widespread viral transmission and wide vaccination campaign coverage, it becomes challenging to model the VE in an efficient and realistic manner, while also including hybrid immunity which is acquired through full vaccination combined with infection. Here, the VE model of hybrid immunity was developed based on an in vitro study and publicly available data. Computational replication of daily positive cases demonstrates a high consistency between the replicated and observed values when considering the effect of hybrid immunity. The estimated positive cases were relatively larger than the observed value without considering hybrid immunity. Replication of the daily positive cases and its comparison would provide useful information of immunity at the population level and thus serve as useful guidance for nationwide policy setting and vaccination strategies.

Incorporating variant frequencies data into short-term forecasting for COVID-19 cases and deaths in the USA: a deep learning approach

BACKGROUND

Since the US reported its first COVID-19 case on January 21, 2020, the science community has been applying various techniques to forecast incident cases and deaths. To date, providing an accurate and robust forecast at a high spatial resolution has proved challenging, even in the short term.

METHOD

Here we present a novel multi-stage deep learning model to forecast the number of COVID-19 cases and deaths for each US state at a weekly level for a forecast horizon of 1-4 weeks. The model is heavily data driven, and relies on epidemiological, mobility, survey, climate, demographic, and SARS-CoV-2 variant frequencies data. We implement a rigorous and robust evaluation of our model-specifically we report on weekly performance over a one-year period based on multiple error metrics, and explicitly assess how our model performance varies over space, chronological time, and different outbreak phases.

FINDINGS

The proposed model is shown to consistently outperform the CDC ensemble model for all evaluation metrics in multiple spatiotemporal settings, especially for the longer-term (3 and 4 weeks ahead) forecast horizon. Our case study also highlights the potential value of variant frequencies data for use in short-term forecasting to identify forthcoming surges driven by new variants.

INTERPRETATION

Based on our findings, the proposed forecasting framework improves upon the available state-of-the-art forecasting tools currently used to support public health decision making with respect to COVID-19 risk.

FUNDING

This work was funded the NSF Rapid Response Research (RAPID) grant Award ID 2108526 and the CDC Contract #75D30120C09570.

Detecting the most critical clinical variables of COVID-19 breakthrough infection in vaccinated persons using machine learning

Background

COVID-19 vaccines offer different levels of immune protection but do not provide 100% protection. Vaccinated persons with pre-existing comorbidities may be at an increased risk of SARS-CoV-2 breakthrough infection or reinfection. The aim of this study is to identify the critical variables associated with a higher probability of SARS-CoV-2 breakthrough infection using machine learning.

Methods

A dataset comprising symptoms and feedback from 257 persons, of whom 203 were vaccinated and 54 unvaccinated, was used for the investigation. Three machine learning algorithms - Deep Multilayer Perceptron (Deep MLP), XGBoost, and Logistic Regression - were trained with the original (imbalanced) dataset and the balanced dataset created by using the Random Oversampling Technique (ROT), and the Synthetic Minority Oversampling Technique (SMOTE). We compared the performance of the classification algorithms when the features highly correlated with breakthrough infection were used and when all features in the dataset were used.

Result

The results show that when highly correlated features were considered as predictors, with Random Oversampling to address data imbalance, the XGBoost classifier has the best performance (F1 = 0.96; accuracy = 0.96; AUC = 0.98; G-Mean = 0.98; MCC = 0.88). The Deep MLP had the second best performance (F1 = 0.94; accuracy = 0.94; AUC = 0.92; G-Mean = 0.70; MCC = 0.42), while Logistic Regression had less accurate performance (F1 = 0.89; accuracy = 0.88; AUC = 0.89; G-Mean = 0.89; MCC = 0.68). We also used Shapley Additive Explanations (SHAP) to investigate the interpretability of the models. We found that body temperature, total cholesterol, glucose level, blood pressure, waist circumference, body weight, body mass index (BMI), haemoglobin level, and physical activity per week are the most critical variables indicating a higher risk of breakthrough infection.

Conclusion

These results, evident from our unique data source derived from apparently healthy volunteers with cardiovascular risk factors, follow the expected pattern of positive or negative correlations previously reported in the literature. This information strengthens the body of knowledge currently applied in public health guidelines and may also be used by medical practitioners in the future to reduce the risk of SARS-CoV-2 breakthrough infection.

Impact of quarantine on fractional order dynamical model of Covid-19

In this paper, a Covid-19 dynamical transmission model of a coupled non-linear fractional differential equation in the Atangana-Baleanu Caputo sense is proposed. The basic dynamical transmission features of the proposed system are briefly discussed. The qualitative as well as quantitative results on the existence and uniqueness of the solutions are evaluated through the fixed point theorem. The Ulam-Hyers stability analysis of the suggested system is established. The two-step Adams-Bashforth-Moulton (ABM) numerical method is employed to find its numerical solution. The numerical simulation is performed to accesses the impact of various biological parameters on the dynamics of Covid-19 disease.

Estimation of mRNA COVID-19 Vaccination Effectiveness in Tokyo for Omicron Variants BA.2 and BA.5: Effect of Social Behavior

The variability of the COVID-19 vaccination effectiveness (VE) should be assessed with a resolution of a few days, assuming that the VE is influenced by public behavior and social activity. Here, the VE for the Omicron variants (BA.2 and BA.5) is numerically derived for Japan’s population for the second and third vaccination doses. We then evaluated the daily VE variation due to social behavior from the daily data reports in Tokyo. The VE for the Omicron variants (BA.1, BA.2, and BA.5) are derived from the data of Japan and Tokyo with a computational approach. In addition, the effect of the different parameters regarding human behavior on VE was assessed using daily data in Tokyo. The individual VE for the Omicron BA.2 in Japan was 61% (95% CI: 57–65%) for the second dose of the vaccination from our computation, whereas that for the third dose was 86% (95% CI: 84–88%). The individual BA.5 VE for the second and third doses are 37% (95% CI: 33–40%) and 63% (95% CI: 61–65%). The reduction in the daily VE from the estimated value was closely correlated to the number of tweets related to social gatherings on Twitter. The number of tweets considered here would be one of the new candidates for VE evaluation and surveillance affecting the viral transmission.