Media evaporation in a dry culture incubator; effect of dish, drop size and oil on media osmolality

The Task Matters: A Comprehensive Review and Proposed Literature Score of the Effects of Chemical and Physical Parameters on Embryo Developmental Competence

To explore the effects of chemical and physical parameters on embryo developmental competence, we conducted a systematic search on PubMed for peer-reviewed original papers using specific keywords and medical subject heading terms. Studies of interest were selected from an initial cohort of 4141 potentially relevant records retrieved. The most relevant publications were critically evaluated to identify the effect of these parameters on embryo development. Moreover, we generated a literature score (LS) using the following procedure: (i) the number of studies favoring a reference group was expressed as a fraction of all analyzed papers; (ii) the obtained fraction was multiplied by 10 and converted into a decimal number. We identified and discussed six parameters (oxygen, temperature, humidity, oil overlay, light, pH). Moreover, we generated a LS according to five different comparisons (37 °C vs. <37 °C; 5% vs. 20% oxygen; 5-2% vs. 5% oxygen; humidity conditions vs. dry conditions; light exposure vs. reduced/protected light exposure). Only two comparisons (37 °C vs. <37 °C and 5% vs. 20% oxygen) yielded a medium-high LS (8.3 and 7, respectively), suggesting a prevalence of studies in favor of the reference group (37 °C and 5% oxygen). In summary, this review and LS methodology offer semi-quantitative information on studies investigating the effects of chemical and physical parameters on embryo developmental competence.

Humidified atmosphere in a time-lapse embryo culture system does not improve ongoing pregnancy rate: a retrospective propensity score model study derived from 496 first ICSI cycles

PURPOSE

To investigate whether high relative humidity conditions (HC), when using a time-lapse system (TLS) with sequential culture media, are beneficial to embryo culture, improving ongoing pregnancy rates.

METHODS

We included patients undergoing their first ICSI cycle treatment from April 2021 to May 2022. Patients assigned to dry conditions (DC) or HC were 278 and 218, respectively. We used a GERI TLS, three chambers configured in humidity conditions and three in dry conditions. The effect of HC on ongoing pregnancy rate was assessed by the propensity matched sample, to reduce potential differences between women undergoing either HC or DC and reduce biased estimation of treatment effect.

RESULT

After adjusting for several confounding variables and applying the propensity score (PS), no significant differences were observed in the rates of normal (2PN) and abnormal (1PN and 3PN) fertilization, blastulation, top-quality blastocysts, frozen blastocysts, ongoing pregnancies, and miscarriages. The 2-cell (t2) and 4-cell (t4) stages and cell divisions between such stages occurred earlier and were more synchronous in the in DC.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that HC conditions do not improve the rate of ongoing pregnancy and several embryological outcomes, under the conditions used in this study based on a time-lapse system and sequential culture with day 3 medium change-over.

Use of mineral oil in IVF culture systems: physico-chemical aspects, management, and safety

PURPOSE

The study aims to summarize current knowledge on the use of oil in embryo culture systems, with a focus on proper management of different types of oil and possible impact on culture systems.

METHODS

PubMed was used to search the MEDLINE database for peer-reviewed English-language original articles and reviews concerning the use of oil in embryo culture systems. Searches were performed by adopting "embryo," "culture media," "oil," and "contaminants" as main terms. The most relevant publications were assessed and discussed critically.

RESULTS

Oils used in IVF are complex mixtures of straight-chain hydrocarbons, cyclic and aromatic hydrocarbons, and unsaturated hydrocarbons, whose precise composition influences their chemical and physical properties. Possible presence of contaminants suggests their storage at 4 °C in the dark to prevent peroxidation. Washing, generally performed by manufacturers prior to commercialization, may remove trace chemical contaminants. Oils reduce evaporation from culture media at rates depending on their chemical physical properties, culture system parameters, and incubator atmosphere. Contaminants - mainly metal ion and plastic components derived from refinement processes and storage - can pass to the aqueous phase of culture systems and affect embryo development.

CONCLUSIONS

Oils are essential components of culture systems. Their original quality and composition, storage, handling, and use can affect embryo development with significant efficiency and safety implications.

