Intramyocardial microdepot injection increases the efficacy of skeletal myoblast transplantation

The Progress of Stem Cell Therapy in Myocardial-Infarcted Heart Regeneration: Cell Sheet Technology

Various tissues, including the heart, cornea, bone, esophagus, bladder and liver, have been vascularized using the cell sheet technique. It overcomes the limitations of existing techniques by allowing small layers of the cell sheet to generate capillaries on their own, and it can also be used to vascularize tissue-engineered transplants. Cell sheets eliminate the need for traditional tissue engineering procedures such as isolated cell injections and scaffold-based technologies, which have limited applicability. While cell sheet engineering can eliminate many of the drawbacks, there are still a few challenges that need to be addressed. The number of cell sheets that can be layered without triggering core ischemia or hypoxia is limited. Even when scaffold-based technologies are disregarded, strategies to tackle this problem remain a substantial impediment to the efficient regeneration of thick, living three-dimensional cell sheets. In this review, we summarize the cell sheet technology in myocardial infarcted tissue regeneration.

The Potential Properties of Natural Compounds in Cardiac Stem Cell Activation: Their Role in Myocardial Regeneration

Cardiovascular diseases (CVDs), which include congenital heart disease, rhythm disorders, subclinical atherosclerosis, coronary heart disease, and many other cardiac disorders, cause about 30% of deaths globally; representing one of the main health problems worldwide. Among CVDs, ischemic heart diseases (IHDs) are one of the major causes of morbidity and mortality in the world. The onset of IHDs is essentially due to an unbalance between the metabolic demands of the myocardium and its supply of oxygen and nutrients, coupled with a low regenerative capacity of the heart, which leads to great cardiomyocyte (CM) loss; promoting heart failure (HF) and myocardial infarction (MI). To date, the first strategy recommended to avoid IHDs is prevention in order to reduce the underlying risk factors. In the management of IHDs, traditional therapeutic options are widely used to improve symptoms, attenuate adverse cardiac remodeling, and reduce early mortality rate. However, there are no available treatments that aim to improve cardiac performance by replacing the irreversible damaged cardiomyocytes (CMs). Currently, heart transplantation is the only treatment being carried out for irreversibly damaged CMs. Hence, the discovery of new therapeutic options seems to be necessary. Interestingly, recent experimental evidence suggests that regenerative stem cell medicine could be a useful therapeutic approach to counteract cardiac damage and promote tissue regeneration. To this end, researchers are tasked with answering one main question: how can myocardial regeneration be stimulated? In this regard, natural compounds from plant extracts seem to play a particularly promising role. The present review will summarize the recent advances in our knowledge of stem cell therapy in the management of CVDs; focusing on the main properties and potential mechanisms of natural compounds in stimulating and activating stem cells for myocardial regeneration.

Use of Repeating Dispensers to Increase the Efficiency of the Intramuscular Myogenic Cell Injection Procedure

Intramuscular myoblast transplantation in humans and nonhuman primates requires precise repetitive cell injections very close to each other. Performed with syringes operated manually throughout large regions, this procedure takes a lot of time, becoming tiring and thus imprecise. We tested two repetitive dispensers with Hamilton syringes as cell injection devices to facilitate this procedure. Monkeys received intramuscular allotransplantations of β-galactosidase-labeled myoblasts, using either a monosyringe or a multisyringe repeating dispenser. The monosyringe repeating dispenser allowed performing cell injections faster and easier than with a manually operated syringe. The multisyringe dispenser accelerated the procedure still more, but it was not ergonomic. Biopsies of the myoblast-injected sites 1 month later showed abundant β-galactosidase-positive myofibers, with the same density and morphological pattern observed following myoblast transplantation with a syringe operated manually. We recommend the monosyringe repeating dispenser for myoblast transplantation in skeletal muscles and maybe in the heart.

Myoblast Therapy: From Bench to Bedside

Myoblasts are defined as stem cells containing skeletal muscle cell precursors. A decade of experimental work has revealed many properties of myoblasts, including the stability of resulting hybrid myofibers without immune suppression, the persistence of transgene expression, and the lack of tumorigenicity. Early phase clinical trials also showed that myoblast-based therapy is a promising approach for many intractable clinical conditions, including both muscle-related and non-muscle-related diseases. The potential application of myoblast therapy may be in the treatment of genetic muscle diseases, cardiomyocyte damaged heart diseases, and urinary incontinence. This review will provide an overview of myoblast biology, along with discussion of the potential application in clinical medicine. In addition, problems in current myoblast therapy and possible future improvements will be addressed.

