Clinical application of sequencing-based methods for parallel preimplantation genetic testing for mitochondrial DNA disease and aneuploidy

Profiling mitochondrial DNA variant segregation during human preimplantation development: a prerequisite to preimplantation genetic testing for mitochondrial DNA-related disorders

STUDY QUESTION

Is preimplantation genetic testing for mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) disorders (PGT-mt) feasible at early compaction and blastocyst stages?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Pathogenic mtDNA variants segregate evenly among cell types and various lineages of a given embryo during preimplantation development, supporting the relevance of genetic analyses performed on Day 4 blastomere and on Day 5 or 6 trophectoderm (TE) samples.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

PGT-mt is validated at cleavage stage (Day 3 of development). However, its feasibility at later stages is questionable, as little is known regarding the segregation of pathogenic mtDNA variants during preimplantation development. Since mtDNA replication is silenced until the blastocyst stage (Day 5 or 6), uneven mtDNA segregation between preimplantation embryo cellular lineages known as a 'bottleneck' effect, cannot be excluded, posing a challenge for PGT-mt.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

We analyzed 112 'mito' embryos carrying pathogenic mtDNA variants and 28 control embryos with mtDNA polymorphism. Heteroplasmy levels were assessed in single cells of the TE, in different parts of blastocysts (inner cell mass and TE), and at three time points of development, namely cleavage (Day 3), early compaction (Day 4), and blastocyst stages (Day 5 or 6).

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

As part of clinical PGT, a blastomere biopsy was performed at cleavage or early compaction stages (Day 3 or 4) on 112 'mito' and 21/28 control embryos. Further analysis was carried out at Day 5 or 6 on 51 embryos deemed unsuitable for uterine transfer and donated to research. Heteroplasmy levels were determined by semi-quantitative PCR amplification of (i) the mtDNA pathogenic variants with additional enzymatic digestion or (ii) the mtDNA polymorphic hypervariable region 2.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

Here, we first show that mtDNA variants segregate evenly among blastomeres during early compaction (Day 4), supporting the feasibility of PGT-mt at this stage. We also found that mtDNA ratios remain stable between cleavage and blastocyst stages. Yet, the substantial variation of heteroplasmy levels occurring among single TE cells in 1/8 embryos suggests that PGT is only feasible when at least 5-10 cells are collected by standard TE biopsy.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

This study sheds light on mtDNA segregation in human preimplantation embryo development. Its limitation lies in the scarcity of the material and the small number of embryos carrying a specific pathogenic mtDNA variant. Furthermore, the study of single cells from TE was performed on control embryos only.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

By supporting the relevance of blastocyst biopsy in the context of PGT for pathogenic mtDNA variants, this study contributes to the general trend of postponing the biopsy to later stages of embryonic development. However, particular attention should be paid to the number of TE cells tested. Due to the potential variation of mutant load during in utero development, a control amniocentesis for evolutive pregnancies following the transfer of heteroplasmic embryos is still recommended.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

This work was funded by 'Association Française contre les Myopathies/AFM Téléthon' (22112, 24317, 28525); and EUR G.E.N.E. (No. ANR-17-EURE-0013). The authors have no competing interests to declare.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

N/A.

The evolution of preimplantation genetic testing: where is the limit?

Preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) has revolutionized reproductive medicine over the past 30 years, providing a reliable method for reducing the risk of transmitting severe inherited conditions and offering the possibility of improved IVF outcomes. Today, PGT is widely accepted and integrated into fertility care in many countries around the world. Its history, however, has not been without controversy, with debate around its application to the diagnosis of late-onset disorders, conditions with incomplete penetrance and its use for embryo selection based upon human leukocyte antigen status. Nonetheless, PGT has progressively broadened its scope, and the number of embryos undergoing genetic testing continues to grow each year. Preimplantation genetic testing is most often used for the detection of chromosomal abnormalities, assisting in the identification of embryos affected by lethal aneuploidy. This application has generated the greatest debate of all, owing, in part, to difficulties delivering effective embryo testing using earlier methods. In recent years, advances in technology and rigorous validation studies have helped to improve accuracy, although variability among methods underscores the need for greater standardization and transparency. Emerging technologies, such as whole genome sequencing (WGS) and genome editing, hold promise for further advancements but introduce complex ethical, privacy and consent challenges that demand careful consideration, public engagement and thorough clinical research before implementation. Given its current trajectory, it seems likely that the use of PGT will continue to grow, offering reduced reproductive risks and the possibility of enhanced fertility treatment outcomes for ever greater numbers of patients, ultimately becoming an accepted cornerstone of reproductive care.

