Evaluation of an accelerated 3D SPACE sequence with compressed sensing and free-stop scan mode for imaging of the knee

Optimizing knee joint imaging: A comparative study of 7T MRI sequences

PURPOSE

To reduce long scan durations and improve patient comfort while maintaining image quality by assessing varying 7 T MRI sequences to optimize knee joint imaging.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this prospective study, healthy participants underwent knee joint scans using 7 T proton density fat-saturated (PD-FS), 3-dimensional double-echo steady-state (3D-DESS), and susceptibility-weighted imaging (SWI) sequences. We evaluated the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) of cartilage, meniscus, ligaments, synovial fluid, and adipose tissue and the imaging quality of cartilage, meniscus, and ligaments. Also, we assessed the concurrence reached by two independent evaluators using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC).

RESULTS

Twenty participants [mean age, 25.6 years ±8.4 (SD); 13 women] were evaluated. The 3D-DESS sequence demonstrated the highest SNR for cartilage, ligament, joint fluid, and meniscus structures (P < .001). It performed similarly to the PD sequence for fat but outperformed the SWI sequence. The CNR analysis revealed that 3D-DESS produced the highest contrast between joint fluid and other structures (P < .001), followed by PD-FS, whereas SWI exhibited the lowest contrast. The SWI sequence demonstrated superior CNR between ligament and fat (P < .001). The PD-FS sequence exhibited the highest CNR between cartilage and meniscus (P < .001). Both observers reported substantial concordance in their evaluations (ICC > 0.7). The cartilage visualization was excellent in all sequences, with the SWI sequence displaying slight superiority (P < .05). The ligament and meniscus images were of the highest quality when using PD-FS (P < .001).

CONCLUSION

A combination of PD-FS and 3D DESS sequences is recommended for comprehensive and comfortable 7 T MRI assessments of knee joints, ensuring detailed visualization of various vital knee structures.

3D CAIPIRINHA SPACE versus standard 2D TSE for routine knee MRI: a large-scale interchangeability study

OBJECTIVE

To perform a large-scale interchangeability study comparing 3D controlled aliasing in parallel imaging results in higher acceleration (CAIPIRINHA) sampling perfection with application optimized contrast using different flip angle evolutions (SPACE) TSE with standard 2D TSE for knee MRI.

METHODS

In this prospective study, 250 patients underwent 3 T knee MRI, including a multicontrast 3D CAIPIRINHA SPACE TSE (9:26 min) and a standard 2D TSE protocol (12:14 min). Thirty-three (13%) patients had previous anterior cruciate ligament and/or meniscus surgery. Two radiologists assessed MRIs for image quality and identified pathologies of menisci, ligaments, and cartilage by using a 4-point Likert scale according to the level of diagnostic confidence. Interchangeability of the protocols was tested under the same-reader scenario using a bootstrap percentile confidence interval. Interreader reliability and intermethod concordance were also evaluated.

RESULTS

Despite higher image quality and diagnostic confidence for standard 2D TSE compared to 3D CAIPIRINHA SPACE TSE, the protocols were found interchangeable for diagnosing knee abnormalities, except for patellar (6.8% difference; 95% CI: 4.0, 9.6) and trochlear (3.6% difference; 95% CI: 0.8, 6.6) cartilage defects. The interreader reliability was substantial to almost perfect for 2D and 3D MRI (range κ, 0.785-1 and κ, 0.725-0.964, respectively). Intermethod concordance was almost perfect for all diagnoses (range κ, 0.817-0.986).

CONCLUSION

Multicontrast 3D CAIPIRINHA SPACE TSE and standard 2D TSE protocols perform interchangeably for diagnosing knee abnormalities, except for patellofemoral cartilage defects. Despite the radiologist's preference for 2D TSE imaging, a pursuit towards time-saving 3D TSE knee MRI is justified for routine practice.

KEY POINTS

• Multicontrast 3D CAIPIRINHA SPACE and standard 2D TSE protocols perform interchangeably for diagnosing knee abnormalities, except for patellofemoral cartilage defects. • Radiologists are more confident in diagnosing knee abnormalities on 2D TSE than on 3D CAIPIRINHA SPACE TSE MRI. • Despite the radiologist's preference for 2D TSE, a pursuit towards accelerated 3D TSE knee MRI is justified for routine practice.