Factors of the human embryo culture system that may affect media evaporation and osmolality

STUDY QUESTION

Which lab-related factors impact the culture system's capacity to maintain a stable osmolality during human embryo culture?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Incubator humidity, the volume of mineral oil, the type of culture media and the design of time-lapse dishes have been identified as important parameters that can cause an impact on media evaporation and consequently osmolality during culture.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

Culture medium is a critical component in human embryo culture. Minimizing its evaporation during culture is an adequate strategy to stabilize osmolality and, as a result, improving culture conditions and clinical outcomes.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

The studied variables included media composition and supplementation; volume of mineral oil; incubator humidification; and the type of dish and incubator used. Additionally, six time-lapse dish models were compared in their ability to prevent evaporation.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

Dishes were incubated in parallel to analyze osmolality during culture between groups: synthetic oviductal medium enriched with potassium versus human tubal fluid medium; protein versus no protein supplementation; dry versus humid atmosphere; high versus low volume of mineral oil. Additionally, media evaporation was compared between six models of time-lapse dishes with distinct designs, cultured in a joint incubator. Two of them were retested in their corresponding incubator to analyze the dish-incubator fit. Daily osmolality measurements were compared between groups. Linear regression was performed to analyze evaporation rates.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

Protein supplementation did not significantly affect evaporation. Contrarily, humidity levels inside the incubators, the volume of mineral oil and the type of culture media, played an important role in osmolality stabilization. The design of time-lapse dishes and their recommended preparation protocol heavily influenced their evaporation rates, which were further altered by each incubator's characteristics. Media with initially high osmolalities had a bigger risk of reaching hypertonic levels during culture.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

While numerous, the studied variables are limited and therefore other factors could play a role in osmolality dynamics, as well. Incontrollable atmospheric factors could also result in some variation in the observed results between different centers and laboratories.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

Published literature has extensively described how hypertonic media may impair embryo development and negatively affect clinical outcomes; therefore, maintaining a stable osmolality during culture should be considered essential. This work is of interest both for embryologists when analyzing their culture system and methodologies, as well as manufacturers in charge of designing IVF consumables.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

This study was privately funded.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

N/A.

[Impact of the type of incubator (non-humidified versus humidified) on embryo culture media osmolality]

INTRODUCTION

Benchtop incubators with small individual chambers have been developed in order to improve the stability of embryo culture conditions reducing the environmental stress during the embryo development. These new dry incubators were designed without any air humidification system in order to prevent bacterial proliferation and to enable the use of time-lapse system. However, an elevated evaporation of the culture media could occur in these conditions. The main objective of the study is to analyse the impact of the used incubator type on the embryo culture media osmolality.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Microdrops of 50μL of culture media were placed in 60mm diameter culture dishes, and quickly covered with either 7 or 8mL of mineral oil in an IVF workstation with laminar airflow. Two series of culture dishes have been randomly placed either in a humidified incubator or in a dry benchtop incubator. The microdrops of each culture dishes were sampled at D0, D1, D2, D3, and D5 respectively to measure the osmolality in triplicate using a cryoscopic osmometer. The mean values of osmolality in each incubator have been compared respectively on D0, D1, D2, D3 and D5 with appropriate statistical tests, and considered statistically significant when P<0.05.

RESULTS

The osmolality of the microdrops placed in the dry benchtop incubator differed significantly after the third day of culture, regardless of the level of mineral oil in the culture dishes. Indeed, using Petri dishes covered respectively with 7 or 8mL of mineral oil, osmolality values of samples from the dry incubator were significantly higher than those from the humidified one, at D3 and D5 (D3/7mL: 273±2.1 vs. 268±1.0mOsm/kg; P=0.02; D3/8mL: 282±8.0 vs. 270±0.7mOsm/kg; P=0.04) and D5 (D5/7mL: 283±1.5 vs. 270±3.6mOsm/kg; P=0.004; D5/8mL: 287±5.6 vs. 268±2.3mOsm/kg; P=0.005). Furthermore, the analysis on paired samples showed that the osmolality in the dry benchtop incubator at D5 using 7mL of oil (283±1.5mOsm/kg; P=0.003) and at D3 (273±2.1mOsm/kg; P=0.016) and D5 (287±5.6mOsm/kg; P=0.009) using 8mL of oil was significantly higher than that measured at D0 (265±1.9mOsm/kg).

CONCLUSION

A significant increase of the embryo culture media osmolality was observed in the dry benchtop incubator with ambient hygrometry in our standard conditions. Adding 1mL of oil was not sufficient to reduce the evaporation of the media. Although maintained at a physiological level, the impact of the osmolality changes on the in vitro embryo development has to be further determined.