Stem cell therapy for ischemic heart diseases

INTRODUCTION

Ischemic heart diseases, especially the myocardial infarction, is a major hazard problem to human health. Despite substantial advances in control of risk factors and therapies with drugs and interventions including bypass surgery and stent placement, the ischemic heart diseases usually result in heart failure (HF), which could aggravate social burden and increase the mortality rate. The current therapeutic methods to treat HF stay at delaying the disease progression without repair and regeneration of the damaged myocardium. While heart transplantation is the only effective therapy for end-stage patients, limited supply of donor heart makes it impossible to meet the substantial demand from patients with HF. Stem cell-based transplantation is one of the most promising treatment for the damaged myocardial tissue.

SOURCES OF DATA

Key recent published literatures and ClinicalTrials.gov.

AREAS OF AGREEMENT

Stem cell-based therapy is a promising strategy for the damaged myocardial tissue. Different kinds of stem cells have their advantages for treatment of Ischemic heart diseases.

AREAS OF CONTROVERSY

The efficacy and potency of cell therapies vary significantly from trial to trial; some clinical trials did not show benefit. Diverged effects of cell therapy could be affected by cell types, sources, delivery methods, dose and their mechanisms by which delivered cells exert their effects.

GROWING POINTS

Understanding the origin of the regenerated cardiomyocytes, exploring the therapeutic effects of stem cell-derived exosomes and using the cell reprogram technology to improve the efficacy of cell therapy for cardiovascular diseases.

AREAS TIMELY FOR DEVELOPING RESEARCH

Recently, stem cell-derived exosomes emerge as a critical player in paracrine mechanism of stem cell-based therapy. It is promising to exploit exosomes-based cell-free therapy for ischemic heart diseases in the future.

Choice of cell-delivery route for successful cell transplantation therapy for the heart

The cell-delivery route is one of the major factors influencing the therapeutic effect and complications of cell transplantation therapy for cardiac diseases. There are four major clinically practical routes, with each method having its own advantages and disadvantages. First, intramyocardial injection allows targeted cell delivery into the areas of interest, although this induces mechanical injury, inflammation and islet-like donor cell clusters, leading to limited donor cell survival and arrhythmogenicity. Second, intracoronary injection is less likely to induce inflammation, whereas poor initial cell retention in the heart is a concern. Third, intravenous injection is easy and economical, but cell recruitment into the heart is not frequent. Finally, epicardial placement of 'cell sheets' enables higher efficiency of cell engraftment, but poor integration into the myocardium may be an issue. This review summarizes up-to-date clinical and preclinical knowledge regarding these cell-delivery methods. We further discuss the ways to refine these methods towards optimizing cell transplantation therapy for the heart.

Radially branched deployment for more efficient cell transplantation at the scale of the human brain

BACKGROUND

In preclinical studies, cell transplantation into the brain has shown great promise for the treatment of a wide range of neurological diseases. However, the use of a straight cannula and syringe for cell delivery to the human brain does not approximate cell distribution achieved in animal studies. This technical deficiency may limit the successful clinical translation of cell transplantation.

OBJECTIVE

To develop a stereotactic device that effectively distributes viable cells to the human brain. Our primary aims were to (1) minimize the number of transcortical penetrations required for transplantation, (2) reduce variability in cell dosing and (3) increase cell survival.

METHODS

We developed a modular cannula system capable of radially branched deployment (RBD) of a cell delivery catheter at variable angles from the longitudinal device axis. We also developed an integrated catheter-plunger system, eliminating the need for a separate syringe delivery mechanism. The RBD prototype was evaluated in vitro and in vivo with subcortical injections into the swine brain. Performance was compared to a 20G straight cannula with dual side ports, a device used in current clinical trials.

RESULTS

RBD enabled therapeutic delivery in a precise 'tree-like' pattern branched from a single initial trajectory, thereby facilitating delivery to a volumetrically large target region. RBD could transplant materials in a radial pattern up to 2.0 cm from the initial penetration tract. The novel integrated catheter-plunger system facilitated manual delivery of small and precise volumes of injection (1.36 ± 0.13 µl per cm of plunger travel). Both dilute and highly concentrated neural precursor cell populations tolerated transit through the device with high viability and unaffected developmental potential. While reflux of infusate along the penetration tract was problematic with the use of the 20G cannula, RBD was resistant to this source of cell dose variability in agarose. RBD enabled radial injections to the swine brain when used with a modern clinical stereotactic system.

