Re-analysis of the 18S rRNA gene phylogeny of the ciliate class Colpodea

Interpreting phylogenetic placements for taxonomic assignment of environmental DNA

Taxonomic assignment of operational taxonomic units (OTUs) is an important bioinformatics step in analyzing environmental sequencing data. Pairwise alignment and phylogenetic-placement methods represent two alternative approaches to taxonomic assignments, but their results can differ. Here we used available colpodean ciliate OTUs from forest soils to compare the taxonomic assignments of VSEARCH (which performs pairwise alignments) and EPA-ng (which performs phylogenetic placements). We showed that when there are differences in taxonomic assignments between pairwise alignments and phylogenetic placements at the subtaxon level, there is a low pairwise similarity of the OTUs to the reference database. We then showcase how the output of EPA-ng can be further evaluated using GAPPA to assess the taxonomic assignments when there exist multiple equally likely placements of an OTU, by taking into account the sum over the likelihood weights of the OTU placements within a subtaxon, and the branch distances between equally likely placement locations. We also inferred the evolutionary and ecological characteristics of the colpodean OTUs using their placements within subtaxa. This study demonstrates how to fully analyze the output of EPA-ng, by using GAPPA in conjunction with knowledge of the taxonomic diversity of the clade of interest.

Ciliate Morpho-Taxonomy and Practical Considerations before Deploying Metabarcoding to Ciliate Community Diversity Surveys in Urban Receiving Waters

Disentangling biodiversity and community assembly effects on ecosystem function has always been an important topic in ecological research. The development and application of a DNA metabarcoding method has fundamentally changed the way we describe prokaryotic communities and estimate biodiversity. Compared to prokaryotes (bacteria and archaea), the eukaryotic microbes (unicellular eukaryotes) also fulfill extremely important ecological functions in different ecosystems regarding their intermediate trophic positions. For instance, ciliated microbes (accounting for a substantial portion of the diversity of unicellular eukaryotes) perform pivotal roles in microbial loops and are essential components in different ecosystems, especially in water purification processes. Therefore, the community composition of ciliated species has been widely utilized as a proxy for water quality and biological assessment in urban river ecosystems and WWTPs (wastewater treatment plants). Unfortunately, investigating the dynamic changes and compositions in ciliate communities relies heavily on existing morpho-taxonomical descriptions, which is limited by traditional microscopic approaches. To deal with this dilemma, we discuss the DNA-based taxonomy of ciliates, the relative merits and challenges of deploying its application using DNA metabarcoding for surveys of ciliate community diversity in urban waterbodies, and provide suggestions for minimizing relevant sources of biases in its implementation. We expect that DNA metabarcoding could untangle relationships between community assembly and environmental changes affecting ciliate communities. These analyses and discussions could offer a replicable method in support of the application of evaluating communities of ciliated protozoa as indicators of urban freshwater ecosystems.

Insights into the phylogeny of the ciliate of class Colpodea based on multigene data

In the class Colpodea, there are many unresolved evolutionary relationships among taxa. Here, we report 30 new sequences including SSU‐rRNA, ITS1‐5.8S‐ ITS2 rRNA, and the mitochondrial small subunit ribosomal RNA (mtSSU‐rRNA) genes of five colpodeans, and conduct phylogenetic analyses based on each individual gene and a two‐gene concatenated dataset. For the first time, multi‐genes were used to analyze phylogenetic relationships in the class Colpodea. The main findings are: (1) SSU‐rRNA, ITS1‐5.8S‐ ITS2 rRNA, and mtSSU‐rRNA gene sequences of C. reniformis and C. grandis are provided for the first time, and these two species group into the clade including C. inflata, C. lucida, C. cucullus, and C. henneguyi; (2) clustering pattern and morphological similarity indicate that Bresslauides discoideus has a close relation with Colpodidae spp.; (3) Emarginatophrya genus diagnosis is improved to be ‘Hausmanniellidae with sharply shortened and isometric leftmost 1‐4 ciliary rows’ and Colpoda elliotti is transferred to Emarginatophrya; (4) the genus Colpoda is still non‐monophyletic with the addition of 10 populations from five Colpoda species sequences, but there are only two Colpoda groups left based on the present work: Group I comprises C. inflata, C. lucida, C. cucullus, C. henneguyi, C. reniformis, and C. grandis, Group II comprises C. maupasi and C. ecaudata, and the presence of diagonal grooves and the way the vestibular opens might be the two key features that differentiates Colpoda species groups; (5) a close molecular relationship, and highly similar merotelokinetal mode, somatic ciliary pattern, and basic organization of the oral apparatus with P. steinii suggests Bromeliothrix metopoides should be temporarily assigned to Colpodidae.