Genetic and reproductive strategies to prevent mitochondrial diseases

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) diseases pose unique challenges for genetic counselling and require tailored approaches to address recurrence risks and reproductive options. The intricate dynamics of mtDNA segregation and heteroplasmy shift significantly impact the chances of having affected children. In addition to natural pregnancy, oocyte donation, and adoption, IVF-based approaches can reduce the risk of disease transmission. Prenatal diagnosis (PND) and preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) remain the standard methods for women carrying pathogenic mtDNA mutations; nevertheless, they are not suitable for every patient. Germline nuclear transfer (NT) has emerged as a novel therapeutic strategy, while mitochondrial gene editing has increasingly become a promising research area in the field. However, challenges and safety concerns associated with all these techniques remain, highlighting the need for long-term follow-up studies, an improved understanding of disease mechanisms, and personalized approaches to diagnosis and treatment. Given the inherent risks of adverse maternal and child outcomes, careful consideration of the balance between potential benefits and drawbacks is also warranted. This review will provide critical insights, identify knowledge gaps, and underscore the importance of advancing mitochondrial disease research in reproductive health.

Preimplantation genetic testing as a preventive strategy for the transmission of mitochondrial DNA disorders

Mitochondrial diseases are distinct types of metabolic and/or neurologic abnormalities that occur as a consequence of dysfunction in oxidative phosphorylation, affecting several systems in the body. There is no effective treatment modality for mitochondrial disorders so far, emphasizing the clinical significance of preventing the inheritance of these disorders. Various reproductive options are available to reduce the probability of inheriting mitochondrial disorders, including in vitro fertilization (IVF) using donated oocytes, preimplantation genetic testing (PGT), and prenatal diagnosis (PND), among which PGT not only makes it possible for families to have genetically-owned children but also PGT has the advantage that couples do not have to decide to terminate the pregnancy if a mutation is detected in the fetus. PGT for mitochondrial diseases originating from nuclear DNA includes analyzing the nuclear genome for the presence or absence of corresponding mutations. However, PGT for mitochondrial disorders arising from mutations in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) is more intricate, due to the specific characteristics of mtDNA such as multicopy nature, heteroplasmy phenomenon, and exclusive maternal inheritance. Therefore, the present review aims to discuss the utility and challenges of PGT as a preventive approach to inherited mitochondrial diseases caused by mtDNA mutations.

The current clinical applications of preimplantation genetic testing (PGT): acknowledging the limitations of biology and technology

INTRODUCTION

Preimplantation Genetic Testing (PGT) is a cutting-edge test used to detect genetic abnormalities in embryos fertilized through Medically Assisted Reproduction (MAR). PGT aims to ensure that embryos selected for transfer are free of specific genetic conditions or chromosome abnormalities, thereby reducing chances for unsuccessful MAR cycles, complicated pregnancies, and genetic diseases in future children.

AREAS COVERED

In PGT, genetics, embryology, and technology progress and evolve together. Biological and technological limitations are described and addressed to highlight complexity and knowledge constraints and draw attention to concerns regarding safety of procedures, clinical validity, and utility, extent of applications and overall ethical implications for future families and society.

EXPERT OPINION

Understanding the genetic basis of diseases along with advanced technologies applied in embryology and genetics contribute to faster, cost-effective, and more efficient PGT. Next Generation Sequencing-based techniques, enhanced by improved bioinformatics, are expected to upgrade diagnostic accuracy. Complicating findings such as mosaicism, mt-DNA variants, variants of unknown significance, or variants related to late-onset or polygenic diseases will however need further appraisal. Emphasis on monitoring such emerging data is crucial for evidence-based counseling while standardized protocols and guidelines are essential to ensure clinical value and respect of Ethical, Legal and Societal Issues.