CONCLUSIONS

By increasing the total delivery volume through a single transcortical penetration in agarose models, RBD strategy may provide a new approach for cell transplantation to the human brain. Incorporation of RBD or selected aspects of its design into future clinical trials may increase the likelihood of successful translation of cell-based therapy to the human patient.

Injectable hydrogel as stem cell scaffolds from the thermosensitive terpolymer of NIPAAm/AAc/HEMAPCL

A series of biodegradable thermosensitive copolymers was synthesized by free radical polymerization with N-isopropylacrylamide (NIPAAm), acrylic acid (AAc) and macromer 2-hydroxylethyl methacrylate-poly(ɛ-caprolactone) (HEMAPCL). The structure and composition of the obtained terpolymers were confirmed by proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, while their molecular weight was measured using gel permeation chromatography. The copolymers were dissolved in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) solution (pH = 7.4) with different concentrations to prepare hydrogels. The lower critical solution temperature (LCST), cloud point, and rheological property of the hydrogels were determined by differential scanning calorimetry, ultraviolet-visible spectrometry, and rotational rheometry, respectively. It was found that LCST of the hydrogel increased significantly with the increasing NIPAAm content, and hydrogel with higher AAc/HEMAPCL ratio exhibited better storage modulus, water content, and injectability. The hydrogels were formed by maintaining the copolymer solution at 37°C. The degradation experiment on the formed hydrogels was conducted in PBS solution for 2 weeks and demonstrated a less than 20% weight loss. Scanning electron microscopy was also used to study the morphology of the hydrogel. The copolymer with NIPAAm/AAc/HEMAPCL ratio of 88:9.6:2.4 was bioconjugated with type I collagen for the purpose of biocompatibility enhancement. In-vitro cytotoxicity of the hydrogels both with and without collagen was also addressed.

Functional regeneration of ischemic myocardium by transplanted cells overexpressing stromal cell-derived factor-1 (SDF-1): intramyocardial injection versus scaffold-based application

OBJECTIVE

Stromal cell-derived factor-1 (SDF-1) is a potent chemotaxin. Increased SDF-1 levels can be found in ischemic myocardium and might protect against ischemia-reperfusion injury. We hypothesized that transplantation of stem cells overexpressing SDF-1 might improve cardiac function after myocardial infarction (MI). We compared intramyocardial injection with a scaffold-based application of SDF-1-transfected cells.

METHODS

Skeletal myoblasts (SkMs) were isolated and expanded from newborn Lewis rats. Cells were transfected with pcDNA3-huSDF-1 and seeded on polyurethane (PU) scaffolds or diluted in medium for cell injection. Two weeks after myocardial infarction, seeded scaffolds were implanted epicardially into rats (group: PU-SDF-1-SkM) or the injection solution was applied intramyocardially (Inj-SDF-1-SkM). Additional groups were treated with non-transfected myoblasts either by injection (Inj-SkM) or by scaffold-based application (PU-SkM) or received a sham operation (Sham). Before this intervention and 6 weeks later, hemodynamic parameters were measured. Infarction size and neovascularization were assessed by histology at study end.

RESULTS

In sham animals, we detected a clear decrease in systolic function from intervention to study end. In group Inj-SkM and PU-SkM, all hemodynamic parameters that were assessed remained unchanged during observation time. Systolic function as measured by dP/dt(max) and SB-Emax was significantly improved in groups Inj-SDF-1-SkM and PU-SDF-1-SkM at study end without a difference between the two SDF-1 groups. Diastolic function measured by post-interventional dP/dt(min) was also increased in group Inj-SDF-1-SkM but not in PU-SDF-1-SkM. Histological analysis revealed a reduced infarction size in all treatment groups at study end but enhanced neovascularization was not observable.

CONCLUSIONS

Transplantation of myoblasts overexpressing SDF-1 improves cardiac function after MI. The restoration of hemodynamic parameters is accompanied by a reduction in infarction size. This reverse remodeling capacity is independent of a scaffold-based application of the SDF-1-transfected cells.