Super-Resolution Magnetic Resonance Imaging of the Knee Using 2-Dimensional Turbo Spin Echo Imaging

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to assess the technical feasibility of 3-dimensional (3D) super-resolution reconstruction (SRR) of 2D turbo spin echo (TSE) knee magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and to compare its image quality with conventional 3D TSE sampling perfection with application optimized contrast using different flip angle evolutions (SPACE) MRI.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Super-resolution reconstruction 2D TSE MRI and 3D TSE SPACE images were acquired from a phantom and from the knee of 22 subjects (8 healthy volunteers and 14 patients) using a clinical 3-T scanner. For SRR, 7 anisotropic 2D TSE stacks (voxel size, 0.5 × 0.5 × 2.0 mm; scan time per stack, 1 minute 55 seconds; total scan time, 13 minutes 25 seconds) were acquired with the slice stack rotated around the phase-encoding axis. Super-resolution reconstruction was performed at an isotropic high-resolution grid with a voxel size of 0.5 × 0.5 × 0.5 mm. Direct isotropic 3D image acquisition was performed with the conventional SPACE sequence (voxel size, 0.5 × 0.5 × 0.5 mm; scan time, 12 minutes 42 seconds). For quantitative evaluation, perceptual blur metrics and edge response functions were obtained in the phantom image, and signal-to-noise and contrast-to-noise ratios were measured in the images from the healthy volunteers. Images were qualitatively evaluated by 2 independent radiologists in terms of overall image quality, edge blurring, anatomic visibility, and diagnostic confidence to assess normal and abnormal knee structures. Nonparametric statistical analysis was performed, and significance was defined for P values less than 0.05.

RESULTS

In the phantom, perceptual blur metrics and edge response functions demonstrated a clear improvement in spatial resolution for SRR compared with conventional 3D SPACE. In healthy subjects, signal-to-noise and contrast-to-noise ratios in clinically relevant structures were not significantly different between SRR and 3D SPACE. Super-resolution reconstruction provided better overall image quality and less edge blurring than conventional 3D SPACE, yet the perceived image contrast was better for 3D SPACE. Super-resolution reconstruction received significantly better visibility scores for the menisci, whereas the visibility of cartilage was significantly higher for 3D SPACE. Ligaments had high visibility on both SRR and 3D SPACE images. The diagnostic confidence for assessing menisci was significantly higher for SRR than for conventional 3D SPACE, whereas there were no significant differences between SRR and 3D SPACE for cartilage and ligaments. The interreader agreement for assessing menisci was substantial with 3D SPACE and almost perfect with SRR, and the agreement for assessing cartilage was almost perfect with 3D SPACE and moderate with SRR.

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrate the technical feasibility of SRR for high-resolution isotropic knee MRI. Our SRR results show superior image quality in terms of edge blurring, but lower image contrast and fluid brightness when compared with conventional 3D SPACE acquisitions. Further contrast optimization and shortening of the acquisition time with state-of-the-art acceleration techniques are necessary for future clinical validation of SRR knee MRI.

Fast 3D Isotropic Proton Density-Weighted Fat-Saturated MRI of the Knee at 1.5 T with Compressed Sensing: Comparison with Conventional Multiplanar 2D Sequences

PURPOSE

 Compressed sensing (CS) is a method to accelerate MRI acquisition by acquiring less data through undersampling of k-space. In this prospective study we aimed to evaluate whether a three-dimensional (3D) isotropic proton density-weighted fat saturated sequence (PDwFS) with CS can replace conventional multidirectional two-dimensional (2D) sequences at 1.5 Tesla.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

 20 patients (45.2 ± 20.2 years; 10 women) with suspected internal knee damage received a 3D PDwFS with CS acceleration factor 8 (acquisition time: 4:11 min) in addition to standard three-plane 2D PDwFS sequences (acquisition time: 4:05 min + 3:03 min + 4:46 min = 11:54 min) at 1.5 Tesla. Scores for homogeneity of fat saturation, image sharpness, and artifacts were rated by two board-certified radiologists on the basis of 5-point Likert scales. Based on these ratings, an overall image quality score was generated. Additionally, quantitative contrast ratios for the menisci (MEN), the anterior (ACL) and the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) in comparison with the popliteus muscle were calculated.