Study on Analysis of Several Molecular Identification Methods for Ciliates of Colpodea (Protista, Ciliophora)

The application of molecular techniques to accurately identify protozoan species can correct previous misidentifications based on traditional morphological identification. Colpodea ciliates have many toxicological and cytological applications, but their subtle morphological differences and small body size hinder species delineation. Herein, we used Cox I and β-tubulin genes, alongside fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), to evaluate each method in delineating Colpodea species. For this analysis, Colpoda harbinensis n. sp., C. reniformis, two populations of C. inflata, Colpoda compare grandis, and five populations of Paracolpoda steinii, from the soil in northeastern China, were used. We determined that (1) the Cox I gene was more suitable than the β-tubulin gene as a molecular marker for defining intra- and interspecific level relationships of Colpoda. (2) FISH probes designed for Colpoda sp., C. inflata, Colpoda compare grandis, and Paracolpoda steinii, provided rapid interspecific differentiation of Colpodea species. (3) Colpoda harbinensis n. sp. was established and mainly characterized by its size in vivo (approximately $80\times 60\mu \text{m}$ ), a reniform body in outline, one macronucleus, its spherical shape, a sometimes nonexistent micronucleus, 11–15 somatic kineties, and five or six postoral kineties. In conclusion, combining oligonucleotide probes, DNA barcoding, and morphology for the first time, we have greatly improved the delineation of Colpodea and confirmed that Cox I gene was a promising DNA barcoding marker for species of Colpodea, and FISH could provide useful morphological information as complementing traditional techniques such as silver carbonate.

When a Ciliate Meets a Flagellate: A Rare Case of Colpoda spp. and Colpodella spp. Isolated from the Urine of a Human Patient. Case Report and Brief Review of Literature

Simple Summary

In the era of new emerging diseases, particularly seen in patients with impaired immunity, it is of outmost importance to recognize unusual etiologic agents and to provide solutions regarding their treatment and prophylaxis. Our paper presents the first recorded evidence of the parasites Colpoda spp. and Colpodella spp. isolated together from the urine of a human patient. Although the patient did not experience any urinary symptoms and we discovered the parasites purely incidental, their disappearance was noticed after a combined therapy with two antibiotic drugs. In order to better understand the involvement of these two parasites in human pathology, we performed a brief review of the existing medical literature. Isolation of these parasites was recorded in different areas of the globe; however, we encountered a discrepancy in the diagnostic techniques used to identify these parasites. In medical parasitology molecular techniques provide the most accurate diagnostic but optical microscopy diagnosis, based on morphologic description of the parasites is also a useful, accessible and affordable diagnostic tool and it should not be neglected in cases involving rare parasites, where molecular diagnosis is not wildly available.

Abstract

An often-overlooked side of the population aging process and the steady rise of non-communicable diseases reflects the emergence of novel infectious pathogens on the background of an altered host immune response. The aim of this article was to present the first record of a ciliate and flagellate protozoa recovered from the urine of an elderly patient and to review the existing medical literature involving these parasites. A 70-year-old female patient was admitted for breathing difficulties on the basis of an acute exacerbation of COPD (Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease) with respiratory insufficiency. The patient reported a long history of multiple comorbidities including COPD Gold II, chronic respiratory insufficiency, chronic heart failure NYHA III (New York Heart Association Functional Classification), type 2 diabetes and morbid obesity. During routine examinations, we ascertained the presence of two unusual protozoa, a ciliate and a flagellate, in the patient’s urine samples, identified on morphological criteria to be most likely Colpoda spp. and Colpodella spp., with similarities to C. steinii and C. gonderi. The presence of these parasites was not associated with any clinical signs of urinary disease. Following a combined treatment with ceftriaxone and metronidazole, we observed the disappearance of these pathogens upon discharge from the primary care clinic. This study highlights the importance of including unusual pathogens in the differential diagnosis of cases which involve immunosuppression.

Colpodean ciliate phylogeny and reference alignments for phylogenetic placements

The Colpodea form a major clade of ciliates that are often found in environmental DNA sequencing studies. They are united by similar somatic ciliature, but differentiated by complex oral structures. Although there are four well supported colpodean subclades, there is disagreement in molecular phylogenetic inferences about their branching order. Using available nuclear SSU-rRNA sequences, we evaluated if the bursariomorphids or the platyophryids are sister to the remaining colpodeans. We inferred the "platyophryids-early" topologies using different alignment and masking methods, but constrained analyses could not reject the "bursariomorphids-early" topology. Both bursariomorphids and platyophryids clades have a similar number of nucleotide positions shared with the outgroup, and both are interconnected with the outgroup in phylogenetic networks. Based on these discordant results, it is hard to determine which clade branched off first, although the "platyophryids-early topology" is also supported by mitochondrial SSU-rRNA data. We also offer different reference alignments that can be used to phylogenetically place short- and long-read data from environmental DNA sequencing studies, and we propose some tentative evolutionary and ecological interpretations of those placements.

Conventional and organic soil management as divergent drivers of resident and active fractions of major soil food web constituents

Conventional agricultural production systems, typified by large inputs of mineral fertilizers and pesticides, reduce soil biodiversity and may negatively affect ecosystem services such as carbon fixation, nutrient cycling and disease suppressiveness. Organic soil management is thought to contribute to a more diverse and stable soil food web, but data detailing this effect are sparse and fragmented. We set out to map both the resident (rDNA) and the active (rRNA) fractions of bacterial, fungal, protozoan and metazoan communities under various soil management regimes in two distinct soil types with barley as the main crop. Contrasts between resident and active communities explained 22%, 14%, 21% and 25% of the variance within the bacterial, fungal, protozoan, and metazoan communities. As the active fractions of organismal groups define the actual ecological functioning of soils, our findings underline the relevance of characterizing both resident and active pools. All four major organismal groups were affected by soil management (p < 0.01), and most taxa showed both an increased presence and an enlarged activity under the organic regime. Hence, a prolonged organic soil management not only impacts the primary decomposers, bacteria and fungi, but also major representatives of the next trophic level, protists and metazoa.