Preconditioning approach in stem cell therapy for the treatment of infarcted heart

Nearly two decades of research in regenerative medicine have been focused on the development of stem cells as a therapeutic option for treatment of the ischemic heart. Given the ability of stem cells to regenerate the damaged tissue, stem-cell-based therapy is an ideal approach for cardiovascular disorders. Preclinical studies in experimental animal models and clinical trials to determine the safety and efficacy of stem cell therapy have produced encouraging results that promise angiomyogenic repair of the ischemically damaged heart. Despite these promising results, stem cell therapy is still confronted with issues ranging from uncertainty about the as-yet-undetermined "ideal" donor cell type to the nonoptimized cell delivery strategies to harness optimal clinical benefits. Moreover, these lacunae have significantly hampered the progress of the heart cell therapy approach from bench to bedside for routine clinical applications. Massive death of donor cells in the infarcted myocardium during acute phase postengraftment is one of the areas of prime concern, which immensely lowers the efficacy of the procedure. An overview of the published data relevant to stem cell therapy is provided here and the various strategies that have been adopted to develop and optimize the protocols to enhance donor stem cell survival posttransplantation are discussed, with special focus on the preconditioning approach.

Injection Parameters Affect Cell Viability and Implant Volumes in Automated Cell Delivery for the Brain

The technique of central nervous system cell implantation can affect the outcome of preclinical or clinical studies. Our goal was to evaluate the impact of various injection parameters that may be of consequence during the delivery of solute-suspended cells. These parameters included ( 1 ) the type and concentration of cells used for implantation, ( 2 ) the rate at which cells are injected (flow rate), ( 3 ) the acceleration of the delivery device, ( 4 ) the period of time between cell loading and injection into the CNS (delay), and ( 5 ) the length and gauge of the needle used to deliver the cells. Neural progenitor cells (NPCs) and bone marrow stromal cells (BMSCs) were injected an automated device. These parameters were assessed in relation to their effect on the volume of cells injected and cell viability. Longer and thinner cannulae and higher cell concentrations were detrimental for cell delivery. Devices and techniques that optimize these parameters should be of benefit.

Scaffold-based transplantation of akt1-overexpressing skeletal myoblasts: functional regeneration is associated with angiogenesis and reduced infarction size

Myoblast-based therapy can improve cardiac function after infarction and is conventionally performed by direct injection. A scaffold-based transfer could overcome injection-associated problems. In upgrading this approach we transplanted skeletal myoblasts (SkM) overexpressing the prosurvival gene Akt1. SkM were transfected with pcDNA3-huda-Akt1 and seeded on polyurethane scaffolds. These scaffolds were transplanted in rats 2 weeks after myocardial infarction. Hemodynamics were analyzed before therapy and 6 weeks later. Infarction size and capillary density were performed thereafter. Additional groups received injections of Akt1-transfected or untransfected myoblasts, scaffolds seeded with untransfected myoblasts, or sham operation. Deterioration of global systolic left ventricular function could be inhibited by all therapeutic approaches. In addition, transplantation of Akt1-transfected cells, either scaffold-based or injected, was superior with regard to systolic properties of the left ventricular wall. This effect was accompanied by smaller infarction sizes and angiogenesis. Scaffolds with untransfected myoblasts yielded also smaller infarctions than injections of untransfected myoblasts. Both Akt groups profited with regard to dP/dt(min). In contrast, other diastolic parameters pointed at impaired relaxation and stiffer myocardium especially in the Akt1-scaffold group. In conclusion, SkM overexpressing Akt1 can maintain myocardial function after infarction, reduce infarction size, and induce neovascularization. Scaffold-based cell transfer does not augment this reverse remodeling capacity.

Manual vs automated delivery of cells for transplantation: accuracy, reproducibility, and impact on viability

BACKGROUND

Cellular transplantation holds promise for the management of a variety of neurological disorders. However, there is great variability in cell type, preparation methods, and implantation technique, which are crucial to clinical outcomes.

OBJECTIVE

We compared manual injection with automated injection using a prototype device to determine the possible value of a mechanized delivery system.

METHODS

Neural progenitor cells and bone marrow stromal cells were injected using manual or automated methods. Consistency of injection volumes and cell number and viability were evaluated immediately or 1 day after injection.

RESULTS

When cells were delivered as a series of 3 manual injections from the same syringe, the variation in fluid volume was greater than for single manual injections. Automated delivery of a series of 3 injections resulted in a lower variability in the amount of delivery than manual injection for both cell lines (1.2%-2.6% coefficient of variability for automated delivery vs 4.3%-24.0% for manual delivery). The amount delivered from injection 1 to injection 3 increased significantly with manual injections, whereas the amount injected did not vary over the 3 injections for the automated unit. Cell viability 1 day after injection was typically 30% to 40% of the value immediately after injection for the bone marrow stromal cells and 30% to 70% for the neural progenitor cells. There were no significant differences in viability attributed to the method of injection.