RESULTS

 The overall image quality was rated superior in 3D PDwFS compared to 2D PDwFS sequences (14.45 ± 0.83 vs. 12.85 ± 0.99; p < 0.01), particularly due to fewer artifacts (4.65 ± 0.67 vs. 3.65 ± 0.49; p < 0.01) and a more homogeneous fat saturation (4.95 ± 0.22 vs. 4.55 ± 0.51; p < 0.01). Scores for image sharpness were comparable (4.80 ± 0.41 vs. 4.65 ± 0.49; p = 0.30). Quantitative contrast ratios for all measured structures were superior in 3D PDwFS (MEN: p < 0.05; ACL: p = 0.06; PCL: p = 0.33). In one case a meniscal tear was only diagnosed using multiplanar reformation of 3D PDwFS, but it would have been missed on standard multiplanar 2D sequences.

CONCLUSION

 An isotropic fat-saturated 3D PD sequence with CS enables fast and high-quality 3D imaging of the knee joint at 1.5 T and may replace conventional multiplanar 2D sequences. Besides faster image acquisition, the 3D sequence provides advantages in small structure imaging by multiplanar reformation.

KEY POINTS

  · 3D PDwFS with compressed sensing enables knee imaging that is three times faster compared to multiplanar 2D sequences. · 3D PDwFS with compressed sensing provides high-quality knee imaging at 1.5 T. · Isotropic 3D sequences provide advantages in small structure imaging by using multiplanar reformations.

CITATION FORMAT

· Endler CH, Faron A, Isaak A et al. Fast 3D Isotropic Proton Density-Weighted Fat-Saturated MRI of the Knee at 1.5 T with Compressed Sensing: Comparison with Conventional Multiplanar 2D Sequences. Fortschr Röntgenstr 2021; 193: 813 - 821.

Evaluation of an accelerated 3D modulated flip-angle technique in refocused imaging with an extended echo-train sequence with compressed sensing for imaging of the knee: comparison with routine 2D MRI sequences

AIM

To accelerate the acquisition of high-resolution magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) by using the three-dimensional (3D) matrix sequence with compressed sensing and to compare it with conventional two-dimensional (2D) proton-density (PD) and fast spin-echo (FSE) sequences.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

3D matrix, 2D FSE, and PD sequences were acquired from 68 participants using 3 T magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Two radiologists scored image quality independently on a four-point scale. The structural similarity index (SSIM), and signal- (SNRs) and contrast-to-noise ratios (CNRs) of different anatomical structures of the knee were assessed and compared between sequences using Wilcoxon signed-rank tests and Cohen's kappa.

RESULTS

The median acquisition time reduction was 44.5%. There was a substantial to perfect agreement for the rating between the 3D matrix FSE and 2D FSE or PD sequences when evaluating cartilage, subchondral bone, and ligaments (κ=0.783-872, p>0.05). The mean SSIM values between the 3D matrix FSE and 2D FSE, and between the 3D matrix PD and 2D PD sequences was 0.994 and 0.971, respectively, which are acceptable. No significant differences were found in SNR between the 3D matrix FSE and 2D FSE, and between the 3D matrix PD and 2D PD sequences, even though the SNR appeared to be higher on routine 2D sequences. The CNR of subchondral bone-meniscus, subchondral bone-joint fluid, and meniscus-joint fluid did not differentiate significantly between the 3D matrix sequence and routine 2D sequences.

CONCLUSIONS

3D matrix reduced the acquisition time in routine clinical knee MRI without the loss in image quality, SNR, and CNR.

Magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography with compressed sensing at 1.5 T: clinical application for the evaluation of branch duct IPMN of the pancreas

Objectives

To evaluate magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography (MRCP) with compressed sensing (CS) for the assessment of branch duct intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm (BD-IPMN) of the pancreas. For this purpose, conventional navigator-triggered (NT) sampling perfection with application-optimized contrast using different flip angle evolutions (SPACE) MRCP was compared with various CS-SPACE-MRCP sequences in a clinical setting.