Good practice recommendations on add-ons in reproductive medicine†

STUDY QUESTION

Which add-ons are safe and effective to be used in ART treatment?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Forty-two recommendations were formulated on the use of add-ons in the diagnosis of fertility problems, the IVF laboratory and clinical management of IVF treatment.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

The innovative nature of ART combined with the extremely high motivation of the patients has opened the door to the wide application of what has become known as 'add-ons' in reproductive medicine. These supplementary options are available to patients in addition to standard fertility procedures, typically incurring an additional cost. A diverse array of supplementary options is made available, encompassing tests, drugs, equipment, complementary or alternative therapies, laboratory procedures, and surgical interventions. These options share the common aim of stating to enhance pregnancy or live birth rates, mitigate the risk of miscarriage, or expedite the time to achieving pregnancy.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

ESHRE aimed to develop clinically relevant and evidence-based recommendations focusing on the safety and efficacy of add-ons currently used in fertility procedures in order to improve the quality of care for patients with infertility.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

ESHRE appointed a European multidisciplinary working group consisting of practising clinicians, embryologists, and researchers who have demonstrated leadership and expertise in the care and research of infertility. Patient representatives were included in the working group. To ensure that the guidelines are evidence-based, the literature identified from a systematic search was reviewed and critically appraised. In the absence of any clear scientific evidence, recommendations were based on the professional experience and consensus of the working group. The guidelines are thus based on the best available evidence and expert agreement. Prior to publication, the guidelines were reviewed by 46 independent international reviewers. A total of 272 comments were received and incorporated where relevant.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

The multidisciplinary working group formulated 42 recommendations in three sections; diagnosis and diagnostic tests, laboratory tests and interventions, and clinical management.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

Of the 42 recommendations, none could be based on high-quality evidence and only four could be based on moderate-quality evidence, implicating that 95% of the recommendations are supported only by low-quality randomized controlled trials, observational data, professional experience, or consensus of the development group.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

These guidelines offer valuable direction for healthcare professionals who are responsible for the care of patients undergoing ART treatment for infertility. Their purpose is to promote safe and effective ART treatment, enabling patients to make informed decisions based on realistic expectations. The guidelines aim to ensure that patients are fully informed about the various treatment options available to them and the likelihood of any additional treatment or test to improve the chance of achieving a live birth.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

All costs relating to the development process were covered from ESHRE funds. There was no external funding of the development process or manuscript production. K.L. reports speakers fees from Merck and was part of a research study by Vitrolife (unpaid). T.E. reports consulting fees from Gynemed, speakers fees from Gynemed and is part of the scientific advisory board of Hamilton Thorne. N.P.P. reports grants from Merck Serono, Ferring Pharmaceutical, Theramex, Gedeon Richter, Organon, Roche, IBSA and Besins Healthcare, speakers fees from Merck Serono, Ferring Pharmaceutical, Theramex, Gedeon Richter, Organon, Roche, IBSA and Besins Healthcare. S.R.H. declares being managing director of Fertility Europe, a not-for-profit organization receiving financial support from ESHRE. I.S. is a scientific advisor for and has stock options from Alife Health, is co-founder of IVFvision LTD (unpaid) and received speakers' fee from the 2023 ART Young Leader Prestige workshop in China. A.P. reports grants from Gedeon Richter, Ferring Pharmaceuticals and Merck A/S, consulting fees from Preglem, Novo Nordisk, Ferring Pharmaceuticals, Gedeon Richter, Cryos and Merck A/S, speakers fees from Gedeon Richter, Ferring Pharmaceuticals, Merck A/S, Theramex and Organon, travel fees from Gedeon Richter. The other authors disclosed no conflicts of interest.

DISCLAIMER

This Good Practice Recommendations (GPRs) document represents the views of ESHRE, which are the result of consensus between the relevant ESHRE stakeholders and are based on the scientific evidence available at the time of preparation.ESHRE GPRs should be used for information and educational purposes. They should not be interpreted as setting a standard of care or bedeemedinclusive of all proper methods of care, or be exclusive of other methods of care reasonably directed to obtaining the same results.Theydo not replace the need for application of clinical judgement to each individual presentation, or variations based on locality and facility type.Furthermore, ESHRE GPRs do not constitute or imply the endorsement, or favouring, of any of the included technologies by ESHRE.