CONCLUSION

The automated delivery device led to enhanced consistency of volumetric cell delivery but did not improve cell viability in the methods tested. Automated techniques could be useful in standardizing reproducible procedures for cell transplantation and improve both preclinical and clinical research.

Skeletal myoblasts for cardiac repair

Stem cells provide an alternative curative intervention for the infarcted heart by compensating for the cardiomyocyte loss subsequent to myocardial injury. The presence of resident stem and progenitor cell populations in the heart, and nuclear reprogramming of somatic cells with genetic induction of pluripotency markers are the emerging new developments in stem cell-based regenerative medicine. However, until safety and feasibility of these cells are established by extensive experimentation in in vitro and in vivo experimental models, skeletal muscle-derived myoblasts, and bone marrow cells remain the most well-studied donor cell types for myocardial regeneration and repair. This article provides a critical review of skeletal myoblasts as donor cells for transplantation in the light of published experimental and clinical data, and indepth discussion of the advantages and disadvantages of skeletal myoblast-based therapeutic intervention for augmentation of myocardial function in the infarcted heart. Furthermore, strategies to overcome the problems of arrhythmogenicity and failure of the transplanted skeletal myoblasts to integrate with the host cardiomyocytes are discussed.

A new direction for cardiac regeneration therapy: application of synergistically acting epicardium-derived cells and cardiomyocyte progenitor cells

BACKGROUND

Adult human epicardium-derived cells (EPDCs), transplanted into the infarcted heart, are known to improve cardiac function, mainly through paracrine protection of the surrounding tissue. We hypothesized that this effect might be further improved if these supportive EPDCs were combined with cells that could possibly supply the ischemic heart with new cardiomyocytes. Therefore, we transplanted EPDCs together with cardiomyocyte progenitor cells that can generate mature cardiomyocytes in vitro.

METHODS AND RESULTS

EPDCs and cardiomyocyte progenitor cells were isolated from human adult atrial appendages, expanded in culture, and transplanted separately or together into the infarcted mouse myocardium (total cell number, 4x10(5)). Cardiac function was determined 6 weeks later (9.4T MRI). Coculturing increased proliferation rate and production of several growth factors, indicating a mutual effect. Cotransplantation resulted in further improvement of cardiac function compared with single cell-type recipients (P<0.05), which themselves demonstrated better function than vehicle-injected controls (P<0.05). However, in contrast to our hypothesis, no graft-derived cardiomyocytes were observed within the 6-week survival, supporting that not only EPDCs but also cardiomyocyte progenitor cells acted in a paracrine manner. Because injected cell number and degree of engraftment were similar between groups, the additional functional improvement in the cotransplantation group cannot be explained by an increased amount of secreted factors but rather by an altered type of secretion.

CONCLUSIONS

EPDCs and cardiomyocyte progenitor cells synergistically improve cardiac function after myocardial infarction, probably instigated by complementary paracrine actions. Our results demonstrate for the first time that synergistically acting cells hold great promise for future clinical regeneration therapy.

Transvenous intramyocardial cellular delivery increases retention in comparison to intracoronary delivery in a porcine model of acute myocardial infarction

BACKGROUND

Clinical trials using intracoronary (IC) delivery of cells have addressed efficacy but the optimal delivery technique is unknown. Our study aimed to determine whether transvenous intramyocardial (TVIM) approach was advantageous for cellular retention in AMI.

METHODS

Domestic pigs (n = 4) underwent catheterization with coronary angiography and ventriculography prior to infarction and pre- and post-cells. Pigs underwent 90-minute balloon occlusion of the left anterior descending artery (LAD). After one week they were prepared for IC (n = 2) or TVIM (n = 2) delivery of bone marrow mononuclear cells (MNC) labeled with GFP. IC infusion used an over-the-wire catheter to engage the LAD and balloon inflation to prevent retrograde flow. Venography via the coronary sinus was used for TVIM delivery. The anterior interventricular vein was engaged with a guidewire allowing use of the TransAccess catheter that is outfitted with an ultrasound tip for visualization. Animals were sacrificed one hour after delivery and tissue was analyzed.

