Management of urethral caruncle – A systematic review of the current literature

Nonneurogenic female bladder outlet obstruction: Conservative and medical management

INTRODUCTION

In nonneurogenic female bladder outlet obstruction (BOO), management goals include reduction of outlet resistance to increase urinary outflow and improve bladder voiding to prevent or reduce lower and upper urinary tract (LUT and UUT) function deterioration, by correcting the underlying etiology. As significant progress has been achieved in the conservative and pharmacological management of nonneurogenic female BOO, the purpose of this article is to review and summarize the current literature.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

For this narrative review, a PubMed® search was performed by cross-referencing the keywords "female bladder outlet obstruction," "female voiding dysfunction," "conservative management," "pharmacological management," and "treatment" with various terms related to the management of female BOO. Clinical practice guidelines and landmark reviews from the most renowned experts in the field were also used.

MANAGEMENT

This review discusses and summarizes the conservative and pharmacological management of nonneurogenic female BOO based on the most relevant data currently available in the literature.

CONCLUSION

The recent advances in the understanding of underlying mechanisms involved in female BOO allow for more individualized management. Conservative and pharmacological options show interesting outcomes, particularly in the context of a functional cause of BOO. Overall, the level of evidence is still low regarding the use of conservative and pharmacological measures and more long-term data are required.

Surgical management of bladder outlet obstruction due to functional and anatomical etiologies in women

INTRODUCTION

Bladder outlet obstruction (BOO) in women includes functional and anatomic etiologies. Primary bladder neck obstruction (PBNO), Fowler's syndrome (FS), and dysfunctional voiding (DV) are some examples of functional obstructions, whereas pelvic organ prolapse (POP), periurethral masses, and intragenic causes are some of the anatomic causes.

METHODS

This literature review describes the etiologies of female BOO, unique aspects of the workup and diagnosis, and the data for the standard surgical treatments and newer surgical techniques to treat women. Urethral stenosis and sling-related obstruction are treated in the other articles of this series. Where possible the focus is the efficacy and outcomes.

RESULTS

Treatment of PBNO using a transurethral incision of the bladder neck and injection of botulinum toxin in the bladder neck decreases the BOO. After the failure of conservative approaches, sacral neuromodulation (SNM) is effective for FS, while DV may benefit from SNM or botulinum toxin injections. Concerning POP, most surgeries have been reported to significantly improve a pre-existent BOO but the level of evidence is low. Benign urethral and periurethral masses may provoke BOO, and surgical excision usually resolves this condition.

CONCLUSION

Although most surgical treatments of BOO for functional and benign anatomical etiologies in women seem to be effective, data are scarce even for more common conditions like POP. Further studies are required to give better advice on the choice of surgical technique for these patients.

Case report of an unusual presentation of a urethral caruncle

INTRODUCTION

Urethral caruncle is a benign lesion located at the urethral meatus, predominantly affecting postmenopausal women. Though often asymptomatic, it can sometimes present with symptoms that significantly impact the patient's quality of life. Diagnosis is usually straightforward based on physical examination. However, in some cases where there is diagnostic uncertainty or suspicion of malignancy, additional investigations may be necessary.

CLINICAL PRESENTATION

We present the case of a 59-year-old postmenopausal woman who reported urinary frequency and painful micturition persisting for two years. The patient also experienced a bulging sensation in the vaginal area, described as a feeling of a foreign body. Upon physical examination, a soft, protruding red mass surrounding the urethral meatus was observed, prompting further investigations due to its unusual appearance.

DISCUSSION

Urethral caruncles are almost exclusively found in postmenopausal women. Often asymptomatic, they can cause bleeding, dysuria, or obstructive symptoms. The exact cause is unclear, but decreased estrogen post-menopause is a significant factor. Diagnosis typically involves physical examination, with biopsy needed if malignancy is suspected. Treatment is usually conservative, though surgical removal may be necessary for symptomatic or large lesions, with recurrence rates between 3.3 % and 12.5 %.

CONCLUSION

Urethral caruncles are the most prevalent benign urethral lesions in postmenopausal women. The variability in clinical presentation and the risk of misdiagnosis highlight the need for thorough clinical evaluation and individualized treatment strategies.

Ultrasonographic features of female urethral caruncle: a retrospective study of 20 patients

Female urethral caruncle is the most common urethral mass in postmenopausal women, yet there is a lack of studies on its imaging. The aim of this study was to provide a summary of the clinical and ultrasound features as well as the precise location of female urethral caruncle. This study reviewed the clinical and ultrasonographic records of 20 consecutive women with pathologically confirmed urethral caruncle. Data on patient demographics, symptoms, and transperineal and transrectal ultrasound imaging features, including location, shape, margin, size, blood flow, and inner echo of the caruncle, were extracted. Each patient presented with only one mass at the urethral meatus. Most caruncles were located on the posterior lip (75%) of the urethra, presenting as oval (80%), mixed-echoic (50%), or hypo-echoic (40%) nodules with abundant linear (40%) or dendritic (60%) blood flow. The average distance between the bladder neck and the cranial end of the masses was 28 mm. Hyper-echogenic spots, cystic echo areas, and macrocalcifications were detected in thirteen caruncles (70%). This study shows that transperineal combined with transrectal ultrasound can be used to assess female urethral caruncle, and its relative location to the urethra can be accurately described, which is helpful for surgeons making preoperative localization and conversations.