Methods

A total of 41 patients (14 male, 27 female, mean age 68 years) underwent 1.5-T MRCP for the evaluation of BD-IPMN. The MRCP protocol consisted of the following sequences: conventional NT-SPACE-MRCP, CS-SPACE-MRCP with long (BHL, 17 s) and short single breath-hold (BHS, 8 s), and NT-CS-SPACE-MRCP. Two board-certified radiologists evaluated image quality, duct sharpness, duct visualization, lesion conspicuity, confidence, and communication with the main pancreatic duct in consensus using a 5-point scale (1–5), with higher scores indicating better quality/delineation/confidence. Maximum intensity projection reconstructions and originally acquired data were used for evaluation. Wilcoxon signed-rank test was used to compare the intra-individual difference between sequences.

Results

BHS-CS-SPACE-MRCP had the highest scores for image quality (3.85 ± 0.79), duct sharpness (3.81 ± 1.05), and duct visualization (3.81 ± 1.01). There was a significant difference compared with NT-CS-SPACE-MRCP (p < 0.05) but no significant difference to the standard NT-SPACE-MRCP (p > 0.05). Concerning diagnostic quality, BHS-CS-SPACE-MRCP had the highest scores in lesion conspicuity (3.95 ± 0.92), confidence (4.12 ± 1.08), and communication (3.8 ± 1.06), significantly higher compared with NT-SPACE-MRCP, BHL-SPACE-MRCP, and NT-CS-SPACE-MRCP (p = <0.05).

Conclusions

MRCP with CS 3D SPACE for the evaluation of BD-IPMN at 1.5 T provides the best results using a short breath-hold sequence. This approach is feasible and an excellent alternative to standard NT 3D MRCP sequences.

Key Points

• 1.5-T MRCP with compressed sensing for the evaluation of branch duct IPMN is a feasible method.

• Short breath-hold sequences provide the best results for this purpose.

Compressed Sensing MR Imaging (CS-MRI) of the Knee: Assessment of Quality, Inter-reader Agreement, and Acquisition Time

We compared 3 Tesla (3T) compressed sensing (CS)-MRI of different pulse sequences with various acceleration factors to standard fast spin-echo (FSE) sequences in terms of time, quality, and inter-reader agreement. Each sequence was qualitatively ranked and then qualitatively scored for blurring, artifact, low contrast detection, noise pattern, signal-to-noise ratio, and overall quality. The CS-MRI sequences demonstrated very good overall quality compared with routine FSE sequences with overall good inter-reader agreement.

Compressed SENSE accelerated 3D T1w black blood turbo spin echo versus 2D T1w turbo spin echo sequence in pituitary magnetic resonance imaging

PURPOSE

To compare image quality between a 2D T1w turbo spin echo (TSE) sequence and a Compressed SENSE accelerated 3D T1w black blood TSE sequence (equipped with a black blood prepulse for blood signal suppression) in pre- and postcontrast imaging of the pituitary and to assess scan time reductions.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

For this retrospective study, 56 patients underwent pituitary MR imaging at 3T. 28 patients were scanned with the 2D- and 28 patients with the accelerated 3D sequence. Two board certified neuroradiologists independently evaluated 13 qualitative image features (12 features on postcontrast- and 1 feature on precontrast images).SNR and CNR measurements were obtained. Interreader agreement was assessed with the intraclass correlation coefficient while differences in scores were assessed with exact Wilcoxon rank sum tests.

RESULTS

The interreader agreement ranged from fair (visibility of the ophthalmic nerve, ICC = 0.57) to excellent (presence and severity of pulsation artefacts, ICC = 0.97). The Compressed SENSE accelerated 3D sequence outperformed the 2D sequence in terms of "overall image quality" (median: 4 versus 3, p = 0.04) and "presence and severity of pulsation artefacts" (median: 0 versus 1, p < 0.001). There were no significant differences in any other qualitative and quantitative (SNR, CNR) image quality features. Scan time was reduced by 03:53 min (33.1%) by replacing the 2D with the 3D sequence.

CONCLUSION

The Compressed SENSE accelerated 3D T1w black blood TSE sequence is a reliable alternative for the standard 2D sequence in pituitary imaging. The black blood prepulse may aid in suppression of pulsation artefacts.