RESULTS

Procedures were performed without complication and monitoring was uneventful. 1 x 10(8) MNC were isolated from each bone marrow (BM) preparation and 1 x 10(7) MNC delivered. Ventriculography at one week revealed wall motion abnormalities consistent with an anterior AMI. TVIM and IC delivery revealed mean 452 cells per section and 235 cells per section on average, respectively, in the infarct zone (P = 0.01).

CONCLUSION

We have demonstrated that TVIM approach for cell delivery is feasible and safe. Moreover, this approach may provide an advantage over IC infusion in retention of the cellular product; however, larger studies will be necessary.

Choice of cell-delivery route for skeletal myoblast transplantation for treating post-infarction chronic heart failure in rat

BACKGROUND

Intramyocardial injection of skeletal myoblasts (SMB) has been shown to be a promising strategy for treating post-infarction chronic heart failure. However, insufficient therapeutic benefit and occurrence of ventricular arrhythmias are concerns. We hypothesised that the use of a retrograde intracoronary route for SMB-delivery might favourably alter the behaviour of the grafted SMB, consequently modulating the therapeutic effects and arrhythmogenicity.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Three weeks after coronary artery ligation in female wild-type rats, 5x10(6) GFP-expressing SMB or PBS only (control) were injected via either the intramyocardial or retrograde intracoronary routes. Injection of SMB via either route similarly improved cardiac performance and physical activity, associated with reduced cardiomyocyte-hypertrophy and fibrosis. Grafted SMB via either route were only present in low numbers in the myocardium, analysed by real-time PCR for the Y-chromosome specific gene, Sry. Cardiomyogenic differentiation of grafted SMB was extremely rare. Continuous ECG monitoring by telemetry revealed that only intramyocardial injection of SMB produced spontaneous ventricular tachycardia up to 14 days, associated with local myocardial heterogeneity generated by clusters of injected SMB and accumulated inflammatory cells. A small number of ventricular premature contractions with latent ventricular tachycardia were detected in the late-phase of SMB injection regardless of the injection-route.

CONCLUSION

Retrograde intracoronary injection of SMB provided significant therapeutic benefits with attenuated early-phase arrhythmogenicity in treating ischaemic cardiomyopathy, indicating the promising utility of this route for SMB-delivery. Late-phase arrhythmogenicity remains a concern, regardless of the delivery route.

Stem cells and cardiac repair: a critical analysis

Utilizing stem cells to repair the damaged heart has seen an intense amount of activity over the last 5 years or so. There are currently multiple clinical studies in progress to test the efficacy of various different cell therapy approaches for the repair of damaged myocardium that were only just beginning to be tested in preclinical animal studies a few years earlier. This rapid transition from preclinical to clinical testing is striking and is not typical of the customary timeframe for the progress of a therapy from bench-to-bedside. Doubtless, there will be many more trials to follow in the upcoming years. With the plethora of trials and cell alternatives, there has come not only great enthusiasm for the potential of the therapy, but also great confusion about what has been achieved. Cell therapy has the potential to do what no drug can: regenerate and replace damaged tissue with healthy tissue. Drugs may be effective at slowing the progression of heart failure, but none can stop or reverse the process. However, tissue repair is not a simple process, although the idea on its surface is quite simple. Understanding cells, the signals that they respond to, and the keys to appropriate survival and tissue formation are orders of magnitude more complicated than understanding the pathways targeted by most drugs. Drugs and their metabolites can be monitored, quantified, and their effects correlated to circulating levels in the body. Not so for most cell therapies. It is quite difficult to measure cell survival except through ex vivo techniques like histological analysis of the target organ. This makes the emphasis on preclinical research all the more important because it is only in the animal studies that research has the opportunity to readily harvest the target tissues and perform the detailed analyses of what has happened with the cells. This need for detailed and usually time-intensive research in animal studies stands in contrast to the rapidity with which therapies have progressed to the clinic. It is now becoming clear through a number of notable examples that progress to the clinic may have occurred too quickly, before adequate testing and independent verification of results could be completed (Check, Nature 446:485-486, 2007; Chien, J Clin Investig 116:1838-1840, 2006; Giles, Nature 442:344-347, 2006). Broad reproducibility and transfer of results from one lab to another has been and always will be essential for the successful application of any cell therapy. So, what is the prognosis for cell therapy to repair heart damage? Will there be an approved cell therapy, or multiple ones, or will it require combinations of more than one cell type to be successful? These are questions often asked. The answers are difficult to know and even more difficult to predict because there are so many variables associated with cell-based therapies. There is much about the biology of cell systems that we still do not understand. Much of the pluripotency or transdifferentiation phenomena (see below) being observed go against accepted and well-tested principles for cell development and fate choice, and has caused a reevaluation of long-accepted theories. Clearly, new pathways for tissue repair and regeneration have been uncovered, but will these new pathways be sufficient to effect significant tissue repair and regeneration? Despite the false starts so far, there is the strong likelihood one or possibly multiple cell therapies will succeed. Clearly, important information has been gained, which should better guide the field to achieving success. When there is the successful verification in patients of a cell therapy, there will be an explosion of technological advances around the approach(es) that succeed. Whatever cells get approved accompanying them will be: more effective delivery methods; growth and storage methods; combination therapies, mixes of cells or cells + gene therapies; combinations with biomaterials and technologies for immune protection, allowing allografting. There are many parallel paths of technology development waiting to be brought together once there is an effective cellular approach. The coming years will no doubt bring some exciting developments.