Urethral Caruncle in Pediatrics: A Northern Tanzania Experience

Urethral caruncles are the most frequent benign tumors of the female urethra. Most of them are found in postmenopausal women, and they are rare in childhood. Only a few pediatric cases have been published in the literature. In this report, we present a case series of three pediatric patients with a urethral caruncle.

Evaluation and management of urethral and periurethral masses in women

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Female periurethral masses are an uncommon occurrence. The purpose of this review is to describe etiologies of female urethral and periurethral masses and to provide an update on diagnosis and management.

RECENT FINDINGS

The most common causes of periurethral and urethral masses in women are urethral caruncles, urethral diverticula, and Skene's gland cysts. Urethral meatal lesions such as urethral caruncles and prolapse can be managed conservatively with topical estrogen therapy and close follow-up or should be excised in the setting of thrombosis, significant or recurrent bleeding, acute urinary retention, or persistent pain. Benign periurethral gland masses, such as Skene's gland cysts, Gartner's duct cysts, and Mullerian duct cysts, remain rare. Recent case series reveal a high rate of surgical management of these lesions with few complications. Urethral malignancy or malignant transformation of benign etiologies are even rarer but can be aggressive in nature and should be treated promptly.

SUMMARY

Nonspecific urinary and vaginal symptoms as well as similar physical presentations make diagnosis of urethral and periurethral lesions in females difficult. Magnetic resonance imaging is useful for differentiation of periurethral masses. The decision for conservative or surgical management is typically guided by patient symptom bother, as well as concern for urethral malignancy.

Angiomatous Urethral Caruncle After Ureteroscopy: A Case Report

Urethral caruncle is a rare condition. Although relatively common in postmenopausal women, its occurrence after a urological endoscopic procedure is unusual. Here, we report the case of a postmenopausal woman who presented with a symptomatic urethral caruncle two weeks after a ureteroscopy for a right ureteral calculus. Treatment consisted of surgical excision of the mass after the failure of local estrogen application, and the postoperative aesthetic and functional result was satisfactory. Through a review of the literature, the etiological, diagnostic, and therapeutic aspects of this pathology will be discussed.

[Surgical treatment of urethral prolapse]

Urethral prolapses in humans are rare. Urethral caruncula are more frequent. Caruncula originate from the dorsal external layer of the urethral meatus. We report on the surgical approach used for the resection of a huge urethral prolapse in a postmenopausal woman with chronic constipation using the four-quadrants resection technique. After the procedure, the patient was quickly relieved from pain and micturition was improved. The patient was fully continent. Alternative treatments to surgical resection include conservative approaches with sitz baths and oestrogen cremes, manual reduction under general anaesthesia and ligation of the prolapse around a transurethral bladder catheter.

The ultrasonographic characteristics of female periurethral solid masses

INTRODUCTION AND HYPOTHESIS

Studies on the imaging of female periurethral masses are sparse, and most are focused on cystic lesions. In this article, we studied female periurethral solid masses and reported their ultrasonographic features.

METHODS

Fifteen women with periurethral solid masses pathologically diagnosed between January 2008 and April 2021 were assessed.

RESULTS

Each patient had only one mass. The pathological types included urethral caruncle (5 patients), urethral leiomyoma (3 patients), urethral malignant tumor (MT) (3 patients), periurethral spindle tumor (3 patients) and cartilage necrosis of pubic symphysis (PS) (1 patient). On ultrasound, all urethral caruncles were located at the urethral meatus. They were hypoechoic/isoechoic and rich in blood flow signal. Each leiomyoma presented as a well-defined hypoechoic mass with an oval shape. The urethral MT had inhomogeneous/isoechoic echoes, with medium to abundant blood flow signal. The spindle cell tumors had regular/irregular shapes, moderate/high density echogenicity and little/rich blood flow signals. The articular cartilage necrosis of PS was regular in shape, with mixed echogenicity and no blood flow.

CONCLUSIONS

Ultrasound imaging is a convenient and useful method to evaluate the morphological characteristics of female periurethral solid masses.

Urethral bulking agent found in a urethral caruncle which did not respond to topical oestrogens: A case report

Background

Urethral caruncles are lesions occurring at the urethral orifice, around the posterior lip of the urethra. They are the most common benign growth of the female urethra. They are often asymptomatic and found incidentally on clinical examination. When symptomatic they commonly present with bleeding. Treatment includes vaginal oestrogens or, failing that, surgical excision. We present an unusual finding after excision of a urethral caruncle.

Case

A patient with a background of stress urinary incontinence had numerous pelvic surgeries, including colposuspension, tension-free vaginal tape (TVT) and Macroplastique (a urethral bulking agent). She developed bleeding from a 3 cm urethral caruncle, which did not improve with vaginal oestrogens. She proceeded to have a surgical excision of the caruncle. Histology revealed a foreign material with surrounding foreign-body-type multinucleate giant cell reaction. The material was compatible with Macroplastique.

Conclusion

This case report describes an unusual and unexpected histological finding. Macroplastique is injected in the urethra, 10–15 mm from the bladder neck. We suspect the caruncle dragged the Macroplastique material out through the urethral meatus. If urethral caruncles are not adequately treated with vaginal oestrogens, surgery should be considered.

•

Urethral caruncles are lesions occurring at the urethral orifice, around the posterior lip of the urethra

•

They are the most common benign growths of the female urethra

•

When symptomatic they commonly present with bleeding.

•

Treatment includes topical oestrogens or failing that, surgical excision.

•

The presence of a urethral bulking agent in a caruncle, which did not respond to topical oestrogen, is reported.