Novel economical, accurate, sensitive, single-cell analytical method for mitochondrial DNA quantification in mtDNA mutation carriers

PURPOSE

Although a variety of analytical methods have been developed to detect mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) heteroplasmy, there are special requirements of mtDNA heteroplasmy quantification for women carrying mtDNA mutations receiving the preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) and prenatal diagnosis (PD) in clinic. These special requirements include various sample types, large sample number, long-term follow-up, and the need for detection of single-cell from biopsied embryos. Therefore, developing an economical, accurate, high-sensitive, and single-cell analytical method for mtDNA heteroplasmy is necessary.

METHODS

In this study, we developed the Sanger sequencing combined droplet digital polymerase chain reaction (ddPCR) method for mtDNA quantification and compared the results to next-generation sequencing (NGS). A total of seventeen families with twelve mtDNA mutations were recruited in this study.

RESULTS

The results showed that both Sanger sequencing and ddPCR could be used to analyze the mtDNA heteroplasmy in single-cell samples. There was no statistically significant difference in heteroplasmy levels in common samples with high heteroplasmy (≥ 5%), low heteroplasmy (< 5%), and single-cell samples, either between Sanger sequencing and NGS methods, or between ddPCR and NGS methods (P > 0.05). However, Sanger sequencing was unable to detect extremely low heteroplasmy accurately. But even in samples with extremely low heteroplasmy (0.40% and 0.92%), ddPCR was always able to quantify them. Compared to NGS, Sanger sequencing combined ddPCR analytical methods greatly reduced the cost of sequencing.

CONCLUSIONS

In conclusion, this study successfully established an economical, accurate, sensitive, single-cell analytical method based on the Sanger sequencing combined ddPCR methods for mtDNA heteroplasmy quantification in a clinical setting.

Cerebral folate deficiency: A report of two affected siblings

Cerebral folate deficiency (CFD) is a rare progressive neurological condition characterized by normal blood folate level and low 5-methyltetrahydrofolate (5-MTHF) levels in the cerebrospinal fluid. Patients present with different neurological findings including hypotonia and microcephaly. Later, patients develop ataxia, seizures, para or quadri-plagia. Herein, we report two siblings; born to consanguineous parents; who had normal neurological development in early childhood. Subsequently they developed drug-resistant seizures, neurological regression, and spastic quadriplegia. After thorough investigations patients had brain MRI which showed abnormal white matter signals and ventricular dilatation, CSF with low 5-MTHF, and whole exome sequencing (WES) revealed a novel homozygous variant in FOLR1 (c.245A > G; p.Tyr82Cys) consistent with the diagnosis of cerebral folate deficiency. They were treated with folinic acid in addition to standard anti-seizure medications. WES aids in reaching CFD diagnosis due to FOLR1 pathogenic variants. These results can be used for future counselling to prevent recurrence in future pregnancies by preimplantation genetic testing prior to implanting the embryo in the uterus. Treatment with folinic acid was shown to improve the neurological symptoms namely reduced the seizures and spasticity.

The Intestinal Microbiota May Be a Potential Theranostic Tool for Personalized Medicine

The human intestine is colonized by a huge number of microorganisms from the moment of birth. This set of microorganisms found throughout the human body, is called the microbiota; the microbiome indicates the totality of genes that the microbiota can express, i.e., its genetic heritage. Thus, microbiota participates in and influences the proper functioning of the organism. The microbiota is unique for each person; it differs in the types of microorganisms it contains, the number of each microorganism, and the ratio between them, but mainly it changes over time and under the influence of many factors. Therefore, the correct functioning of the human body depends not only on the expression of its genes but also on the expression of the genes of the microorganisms it coexists with. This fact makes clear the enormous interest of community science in studying the relationship of the human microbiota with human health and the incidence of disease. The microbiota is like a unique personalized "mold" for each person; it differs quantitatively and qualitatively for the microorganisms it contains together with the relationship between them, and it changes over time and under the influence of many factors. We are attempting to modulate the microbial components in the human intestinal microbiota over time to provide positive feedback on the health of the host, from intestinal diseases to cancer. These interventions to modulate the intestinal microbiota as well as to identify the relative microbiome (genetic analysis) can range from dietary (with adjuvant prebiotics or probiotics) to fecal transplantation. This article researches the recent advances in these strategies by exploring their advantages and limitations. Furthermore, we aim to understand the relationship between intestinal dysbiosis and pathologies, through the research of resident microbiota, that would allow the personalization of the therapeutic antibiotic strategy.