Association between a cell-seeded collagen matrix and cellular cardiomyoplasty for myocardial support and regeneration

The objective of cellular cardiomyoplasty is to regenerate the myocardium using implantation of living cells. Because the extracellular myocardial matrix is deeply altered in ischemic cardiomyopathies, it could be important to create a procedure aiming at regenerating both myocardial cells and the extracellular matrix. We evaluated the potential of a collagen matrix seeded with cells and grafted onto infarcted ventricles. A myocardial infarction was created in 45 mice using coronary artery ligation. Animals were randomly assigned to 4 local myocardial treatment groups. Group I underwent sham treatment (injection of cell culture medium). Group II underwent injection of human umbilical cord blood mononuclear cells (HUCBCs). Group III underwent injection of HUCBCs and fixation onto the epicardium of a collagen matrix seeded with HUCBCs. Group IV underwent fixation of collagen matrix (without cells) onto the infarct. Echocardiography was performed on postoperative days 7 and 45, followed by histological studies. Echocardiography showed that the association between the cell-loaded matrix and the intrainfarct cell implants was the most efficient approach to limiting postischemic ventricular dilation and remodeling. Ejection fraction improved in both cell-treated groups. The collagen matrix alone did not improve left ventricular (LV) function and remodeling. Histology in Group III showed fragments of the collagen matrix thickening and protecting the infarct scars. Segments of the matrix were consistently aligned along the LV wall, and cells were assembled within the collagen fibers in large populations. Intramyocardial injection of HUCBCs preserves LV function following infarction. The use of a cell-seeded matrix combined with cell injections prevents ventricular wall thinning and limits postischemic remodeling. This tissue engineering approach seems to improve the efficiency of cellular cardiomyoplasty and could emerge as a new therapeutic tool for the prevention of adverse remodeling and progressive heart failure.

Ischemic central necrosis in pockets of transplanted myoblasts in nonhuman primates: implications for cell-transplantation strategies

BACKGROUND

Several cell-transplantation strategies implicate the injection of cells into tissues. Avascular accumulations of implanted cells are then formed. Because the diffusion of oxygen and nutrients from the surrounding tissue throughout the implanted cell accumulations may be limited, central ischemic necrosis could develop. We analyzed this possibility after myoblast transplantation in nonhuman primates.

METHODS

Macaca monkeys were injected intramuscularly with different amounts of myoblasts per single site. These sites were sampled 1 hr later and at posttransplantation days 1, 3, 5, and 7 and analyzed by histological techniques.

RESULTS

One day posttransplantation, the largest pockets of implanted cells showed cores of massive necrosis. The width of the peripheral layer of living cells was approximately 100-200 microm. We thus analyzed the relationship between the amount of myoblasts injected per site and the volume of ischemic necrosis. Delivering 0.1 x 10(6) and 0.3 x 10(6) myoblasts did not produce ischemic necrosis; pockets of 1 x 10(6), 3 x 10(6), 10 x 10(6), and 20 x 10(6) myoblasts exhibited, respectively, a mean of 2%, 9%, 41%, and 59% of central necrosis. Intense macrophage infiltration took place in the muscle, invading the accumulations of necrotic cells and eliminating them by posttransplantation days 5 to 7.

CONCLUSIONS

The desire to create more neoformed tissue by delivering more cells per injection site is confronted with the fact that the acute survival of the implanted cells is restricted to the peripheral layer that can profit of the diffusion of oxygen and nutriments from the surrounding recipient's tissue.

Stem Cell Therapy: A Hope for Dying Hearts

The restoration of functional myocardium following heart failure still remains a formidable challenge among researchers. Irreversible damage caused by myocardial infarction is followed by left ventricular remodeling. The current pharmacologic and interventional strategies fail to regenerate dead myocardium and are usually insufficient to meet the challenge caused by necrotic cardiac myocytes. There is growing evidence, suggesting that the heart has the ability to regenerate through the activation of resident cardiac stem cells or through the recruitment of a stem cell population from other tissues such as bone marrow. These new findings belie the earlier conception about the poor regenerating ability of myocardial tissue. Stem cell therapy is a promising new approach for myocardial repair. However, it has been limited by the paucity of cell sources for functional human cardiomyocytes. Moreover, cells isolated from different sources exhibit idiosyncratic characteristics including modes of isolation, ease of expansion in culture, proliferative ability, characteristic markers, etc., which are the basis for several technical manipulations to achieve successful engraftment. Clinical trials show some evidence for the successful integration of stem cells of extracardiac origin in adult human heart with an improved functional outcome. This may be attributed to the discrepancies in the methods of detection, study subject selection (early or late post transplantation), presence of inflammation, and false identification of infiltrating leukocytes. This review discusses these issues in a comprehensive manner so that their physiological significance in animal as well as in human studies can be better understood.

Direct intramyocardial but not intracoronary injection of bone marrow cells induces ventricular arrhythmias in a rat chronic ischemic heart failure model

BACKGROUND

Therapeutic efficacy of bone marrow (BM) cell injection for treating ischemic chronic heart failure has not been established. In addition, experimental data are lacking on arrhythmia occurrence after BM cell injection. We hypothesized that therapeutic efficacy and arrhythmia occurrence induced by BM cell injection may be affected by the cell delivery route.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Three weeks after left coronary artery ligation, wild-type female rats were injected with 1x10(7) mononuclear BM cells derived from green fluorescent protein-transgenic male rats through either a direct intramyocardial or a retrograde intracoronary route. Both intramyocardial and intracoronary injection of BM cells demonstrated similar improvement in left ventricular ejection fraction measured by echocardiography and a similar graft size analyzed by real-time polymerase chain reaction for the Y chromosome-specific Sry gene. Noticeably, intramyocardial injection of BM cells induced frequent ventricular premature contractions (108+/-73 per hour at 7 days after BM cell injection), including multiform, consecutive ventricular premature contractions and ventricular tachycardia for the initial 14 days; intracoronary injection of BM cells and intramyocardial injection of phosphate-buffered saline rarely induced arrhythmias. Immunohistochemistry demonstrated that intramyocardial BM cell injection formed distinct cell clusters containing donor-derived cells and accumulated host-derived inflammatory cells in the infarct border zone, whereas intracoronary BM cell injection provided more homogeneous donor cell dissemination with less inflammation and without disrupting the native myocardial structure.

CONCLUSIONS

BM cell injection is able to improve cardiac function in ischemic chronic heart failure but has a risk of arrhythmia occurrence when the intramyocardial route is used. Such arrhythmias may be prevented by using the intracoronary route.

Comparison of intracardiac cell transplantation: autologous skeletal myoblasts versus bone marrow cells

An increasing number of patients living with cardiovascular disease (CVD) and still unacceptably high mortality created an urgent need to effectively treat and prevent disease-related events. Within the past 5 years, skeletal myoblasts (SKMBs) and bone marrow (or blood)-derived mononuclear cells (BMNCs) have demonstrated preclinical efficacy in reducing ischemia and salvaging already injured myocardium, and in preventing left ventricular (LV) remodeling, respectively. These findings have been translated into clinical trials, so far totaling over 200 patients for SKMBs and over 800 patients for BMNCs. These safety/feasibility and early phase II studies showed promising but somewhat conflicting symptomatic and functional improvements, and some safety concerns have arisen. However, the patient population, cell type, dose, time and mode of delivery, and outcome measures differed, making comparisons problematic. In addition, the mechanisms through which cells engraft and deliver their beneficial effects remain to be fully elucidated. It is now time to critically evaluate progress made and challenges encountered in order to select not only the most suitable cells for cardiac repair but also to define appropriate patient populations and outcome measures. Reiterations between bench and bedside will increase the likelihood of cell therapy success, reduce the time to development of combined of drug- and cell-based disease management algorithms, and offer these therapies to patients to achieve a greater reduction of symptoms and allow for a sustained improvement of quality of life.